Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls...6 Measures of Health and Function that...
Transcript of Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls...6 Measures of Health and Function that...
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
Matthew O’Connell, Rose Anne Kenny and Orna Donoghue
ContentsKey Findings ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ 130
6�1 Introduction ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������ 131
6�2 Prevalence of falls ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 132
6.3 Profileofindividualsreportingrecurrentfalls �������������������������������������������������������� 1356�3�1 Co-morbidities and medications ���������������������������������������������������������������� 1356�3�2 Physical health and function���������������������������������������������������������������������� 1366�3�3 Cognitive and mental health and function ������������������������������������������������� 1376�3�4 Sensory function ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 140
6.4 Identifyingthemostimportantpredictorsofrecurrentfalls ������������������������������������ 144
6.5 Identifyingthemostimportantpredictorsofinjuriousfalls ������������������������������������� 145
6�6 Conclusion ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 146
References ��������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 148
The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing
130
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
Key Findings
• Fallsareassociatedwithmanynegativeoutcomessuchasinjury,disability,hospitalisationandreducedqualityoflife,thereforetheyareamajorburdenforolderadultsandamajorchallengeforthehealthcareservices.
• Fallsarecommonincommunity-dwellingadultsaged50yearsandoverinIreland,withalmost2in5reportingafallduring4yearsoffollow-upand1in5reportingrecurrentfallsandinjuriousfalls.
• Theprevalenceoffallsishigherinwomenthanmenandincreaseswithageinboth.Twooutoffivewomenaged75yearsandoverreportedrecurrentfallsduring4yearsoffollow-upwhileasimilarnumbersustainedafall-relatedinjuryrequiringmedicalattention�
• Olderadultswhoreportrecurrentfallsorinjuriousfallsdisplaypoorerindicatorsofphysical,cognitiveandmentalhealthandfunctioncomparedtonon-fallers.
• Manyofthemostimportantriskfactors,e.g.unsteadinesswhenwalking,depressivesymptoms,non-cardiovascularconditions,fearoffallingandhavingorthostatichypotension,aremodifiableandcanbetreatedandimproved.
• Fallsassessmentsshouldberoutinelyconductedinolderadultstoidentifyriskfactorsandcausesoffallssothatappropriatemanagementandfallpreventionstrategiescanbeimplemented.
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
131
6.1 Introduction
Fallsareoneofthebiggestproblemswhichoccurinadvancingyears,becauseoftheirhighfrequencyandadversehealthconsequences.Olderadultsareparticularlyvulnerabletobothfallsandtheassociatednegativeconsequencesoffallsastheydisplayage-relatedphysiologicalchangessuchaspoorerbalanceandslowerreactiontimes.Inadditiontheyaremoresusceptibletoinjuryduetoanincreasedprevalenceofclinicalconditionssuchasosteoporosis,andtheyrecoverlesswellafterinjury,thereforeplacingtheminadeconditionedstateforlonger(1).Fallscanleadtofearoffallingandactivityrestriction,disability,hospitalisationandreducedqualityoflife.AnEconomicBurdenofIllnessStudyestimatedthatfall-relatedinjuriesinolderpeoplecost€402milliontotheIrisheconomyin2006andwouldincreaseto€922-1077millionby2020intheabsenceofaNationalFallandFracturePreventionStrategybeingimplemented(2).Thisisaconservativeestimatewhichdoesnotincludethewidereconomicimpactincurredbycarersandthelongertermconsequencesoutwithinjurysuchassubsequenthomecare,medicationsandinstitutionalisation costs�
Manyaccidentalfallsoccurpartlyduetoenvironmentalfactorse.g.trippingoveranunevenpavement;however,intrinsicfactorsrelatingtotheindividualalsoplayarole.Previousresearchhasidentifiedalargenumberofriskfactorsforfallsincludingpriorhistoryoffalls;chronicconditionssuchasarthritisorurinaryincontinence;deficitsingaitorbalance;reducedmusclestrength;poorvision;depressivesymptoms;dizziness;takingfourormoremedicationsandimpairedcognition(1,3).Mostfallsarenotduetojustoneriskfactor;insteadmanyinteractwitheachotherandtheriskoffallingincreaseswithanincreasingnumberofriskfactors.However,themostimportantrisksappeartobeimpairmentsingait,balanceandmusclestrength(1).
Despitethesepreviousstudies,thereremainsalackofinformationonboththeimpactoffallsandthemostimportantriskfactorsatthepopulationlevelinIreland.Throughitsextensivesurveydatacollectionandstate-of-thearthealthassessment,TILDAcollectssomeofthemostcomprehensiveinformationonfallsriskfactorsavailableinternationally.
Inthischapter,theaimistodescribethefrequencyoffallsincommunity-dwellingolderadultsinIrelandoverthefirstthreewavesofdatacollectionandsubsequently,toestablishaprofileoffallersinrelationtobothself-reportedandobjectivemeasuresofhealthandfunction obtained at baseline (Wave 1)� These measures can be roughly divided into chronicconditionsandmedications,physicalhealthandfunction,sensoryfunction,cognitiveandmentalhealth.Wethenidentifythefactorsthatarethemostimportant
The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing
132
predictorsoffuturefallsandexamineiftheseriskfactorsaremodifiableinanefforttobestinformpolicymakersandclinicalpracticeinIreland.
