Mapping the European TEL Project Landscape Using Social Network Analysis and Advanced Query...
-
Upload
michael-derntl -
Category
Education
-
view
1.892 -
download
3
description
Transcript of Mapping the European TEL Project Landscape Using Social Network Analysis and Advanced Query...
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-1
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Mapping the European TEL Project
Landscape Using Social Network Analysis
and Advanced Query Visualization
M. Derntl, D. Renzel, R. Klamma
Information Systems and Databases
RWTH Aachen University, Aachen, Germany
ADVTEL @ ECTEL 2011 September 20, 2011 Palermo, Sicily
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-2
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Work context
Mapping and roadmapping for TEL
Understanding the current TEL landscape
Finding strong and weak signals for change at different
levels
Different methods, e.g. Delphi, Community modeling,
Text analysis, Visual analytics, etc.
Here: Social network analysis and visualization
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-3
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
TEL-Map Mediabase
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-4
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Component Layers
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-5
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
SNA and TM in TEL sources
Social Network Analysis Topic Mining
TEL
Papers
•Most central authors in TEL
•Most frequent collaborations on TEL papers
•Most important TEL conferences and journals
•Development characteristics of authorship
networks in TEL conferences.
•Rising and falling terms in TEL paper
abstracts and keywords
•Co-occurrence of topics in TEL papers
•Topics addressed by most important
TEL authors/papers
TEL
Projects
•Consortium progression between projects
•Partner collaborations across TEL projects
•Most central organizations in TEL projects
•Most central TEL projects
•Development of SNA metrics in project
collaboration network over time
•Topic distribution and shifts in TEL
project foci over time
•Funding and partners related to topics
in TEL projects
TEL
Media
•Citation network in TEL blogs
•Most central web sources referenced in TEL blogs
•Authorities and hubs in the TEL blogosphere
•Co-occurrence of words/bursts in blog entries
•Topic bursts in TEL blogs over time
•Topic shifts in TEL blogs over time
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-6
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Main
source:
CORDIS
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-7
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
TEL Projects – Data model
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-8
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Data set
Progr. Call # Projects (acronyms)
ECP
Call 2005 4 CITER, JEM, MACE, MELT
Call 2006 7 COSMOS, EdReNe, EUROGENE, eVip, Intergeo, KeyToNature, Organic.Edunet
Call 2007 3 ASPECT, iCOPER, EduTubePlus
Call 2008 5 LiLa, Math-Bridge, mEducator, OpenScienceResources, OpenScout
FP6
IST-2002-
2.3.1.12a8
CONNECT, E-LEGI, ICLASS, KALEIDOSCOPE, LEACTIVEMATH, PROLEARN,
TELCERT, UNFOLD
IST-2004-
2.4.10b14
APOSDLE, ARGUNAUT, ATGENTIVE, COOPER, ECIRCUS, ELEKTRA, I-MAESTRO,
KP-LAB, L2C, LEAD, PALETTE, PROLIX, RE.MATH, TENCOMPETENCE
IST-2004-
2.4.13c10
ARISE, CALIBRATE, ELU, EMAPPS.COM, ICAMP, LOGOS, LT4EL, MGBL, UNITE,
VEMUS
FP7
ICT-2007.4.1d 6 80DAYS, GRAPPLE, IDSPACE, LTFLL, MATURE, SCY
ICT-2007.4.3d 7 COSPATIAL, DYNALEARN, INTELLEO, ROLE, STELLAR, TARGET, XDELIA
ICT-2009.4.2b 13ALICE, ARISTOTELE, ECUTE, GALA, IMREAL, ITEC, METAFORA, MIROR,
MIRROR, NEXT-TELL, SIREN, TEL-MAP, TERENCE
Total: 77a … Technology-enhanced learning and access to cultural heritage”b … Technology-Enhanced Learning
c … Strengthening the Integration of the ICT research effort in an Enlarged Europe”d … Digital libraries and technology-enhanced learning”
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-9
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Data set
4
7
35
8
14
10
6
7
13
0123456789
101112131415
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
New projects per programme per year
FP7
FP6
eContentplus
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-10
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
TEL projects as social networks
P … projects
O … organizations
Consortium membership � ∶ � � � → { 1, 0 }
Project consortium progression �� �, ��� �
�� , � ∶ , � ∈ � ∧ � � ∧ ∃� ∈ � ∶ � , � ∧ � �, �
Organizational collaboration �� � , ��� �
�� , � ∶ , � ∈ � ∧ � � ∧ ∃� ∈ � ∶ � �, ∧ � �, �
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-11
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
GP – FP7 project progression
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-12
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
FP6, FP7, ECP projectsFP6, FP7,
eContentplus
Central role of IPs and NoEs as sources and harbors of consortia
eContentplus as “gap filler”
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-13
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Project ranking
PROJECTProgr-amme
StartYear
Authority▼
HubPage-Rank
DegreeWeightedDegree
Close.Centrality
Betw.Centrality
LocalClust. Coeff.
