Mars Sample Return (MSR) - Saylor Academy...Mars surfa cameras. rm physical e and the in in certain...

Prepar

Check

Appro

SSE 1NASAhttp://w

……

red by: Gian

ked by:

oved by:

01, Space SA and Saylowww.saylor

ProjecPhas

DocumenDat

M………………

n Luigi Som

Systems Engr.org Acader.org/sse10

ct: se: nt: te:

Mars SamPre- PhaConcept 2014/04/

Mars Sam……………

Pre-Pha

Da

mma

gineering Cemy 1/

mple Return (ase A Study

/18

1

mple Ret………………

ase A Con

Ref: Non

Issue: 1ate : 2014/0

Date: 2

Date:

Date:

Course by

(MSR)

turn (MS……………

cept Stud

e

04/18

2014/04/18

SR) ………………

dy

……….

Doc

Issue 1 2 3

4 5

Doc

This dSaylor

cumen

Date 2014/03/2014/04/2014/04/

2014/04/2014/04/

cumen

document ilr.org's Surv

ProjecPhas

DocumenDat

t Chan

Chan/27 First D/11 Add n/16 Add n

conne/18 Final R/18 Repor

t scope

llustrates they of System

ct: se: nt: te:


nge Rec

ges Draft new paragranew paragraected sectionReview Actrt Submissio

e

he Mars Samms Enginee


/18

2

cord

aphs aphs, changns. tions on

mple Returnering - Part

(MSR)

e figures an

n Mission p1.

Name oGian LuGian Lu

nd Gian Lu

Gian LuGian Lu

project for

of person uigi Sommauigi Sommauigi Somma

uigi Sommauigi Somma

the NASA

a a a

a a

and

Term

ACS AO C&DHCDR ConOCOSPCSM DCR DR EOM ESA FOM FRR GNC ISS JAXAJPL KDP LEM LEO MAV MCR MER MGS MOE MOP MRO MSL MSR MTO NASANPR ORR OTS PBS PDR PLARP(LOCP(LOMPRD PRR P/SDRPSR P/SRR

rms, de

At An

H Co Cr

Ops CoPAR Co Co

De De

En Eu Fig Fli Gu Int

A Jap Je Ke Ap Lo

Ma Mi Ma Ma

Me Me Ma Ma Ma Ma

A Na NA Op Of Pro Pre

R PoC) ProM) Pro

Pro Pro

R Pro Pro

R Pro

ProjecPhas

DocumenDat

efinition

ttitude Contnnouncemenommand andritical Desigoncept of Opommittee onommand Seesign Certifecommissiond of Missiouropean Spagures of Meight Readinuidance Navternational pan Aerospet Propulsioey Decisionpollo Lunar ow Earth Orars Ascent Vission Concars Exploraars Global Seasure of Eeasure of Pears Reconnaars Science ars Sample ars Transferational AeroASA Procedperational Rff-the-Shelf oduct Breakeliminary D

ost-Launch Aobability ofobability ofoject Requioduction Reogram/Systogram Statuogram/Syst

ct: se: nt: te:


ns and

trol Systemsnt of Oppord Data Han

gn Reviewperations n Space Resrvice Modu

fication Revoning Reviewon ace Agencyerit

ness Reviewvigation andSpace Statioace Exploran Laborator

n Point Module

rbit Vehicle cept Reviewation Rover Surveyor ffectivenesserformanceaissance OrLaboratoryReturn r Orbit onautics anddural Requi

Readiness Rfkdown Stru

Design ReviAssessmentf Loss of Crf Loss of Mirements Doeadiness Retem Definitius Reviewtem Require


/18

3

d abbre

s rtunity

ndling

search ule (Apolloview w

w d Control on ation Agencry

w (Spirit and

s rbiter y (Curiosity

d Space Admirements

Review

ucture iew t Review rew ission

ocument eview ion Review

ements Revi

(MSR)

eviated

Spacecraft)

cy

Opportunit

y and)

ministration

iew

d terms

)

y)

n

s

PTR QA RKA SAR SDR SIR SE SRR SSA TPM TRARTRR TT&CV&V WBS

Pe Qu Ro Sy Sy Sy Sy Sy Sp

TeR Te

TeC Te Ve W

ProjecPhas

DocumenDat

eriodic Techuality Assuroscosmos (Рystem accepystem Definystem Integrystem Enginystem Requipace Situatioechnical Perechnology Rest Readineselemetry Traerification a

Work Breakd

ct: se: nt: te:


hnical Revierance Роскосмос)ptance Revienition Reviewration Revieneering irements Reonal Awarenrformance MReadiness Ass Review acking and and Validatiown Structu


/18

4

ews

) - Russian ew w ew

eview ness

Measure Assessment R

Commandion ure

(MSR)

Federal Spa

Report

ace Agencyy

Tab

DOCU

DOCU

TERM

TABLE

1 IN

2 P

2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.6

2.2.

2.7

3 C

3.1 3.3.3.

3.2 3.

3.3

4 P

4.1 4.2

5 L

6 F

INDEX

ble of C

MENT CHA

MENT SCOP

MS, DEFINITI

E OF CONTE

NTRODUCT

PROJECT SC

NEEDS .......GOALS .......OBJECTIVES

ASSUMPTION

MISSION CO

CONSTRAIN

.6.1 Budge

.6.2 SchedAUTHORITY

CONOPS AND

MISSION AR

.1.1 One-la

.1.2 Two-l

.1.3 ThreeMISSION AR

.2.1 JustifiCONCEPT OF

PRODUCT A

PRODUCT BR

WORK BREA

LIFECYCLE

FIGURES OF

X OF FIGUR

ProjecPhas

DocumenDat

Conten

ANGE RECO

PE .................

IONS AND A

ENT ..............

TION .............

COPING .......

......................

......................S .....................NS ..................