Inthisanalysis,informationisobtainedfromboththeinterviewandhealthcentreassessmentcomponentsofTILDA,thereforeonlythosewhoparticipatedinbothcomponentsatbaselinewereeligibleforthisanalysis(n=5,035).Oftheseparticipants,4,700participatedinWave2(including12proxyinterviews)and4,400participatedinWave3(including32proxyinterviews).Proxyinterviewswerecompletedbyafamilymember/closefriendiftheparticipantwasunabletoparticipatethemselvesduetophysicalorcognitivereasons.Participantsweredividedintothreeagegroups(50-64years,65-74yearsand75yearsorover)whichreflecttheiragesatWave1.
6.2 Prevalence of falls
Duringeachinterview,participantswereaskediftheyhadfalleninthepastyearand/orsincetheirlastinterviewandiftheyhadrequiredmedicalattentionasaresultofanyofthesefalls.AtWave1,thisinformationreflectsanindividual’shistoryoffallsinthepastyear.FallsreportedatWaves2and3wereusedtodefinethevariousfallsoutcomes(anyfalls,recurrentfalls,injuriousfalls)occurringafterthisbaselinemeasurement(Table6.1).
Table 6.1: Definition of falls outcomes
Outcome Definition
Any Fall AnyfallreportedinthelastyearORsincetheparticipant’slastinterview�
Recurrent Falls TwoormorefallsreportedatWave2orWave3orbothORasinglefallreportedatbothWave2andWave3.
Injurious Falls Anyfallinwhichaninjuryseriousenoughtorequiremedicalattention was sustained at Wave 2 or Wave 3�
Table6.2showstheprevalenceoffalls,recurrentfallsandinjuriousfallsatWaves1,2and3�
Table 6.2: Prevalence of recurrent falls and injurious falls at Waves 1, 2 and 3
Wave 1 Wave 2 Wave 3 Wave 2 and 3
N 4,788 4,696 4,398 4,789
Any fall (%) 21�1 23.9 25�8 37�3
Recurrent falls (%) 7�7 9.9 11�1 19.1
Injurious falls (%) 7�7 10�2 12�1 18�4
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
133
AtWave1,21%ofparticipantsreportedanyfallintheyearpriortointerviewwhilethisfigureincreasedto24%atWave2and26%atWave3.WhenconsideringfallswhichoccurredatWaves2and3,overonethird(37%)ofparticipantsexperiencedafallduringthisfollow-upperiod.AtWave1,8%ofparticipantsreportedrecurrentfallsinthepastyearandthisincreasedto10-11%atWaves2and3.Overthefouryearsoffollow-up(i.e.Waves2and3),19%ofparticipantsexperiencedrecurrentfalls.Theprevalenceofinjuriousfallswasverysimilartorecurrentfallsatallwaves.Fortheremainderofthischapter,wepresentthecombinedfigureforfallsoccurringduringfollow-upi.e.basedonfalls occurring at Wave 2 and Wave 3�
Womenweremorelikelytoreportanyfallsduring4yearsfollow-upcomparedtomen(42%versus32%).Theprevalenceincreasedwithageinbothgendersfrom29%and34%(inmenandwomenaged50-64years)to42%and60%(inmenandwomenaged75yearsandolder)(Figure6.1).ApproximatelyoneinfiveolderadultsinIreland(17%ofmen;21%ofwomen)experiencedrecurrentfallsinthelastfouryears.Recurrentfallsweremorecommoninwomenaged65-74yearsand75yearsandoldercomparedtowomenaged50-64years(Figure6.2),howeverthisrelationshipwithagewasweakerinmen.Injuriousfallswerealsomorecommoninwomen(23%)comparedtomen(13%)butincreasedwithageinbothgenders(Figure6.3).Forexample,18%ofwomenaged50-64yearsreportedaninjuriousfallcomparedto38%ofthoseaged75yearsandover.
Figure 6.1: Prevalence of any fall at Wave 2 and Wave 3, by age group and sex
The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing
134
Figure 6.2: Prevalence of recurrent falls at Wave 2 and Wave 3, by age group and sex
Figure 6.3: Prevalence of injurious falls at Wave 2 and Wave 3, by age group and sex
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
135
Asshownabove,fallscanbedefinedinanumberofways.However,fallsareoftensubjecttorecallbiasleadingtoinaccuraciesinreporting.Inaddition,asinglefallcanoftenresultfromanisolatedeventratherthananumberofunderlyingcauses.Consequently,wehavechosentofocusonthemoreseriousfallsoutcomesofrecurrentfallsandinjuriousfallsfortheremainderofthischapter.
6.3 Profileofindividualsreportingrecurrentfalls
Self-reportedmeasuresweretypicallyobtainedduringtheinterviewwhileobjectivemeasureswereobtainedduringthehealthassessmentwhichtookplaceinhealthcentresinDublinandCork.Thishealthassessmentincludedtestsofcardiovascularfunction,cognitivefunction,mobility,vision,bonehealthandanthropometry.
