MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for...

79
MARCH 2016 MOUNT GIBSON MINING IRON HILL FLORA AND VEGETATION ASSESSMENT BASED ON REGIONAL AND LOCAL FLORISTIC ANALYSES REVISION 1

Transcript of MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for...

Page 1: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

MARCH 2016

MOUNT GIBSON MINING

IRON HILL FLORA AND VEGETATION ASSESSMENT BASED ON REGIONAL AND LOCAL FLORISTIC ANALYSES

REVISION 1

Page 2: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

This page has been left blank intentionally.

Page 3: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

iii

Document Status

Rev Author Reviewer Date

Approved for Issue

Name Distributed To Date

Draft M Macdonald M Hay 02/03/2016 S Grein M Hamilton 02/03/2016

Revision M Macdonald M Hay 03/03/2016 S Grein M Hamilton 03/03/2016

ecologia Environment (2016). Reproduction of this report in whole or in part by electronic, mechanical or chemical means including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, in any language, is strictly prohibited without the express approval of Mount Gibson Mining and/or ecologia Environment.

Restrictions on Use

This report has been prepared specifically for Mount Gibson Mining. Neither the report nor its contents may be referred to or quoted in any statement, study, report, application, prospectus, loan, or other agreement document, without the express approval of Mount Gibson Mining and/or ecologia Environment.

ecologia Environment 1/224 Lord Street PERTH WA 6000 Phone: 08 96168 7200 Email: [email protected]

Page 4: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

iv

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................ 1

1.1 BACKGROUND ........................................................................................................................... 1

1.2 PREVIOUS FLORA AND VEGETATION ASSESSMENTS ................................................................ 2

2 METHODS FOR SURVEY AND ANALYSIS ............................................................................. 5

2.1 FLORISTIC SURVEY ..................................................................................................................... 5

2.2 TARGETED SURVEY .................................................................................................................... 7

3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION ................................................................................................ 9

3.1 FLORA ........................................................................................................................................ 9

3.2 VEGETATION ...........................................................................................................................10

3.3 SURVEY LIMITATIONS .............................................................................................................26

4 CONCLUSIONS ................................................................................................................ 29

5 REFERENCES ................................................................................................................... 31

TABLES

Table 3.1 – Floristic groups at Iron Hill ...................................................................................................23

Table 3.2 – Floristic group and vegetation mapping (Bennett 2000) comparison .................................24

Table 3.3 – Floristic subgroup and vegetation mapping (Bennett 2000) comparison ...........................25

Table 3.3 – Survey limitations ................................................................................................................26

FIGURES

Figure 2.1 – Mean monthly, 2014 (–) and 2015 (–) rainfall (Paynes Find BoM 007139) ......................... 5

Figure 2.2 – Species accumulation curve for 167 quadrats ..................................................................... 7

Figure 2.3 – Iron Hill quadrats, transects and significant flora records (ecologia 2015) ......................... 8

Figure 3.1 – Mt Gibson Iron Hill floristic analysis (Bray-Curtis coefficient) ............................................15

Figure 3.2 – Iron Hill floristic groups ......................................................................................................17

Figure 3.3 – Mount Gibson Ranges floristic groups ...............................................................................18

Figure 3.4 – Regional quadrats by floristic group ...................................................................................19

Page 5: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

v

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore Mine and Infrastructure Project, including a proposal to mine the Iron Hill deposits, approximately 2.5 km south of the existing Extension Hill mine.

To provide additional data on the flora and vegetation of the proposed Iron Hill disturbance area, including the delineation of floristic groups, Mount Gibson Mining engaged ecologia to complete a flora and vegetation assessment, including sampling 17 additional quadrats (each 20 x 20 m) within and adjacent to the proposed Iron Hill development envelope and floristic analysis to assess the vegetation at Iron Hill, incorporating the new floristic data and previously collected data. In addition, Priority flora searches were conducted across the study area in areas not known to be covered by previous targeted flora searches.

A total of 115 vascular flora taxa were recorded from the 17 quadrats and transects surveyed in April/May 2015. Eight of the quadrats are located within the area covered by the Iron Hill proposal and nine are located in similar vegetation nearby. The vegetation condition in all quadrats sampled in 2015 was rated as either ‘Excellent’ or ‘Very Good’. One Threatened flora species (Darwinia masonii) was recorded, within areas where the species has previously been recorded. No Priority flora taxa were recorded. Three range extensions were recorded: Hibbertia hypericoides, Hemigenia macphersonii and Sclerolaena eriacantha and eight additional taxa were recorded at the edge of their range: Eremophila eriocalyx, Eucalyptus kochii subsp. amaryssia, Leucopogon sp. Clyde Hill (M.A. Burgman 1207), Mirbelia sp. Bursarioides (T.R. Lally 760), Philotheca sericea, Prostanthera althoferi subsp. althoferi, Protanthera patens, Sida sp. Golden calyces glabrous (H.N. Foote 32). One introduced species (*Pentameris airoides subsp. airoides) was also recorded.

The 167 quadrats in the floristic analysis were classified into 14 floristic groups. Six of these floristic groups (A, B, C1, C2, E and K) are recorded at Iron Hill and Iron Hill South (collectively known as Iron Hill). Floristic groups are related to the geographic location of the quadrats, whereby the quadrats from Iron Hill ironstone ridges and slopes belong exclusively to groups E and K, and those from the shrublands and woodlands of the adjacent plains are represented in groups A, B , C1 and C2. Within the proposed Iron Hill development envelope, floristic groups E and K are associated with the ironstone hills and slopes and are considered to be key components of the Priority 1 Mount Gibson Range vegetation complexes (banded ironstone formation) Priority Ecological Community.

Floristic group K, the largest PEC floristic group (with respect to both number of quadrats and area mapped) was further divided into three subgroups, K1, K2 and K3. These three subgroups are similar in species composition and many taxa are common to all three subgroups, but may be represented in different frequencies.

Page 6: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

vi

This page has been left blank intentionally.

Page 7: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

1

1 INTRODUCTION

1.1 BACKGROUND

Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore Mine and Infrastructure Project, including a proposal to mine the Iron Hill deposits, approximately 2.5 km south of the existing Extension Hill mine. The proposed Iron Hill Development Envelope is approximately 2.5 km wide and covers 112 hectares (ha). The Western Australian Environment Protection Authority (EPA) issued an Environmental Scoping Document (ESD) outlining additional environmental assessment works required prior to submission of the Public Environmental Review (PER) for the Iron Hill project.

In particular, this report and its content address the following ESD requirements:

10. In areas not already surveyed or where survey information is not of acceptable quality (such as incorrect survey season), standard and/or the proponent intends to use results from surveys at a lower level than a Level 2, justification will be required to ensure those surveys are relevant, representative of the development envelope, and were carried out using methods consistent with current best practice. A peer review of the vegetation and flora information by a botanist with appropriate experience and expertise would also be required.

11. Identify and map vegetation units (including sub-units of the plant assemblages of the Mt Gibson Range PEC) and DRF, Priority flora and other conservation significant flora species and their areas to be cleared or indirectly impacted as defined in EPA Guidance Statement 51. Provide details of the methodology used in the identification and mapping of vegetation units. The vegetation units should be based on floristics, rather than structural vegetation features. Describe the condition of the vegetation.

Conservation significant as defined in Guidance Statement 51 includes flora other than those that are listed at the State or national level as threatened, Priority and specially protected (e.g. endemic or restricted taxa, new taxa or affinities, taxa at the limits of their range, etc.).

12. Assess the impact on the different vegetation units (including sub-units of the plant assemblages of the Mt Gibson Range PEC).

To provide additional data on the flora and vegetation of the proposed Iron Hill development envelope, Mount Gibson Mining engaged ecologia to complete a flora and vegetation assessment, including sampling 17 additional quadrats within and adjacent to the proposed Iron Hill development envelope and floristic analysis to assess the vegetation values at Iron Hill, incorporating the new floristic data, and that previously collected by ATA Environmental in 2005 (ATA 2006b) and the Department of Environment and Conservation (DEC) Banded Iron Formation (BIF) survey conducted in 2005 (Meissner and Caruso 2008b). In addition, Threatened and Priority flora searches were conducted across the study area at approximately 50 m intervals, concentrating on areas not previously covered by targeted searches for Threatened and Priority flora. Threatened and Priority flora taxa with potential to occur within the Iron Hill development envelope include: • Darwinia masonii (Threatened) listed as Vulnerable under the WC Act and EPBC Act; • Lepidosperma gibsonii (Threatened) listed as Vulnerable under the WC Act); • Acacia cerastes (Priority 1); • Allocasuarina tessellata (Priority 1); • Chamelaucium sp. Yalgoo (Y. Chadwick 1816) (Priority 1); • Grevillea scabrida (Priority 1); • Micromyrtus trudgenii (Priority 3);

Page 8: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

2

• Persoonia pentasticha (Priority 3); and • Podotheca uniseta (Priority 3).

1.2 PREVIOUS FLORA AND VEGETATION ASSESSMENTS

Previous flora and vegetation assessments completed in the Mount Gibson Ranges include: • Muir Environmental (1995): Observations on the Presence and Distribution of Rare Flora,

especially Darwinia masonii, near Mt Gibson; • Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000): Flora and Vegetation of Mt Gibson; • ATA (2004): Targeted Search at Mt Gibson for the Declared Rare Flora Darwinia masonii; • Armstrong (2004): Vegetation Assessment and Rare Flora Search between Perenjori and Mt

Gibson; • Griffin (2005): Numerical Analysis of Floristic Data in Mt Gibson Area, (based on the ATA (2006b)

data); • ATA (2006a): Chamelaucium sp. Yalgoo Supplementary Survey – Mt Gibson; • ATA (2006b): Mt Gibson Magnetite Project Supplementary Vegetation and Flora Surveys; • ATA (2006c): Targeted Survey at Mt Gibson for a new Lepidosperma sp. Mt Gibson; • Coffey (2008a): Location of Darwinia masonii (DRF) Associated with Phase 1 Drill Pads – Extension

Hill; • Coffey (2008b): Locations of Lepidosperma gibsonii; • Meissner and Caruso (2008b): Flora and vegetation of banded iron formations of the Yilgarn

Craton: Mount Gibson and surrounding area; • Borger and Nicholls (2013): Survey of Proposed Drill Lines in Tenement M59/339 at Extension Hill; • Martinick Bosch Sell (2013): Targeted Flora Survey: Extension Hill Hematite Project, Midwest

Region, Western Australia – Iron Hill and Gibson Hill Prospect Areas; • Eco Logical (2014): Mount Gibson Ranges Darwinia masonii Census; • Globe (2014): Iron Hill Deposit Assessment of the Threatened Taxa Category for Darwinia masonii

using IUCN (2012) Criteria; • Maia (2014): Mt Gibson Ranges Targeted Darwinia masonii Survey; and • Martinick Bosch Sell (2014): Extension Hill Hematite Operations Annual Declared Rare Flora

Monitoring. The original floristic data from the ATA (2006b) and Meissner and Caruso (2008) surveys were sourced for inclusion in the floristic analysis of this study.

1.3 Mid-west Regional Floristic Analysis

In addition to the floristic analysis presented in following sections, a separate regional floristic analysis was completed by van Etten (2013), which places the previously collected Iron Hill quadrats in the context of other district and regional quadrats. The regional floristic analysis includes the (ATA 2006b) and Meissner and Caruso (2008b) datasets from the Mt Gibson Ranges used in this analysis, as well as the following regional data sources: • DEC Tallering BIF Survey – 103 quadrats (Markey and Dillon 2008); • DEC Koolanooka and Perenjori Hills BIF Survey – 50 quadrats (Meissner and Caruso 2008a); • DEC Gullewa BIF Survey – 50 quadrats (Markey and Dillon 2010); • DEC Yalgoo BIF Survey – 55 quadrats (Markey and Dillon 2011); • Sandplains – 53 quadrats (Knuckey 2011); and • EnviroWorks Mummaloo Flora and Vegetation Survey – 98 quadrats (EnviroWorks 2012).

Page 9: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

3

For analysis, quadrats from ironstone ridges at Mount Gibson Ranges were assigned as three groups: ‘Mount Gibson’ (generally the eastern part of the range); ‘Extension Hill’ (generally the northern part of the range); and, ‘Iron Hill’ (in the central part of the range). The ordination output (Appendix A) shows that the Mount Gibson Ranges quadrats are similar to each other. As a collective set, the ‘Mt Gibson’ quadrats are generally similar in floristic composition to Tallering quadrats, whereas ‘Extension Hill’ quadrats and most of the ‘Iron Hill’ quadrats are more similar to the BIF quadrats of Koolanooka and Perenjori Hills, although there is some overlap. Not unexpectedly, ‘Iron Hill’ quadrats are similar to ‘Mt Gibson’ in some cases and ‘Extension Hill’ in others.

Based on the regional analysis, van Etten (2013) found that: • Analysis of the EnviroWorks Consulting (2012) quadrat data using alternative multivariate

techniques had given strong support for the vegetation classification; in particular, the main plant communities defined by EnviroWorks Consulting (2012) closely matched those found in the multivariate study. This means that the technique is a strong surrogate for identifying floristic similarity between quadrats mapped as communities;

• Using only perennial species data in the multivariate analysis did not dramatically alter the vegetation classification with the main community types being consistently delineated and identified;

• A high level of floristic similarity was found between 100 m2 and 400 m2 quadrats surveyed. This supported the use of data from smaller sized quadrats in local and regional analyses;

• Multivariate analyses of the regional quadrat dataset shows that the vegetation of the Mummaloo area is dissimilar to the vegetation reported in other survey areas of the region. It is important to note that there is no broad-scale vegetation survey available for the region, with most surveys being restricted to particular geologies/landforms or development sites (e.g. Mt Gibson Iron Ore mine); and

• The vegetation of Mummaloo area and the flats adjacent to ranges is distinct from vegetation on ironstone and greenstone ranges of the region, including the PECs at ironstone ranges at Mt Gibson, Koolanooka and Blue Hills.

Other evident findings were: • Floristic composition in quadrats on most of the Mount Gibson tenements (Mt Gibson Mining),

being the sandplains and flats adjacent and partly within the PEC (but not on ironstone ridges or slopes) were largely dissimilar from quadrats on ‘Mt Gibson Surrounds’ (Figure 1.1). The clear distinction shows that the floristics of communities mapped on the Mt Gibson surrounds do not show general characteristics of the upslope or ironstone ridge communities;

• Mt Gibson ironstone communities and ‘Tallering BIF’ quadrats were similar, and clearly far more similar overall than ‘Mt Gibson Surrounds’ flats/plains or other regional ironstone ridge quadrats (being Yalgoo, Gullewa and Koolanooka-Perenjori). While they were similar to each other, they clearly are different to the floristics in quadrats adjacent to them on the flats and sandplains;

• The Iron Hill quadrat data map well within the typical set of floristic similarities from quadrats over Mt Gibson Ranges indicating that it is not atypical or unusual in its floristic composition for ironstone ridges or within the Mt Gibson Ranges.)

Page 10: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

4

This page has been left blank intentionally.

Page 11: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

5

2 METHODS FOR SURVEY AND ANALYSIS

2.1 FLORISTIC SURVEY

Seventeen quadrats (20 x 20 m) were surveyed by two ecologia botanists from 29 April to 2 May 2015 (Matthew Macdonald and John Grantham under DPaW Licence to Take Flora for Scientific or Other Prescribed Purposes SL010976 and SL01141, respectively). Approximately 70% of the field survey duration was utilised establishing the floristic quadrats and the remaining time focussed on conducting traverses in areas which have not previously been targeted for Threatened and Priority flora. The nearest long term weather station is at Paynes Find (BoM Station 007139) approximately 60 km north-east of Iron Hill (BoM 2016). The mean rainfall (rainfall records from 1919 to 2016) for March and April is 24.7 mm and 26.0 mm respectively, but prior to the 2015 field survey 54.8 mm of rain was recorded in March and 32.6 mm recorded in April. Mean monthly rainfall and rainfall recorded at Paynes Find for the 12 months prior to the field survey are shown in Figure 2.1. The favourable conditions at the time of survey are corroborated by the presence of fruit and/or flowers on 49% of the vascular flora recorded.