ONCEPT ...........TS ..................et....................dule ................Y & RESPONSIB

D MISSION

RCHITECTURE ..aunch architelaunches arche-launches arcRCHITECTURE

fication of discF OPERATIONS

ND WORK B

REAKDOWN SAKDOWN STRU

SCHEDULE

F MERIT ......

RES .................

ct: se: nt: te:


t

RD ...............

......................

ABBREVIAT

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................BILITY ............

ARCHITEC

......................ecture .............itecture .........

chitecture .......SELECTION ....

carded optionsS ....................

BREAKDOW

TRUCTURE ....UCTURE .........

E ....................

......................

......................


/18

5

......................

......................

TED TERMS

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

................................................................

......................

CTURE .........

.....................................................................................

......................s ..........................................

WN STRUCT

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

(MSR)

......................

......................

.....................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

TURE ............

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

......................

.....................

.....................

......................

.....................

......................

.....................

.....................

.....................

......................

.....................

......................

.....................

......................

......................

.....................

.....................

.....................

...... 2

...... 2

...... 3

...... 5

. - 6 -

. - 7 -

.. - 8 -

.. - 8 -

.. - 9 - - 10 - - 10 - - 10 - - 11 - - 13 - - 14 -

- 15 -

- 15 - - 15 - - 15 - - 17 - - 18 - - 18 - - 20 -

- 20 -

- 22 - - 22 -

- 25 -

- 28 -

- 29 -

MS

1

ThisSay At tassuhigharchand WorTheprogthe mis

SR_PreA

Introd

s documentylor.org's Su

the beginniumptions anh-level Conhitecture seltrade study

rk Breakdowe Project Lgrammatic rproject. In sion effectiv

Fi

Pro

PD

duction

t illustratesurvey of Sys

ing of this nd mission cncept of Olection procy. The followwn StructurLifecycle wreviews, dethe last chaveness and

igure 1-1: Th

oject: Doc: hase: Date: Ref:

Mars Pre-APre-A2014/None

n

the Mars stems Engin

document,concept) fo

Operations cess will thewing sectionre. will be thcision pointapter five Fperformanc

he Lander and

Sample ReturAlpha Phase cA /04/18

- 6 -

Sample Reneering - Pa

the scopinor the MSR

and multipen be carriedn covers the

hen presents, and the t

Figures of Mces.

d the Mars A

rn (MSR) oncept study

eturn Missioart 1”.

ng elementsmission wi

ple feasibled and explae Product B

nted with transitions bMerit will b

scent Vehicle

on project

s (needs, gll be definee architectuained througBreakdown S

milestones,between thebe identified

e (MAV) conc

for “NASA

goals, objeced, followedures. A migh a decisionStructure an

, technicale seven phasd to evaluat

cept.

A and

ctives, d by a ission n tree nd the

l and ses of te the

MS

2

In thdefibudassu CoshavSomansw

Figu

SR_PreA

Projec

his chapter,ined togethe

dget and schumption wil

smologists, e a bold in

me of these wer to as m

ure 2-1: List o

Pro

PD

ct scop

, the scopinger with a bahedule willll be noted.

geologists,nterest in Mare listed in

many questio

of previous M



ping

g exercise wasic missionl be also li

exo-biologMars. In thisn the goal pons as possib

Mars mission.


- 7 -

will be carrin profile. Baisted. At la

gists and ss field manparagraph. Tble.

. In recent ye


ied on. Neeasic constraast, authorit

cientists frony questionsThe objectiv

ars the succe

ds, goals, oaints such aty, responsi

om many os still wait ve of the M

ss rate signifi

objectives was technical ibility and

other discipto be answ

MSR mission

ficantly increa

will be ones, basic

plines wered. n is to

ased.

MS

2.1

The

2.2

Som

Thiscommis200inveaddrwou

SR_PreA

1 Needs

e main need

Improvevoluti

Discovsuppormicrob

2 Goals

me of the ma

Verify seismol

o o o o

Collect evolutio

o o o o

Investigand und

o o o

s list showsmmunity. Sosions (MRO6, a NASestigations ressed to ould make th

Pro

PD

ds for the MS

ve the undion of Marsver if it harted or if ibial).

ain goals ar

and imprology of MarDid it workHow much Are there stWhat is thedata and

on. InvestigWhy has thHow did it What is theTheories agreenhouse

gate on the pderstand theWas there fCould thereIs possible rock sampl

s only a fracome of theO, MER, MSA's Mars

related to ne degree oe most prog



SR mission

derstanding . s ever beenit still sup

re:

ove theoriesrs. Investigak in the sam

was the redtill residual

e chemical cimprove kn

gate on Marthe planet slohappen?

e chemical cand data ae effect on Epossibility a

e role of watflowing wate be still iceto discove

es?

ction of the ese where a

MSL and othPlanning the explor

or another bgress toward


- 8 -

n are:

of the g

n a habitabpport the ri

s on plate ate on its mi

me manner ad planet actil activities?compositionnowledge otian climateowly becom

compositionavailable fEarth? about past oter and planter on Marsed or (underer traces of

questions canswered (phers), but mGroup ide

ration of Mby MSR",ds the entire


geological h

ble planet, ight condit

tectonics, ineralogy. s on Earth?ive?

n of rocks?on the plane, geology a

me arid, deso

n of the soilfrom Mars

or present cnetary habit? rground) flobiomolecul

concerning Mpartially or

many more sentified 55 Mars. Aboumaking MSe list".

history and

i.e. if it ctions for li

past volcan

net itself anand chemistrolated and ir

and of the can be u

ondition forability.

owing waterles, bacteria

Mars raised totally) th

still need to important

ut half of tSR "the sin

d the plan

could have ife (bacteri

nic activity

nd his planry. ron-oxided?

atmosphereused to pr

r supporting

r? a or microb

d by the sciehanks to the be answere

t future scthem "coul

ngle mission

netary

been ial or

y and

netary

?

