Marx, Bureaucracy, And Truth

2
G|xby| Zjbijbxi| Gy`yzxo/ZJZO72>> </<3/7< Sdzsgegxbge— z gzzizzfiex o c xbi zojdo&`molgm ~|olmifz oc Pizxi|e xijbeozjdieji de  Aeopmih`i-  Kyzxdji- geh Hifoj|gjt zbopz gx xbid| big|x xo li g hdzxdejxdsi pgt oc eox ziide`- gjae opmih`de`- o| gjjoyexde` co| xbi jo`edxdsi cgjymxdiz- o| dehiih xbi pimcg|i oc xbi jymxy|gm ”oxbi|zoc xbi x|ghdxdoe dxzimc% Xbgx dz xo zgt - xbi xo~&hope ghfdedzx|gxdoe oc xijbeomo`djgm gmxi|gxdoez de g `dsie fgxi|dgm joexirx |imi`gxiz xo g zo|x oc ~ozdxdoe oc irxi|egmdxt geh glkijxdoe- pbgxisi| ~|gjxdjgm geh |igmmt mdsih |i~i|jyzzdoez oc xbozi jo`edxdsimt yehi||i~|iz iexih ~io~mi fgt jofi xo ~gzz% Xbi irxiex xo pbdjb xbi xbio|ixdjgm sd|xyiz oc g ~oxiexdgm xijbeomo`djgm yeh i|xgade` glzx|gjxih g ~|do|d g|i hdzji|edlmi de xbi  ~|gjxdjgm ieh |izymxz oc dxz irijyxdoe- dz xbi fto~dj `g{i oc jo`edxdsi foedzf pbdjb dz xijbeozjdiexdcdj  ly|igyj|gjt % Get gjxygm byfge dmmz pbdjb g|dzi joex|g|t xo o| hiz~dxi xbi zxgxih xbio|ixdjgm egxy|i oc ge ”df~|osifiex|ifgde yeziie geh ye|i~|iziexih% Zyccdji dx xo | ijgmm Fg|r— z id`bxb xbizdz oe Ciyi|lgjb; ”Zojdgm mdci dz izziexdgmmt ~|gjxdjgm % Gmm ftzxi|diz pbdjb fd zmigh xbio|t dexo ftzxd jdzf cdeh xbid| |gxdoegm zomyxdoe de byfge ~|gjx dji geh de xbi jof~|ibiezdoe oc xbdz ~|gjxdji%Xbdz oyxmooa dz zbgxxi|de`mt j|dxdjgm- lyx get xb|igx oc gmxi|gxdoez xo xbi irdzxde`- ~opi|&decmijxih o~i|gxdoegm jofldegxdoez oc xijbeozjdieji geh xijbeozjdiexdcdj jymxy|i dz ~yx hope lt xbi geeymmde` Pizxi|e @g{i% Pbie jo`edxdoe pbdjb jo f~|ibiehz xbi debyfgedxt o| yezyzxgdegldmdxt oc ji|xgde |igm |imgxdoez cd|zx bgeh- dx `oiz eijizzg|dmt geh jgxi`o|djgmmt ye|i~|iziexih- zgj|dcdjih xo xbi fgdexiegeji oc xbi ztflomdj jobizdoe oc ly|igyj|gxdj fgehgxiz% Dc g ~|okijx pbozi ~y|~o|xih egxy|i dz xbi df~|osifiex oc xbi |igm zojdgm |imgxdoez de g ~o ~ymgxdoe- jo`edxdsi kyzxdji zyjb gz Sdzsgegxbge hizj|dliz dz xbi oemt pgt xo misim |igm j|dxdwyi geh gjxygmd{i xbi fozx ~ozdxdsi |izymxz ~ozz dlmi co| ~io~mi% Xbi eoxdoe oc ”~my|gm sdzdoezgz isie getxbde` oyx oc x bi o|hdeg|t z~igaz xo xbi eg||op `g{i oc ~opi|&|imgxdoez `osi|ede` xijbeomo`t x|gezci|% Pi poymh ho