Figure 2.1 – Mean monthly, 2014 (–) and 2015 (–) rainfall (Paynes Find BoM 007139)

Previous surveys completed at Iron Hill and incorporated into this assessment (ATA 2006b and Meissner and Caruso 2008b) were conducted in spring 2005 and include a total of 150 quadrats. This survey of 17 quadrats was conducted after autumn rains and is therefore suitable as a supplementary survey. Eight of the 17 quadrats are located within the area covered by the Iron Hill proposal and nine are located in similar vegetation nearby. Due to the spread of the previously sampled quadrats across the Mt Gibson Range and nearby hills and plains, the 17 quadrats from this survey were concentrated in and around the Iron Hill development envelope. Quadrat locations were selected to represent the range of vegetation at the site without duplicating sampling in areas where quadrats have been previously surveyed. The locations of the quadrats are shown in Figure 2.1.

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

Rain

fall

(mm

)

Month

Page 12: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

6

Data collected at each quadrat includes: • Percentage cover for each species present using the cover ranges cited by NVIS and as a

percentage cover estimate (rounded to nearest 5%) along with presence/absence of fruit/flowers; • Landform element (morphological type, position and element type) that the plot occupies; • Degree and nature of any site disturbance (based on Trudgen (1991) scale); • Presence of coarse fragments on the surface (type and abundance); • Presence of rock outcrops (type and abundance); • Soil type (colour, profile, field texture and surface type); • Vegetation structure (scoring three layers for dominance, growth form, height and estimated

cover consistent with the National Vegetation Information System (NVIS) Level V); and • Data on position, slope, and aspect. Data from 150 previously surveyed quadrats (all quadrats were 20 x 20 m) from the following assessments was included in the floristic analysis: • 100 quadrats from ATA (2006b); and • 50 quadrats from Meissner and Caruso (2008b) which were sampled in September and October

2005. Floristic analysis of the amalgamated dataset, incorporating the newly collected (2015) floristic data, along with data previously collected by ATA Environmental in 2005 (ATA 2006b) and from the DEC BIF survey (Meissner and Caruso 2008b) was undertaken by experienced ecologia ecologist Dr Matthew Macdonald, who has extensive experience in multivariate statistical and floristic analysis. Floristic analysis was undertaken on presence/absence data from each quadrat, with species of annuals and geophytes excluded. Some taxa were consolidated to produce a single consistent dataset from the three data sources, consistent with Meissner and Caruso (2008b). The site by species matrix used in the floristic analysis therefore consisted of 167 quadrats and 184 taxa. A species accumulation curve is shown in Figure 2.2. The incidence-based species richness (ICE) is estimated at 238 species, of which the 184 taxa included in the analysis represent 77% of the expected species richness. A consolidated list of vascular flora recorded from the three surveys and included in the analysis is provided in Appendix B. Quadrats were classified into floristic groups based on differences in species composition using the Bray-Curtis coefficient and flexible UPGMA (Unweighted Pair-Group Mean Average) using PATN multivariate statistical program. The locations of quadrats representing these floristic groups formed the basis for mapping of the vegetation groups across the Mount Gibson Ranges and surrounding slopes and plains. Other sources of data which were used to inform the mapping of floristic groups include: terrain (elevation contours); locations of Threatened and Priority flora taxa, particularly the Threatened (Vulnerable) species Darwinia masonii and Lepidosperma gibsonii and field observations made during this survey and by Eco Logical for delineation of floristic group E across the Mount Gibson Ranges.

Page 13: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

7

Figure 2.2 – Species accumulation curve for 167 quadrats

2.2 TARGETED SURVEY

Areas within the Iron Hill development envelope which have not been searched during previous surveys were traversed at approximately 50 m intervals to record Threatened and Priority flora in these areas. Most of the steeper areas associated with Iron Hill itself have previously been searched for Threatened and Priority flora (particularly Eco Logical 2014, but also other references listed in section 1.2). These previous targeted surveys cover virtually all of the Mt Gibson Range PEC; therefore additional targeted surveys outside the Iron Hill development envelope were not undertaken.

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160

Spec

ies

Quadrats

Page 14: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

#*#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*#*

#*#*

#*#*

#*

#*

#*#*

#*#*

#*

#*

#*#*

#*

#*

#*#*

#*#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

#*#*

#*#*

#* #*

#*

#*#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

!(!(!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

")

")

")

")

")

")

")

")

")

")

")

")

")

")

")

")

")

DE

E

E

E

48

46

45

44

434241

40

2

4

7

6

5

1

8

3

9

14

15

13

12

11

1016

17

MTGB32

MTGB31

MTGB21

MTGB20

MTGB19MTGB18

MTGB17

515000 516000 51700067

2400

067

2500

067

2600

0

LegendE Darwinia masonii (Threatened)

D Hibbertia hypericoides (Range Extension)

Proposed Iron Hill Development Envelope

") ecologia (2015) Quadrat

!( ATA (2006b) Quadrat

#* Meissner and Caruso (2008b) Quadrat

Track

Coordinate SystemName: GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50Projection: Transverse MercatorDatum: GDA 1994 A4

Figure: 2.оProject ID: 1639

Drawn: MMDate: 04/10/2015

K0 0.25 0.5

Kilometres1:12,000Absolute Scale -

Iron Hill Quadrats, Tracks and Significant Flora Records (ecologia 2015)

Page 15: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

9

3 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

3.1 FLORA

A total of 115 vascular flora taxa were recorded from the 17 quadrats and transects surveyed in 2015 (see Appendix B). Quadrat species richness varied from nine taxa at quadrat numbers 2 and 17 from sandplain shrubland to 26 taxa from quadrat numbers 9 and 11 from hilltop/hillslope shrubland. Site descriptions are provided in Appendix C.

The most species rich families were Myrtaceae with 20 taxa, Fabaceae with 18 taxa, Lamiaceae with 8 taxa, Chenopodiaceae and Proteaceae with 7 taxa each and Poaceae with 6 taxa. The most species rich genera were Acacia, with 13 taxa; Eucalyptus with 7 taxa; Melaleuca with 6 taxa; and Eremophila and Grevillea with 5 taxa each.

One listed Threatened flora species, Darwinia masonii (Vulnerable under the WC Act and EPBC Act) was recorded from Quadrats 8, 9, 10 and 11 on Iron Hill, within areas where the species has previously been extensively recorded (Eco Logical 2014).

Three range extensions were recorded:

• Hibbertia hypericoides – recorded at Quadrat 8 (outside the Iron Hill development envelope), approximately 100 km north-east of the nearest vouchered record. This species has also been recorded from both the ATA (2006b) and Meissner and Caruso (2008b) Gibson Range surveys, but apparently no specimen has been lodged with the Western Australian Herbarium;

• Hemigenia macphersonii – recorded from Quadrats 7 and 9 outside the Iron Hill development envelope, and quadrats 14 and 16 inside the Iron Hill development envelope, approximately 100 km south of the nearest vouchered record. This species has also been recorded from both the ATA (2006b) and Meissner and Caruso (2008b) Gibson Range surveys, but apparently no specimen has been lodged with the Western Australian Herbarium; and

• Sclerolaena eriacantha – recorded from Quadrat 10, inside the Iron Hill development envelope, approximately 100 km south of the nearest vouchered record.

Eight additional taxa were recorded at the edge of their range:

• Eremophila eriocalyx – recorded from Quadrat 10, inside the Iron Hill development envelope. • Eucalyptus kochii subsp. amaryssia – recorded from Quadrats 2 and 3 inside the Iron Hill

development envelope, and quadrats 4 and 15 outside the Iron Hill development envelope. This taxon was also recorded in the Meissner and Caruso (2008b) survey.

• Leucopogon sp. Clyde Hill (M.A. Burgman 1207) – recorded at Quadrats 7 and 15 outside the Iron Hill development envelope, and Quadrats 13 and 14 inside the Iron Hill development envelope. This taxon has also been recorded from both the ATA (2006b) and Meissner and Caruso (2008b) surveys.

• Mirbelia sp. Bursarioides (T.R. Lally 760) – recorded from one opportunistic collection on the lower slopes of Iron Hill approximately mid-way between Quadrats 12 and 13 within the Iron Hill development envelope. This taxon was also recorded in the Meissner and Caruso (2008b) survey.

• Philotheca sericea recorded at Quadrats 5 and 7 outside the Iron Hill development envelope, and Quadrats 11 and 14 inside the Iron Hill development envelope. This species has also been recorded from both the ATA (2006b) and Meissner and Caruso (2008b) surveys.

• Prostanthera althoferi subsp. althoferi – recorded from Quadrats 15 and 17 outside the Iron Hill development envelope, and Quadrats 13 and 16 inside the Iron Hill development envelope. This taxon was also recorded in the Meissner and Caruso (2008b) survey.

Page 16: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

10

• Protanthera patens – recorded from Quadrat 7, outside the Iron Hill development envelope. This species has also been recorded from both the ATA (2006b) and Meissner and Caruso (2008b) surveys.

• Sida sp. Golden calyces glabrous (H.N. Foote 32) – recorded from Quadrat 5, outside the Iron Hill development envelope.

Figures showing the distribution of vouchered records for range extension and range edge records are provided in Appendix D (Western Australian Herbarium 1998-2016). Specimens representing range extension and range edge records will be lodged with the Western Australian Herbarium (see Appendix E for list of voucher specimens).

One introduced species (*Pentameris airoides subsp. airoides) was from Quadrat 11 (inside the Iron Hill development envelope).

3.2 VEGETATION

The 167 quadrats in the floristic analysis were classified into 14 identifiable floristic groups based on the dendrogram produced by the PATN analysis (Figure 3.1). Six of these floristic units (A, B, C1, C2, E and K) are represented within the Iron Hill proposal and are summarised in Table 3.1. In general, the groupings are related to the geographic location of the quadrats, whereby the quadrats from Iron Hill ironstone ridges and slopes belong exclusively to Groups E and K, those from the footslopes belong to Group C2 and shrublands and woodlands of the adjacent plains are represented in Groups A, B and C1. This pattern of floristic composition changing with landscape position is consistent with the previous floristic analyses of the Mount Gibson Ranges (Griffin 2005; Meissner and Caruso 2008b). A two-way table of floristic groups and taxa is provided in Appendix F.

The vegetation condition in all 17 quadrats sampled in 2015 was rated as either ‘Excellent’ (13 quadrats) or ‘Very Good’ (4 quadrats).

3.2.1 Floristic Groups

Quadrats included in the floristic analysis of the 167 quadrats are clustered in the 14 floristic groups as follows (Figure 3.2): • A: Eucalyptus kochii sparse woodland over Melaleuca hamata, Acacia anthochaera and Acacia

ramulosa shrubland over Dianella revoluta herbs and Amphipogon caricinus var. caricinus tussock grasses. This floristic group is represented by five quadrats from the 2015 survey, all of which are located on the sandplains to the west of Iron Hill, in particular two quadrats (quadrats 2 and 3) are within the northern section of the proposed Iron Hill disturbance area, and three quadrats (quadrats 1, 4 and 17) are outside and adjacent to the proposed haul road alignment.

• B: Eucalyptus horistes open woodland over Acacia ramulosa and Cryptandra apetala shrubland over Triodia scariosa open hummock grassland. This floristic group is represented by two quadrats from the 2015 survey, both of which are located on the sandplains to the west of Iron Hill, one within (quadrat 16) the proposed haul road alignment and one outside (quadrat 6).

• C1: Eucalyptus loxophleba subsp. supralaevis and/or Eucalyptus kochii subsp. amaryissa woodland over Acacia tetragonophylla, Acacia anthochaera, Acacia assimilis subsp. assimilis, Eremophila clarkei, and Ptilotus obovatus shrubland over Austrostipa elegantissima tussock grasses. This floristic group is represented by six quadrats, four from the ecologia 2015 survey, and two from the DEC (Meissner and Caruso 2008b) survey. One ecologia 2015 quadrat (quadrat 13) is located within the Iron Hill development envelope, whereas the three remaining ecologia 2015 quadrats (quadrats 5, 7 and 15) are located on the colluvial plains to the west of Iron Hill, with one

Page 17: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

11

DEC quadrat to the east of Extension Hill (MTGB30) and one quadrat from the near the Yandhanoo Hills (YAND9).

• C2: Eucalyptus loxophleba subsp. supralaevis, Eucalyptus kochii subsp. amaryissa and/or Eucalyptus horistes mallee woodland over Acacia acuminata, Eremophila clarkei, Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsepiana, Philotheca brucei, Dodonaea inaequifolia and Melaleuca hamata shrubland over Austrostipa elegantissima tussock grasses. This floristic group is represented by five quadrats, one from the ecologia 2015 survey, and four from the DEC (Meissner and Caruso 2008b) survey. One ecologia 2015 quadrat (quadrat 14) and two DEC quadrats (quadrats MTBGB21 and MTGB31) are located within the proposed Iron Hill development envelope, and the DEC quadrat MTGB32 located on the footslopes to the west of Iron Hill, with one DEC quadrat to the east of Mount Gibson (MTGB27).

• D: Represented by a single ATA quadrat at Mt Singleton. • E: Calycopeplus paucifolius, Acacia tetragonophylla and Ptilotus obovatus open shrubland over

Cheilanthes adiantoides ferns and Austrostipa elegantissima tussock grasses. This floristic group is represented by 15 quadrats on ironstone ridges, four within the Iron Hill proposal (DEC quadrats MTGB18, MTGB19 and MTGB20 and ATA quadrat 44) and the remaining eleven quadrats outside the proposed development envelope at Iron Hill (2015 quadrat 8), Iron Hill North (MTGB17 and ATA 42), and Mount Gibson (MTGB24, MTGB25). One DEC quadrat from near the Great Northern Highway (GNH3) and one from Yandhanoo Hills (YAND3), and two more distant ATA quadrats (ATA 63 and 64) also cluster with this group. This floristic unit includes Community Type 5 (six quadrats) and Community Type 1 (two quadrats) of the (Meissner and Caruso 2008b) assessment, and ATA (2006b) mapped vegetation units T3 (one quadrat), T5 (one quadrat) and HS1 (two quadrats).

• F, G, H, I, and J: All quadrats representing these groups are located away from the Mount Gibson Ranges, such as Yandhanoo Hills, Mount Singleton, Warroo Well and along the Great Northern Highway and the Emu Proof Fence.

• K: Allocasuarina acutivalvis, Melaleuca nematophylla and Grevillea obliquistigma shrubland over Cheilanthes adiantoides ferns.

This floristic group is represented by 74 quadrats which clearly cluster floristic compositions on ironstone ridges across the Mt Gibson ranges; five within the Iron Hill proposal and the remaining 69 from Extension Hill, Extension Hill North, Extension Hill South, Iron Hill North, Iron Hill East, and Mount Gibson North. Based on the ATA (2006b) quadrats this floristic unit is equivalent to mapped vegetation units T1 (33 quadrats), T3 (seven quadrats), T5 (three quadrats), T6 (eight quadrats), T12 (three quadrats) and M4 (one quadrat) as well as Community Type 6 (14 quadrats) and Community Type 4 (one quadrat) from the Meissner and Caruso (2008b) survey. The relatively large number of quadrats in this unit is a function of the high density of quadrats on the Mt Gibson Ranges.

Due to the large number of quadrats representing Floristic Group K, this group was divided further into three floristic subgroups to investigate finer-scale vegetation patterns. The subgroups are similar in species composition and many taxa are common to all three subgroups, but represented in different frequencies.

o K1: Calycopeplis pauciflorus, Leucopogon sp. Clyde Hill, Philotheca sericea, Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsepiana, Eremophila clarkei, Grevillea paradoxa and Melaleuca nematophylla shrubland over Cheilanthes adiantoides ferns

This floristic subgroup is represented by 13 quadrats, four of which are from the ecologia 2015 survey, four from the Meissner and Caruso (2008b) assessment and five from the ATA (2006b) survey. Three quadrats from this subgroup are within the Iron Hill development envelope (ecologia quadrats 10, 11 and 12). Three of the Meissner and Caruso (2006b)

Page 18: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

12

quadrats represent Community Type 6 and one represents Community Type 4. Floristic subgroup K1 is largely associated with Iron Hill with four quadrats inside and one just north of the Iron Hill development envelope, but there are also 6 quadrats on the north-east of Extension Hill and the remaining two quadrats are relatively isolated: one at Extension Hill South, and the other north of Mount Gibson.

o K2: Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsepiana, Melaleuca nematophylla, Grevillea obliquistigma subsp. obliquistigma, Aluta aspera subsp. hesperia, Acacia assimilis subsp. assimilis and Philotheca sericea shrubland over Cheilanthes adiantoides ferns

This floristic subgroup is represented by 39 quadrats, 30 from the ATA (2006b) survey and nine from the Meissner and Caruso (2008b) assessment. No quadrats from this subgroup are within the Iron Hill development envelope. All nine of the Meissner and Caruso (2006b) quadrats represent Community Type 6. Floristic subgroup K2 is largely associated with Extension Hill, with 35 quadrats representing the subgroup from Extension Hill and the remaining four quadrats from Iron Hill East (two quadrats) and the lower slopes of Mount Gibson (two quadrats).

o K3: Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsepiana, Grevillea obliquistigma subsp. obliquistigma, Calycopeplus pauciflorus, Melaleuca nematophylla, Grevillea paradaoxa and Philotheca sericea shrubland over Xanthosia kochii herbs and Cheilanthes adiantoides ferns

This floristic subgroup is represented by 22 quadrats, 20 of which are from the ATA (2006b) survey and two from the Meissner and Caruso (2008b) assessment. One quadrat from this subgroup is within the Iron Hill development envelope (ATA 45). Both of the Meissner and Caruso (2006b) quadrats represent Community Type 6. Floristic subgroup K3 appears to be generally associated with the higher peaks of the hills (but with some exceptions) and often near the Group E quadrats which is restricted to the steepest, most unstable slopes of the range. The quadrats are widely distributed across the range at Extension Hill, Extension Hill South, Iron Hill, Iron Hill North, Mt Gibson and Mount Gibson South.