e? redict

g life,

bes in

entific e last ed. In cience ld be n that

MS

2.3

To manscie

FigubiggareaIt is than

SR_PreA

3 Object

contribute ny followinence:

Collecthe inncandid

Study spectra

Perforsurfac

Searchof flosedime

Performicrob

ure 2-2: The gest and higha approximat

a system of n 4,000 km (2

Pro

PD

tives

to the scienng science

ct data abouner surface date). Mars surfaa cameras. rm physical e and the inh in certain owing wateents). rm bio-chembial life, org

planet Marshest volcano itely the size ocanyons that,500 mi.) long



nce needs aobjectives

ut the lithosof a crater

ce, soil and

and chemicnner core)

region of Mer (e.g. er

mical analyganic compo

s. The Olympin the solar sf Arizona. Int runs along g, 200 km (12


- 9 -

and meet thconcerning

sphere at dior of a can

d terrain mo

cal analyses

Mars whererosion, terr

ysis on roounds and b

pus Mount csystem. It is n this picturethe Martian 20 mi) wide a


he stakeholg geology,

ifferent deepnyon (Valles

orphology w

s on soil and

e there coulrain morph

ock samplebiomolecule

can be recogat least 22 k

e the Valles Msurface east

and up to 7 km

der expectaexo-biolog

ps e.g. drills Marineris

with spectrom

d rocks (bot

ld be signs hology, roc

s to searches.

gnized from tkm (14 mi.) hMarineris, can

of the Tharsm (23,000 ft)

ations, MSRgy and plan

ling or analcould be a

meters and

th from the

of past preck compos

ch for trace

the orbit. It

high and covn be easiy detsis region. Atdeep.

R has netary

lysing good

multi

outer

sence sition,

es of

is the ers an tected. t more

MS

2.4

SomCurassu

2.5

A rsamSurfto mMarMarMSR4 bistor

2.6

For shouagen

Timbetwever BesTrea

SR_PreA

4 Assum

me assumptirrent theorieumptions m

Mars co Flowing Life con Returni

conductlaborato

Back ameasure

With thMars sa

A safe constrai

5 Missio

robotic Marmples from s

face samplemaximize ors environmrtian organiR shall meeiosafety conrage and res

6 Constr

every missuld be apprncies eventu

me and scheween Earth ry two year

ides this, thaty. The s

Pro

PD

mptions

ion where mes or comm

made for the

ould have bg water wasnditions areing back sating a wide ories on Earand forwardes.

he right techamples residsample retuints and mis

on conce

rs Sample Rsoil, rocks ae should bebjective acc

ment, Mars isms into Eaet the termsntainment fsearch of oth

raints

sion, budgetroved and fiually joinin

dule constrand Mars

rs.

he mission samples m



made prior mon undersMSR missi

een supports present one compatiblemples of rospectrum o

rth both witd contamina

hnology anddual traces ourn missionssion object

pt

Return misand atmosphe, if possiblecomplishmesamples an

arth's biosphs of Article facility shalher Mars, as

t constraintfinanced in tg the missio

aints are deallows, wit

must adherust not ba


- 10 -

to the estastandings wion are:

ted life in thn Mars in ane with the cock, soil anof analyses,th current anation could

d instrumenof past life (n should betive achieve

ssion shouldhere from Me, selectedent. Both fond Earth (chere) shouldVII of the O

ll be built. Tsteroids, com

ts are alwaythe yearly bon).

etermined bth current p

re to the Teack contam


ablishment owhere used

he past. ncient timescurrent modnd atmosphe to be perfond future fad be avoide

ntation it wo(if there wa

e performedements.

d be able tMars.

with precisforward andcaused by td be avoidedOuter SpaceThese facilmets or plan

ys present. budget alloc

by celestial mpropulsion t

erms of Artiminate the

of a possiblin the pro

. el of Mars pere from Mormed in thecilities. ed using st

ould be possas any). d in respect

to return ca

e scientific d back contahe possibled. e Treaty, anities could netary samp

The missiocation by N

mechanics. technology,

icle VII of Earth bio

le Mars misocess. The

past conditiMars would

e most adva

trong preca

sible to det

t of budget,

arefully sel

criteria in amination oe introducti

nd a specialbe used als

ples.

on and its bNASA (and

Relative m, a mission

the Outer Sosphere and

ssion. main

ions. allow anced

aution

ect in

, time

lected

order of the on of

level so for

udget other

motion n only

Space d the

MS

landonlySpa

FiguReco

2.6

A bmisbe rfromsom

SR_PreA

der/rover my in a Specace Research

ure 2-3: Someonnaissance O

6.1 Budge

baseline budsion ever prequired to m comparis

me past and

The Mabefore blaunch $672 m

Mars RconductspacecrPropuls

The totExplora(Martiacontinuthem hareachedwhile textensio

Pro

PD

must not to cial Level 4 h (COSPAR

e of the recenOrbiter (MR

et

dget estimatperformed. M

fulfil the msons with pfuture Mars

ars Scout mbeing canceservices, wh

million.