6.3.1 Co-morbidities and medications
Participantswereaskedtoindicateifadoctorhadevertoldthemthattheyhadanyofthefollowingcardiovascularconditions(highbloodpressure,angina,heartattack,heartfailure,diabetes,stroke,mini-stroke,highcholesterol,heartmurmurandheartrhythm)andnon-cardiovascularconditions(chroniclungdisease,asthma,arthritis,osteoporosis,cancer,Parkinson’sdisease).Thenumberofconditionsineachcategorywasobtained.Participantsalsolistedallmedicationstakenregularlywithpolypharmacydefinedasfiveormore medications�
Havingahighburdenofcardiovascularornon-cardiovascularconditionswasstronglyassociatedwithrecurrentfalling.Approximatelytwiceasmanyrecurrentfallershad3ormorecardiovascularconditionsor2ormorenon-cardiovascularconditions,comparedtonon-recurrentfallers(Table6.3).Similarly,polypharmacywasalmosttwiceascommonamongrecurrentfallers.Thisdifferencewasmostpronouncedinwomenaged50-64years(10%innon-recurrentfallersversus25%inrecurrentfallers).
Table 6.3: Co-morbidities and medications in non-recurrent fallers and recurrent fallers
Co-morbidities and medicationsNon-recurrent fallers Recurrent fallers
n% (95% CI) % (95% CI)
≥3cardiovascularconditions 9.6 (8.5-10.9) 18�3 (15.3-21.9) 4,788
≥2non-cardiovascularconditions 9.9 (8�8-11�1) 18.9 (15�7-22�5) 4,788
Polypharmacy 18�2 (16.7-19.9) 32�3 (28�2-36�8) 4,766
Note:CI=confidenceinterval
The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing
136
6.3.2 Physical health and function
TheTILDAhealthassessmentincludesanumberofhighqualityandnovelassessmentsofphysicalhealthandfunction.Walkingspeedwasmeasuredusingacomputerisedmat(activearea4.88m)withembeddedpressuresensors(GAITRite®,CIRSystemsInc,NewYork,USA).Participantsstartedandstopped2.5mbeforeand2mafterthemat;averagewalkingspeedwasobtainedacrosstwotrials.GripstrengthisaproxyforoverallbodystrengthandwasmeasuredusingahandheldBaselinedynamometer.Theaverageoftwomeasurements was obtained for the dominant hand�
OneofthemostinnovativetestsincludedinTILDAiscontinuousbloodpressuremonitoringduringactivestanding.AFinometerdevicewasusedtomeasurechangesinbloodpressurewhilestandingupfromalyingposition.OrthostaticHypotension(OH)isdefinedaslowbloodpressurethroughoutthesecondminuteofstanding(4).Participantsalsounderwentaquantitativeheelboneultrasound(AchillesHeelUltrasound,Lunar,Madison,USA)toassessbonehealthandtheriskofosteoporoticfracture.Thisdeviceprovidesanindexofbonestiffnessandwhilethisisnotdiagnostic,anindividualisconsideredtohaveosteoporosis,osteopeniaornormalbonedensityifthestiffnessindexis<65%,65-86%,or>86%respectively(5).
HeightandweightweremeasuredusingstandardequipmentandusedtocalculateBodyMassIndex(BMI).PhysicalactivitywasmeasuredusingtheshortformInternationalPhysicalActivityQuestionnaire(IPAQ),inwhichthenumberofdaysandhoursspentwalkinganddoingvigorousandmoderateintensityactivitiesinthelastweekwasrecorded(6).SpecificcriteriawereusedtoclassifyparticipantsintoHigh,ModerateorLowActivitylevels (7)�
Recurrentfallersintheolderadultpopulationhadslowerwalkingspeedandlowergripstrengthcomparedtonon-recurrentfallers(Table6.4).Orthostatichypotensionwasalmosttwiceascommonamongrecurrentfallers,whilelowphysicalactivitywasslightlymorecommon.Bonehealthwassimilarinrecurrentfallersandnon-recurrentfallers.Levelsofobesitywerealsosimilarexceptwhenlookingatadultsaged50-64yearswhererecurrentfallersweremorelikelytobeobese(39%)comparedtonon-recurrentfallers(33%).Unsurprisingly,ahistoryoffallingisstronglyrelatedtofuturefallsas40%ofrecurrentfallersatWaves2and3reportedafallintheyearpriortotheirWave1interviewcomparedto17%ofnon-recurrentfallers.
