McGill March 2014 - WordPress.comMcGill Presentation March 2015 Private Equity Experiences in...
Transcript of McGill March 2014 - WordPress.comMcGill Presentation March 2015 Private Equity Experiences in...
McGill Presentation March 2015
Private Equity Experiences
in
Frontier Markets
by
Brian Langis
Overview
• Intro • Frontier Markets Overview
• PE in America vs EM/Frontier Markets • Past Investment Summary • Questions??
Contact Info
• @absolut_brian
• brianlangis.wordpress.com
• seekingalpha.com/author/brian-langis
Leopard Capital Background
• Established in 2008, raised $34m, exit 2016 • Frontier Market PE fund (pre-EM) • Chairman: Marc Faber • LP domiciled in the Cayman • Mid-Market • Activities in Cambodia, Laos, Haiti, Thailand, Myanmar,
Bangladesh • Investments: SEA 13 and Haiti 3 • Focus on buy-out, venture, expansion • Role: Passive and active role • Spun-off Mutual Fund, Asia Frontier Capital
Analysts/Associate: PE vs Investment Banking
• IB = advisory/capital raising, m&a, restructuring
• PE = investment business, investors not advisor
• Business models do intersect
• IB: Pitch book, modeling, administrative work
• PE: Less standardization. Fundraising, screening + making investments, managing companies, exit
Typical Structure
Frontier Markets Perception
• Highly indebted /Poor fiscal shape • Poor • Wild Wild West of investing • Corruption, you have to bribe to get ahead • Poor corporate governance • Volatile • Mismanagement • Too commodity oriented • Uneducated/Illiterate • Malnourished kids, genocides, despots, disasters,
despair
Reality
• Next wave of emerging markets • Young population, rising income, growing middle class • Low debt • Low correlation to rich countries • Profits mostly depends on local factors • Attractive valuation • Higher growth • Lost-cost workforce • Leapfrog • Reverse “brain drain”
Frontier Markets Snapshot
• ~198 countries, ~9 without exchanges (3 traditional; North-Korea, Brunei, Myanmar)
• 30% of world’s population
• 13% of world’s GDP
• Less than 3% global market cap
• 70% of countries with stock exchanges are not represented by the MSCI All-Country World Index.
• MSCI Frontier Index – Not perfect
• 23 of 25 fastest growing countries over the next 5 years are frontiers – Source IMF
Early America
• Former frontier market
• Was one of the most corrupt country in the world
• Wild Wild West of Investing/ Dog eat dog world
• Lack of rule of law
• Wars, financials crisis
• Cheap labor, plenty of natural resources
• Plenty of bankruptcy (banks, railroads…etc)
• State bankruptcy (Arkansas, Illinois, Mississippi…)
Perception: True Size
Not All FM Are Equal
• We “categorized countries” • Required:
– Legal reliable framework (respect property rights, enforce contracts)
– Free market – Capital mobility – Pro-business, Pro-Investment – Openness to foreign investors – Stable government – Eradication of corruption, enhanced transparency – Sound corporate governance – Development of Capital Markets
Why Invest in Frontier Markets?
• It’s about showing up to the party early. First-mover advantage. You get a head start. You get the best deals before the herd shows up. (Selling to the herd should be profitable.)
• Capturing where the growth is going to be • There are GREAT BUSINESSES THAT ARE CHEAP • The point is to invest in the “BRICs” before it was cool. • Imagine investing in after WWII Japan, or Korea, or
Thailand forty years ago. It’s sounded crazy, very contrarian. • Still a lot of untapped resources. • Government reform efforts also present the potential for
both earnings growth and revaluation for frontier-market companies.
Typical Target
• Are mid sized companies
• Offer a projected Gross IRR of 20 - 30%
• Employ some international managers
• Face minimal local competition
• Are future candidates for local IPOs
• Comply with our ESG policies
• Use credible auditors
PE in NA vs FM
• Financial options are limited • Investor education • Good partners • Policy • Legal • Due diligence • Time for deals to materialize • Risk of underperformance • Liquidity • Higher risk (Political, currency, stability, volatility,
corruption…etc)
FM Investment Decision Drivers
• Very important: Funding access, openness to foreign investors, legal, group/partners
• Less important: GDP growth, interest rates
• Great partner = capitalize on the growth
• Other issues: corporate governance, transparency, clean background
• Early mover = tie up best partners and best deals
Valuation Challenges
• Boots on the ground • Lack of information/data • Google/Capital IQ/Bloomberg • Investor education • Due diligence • Pretty financial modeling = useless • Culture • Investment quality • Fail deals: Not legal, no financial.
