Material Characterisation of Australian...

26
AAPA Pavement Solutions for Life Material Characterisation of Australian Asphalts Progress Summary Report – April 2013 Bevan Sullivan Fulton Hogan

Transcript of Material Characterisation of Australian...

Page 1: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

AAPA Pavement Solutions for Life

Material Characterisation of Australian Asphalts

Progress Summary Report – April 2013 Bevan Sullivan Fulton Hogan

Page 2: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

• Australia designs some of, if not, the thickest asphalt pavements in the world

• Fatigue Endurance Limit valid and accepted • Poor correlation between how and when

damage occurs and design models

Why APS – fL

Page 3: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

• Project Management • National Asphalt Materials Characterisation • International Validation – NCAT • Calibrate model against NCAT track data • Information Dissemination & Training • LLAP Design Software and Manual • Environment & Sustainability Study & Report

APS-fL Project Elements

Page 4: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

• Why Dynamic Modulus – Characterises material properties over a full range

of loading times and temperatures – Ability to develop “mater curves” – Established researched test method

internationally used – Link to overseas performance studies

Material Characterisation

Page 5: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Dynamic Modulus Test

Page 6: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Temperature Shifting

Page 7: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Temperature Shifting

Page 8: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Master Curve

Page 9: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Comparison with NCAT Data

Page 10: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Comparison with NCAT Shifted

Page 11: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Sample Comparison

Page 12: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Materials tested • Commercial project mixes ex production plant

(from all states) – 28 mixes in total: 14 x AC14: 14 x AC20 – Binders: C320; C450; C600; A15E; Multigrade

Australian Materials Characterisation

Page 13: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Mix Gradations-AC14

Page 14: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Mix Gradations– AC20

Page 15: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Material Characterisation

• Dynamic Modulus characterisation – 28 standard production mixtures tested – The ability now exists to characterise Australian

mixtures for any load time or temperature

• Link established link between Australian test results and NCAT

Page 16: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Level 1 Design Recommendations

• Pavement designer will not have access to mix design characteristics – Use confidence based Master Curves with field

shift factors (as being developed)

– Frequency related to depth in the pavement (the relationship is to be calibrated)

Page 17: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

• Based on grouping common Australian production mixtures

• Confidence based on t-distribution around common mixtures

• No difference between Australian Mixtures

Level 1 Master Curves

Page 18: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Temperature Shift

Page 19: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Master Curve C320 Binder

Page 20: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Master Curve C450 Binder

Page 21: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Master Curve C600 Binder

Page 22: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Master Curve A15E Binder

Page 23: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Dynamic Modulus vs. Field

Page 24: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

• Results are logical • Results are higher than design modulus used in

Australia • We are undervaluing the performance of asphalt

in pavement design • Outcomes of this work can immediately deliver

significant benefits for Australian road communities

• Immediate (interim) changes can be made to achieve first step benefits

Modulus Summary Comments

Page 25: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Next Step Empirical Calibration - NCAT

Page 26: Material Characterisation of Australian Asphaltsaapaqtmr.org/SAWS20130405/SAWS20130405_2_Bevan_Sullivan_PPT.pdfMaster Curve C450 Binder . Master Curve C600 Binder . Master Curve A15E

Thank you

Asphalt Pavement Solutions – for Life