Reconnaissant reconnaissraft was busion Labora

tal cost of ation Roveran days) priued functionas received

d in July 20the Spirit ron. A $2.8



contaminatebiosafety c

R).

nt Mars orbiteO).

te hypothesMultiple laumission objprevious Mas mission an

missions (e.elled, had ashich cost ap

nce Orbitersance and euilt by Loctory.

f building, s (Sprit andimary missining far beyd many yea13 a decaderover cease million pe


- 11 -

e Mars surfcontainmen

ers: Odyssey

sizes that thunches of sjective. A rars missionnd their fina

.g. the Phoes target a copproximatel

r (MRO) is exploration ckheed Mar

launching, d Opportuniion was $8

yond their inars of missie on Mars, aed to functer month (


face. The rent facility, a

, Mars Globa

his would bpacecraft (rough estimns. The follal (or estima

enix landerost of less thly $187 mil

a multipurpof Mars fro

rtin under

landing anity) on the s820 million.nitial 90 soion extensioand is still ftion in 201$33.6/year)

eturn sampls defined b

al Surveyor (M

be the most (orbiter/land

mation coullowing paraated) cost.

r and the Mhan $485 mllion, the tot

pose spacecom orbit. Tthe superv

nd operatinsurface for t. But since ls primary m

ons. The Opfunctioning 10, after a ) is a rough

les must beby Committ

MGS) and M

expensive der/rover) wld be formuagraphs wi

MAVEN orbmillion. Inclu

tal price is

craft designThe $720 mvision of th

ng for the the initial 90

the rovers mission, ea

Opportunity and researc7 year mi

h estimatio

e used ee on

Mars

Mars would ulated ll list

biter), uding about

ned to million he Jet

Mars 0 sols have

ach of rover

ching, ission

on for

MS

SR_PreA

continuwere all

The MSas a mereach $2

The futwith Nbillions($1.3 biof the v

The Ma(plus or

The costs fthe final busingle Landthe budget could needmore plaus The MSstay on theopening ofoption withan estimatiabout $50 m An orbineeded, and The missiomillion for achieve thecontingency

There are treturn sampsecond one

Pro

PD

uing operatiolocated only

SL initial buedium-cost m2.47 billion

ture ExomaNASA, confs). ESA hadillions) but

ventures wil

ars 2020 ror minus $20

for the pastudget becamder is aboutshould be s

d one rover ibly $3-4 bi

SL mission e surface fof liftoff winh approx. 50on of additmillion. iter capabled then anoth

n should ththe orbiter

e mission, y plans, risk

two proposample orbiter e with a land



ons during my for missio

udget cost emission, bu

n.

rs mission firming thed originallythe withdra

ll probably a

over mission00 million),

t Mars missme always t $1 billion,scaled, as leand one M

illion. could also or searchingndows. This00 days lonional $3 mi

e of taking her $700 mi

en require: . Since lot oaround $3

k reduction,

al (for furthand a sing

der, a rover


- 12 -

mission exton extension

estimate waut eventually

was initialleir commit

y cost-cappeawal of NAadd several

n launch is according t

sions have aat least tw

, but for a mearned from

MAV, and t

require long, collectins would be ng operationillion per m

back to Eaillion should

$2 billion fof new tech00 million , and other c

her details sgle lander wand an orbi


tension. In tns.

s $650 milly the costs f

ly approvedtment to sped the Exom

ASA and thehundred m

estimated tto The Aero

always beenwice the orimore complm the MSLthey accoun

ng times forng and stori

required inns for the l

month shoul

arth the retd be added

for each lanhnology mu

dollars arecost/schedu

see next chwill then citer will cos

the end alm

ion. Indeed for developi

d by ESA aspend €850 mars projece consequenillions euro

to cost rougospace Corp

n underestimiginal ones.lex and mor(see Figurent for minim

r the rover aing the samn the case oander. Fromd be requir

turn capsuleto the budg

nder and theust be devele suggested

ule mitigatio

apters): thecost approxst around $5

most $600 m

d it was clasing the rove

s a joint mi0 million (cts at €1 bint reorganis

o to the total

ghly $1.5 bporation.

mated, as r. The cost re massive e 2-4). The mum $2 bi

and the MAmples beforof a “long

m MER misred, for a to

e would alget estimate.

e MAV and loped in ordd as reservon measures

e first one w. $3 billion

5 billion.

million

sified er did

ission $1.23 illion, sation l.

billion

result, for a rover MSR

illion,

AV to re the stay”

ssion, otal of

so be .

$700 der to ve for s.

with a n; the

MS

FiguPaththe i

2.6

Anoposiconv Celeyearschein 2

SR_PreA

ure 2-4: Evohfinder missioidle is about 1

6.2 Sched

other imporitions and mvenient laun

estial mechr for 2024eduled for 9

2020-2026 a

L

T

Pro

PD

olution of Mon), Spirit/O1 foot high.

dule

rtant constramotions of nch opportu

hanics deter, the launc9 months laare listed in

Launch yea2020 2022 2024 2026

Table 2-1: Est



ars rovers. pportunity (t

aint for a MEarth and M

unity only e

rmine the pch has to bter, in June the table be

ar Month6 8 9

11

timated launc


- 13 -

From bottomtwin rovers o

Mars missioMars make

every 2 year

ossible launbe in late 2025. Estimelow.

h Day Ar18 7

26 15

ch dates from


m left corneof MER), and

on is the la possible, w

rs, when Ma

nch windowSeptember,mated launc

rrive year2021 2023 2025 2027

m Earth to Ma

r clockwise: d Curiosity (M

aunch windowith currentars approach

ws. Selectin, and Marsch dates fro

Month D3 4 6 7

ars in 2020-20

Sojourner MSL). The r

ow. The ret technologh its perigee

ng a base las arrival is om Earth to

Day 4

22 11 30

026

(Mars rock in

lative gies, a e.

aunch then

Mars

MS

2.7

SR_PreA

The init Prelimi

early 20 In June In Janu

phases In July Two ye

so the mtesting t This timallocatidue to t

7 Author

NASA andOther agenallocated breturn stageor a comme

Pro

PD

Figure 2-5

tial project nary analys018. 2018 Phaseary 2019, ashould start2020 fabric

ears later (Jmission can that termina

me-table aon reduces the fact that

rity & Re

d JPL havencies (e.g. udget. Othee will dock ercial one.