Advice Approach
• Macro factors such as GDP growth, the level of interest rates, et cetera are less important in deciding whether to invest in a given country.
• Be skeptical of local brokers/analysts • Always bullish, otherwise is seen as a traitor • Usually after own interest (Want money to increase fund size) • If bearish, will lose job, potential government business, and
corporate finance deals • Academic papers – (guess who paid the academics) • Don’t rely too much on statistics. GDP often understated.
(Bartering, household, underground economy etc…) • The emergence of the middle class in country X —these are
gimmicks, just marketing stories for fund managers.
PPWSA
• First Cambodia IPO April 2012
• Government spin-off 15%, 13m shares offered
• Offering price range of 4,050 to 6,350 riel (US$1.00-1.57) per share
• Size: The implied offering size is US$13.0 to US$20.4m
• IPO bookbuilding process managed by TONGYANG Securities (Korean)
• Post-IPO share count: 86.9m
PPWSA
• PPWSA revenues: Water supply, connections, service and consulting
• Water tariff progressive
• Total capacity of 330,000m3/day
• Network of ~2,000 km covering 90% of PP
• Revenues: ~$30m
• Assets: ~220m in assets
• Equity ~$145m
COMPARABLE COMPANIESAll $ figures in millions except per share amounts
Company Name (Ticker)
Market
Cap ($mm)
Enterprise
Value
($mm)
P/E
2011
P/E
2012E
P/E
2013E
Price /
Book
EV/
EBITDA
2011
EV /
EBITDA
2012E
Dividend
Yield
2012E
ROE
2011
SE AsiaThai Tap Water Supply (SET:TTW) $ 745 $ 916 10.8x 10.0x 9.3x 2.2x 7.3x 7.8x 7.0% 22.5%
Eastern Water Resources (SET:EASTW) $ 390 $ 483 11.8x 10.7x 9.6x 1.7x 8.2x 7.1x 7.7% 13.5%
Manila Water Company (PSE:MWC) $ 1,037 $ 1,406 10.7x 9.0x 7.7x 2.0x 6.8x 5.8x 2.0% 19.1%
Other AsiaHyflux Ltd (Singapore:600) $ 996 $ 1,131 22.3x 13.2x 10.6x 1.3x 8.7x 7.3x 2.8% 16.5%
Beijing Enterprises Water Group (HK:371) $ 1,870 $ 2,548 20.1x 14.6x 12.4x 2.2x 15.3x 11.2x 2.0% 13.6%
China Water Affairs (HK:855) $ 458 $ 668 8.4x 13.3x 12.5x 1.1x 2.0% 14.7%
Non-AsiaUK
United Utilities Group PLC (London:UU) $ 6,715 $ 14,928 9.2x 15.3x 13.6x 2.5x 10.6x 10.7x 5.2% 18.2%
Pennon Group PLC (London:PNN) $ 4,217 $ 7,286 15.4x 17.0x 15.2x 3.4x 11.4x 11.0x 3.8% 20.8%
Severn Trent (London:SVT) $ 5,963 $ 12,358 13.6x 15.9x 13.6x 3.4x 9.7x 9.5x 4.5% 24.5%
USAmerican Water Works (NYSE:AWK) $ 6,008 $ 11,611 19.3x 17.8x 16.3x 1.4x na na 2.8% 7.5%
American States Water (NYSE:AWR) $ 682 $ 1,022 15.9x 15.9x 15.1x 1.7x na na 3.2% na
Aqua America, Inc. (NYSE:WTR) $ 3,071 $ 4,538 21.2x 20.0x 18.5x 2.5x na na 3.1% na
California Water Service Group (NYSE:CWT) $ 763 $ 1,271 17.8x 16.2x 15.3x 1.7x na na 3.4% na
SJW Corp. (NYSE:SJW) $ 443 $ 787 26.2x 22.2x 19.2x 1.7x na na 3.0% na
Middlesex Water Company (NASDAQ:MSEX) $ 287 $ 420 21.4x 18.7x 17.5x 1.6x na na 3.9% na
Connecticut Water Service, Inc. (NASDAQ:CTWS) $ 252 $ 362 21.4x 19.6x 19.6x 2.1x na na 3.5% na
PPWSA
High $ 137 $ 182 15.9x 17.0x 13.8x 3.3x 12.5x 11.9x 0.6% 6.5%
Medium $ 112 $ 157 13.0x 13.9x 11.3x 2.9x 10.8x 10.2x 0.7% 6.5%
Low $ 87 $ 133 10.1x 10.8x 8.8x 2.5x 9.1x 8.6x 0.9% 6.5%
IPO Results
• Offering 17x oversubscribed
• Share went up 60% on the first day of trading
• Leopard exited with a 42% gain
• Share tanked since then, now trading at 5,000 riel, below book value