• L: Eucalyptus oldfieldii open woodland over Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsepiana, Aluta aspera subsp. hesperia, Enekbatus stowardii, Melaleuca fabri and Acacia coolgardiensis subsp. effusa shrubland over Amphipogon caricinus var. caricinus grassland and Cheilanthes adiantoides ferns.

This floristic group was not sampled in the ecologia (2015) assessment, but is composed of seven previously sampled quadrats: one ATA (2006b) quadrat (ATA 2) and six DEC (Meissner and Caruso 2008b) quadrats (MTGB03), MTGB05, MTGB07, MTGB11, MTGB16 and MTGB29). Five of the DEC quadrats constitute Community Type 6 (Meissner and Caruso 2008b) . All seven quadrats from this floristic group are associated with the Extension Hill section of the Mount Gibson Ranges on slopes and footslopes.

• M: The single quadrat from this group is located away from the Mount Gibson Ranges, at the Emu-proof fence.

All floristic groups as defined in this floristic analysis are also well represented by quadrats from outside the Iron Hill development envelope. This analysis shows: • The six floristic groups from within the proposed Iron Hill development footprint also occur

outside the proposed development footprint within the Mt Gibson Ranges or elsewhere; and • A clear distinction between ridge tops/slopes, foot slopes/flats and sandplains is evident in the

analysis.

Page 19: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

13

Vegetation mapping from the floristic groups was extrapolated over areas where floristic quadrats were limited or absent, but where vegetation previously mapped by Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000) provides information on the vegetation present (Figure 3.3).

Within the proposed Iron Hill development envelope, Floristic Groups E, K and L are associated with the ironstone hills and slopes and are considered to be components of the Priority 1 Mount Gibson Range vegetation complexes (banded ironstone formation) PEC. Of these Floristic Groups considered to represent components of the PEC, quadrats representing Groups K and L are restricted to the Mount Gibson Ranges, whereas three of the quadrats representing Group E are present on a hill to the north of the Great Northern Highway, approximately 8 km north of the Mount Gibson Ranges and one quadrat at Yandhanoo Hills approximately 8 km north-east of the Mount Gibson Ranges (Figure 3.4).

Page 20: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

14

This page has been left blank intentionally.

Page 21: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Iron Hill Proposal Location Floristic DPaW Bennett

Non‐impact M1/T9

Impact T9

Non‐impact T9

Non‐impact T9

Impact T9

Non‐impact M1

Impact M1

Non‐impact M1

Non‐impact M1

Non‐impact M1

Impact M1

‐ CT3 T8

‐ CT3 ‐

Impact M1/T3

Impact CT4 T9

‐ CT4 T10/W5

Non‐impact CT4 T9

Impact CT4 M1

‐ Mt Singleton D ‐

Non‐impact T3

‐ CT5 T6

‐ CT5 T6

‐ CT1 ‐

‐ CT1 ‐

Non‐impact T5

Non‐impact CT5 T5

Impact T3

Impact CT5 T3

Impact CT5 T3

Impact CT5 T3

‐ HS1

‐ HS1

‐ ‐

‐ W2

‐ ‐

‐ CT2 ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ CT1 ‐

‐ CT1 ‐

‐ CT3 ‐

‐ CT1 ‐

‐ CT1 ‐

‐ CT1 ‐

‐ CT1 ‐

‐ CT1 ‐

‐ CT1 ‐

‐ CT2 ‐

‐ CT2 ‐

‐ CT2 ‐

‐ CT2 ‐

‐ CT2 ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

‐ ‐

Non‐impact T3

Impact T3

‐ CT6 T6

Impact T3

Impact T3

Impact T3

‐ T1/T12

‐ CT6 T1

‐ CT6 T1

‐ T12

‐ T12

‐ CT4 T12

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1/T12

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1/T3

‐ T1

‐ T3

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1/T3

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ CT6 T1

‐ CT6 T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ CT6 T1

‐ T1

‐ CT6 T3

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ CT6 T1

‐ CT6 T1

‐ CT6 T1/T3

‐ CT6 T3

‐ CT6 T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

Non‐impact T3

‐ T1

‐ CT6 T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T1

‐ T3

‐ T3

Non‐impact T3

‐ T6

‐ CT6 T6

‐ T6

‐ T6

‐ T6

‐ T6

Non‐impact T5

‐ T6

‐ T6

‐ M4

Non‐impact T5

‐ T6

Non‐impact T5

Impact T3

‐ T1/T3

‐ CT7 T3/T12

‐ CT7 T9

‐ CT7 T1

‐ CT7 T2

‐ CT7 T2

‐ CT6 T1

‐ Emu Proof Fence M ‐

C1

Colluvial Plains 

around Mount 

Gibson Ranges and 

Yandhanoo Hills

Great Northern Hwy, 

Yandhanoo Hills and 

Warroo Well

G

H

I

Footslopes of Mount 

Gibson RangesC2

Figure 3.1 ‐ Mt Gibson Iron Hill Floristic Analysis (Bray‐Curtis coefficient)

J

Group

A

B

E

BIF Hills (Extension 

Hill & Extension Hill 

South)

L

Sandplain west of Mt 

Gibson Ranges

Sandplain west of Mt 

Gibson Ranges

Mount Gibson Ranges 

(Iron Hill, Iron Hill 

North, Mt Gibson)

Great Northern 

Hwy/Emu Proof 

Fence

Yandhanoo Hills and 

Great Northern Hwy

Mt Singleton

Mt Singleton/Emu 

Proof Fence

F

K1

Mount Gibson Ranges 

(Extension Hill, 

Extension Hill South, 

Iron Hill, Iron Hill East 

and Mt Gibson)

Mount Gibson Ranges 

(Extension Hill, Iron 

Hill East and Mt 

Gibson North)

K2

Mount Gibson Ranges 

(Extension Hill, 

Extension Hill South, 

Iron Hill, Iron Hill 

North, Mt Gibson and 

Mt Gibson South)

K3

Page 22: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

16

This page has been left blank intentionally.

Page 23: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

A

A

B

A

K

K

K

E

BA

A

K

C2

C1

C1

C1

C1 K

K

E

KE KK

E

EE

E

C2

C2

515000 516000 51700067

2400

067

2500

0

LegendFloristic Group Mapping

A (Sandplain Shrublands)

B (Sandplain Woodlands)

C1 (Plain Woodlands)

C2 (Foothill Mallee Woodlands)

E (Ironstone Outcrop Shrublands)

K (Ironstone Hill Shrublands)

L (Foothill Woodlands)

Floristic Group Quadrat") A (Sandplain Shrublands)

") B (Sandplain Woodlands)

") C1 (Plain Woodlands)

") C2 (Foothill Mallee Woodlands)

") E (Ironstone Outcrop Shrublands)

") K (Ironstone Hill Shrublands)

Proposed Iron Hill Development Envelope

Quadrat Data Source!( ATA (2005)

#* Meissner and Caruso (2008)

") ecologia (2015)

Coordinate SystemName: GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50Projection: Transverse MercatorDatum: GDA 1994 A4

Figure: 3.2Project ID: 1639

Drawn: MMDate: 03/03/2016

K0 0.25 0.5

Kilometres1:12,000Absolute Scale -

Iron Hill Floristic Groups and Quadrats

Page 24: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

G

G

GG

L

EE

EEE

E

L

LL L

L

C1

C2

C2

C1

K2C2

K2

K1

K3

C2

K2K2

K2

K1

K2K2K3

K2

K2

K1

K1

AA

B

A

EBA

A

C2

C1

C1

C1

C1

K1

K1K1

K1

H

H

HH

J

EEE

L

K3

K3

K3

K3

K3K3

K3K3

K2K2

K1

K3K3

K3

K3

K2

K2

K2

K2

K2

K2

K3

K2

K2

K1K2K2

K2

K2K1K2

512000 514000 516000 518000 520000 52200067

2400

067

2600

067

2800

067

3000

0

LegendIron Hill Development Envelope

Key PEC components (E, K and L)

Floristic Group MappingA (Sandplain Shrublands)

B (Sandplain Woodlands)

C1 (Plain Woodlands)

C2 (Foothill Mallee Woodlands)

E (Ironstone Outcrop Shrublands)

K1 (Ironstone Hill Shrublands)

K2 (Ironstone Hill Shrublands)

K3 (Ironstone Hill Shrublands)

L (Foothill Woodlands)

Floristic Group Quadrat") A (Sandplain Shrublands)

") B (Sandplain Woodlands)

") C1 (Plain Woodlands)

") C2 (Foothill Mallee Woodlands)

") E (Ironstone Outcrop Shrublands)

") K1 (Ironstone Hill Shrublands)

") K2 (Ironstone Hill Shrublands)

") K3 (Ironstone Hill Shrublands)

") L (Foothill Woodlands)

Quadrat Data Source!( ATA (2005)

#* Meissner and Caruso (2008)

") ecologia (2015)

Coordinate SystemName: GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50Projection: Transverse MercatorDatum: GDA 1994 A4

Figure: 3.3Project ID: 1639

Drawn: MMDate: 28/02/2016

K0 0.5 1

Kilometres1:40,000Absolute Scale -

Gibson rangeFloristic Groups

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

!(

#*#*

E

E

K3K3

K3

K3

EE

!(!(!(

!(

!(

#*

#*#*

#*

#*

#*

")

")

")A

E

E

E K3K3

K3

E

EE

E

C2

Page 25: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(

!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(!(

!(!(

!(!(!(!(

!(!(

!(

!(!(!( !(!(!(!(!(!(!(!( !(!(

!(

")")

!(!(

!(

")")")")")")")")")")") !(

!(!(

")!(!(

!(!(!(

")")!(!(

!(!(

!( !(!(!(

!(!(

!(!(

!(

#*#*#*#*

#*#*#*

#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*

#*#*#*#*#*

#*

#*#*#*#*

#*#*#*#*#*#*#*

#*

#*

#*

#*

")

#*#* #*#*

#*#*

#*#*#*

#*#*#*

#*

")")")")

")")")

")")

")

")

")") ")

")")")

Doney Land SystemSingleton Land System

Pindar Land System

Joseph Land System

Bannar Land System

Gabanintha Land System

Moriarty Land System

Yowie Land SystemCarnegie Land System

Rainbow Land System

Kalli Land System

Challenge Land System

Illaara Land System

Watson Land System

Olympic Land System

Tallering Land System

Jundee Land System

Euchre Land System

Graves Land System Tindalarra Land SystemWaguin Land System

Nubev Land System

Lake Bed Land System

Bandy Land System

Campsite Land System

G

GG

G

GE

G

G

G

GGG

F

L

E

EE

E

E

E

LL

L

L

GE

G

C1

C2

C2

C1

K2

K2

K1

C2

K2K2

K2

K1

K1

A

B

A

B A

C1

K1

H

HH

H

H

J

J

J

J

J

FF

H

HH

J

J

D

J

J

JII

I

III

II

I I

H

M

E

E

E

K3

K3

K1

500000 510000 520000 53000067

3000

067

4000

0

LegendMount Gibson Range PEC (DPaW 500 m buffer)

Floristic Group Quadrat") A (Sandplain Shrublands)

") B (Sandplain Woodlands)

") C1 (Plain Woodlands)

") C2 (Foothill Mallee Woodlands)

") E (Ironstone Outcrop Shrublands)

") K1 (Ironstone Hill Shrublands)

") K2 (Ironstone Hill Shrublands)

") K3 (Ironstone Hill Shrublands)

") L (Foothill Woodlands)

Quadrat Data Source!( ATA (2005)

#* Meissner and Caruso (2008)

") ecologia (2015)

Road

Coordinate SystemName: GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50Projection: Transverse MercatorDatum: GDA 1994 A4

Figure: 3.4Project ID: 1639

Drawn: MMDate: 04/10/2015

K0 2 4

Kilometres

1:140,000Absolute Scale -

Iron HillRegional Quadrats by Floristic Group

!(

!(

#*#*

#*

#*

Doney Land System

Watson Land System

G

E

G G

E

E

!(!(

!(#*

#*#*

Watson Land SystemDoney Land System

Yowie Land System

G G

E

H

HH

Page 26: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

20

3.2.2 Floristic Group Comparison with Previous Vegetation Assessments

The six floristic groups represented by quadrats within the Iron Hill development envelope are summarised in Table 3.1, and compared to the vegetation mapping completed by Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000) in Table 3.2. This enables the results of previous studies to inform this study in areas where floristic quadrats are limited or absent, In summary: • A: All five quadrats representing floristic group A are located within vegetation unit T9 of Bennett

Environmental Consulting (2000), although one quadrat is located on the boundary vegetation units T9 and M1. All five floristic group A quadrats are from the current field assessment.

• B: Quadrats representing floristic group B are located within vegetation unit M1 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), although both floristic group B quadrats are from the current field assessment.

• C1: Four of the six quadrats representing floristic group C1 are located within vegetation unit M1 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000). The remaining quadrats are located in vegetation units T8 (one quadrat) and one quadrat is located outside the extent of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000) vegetation mapping, near Yandhanoo Hills. This floristic group also includes two of the three DEC quadrats that represent DEC community 3 (Meissner and Caruso 2008b).

• C2: One of the five quadrats representing floristic group C2 is located within vegetation unit M1 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), and one quadrat is located on the boundary of vegetation units M1 and T3. The remaining quadrats are located in vegetation unit T9 (two quadrats) and on the boundary of T10 and W5 (one quadrat). This floristic group also includes four of the five quadrats representing community 4 (Meissner and Caruso 2008b).

• E: Five of the 15 quadrats representing floristic group E are located within vegetation unit T3 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000). The other quadrats are located in related vegetation units: T5, T6, HS1 (two quadrats in each) and W2 (one quadrat to the east on Ninghan Station). Three additional quadrats are located outside the extent of the Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000) vegetation mapping. This floristic group also includes two of the ten DEC quadrats that represent DEC community 1 and all six quadrats representing community 5 (Meissner and Caruso 2008b).

• K: Thirty-nine of the 74 quadrats representing group K are located within vegetation unit T1 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), 13 are from vegetation unit T3, which includes the quadrats on Iron Hill) and ten are from vegetation unit T6. The remaining quadrats are located in related vegetation units: T5, T12 and M4. This floristic group also includes 14 of the 15 DEC quadrats that represent community 6 and one quadrat representing community 4 (Meissner and Caruso 2008b). o K1: Five of the 13 quadrats from subgroup K1 are located within vegetation unit T3 of

Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), three are from each of the vegetation units T1 and T12, and one from T6. An additional quadrat straddles the boundary of vegetation units T1 and T12. This floristic subgroup also includes three of the 15 DEC quadrats that represent community 6 and one quadrat representing community 4.

o K3: Nine of the 22 quadrats from subgroup K3 are located within vegetation unit T6 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), five are from vegetation unit T1, four from T3, three from T5 and one from M4. This floristic subgroup also includes two of the 15 DEC quadrats that represent community 6 (Meissner and Caruso 2008b)

Page 27: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

21

Therefore, in the vicinity of Iron Hill and the Mount Gibson Ranges, the floristic groups are equivalent to the vegetation units of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000) and community types of Meissner and Caruso (2008b) as follows: • Floristic group A is equivalent and a subset of vegetation unit T9 of Bennett Environmental

Consulting (2000), but being located away from the Mt Gibson Range, is not equivalent to any community of Meissner and Caruso (2008b).