: An example

developmensis and desi

e B should sfter a Prelimt and last focation has toJuly 2022) a

proceed wiate in May 2

llows for the risk of

the followi

esponsib

e the authorESA, JAXAer agencies to the ISS a


- 14 -

e of previous

nt should stign of comp

start. minary Desior 18 montho start. all the hardith a 22 mon2024.

a 4 monthf mission scing planetar

bility

rity and reA, and RKand private

and the cani


NASA progr

tart in Septeponents (Ph

ign Reviews.

dware and snths System

hs schedulecrub that wry window i

sponsibilityKA) may be companieister be take

ram schedule

ember 2017.ase A) shou

(PDR), the

oftware mum Assembly

e margin. Twould cause is scheduled

y to carry oe involved

es should bee back with

e

. uld also beg

e implement

ust be compy, Integratio

This extra e a 2 years d for 2026.

out the misd to increase involved a Soyuz ca

gin in

tation

pleted n and

time delay

ssion. se the if the

apsule

MS

3

3.1

Sevbriearchtrad ComtypeusedanalVencallanaldock Thebackthird

3.1

Singlaunhugneitthe dev

3.1

In thone FiguStayon t

SR_PreA

ConOp

1 Missio

veral strategefly describehitecture selde study.

mmon optioe and the Md (see Figurlyses and snus flyby (ted “Long Slyses, selectk to the obi

e basic elemk the sampd spacecraft

.1 One-la

gle launch anching all ege and heavther in the n

Falcon 9 elopment.

.2 Two-la

his scenariofor the land

ure 3-1, is ty” profile othe surface f

Pro

PD

ps and

on archite

ies of returne the possiblection proc

ons among Mars surfacere 3-1). Theample pickto decrease Stay” and wtion and piciter and then

ment of the le to Earth

ft, rover for

aunch arc

architectureelements iny payload inear future.

Heavy fro

aunches

o, the sampder and the to launch bor at an interfor a 500 da



d missi

ecture

ning a sampble high-levcess will be

all the arche mission de first one isking in a 30

the total awould assurecking sampln come back

mission w(or to ISS)

rock drillin

chitecture

e, as the namn a single laisn’t still av Possible com SpaceX

architect

le return msecond one

oth missionrval of abouays mission


- 15 -

ion arc

ple of Mars vel Architeccarried and

hitecture opduration. Tws called “Sh0 days campamount of pe 500 days les, and thenk to Earth.

would be an), one land

ng, analysis,

e

me says, is aunch. Howvailable at tcompatible lX Corporat

ture

mission woule for the orbns, during thut two yearsn.


chitectu

to Earth arecture for thd explained

tions concewo differenthort Stay” anpaign, and propellant nfor the roven return the

orbiter witer (with the and sample

organized twever, the lthe momentlauncher cotion, but b

ld be dividebiter. The suhe same laus. In the latt

ure

e possible. The MSR mis

through a d

ern the intert approachend would cothen return

needed). Ther to performem with the

th a return e MAV) ane caching.

to allow a slauncher net and does n

ould be the both are st

ed in two lauggested opunch windowter case the

This chaptession. A midecision tre

rplanetary ces can indeoncentrate an to Earth whe second om all the saMAV into

stage for tnd eventual

sample retueeded for sunot appear NASA SLStill current

aunches: theption, depictw, with a “rover could

er will ission

ee and

cruise ed be all the with a one is ample orbit,

aking ly, as

urn by uch a to be

S and tly in

e first ted in

“Short d stay

MS

Fig

SR_PreA

Figure 3-1:

gure 3-2: Co

Pro

PD

: MSR trajec

onOps for a twand land



ctories for a sharc

wo spacecrafder stay on th


- 16 -

hort or long chitecture pr

ft architecturhe surface for


stay option uofile.

re with a “Shoa short amou

used in the 2 o

ort-Stay” optunt of time

or 3 launches

tion. Both orb

s

biter

MS

3.1

TheIn tlandat leTwolandcollfuncand Thiscarrtwothe costscra

SR_PreA

.3 Three

e sub-mentiothis scenarid on Mars, teast 500 Solo years laterder includinlection rovection wouldreturn it to

s design wory out the ro payloads (successful lts and risks atch.

Figure 3

Pro

PD

-launche

oned archito, the sampthen it wouls (Martian r, the orbiteng the Marer, the landd be to retrthe lander w

ould ease threquired op(the samplelanding systassociated

3-3: A possib



s architec

ecture wouple-collectiold carry outdays).

er (see figurrs Ascent Ver would bieve the samwhere it wo

he scheduleerations. Fu-collection tem developwith develo

le trajectory


- 17 -

cture

uld split the on rover wt analyses a

re Figure 3-Vehicle (MAbring a smample conta

ould be load

e of the whurthermore,rover and t

ped for the oping and te

for the orbit


mission intwould be lauand sample c

-3) would bAV). Instea

aller, simpleainer from tded onto the

ole mission, by spreadthe lander),Mars Scienesting yet a

er simulated

to a total ofunched sepcollection o

e launched,ad of a fulle "fetch rovhe sample-

e MAV.

n, giving coing the land, the progrance Laboratoanother land

with STK As

f three launparately andover a lifetim

, followed bl-blown samver", whose-collection r

ontrollers timnded mass aam could reory, avoidinding system

strogator.

nches. d first me of

by the mple-e sole rover,

me to across ely on ng the

from

MS

3.2

SincanaldepiFigu

3.2

Onethe p A tstakcomnewMarhavi Theapprfor of sbed expfaciwoucon Tand coulrequ Thenearthe analthre

SR_PreA

2 Missio

ce many polyses were icted in ure 4-1.