GALA FP7 2010 .0546 [1] .0634 [1] .0338 [4] 42 [3] 79 [5] .6847 [4] .0585 [3] .3449 [74]
OpenScout ECP 2009 .0442 [2] .0495 [2] .0287 [6] 37 [6] 72 [6] .6609 [6] .0310 [7] .4790 [56]
TEL-MAP FP7 2010 .0416 [3] .0000 [75] .0207 [11] 31 [11] 51 [11] .6230 [11] .0147 [20] .5032 [50]
STELLAR FP7 2009 .0403 [4] .0464 [3] .0324 [5] 42 [3] 81 [4] .6909 [3] .0390 [4] .4135 [71]
ROLE FP7 2009 .0338 [5] .0386 [4] .0252 [8] 36 [7] 61 [8] .6552 [7] .0347 [6] .4540 [63]
iCOPER ECP 2008 .0338 [5] .0386 [4] .0354 [3] 39 [5] 91 [3] .6667 [5] .0224 [12] .4764 [59]
Math-Bridge ECP 2009 .0299 [7] .0340 [6] .0156 [18] 26 [15] 35 [17] .5891 [16] .0163 [15] .5446 [42]
ASPECT ECP 2008 .0286 [8] .0309 [7] .0250 [9] 30 [12] 59 [9] .6179 [12] .0289 [8] .4989 [55]
mEducator ECP 2009 .0260 [9] .0294 [8] .0135 [23] 24 [18] 28 [26] .5891 [16] .0234 [10] .5580 [40]
ITEC FP7 2010 .0260 [9] .0294 [8] .0167 [16] 22 [22] 37 [16] .5758 [23] .0176 [14] .5022 [51]
MIRROR FP7 2010 .0260 [9] .0294 [8] .0129 [25] 24 [18] 29 [23] .5802 [20] .0061 [30] .6051 [33]
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-14
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Geo-mapping
http://is.gd/fp7telmap
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-15
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
GO – Project collaborations FP7
Each project creates ties among ist consortium members
GOTTFRIED WILHELM LEIBNIZ UNIVERSITAET HANNOVER
DEUTSCHES FORSCHUNGSZENTRUM FUER KUENSTLICHE INTELL IGENZ GMBH
UNIVERSITE CATHOLIQUE DE LOUVAIN
UNIVERSITAET GRAZ
THE UNIVERSITY OF WARWICK
TECHNISCHE UNIVERSITEIT DELFT
OPEN UNIVERSITEIT NEDERLAND
UNIVERSITA DELLA SVIZZERA ITALIANA
EXACT LEARNING SOLUTIONS SPA
IMC INFORMATION MULTIMEDIA COMMUNICATION AG
VRIJE UNIVERSITEIT BRUSSEL
ATOS ORIGIN SOCIEDAD ANONIMA ESPANOLA
THE CHANCELLOR, MASTERS AND SCHOLARS OF THE UNIVERS ITY OF CAMBRIDGE
TECHNISCHE UNIVERSITEIT EINDHOVEN
THE PROVOST FELLOWS AND SCHOLARS OF THE COLLEGE OF THE HOLY AND UNDIVIDED TRINITY OF QUEEN ELIZABETH N EAR DUBLIN
EBERHARD KARLS UNIVERSITAET TUEBINGEN
UNIVERSITEIT UTRECHT
AURUS KENNIS- EN TRAININGSSYSTEMEN B.V.
UNIVERSITATEA POLITEHNICA DIN BUCURESTI
UNIVERSITE PIERRE MENDES FRANCE
INSTITUTE FOR PARALLEL PROCESSING OF THE BULGARIAN ACADEMY OF SCIENCES
BIT MEDIA E-LEARNING SOLUTION GMBH AND CO KG
THE UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER
THE OPEN UNIVERSITY
WIRTSCHAFTSUNIVERSITAET WIENUNIVERSITAET DUISBURG-ESSEN
THE GOVERNING COUNCIL OF THE UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO
DE PRAKTIJK, NATUURWETENSCHAPPELIJK ONDERWIJS V.O.F .