• Floristic group B is equivalent to a subset of vegetation unit M1 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), but being located away from the Mt Gibson Range, is not equivalent to any community of Meissner and Caruso (2008b).

• Floristic group C1 is equivalent to a subset of vegetation unit M1 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), and equivalent to community 3 of Meissner and Caruso (2008b).

• Floristic group C2 is equivalent to a subset of vegetation unit M1 and unit T9 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), and equivalent to community 4 of Meissner and Caruso (2008b).

• Floristic group E is mostly equivalent to a subset of vegetation unit T3 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), and equivalent to community 5 of Meissner and Caruso (2008b).

• Floristic group K is equivalent to a subset of vegetation units T1 and T3 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), but vegetation unit T1 is restricted to Extension Hill. Floristic group K is also equivalent to community 6 of Meissner and Caruso (2008b). o Floristic subgroup K1: is equivalent to a subset of vegetation T3 of Bennett Environmental

Consulting (2000) and a subset of community 6 of Meissner and Caruso (2008b). o Floristic subgroup K3: is equivalent to a subset of vegetation T6 of Bennett Environmental

Consulting (2000) and a subset of community 6 of Meissner and Caruso (2008b)

Page 28: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

22

This page has been left blank intentionally.

Page 29: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Within Iron Hill Proposal Outside

ecologia  13 ecologia  5, 7, 15

‐ MTGB30, YAND9

ecologia  14 ‐

MTGB21, MTGB31  MTGB27,  MTGB32

ecologia  8 ‐

MTGB18, MTGB19, MTGB20MTGB17, MTGB24, MTGB25, GNH3, 

YAND3

ATA 44 ATA 42, 58, 59, 63, 64

ecologia  10, 11, 12 ecologia  9

MTGB01, MTGB02, MTGB04, MTGB06, 

MTGB08, MTGB09, MTGB10, MTGB12, 

MTGB13, MTGB14, MTGB15, MTGB22, 

MTGB23, MTGB26, MTGB28

ATA 45, 46

ATA 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 

14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 

25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 

36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 43, 47, 48, 49, 50, 

51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 60

ecologia  10, 11, 12 ecologia  9

‐ MTGB01, MTGB2, MTGB12, MTGB23

ATA 46 ATA 1, 3, 6, 15

ATA 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 16, 

17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 23, 24, 26, 27, 28, 29, 

30, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 47, 48

MTGB04, MTGB06, MTGB09, MTGB10, 

MTGB13, MTGB14, MTGB15, MTGB26, 

MTGB28

ATA 45ATA 22, 25, 31, 32, 38, 39, 40, 41, 43, 45, 

49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 60

‐ MTGB08, MTGB22

K3

Ironstone Hill 

Shrublands

Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsipeana , Grevillea obliquistigma subsp. obliquistigma , Calycopeplus pauciflorus , Melaleuca nematophyla, Grevillea paradaoxa  and Philotheca sericea  shrubland over Xanthosia kochii  herbs and Cheilanthes adiantoides  ferns

124.6

Within Iron Hill 

Proposal = 1.4 ha (<1%)

No image available

K1

Ironstone Hill 

Shrublands

Calycopeplis pauciflorus , Leucopogon  sp. Clyde Hill, Philotheca sericea , Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsipeana , Eremophila clarkei , Grevillea paradoxa  and Melaleuca nematophyla  shrubland over Cheilanthes adiantoides  ferns

129.9

Within Iron Hill 

Proposal = 39.4 ha 

(30%)

K2

Ironstone Hill 

Shrublands

Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsipeana, Melaleuca nematophyla, Grevillea obliquistigma  subsp. obliquistigma, Aluta aspera, Acacia assimilis subsp. assimilis and Philotheca sericea  shrubland over Cheilanthes adiantoides  ferns

392.7 No image available

Area (ha) as mapped 

in Figure 3.2

118.6

Within Iron Hill 

Proposal = 17.8 ha 

(15%)

140.2

Within Iron Hill 

Proposal = 3.4 ha (2%)

383.1

Within Iron Hill 

Proposal = 26.7 ha (7%)

771.3

Within Iron Hill 

Proposal = 19.0 ha (2%)

Table 3.1 ‐ Floristic Groups at Iron Hill

ecologia  1, 4 and 17

ecologia  16 ecologia  6

Photograph

A

Sandplain 

Shrublands

Eucalyptus kochii  sparse woodland over Melaleuca hamata, Acacia anthochaera  and Acacia ramulosa  shrubland over Dianella revoluta  herbs and Amphipogon caricinus  var. caricinus  tussock grasses

ecologia  2, 3

B

Sandplain 

Woodlands

Eucalyptus horistes  open woodland over Acacia ramulosa  and Cryptandra apetala  shrubland over Triodia scariosa  open hummock grassland

C2

Foothill Mallee 

Woodlands

QuadratsFloristic Group Desciption

Allocasuarina acutivalvis, Melaleauca nematophylla  and Grevillea obliquistigma  shrubland over Cheilanthes adiantoides  ferns

C1

Plain Woodlands

Eucalyptus loxophleba  subsp. supralaevis  and/or Eucalyptus kochii  subsp. amaryissa woodland over Acacia tetragonophylla, Acacia anthochaera, Acacia assimilis  subsp. assimilis, Eremophila clarkei,  and Ptilotus obovatus shrubland over Austrostipa elegantissima  tussock grasses

Eucalyptus loxophleba  subsp. supralaevis , Eucalyptus kochii  subsp. amaryissa  and/or Eucalyptus horistes mallee woodland over Acacia acuminata, Eremophila clarkei, Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsepiana, Philotheca brucei, Dodonaea inaequifolia  and Melaleuca hamata  shrubland over Austrostipa elegantissima  tussock grasses

E

Ironstone Outcrop 

Shrublands

Calycopeplus paucifolius, Acacia tetragonophylla  and Ptilotus obovatus open shrubland over Cheilanthes adiantoides  ferns and Austrostipa elegantissima  tussock grasses

K

Ironstone Hill 

Shrublands

16.7

Within Iron Hill 

Proposal = 4.3 ha (26%)

647.2

Within Iron Hill 

Proposal = 40.5 ha (6%)

Page 30: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Code Description

T9

Dense thicket of Acacia  species, Hakea  species, Eucalyptus brachycorys  and E. oldfieldii with emergent Callitris glaucophylla,  over low open shrubland of mixed species on sand

4

T9/M1 One quadrat is located on the boundary of these vegetation types 1

B

Eucalyptus horistes  open woodland over Acacia ramulosa  and Cryptandra apetala  shrubland over Triodia scariosa  open hummock grassland

M1

Open Tree Mallee of Eucalyptus brachycorys, E. hypochlamydea  subsp. hypochlamydea, E. loxophleba  subsp. supralaevis  and Callitris glaucophylla over Thicket of Acacia  species over Low Shrubland and Herbs on Loam

2

M1

Open Tree Mallee of Eucalyptus brachycorys, E. hypochlamydea  subsp. hypochlamydea, E. loxophleba  subsp. supralaevis  and Callitris glaucophylla over Thicket of Acacia  species over Low Shrubland and Herbs on Loam

4

T8Dense Thicket of Melaleuca  sp. Wongan Hills and Acacia ramulosa  over mixed 

species on loamy clay soil1

M1

Open Tree Mallee of Eucalyptus brachycorys, E. hypochlamydea  subsp. hypochlamydea, E. loxophleba  subsp. supralaevis  and Callitris glaucophylla over Thicket of Acacia  species over Low Shrubland and Herbs on Loam

1

M1/T3 One quadrat is located on the boundary of these vegetation types 1

T9

Dense Thicket of Acacia  species, Hakea  species, Eucalyptus brachycorys  and E. oldfieldii with emergent Callitris glaucophylla,  over low open shrubland of mixed species on sand

2

T10/W5 One quadrat is located on the boundary of these vegetation types 1

T3

Dense Thicket of Acacia assimilis, Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsepiana and Melaleuca nematophylla  over Low Shrubland of Hemigenia  sp. Pynes Find and Hibbertia crassifolia  in loam pockets in Jaspilite rocks

5

T5

Thicket of Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsepiana  and Grevillea obliquistigma with emergent Callitris glaucophylla  over Low Shrubland dominated by Darwinia masonii, Hibbertia crassifolia, Melaleuca radula  and Phylotheca brucei  subsp. brucei  over Open Herbs of Xanthosia bungei  in loam 

pockets in dense jaspilite rocks

2

T6

Thicket of Acacia aneura  and Acacia stowardii  over Low Shrubland of mixed 

species with large numnbers of Darwina masonii  in loam with abundant rocks 

on the surface

2

HS1Low Heath of Ptilotus obovatus  with emergent shrubs of Acacia stowardii  and Calycopeplus paucifolius  over Herbs in loamy clay amongst large boulders

2

W2

Dense to Open Woodland of Eucalyptus loxophleba  subsp. supralaevis with occassional Callitris glaucophylla  over a thicket of Acacia  species dominated 

by A. assimilis  over Herbs dominated at the time of survey by Velleia rosea  on silty sand

1

T1

Dense Thicket of mixed species dominated by Acacia  species, Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsepiana, Calycoopeplus paucifolius,  and Melaleuca nematophylla  over Low Shrubland in Jaspilite rocks with pockets of loam

39

T3

Dense Thicket of Acacia assimilis, Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsepiana and Melaleuca nematophylla  over Low Shrubland of Hemigenia  sp. Pynes Find and Hibbertia crassifolia  in loam pockets in Jaspilite rocks

13

T1/T3 Three quadrats are located on the boundary of these vegetation types 3

T5

Thicket of Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsepiana  and Grevillea obliquistigma with emergent Callitris glaucophylla  over Low Shrubland dominated by Darwinia masonii, Hibbertia crassifolia, Melaleuca radula  and Phylotheca brucei  subsp. brucei  over Open Herbs of Xanthosia bungei  in loam 

pockets in dense jaspilite rocks

3

T6

Thicket of Acacia aneura  and Acacia stowardii  over Low Shrubland of mixed 

species with large numnbers of Darwina masonii  in loam with abundant rocks 

on the surface

10

T12

Thicket of Acacia ramulosa  with emergent Eucalyptus oldfieldii  and Eucalyptus loxophleba  subsp. supralaevis  over a Low Shrubland over Herbs in loam with pebbles common on the surface

3

T1/T2 Two quadrats are located on the boundary of these vegetation types 2

M4

Very Open Woodland of Callitris glaucophylla  and Eucalyptus loxophleba subsp. supralaevis  over an Open Thicket of Acacia acuminata  over a Herbland in sandy loam

1

K

Allocasuarina acutivalvis, Melaleauca nematophylla  and Grevillea obliquistigma  shrubland over Cheilanthes adiantoides  ferns

Table 3.2 ‐ Floristic Group and Vegetation Mapping (Bennett 2000) Comparison

Eucalyptus kochii  sparse woodland over Melaleuca hamata, Acacia anthochaera  and Acacia ramulosa shrubland over Dianella revoluta  herbs and Amphipogon caricinus  var. caricinus  tussock grasses

A

Calycopeplus paucifolius, Acacia tetragonophylla  and Ptilotus obovatus  open shrubland over Cheilanthes adiantoides  ferns and Austrostipa elegantissima  tussock grasses

E

Vegetation Type (mapped by Bennett 2000) Floristic Group Description # Quadrats

Eucalyptus loxophleba  subsp. supralaevis  and/or Eucalyptus kochii  subsp. amaryissa woodland over Acacia tetragonophylla, Acacia anthochaera, Acacia assimilis  subsp. assimilis, Eremophila clarkei,  and Ptilotus obovatus  shrubland over Austrostipa elegantissima  tussock grasses

Eucalyptus loxophleba  subsp. supralaevis, Eucalyptus kochii  subsp. amaryissa  and/or Eucalyptus horistes mallee woodland over Acacia acuminata, Eremophila clarkei, Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsepiana, Philotheca brucei, Dodonaea inaequifolia  and Melaleuca hamata  shrubland over Austrostipa elegantissima tussock grasses

C1

C2

Page 31: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Code Description

T1

Dense Thicket of mixed species dominated by Acacia  species, Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsepiana, Calycoopeplus paucifolius, and Melaleuca nematophylla over Low Shrubland in Jaspilite rocks with pockets of loam

3

T3

Dense Thicket of Acacia assimilis, Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsepiana and Melaleuca nematophylla  over Low Shrubland of Hemigenia  sp. Pynes Find and Hibbertia crassifolia  in loam pockets in Jaspilite rocks

5

T6

Thicket of Acacia aneura and Acacia stowardii over Low Shrubland of mixed 

species with large numnbers of Darwina masonii  in loam with abundant rocks 

on the surface

1

T12

Thicket of Acacia ramulosa with emergent Eucalyptus oldfieldii and Eucalyptus loxophleba  subsp. supralaevis  over a Low Shrubland over Herbs in loam with 

pebbles common on the surface

3

T1/T2 Two quadrats are located on the boundary of these vegetation types 1

T1

Dense Thicket of mixed species dominated by Acacia  species, Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsepiana, Calycoopeplus paucifolius, and Melaleuca nematophylla over Low Shrubland in Jaspilite rocks with pockets of loam

31

T3

Dense Thicket of Acacia assimilis, Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsepiana and Melaleuca nematophylla  over Low Shrubland of Hemigenia  sp. Pynes Find and Hibbertia crassifolia  in loam pockets in Jaspilite rocks

4

T1/T3 Three quadrats are located on the boundary of these vegetation types 3

T1/T2 Two quadrats are located on the boundary of these vegetation types 1

T1

Dense Thicket of mixed species dominated by Acacia  species, Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsepiana, Calycoopeplus paucifolius, and Melaleuca nematophylla over Low Shrubland in Jaspilite rocks with pockets of loam

5

T3

Dense Thicket of Acacia assimilis, Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsepiana and Melaleuca nematophylla  over Low Shrubland of Hemigenia  sp. Pynes Find and Hibbertia crassifolia  in loam pockets in Jaspilite rocks

4

T5

Thicket of Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsepiana  and Grevillea obliquistigma with emergent Callitris glaucophylla  over Low Shrubland dominated by Darwinia masonii, Hibbertia crassifolia, Melaleuca radula and Phylotheca brucei  subsp. brucei  over Open Herbs of Xanthosia bungei  in loam 

pockets in dense jaspilite rocks

3

T6

Thicket of Acacia aneura and Acacia stowardii over Low Shrubland of mixed 

species with large numnbers of Darwina masonii  in loam with abundant rocks 

on the surface

9

M4

Very Open Woodland of Callitris glaucophylla and Eucalyptus loxophleba subsp. supralaevis  over an Open Thicket of Acacia acuminata over a Herbland in sandy loam

1

K3

Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsipeana , Grevillea obliquistigma  subsp. obliquistigma , Calycopeplus pauciflorus , Melaleuca nematophyla, Grevillea paradaoxa and Philotheca sericea  shrubland over Xanthosia kochii herbs and Cheilanthes adiantoides  ferns

K1

Calycopeplis pauciflorus , Leucopogon  sp. Clyde Hill, Philotheca sericea , Allocasuarina acutivalvis  subsp. prinsipeana , Eremophila clarkei , Grevillea paradoxa and Melaleuca nematophyla shrubland over Cheilanthes adiantoides  ferns

K2

Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsipeana, Melaleuca nematophyla, Grevillea obliquistigma subsp. obliquistigma, Aluta aspera, Acacia assimilis subsp. assimilis and Philotheca sericea shrubland over Cheilanthes adiantoides  ferns

Table 3.3 ‐ Floristic Subgroup and Vegetation Mapping (Bennett 2000) Comparison

Floristic 

SubgroupDescription

Vegetation Type (mapped by Bennett 2000) # Quadrats

Page 32: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

26

3.3 SURVEY LIMITATIONS

According to the EPA Guidance Statement (No. 51) for Terrestrial Flora and Vegetation Surveys for Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) in Western Australia (EPA 2004), flora and vegetation surveys may be limited in several respects. An assessment of this study against these aspects is provided in Table 3.3.

Table 3.4 – Survey limitations

Aspect Comment

Sources of information and availability of contextual information (i.e. pre-existing background versus new material)

Flora and Vegetation Assessments previously completed at Mt Gibson, include: • Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000): Flora and Vegetation of Mt Gibson; • Armstrong (2004): Vegetation Assessment and Rare Flora Search between Perenjori and Mt

Gibson; • ATA (2006b) Mt Gibson Magnetite Project Supplementary Vegetation and Flora Surveys; and • Meissner and Caruso (2008b) Flora and vegetation of banded iron formations of the Yilgarn

Craton: Mount Gibson and surrounding area. In addition, numerous targeted flora surveys have been conducted at Mount Gibson, in particular for the Threatened (Vulnerable) Darwinia masonii and Lepidosperma gibsonii.