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
137
Table 6.4: Physical health and function measures in non-recurrent fallers and recurrent fallers
Physical health measures Non-recurrent fallers Recurrent fallers n
Mean(95%CI)
Walkingspeed(cm/s) 134�4 (133�5-135�3) 123�8 (121�3-126�2) 4,714
Gripstrength(kg) 26�5 (26�1-26�8) 23�7 (22�8-24�5) 4,732
%(95%CI)
OrthostaticHypotension 5�5 (4�7-6�5) 9.6 (7�0-13�2) 4,255
Bone health
Normal 50�6 (48�7-52�4) 46�1 (42�0-50�2)
Osteopenia 40�3 (38�6-42�2) 41.9 (37�6-46�3) 4,760
Osteoporosis 9.1 (7.9-10.4) 12�0 (9.3-15.5)
Body Mass Index
Underweight 0�5 (0�3-0�8) 0�5 (0�2-1�3)
Normal 22�0 (20�5-23�6) 25�4 (21.8-29.4) 4,780
Overweight 44�5 (42�7-46�3) 38�6 (34.4-42.9)
Obese 33�1 (31�4-34�8) 35�5 (31.7-39.4)
Physical activity level
Low 28�4 (26�6-30�4) 34�7 (30.7-39.0)
Moderate 35�8 (34�0-37�7) 36�4 (32�6-40�3) 4,748
High 35�7 (33�6-37�5) 28.9 (25�3-32�8)
Fallin12monthspriortoWave1 16�5 (15�1-18�0) 40�3 (36�2-44�6) 4,786
OsteopeniaandosteoporosiswerebasedontheStiffnessIndexobtainedfromthequantitativeheelultrasound.
Note:CI=confidenceinterval
6.3.3 Cognitive and mental health and function
GlobalcognitionwasassessedusingtheMontrealCognitiveAssessment(MoCA)whichassessesabilityacrossmultipledomainsofcognitivefunction:memoryrecall,visuospatialability,executivefunction,attention,language,andorientationtotime/place.Executivefunctionallowsanindividualtoplan,organizeandcompleteatask.Itisoftenassociatedwithbalanceandwalking-basedtasksandthereforepoorexecutivefunctionisariskfactorforfalls.ItwasassessedusingtheColourTrailsTestwhichhastwocomponents,bothof which involve connecting a series of numbered and coloured circles� The difference betweenthetwocomponents(ColourTrailstimedifference)reflectsexecutivefunction(8).
The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing
138
Concentrationandprocessingspeedwereassessedusingacomputer-basedchoicereactiontimetest.Participantspressedabuttononthekeyboarduntilanon-screenstimulusappeared(YES/NO);thentheyreleasedthebuttonandpressedthecorrespondingYES/NObuttononthekeyboard.Totalresponsetimeisthetimetakenfromwhenthestimulusappeared,fortheparticipanttoreleasethebuttonandpressthetargetbuttononthekeyboard.
RecurrentfallersintheolderadultpopulationhadlowerscoresonMoCA(lowerglobalcognitivefunction)andalargerColourTrailstimedifference(poorerexecutivefunction)(Table6.5).Therewerenogenderdifferencesinglobalcognition,executivefunctionorreactiontime,howevertherewasaclearassociationbetweenincreasingageandpoorerfunction in all three cognitive tests in both recurrent fallers and non-recurrent fallers� The relationshipbetweenageandColourTrailtimedifferenceisshowninFigure6.4.
Table 6.5: Cognitive function in non-recurrent fallers and recurrent fallers
Cognitive functionNon-recurrent fallers Recurrent fallers
n% (95% CI) % (95% CI)
MoCA (max score 30) 24�7 (24.6-24.9) 24�1 (23�7-24�4) 4,772
Colour trail time difference (s) 56�3 (55�1-57�6) 61�3 (58�2-64�4) 4,723
Choice reaction time (ms) 844�2 (829.0-859.5) 891.6 (859.0-924.1) 4,694
Note:CI=confidenceinterval
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
139
Figure 6.4: Executive function (indicated by colour trails time difference) in non-recurrent fallers and recurrent fallers, by age group
Depressivesymptomswereassessedusingthe20-itemCentreforEpidemiologicalStudiesDepression(CES-D)scale,wherethemaximumscoreis60(9).Participantsscoring≥16wereclassifiedashavingmoderateorpotentiallyclinicallyrelevantdepressivesymptomswhilethosescoring8-15wereclassifiedashavingmildorsub-thresholddepressivesymptoms.Fearoffallingwasidentifiedbyasking“Areyouafraidoffalling?”andifso,towhatextent(somewhatafraidorverymuchafraid).
Participantswhoreportedrecurrentfallsatfollow-upweremorelikelytoreportpotentiallyclinicallyrelevantdepressivesymptomsandtobesomewhatorverymuchafraidoffallingcomparedtonon-recurrentfallers(Table6.6).Depressivesymptomsdidnotvarybyagegrouporsexinrecurrentfallers,howeverbeingsomewhatafraidoffallingwasreportedmorefrequentlyinwomen(36%versus18%inmen)andintheolderagecategories(41%infallersaged≥75yearsversus20%infallersaged50-64years).