.1 Justif

e-launch arcpresent mom

three-launchkeholder exmplexity wow technologrs ascendining enough

e chosen oproach to colbudget, sch

samples canfor new

ensive) samilities and lould benefit gcept and de

The orbiter should rem

ld be projeuirements.

e lander wilr a predefinmission e.

lyses. It wilee spacecraf

Pro

PD

on Archit

ossible misconducted

ication of

chitecture isment there a

hes missionxpectations,

ould put in sgy and operng vehicle,

funding or

ption was thllect sample

hedule or ann be returned

technologiemple returnot of spare pgreatly with

esign.

and the lanmain on theected for a

ll try to accned site or n.g. investigll also have ft MRS miss



tecture s

ssion archite. A decisio

f discarde

s not possibare no launc

n has a ver, but it wserious risk rations has Mars orbitamission an

hen the twoe from Marsnomalies. Wd to Earth. es allowing

n mission. parts and deh a significa

nder would surface onfunctioning

complish (fnear a previgating on th

a small fetcsion.


- 18 -

selection

ectures are on tree for

ed option

ble since, achers capab

ry high sciwould cost

the accompto be teste

al docking,nomalies) th

o-launchess, preventin

With this arOn the otheg a followThe latteresign of thiant reductio

be launchenly for a shog in a shor

for the first ious Mars mthe anomalich rover as


available,the missio

ns

as discussedble of doing

ientific valut around $plishment o

ed for the f etc.). For

his option w

mission arcng unacceptrchitecture,er hand it c

wing (morecould use s mission. Ion of cost a

ed and reachort period.rter period

time ever)mission. Thiies of a pra technolog

trade studyon architect

d in the prevso.

ue, meeting$5 billion. of the missiofirst time (pthese reasoas discharge

chitecture. Table risks ohowever, aould be con

e complex, all the kno

In this way and improve

h Mars on With this cof time, re

a precise pis will add arevious langy demonstr

y and feasiture selecti

vious chapt

g almost aMoreover

on, since a pinpoint lanons (risks oed.

This is the of mission faa smaller amnsidered as

safer andow-how, althe new mi

ement in mi

the same pchoice all syesulting in l

pinpoint lanan extra valnder with vtrator for a f

ibility ion is

ter, at

ll the r, his lot of

nding, of not

safer failure mount a test

d less ll the ission ission

period ystem lower

nding lue to visual future

MS

SR_PreA

Figure 3-4:

Pro

PD

Decision tree



e for the missdi


- 19 -

sion architectiscarded opti


ure selectionons.

. Red backgrround indicat

te

MS

3.3

As euse for u ThespacbackFalcarch An capacaparovehad fromthis prop Theand in thMarposs

SR_PreA

3 Conce

every compof system eunmanned m

e chosen mcecraft: a lak the sampcon 9 Heahitecture on

upgraded abilities) coable of picker on the sunever been

m past Marsobjective,

pulsion syst

e proposal fverify the

he Apollo prs ascendinsibly Mars e

Achievein order

Test theatmosphdrilling

PerformThe orb

Build thoperate return M

The lander bigger thanone robotic The detaile

1. The

Pro

PD

ept of Op

plex project,engineers (Smission.

mission arcander with ple canister avy will nn currently c

mission pould includking up rocurface, a prn performeds missions. e.g. impro

tem capable

for the currefeasibility oprogram, wng vehicle, exploration

e first ever r to collect se MAV aschere sample tool install

m the first ebiter will thehe facilities with samp

Missions.

is a small sn the Sojourc arm to coll

ed ConOps i

e lander and



erations

, MSR will SE). The pr

chitecture ea Mars Ascfrom Mars

not be avacommerciall

profile (witde also an cks and delrecise Marsd on the redNew technving the Sk

e of doing so

ent mission of a three-sp

will develop Mars orbit

:

pin-pointinsamples in d

cending vehes while ased on the ro

ever Mars oen take backs to analyseples provide

cience laboner) used folect soil sam

is detailed d

d the orbiter


- 20 -

s

require a mroject will u

establishescending Vehs orbit to Lailable in tly available

th one of additional

liver them ts pin-pointind planet du

nology deveky Crane so.

n is to use thpacecraft mand test th

tal docking

ng landing odifferent loc

hicle. It willcending. Roover or on thorbit rendezk to LEO the the samped by this m

oratory, provor testing aumples and a

depicted in F

are launche


multidisciplinuse the stand

a basic phicle (MAV

LEO. If bigthe near fue rockets wo

f the launcrover to beto the MAVng should b

ue to the lowlopment mu

system used

he basic promission. Thihe key techng, …) for

on Mars. It ccations. l also contaock samplehe base of l

z-vouz fromhe sample cales from Mmission and

vided with autonomous rsmall ascen

Figure 3-2.

ed with two

nary team wdard 7 phas

profile usinV) and an o

launchers future, a mould be the b

cher with e deployed V. In order be achievedw landing aust be perfod on MSL

ofile to test s will ease nologies (pifuture retur

could be als

ain soil sames could be ander.

m the MAV anister.

Mars. They wd reduce the

a very smallrock cache nding vehic

The major p

o separate la

with an exteses lifetime

ng two seporbiter for t

like the SLmultiple-launbest choice.

bigger paon the suto use a se

d. This operaccuracy reaormed to acor develop

new technothe costs aninpoint landrn missions

so be a “ho

mples and cacollected w

with the or

will be reae cost for f

l rover (a lirecovery. It

cle.

phases are:

aunchers.

ensive cycle

parate aking LS or nches .

yload rface, econd ration ached

chieve ping a

ology nd, as ding , s and

pper“

apture with a

rbiter.

ady to future

ttle t has

MS

SR_PreA

2. Theinte

3. Aftewhiland

4. Afteland

5. Therese

6. Afte7. MA

perithatCom

8. MAstag

9. Thecorr

10. A m11. The

SoyDra

12. The13. The

Figure 3-5: T

Pro

PD

ey performerplanetary oer a 9 monile the landeding. er have sloding to a pree lander peearch and saer a sealing

