Maya Kodnani - Bail and Suspension of Sentence Gujarat HC

8/12/2019 Maya Kodnani - Bail and Suspension of Sentence Gujarat HC

1/9

R/CR.MA/10567/2014 ORDER

IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD

CRIMINAL MISC. APPLICATION (FOR SUSPENSION OFSENTENCE) NO. 10567 of 2014

InCRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1713 of 2012

=========================================MAYAEN SUREN!RA"AI #O!NANI....A$$%&'n

*+,--STATE OF /UARAT 1....R+-$on+n-

=========================================AppearanceMR S * RAU SENIOR COUNSEL ASSISTE! Y MR MITES" R AMINA!*OCATE fo, + A$$%&'n.MR PRAS"ANT !ESAI SENIOR COUNSEL ASSISTE! Y MR AY #O/E AN!

MR /AURAN/ *YAS SPECIAL PULIC PROSECUTORS fo, + R+-$on+n-.=========================================

CORAM "ONOURALE MR.USTICE *IAY MANO"AR SA"AIn"ONOURALE MR.USTICE R.P.!"OLARIA

!+ 30072014

ORAL OR!ER (PER "ONOURALE MR.USTICE *IAY MANO"AR SA"AI)

RULE. No&'+ of ,%+ - ++n 8&9+ : %+,n+

'on-+% $$+,&n; fo, + ,+-$on+n-.

&n n M,. ",&? !9+ %+,n+

'on-+% $$+,&n; fo, + $$%&'n M,. P,-n /. !+-& %+,n+

S+n&o, Con-+% --&-+ : M,. A.Y. #o;+ n M,. /,n; *:-

%+,n+ S$+'&% P%&' P,+o-+'o,- $$+,&n; fo, + ,+-$on+n

No.2 n M,. #.N. S-,& %+,n+ 'on-+% $$+,&n; fo, +

9&'&>-.

2. T&- $$%&'&on fo, --$+n-&on of -+n+n'+ n fo,

;,n of ,+;%, &% $+n&n; +, $$+% - ++n f&%+ : +

$$%&'n. T+ $$%&'n 8- n ''-+ &n S+--&on- C-+ No.243

Page 1of 9


2/9


of 200@ n &n f' +,+ 8+,+ S+--&on- C-+- ,&+. T+: 8+,+

%% '%+ o;++, n + %+&n; S+--&on- C-+ 8- ,++ o

+ S+--&on- C-+ No.235 of 200@. T+ $$%&'n - ++n

'on9&'+ fo, + &ff+,+n off+n'+- - >+n&on+ +%o8 B

Convictionunder Sectionof IC

Sentence Fine Defau!tSentence

2@5 ,8 120B 2 Y+,- RI 200B 15 :- RI

427 ,8 120B 2 :+,- RI 200B 15 :- RI

435 ,8 120B 2 :+,- RI 200B 15 :- RI

436 ,8 120B 2 :+,- RI 1000B 30 :- RI440 ,8 120B 5 :+,- RI 500B 20 :- RI

153 ,8 120B 1 Y+, RI 200B 7 :- RI

153BA ,8 120B 3 :+,- RI 300B 20 :- RI

153BA (2) ,8120B

3 :+,- RI 300B 20 :- RI

323 ,8 120B 6 >on- RI 200B 7 :- RI

324 ,8 120B 1 :+, RI 200B 15 :- RI

325 ,8 120B 7 :+,- RI 500B 20 :- RI

326 ,8 120B 10 :+,- RI 1000B 30 :- RI

307 ,8 120B 10 :+,- RI 1000B 30 :- RI

302 ,8 120B 1 :+,- RI 5000B 40 :- RI

3. T+ $$+%%n f&%+ n $$+% n+, S+'&on 374 of

+ Co+ of C,&>&n% P,o'+,+ 1@73. To; + $$+% 8- f&%+

&n No9+>+, 2012 & 8- no f&%+ %on; 8& n: ,+;%, &%

$$%&'&on. A ,+;%, &% $$%&'&on 8- f&%+ +&n; C,&>&n%

M&-'. A$$%&'&on No.6023 of 2013 8+,+&n +,+ 8+,+ off&'+

o+'&on- & 'o% no + ,+>o9+ : + $$%&'n + o

8&' & -oo &->&--+ 8&o ,+f+,+n'+ o + Co, - $+, +

o,+, + 12.6.2013 $--+ : + !&9&-&on +n'.