The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing
140
Table 6.6: Depressive symptoms and fear of falling in non-recurrent fallers and recurrent fallers
Mental healthNon-recurrent fallers Recurrent fallers
n% (95% CI) % (95% CI)
Depressivesymptoms(%)
None 73�4 (71�6-75�2) 62�8 (58�5-66�8)
Mild (sub-threshold) 16.9 (15�5-18�4) 19.3 (16�0-23�1) 4,788
Moderate(potentiallyclinically relevant)
9.7 (8�5-11�0) 17.9 (14�8-21�5)
Fear of falling (%)
None 81�5 (79.6-83.3) 63�2 (58�5-67�7)
Somewhat afraid 14�8 (13�3-16�6) 28�4 (24�0-33�2) 4,787
Very much afraid 3�6 (2�8-4�8) 8�3 (6�1-11�3)
Note:CI=confidenceinterval
6.3.4 Sensory function
Duringtheinterview,participantsratedtheirsteadinesswhenwalking(10)withunsteadinessindicatedifparticipantsreportedbeingSlightlysteady,SlightlyunsteadyorVeryunsteady(asopposedtoVerysteady).Participantsalsoself-ratedtheirvisionandhearingwithanswersdichotomisedintotwocategories:Excellent/VeryGood/GoodandFair/Poor.OneparticipantwhoreportedbeinglegallyblindwasincludedintheFair/Poorvision category�
Two measures of visual function were assessed during the health assessment� Visual acuity,whichistheacutenessorclearnessofvision,wasassessedusingaLogMAR(MinimalAngleofResolution)chartwhichisoftenusedbyoptometristsandGPs.Participantsstood4metresawayfromthechartandcompletedthetestwitheacheye,usingcorrectiveglasses/lensesifrequired.ThelogMARscoreforthebesteyewasconvertedintoaVisualAnalogScore(VAS)wherehigherscoresrepresentbettervisualacuity(11).Contrastsensitivityistheabilitytodistinguishanobjectfromthebackgroundinlowcontrastconditionse.g.atdusk.ItwasmeasuredusingaFunctionalVisionAnalyser(StereoOptical,Chicago,IL,USA)undermesopic(3cd/m2)backgroundilluminationconditionsinnon-glareandglareconditions.Thetestprovides10scoresobtainedatdifferentspatialfrequencies(1.5,3,6,12and18cyclesperdegree,cpd).Sharpimageswithsmalldetailscontainhighspatialfrequencyinformationwhilecoarserimageswith
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
141
blurreddetailscontainlowspatialfrequencyinformation.Wesubsequentlyusedfactoranalysistoidentifytwodistinctfeaturesforeachindividualcorrespondingtotheir“highfrequency”and“lowfrequency”contrastsensitivity(12).Eachfactorscorewasdividedintoquartileswiththelowestquartilerepresentingpoorercontrastsensitivity.
Overall,recurrentfallersintheolderadultpopulationinIrelandweremorelikelytoreportunsteadinesswhenwalkingcomparedtonon-recurrentfallersalthoughtherewasnodifference in self-rated vision or hearing (Table 6�7)�
Table 6.7: Sensory function in non-recurrent fallers and recurrent fallers
Sensory functionNon-recurrent fallers Recurrent fallers
n % (95% CI) % (95% CI)
Self-rated unsteadiness 14�7 (13�1-16�4) 37�4 (33�0-42�1) 4,785
Self-ratedvision(poor/fair) 8�8 (7�7-10�1) 12�4 (9.8-15.7) 4,788
Self-ratedhearing(poor/fair) 14�5 (13�2-16�0) 19.0 (15�8-22�8) 4,788
Visual acuity score 96.0 (95.7-96.4) 95.1 (94.2-95.9) 4,771
Contrast sensitivity (no glare)
1.5cpd 36�1 (35.4-36.9) 34�2 (32�4-36�0)
3cpd 66�6 (65�4-67�8) 62�4 (59.7-65.0)
6cpd 31�7 (30�8-32�7) 27�6 (25.7-29.5) 4,561
12cpd 6�5 (6�1-6�8) 5�3 (4�4-6�3)
18cpd 0�7 (0�7-0�8) 0�6 (0�4-0�7)
Contrast sensitivity (glare)
1.5cpd 37.9 (37�2-38�6) 33�8 (32�3-35�2)
3cpd 68.9 (67�6-70�2) 62�6 (59.8-65.3)
6cpd 32�1 (31�1-33�1) 27�8 (25.9-29.6) 4,553
12cpd 6.9 (6�5-7�3) 5�1 (4�4-5�7)
18cpd 0�8 (0.7-0.9) 0�5 (0�4-0�6)
Note:CI=confidenceinterval
The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing
142
Oldermenandwomenwhowererecurrentfallerswereequallyaslikelytoreportunsteadinesswhilewalking(36%versus39%)andfair/poorvision(14%versus11%),howeverwomenwerelesslikelytoreportfair/poorhearingthanmen(14%versus26%).Ingeneral,unsteadinessbecamemoreprevalentwithincreasingageespeciallyinrecurrentfallers(Figure6.5),althoughtherelationshipwasweakerforfair/poorvisionandhearing.