Transcript of Marx, Bureaucracy, And Truth

Page 1: Marx, Bureaucracy, And Truth

 

G|xby| Zjbijbxi| 

Gy`yzxo/ZJZO72>>

</<3/7<

Sdzsgegxbge—z gzzizzfiex oc xbi zojdo&`molgm ~|olmifz oc Pizxi|e xijbeozjdieji de Aeopmih`i-

 Kyzxdji- geh Hifoj|gjt zbopz gx xbid| big|x xo li g hdzxdejxdsi pgt oc eox ziide`- gjaeopmih`de`- o| 

gjjoyexde` co| xbi jo`edxdsi cgjymxdiz- o| dehiih xbi pimcg|i oc xbi jymxy|gm ”oxbi|z‖ oc xbi x|ghdxdoe

dxzimc% Xbgx dz xo zgt- xbi xo~&hope ghfdedzx|gxdoe oc xijbeomo`djgm gmxi|gxdoez de g `dsie fgxi|dgm

joexirx |imi`gxiz xo g zo|x oc ~ozdxdoe oc irxi|egmdxt geh glkijxdoe- pbgxisi| ~|gjxdjgm geh |igmmt mdsih

|i~i|jyzzdoez oc xbozi jo`edxdsimt yehi||i~|iziexih ~io~mi fgt jofi xo ~gzz% Xbi irxiex xo pbdjb xbi

xbio|ixdjgm sd|xyiz oc g ~oxiexdgm xijbeomo`djgm yehi|xgade` glzx|gjxih g ~|do|d g|i hdzji|edlmi de xbi

 ~|gjxdjgm ieh |izymxz oc dxz irijyxdoe- dz xbi fto~dj `g{i oc jo`edxdsi foedzf pbdjb dz xijbeozjdiexdcdj

 ly|igyj|gjt% Get gjxygm byfge dmmz pbdjb g|dzi joex|g|t xo o| hiz~dxi xbi zxgxih xbio|ixdjgm egxy|i oc ge

”df~|osifiex‖ |ifgde yeziie geh ye|i~|iziexih% Zyccdji dx xo |ijgmm Fg|r—z id`bxb xbizdz oe

Ciyi|lgjb; ”Zojdgm mdci dz izziexdgmmt ~|gjxdjgm % Gmm ftzxi|diz pbdjb fdzmigh xbio|t dexo ftzxdjdzf cdeh

xbid| |gxdoegm zomyxdoe de byfge ~|gjxdji geh de xbi jof~|ibiezdoe oc xbdz ~|gjxdji%‖ Xbdz oyxmooa dz

zbgxxi|de`mt j|dxdjgm- lyx get xb|igx oc gmxi|gxdoez xo xbi irdzxde`- ~opi|&decmijxih o~i|gxdoegm

jofldegxdoez oc xijbeozjdieji geh xijbeozjdiexdcdj jymxy|i dz ~yx hope lt xbi geeymmde` Pizxi|e @g{i%

Pbie jo`edxdoe pbdjb jof~|ibiehz xbi debyfgedxt o| yezyzxgdegldmdxt oc ji|xgde |igm |imgxdoez cd|zx

bgeh- dx `oiz eijizzg|dmt geh jgxi`o|djgmmt ye|i~|iziexih- zgj|dcdjih xo xbi fgdexiegeji oc xbi ztflomdj

jobizdoe oc ly|igyj|gxdj fgehgxiz%

Dc g ~|okijx pbozi ~y|~o|xih egxy|i dz xbi df~|osifiex oc xbi |igm zojdgm |imgxdoez de g ~o~ymgxdoe-

jo`edxdsi kyzxdji zyjb gz Sdzsgegxbge hizj|dliz dz xbi oemt pgt xo misim |igm j|dxdwyi geh gjxygmd{i xbi

fozx ~ozdxdsi |izymxz ~ozzdlmi co| ~io~mi% Xbi eoxdoe oc ”~my|gm sdzdoez‖ gz isie getxbde` oyx oc xbi

o|hdeg|t z~igaz xo xbi eg||op `g{i oc ~opi|&|imgxdoez `osi|ede` xijbeomo`t x|gezci|% Pi poymh ho

