Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning...

48
Measuring the eastern boundary inflow Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated with measuring the eastern boundary current 3. Strawman array design and remaining questions reenland coast viewed from R/V Knorr , Oct 2008 reenland coast viewed from R/V Knorr , Oct 2008 (Photo by Ben Harden) (Photo by Ben Harden) Robert S. Pickart (WHOI)

Transcript of Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning...

Page 1: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Measuring the eastern boundary inflow Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea to the Labrador Sea

Measuring the eastern boundary inflow Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea to the Labrador Sea

Outline

1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea

2. Challenges associated with measuring the eastern boundary current

3. Strawman array design and remaining questions

Greenland coast viewed from R/V Knorr , Oct 2008 Greenland coast viewed from R/V Knorr , Oct 2008

(Photo by Ben Harden)(Photo by Ben Harden)

Robert S. Pickart (WHOI)

Page 2: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Labrador Sea general circulation

Page 3: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Wintertime storm tracks (from 45 years of ECMWF re-analysis data) Wintertime storm tracks (from 45 years of ECMWF re-analysis data)

VVååge et al. (2009) ge et al. (2009)

Mean storm track

Page 4: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Heat loss from wintertime cold-air outbreaks Heat loss from wintertime cold-air outbreaks

Color = heat loss in Watts/mColor = heat loss in Watts/m22 (from NCEP reanalysis) (from NCEP reanalysis) Ice

Page 5: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Heat loss from wintertime cold-air outbreaks Heat loss from wintertime cold-air outbreaks

Color = heat loss in Watts/mColor = heat loss in Watts/m22 (from NCEP reanalysis) (from NCEP reanalysis)

Contours = Absolute geostrophic Contours = Absolute geostrophic pressure (Lavender et al. (2000) pressure (Lavender et al. (2000)

Ice

Page 6: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Surface eddy speed Surface eddy speed

After Lilly et al. (2003) After Lilly et al. (2003)

Color = surface eddy Color = surface eddy speed (cm/s) speed (cm/s)

Contours = Absolute geostrophic Contours = Absolute geostrophic pressure (Lavender et al. (2000) pressure (Lavender et al. (2000)

Page 7: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Surface eddy speed and regions of deep convection Surface eddy speed and regions of deep convection

Color = surface eddy Color = surface eddy speed (cm/s) speed (cm/s)

Contours = Absolute geostrophic Contours = Absolute geostrophic pressure (Lavender et al. (2000) pressure (Lavender et al. (2000)

Page 8: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Surface eddy speed and regions of deep convection Surface eddy speed and regions of deep convection

Color = surface eddy Color = surface eddy speed (cm/s) speed (cm/s)

Contours = Absolute geostrophic Contours = Absolute geostrophic pressure (Lavender et al. (2000) pressure (Lavender et al. (2000)

Page 9: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Mixed-layer depth in winter 1997 Mixed-layer depth in winter 1997

Color = mixed layer depth (m) Color = mixed layer depth (m)

Contours = Absolute geostrophic Contours = Absolute geostrophic pressure (Lavender et al. (2000) pressure (Lavender et al. (2000)

Page 10: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

WOCE AR7W lineInverse calculation

AR7W AR7W

Time period of high NAO in the early to mid 1990s

Page 11: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Float data

Mean circulation at 700m 1995Mean circulation at 700m 1995–19–1999 99

Lavendar et al. (2000) Lavendar et al. (2000)

AR7WAR7W

Page 12: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Referencing the geostrophic velocity section

Mean velocity at 700m from PALACE Mean velocity at 700m from PALACE

Page 13: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Referencing the geostrophic velocity section

Mean velocity at 700m from PALACE Mean velocity at 700m from PALACE

Mean temperature/density section Mean temperature/density section

X

Robert S. Pickart
--adjustment across the entire section is 0.3 cm/s--across eastern boundary current is 1.75 cm/s
Page 14: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Referencing the geostrophic velocity section

Mean velocity at 700m from PALACE Mean velocity at 700m from PALACE

Mean temperature/density section Mean temperature/density section

X

Robert S. Pickart
--adjustment across the entire section is 0.3 cm/s--across eastern boundary current is 1.75 cm/s
Page 15: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Referencing the geostrophic velocity section

Mean velocity at 700m from PALACE Mean velocity at 700m from PALACE

Mean temperature/density section Mean temperature/density section

X

Total transport in: 35.4 SvTotal transport in: 35.4 SvTotal transport out: 35.5 SvTotal transport out: 35.5 Sv

Robert S. Pickart
--adjustment across the entire section is 0.3 cm/s--across eastern boundary current is 1.75 cm/s
Page 16: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Absolute geostrophic velocity

AR7W AR7W

Page 17: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Absolute geostrophic velocity

Total Boundary Current transport = 28.5 Sv Total Boundary Current transport = 28.5 Sv

Recirculation transport = 2.5 Sv Recirculation transport = 2.5 Sv

Overflow water transport = 12.4 Sv Overflow water transport = 12.4 Sv Throughput

Page 18: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Absolute geostrophic velocity

Total Boundary Current transport = 28.5 Sv Total Boundary Current transport = 28.5 Sv

Recirculation transport = 2.5 Sv Recirculation transport = 2.5 Sv

Overflow water transport = 12.4 Sv Overflow water transport = 12.4 Sv Throughput

Near zeroNear zerovelocity! velocity!