Figure 6.5: Self-reported unsteadiness while walking in non-recurrent fallers and recurrent fallers, by age group
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
143
AtmostspatialfrequenciesofvisualfunctionassessedinTILDA(i.e.acrossthespectrumrepresentingsharpdetailedimagestocoarserimages),contrastsensitivitywaslowerinrecurrentfallerscomparedtonon-recurrentfallersbuttherewasnodifferenceinvisualacuity(Table6.7).However,therewereclearageandsexdifferenceswithlowervisualacuity and contrast sensitivity observed with increasing age and in women (Figure 6�6)�
Figure 6.6: Visual acuity in non-recurrent fallers and recurrent fallers, by age group and sex
The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing
144
6.4 Identifyingthemostimportantpredictorsofrecurrentfalls
AllofthevariablesusedabovetoprofilefallerswereincludedinamultivariatemodeltoidentifythemostimportantpredictorsofrecurrentfallsatWave2and/orWave3.Thesewereidentifiedasprevioushistoryoffalling,fearoffalling,self-reportedunsteadinesswhilewalking,andnon-cardiovascularchronicconditions(Table6.8).TheRelativeRisks(RR)presentedinthetablecanbeinterpretedasthechangeinriskassociatedwithhavingtheriskfactormentioned.Forexample,participantswhoreportedunsteadinesswhilewalkinghada1.5times,or50%,increasedriskofreportingrecurrentfallscomparedtothosewhodidnotreportunsteadinesswhilewalking.Itshouldbenotedthatthisrelativelysimplemodellingapproachdoesnottakeaccountofpotentiallyimportantmodifyingeffectsofdifferentvariablesinthemodel,norofpotentialcausalpathwaysbetweenvariables.FutureanalysesfromTILDAwillusemoresophisticatedstatisticalmethodstobetterunderstandhowtheseriskfactorsmayvarydependingontheirinteractionswithcertaincharacteristicse.g.sex,agegroup,depressivesymptoms.
Table 6.8: Indicators of health and function which predict recurrent falls at Wave 2 and/or Wave 3
RR (95% CI)
Self-reportedunsteadinesswhenwalking 1�50 (1�22-1�85)
1 non-cardiovascular condition 1�47 (1.21-1.79)
≥2non-cardiovascularconditions 1�55 (1.21-1.97)
Somewhat afraid of falling 1�31 (1.07-1.59)
Very afraid of falling 1�50 (1.13-1.99)
Previous history of falls 2�03 (1�72-2�38)
Fullmodelincludesage,sex,BMI,previoushistoryoffalls,numberofcardiovascularconditions,numberofnon-cardiovascularconditions,orthostatichypotension,osteopenia/osteoporosis,gripstrength,usualwalkingspeed,self-ratedunsteadinesswhenwalking,self-ratedhearing,self-ratedvision,visualacuity,contrastsensitivity,MontrealCognitiveAssessment,colourtrailstimedifference,choicereactiontime,depressivesymptoms,fearoffallingandpolypharmacy(n=3,858).
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
145
6.5 Identifyingthemostimportantpredictorsofinjuriousfalls
Theprofileofinjuriousfallerswasverysimilartorecurrentfallers.Theyalsodisplayedpoorerindicatorsofhealthandfunctionacrossmultipledomainsincludingphysical,cognitiveandmentalhealth.Wetheninvestigatedthepredictorsofinjuriousfalls,againusingamultivariateanalysis.Themostimportantvariablesthatpredictinjuriousfallsatfollow-upareage,beingfemale,aprevioushistoryoffalls,havingorthostatichypotension,clinicallyrelevantdepressivesymptoms,osteopeniaandself-reportedunsteadinesswhenwalking(Table6.9).
Table 6.9: Indicators of health and function which predict injurious falls at Wave 2 and/or Wave 3
RR (95% CI)
Orthostatichypotension 1�56 (1�22-2�00)
Self-reportedunsteadinesswhenwalking 1�32 (1�06-1�64)
Clinicallyrelevantdepressivesymptoms 1�35 (1�05-1�74)
Osteopenia 1�26 (1�05-1�50)
Age(per1yearincrease) 1�02 (1�01-1�03)
Female sex 1�54 (1�27-1�87)
Previous history of falls 1�82 (1�54-2�15)
Fullmodelincludesage,sex,BMI,previoushistoryoffalls,numberofcardiovascularconditions,numberofnon-cardiovascularconditions,orthostatichypotension,osteopenia/osteoporosis,gripstrength,usualwalkingspeed,self-ratedunsteadinesswhenwalking,self-ratedhearing,self-ratedvision,visualacuity,contrastsensitivity,MontrealCognitiveAssessment,colourtrailstimedifference,choicereactiontime,depressivesymptoms,fearoffallingandpolypharmacy(n=3,858).