Page 2: Marx, Bureaucracy, And Truth

 

pimm xo xy|e xo Fg|r—z j|dxdwyi oc zxgxi&co|fgmdzf geh ly|igyj|gjt de Bi`im% Zxgxi co|fgmdzf |ifgdez

yexgdexih lt xbi loxbi|zofi sg|dgldmdxt geh jof~mirdxt oc |igm zojdgm gccgd|z lt- wydxi zdf~mt-

hdzgsopde` gjxygm aeopmih`i% Wyoxi Fg|r- ”Xbi ly|igyj|gjt dz g jd|jmi c|of pbdjb eo oei jge

izjg~i% Dxz bdi|g|jbt dz g bdi|g|jbt oc aeopmih`i‣ Gjxygm aeopmih`i ziifz hisodh oc joexiex- kyzx gz

gjxygm mdci ziifz high1 co| xbdz dfg`deg|t aeopmih`i geh xbdz dfg`deg|t mdci g|i xgaie co| xbi zgfi

xbde`%‖ De "~ozx$jomoedgm joexirx- xbdz |dcx lixpiie dfg`deg|t geh gjxygm dz |iex pdhi| xbge ~i|bg~z

Fg|r isi| dfg`deih- pbi|i xbi fgehgxi oc ~|o`|izz irdzxz gmfozx irjmyzdsimt gz g zylmdfgxih dhig "geh

ziiz get eoxdoe oc df~|osifiex gz eijizzg|dmt cgmmde` dexo dxz xif~o|gm |yl|dj$% Jo`edxdsi

|i~|iziexgxdoe ziifz xo li pbgx Fg|r zgp gz xbi gexdhoxi xo ly|igyj|gjt- egfimt- ”xbi `iei|gm dexi|izx

gjxygmmt-‖ pbdjb- pbie cymmt gjxygmd{ih- poymh eijizzg|dmt migh xo g eip zjbifgxd{gxdoe oc aeopmih`i

pbozi sojgm jof~ozdxdoe poymh eijizzg|dmt li ~my|gm- zyjb xbgx igjb gjxdsdxt joymh li jof~|ibiehih

de dxzimc- geh eox de ge gmdie co|f o| de get pgt pbdjb zgj|dcdjih ~|gjxdjgmdxt co| xbi jof~mixieizz oc g

xbio|t1 |gxbi|- ~|gjxdjgm |y~xy|iz co|f xbi lyma oc xbi |igm- zojdgm mdci oc g xbio|ixdjgm joeji~x- pbdjb oei

oy`bx gmpgtz xo zx|dsi xo yehi|zxgeh lixxi|% Dx dz gjxygm ~my|gmdxt- o| xbi ~my|gm gjxygmdxt oc egxy|i pbdjb

xbi |idcdih- Pizxi|e ly|igyj|gxdj co|f cyehgfiexgmmt "geh eijizzg|dmt$ cgdmz xo zii- g co|fymgxdoe pbdjb

ziifz |imgxdsimt yejbge`de` de dxz x|yxb geh joexdeyde` ifi|`ieji%

Zoy|jiz;

Fg|r- Ag|m- C|dih|djb Ie`imz- geh \oli|x J% Xyjai|% ,Joex|dlyxdoe xo xbi J|dxdwyi oc Bi`im'z

^bdmozo~bt oc \d`bx%, Xbi Fg|r&Ie`imz \ighi| % Eip To|a; Eo|xoe- 7402% <8&<9% ^|dex%

Fg|r- Ag|m- C|dih|djb Ie`imz- geh \oli|x J% Xyjai|% ”Xbiziz oe Ciyi|lgjb‖ Xbi Fg|r&Ie`imz \ighi| %

 Eip To|a; Eo|xoe- 7402% ̂ |dex%