4. T+ $$%&'n 8- -&'? n +,+fo,+ -+ $$%&+ fo,

Page 2of 9


3/9


+>$o,,: &% 8&' 8- ;,n+ : + !&9&-&on +n' on

12.11.2013 fo, $+,&o of ,++ >on-. T+ $$%&'n ;&n

$$%&+ fo, +>$o,,: &% on + ->+ ;,on of >+&'% &%%n+--

+ +>$o,,: &% $$%&'&on 8- no ;,n+ : + !&9&-&on

+n' n : &- o,+, + 6.2.2014 & &,+'+ +

$$%&'n 'n + ,++ + C&9&% "o-$&% ,n : + S+

/o9+,n>+n - ''o,&n; o + !&9&-&on +n' + ,+>+n

f'&%&: 8- 9&%%+ &n + C&9&% "o-$&% n + +>$o,,: &%

$$%&'&on 8- ,+f-+.

5. T&- o,+, + 6.2.2014 8- '%%+n;+ : +

$$%&'n +fo,+ + A$+ Co,. T+ A$+ Co, : &- ;>+n

+ 24.2.2014 &->&--+ + S$+'&% L+9+ P+&&on (C,&>&n%)

No.352 of 2014. "o8+9+, %&+,: 8- ;,n+ o + $$%&'n

fo, f&%&n; $$,o$,&+ $$%&'&on fo, ;,n of ,+;%, &% +fo,+ +

"&; Co,. T+,+fo,+ + $$%&'n - $$%&+ fo, ;,n of

,+;%, &%.

6. L+,n+ 'on-+% fo, + $$+%%n - ,;+ +

$$+%%n ++n 'on9&'+ : + S$+'&% Co, on +

$,+->$&on of +, $,&'&$&on &n + ,&o- o; + +9&+n'+

on ,+'o, $,o9+- o+,8&-+. "+ - f,+, ->&+ +

$$%&'n &- &nno'+n n 8- no &n9o%9+ &n + %%+;+ ',&>+. I

&- f,+, %%+;+ + $$%&'n &- no ;&%: of n: 'on-$&,':."+ - f,+, ,;+ -+ &- -+,&o-%: -&'? n C+,&f&'+

+ 14.7.2014 &--+ : C&,>n C.!.M.O. M+&'%

S$+,&n+n+n of C&9&% "o-$&% A>+ &- on + ,+'o,

8+,+&n & &- -+ + +>&n+ + $$%&'n n -+ &-

-ff+,&n; f,o> + &-+-+- >+n&on+ &n + C+,&f&'+ n f,+,

& - ++n o-+,9+ &n + '+,&f&'+ + $$%&'n &- no

,+-$on&n; o + ,+>+n n +,+ 8- no &>$,o9+>+n.

Page 3of 9


4/9


7. On + o+, n M,. P,-n !+-& %+,n+ S+n&o,

Con-+% n S$+'&% P%&' P,o-+'o, $$+,&n; fo, +

,+-$on+n- - 9++>+n%: ,;+ %oo?&n; o + +&no-

',&>+ 8+,+&n %,;+ n>+, of $+o$%+ &+ n 8+,+ &n,+

$,o$+,&+- 8+,+ +-,o:+ n ,n-'?+ + Co, -o% no +

%&+,% &n ;,n of &% $$%&'&on n -o% 9&+8 + >+, 9+,:

-,&'%: n %oo?&n; o + -+,&o-n+-- of + off+n'+ &n 8&' +

$$%&'n - ++n fon o + ;&%: -+ &- +n&%+ fo, no

&n%;+n'+ n +, &% $$%&'&on &- %&%+ o + ,++'+. T+

,;>+n of M,. !+-& ++n o$+ : M,. #.N. S-,&

9o'+ fo, + 9&'&>-.

. An &n'&+n ?+n $%'+ of ?&%%&n; of #, S+9?-

/o, &n S,>& E$,+-- on 27.2.2002 8&%+ + T,&n 8-

'o>&n; f,o> A:o: %+ /o,. Af+, + /o, ,&n

',n;+ 8&+ -$,+ n %,;+ -'%+ 'o>>n% ,&o- ,&;;+,+ of&n + S+ of /,. In N,o P&: on 2.2.2002 @6 >n

%&9+- 8+,+ %o- 8&' &n'%+- >&--&n; $+,-on- 125 $+,-on- 8+,+

&n,+ $,o$+,: of ',o,+- of ,$++- 8+,+ >;+ +-,o:+ n

,n-'?+. T+ ;,o$ of S+--&on- C-+- &- $o$%,%: ?no8n -

DN,o P&: C-+ ?+n $%'+ &n + f+,> of +

+-,'&on of + ,& M-& &n A:o: U, P,+-.