Page 19: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Depth space: Overturning and horizontal components of the flow

Decompose the full velocity: Decompose the full velocity:

Then decompose the deviation velocity: Then decompose the deviation velocity:

),(')(),( zxvzvzxv x

),(~)('),(' zxvxvzxv z

Overturning Overturning Deviation Deviation

Horizontal gyre

Horizontal gyre

Baroclinic gyre

Baroclinic gyre

Page 20: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Transport components

Overturning Cell Overturning Cell

Horizontal cell Horizontal cell

Page 21: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Transport components

95% of sinking happens 95% of sinking happens

in boundary current in boundary current

Page 22: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Density space: Overturning transport

Page 23: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Density space: Overturning transport

> 95% of the transport imbalance > 95% of the transport imbalance occurs in the boundary current occurs in the boundary current

Page 24: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

What are the important points for OSNAP? What are the important points for OSNAP?

Seaward of the 700m isobath there is mass balance across Seaward of the 700m isobath there is mass balance across the section (i.e. excluding the shallow shelf-edge flows). the section (i.e. excluding the shallow shelf-edge flows).

The horizontal cell is significantly larger than the overturning cell. The horizontal cell is significantly larger than the overturning cell.

Nearly all of the overturning, in depth space and density space,Nearly all of the overturning, in depth space and density space,occurs along the rim of the basin. Flows in the middle of theoccurs along the rim of the basin. Flows in the middle of theBasin are weak.Basin are weak.

There is substantial mesoscale variability, so low-passing will be There is substantial mesoscale variability, so low-passing will be necessary. necessary.

Page 25: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Ongoing Timeseries in the Labrador Sea Ongoing Timeseries in the Labrador Sea

OSNAP-east moorings

Page 26: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Ongoing Timeseries in the Labrador Sea Ongoing Timeseries in the Labrador Sea

OSNAP-east moorings

Page 27: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array

Page 28: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array

1997 hydrographicSections

Page 29: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Two eastern boundary Two eastern boundary crossings in Feb 1997crossings in Feb 1997

Salinity (color) overlain Salinity (color) overlain by density (contours) by density (contours)

North North

South South

16 Feb 16 Feb

26 Feb 26 Feb

Page 30: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array

Page 31: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array

Page 32: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array

Page 33: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array

2001 hydrographic Section

Page 34: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Eastern boundary crossing Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001 in Aug 2001

Salinity (color) overlain bySalinity (color) overlain bydensity (contours) density (contours)

Absolute geostrophic velocity (color) Absolute geostrophic velocity (color) overlain by density (contours) overlain by density (contours)

Page 35: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Eastern boundary crossing Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001 in Aug 2001

Salinity (color) overlain bySalinity (color) overlain bydensity (contours) density (contours)

Absolute geostrophic velocity (color) Absolute geostrophic velocity (color) overlain by density (contours) overlain by density (contours)

Page 36: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001 Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001

Page 37: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001 Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001

Page 38: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array

Page 39: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001 Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001

Page 40: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001 Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001

Page 41: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001 Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001

Page 42: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001 Eastern boundary crossing in Aug 2001

Use of current meters and Microcats is safer and allows for 2-year deployments

Page 43: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Strawman OSNAP-West Boundary Arrays Strawman OSNAP-West Boundary Arrays

Page 44: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Remaining issues: shelf, near-surface, recirculation Remaining issues: shelf, near-surface, recirculation

Page 45: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Remaining issues: shelf, near-surface, recirculation Remaining issues: shelf, near-surface, recirculation

Page 46: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array Considerations for OSNAP eastern boundary array

Page 47: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Positive aspects of eastern array location Positive aspects of eastern array location

Bottom topography is gentle enough to effectively resolve Bottom topography is gentle enough to effectively resolve the boundary current. the boundary current.

Array will coincide with an altimeter line (providing additional Array will coincide with an altimeter line (providing additional surface velocity information). surface velocity information).

By moving south, the array is a true input boundary condition forBy moving south, the array is a true input boundary condition forthe Labrador Sea (to compare to the western export array). the Labrador Sea (to compare to the western export array).

The offshore recirculation is geographically confined, which The offshore recirculation is geographically confined, which means it can be effectively sampled with floats. means it can be effectively sampled with floats.

Page 48: Measuring the eastern boundary inflow to the Labrador Sea Outline 1. Insights on the overturning circulation of the Labrador Sea 2. Challenges associated.

Negative aspects of eastern array location Negative aspects of eastern array location

It is not the AR7W line! (which provides a wonderful context). It is not the AR7W line! (which provides a wonderful context).

Logistically more difficult to service the array.Logistically more difficult to service the array.

Closer to OSNAP Cape Farewell array (less contrast). Closer to OSNAP Cape Farewell array (less contrast).