The scope (i.e. what life forms were sampled?)

The vascular flora of the study area was sampled in accordance with Guidance Statement 51.

Proportion of flora collected and identified (based on sampling, timing and intensity)

From the 17 new quadrats of the 2015 survey, 115 vascular flora taxa were recorded, which is 62.5% of the (Chao 2) estimated richness of 176 taxa. When the 50 DEC quadrats (Meissner and Caruso 2008b) and 100 ATA (2006b) quadrats were included, the data from all 167 quadrats yielded 184 taxa (77.3%) of an estimated total 238 taxa (Chao 2 Classic incidence-based richness estimator).

Completeness and further work which might be needed (e.g. was the relevant area fully surveyed?)

Sixteen quadrats have now been sampled within the study area, and all areas have been searched for Threatened and Priority flora at approximately 50 m search grids or finer, either from this assessment or previously (Eco Logical (2014) Mount Gibson Ranges Darwinia masonii Census).

Mapping reliability Aerial imagery was available and the number and distribution of quadrats was considered adequate for definition of vegetation within the study area. Vegetation mapping information from previous surveys was made available by Mt Gibson Mining.

Timing/weather/ season/ cycle

The survey was conducted in late April/early May 2015, following above average rainfall (53.9 mm of rain recorded at Mt Gibson (BOM Station: 010075) in March and 25.8 mm in April. Approximately 50% of taxa were recorded with reproductive material.

Disturbances (e.g. fire, flood, accidental human intervention)

Some sections of the Iron Hill proposal have been burnt in 2003, but not since that date. Previous mining and exploration activities are also widespread in the study area, but quadrat locations were selected outside the area of these disturbances.

Intensity (in retrospect, was the intensity adequate?)

Quadrats were distributed across the Iron Hill proposal at a density of 1 quadrat per 7 ha. The species accumulation curve suggests that approximately 62.5% of the taxa expected to be present in the study area were recorded in the 2015 survey, and 76.6% when data from all 167 quadrats were included.

Resources A total of 8 person days was expended, providing comprehensive coverage of the study area and regional data from adjacent areas.

Access problems Existing exploration tracks throughout the study area provided excellent access, with all parts of the study area readily accessible.

Page 33: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

27

Aspect Comment

Experience levels (e.g. degree of expertise in plant identification to taxon level)

The project manager (Shaun Grein) has been involved in multiple botanical surveys at Mount Gibson and in the surrounding area, including: • ATA (2006a): Chamelaucium sp. Yalgoo Supplementary Survey – Mt Gibson; • ATA (2006b): Mt Gibson Magnetite Project Supplementary Vegetation and Flora; • ATA (2006c): Targeted Survey at Mt Gibson for a new Lepidosperma sp. Mt Gibson; • Coffey (2008a): Location of Darwinia masonii (DRF) Associated with Phase 1 Drill Pads –

Extension Hill; and • Coffey (2008b): Locations of Lepidosperma gibsonii. Dr Matthew Macdonald also has experience with Darwinia masonii Survival and Health Analysis (ecologia 2014), as well as experience on other BIF ranges of the Yilgarn Craton, such as Helena and Aurora Range, Jackson Range and Weld Range. John Grantham has previous experience in flora and vegetation assessments in WA, including in the Pilbara and South-west and well as experience on BIF ranges including Koolyanobbing Range.

Page 34: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

28

This page has been left blank intentionally.

Page 35: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

29

4 CONCLUSIONS With the inclusion of the 17 new quadrats surveyed in 2015 (eight within the proposed Iron Hill development envelope and nine in adjoining vegetation), five quadrats from Meissner and Caruso (2008b) and three from ATA (2006b) previously sampled, there are 16 quadrats within the proposed Iron Hill development envelope. This represents a high density of quadrats, approximately one quadrat every 7 hectares, which is considered sufficient to adequately describe the vegetation of the proposed Iron Hill development envelope. All quadrats from the proposed Iron Hill development envelope are 20 x 20 m in size and have been completed consistent with current guidelines.

The increased floristic sampling from quadrats and systematic transects in areas not previously covered in targeted flora searches provides satisfactory level of information for impact assessment on flora values of the proposed Iron Hill development envelope.

All six floristic units as defined in this analysis that are represented by quadrats within the Iron Hill development envelope are also represented by quadrats from outside the Iron Hill development envelope: • Floristic group A is represented across the sandplains to the west of Iron Hill, and is located

primarily within vegetation unit T9 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000). • Floristic group B is also represented across the sandplains to the west and south west of Iron

Hill, and is located within vegetation unit M1 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000). • Floristic group C1 is represented by quadrats on the colluvial plains west of Iron Hill, as well as

on similar landforms to the east of the Mt Gibson Ranges and near the Yandhanoo Hills. Most quadrats from this floristic group are located within vegetation unit M1 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000) and represents community 3 Meissner and Caruso (2008b).

• Floristic group C2 is represented on the footslopes west of Iron Hill, as well as on a similar low landforms to the east of Mt Gibson. Most quadrats from this floristic group are located within vegetation units M1 and T9 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), and also represents community 4 of Meissner and Caruso (2008b).

• Floristic group E is represented on the nearby ridges at ‘Iron Hill North’ and ‘Mount Gibson’, in addition to ‘Iron Hill’. In the vicinity of the Iron Hill proposal, this floristic group is located within vegetation unit T3 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), and also represents community 5 of Meissner and Caruso (2008b).

• Floristic group K is well represented across the ironstone ranges at ‘Extension Hill’, ‘Extension Hill North’, ‘Extension Hill South’, ‘Iron Hill North’, ‘Iron Hill East’, and ‘Mount Gibson North’ as well as at ‘Iron Hill’. In the vicinity of the Iron Hill proposal, this floristic group is located within vegetation unit T3 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), and also represents community 6 of Meissner and Caruso (2008b). Floristic Group K was further divided into three subgroups of very similar floristic composition: o Floristic subgroup K1 is largely associated with Iron Hill with four quadrats inside and

one just north of the Iron Hill development envelope, but there are also 6 quadrats on the north-east of Extension Hill and the remaining two quadrats are relatively isolated: one at Extension Hill South, and the other north of Mount Gibson. This floristic subgroup is is equivalent to a subset of vegetation T3 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000) and a subset of community 6 of Meissner and Caruso (2008b).

o Floristic subgroup K3 appears to be generally associated with the higher peaks of the hills (but with some exceptions) and often near the Group E quadrats which is restricted to the steepest, most unstable slopes of the range. The quadrats are widely distributed across the range at Extension Hill, Extension Hill South, Iron Hill, Iron Hill North, Mt Gibson and Mount Gibson South. This floristic subgroup is equivalent to vegetation unit

Page 36: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

30

T6 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000) and a subset of community 6 of Meissner and Caruso (2008b).

Three floristic groups (E, K and L) are considered to represent key components of the Priority 1 Mount Gibson Range vegetation complexes (banded ironstone formation) PEC, due to their association with ironstone range landforms. In the vicinity of Iron Hill, floristic groups E and K are approximately equivalent to the structural vegetation units T1 and T3 of Bennett Environmental Consulting (2000), which is also associated with the ironstone range, and equate to the DEC communities 5, 6 and 7 (Meissner and Caruso 2008b). Therefore the outer boundary of floristic groups E, K and L is considered to represent the key component of the PEC across the Mount Gibson Ranges.

Page 37: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

31

5 REFERENCES Pilbara Development Commision. 2010. Available at: www.pdc.wa.gov.au. Accessed

Armstrong. 2004. Vegetation assessment and rare flora search between Perenjori and Mt Gibson. Unpublished report by Paul Armstrong and Associates for Mount Gibson Mining Ltd.

ATA. 2004. Targeted Search at Mt Gibson for the Declared Rare Flora Darwinia masonii. Unpublished report prepared by ATA Environmental for Mount Gibson Mining Ltd.

ATA. 2006a. Chamelaucium sp. Yalgoo Supplementary Survey - Mt Gibson. Unpublished report by ATA Environmental for the Environmental Protection Authority on behalf of Mount Gibson Mining Ltd.

ATA. 2006b. Mt Gibson Magnetite Project Supplementary Vegetation and Flora Surveys. Unpublished report by ATA Environmental for Mount Gibson Mining Limited.

ATA. 2006c. Targeted Survey at Mt Gibson for a new Lepidosperma sp. Mt Gibson. Unpublished report prepared by ATA Environmental for Mount Gibson Mining Ltd.

Bennett Environmental Consulting. 2000. Flora and Vegetation of Mt Gibson. Unpublished report by Bennett Environmental Consulting Pty Ltd for Mount Gibson Iron Ltd.

BoM. 2016. Bureau of Meteorology. Available at: http://www.bom.gov.au. Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.

Borger, J. and Nicholls, I. 2013. Survey of Proposed Drill Lines in Tenement M59/339 at Extension Hill. Unpublished report prepared for Extension Hill Pty Ltd.

Coffey. 2008a. Location of Darwinia masonii (DRF) Associated with Phase 1 Drill Pads – Extension Hill. Unpublished report prepared by Coffey Environments Pty Ltd for Asia Iron Australia Pty Ltd.

Coffey. 2008b. Locations of Lepidosperma gibsonii. Unpublished report prepared by Coffey Environments Pty Ltd for Asia Iron Australia Pty Ltd.

Eco Logical. 2014. Mount Gibson Ranges Darwinia masonii Census. Unpublished report prepared by Eco Logical Australia Pty Ltd for Mount Gibson Mining Limited.

ecologia. 2014. Darwinia masonii Survival and Health Analysis. Unpublished report prepared by Ecologia Environmental Consultants Pty Ltd for Mount Gibson Mining Ltd.

EnviroWorks. 2012. Level 2 Flora and Vegetation Survey – Mummaloo. Report by EnviroWorks Consulting for Top Iron P/L.

EPA. 2004. Terrestrial flora and vegetation surveys for environmental impact assessment in Western Australia. Guidance for the Assessment of Environmental Factors No. 51. Environmental Protection Authority, Western Australia.

Globe. 2014. Iron Hill Deposit Assessment of the Threatened Taxa Category for Darwinia masonii using IUCN (2012) Criteria. Report prepared by Globe Environments Australia Pty Ltd for Mount Gibson Mining Ltd.

Griffin, E. A. 2005. Numerical analysis of floristic data in Mt Gibson area. Unpublished report by E. A. Griffin and Associates for ATA Environmental.

Knuckey, C. 2011. Effects of fire on shrubland vegetation of the semi-arid sandplains of Western Australia. BSc (Hons) thesis, Edith Cowan University, Perth.

Maia. 2014. Mt Gibson Ranges Targeted Darwinia masonii Survey. Unpublished report prepared by Maia Environmental Consultancy Pty Ltd for Mount Gibson Mining Ltd.

Page 38: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

32

Markey, A. S. and Dillon, S. J. 2008. Flora and vegetation of the banded ironstone formations of the Yilgarn Craton: the Central Tallering Land System. Conservation Science Western Australia. 7:121-149.

Markey, A. S. and Dillon, S. J. 2010. Flora and vegetation of the Banded Iron Formations of the Yilgarn Craton: Gullewa. Conservation Science Western Australia. 7:531-556.

Markey, A. S. and Dillon, S. J. 2011. Flora and vegetation of the banded iron formations of the Yilgarn Craton: Yalgoo. Conservation Science Western Australia. 8:113-136.

Martinick Bosch Sell. 2013. Targeted Flora Survey: Extension Hill Hematite Project, Midwest Region, Western Australia - Iron Hill and Gibson Hill Prospect Areas. Unpublished report prepared by Martinick Bosch Sell Pty Ltd for Mount Gibson Mining Ltd.

Martinick Bosch Sell. 2014. Extension Hill Hematite Operations Annual Declared Rare Flora Monitoring. Report prepared by Martinick Bosch Sell Pty Ltd for Mount Gibson Mining Ltd.

Meissner, R. and Caruso, Y. 2008a. Flora and vegetation of banded iron formations of the Yilgarn Craton: Koolanooka and Perenjori Hills. Conservation Science Western Australia. 7:73-88.

Meissner, R. and Caruso, Y. 2008b. Flora and vegetation of banded iron formations of the Yilgarn Craton: Mount Gibson and surrounding area. Conservation Science Western Australia. 7:105-120.

Muir Environmental. 1995. Observations on the presence and distribution of Rare Flora, especially Darwinia masonii, near Mt Gibson. Report prepared by Muir Environmental for Extension Hill Pty Ltd (Formerly as Asia Iron Ltd).

Trudgen, M. E. 1991. Vegetation Condition Scale. In: National Trust (WA) 1993 Urban Bushland Policy. National Trust of Australia (WA), Wildflower Society of WA (Inc.), and the Tree Society (Inc.), Perth, Western Australia.

van Etten, E. 2013. Mummaloo Project and Regional Vegetation Assessment. Report for EnviroWorks Consulting for Top Iron Pty Ltd.

Western Australian Herbarium. 1998-2016. FloraBase - The Western Australian Flora. Government of Western Australia Department of Parks and Wildlife. Available at: http://florabase.dpaw.wa.gov.au.

Page 39: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

33

APPENDIX A REGIONAL FLORISTIC ANALYSIS (VAN ETTEN)

Page 40: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

ORDINATION OF REGIONAL FLORISTIC DATA ‐ EXTENSION HILL, IRON HILL AND MT GIBSON BIFS IN RELATION TO OTHER NEARBY BIFS AND OTHER 

SURROUNDING VEGETATION 

By Eddie van Etten 

 

Resemblance: S17 Bray Curtis similarity

SiteMt GibsonExtension HillIron HillMummalooMt Gibson SurroundsGullewa BIFTallering BIFNorth of Mt Gibson BIFYalgoo BIFSandplainKoolanooka-Perenjori BIF

NN

NN

C

C

S

EEN C

C

C

C

CN

2D Stress: 0.18

Page 41: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site Codes: 

Mt Gibson:  ATA and DPaW quadrats on Mt Gibson BIF 

Extension Hill: ATA and DPaW quadrats on Extension Hill North BIF 

Iron Hill: ATA and DPaW quadrats on Iron Hill BIFs (East, North and South) 

Mummaloo: Enviroworks/Connell quadrats at Mummaloo BIF rise, south of Mt Gibson 

Mt Gibson Surrounds: ATA quadrats from 2006 survey to west of Mt Gibson and Extension Hill (mostly not BIF) 

Gullewa BIF: from DPaW quadrats in Gullewa area, west of Mt Gibson 

Tallering BIF: DPaW quadrats on Tallering land system to west of Mt Gibson 

North of Mt Gibson: ironstone hills and rises to north  and east of Extension Hill and Mt Gibson (including Mt Singleton and Yunhanoo Hills) 

Yalgoo BIF: DPaW quadrats BIFs in Yalgoo area to west of Mt Gibson 

Sandplain: Quadrats on sandplains in Mt Gibson area (from Knuckey Hons Study, ECU) 

Kookanooka‐Perenjori BIF: DPaW quadrats on BIFs in Kookanooka‐Perenjori area to west of Mt Gibson 

 

For Iron Hill quadrats – the follow letter indicate position:  N=north, S=south, C=central, E=east 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Page 42: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

References and further information on these surveys are included below: 

Author/ Consultant 

Report/Paper Details  Quadrats  Area  For‐mat 

Have?

Meissner & Caruso (2008) [DEC BIF study] 

Flora and vegetation of banded iron formations of the Yilgarn Craton: Mount Gibson and surrounding area. Conservation Science W Aust 7 (1) : 105–120 

50  20x20m  

Mt Gibson, Extension Hill & Iron Hills, and areas to north. Uplands and slopes only.  See below for sites  

Excel   Yes 

Markey & Dillon (2008) [DEC BIF study] 

Flora and vegetation of the banded iron formations of the Yilgarn Craton: the central Tallering Land System. Conservation Science W Aust 7 (1) : 121=149 

103 20x20m  Tallering BIF: Minjar‐Jasper Hill ‐ Blue Hills Range – Karara. Uplands and slopes only.   