A''o,&n; o + $,o-+'&on '-+ + 9&'&>- >&n%: &%+ f,o>M-%&> 'o>>n&:.

@. T+ A$+ Co, +'&+ + &ff+,+n'+ of o$&n&on

+8++n 8o "on%+ ;+- of + A$+ Co, on + +-&on -

o 8++, + 'o>>n% ,&o '-+- ,+&,+ &ff+,+n -n, of

$,oof n o,&n,: ',&>&n% '-+-. In $,;,$ 43 of &-

;>+n &n "ai!a#$ Gour and ot$er# v% State of A##a&' ()*+),

Page 4of 9


5/9


) SCC -. + A$+ Co, +% - n+, B

G43. H n ''-+ &- $,+->+ o + &nno'+n &%%

+ &- $,o9+ ;&%: +:on ,+-on%+ o &-

$,&n'&$%+ 'nno + -',&f&'+ on + %, of

&n+ff&'&+n': &n+': o, &n+$ n%&n; of +

&n9+-&;&on : + $o%&'+. T+ +n+f& ,&-&n; f,o>

n: -' f%: &n9+-&;&on o; o ;o o +

''-+ n no o + $,o-+'&on. So %-o +

%&: n ',+&&%&: of + +9&+n'+ ,+&,+ o

,&n; o>+ + ;&% of + ''-+ 'nno +

&ff+,+n &n '-+- 8+,+ + &n9+-&;&on &-

-&-f'o,: 9&-BB9&- '-+- &n 8&' & &- no. T+

,%+- of +9&+n'+ n + -n,- : 8&' +

->+ - o + +9%+ %-o 'nno + &ff+,+n &n

'-+- +$+n&n; $on 8++, + '-+ - n:

'o>>n% o9+,on+- o, &n n o,&n,: ',&>+ fo,

$--&on ;&n o, 9,&'+.J

10. T+,+fo,+ + %8 &- -+%+ n ''-+ &-

$,+->+ o + &nno'+n &%% + &- $,o9+ ;&%: +:on ,+-on%+

o n &f +,+ &- f%: &n9+-&;&on o, &n+ff&'&+n':

&n+': o, &n$ n%&n; of + &n9+-&;&on : + Po%&'+

+n +n+f& of -' f%: &n9+-&;&on - o ;o o + ''-+

n no o + $,o-+'&on n + $,o-+'&on 'nno +-'$+ f,o>

$,o9&n; + '-+ ;&n- + ''-+ : %+&n; ',+&%+ +9&+n'+

8&' &- ,+&,+ o + +-%&-+ +9+n &n n o,&n,: ',&>+.

11. "+&no-n+-- of ',&>+ o, ',+%: &n &- ++'&on

o8-o+9+, o,,&n; n +f% 'nno ,+f%+' &n +'&&n; +

;&%. E' ?no of + ',&>&no%o;&'% '&n - o + $,o9+

+:on -o8 of o o ,&n; o>+ + ;&%. An: ','? o,

%oo-+n&n; &n & 8+?+n- + $,o-+'&on. E' %&n? >- + -o

'on-&-+n + on%: 'on'%-&on 8&' >- f%o8 &- +

Page 5of 9


6/9


''-+ &- ;&%:. C,+&&%&: of 8&n+--+- - o + >+-,+ 8&

->+ :,-&'? 8++, & &- n o,&n,: ',&>+ o, ',&>+

+>n&n; + o 'o>>n% f,+nK:. L8 o+- no >?+ n:

&-&n'&on +&+, &n %+&n; of +9&+n'+ o, &n &- --+-->+n.

12. T+ %8 o+- no >?+ n: &-&n'&on +8++n +

,+$,+-+n&9+- of + $+o$%+ M.L.A. M&n&-+, n o+,- ''-+

of ',&>&n% off+n'+-. N+&+, +: 'n '%&> n: $,&9&%+;+ no, 'n &

+ ;,n+ : n: Co, of L8. T+ %8 ,+- %% +%%:. In

o,+, o o -&'+ +8++n + $,&+- + Co, >- +>&n+ +

>+,&%- ,o; on ,+'o, &n +' '-+ on &- o8n >+,&-.M,-%%&n; n $$,+'&&on of +9&+n'+ >- + on+ -,&'%: &n

''o,n'+ 8& %8. P,+->$&on of &nno'+n'+ &- >n ,&;.