The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing
146
6.6 Conclusion
Theburdenoffallsishighinadultsaged50yearsandoverinIreland,withalmost40%reportingatleastonefallduring4yearsfollow-up.Importantly,approximatelyhalfoffallersornearly20%ofthepopulationreportedrecurrentfalls,awellknownriskfactorforsubsequentinjuryandhospitalisation.Asimilarproportionexperiencedafallthatresultedinaninjuryseriousenoughtorequiremedicaltreatment.Ingeneral,olderadultswhoreportrecurrentfallsorinjuriousfallsdisplaypoorerindicatorsofphysical,cognitiveandmentalhealthandfunctioncomparedtonon-fallers.Themostimportantfactorsthatpredictrecurrentfallsareahistoryofpreviousfalls,self-reportedunsteadinesswhenwalking,anincreasingnumberofnon-cardiovascularconditions,andbeingsomewhatafraidoffalling.Injuriousfallerssharemanyoftheseriskfactors(historyofpreviousfalls,self-reportedunsteadinesswhenwalking),howeverbeingolder,female,havingpotentiallyclinicallyrelevantdepressivesymptoms,reducedbonestrength(osteopenia)andhavingorthostatichypotensionarealsoimportantpredictorsinthisgroup.
Theimportanceofaprevioushistoryoffallshighlightstheneedforearlymonitoringandinterventiontoaddressanyexistingriskfactors.Mostfallsoccurwhilewalking(13),thereforeunsteadinesswhilewalkingpresentsanopportunitytoidentifyanunderlyingdifficultyorperceptionthatsomethingisnotquiteright,evenifthisisnotvisuallyobvious.Depressivesymptomsarecommoninolderadultsandtheyhaveacomplexrelationshipwithfalls.Bothsharecommonriskfactors;depressivesymptomsandconsequenttreatmentwithantidepressantscanleadtoafall,whilefallscanalsoresultinincreaseddepressivesymptoms(14).Orthostatichypotensionisalsocommoninolderadultsandmaycausefallsandfaintsthroughdecreasesinbrainbloodflowwhenstandingup.
Fallshaveveryseriousconsequences,therefore,itisimportanttoidentifysomeonewithahighriskoffallsandsubsequentlyimplementanappropriatefallpreventionprogrammetoreducetheirriskfactorswherepossible.ThecurrentAmericanGeriatricSocietyandBritishGeriatricSocietyGuidelinesforFallPrevention(15)recommendthatalladultsaged65yearsandovershouldbeaskedaboutfallsinthepast12monthsanddifficultieswithgaitorbalance,atleastonceperyear.Thosewhohavefallenpreviouslyorwhoreportdifficultieswithgaitorbalanceshouldthenundergoacomprehensivefallsassessmenttoidentifytheneedforaninterventiontoreducetheirfallrisk.Ideally,thiswouldbeimplementedattheprimarycareleveltopromoteaproactiveapproachthatfocusesonearlydetectionofriskratherthanareactiveapproachafterafallhasoccurred.Luckily,manyoftheriskfactorshighlightedabovearemodifiableandcanatleastbeimprovedifnot removed altogether�
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
147
Itisimportanttohighlightthatfallsandphysiologicaldeclinearenotaninevitableconsequenceofageing.Themosteffectivefallpreventionstrategiesaremultifactorialandmayincludeinterventionstoimprovemusclestrength,gaitandbalance;reducemedications(wherepossible);manageposturalhypotension;managefootproblemsandfootwear;adaptormodifythehomeenvironmentandsupplementwithVitaminD(AmericanGeriatricSociety/BritishGeriatricSocietyGuidelines,2011).Physicalexerciseisoneofthemosteffectivemeansofimprovingwalking,balanceandstrengthwhilealsoprovidingarangeofotherphysical,cognitive,psychologicalandsocialbenefits(16,17,18).Assumingthatitisadaptedtoeachindividual’sneeds,itshouldberecommendedasstandardforallindividuals,youngandold.However,Rosehighlightedthatthemosteffectivetype,intensityanddoseofexerciseisnotyetclearandthereforeislikelytovarywithdifferentlevelsoffallrisk(19).
Giventhechangingdemographics,fallsrepresentamajorchallengeforthehealthcareservices.In2008,theHealthServiceExecutive,DepartmentofHealthandChildrenandNationalCouncilonAgeingandOlderPeoplepublishedaStrategytoPreventFallsandFracturesinIreland’sAgeingPopulation.Thisreliesonidentificationofriskfactors,managementofspecificconditionsandappropriateinterventiontohelppeopletoreducetheirriskoffalls.TheNationalFallsandBoneHealthProjectAFFINITY(ActivatingFallsandFracturePreventioninIrelandTogether)wassetupin2013toimplementthisstrategy(20).Howevertodate,fallriskassessmentisnotroutinelycarriedout,thereforemanyolderadultswhowouldbenefitfrominterventionand/ormodificationofriskfactorsarenotbeingflaggedforfollow-up.
Morerecently,theNationalClinicalProgrammeforOlderPeoplewhichisajointinitiativebetweentheHSEClinicalStrategyandProgrammesDivisionandtheRoyalCollegeofPhysiciansofIreland,havehighlightedtheroleofthecomprehensivegeriatricassessment.Thisreviewsanolderperson’smedicalconditions,mentalhealth,functionalcapacityandsocialcircumstanceswiththeintentionofdevelopingandimplementinganintegratedassessment,interventionandreviewofanolderperson’sindividualneeds(21).Thisencompassesmanyofthesameteststhatareusedinfallsassessmentandtherefore,thereisalotofscopetoidentifyfallriskusingthisapproach.