AV manoeuigee to perfot one perfommand Serv

AV and the oge. e return vehrect his traje

manual or aue sample cayuz or commagon) e capsule lane sample are

The Dragon c



m some buorbit towardnths journeyer accompli

owed down e-selected aerforms allample collecof canister

uvres to a lform a rendeormed in thvice Moduleorbiter dock

hicle starts iectory to intutomatic doanister is trmercial (or

nds in Oceae transferred

capsule captu


- 21 -

urns in LEds Mars. y, the orbitish an aero

with paracarea. l the needction. compartme

low Mars ez-vouz withe Apollo e). k. The samp

its long jouterplanetary

ocking with ransferred tOrion, if r

an or on the d to the leve

ured by the C


EO to corr

ter perform-braking m

chutes, the

ded operati

ent, the MAorbit, whileth the MAV

program b

ple canister

urney homey one direct the ISS is pto a return

ready), and

ground. el 4 bio-safe

Canadarm in

rect their t

ms a Mars oanoeuvre in

lander perf

ions, exper

AV departs fe the orbite

V (this operabetween the

is transferre

, performinto LEO.

performed. capsule. I

manned or

e Mars Sam

order to dock

trajectories

orbit acquisn preparatio

forms a pin

riments, sc

from Mars. er decreaseation is simie LEM an

ed into the r

ng some bur

It could be r unmanned

mple Facility

k with the IS

into

sition, on for

npoint

cience

es his ilar to d the

return

rns to

both d (e.g.

y.

S.

MS

4

4.1

TheThesche TheTheIt shsyst(TTsubsdock

4.2

Theworincladdiengi In oand

SR_PreA

Produ

1 Produc

e PBS (Prode hierarchicaeme in Figu

e main eleme MAV is clhould also tems, comm

T&C), Guidsystem. Somking sub-sy

2 Work B

e Work Brerk necessaryludes the Pring (at eachineering, in

order to impwith high-l

Pro

PD

uct and

ct Break

duct Breakdal ordered e

ure 4.1.

ments of the mlassified as have all th

munication (dance Navime exampleystem, MAV

Breakdow

eakdown Stry to compleroduct Breah level) the

ntegration an

prove claritylevel elemen



d Work

down St

own Structuelements of

mission area tier 2 eleme main sub(low/high ggation and

es of compoV propulsion

wn Struc

ructure (WBete a projecakdown Strue necessary nd verificati

y, in Figurents only.


- 22 -

Break

tructure

ure) is the rf the PBS f

e the two spment, since bsystem sucgain) antennd Control (onents ad pan and samp

cture

BS) represect. The WBucture. The

y service eleion, and log

e 4.2 the WB


kdown S

esult of the for the MSR

acecraft: thit will beco

ch as thermna, Telemet(GNC), andarts are listele unit.

ents the hieBS is produc

WBS is inements, sucgistics suppo

BS has bee

Structu

decomposiR mission a

e orbiter anome an indeal control, try Trackingd, of coursed, such as o

erarchical brct-based, hideed built fch as managort.

n depicted

ure

ition procesare depicted

nd the landerependent vestructure, pg and Comse, a propuorbiter and M

reakdown oierarchical afrom the PBgement, sy

without the

s. d in a

r. ehicle. power mand ulsion MAV

of the and it BS by stems

e PBS

MS

SR_PreA

Pro

PD

F



Figure 4-1: Pr


- 23 -

roduct Break


kdown Structuure

MS

SR_PreA

Figure

Pro

PD

e 4-2: Work B



Breakdown S


- 24 -

Structure. On


nly high-level elements aree shown.

MS

5

Theon awithesta

SR_PreA

Lifecy

e project wila historical h new enginablished, fro

Pre-Phawill takthe Pha

A Systemonths maturatbaseline

In JanuDesign final deJuly 202

In July All the with a 2in May

Pro

PD

ycle sch

ll use the stproject schneering andom mission

aseA starts ke to complase A.

em Definit long Phasetion. This pe capable of

uary 2019 thReview (P

esign will la20 and last

2022, afterhardware a

22 months 2024.

Figure 5-



hedule

andard 7 phedule analy

d new technselection to

in Septemblete the mis

ion Reviewe B (in Junhase definef meeting m

here will bPDR) the imasts for 18 mfor two yea

r another coand softwarSystem Ass

-1: Historical


- 25 -

e

hases lifetimysis (see Fignology, an eo launch.

ber 2017, lassion concep

w (SDR) wne 2018) wie the projectmission need

be a main Kmplementatmonths, whiars.

ontrol gate (re must be csembly, Inte

l project sche


me cycle forgure 5-1) foestimate of

asting for 3 pt and techn

will be perfoith prelimint in enough ds.

KDP: only tion phases ile the hardw

(SIR and KDcompleted segration and

edule analysis

r unmannedor a highly c

a 7 years lo

months. Anology dev

ormed prionary designdetail to es

after passinwill start.

ware fabrica

DP-D), Phaso the missd testing th

s in months

d mission. Bcomplex paong proces

Another 6 mvelopment d

or to enter n and technostablish an i

ng a PrelimIn phase C

ation will st

ase D will bsion will prohat will term

Basing yload s was

months during

the 7 ology initial

minary C, the tart in

begin. oceed

minate

MS

Durmanand

SR_PreA

Last revlaunch for the availabi

Phase Elauncheare achchapter

Final Fand timextensiosince m

ring the projny others) wphases are

Pro

PD

views (TRRscheduled iwhole pro

ility of the f

E (Operatioes. This phahieved and tr for mission

-Phase willmes will depons. All the

many years o

ject many owill be perfo

provided in



R, SAR, ORin Septemboject to prefollowing p

ons and suase will lastthe sample n details.

l perform thpend on lane data colleof research c

other KDP aormed. A sun Figure 5-2


- 26 -

RR and FRRber 2024. Aevent a mi

planetary wi

ustainment)t for severalcapsule ret

he closeout nder/rover stected must bcould be pe

and review ummary of t2 and Figure


R) will checA time marg

ission delaindow, whic

will beginl years till aturn to Eart

operations tatus and pbe archived

erformed on

(Peer, Substhe main ace 5-3.