S' %+;% $,&n'&$%+ 'nno + ,o8n -&+ n+, n: -&&on.

13. No8 &- ,&n;- - o + ,;>+n of %+,n+ 'on-+%

fo, + $$%&'n o + -&'?n+-- of + $$%&'n. In +

'+,&f&'+ + 14.7.2014 &--+ : C&,>n

C.!.M.O.M+&'% S$+,&n+n+n C&9&% "o-$&% A>+ & &-

o-+,9+ - n+, B

GS+ &- -ff+,&n; f,o>

(1) In+-&n% +,'%o-&- 8& I..S.

;-,o ,+f% &-+-+ n 8& -+9+,+ 8+&;%o--. S+ &- on n& +,'%o-&- ,;- n&; $,o+&n &+.

(2) Mo, +$,+--&9+ &-o,+, 8& -&'&%&+&on -+9+,+ -%++$ &-,n'+ n -+8- ;&9+n 8o +%+',o 'on9%-&9+ +,$:n+, ;+n+,% n+-+-&.

(3) Lo8 '? $&n 8& &%+,% %o8+, %&>-

Page 6of 9


7/9


,&'%o$: 8& ;+n+,%&K+ o-+o$o,o-&-n -+ &- on &n+'&on +,&$,&+ 0.0 >% $+,: -'n+o-%: n o+, o-+o$o,o&',;-.

(4) *+,&;o n $+,&$+,% n+,&&-.

(5) S+ &- no ,+-$on&n; o ,+>+n nno &>$,o9+>+n &- o-+,9+.J

14. L+,n+ 'on-+% $$+,&n; fo, + $$%&'n - $%'+

,+%&n'+ on + +'&-&on of + A$+ Co, &n + '-+ ofAni! Ari v%

State of /e#t Ben0a!' ()**1, ++ SCC -2-8+,+&n + A$+

Co, - &,+'+ ,+%+-+ of + ''-+ o; + 8- 'on9&'+

fo, %&f+ &>$,&-on>+n %oo?&n; o &- ;+.

15. L+,n+ 'on-+% $$+,&n; fo, + $$%&'n -

->&+ + $$%&'n &- ;+ 5@ :+,- n -+ &- -+n&o,

'&&K+n n -+ &- 9&n; -+,&o- &%%n+-- 8&' &- '+,&f&+ :

C&,>n C.!.M.O.M+&'% S$+,&n+n+n C&9&% "o-$&%

A>+. T+,+fo,+ %oo?&n; o +, >+&'% 'on&&on - -+ &-

no ,+-$on&n; o + ,+>+n of + C&9&% "o-$&% -+ ,+&,+-

-$+'&%&K+ ,+>+n : $,&9+ !o'o,- fo, 8&' -+ &- +n&%+

fo, ;,n of ,+;%, &%.

16. So f, - + >+,&- of + >+, &- 'on'+,n+ +%+,n+ 'on-+% $$+,&n; fo, + $$%&'n - $o&n+ o

+ $$%&'n - ++n 'on9&'+ 8& + & of S+'&on 120B of

+ In&n P+n% Co+ n -+ - ++n '&+ fo, + off+n'+-

',;+ ;&n- +, n+, S+'&on- 143 o 14@ n %%&+ off+n'+-

of + In&n P+n% Co+. "+ - ,;+ + +9&+n'+ on

,+'o, &- -;;+-&9+ +, '&9+ $,&'&$&on 8- +,+ +

$%'+ of &n'&+n. S&%% o8+9+, -+ - ++n '&+ : +%+,n+ S$+'&% ;+ : no 'on-&+,&n; +, - >+>+, of

Page 7of 9


8/9


n%8f% --+>%:. S+ - ++n 'on9&'+ 8& + & of S+'&on

120B of + In&n P+n% Co+. M,. P,-n !+-& %+,n+

S+n&o, Con-+% $$+,&n; fo, + ,+-$on+n- 8- -?+ 8++,

$, f,o> + +9&+n'+ + $$%&'n ,,&9+ + $%'+ of&n'&+n &n +, C, &- +,+ n: +9&+n'+ 8& ,+;, o $,&o,

'on'+, o, >++&n; of >&n 8& + >o- 8&' - ?+n + %8

&n &- o8n n- + ,+$%: &- &n n+;&9+. M,. !+-& - ,&+ o

$+,-+ - o +%&+9+ 8+n+9+, ,&o- 8+,+ +,$+ &n +

+n&,+ S+ on +&n; ,,&9+ + $%'+ of &n'&+n n on

,,&9&n; +,+ n &n'&&n; o + >o &-+%f ,'+ S+'&on 120B

of + In&n P+n% Co+.