Excel  Yes 

Meissner & Caruso (2008) [DEC BIF study] 

Flora and vegetation of banded iron formations of the Yilgarn Craton: Koolanooka and Perenjori Hills. Conservation Science Western Australia 7: 73–88  

50 20x20m 

Koolanooka – Perenjori Hills BIF 

Excel  Yes 

Markey & Dillon (2011) [DEC BIF study] 

Flora and vegetation of the banded iron formations of the Yilgarn Craton: Yalgoo, Conservation Science Western Australia 8: 113‐136. 

55 20x20m 

Yalgoo BIF: Gnows Nest Range, Wolla Wolla and Woolgah–Wadgingarra Hills 

Excel  Yes 

Page 43: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Markey & Dillon (2010) [DEC BIF study] 

Flora and vegetation of banded iron formations of the Yilgarn Craton: Koolanooka and Perenjori Hills. Conservation Science Western Australia 7: 531‐536 

50 20x20m 

Gullewa BIF: Buddadoo Range, Edamurta Range, Mugga Mugga Hill and Murdaburia Hill 

Excel  Yes 

EnviroWorks/S Connell (2012) 

Level 2 Flora and Vegetation Survey – Mummaloo – Report for Top Iron P/L 

98 10x10   Mummaloo Project Area (just south of Mt Gibson) 

Excel  Yes 

ATA Environmental (2006) 

Mt Gibson Magnetite Project Supplementary Vegetation and Flora Surveys 

76 30x30 

Mt Gibson mining area, but mostly in surrounds to west – not on BIF but some on lateritic slopes  

pdf*   Yes  

ATA (sourced from E.A. Griffin & Associates report)  

Numerical Analysis   100 20x20m Cover Perennials only 

Extension Hill, Iron Hills & Mt Gibson BIF and surrounds (20 km radius) Ridges and slopes of BIF See below for localities 

pdf*   Yes 

Knuckey 2011  Hons thesis ECU  53 20x20m Cover All Species 

Sandplain of region 

Excel  Yes 

 

Page 44: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

In summary, Mt Gibson BIFs are generally similar in floristics to Tallering BIFs, whereas Extension Hill and most of the Iron Hill quadrats are more similar to 

the BIFs of Koolanooka – Perenjori Hills, although there is some overlap (see grouping in middle of ordination) 

Also note that the ATA quadrats on Mt Gibson, Extension Hill and Iron Hill BIFs are distinct from the DPaW quadrats in the same area – they are grouped to 

the top‐left side of  ordination (see labelling of sites below – you may need to zoom in to read labels, but the ATA quadrats have a ‘G’ prefix). It is unclear 

why this is, but the ATA quadrats were floristically less rich than DPaWs (maybe sampled during dry spell?).  

 

Page 45: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

 

 

Resemblance: S17 Bray Curtis similarity

SiteMt GibsonExtension HillIron HillMummalooMt Gibson SurroundsGullewa BIFTallering BIFNorth of Mt Gibson BIFYalgoo BIFSandplainKoolanooka-Perenjori BIF

q1

q2q3

q4

q5

q6

q7

q8

q9

q10

q11q12

q13

q14

q15q16

q17q18

q19q20q21

q22

q23

q24

q25

q26

q27

q28 q29 q30q31 q32q33

q34

q35

q36

q37

q38

q39

q40

q41

q42

q43

q44

q45

q46

q47

q48q49

q50

q51

q52

q53

q54

q55

q56

q57

q58 q59q60q61

q62

q63

q64

q65

q66

q67

q68

q69

q70

q71

q72

q73

q74

q75

q76 q77

q78

q79

q80q81

q82

q83

q84q85

q86

q87

q88

q89q90

q91

q92

q93

q94

q95q96

q97q98

aq1aq2 aq3

aq4aq5

aq6

aq7ATAQ10A

ATAQ10B

ATAQ10CATAQ10D

ATAQ10E

ATAQ11A

ATAQ11B

ATAQ11CATAQ12A

ATAQ12B

ATAQ12C

ATAQ13A

ATAQ13B

ATAQ13C

ATAQ14AATAQ14B

ATAQ15A

ATAQ15B

ATAQ15C

ATAQ16A

ATAQ16B

ATAQ16CATAQ17AATAQ17B ATAQ17CATAQ18AATAQ18B

ATAQ18C

ATAQ19

ATAQ1AATAQ1B

ATAQ1C

ATAQ20A

ATAQ20B

ATAQ21

ATAQ22

ATAQ23 ATAQ24ATAQ25

ATAQ26

ATAQ27ATAQ28

ATAQ29

ATAQ2A

ATAQ2B

ATAQ2C

ATAQ2D

ATAQ30ATAQ31

ATAQ32

ATAQ33

ATAQ34

ATAQ35

ATAQ3A

ATAQ3B

ATAQ3C

ATAQ4AATAQ4B

ATAQ4C

ATAQ4DATAQ4E

ATAQ4F

ATAQ4G

ATAQ5A

ATAQ5B

ATAQ6A

ATAQ6B

ATAQ6C

ATAQ7A

ATAQ7B

ATAQ8AATAQ8B

ATAQ9AATAQ9B

ATAQ9C

ATAQ9D

BUDD01

BUDD02BUDD03 BUDD04BUDD05

BUDD06

BUDD07BUDD08

BUDD09

BUDD10

BUDD11BUDD12

BUDD13BUDD14

BUDD15

BUDD16

CAGA01

CAGA02

CHUL01

CHUL02

CHUL03

CHUL04

CHUL05

EDAM01

EDAM02

EDAM03

EDAM04

EDAM05

EDAM06

EDAM07

EDAM08EDAM09

EDAM10EDAM11

G1G10

G100

G11G12G13

G14

G15G16

G17

G18G19

G2

G20G21

G22

G23

G24

G25G26

G27G28

G29

G3

G30G31

G32

G33

G34

G35G36

G37

G38G39

G4

G40G41

G42G43

G44

G45

G46

G47G48

G49

G5

G50

G51

G52G53

G54 G55

G56

G57

G58

G59

G6

G60

G61

G62

G63

G64

G65

G66G67

G68G69

G7

G70

G71

G72G73

G74

G75

G76

G77G78G79

G8

G80

G81G82

G83

G84 G85

G86G87

G88

G89

G9

G90

G91

G92

G93

G94

G95

G96G97

G98G99

GNH01

GNH02

GNH03

GNH04

GNOW01

GNOW02

GNOW03

GNOW04

GNOW05

GNOW06

GNOW07

GNOW08

GNOW09 GNOW10

GNOW11

GNOW12

GNOW13GNOW14

GNOW15GNOW16

GNOW17

GNOW18GNOW19

GNOW20

GNOW21

GNOW22

GNOW23

GNOW24

GNOW25

JASP01

JASP02JASP03

JASP04

JASP05JASP06

JASP07

JOS2.1

JOS2.10.JOS2.11

JOS2.12

JOS2.13JOS2.14

JOS2.2JOS2.3

JOS2.4

JOS2.5

JOS2.6

JOS2.7

JOS2.8

JOS2.9

JOSFF2.1

JOSFF2.10

JOSFF2.11JOSFF2.12

JOSFF2.13

JOSFF2.2

JOSFF2.3

JOSFF2.4

JOSFF2.5

JOSFF2.6

JOSFF2.7

JOSFF2.8

JOSFF2.9

JOSFF3.1 JOSFF3.10

JOSFF3.2

JOSFF3.3

JOSFF3.4JOSFF3.5

JOSFF3.6

JOSFF3.7

JOSFF3.8

JOSFF3.9

KARA01

KARA02

KARA03

KARA04KARA05KARA06

KARA07

KARA08KARA09KARA10

KARA11KARA12KARA13

KARA14KARA15

KARA16

KARA17

KARA18KARA19

KARA20KARA21KOOL01

KOOL02

KOOL03

KOOL04KOOL05KOOL06

KOOL07

KOOL08

KOOL09 KOOL10KOOL11

KOOL12KOOL13

KOOL14

KOOL15 KOOL16 KOOL17

KOOL18KOOL19KOOL20

KOOL21KOOL22KOOL23

KOOL24

KOOL25

KOOL26KOOL27

KOOL28

KOOL29

KOOL30KOOL31

KOOL32

KOOL33KOOL34

KOOL35KOOL36

KOOL37

KOOL38

KOOL39KOOL40 KOOL41

MNJR01

MNJR02MNJR03

MNJR04

MNJR05

MNJR06

MNJR07

MNJR08

MNJR09

MNJR10

MNJR11MNJR12

MNJR13MNJR14

MNJR15

MNJR16

MNJR17

MNJR18

MNJR19

MNJR20

MNJR21

MNJR22

MNJR23

MNJR24

MNJR25

MNJR26

MNJR27

MTGB01MTGB02

MTGB03MTGB04

MTGB05

MTGB06

MTGB07

MTGB08MTGB09

MTGB10MTGB11

MTGB12

MTGB13

MTGB14MTGB15

MTGB16 MTGB17MTGB18

MTGB19

MTGB20

MTGB21

MTGB22

MTGB23

MTGB24MTGB25

MTGB26

MTGB27

MTGB28

MTGB29

MTGB30

MTGB31MTGB32

MUGG01

MUGG02

MUGG03

MUGG04

MUGG05

MUGG06

MUGG07

MUGG08MURD01

MURD02

MURD03

MURD04

MURD05

MURD06

MURD07

MURD08

MURD09

MURD10

MURD11

MURD12

MURD13

PERE01PERE02

PERE03

PERE04PERE05

PERE06

PERE07

PERE08

PERE09

PINY01

PINY02

PINY03

PINY04

PINY05PINY06

PINY07

PINY08

PINY09

qa23

qa43

qa49

RBFW01

REDH01

REDH02

REDH03

WADG01

WADG02WADG03

WADG04

WADG05

WADG06

WADG07

WADG08

WADG09

WADG10

WADG11

WADG12

WADG13

WADG14

WADG15

WADG16

WADG17WADG18

WADG19

WADG20

WADG21

WADG22WADG23

WADG24

WALA01

WALA02

WARR01

WARR02

WARR03

WARR04

WIND01

WIND02

WIND03 WIND04

WIND05

WIND06WIND07

WIND08

WIND09

WIND10

WIND11

WIND12

WIND13

WIND14

WIND15

WIND16

WIND17

WIND18

WIND19

WIND20

WOLL01

WOLL02

WOLL03

WOLL04WOLL05

WOLL06

WRHL01WRHL02

WRHL03

WRHL04WRHL05

WRHL06

WRHL07

WRHL08WRHL09

YAND01

YAND02

YAND03YAND04

YAND05

YAND06YAND07

YAND08

YAND09

2D Stress: 0.18

Page 46: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

40

This page has been left blank intentionally.

Page 47: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

41

APPENDIX B VASCULAR FLORA LIST

Page 48: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Appendix A ‐ Vascular Flora ListFamily Taxon Status ATA (2005) CALM (2005) ecologia  (2015) Analysis

Aizoaceae Cleretum papulosum Introduced •

Amaranthaceae Ptilotus drummondii • • • Yes

Amaranthaceae Ptilotus gaudichaudii var. gaudichaudii •

Amaranthaceae Ptilotus helipteroides   •   Yes

Amaranthaceae Ptilotus nobilis • • Yes

Amaranthaceae Ptilotus obovatus var. obovatus • • • Yes

Apiaceae Daucus glochidiatus • •

Apiaceae Hydrocotyle pilifera var. glabrata •

Apiaceae Hydrocotyle rugulosa •

Apiaceae Platysace trachymenioides • Yes

Apiaceae Trachymene cyanopetala •

Apiaceae Trachymene ornata • •

Apiaceae Trachymene pilosa •

Apiaceae Xanthosia kochii • • • Yes

Apocynaceae Alyxia buxifolia • • • Yes

Apocynaceae Rhyncharrhena linearis   •   Yes

Asparagaceae Arthropodium curvipes • •

Asparagaceae Arthropodium dyeri • •

Asparagaceae Chamaexeros macranthera • •   Yes

Asparagaceae Dichopogon capillipes •

Asparagaceae Dichopogon tyleri •

Asparagaceae Thysanotus manglesianus • •

Asparagaceae Thysanotus multiflorus •

Asparagaceae Thysanotus patersonii •

Asparagaceae Thysanotus pyramidalis •

Asphodelaceae Bulbine semibarbata •

Asteraceae Actinobole ?uliginosum •

Asteraceae Arctotheca calendula Introduced •

Asteraceae Asteraceae sp. •

Asteraceae Bellida graminea • •

Asteraceae Blennospora drummondii • •

Asteraceae Brachyscome iberidifolia •

Asteraceae Brachyscome perpusilla •

Asteraceae Brachyscome pusilla • •

Asteraceae Calocephalus multiflorus •

Asteraceae Calotis hispidula • •

Asteraceae Calotis multicaulis • •

Asteraceae Cephalipterum drummondii •

Asteraceae Ceratogyne obionoides •

Asteraceae Chthonocephalus pseudevax •

Asteraceae Cratystylis subspinescens •     Yes

Asteraceae Feldstonia nitens •

Asteraceae Gilberta tenuifolia •

Asteraceae Gilruthia osbornei •

Asteraceae Gnephosis tenuissima •

Asteraceae Helipterum craspedioides •

Asteraceae Hyalosperma cotula •

Asteraceae Hyalosperma demissum •

Asteraceae Hyalosperma glutinosum subsp. glutinosum •

Asteraceae Hyalosperma glutinosum subsp. venustum •

Asteraceae Hypochaeris glabra Introduced • •

Asteraceae Isoetopsis graminifolia •

Asteraceae Lawrencella davenportii •

Asteraceae Lawrencella rosea • •

Asteraceae Millotia myosotidifolia •

Asteraceae Myriocephalus guerinae • •

Asteraceae Myriocephalus pygmaeus • •

Asteraceae Olearia dampieri  • Yes

Asteraceae Olearia humilis • • • Yes

Asteraceae Olearia muelleri   • • Yes

Asteraceae Olearia pimeleoides   • • Yes

Asteraceae Podolepis canescens • •

Asteraceae Podolepis lessonii • •

Asteraceae Podotheca gnaphalioides •

Asteraceae Podotheca uniseta P3 •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe battii •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe charsleyae •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe chlorocephala •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe chlorocephala subsp. rosea •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe chlorocephala subsp. splendida •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe citrina •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe collina •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe laevis • •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe manglesii • •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe maryonii •

Page 49: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Appendix A ‐ Vascular Flora ListFamily Taxon Status ATA (2005) CALM (2005) ecologia  (2015) Analysis

Asteraceae Rhodanthe polycephala • •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe pygmaea •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe spicata •

Asteraceae Rhodanthe stricta •

Asteraceae Roebuckiella cheilocarpa •

Asteraceae Roebuckiella ciliocarpa •

Asteraceae Schoenia cassiniana • •

Asteraceae Schoenia filifolia subsp. filifolia • •

Asteraceae Senecio glossanthus •

Asteraceae Sonchus oleraceus Introduced • •

Asteraceae Sondottia connata •

Asteraceae Urosperma picroides •

Asteraceae Ursinia anthemoides •

Asteraceae Waitzia acuminata var. acuminata • •

Asteraceae Waitzia nitida •

Asteraceae Waitzia suaveolens var. suaveolens •

Boraginaceae Halgania integerrima •

Boryaceae Borya sphaerocephala •     Yes

Brassicaceae Brassica tournefortii Introduced •

Brassicaceae Carrichtera annua Introduced •

Brassicaceae Lepidium oxytrichum •

Brassicaceae Stenopetalum anfractum •

Brassicaceae Stenopetalum filifolium • •

Campanulaceae Lobelia winfridae •

Campanulaceae Wahlenbergia gracilenta •

Campanulaceae Wahlenbergia tumidifructa •

Casuarinaceae Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. prinsepiana • • • Yes

Casuarinaceae Allocasuarina campestris •     Yes

Celastraceae Psammomoya grandiflora • •   Yes

Celastraceae Stackhousia muricata •

Chenopodiaceae Chenopodiaceae sp. •

Chenopodiaceae Chenopodium melanocarpum •

Chenopodiaceae Enchylaena tomentosa var. tomentosa     • Yes

Chenopodiaceae Maireana georgei   •   Yes

Chenopodiaceae Maireana marginata • Yes

Chenopodiaceae Maireana thesioides     • Yes

Chenopodiaceae Maireana trichoptera • •   Yes

Chenopodiaceae Rhagodia drummondii •   • Yes

Chenopodiaceae Rhagodia sp. Watheroo (R.J. Cranfield & P.J. Spencer 8•83)   •   Yes

