Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and...

35

Transcript of Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and...

Page 1: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.
Page 2: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Massive star evolution

convection semiconvection overshoot

angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques

nucleosynthesis

presupernova models

Page 3: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Supernovae Type II

Core collapse Neutrino transport B-fields and rotation Mass dependence Equation of state

Mixing and fall back

Nucleosynthesis

Light curves

Spectra

Page 4: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Supernovae Type Ia

Ignition – the last 100 seconds

Flame physics and instabilities

Flame propagation – 3D with attendant turbulence and instabilities

Nucleosynthesis Light curves

Spectra

Page 5: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Transients

X-ray bursts – large reaction networks

novae – dredge up and mixing

gamma-ray bursts progenitors central engine relativistic jet propagation

Page 6: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Nuclear Reaction Data Base

Tabulations of experimental rates

Calculation of theoretical strong, weak, electromagnetic, and neutrino rates

Fitting and extrapolation

Archiving and disemination

Page 7: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.
Page 8: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Michael Kuhlen – rotating 15 solar mass star burning hydrogen

Page 9: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Rogers, Glatzmaier, and Woosley (2002)

Page 10: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Semiconvection:

E.g., following hydrogen core burning, is the gradientin H and He erased by mixing processes or does it survive?

Changes the entire stellar structure and whether it burns helium as a blue staror a red star.

Page 11: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

note models “b” (withB-fields) and “e” (without)

Heger, Woosley, & Spruit,in prep. for ApJ

Spruit, (2001), A&A, 381, 923

- red supergiants at death. Pulsar periods 3 to 15 ms

Page 12: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Burrows, Hayes,and Fryxell (1995)

Mezzacappa et a l (1998)

The current paradigm forsupernova explosion poweredby neutrino energy depositiongives ambiguous results.

Rotation could alter this by

• Providing extra energy input

• Creating ultrastrong B fields and jets

• Changing the convective flow pattern

Ostriker and Gunn 1971

LeBlanc and Wilson 1970Wheeler et al 2002

Fryer and Heger 2000

Page 13: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

First three-dimensional calculation of a core-collapse15 solar mass supernova.

This figure shows the iso-velocitycontours (1000 km/s) 60 ms aftercore bounce in a collapsing massivestar. Calculated by Fryer and Warrenat LANL using SPH (300,000 particles).

Resolution is poor and the neutrinoswere treated artificially (trapped orfreely streaming, no gray region), butsuch calculations will be used toguide our further code development.

The box is 1000 km across.

300,000 particles 1.15 Msun remnant 2.9 foe1,000,000 “ 1.15 “ 2.8 foe – 600,000 particles in convection zone3,000,000 “ in progress

Page 14: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Or do we simply not have the correct equation of state?

Or do we need to do the multi-D neutrino transport better?

Or is new physics needed (flavor mixing?)?

Page 15: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

As the expanding helium core runsinto the massive, but low densityhydrogen envelope, the shock at itsboundary decelerates. The decelerationis in opposition to the radially decreasingdensity gradient of the supernova.

Rayleigh-Taylor instability occurs.

The calculation at the right (Herant andWoosley, ApJ, 1995) shows a 60 degree wedge of a 15 solar mass supernova modeledusing SPH and 20,000 particles. At 9 hours and 36 hours, the growth of thenon-linear RT instability is apparent.

Red is hydrogen, yellow is helium, greenis oxygen, and blue is iron. Radius is insolar radii.

Mixing

Page 16: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

with FLASH

Page 17: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Fall back

Page 18: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Fall back absorbs all the 56Ni

light curves without mixing - will be recalculated

30 models

Light curves

Page 19: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Nuclear Reaction Data

Page 20: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

25 Solar Mass Supernova

15 Solar Mass Supernova

The figures at the right showthe first results of nucleosynthesiscalculations in realistic (albeit1D) models for two supernovaemodelled from the main sequencethrough explosion carrying a network of 2000 isotopes ineach of 1000 zones.

A (very sparse) matrix of 2000 x 2000 was invertedapproximately 8 million timesfor each star studied.

The plots show the log of the final abundances compared to their abundance in the sun.

Nucleosynthesis

Page 21: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

The ignition conditions depend weakly on the accretion rate.For lower accretion rates the ignition density is higher. Because of the difficulty with neutron-rich nucleosynthesis,lower ignition densities (high accretion rates) are favored.

*Ignition when nuclear energy generation by (highly screened) carbon fusion balances cooling by neutrino emission.

Type Ia Supernovae – White dwarf accretion

Page 22: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Conditions in a ChandrasekharMass white dwarf as its center runs away – following about a century of convection.

Vertical bars denoteconvective regions

Page 23: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Convection for 100 years, then formation of a thin flame sheet.

T

radius0

Note that at:

7 x 108 K the burning time and convection time become equal. Can’t maintain adiabatic gradient anymore

1.1 x 109 K, burning goes faster than sound could go a pressure scale height

Burning becomes localized

26TSnuc

Page 24: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Timmes and Woosley, (1992), ApJ, 396, 649

2/1

condv

nucS

c

Laminar Flame Speed

km/s

cm

km/s000,10sound c

Page 25: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Speculation

How many points and when and whereeach ignites may have dramatic consequencesfor the supernova (origin of diversity?)

2/L km 200 r P

Page 26: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

"Sharp-Wheeler Model"

g

Model OK, but deficient in Si, S, Ar, Ca

2SW

2SW

1.0v

05.0r

tg

tg

eff

eff

A simple toy model ...

Page 27: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Igniting the star at a single point off center gives very different results than ignitingprecisely at the center orin a spherical volume.

This "single point ignition"model did not produce a supernova (pulsation would have ensued)

Page 28: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Ignition at 5 pointsdid produce a successfulsupernova with 0.65 solar masses of burnedmaterial, 0.5 solar masses of which was56Ni.

Note - this was a 2D calculation.

Page 29: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Reinecke et al. (2002)

Page 30: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

An idealized model

Assume a starting mass of1.38 solar masses, a centraldensity of 2 x 109 g cm-3

and a C/O ratio of 1::2

For a given starting density, the final composition (threevariables, plus mixing) then defines the model.

Page 31: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.
Page 32: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

X-Ray Bursts

ZingaleCummingWoosley et al.

Page 33: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.

Lorentz factor DensityGRBs

Page 34: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.
Page 35: Massive star evolution convection semiconvection overshoot angular momentum transport with and without B-field torques nucleosynthesis presupernova models.