Sff&'+ & o -: &n-$&+ ,+'o,&n; f&n&n;- ,+;,&n;

+, $,+-+n'+ + -'+n+ of o'',,+n'+ + %+,n+ S$+'&% ;+

'&+ +, f,o> %% + ',;+- %+9+%%+ ;&n- +, - +&n;

>+>+, of n%8f% --+>%: n 'on9&'+ +, fo, '&n;

'on-$&,': 8& o-n- of $+o$%+ 8o 8+,+ >+>+,- of >o.

"o8+9+, &- -;+ 8++, o --$+n + -+n+n'+ n,+%+-+ + ''-+ on &% 8+ 8o% no + -&f&+ &n ,+B

$$,+'&&n; + +n&,+ +9&+n'+ on ,+'o,. A &- -;+ 8+ 9+

o +, &n >&n + n,+ of +9&+n'+ 'on-&+,&on of -'

+9&+n'+ : + %+,n+ S$+'&% ;+ fo, + $,$o-+ of $,&>(

f('&+ -&-f'&on of + 9%&&: of + 'on'%-&on- $, f,o>

o+, ,+%+9n f'o,- ,+%&n; o + &n'&+n. T+,+fo,+ 8+ ++>

& $,o$+, no o ;o &no + +&%- ,+;,&n; + 'on'%-&on ,,&9+: + %+,n+ S$+'&% ;+ 8&%+ ++,>&n&n; + f'o,- 8&'

%+ + %+,n+ S$+'&% ;+ o +%&+9+ + $$%&'n -

'on-$&,o,.

17.


9/9


'on-&+,&n; + $$%&'&on of + $$%&'n fo, --$+n-&on of

-+n+n'+ n ;,n of &% $+n&n; $$+%. T+,+fo,+ 8+ ++> &

$,o$+, no o +n+, &no ;,+ +&% of + +9%&on of +

+9&+n'+ on + ,+'o, - & 8&%% + -++n + &>+ of f&n%+,&n; of + $$+%.

1. To; %+,n+ 'on-+% fo, + $$%&'n - ,&+ o

+>on-,+ +fo,+ - -+,&o- 'on,&'&on- n &>$,o9+>+n-

8+ ,+ no +n+,&n; &no + ->+ +'-+ &- 8&%% + ,;+

n +'&+ + &>+ of f&n% +,&n; of &- $$+%.

1@. Fo, + ,+-on- ,+'o,+ o9+ 8+ ,+ of +

'on-&+,+ o$&n&on + $$%&'n &- +n&%+ fo, --$+n-&on of

-+n+n'+. A''o,&n;%: + $,+-+n $$%&'&on -n- %%o8+. T+

'on9&'&on n -+n+n'+ + 31..2012 ,+'o,+ : + %+,n+

S$+'&% ;+ &n S+--&on- C-+ No.243 of 200@ &- +,+:

--$+n+ $+n&n; $$+% n + $$%&'n &- +,+: o,+,+ o

+ ,+%+-+ on &% on +, ++'&n; on of R-.100000B (R$++-

On+ L' on%:) 8& 8o -,+: of %&?+ >on o + -&-f'&on of

+ 'on'+,n+ Co, n -+' o + 'on&&on -+ -%%

-,,+n+, +, $--$o, &f n: +fo,+ + T,&% Co,.

20. &% +fo,+ + T,&% Co, 9&n; ,&-&'&on.

21. R%+ &- >+ -o%+. !&,+' -+,9&'+ $+,>&+ o:.

(3%M%SAHAI' J%,

(R%%DHO4ARIA' J%,

Savariya

Page 9of 9

Maya Kodnani - Bail and Suspension of Sentence Gujarat HC

Documents

Transcript of Maya Kodnani - Bail and Suspension of Sentence Gujarat HC