Chenopodiaceae Sclerolaena cuneata     • Yes

Chenopodiaceae Sclerolaena eriacantha • Yes

Chenopodiaceae Sclerolaena fusiformis   •   Yes

Chenopodiaceae Sclerolaena gardneri   2  

Colchicaceae Wurmbea densiflora • • •

Colchicaceae Wurmbea deserticola •

Crassulaceae Crassula closiana  •

Crassulaceae Crassula colorata var. acuminata •

Crassulaceae Crassula colorata var. colorata • •

Crassulaceae Crassula extrorsa •

Crassulaceae Crassula tetramera •

Cupressaceae Callitris columellaris • • • Yes

Cuscutaceae Cuscuta epithymum Introduced • •

Cyperaceae Lepidosperma costale •   Yes

Cyperaceae Lepidosperma gibsonii Threatened • Yes

Cyperaceae Schoenus nanus • •

Dilleniaceae Hibbertia acerosa •     Yes

Dilleniaceae Hibbertia aff. rostellata    •   Yes

Dilleniaceae Hibbertia ancistrophylla •     Yes

Dilleniaceae Hibbertia arcuata • • • Yes

Dilleniaceae Hibbertia crassifolia • Yes

Dilleniaceae Hibbertia glomerosa var. glomerosa   • • Yes

Dilleniaceae Hibbertia hypericoides • • • Yes

Dioscoreaceae Dioscorea hastifolia • Yes

Droseraceae Drosera andersoniana •

Droseraceae Drosera macrantha subsp. macrantha • • •

Ecdeiocoleaceae Ecdeiocolea monostachya • Yes

Ericaceae Leucopogon sp. Clyde Hill (M.A. Burgman •207) • • • Yes

Euphorbiaceae Calycopeplus paucifolius • • • Yes

Euphorbiaceae Euphorbia boophthona •

Euphorbiaceae Euphorbia tannensis subsp. eremophila •

Euphorbiaceae Poranthera microphylla •

Fabaceae Acacia acanthoclada •     Yes

Fabaceae Acacia acuaria • •   Yes

Fabaceae Acacia acuminata • • • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia andrewsii • • • Yes

Page 50: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Appendix A ‐ Vascular Flora ListFamily Taxon Status ATA (2005) CALM (2005) ecologia  (2015) Analysis

Fabaceae Acacia aneura • •   Yes

Fabaceae Acacia anthochaera   • • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia assimilis subsp. assimilis • • • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia cerastes  P• • •   Yes

Fabaceae Acacia colletioides   • • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia coolgardiensis subsp. effusa • •   Yes

Fabaceae Acacia effusifolia • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia erinacea •     Yes

Fabaceae Acacia exocarpoides • • • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia kochii •     Yes

Fabaceae Acacia longispinea     • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia neurophylla subsp. erugata • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia obtecta   • • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia oswaldii • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia quadrimarginea •     Yes

Fabaceae Acacia ramulosa var. ramulosa • • • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia sibina • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia sibirica   •   Yes

Fabaceae Acacia stereophylla var. stereophylla • •   Yes

Fabaceae Acacia tetragonophylla • • • Yes

Fabaceae Acacia umbraculiformis   •   Yes

Fabaceae Daviesia benthamii subsp. benthamii •

Fabaceae Gastrolobium laytonii • • • Yes

Fabaceae Leptosema aphyllum •     Yes

Fabaceae Mirbelia depressa •  

Fabaceae Mirbelia microphylla •

Fabaceae Mirbelia sp. Bursarioides (T.R. Lally 760) • • Yes

Fabaceae Senna artemisioides subsp. artemisioides •     Yes

Fabaceae Senna artemisioides subsp. filifolia   •   Yes

Fabaceae Senna charlesiana •   • Yes

Fabaceae Senna glutinosa subsp. chatelainiana • Yes

Fabaceae Senna glutinosa subsp. x luerssenii • Yes

Fabaceae Senna sp. Austin (A. Strid 202•0) • •   Yes

Fabaceae Senna stowardii •   • Yes

Fabaceae Trifolium capestre Introduced •

Geraniaceae Erodium cicutarium Introduced •

Geraniaceae Erodium cygnorum • • •

Goodeniaceae Brunonia australis • •

Goodeniaceae Goodenia ?peacockiana •

Goodeniaceae Goodenia berardiana • •

Goodeniaceae Goodenia corynocarpa •

Goodeniaceae Goodenia havilandii •

Goodeniaceae Goodenia mimuloides •

Goodeniaceae Goodenia occidentalis •

Goodeniaceae Goodenia pinifolia • Yes

Goodeniaceae Goodenia pinnatifida • •

Goodeniaceae Scaevola spinescens • • • Yes

Goodeniaceae Velleia cycnopotamica • •

Goodeniaceae Velleia hispidula •

Goodeniaceae Velleia rosea • •

Gyrostemonaceae Codonocarpus cotinifolius • Yes

Haloragaceae Glischrocaryon aureum •     Yes

Haloragaceae Glischrocaryon flavescens • Yes

Haloragaceae Gonocarpus nodulosus •

Haloragaceae Haloragis odontocarpa forma rugosa •

Haloragaceae Haloragis trigonocarpa •

Hemerocallidaceae Caesia sp. Wongan (K.F. Kenneally 8820) •

Hemerocallidaceae Dianella revoluta var. divaricata • • • Yes

Hemerocallidaceae Tricoryne elatior •

Hypoxidaceae Hypoxis occidentalis var. occidentalis •

Juncaginacae Triglochin isingiana •

Lamiaceae Hemigenia botryphylla     • Yes

Lamiaceae Hemigenia ciliata   • • Yes

Lamiaceae Hemigenia macphersonii • • • Yes

Lamiaceae Hemigenia sp. Yalgoo (A.M. Ashby 2624) • Yes

Lamiaceae Microcorys sp. Mt Gibson (S. Patrick 2098) • Yes

Lamiaceae Pityrodia teckiana •

Lamiaceae Prostanthera althoferi subsp. althoferi   • • Yes

Lamiaceae Prostanthera magnifica • •   Yes

Lamiaceae Prostanthera patens • • • Yes

Lauraceae Cassytha nodiflora • •   Yes

Loganiaceae Phyllangium sulcatum •

Loranthaceae Amyema gibberula var. tatei • Yes

Malvaceae Androcalva loxophylla • Yes

Malvaceae Androcalva luteiflora • • Yes

Page 51: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Appendix A ‐ Vascular Flora ListFamily Taxon Status ATA (2005) CALM (2005) ecologia  (2015) Analysis

Malvaceae Brachychiton gregorii • •   Yes

Malvaceae Keraudrenia velutina subsp. velutina •   • Yes

Malvaceae Sida atrovirens   •   Yes

Malvaceae Sida chrysocalyx • •   Yes

Malvaceae Sida sp. dark green fruits (S. van Leeuwen 2260)     • Yes

Malvaceae Sida sp. Excedentifolia (J.L. Egan •925) • Yes

Malvaceae Sida sp. Golden calyces (H.N.Foote 32) • Yes

Myrtaceae Aluta aspera subsp. hesperia • • • Yes

Myrtaceae Baeckea sp. Mt Gibson (R.Meissner & Y.Caruso •9)   •   Yes

Myrtaceae Baeckea sp. Wanarra (M.E. Trudgen MET 5376) • Yes

Myrtaceae Calothamnus gilesii • Yes

Myrtaceae Calytrix leschenaultii • Yes

Myrtaceae Darwinia masonii Threatened • • • Yes

Myrtaceae Enekbatus stowardii • • • Yes

Myrtaceae Eucalyptus horistes   • • Yes

Myrtaceae Eucalyptus kochii subsp. amaryssia   • • Yes

Myrtaceae Eucalyptus kochii subsp. plenissima • Yes

Myrtaceae Eucalyptus leptopoda subsp. leptopoda •

Myrtaceae Eucalyptus loxophleba subsp. supralaevis • • • Yes

Myrtaceae Eucalyptus oldfieldii • • • Yes

Myrtaceae Eucalyptus sp. •

Myrtaceae Malleostemon tuberculatus • Yes

Myrtaceae Melaleuca atroviridis • Yes

Myrtaceae Melaleuca conothamnoides x nematophylla •

Myrtaceae Melaleuca cordata • • Yes

Myrtaceae Melaleuca eleuterostachya   • • Yes

Myrtaceae Melaleuca fabri • • • Yes

Myrtaceae Melaleuca fulgens subsp. fulgens  •     Yes

Myrtaceae Melaleuca hamata   • • Yes

Myrtaceae Melaleuca leiocarpa • • • Yes

Myrtaceae Melaleuca nematophylla • • • Yes

Myrtaceae Melaleuca radula   • • Yes

Myrtaceae Melaleuca uncinata •     Yes

Myrtaceae Micromyrtus clavata •

Myrtaceae Micromyrtus racemosa • • Yes

Myrtaceae Micromyrtus trudgenii P3 • Yes

Myrtaceae Thryptomene costata  •     Yes

Myrtaceae Thryptomene cuspidata • Yes

Orchidaceae Caladenia flaccida •

Orchidaceae Caladenia latifolia •

Orchidaceae Cyanicula amplexans •

Orchidaceae Cyanicula sp. •

Orchidaceae Diuris porrifolia •

Orchidaceae Thelymitra ?petrophila •

Pittosporaceae Cheiranthera filifolia var. simplicifolia • •   Yes

Plantaginaceae Plantago aff. hispida (R.Meissner & Y.Caruso •2•) •

Poacaeae Amphipogon caricinus var. caricinus • • • Yes

Poacaeae Aristida contorta • •   Yes

Poacaeae Austrodanthonia caespitosa   • • Yes

Poacaeae Austrostipa blackii •

Poacaeae Austrostipa elegantissima • • • Yes

Poacaeae Austrostipa eremophila •

Poacaeae Austrostipa hemipogon •

Poacaeae Austrostipa nitida •

Poacaeae Austrostipa scabra •

Poacaeae Austrostipa sp. • •

Poacaeae Austrostipa trichophylla •

Poaceae Bromus arenarius •

Poaceae Elymus sp. • •   Yes

Poaceae Lachagrostis plebeia •

Poaceae Monachather paradoxus   • • Yes

Poaceae Neurachne alopecuroidea • Yes

Poaceae Pentameris airoides subsp. airoides Introduced • • • Yes

Poaceae Triodia scariosa     • Yes

Poaceae Vulpia muralis Introduced •

Polygalaceae Comesperma integerrimum • • • Yes

Portulacaceae Calandrinia baccata •

Portulacaceae Calandrinia eremaea • •

Portulacaceae Calandrinia sp. Bungalbin (G.J. Keighery & N. Gibson •656) •

Portulacaceae Calandrinia sp. Truncate capsules (A. Markey & S. Dillon 3474) •

Portulacaceae Calandrinia translucens •

Primulaceae Lysimachia arvensis Introduced •

Proteaceae Grevillea acacioides • Yes

Proteaceae Grevillea extorris • Yes

Proteaceae Grevillea hakeoides subsp. stenophylla • Yes

Page 52: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Appendix A ‐ Vascular Flora ListFamily Taxon Status ATA (2005) CALM (2005) ecologia  (2015) Analysis

Proteaceae Grevillea hookeriana subsp hookeriana •

Proteaceae Grevillea juncfolia subsp. temulenta • Yes

Proteaceae Grevillea obliquistigma subsp. obliquistigma • • • Yes

Proteaceae Grevillea paradoxa • • • Yes

Proteaceae Grevillea pityophylla • Yes

Proteaceae Grevillea sarissa subsp. sarissa • Yes

Proteaceae Grevillea scabrida P• •     Yes

Proteaceae Grevillea sp. • Yes

Proteaceae Hakea minyma     • Yes

Proteaceae Hakea preissii •     Yes

Proteaceae Hakea recurva   • • Yes

Proteaceae Persoonia manotricha •

Proteaceae Persoonia pentasticha P3 •

Proteaceae Persoonia sp.   •   Yes

Pteridiacae Cheilanthes adiantoides • • • Yes

Pteridiacae Cheilanthes sieberi subsp. sieberi • • •

Ranunculaceae Clematis linearifolia • Yes

Rhamnaceae Cryptandra apetala var. apetala •

Rhamnaceae Cryptandra connata •   • Yes

Rubiaceae Opercularia vaginata • Yes

Rutaceae Phebalium tuberculosum •

Rutaceae Philotheca brucei subsp. brucei • • • Yes

Rutaceae Philotheca deserti subsp. deserti • Yes

Rutaceae Philotheca sericea • • • Yes

Rutaceae Philotheca thryptomenoides   • Yes

Rutaceae Philotheca tomentella • Yes

Santalaceae Exocarpos aphyllus     • Yes

Santalaceae Santalum acuminatum   •   Yes

Santalaceae Santalum spicatum • • • Yes

Sapindaceae Dodonaea inaequifolia • • • Yes

Sapindaceae Dodonaea sp. Ninghan (H. Demarz 5•••)   •   Yes

Scrophulariaceae Eremophila clarkei • • • Yes

Scrophulariaceae Eremophila eriocalyx • Yes

Scrophulariaceae Eremophila forrestii subsp. forrestii • •   Yes

Scrophulariaceae Eremophila georgei •     Yes

Scrophulariaceae Eremophila glutinosa • Yes

Scrophulariaceae Eremophila granitica     • Yes

Scrophulariaceae Eremophila latrobei subsp. latrobei • • • Yes

Scrophulariaceae Eremophila oldfieldii subsp. angustifolia • •   Yes

Scrophulariaceae Eremophila oppositifolia •     Yes

Scrophulariaceae Eremophila serrulata • Yes

Scrophulariaceae Eremophila sp. •

Scrophulariaceae Zaluzianskya divaricata •

Solanaceae Anthocercis anisantha •

Solanaceae Nicotiana rosulata •

Solanaceae Nicotiana rotundifolia •

Solanaceae Solanum ellipticum   •   Yes

Solanaceae Solanum lasiophyllum • • • Yes

Solanaceae Solanum nummularium • Yes

Solanaceae Solanum orbiculatum subsp. orbiculatum  •

Stylidiaceae Stylidium confluens • • • Yes

Thymelaeaceae Pimelea avonensis • •   Yes

Thymelaeaceae Pimelea microcephala •

Urticaceae Parietaria cardiostegia • • Yes

Zygophyllaceae Zygophyllum eremaeum • •

Zygophyllaceae Zygophyllum ovatum •

Zygophyllaceae Zygophyllum tesquorum •

Page 53: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

47

APPENDIX C QUADRAT DESCRIPTIONS

Page 54: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 1Date: 30/04/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0515504 6725261Habitat: Undulating PlainSlope: Negligible; Surface Layer: Loose; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sandy‐Clay; Rock Type: No Rocks; Rock Size: No Rocks; Rock Abundance: None (0%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 4%

Taxa:Acacia anthochaeraAcacia ramulosa var. ramulosaAmphipogon caricinus var. caricinusAsteraceae sp.Dianella revolutaEnekbatus stowardiiEucalyptus kochii subsp. plenissimaHakea minymaMelaleuca leiocarpaPhilotheca deserti subsp. desertiWurmbea densiflora

Page 55: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 2Date: 30/04/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0515940 6725285Habitat: Undulating PlainSlope: Negligible; Surface Layer: Loose; Crust; Soil Colour: Red; Orange; Soil Texture: Sand; Rock Type: No Rocks; Rock Size: No Rocks; Rock Abundance: None (0%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 3%

Taxa:Acacia anthochaeraAcacia ramulosa var. ramulosaAsteraceae sp.Erodium sp.Eucalyptus kochii subsp. amaryssiaEucalyptus sp. Melaleuca eleuterostachyaMelaleuca hamataMicrocorys sp. Mt Gibson (S. Patrick 2098)

Page 56: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 3Date: 30/04/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0516151 6725485Habitat: Low RiseSlope: Gentle; Surface Layer: Loose; Crust; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sand; Rock Type: Ironstone; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Rock Abundance: Few (<10%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 2%

Taxa:Acacia anthochaeraAcacia longispineaAcacia ramulosa var. ramulosaAllocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. acutivalvisAmphipogon caricinus var. caricinusAsteraceae sp.Baeckea sp. Wanarra (M.E. Trudgen MET 5376)Dianella revolutaEcdeiocolea monostachyaEnekbatus stowardiiEucalyptus kochii subsp. amaryssiaEucalyptus kochii subsp. plenissimaGrevillea juncifolia subsp. temulentaHakea minymaHemigenia botryphyllaHibbertia glomerosa var. glomerosaMelaleuca hamataThysanotus manglesianus