Insummary,fallsandfall-relatedinjuriesarecommonamongolderadultsinIrelandandtherearemultiplehealth-relatedfactorsthatmayincreaseanindividual’sriskoffalls.Excitingly,manyofthefactorsidentifiedarepotentiallymodifiable,pavingthewayforfutureinterventionsandfallspreventioninitiatives.
The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing
148
References
1� RubensteinLZ.Fallsinolderpeople:epidemiology,riskfactorsandstrategiesforprevention.AgeAgeing.2006;35Suppl2:ii37-ii41.
2� HealthServiceExecutive,NationalCouncilonAgeingandOlderPeople,DepartmentofHealthandChildren.StrategytoPreventFallsandFracturesinIreland’sAgeingPopulation.ReportoftheNationalSteeringGrouponthePreventionofFallsinOlderPeopleandthePreventionandManagementofOsteoporosisthroughoutLife,June2008�
3� TinettiME.Preventingfallsinelderlypersons.NEnglJMed.2003;348(1):42-49.
4� FinucaneC,O’ConnellMD,FanCW,SavvaGM,SoraghanCJ,NolanH,CroninH,KennyRA.AgerelatedNormativechangesinphasicorthostaticbloodpressureinalargepopulationstudy:FindingsfromtheIrishLongitudinalStudyonAgeing(TILDA).Circulation.2014;130:1780-1789
5� VarennaM,SinigagliaL,AdamiS,GianniniS,IsaiaG,MaggiS,etal.Associationofquantitativeheelultrasoundwithhistoryofosteoporoticfracturesinelderlymen:theESOPOstudy.OsteoporoInt.2005;16(12):1749-1754.
6� CraigCL,MarshallAL,SjostromM,BaumanAE,BoothML,AinsworthBE,etal.Internationalphysicalactivityquestionnaire:12-countryreliabilityandvalidity.MedSciinSportsExerc.2003;35(8):1381-95.
7� IPAQ.GuidelinesforthedataprocessingandanalysisoftheInternationalPhysicalActivityQuestionnaire2005.
8� D’EliaLF,SatzP,UchiyamaCL,WhiteT.ColorTrailsTest.Professionalmanual.Odessa,FL:PsychologicalAssessmentResources,1996.
9. RadloffLS.TheCES-Dscale:Aself-reportdepressionscaleforresearchinthegeneralpopulation.AppliedPsychologicalMeasurement.1977;1:385-401.
10� ClarkDO,CallahanCM,CounsellSR.,Reliabilityandvalidityofasteadinessscore.AmGeriatrSoc.2005;53(9):1582-6.
6 Measures of Health and Function that Predict Future Falls
149
11� ColenbranderA.Visualstandards,aspectsandrangeofvisionlosswithemphasisonpopulationsurveys.ReportpreparedfortheInternationalCouncilofOphthalmologyatthe29thInternationalCongressofOphthalmology.Sydney,2002.
12� DonoghueOA,RyanH,DugganE,FinucaneC,SavvaGM,CroninH,LoughmanJ,KennyRA.Relationshipbetweenfearoffallingandmobilityvarieswithvisualfunctionamongolderadults.GeriatrandGerontolInt.2014;14(4):827-36
13� MackenzieL,ByesJ,HigginbothamN.Aprospectivecommunity-basedstudyoffallsamongolderpeopleinAustralia:Frequency,circumstances,andconsequences.OTJR:Occupation,Participation,andHealth.2002;22(4):143-152.
14� IaboniA,FlintAJ.Thecomplexinterplayofdepressionandfallsinolderadults:aclinicalreview.AmJGeriatrPsychiatry2013;21:484-492.
15� SummaryoftheUpdatedAmericanGeriatricsSociety/BritishGeriatricsSocietyclinicalpracticeguidelineforpreventionoffallsinolderpersons.AmGeriatrSoc.2011;59(1),148-157�
16� ColcombeS,KramerAF.Fitnesseffectsonthecognitivefunctionofolderadults:ameta-analyticstudy.PsycholSci.2003;14:125-130.
17� DonoghueO,O’ConnellM,KennyRA.WalkingtoWellbeing:PhysicalActivity,SocialParticipationandPsychologicalHealthinIrishadultsaged50yearsandOlder.Dublin:TheIrishLongitudinalStudyonAgeing,2016.
18� WorldHealthOrganisation.GlobalRecommendationsonPhysicalActivityforHealth.2010�
19.RoseDJ.Preventingfallsamongolderadults:No“onesizesuitsall”interventionstrategy.RehabilResDev.2008;45(8):1153-1166.
20� NationalFallsandBoneHealthProjectAFFINITY(ActivatingFallsandFracturePreventioninIrelandTogether).Availableat:http://www.affinityfallsbonehealth.ie/index.html�
21� NationalClinicalProgrammeforOlderPeople(2016).ComprehensiveGeriatricAssessmentAvailablefrom:https://www.hse.ie/eng/about/Who/clinical/natclinprog/olderpeopleprogramme/resources/ComprehensiveGeriatricAssessmentSummary.pdf
The Irish Longitudinal Study on Ageing
150