ck all the sygin of 4 moy of two ych is schedu

n with theall the operth. Please r

for the proossible fund

d and preparthe returne

system, Sysctivity, revie

ystems beforonths is alloyear due t

uled for 202

e two spacration in Corefer to pre

oject. Operading for mired for ana

ed samples.

stem Reviewew, control

re the ocated o the

26.

ecraft onOps evious

ations ission lyses,

w and gates

MS

SR_PreA

Pro

PD

Figure



Figure 5-2

e 5-3: Project


- 27 -

2: NASA proj

t phases, KD


ject lifecycle

P and major reviews

MS

6

Thismisand Tot

Mis

TotMisexte

TotMisRisk

7

Thisarchpassimp

SR_PreA

Figure

s chapter shsion architedetermined

tal rock and

ssion compl

tal mission ssion flexibension for r

tal cost ssion accomk of failure

Future

s documenthitecture, Csing to nex

prove and en

Pro

PD

es of M

hortly lists ecture optiod the selecti

d soil samp

lexity

duration (oility (e.g. brover/lande

mplishmente or anoma

e works

t provide a bConOps, WBxt project pnrich the mi



Merit

some Figurons. The lasion of the tw

ple mass ret

operationaackup lander, etc.)

t lies

ks

basic feasibBS, PBS, s

phases, furthission profil


- 28 -

res of Merist parameterwo launches

turned to E

al phase) der, mission

bility analysscoping eleher and dele with requ


it that werer was choses option.

Earth

S

n V

<

A

sis and a higements and eper analys

uirements an

e used to even to be the

2 launch 100-500g

Somewhat Less

650 days Very low

<$3 billion Good

Acceptable

gh-level conlifecycle s

sis should bnd details.

valuate the e most impo

3 laun1-10k

High

4 yearPossibchoice

availab>$5 billExcelle

High

ncept for mischedule. Bbe perform

MSR ortant

nch kg

h

rs ble es ble lion ent h

ission Before med to

MS

Ind

Figu

Figu

incr

Figu

is th

and

Mar

surf

(120

Figu

and

Figu

(Ma

(MS

Figu

Figu

arch

Figu

orbi

Figu

Figu

indi

Figu

ISS

Figu

Figu

Figu

Figu

Figu

SR_PreA

dex of

ure 1-1: The

ure 2-1: Lis

reased. .......

ure 2-2: The

he biggest a

covers an a

rineris, can

face east of

0 mi) wide

ure 2-3: Som

Mars Reco

ure 2-4: Evo

ars Pathfind

SL). The roc

ure 2-5: An

ure 3-1: MS

hitecture pro

ure 3-2: Co

iter and land

ure 3-3: A p

ure 3-4: Dec

icate discard

ure 3-5: The

. .................

ure 4-1: Pro

ure 4-2: Wo

ure 5-1: His

ure 5-2: NA

ure 5-3: Pro

Pro

PD

f figures

e Lander an

st of previou

..................

e planet Ma

and highest v

area approx

be easiy de

the Tharsis

and up to 7

me of the re

onnaissance

olution of M

der mission)

ck in the idl

example of

SR trajector

ofile. ..........

onOps for a

der stay on

possible traj

cision tree f

ded options

e Dragon ca

..................

oduct Break

ork Breakdo

storical proj

ASA project

oject phases



s

nd the Mars

us Mars mis

..................

ars. The Oly

volcano in t

imately the

tected. It is

region. At

km (23,000

ecent Mars o

Orbiter (M

Mars rovers.

), Spirit/Opp

le is about 1

f previous N

ies for a sho

..................

two spacec

the surface

jectory for t

for the miss

. .................

apsule captu

..................

kdown Struc

own Structu

ect schedul

t lifecycle ...

, KDP and m


- 29 -

Ascent Veh

ssion. In rec

...................

ympus Mou

the solar sy

size of Ari

a system o

more than 4

0 ft) deep. ..

orbiters: Od

MRO). ..........

. From botto

portunity (tw

1 foot high.

NASA prog

ort or long s

...................

craft archite

for a short

the orbiter s

sion architec

...................

ured by the

...................

cture ...........

ure. Only hig

le analysis i

...................

major revie


hicle (MAV)

cent years th

...................

nt can be re

stem. It is a

zona. In th

f canyons th

4,000 km (2

...................

dyssey, Mar

...................

om left corn

win rovers o

..................

gram schedu

stay option

...................

cture with a

amount of t

simulated w

cture selecti

...................

Canadarm i

...................

...................

gh-level ele

in months ...

...................

ews .............

) concept. ...

he success r

...................

ecognized fr

at least 22 km

is picture th

hat runs alo

2,500 mi.) lo

...................

rs Global Su

...................

ner clockwi

of MER), an

...................

ule ...............

used in the

...................

a “Short-Sta

time ...........

with STK As

ion. Red ba

...................

in order to d

...................

...................

ements are s

...................

...................

...................

..................

rate signific

..................

rom the orb

km (14 mi.)

he Valles

ong the Mar

ong, 200 km

..................

urveyor (MG

..................

ise: Sojourn

nd Curiosity

..................

..................

2 or 3 laun

..................

ay” option.

..................

strogator. ...

ackground

..................

dock with th

..................

..................

shown. .......

..................

..................

..................

.. - 6 -

antly

.. - 7 -

bit. It

high

tian

m

.. - 9 -

GS)

- 11 -

ner

y

- 13 -

- 14 -

ches

- 16 -

Both

- 16 -

- 17 -

- 19 -

he

- 21 -

- 23 -

- 24 -

- 25 -

- 27 -

- 27 -

Mars Sample Return (MSR) - Saylor Academy...Mars surfa cameras. rm physical e and the in in certain...

Documents

Transcript of Mars Sample Return (MSR) - Saylor Academy...Mars surfa cameras. rm physical e and the in in certain...