Page 57: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 4Date: 29/04/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0516282 6725157Habitat: Hillslope ‐ FootslopeSlope: Gentle; Surface Layer: Crust; Gravel; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sandy‐Clay; Rock Type: Ironstone; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Rock Abundance: Common (10‐30%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 1%

Taxa:Acacia anthochaeraAcacia longispineaAcacia ramulosa var. ramulosaAluta aspera subsp. hesperiaAsteraceae sp.Cheilanthes sieberi subsp. sieberiDianella revolutaEnekbatus stowardiiEucalyptus kochii subsp. amaryssiaMelaleuca fabriMelaleuca hamata

Page 58: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 5Date: 30/04/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0516507 6724568Habitat: Undulating PlainSlope: Negligible; Surface Layer: Crust; Soil Colour: Orange; Brown; Soil Texture: Sandy‐Clay; Rock Type: Ironstone; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Rock Abundance: Common (10‐30%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 3%

Taxa:Acacia acuminataAcacia andrewsiiAcacia anthochaeraAcacia tetragonophyllaAlyxia buxifoliaAmphipogon caricinus var. caricinusAsteraceae sp.Austrostipa elegantissimaCheilanthes adiantoidesChenopodiaceae sp.Comesperma integerrimumEremophila graniticaEucalyptus loxophleba subsp. supralaevisExocarpos aphyllusHakea recurvaMaireana thesioidesMonachather paradoxusOlearia humilisOlearia muelleriProstanthera althoferi subsp. althoferiPtilotus obovatusPtilotus sp.Scaevola spinescensSclerolaena cuneataSenna stowardiiThysanotus manglesianusWurmbea densiflora

Page 59: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 6Date: 30/04/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0516148 6724391Habitat: Undulating PlainSlope: Negligible; Surface Layer: Crust; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sand; Rock Type: No Rocks; Rock Size: No Rocks; Rock Abundance: None (0%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 8%

Taxa:Acacia acuminataAcacia anthochaeraAcacia anthochaeraAcacia colletioidesAcacia ramulosa var. ramulosaAmphipogon caricinus var. caricinusAsteraceae sp.Cheilanthes adiantoidesCryptandra apetalaEnekbatus stowardiiEremophila graniticaEucalyptus ?horistesHemigenia botryphyllaHibbertia arcuataThysanotus manglesianusTriodia scariosa

Page 60: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 7Date: 30/04/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0516678 6724297Habitat: Undulating PlainSlope: Negligible; Surface Layer: Crust; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sand; Rock Type: Ironstone; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Rock Abundance: Few (<10%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 2%

Taxa:Acacia anthochaeraAcacia assimilis subsp. assimilisAcacia obtectaAcacia ramulosa var. ramulosaAcacia tetragonophyllaAlyxia buxifoliaAmphipogon caricinus var. caricinusAustrostipa elegantissimaCallitris columellarisCheilanthes adiantoidesDianella revolutaEremophila sp.Erodium sp.Hakea recurvaHemigenia ?macphersoniiHemigenia botryphyllaMonachather paradoxusOlearia humilisOlearia pimeleoidesProstanthera althoferi subsp. althoferiSantalum spicatumScaevola spinescensSida sp. dark green fruits (S. van Leeuwen 2260)

Page 61: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 8Date: 1/05/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0516690 6725380Habitat: Hillslope ‐ RidgetopSlope: Moderate; Surface Layer: Rocky/Stony; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sandy‐Clay; Rock Type: Ironstone; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Boulders (can't pick up); Rock Abundance: Continuous (>70%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 2%

Taxa:Acacia effusifoliaAcacia exocarpoidesActinobole ?uliginosumAmanita carneiphyllaAmphipogon caricinus var. caricinusAsteraceae sp.Austrostipa elegantissimaCalycopeplus paucifoliusCheilanthes sieberi subsp. sieberiDarwinia masoniiDodonaea inaequifoliaEremophila clarkeiEremophila latrobei subsp. latrobeiGrevillea ?juncifoliaHakea recurvaHibbertia hypericoidesMonachather paradoxusPhilotheca brucei subsp. bruceiPhilotheca sericeaPtilotus obovatusSida sp. dark green fruits (S. van Leeuwen 2260)Sida sp. Golden calyces glabrous (H.N. Foote 32)

Page 62: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 9Date: 1/05/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0516941 6725414Habitat: Hillslope ‐ MidslopeSlope: Gentle; Surface Layer: Crust; Rocky/Stony; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sandy‐Clay; Rock Type: Ironstone; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Other; Rock Abundance: Common (10‐30%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 3%

Taxa:Acacia acuminataAcacia exocarpoidesAcacia ramulosa var. ramulosaAllocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. acutivalvisAluta aspera subsp. hesperiaAsteraceae sp.Cheilanthes adiantoidesDarwinia masoniiDodonaea inaequifoliaDodonaea inaequifoliaEremophila clarkeiEremophila latrobei subsp. latrobeiGrevillea obliquistigma subsp. obliquistigmaGrevillea paradoxaHemigenia ciliataHemigenia macphersoniiLeucopogon sp. Clyde Hill (M.A. Burgman 1207)Melaleuca nematophyllaMicromyrtus racemosaOlearia humilisPhilotheca sericeaProstanthera patensScaevola spinescensSida sp. dark green fruits (S. van Leeuwen 2260)Solanum lasiophyllumWurmbea ?densifloraXanthosia kochii

Page 63: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 10Date: 1/05/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0517069 6725109Habitat: Hillslope ‐ MidslopeSlope: Moderate; Surface Layer: Crust; Rocky/Stony; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sandy‐Clay; Rock Type: Ironstone; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Rock Abundance: Common (10‐30%)Vegetation Condition: Very Good (slight disturbance)Disturbance Type: Mining Activities; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 3%

Taxa:Allocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. acutivalvisAsteraceae sp.Calycopeplus paucifoliusDarwinia masoniiDodonaea inaequifoliaEremophila clarkeiEremophila latrobei subsp. latrobeiEucalyptus oldfieldiiGrevillea obliquistigma subsp. obliquistigmaGrevillea paradoxaHemigenia ciliataHibbertia glomerata subsp. glomerataLeucopogon sp. Clyde Hill (M.A. Burgman 1207)Micromyrtus racemosaOlearia humilisPhilotheca brucei subsp. bruceiProstanthera althoferi subsp. althoferiThysanotus manglesianusXanthosia kochii

Page 64: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 11Date: 1/05/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0517144 6724986Habitat: Rocky OutcropSlope: Moderate; Surface Layer: Crust; Rocky/Stony; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sandy‐Clay; Rock Type: Ironstone; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Other; Rock Abundance: Common (10‐30%)Vegetation Condition: Very Good (slight disturbance)Disturbance Type: Mining Activities; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 2%

Taxa:Acacia acuminataAcacia assimilis subsp. assimilisAcacia exocarpoidesAllocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. acutivalvisAmphipogon caricinus var. caricinusAsteraceae sp.Austrodanthonia sp.Calycopeplus paucifoliusCheilanthes adiantoidesComesperma integerrimumDarwinia masoniiDodonaea inaequifoliaEremophila clarkeiEremophila latrobei subsp. latrobeiGrevillea obliquistigma subsp. obliquistigmaHemigenia macphersoniiHibbertia hypericoidesLeucopogon sp. Clyde Hill (M.A. Burgman 1207)Melaleuca nematophyllaMelaleuca radulaMicromyrtus racemosaParietaria cardiostegiaPentameris airoidesPhilotheca brucei subsp. bruceiPhilotheca sericeaXanthosia kochii

Page 65: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 12Date: 30/04/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0517239 6724478Habitat: Hillslope ‐ FootslopeSlope: Gentle; Surface Layer: Loose; Crust; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sandy‐Clay; Rock Type: Ironstone; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Rock Abundance: Few (<10%)Vegetation Condition: Very Good (slight disturbance)Disturbance Type: Vehicle Tracks; Mining Activities; Time Since Fire: 2‐5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 5%

Taxa:Acacia acuminataAcacia assimilis subsp. assimilisAcacia ramulosa var. ramulosaAllocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. acutivalvisAmphipogon caricinus var. caricinusAsteraceae sp.Cheilanthes adiantoidesDodonaea inaequifoliaEremophila clarkeiEremophila graniticaEucalyptus kochii subsp. amaryssiaGrevillea obliquistigma subsp. obliquistigmaGrevillea paradoxaHibbertia glomerosa var. glomerosaLeucopogon sp. Clyde Hill (M.A. Burgman 1207)Micromyrtus racemosaOlearia pimeleoidesPhilotheca brucei subsp. bruceiPimelea microcephalaProstanthera althoferi subsp. althoferiWurmbea densifloraXanthosia kochii

Page 66: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 13Date: 30/04/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0516914 6724671Habitat: Undulating PlainSlope: Gentle; Surface Layer: Crust; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sandy‐Clay; Rock Type: Ironstone; Quartz; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Rock Abundance: Few (<10%)Vegetation Condition: Very Good (slight disturbance)Disturbance Type: Vehicle Tracks; Litter; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 3%

Taxa:Acacia anthochaeraChenopodiaceae sp.Comesperma integerrimumEnchylaena tomentosa var. tomentosaEremophila clarkeiErodium sp.Eucalyptus loxophleba subsp. supralaevisExocarpos aphyllusMaireana thesioidesMaireana thesioidesOlearia pimeleoidesSclerolaena cuneataSenna charlesianaWurmbea ?densifloraZygophyllum ?eremaeum

Page 67: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 14Date: 30/04/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0516690 6724899Habitat: Hillslope ‐ FootslopeSlope: Gentle; Moderate; Surface Layer: Crust; Cracking Clay; Soil Colour: Red; Orange; Soil Texture: Sandy‐Clay; Rock Type: Ironstone; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Rock Abundance: Few (<10%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 5%

Taxa:Acacia acuminataAcacia andrewsiiAllocasuarina acutivalvis subsp. acutivalvisAsteraceae sp.Cheilanthes adiantoidesDodonaea inaequifoliaEremophila clarkeiEucalyptus loxophleba subsp. supralaevisHemigenia macphersoniiMelaleuca hamataMelaleuca leiocarpaPhilotheca brucei subsp. bruceiScaevola spinescensSida sp. dark green fruits (S. van Leeuwen 2260)Thysanotus manglesianusWurmbea densiflora

Page 68: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 15Date: 30/04/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0517003 6724075Habitat: Undulating PlainSlope: Negligible; Surface Layer: Crust; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sandy‐Clay; Rock Type: Ironstone; Quartz; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Rock Abundance: Few (<10%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 4%

Taxa:Acacia andrewsiiAcacia anthochaeraAcacia assimilis subsp. assimilisAcacia tetragonophyllaAlyxia buxifoliaAustrostipa elegantissimaChenopodiaceae sp.Enchylaena tomentosa var. tomentosaEremophila eriocalyxEremophila graniticaEremophila graniticaErodium sp.Eucalyptus kochii subsp. plenissimaExocarpos aphyllusHakea recurvaMaireana thesioidesMelaleuca eleuterostachyaOlearia pimeleoidesPlatysace trachymenioidesPtilotus obovatusRhagodia drummondiiScaevola spinescensSclerolaena eriacanthaSenna charlesiana

Page 69: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 16Date: 1/05/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0515328 6725127Habitat: Undulating PlainSlope: Negligible; Surface Layer: Crust; Soil Colour: Orange; Soil Texture: Sand; Rock Type: No Rocks; Rock Size: No Rocks; Rock Abundance: None (0%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 4%

Taxa:Acacia ramulosa var. ramulosaAcacia sibinaAmphipogon caricinus var. caricinusAsteraceae sp.Comesperma integerrimumCryptandra apetala var. apetalaEucalyptus ?horistesHakea minymaPhilotheca sericeaStylidium sp.Thysanotus manglesianusTriodia scariosa

Page 70: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Site: 17Date: 1/05/2015Botanist: Matthew Macdonald/John GranthamQuadrat Size: 20 X 20 mNorth‐west Corner: 50J 0515080 6725181Habitat: Undulating PlainSlope: Negligible; Surface Layer: Crust; Soil Colour: Orange; Yellow; Soil Texture: Sand; Rock Type: Ironstone; Rock Size: Gravel/Pebble; Stones (can pick up); Rock Abundance: Few (<10%)Vegetation Condition: Excellent (no obvious disturbance)Disturbance Type: No Disturbance; Time Since Fire: > 5 years; Leaf Litter Cover: 1%

Taxa:Acacia anthochaeraAcacia longispineaAcacia ramulosa var. ramulosaAsteraceae sp.Dianella revolutaEnekbatus stowardiiEucalyptus kochii subsp. plenissimaHakea minymaMelaleuca eleuterostachya

Page 71: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

65

APPENDIX D RANGE EXTENSION AND RANGE EDGE TAXA

Page 72: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Appendix C ‐ Mt Gibson Iron Hill Range Extensions  

 

 

 

 

 

 

Page 73: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Appendix C ‐ Mt Gibson Iron Hill Range Edge Taxa  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Page 74: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Appendix C ‐ Mt Gibson Iron Hill Range Edge Taxa  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Page 75: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

69

APPENDIX E VOUCHER SPECIMENS

Page 76: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Appendix E ‐ Herbarium Voucher SpecimensSpecimen Code Taxon Collector Date Significance Coordinate System Easting Northing

1639‐09‐27 Hemigenia macphersonii  Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Extension GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516941 6725414

1639‐11‐18 Hemigenia macphersonii  Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Extension GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517144 6724986

1639‐14‐09 Hemigenia macphersonii  Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 30‐Apr‐15 Range Extension GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516690 6724899

1639‐08‐01 Hibbertia hypericoides Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Extension GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516690 6725380

1639‐11‐14 Hibbertia hypericoides Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Extension GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517144 6724986

1639‐7‐22 Hibbertia hypericoides Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 30‐Apr‐15 Range Extension GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516678 6724297

1639‐15‐23 Sclerolaena  eriacantha  Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 30‐Apr‐15 Range Extension GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517003 6724075

1639‐15‐16 Eremophila eriocalyx Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 30‐Apr‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517003 6724075

1639‐02‐07 Eucalyptus kochii  subsp. amaryssia Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 30‐Apr‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 515940 6725285

1639‐03‐15 Eucalyptus kochii  subsp. amaryssia Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 30‐Apr‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516151 6725485

1639‐04‐11 Eucalyptus kochii  subsp. amaryssia Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 29‐Apr‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516282 6725157

1639‐12‐06 Eucalyptus kochii  subsp. amaryssia Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 30‐Apr‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517239 6724478

1639‐09‐06 Leucopogon  sp.  Clyde Hill (M.A. Burgman 1207) Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516941 6725414

1639‐10‐07 Leucopogon  sp.  Clyde Hill (M.A. Burgman 1207) Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517069 6725109

1639‐11‐23 Leucopogon  sp.  Clyde Hill (M.A. Burgman 1207) Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517144 6724986

1639‐12‐20 Leucopogon  sp.  Clyde Hill (M.A. Burgman 1207) Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 30‐Apr‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517239 6724478

1639‐MJM14 Mirbelia sp. Bursarioides (T.R. Lally 760) Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 2‐May‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517090 6724579

1639‐08‐06 Philotheca sericea Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516690 6725380

1639‐09‐03 Philotheca sericea Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516941 6725414

1639‐11‐05 Philotheca sericea Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517144 6724986

1639‐16‐05 Philotheca sericea Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 515328 6725127

1639‐05‐08 Prostanthera althoferi  subsp. althoferi Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 30‐Apr‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516507 6724568

1639‐07‐21 Prostanthera althoferi  subsp. althoferi Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 30‐Apr‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516678 6724297

1639‐10‐05 Prostanthera althoferi  subsp. althoferi Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517069 6725109

1639‐12‐04 Prostanthera althoferi  subsp. althoferi Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 30‐Apr‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 517239 6724478

1639‐09‐26 Protanthera patens Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516941 6725414

1639‐08‐08 Sida  sp. Golden calyces glabrous (H.N. Foote 32) Matthew Macdonald/John Grantham 1‐May‐15 Range Edge GDA 1994 MGA Zone 50 516690 6725380

Page 77: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

71

APPENDIX F FLORISTIC TWO-WAY TABLE

Page 78: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore

Mount Gibson Mining Iron Hill Flora and Vegetation Assessment Based on Regional and Local Floristic Analyses

March 2016

72

This page has been left blank intentionally.

Page 79: MARCH 2016 - EPA WA · Mount Gibson Mining Limited is seeking to obtain environmental approvals for the operational expansion of hematite production from its Mount Gibson Iron Ore