• No trading
• Other IPOs taking a long time
• Today only one stock is trading but 2nd on the way. Grand Twins International
PPWSA Update Fiscal 2014 Numbers / US$
• Water utility company, $1.09/share, $94 million market cap • Price below 2012 IPO of $1.55 • FY2014 Revenue – $37.2m, yoy +14.5% • Profit – $11.3m, EPS: $0.13, yoy+30% • ROE – 2.55% • ROA – 1.59% • Current and Quick Ratio – 4.2x and 3.4x • Dividend Payout Ratio – 12.50% (2012: 7%) • 2013 Dividend per share: $0.013 (2012: $0.006) +116% • Great management, 99% billing collection, monopoly • Valuation: Forward P/E 9x, P/B: 0.52x
Stock Exchange Update
• Cambodia (World’s smallest exchange?) – 2 listing, ~$5k volume, mkt cap:
1) Phnom Penh Water Supply Authority
2) Grand Twins International
• Laos – 4 listings, ~$750k volume, mkt cap:
1) Banque Pour Le Commerce Exterieur Lao
2) Electricite du Laos Generation Public Company
3) Petroleum Trading Lao Public Company
4) Lao World Public Company
Difficulties
• Education • Mindset • Resistance • Lack of volume, Size, Cost • Don’t understand the mechanism of the stock
market • Need for compliance + transparency • Company owners don’t understand why they
have to reveal their financial statements to the public.
Extreme Frontier Investing
• WARNING
• For informational purposes.
• Do your own research.
• Not an investing recommendation.
• Information need to be verified.
• This is not an endorsement.
Extreme Frontier Investing
• Defaulted North Korea Bond from the 1970s for about ~0.15 on the dollar. The interest accrual, since their 1984 default, amounts to more than 500 percent of the principal in unpaid interest.
• Largest car theft in the world, US$393m • Orascom Telecom (EGX:OTMT) – 1m+ subscriber in NK.
Owns 25% of Koryolink. Only 4% mobile penetration. • Invest in Chinese companies operating in NK. • South-Korea companies operating in NK • Alternative assets: Coins, stamps, art. • Special Economic Zones on the rise. (Rason)
NK Mobile Connections
More Exotic Investments
• The world’s first pirate exchange, Harardheere, Somalia.
• Open 24 hours a day, the exchange allows investors to profit from ransoms collected on the high seas, which can approach $10 million for successful attacks against Western commercial vessels.
• There’s now approximately 72 maritime companies. • You can provide cash, weapons or useful materials. • Ransoms collects between $2 to $4 million. $9.5m for
the Smyrni, a Greek tanker. • Risk: Attacks are dropping. 237 attacks in 2011, 75 in
2012, 15 in 2013. Is the market hitting a bottom?
At the end of the day this is what matters:
• Don’t buy a stock because its from an “exotic high growth country”.
• Valuation. Buying below its intrinsic value. Value < price. Low/reasonable valuation.
• Margin of safety
• Adjusted EBITDA good for comparing cross-country companies.
• Predictable, consistent cash flow
• Look for increasing FCF, and ability to re-invest
• Prefer dividend paying Co. Can fake earnings. Can’t fake dividend. Shareholder oriented.
• Reliable financial statements
• Excellent management/partners
Advice
• Networking. No job posting.
• Ask for 15 min trick
• Knock on the door
• Attitude
• Just show up
• PE hiring cycle
• “Resourcefulness”