TARTU ULIKOOL
UNIVERSITETET I BERGEN
ENOVATE AS
UNIVERSITETET I OSLO
STICHTING TECHNASIUM
UNIVERSITE JOSEPH FOURIER GRENOBLE 1
UNIVERSITY OF CYPRUS
FRAUNHOFER-GESELLSCHAFT ZUR FOERDERUNG DER ANGEWAND TEN FORSCHUNG E.VUNIVERSITEIT TWENTE
STIFTELSEN SINTEF TECHNOLOGY & SOCIETY
SIEMENS AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT OESTERREICH
CLEAR COMMUNICATION ASSOCIATES LIMITED - CCA
LEAN ENTERPRISE INSTITUTE POLSKA SPOLKA Z OGRANICZO NA ODPOWIEDZIALNOSC IA
NORGES TEKNISK-NATURVITENSKAPELIGE UNIVERSITET NTNU
POLITECNICO DI MILANO
AALTO-KORKEAKOULUSAATIO
VIRTECH LTD
TECHNISCHE UNIVERSITAET GRAZ
BIBA - BREMER INSTITUT FUER PRODUKTION UND LOGISTIK GMBH
INOVACIJSKO-RAZVOJNI INSTITUT UNIVERZE V LJUBLJANI
INESC ID - INSTITUTO DE ENGENHARIA DE SISTEMAS E CO MPUTADORES, INVESTIGACAO E DESENVOLVIMENTO EM LISBO A
CYNTELIX CORPORATION LIMITED
NOKIA OYJ
UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON
MOMA SPA
HEALTHWARE SPA - PHI
UNIVERSITAET INNSBRUCK
ENGINEERING - INGEGNERIA INFORMATICA SPA
UNIVERSITA DEGLI STUDI DI MILANO
AMIS DRUZBA ZA TELEKOMUNIKACIJE D.O.O.
CENTRO DI RICERCA IN MATEMATICA PURA ED APPLICATA - CONSORZIO
FUNDACIO PER A LA UNIVERSITAT OBERTA DE CATALUNYA
COVENTRY UNIVERSITY
IMAGINARY SRLEMPOWERTHEUSER LTD
UNIVERSITY OF LEEDS
FRIEDRICH-ALEXANDER UNIVERSITAET ERLANGEN - NUERNBE RG
UNIVERSITAET PADERBORN
BOC ASSET MANAGEMENT GMBH
LONDON METROPOLITAN UNIVERSITY
FACHHOCHSCHULE NORDWESTSCHWEIZ
SOLUCIONES INTEGRALES DE FORMACION Y GESTION STRUCT URALIA, S.A
FORSCHUNGSZENTRUM INFORMATIK AN DER UNIVERSITAET KA RLSRUHE
PONTYDYSGU LTD
SAP AG
CENTRE INTERNACIONAL DE METODES NUMERICS EN ENGINYE RIA
NATIONAL AND KAPODISTRIAN UNIVERSITY OF ATHENS
ALMA MATER STUDIORUM-UNIVERSITA DI BOLOGNA
COMPEDIA SOFTWARE & HARDWARE DEVELOPMENT LTD
GOETEBORGS UNIVERSITET
UNIVERSITA DEGLI STUDI DI GENOVA
THE UNIVERSITY OF EXETER
SONY FRANCE S.A.
REGISTERED NURSING HOME ASSOCIATION LIMITED
THE CITY UNIVERSITY
TRACOIN QUALITY BV
REGOLA SRL
INFOMAN AG
NEUROLOGISCHE KLINIK GMBH BAD NEUSTADT
RUHR-UNIVERSITAET BOCHUM
BRITISH TELECOMMUNICATIONS PUBLIC LIMITED COMPANY*
MEDIEN IN DER BILDUNG
KOMPETENZZENTRUM FUER WISSENSBASIERTE ANWENDUNGEN U ND SYSTEME FORSCHUNGS - UND ENTWICKLUNGS GMBH
VEREIN OFFENES LERNEN
THE UNIVERSITY OF BIRMINGHAM
BOC INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES CONSULTING SP. Z.O.O.
UNI RESEARCH AS
MTO PSYCHOLOGISCHE FORSCHUNG UND BERATUNG GMBH
COPENHAGEN BUSINESS SCHOOL
INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION, UNIVERSITY OF LONDON
JOANNEUM RESEARCH FORSCHUNGSGESELLSCHAFT MBH
CONSIGLIO NAZIONALE DELLE RICERCHE
THE UNIVERSITY OF NOTTINGHAM
PLAYGEN LTD
UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST OF SCOTLAND
FUNDACION ESADE
MINISTERUL APARARII NATIONALE
NATO UNDERSEA RESEARCH CENTRE
CENTRE EUROPEEN D'EDUCATION PERMANENTE
UNIVERSITE PAUL SABATIER TOULOUSE III
TTY-SAATIO
SERIOUS GAMES INTERACTIVEAALBORG UNIVERSITET
CYNTELIX CORPORATION BV
HERIOT-WATT UNIVERSITY
RHEINISCH-WESTFAELISCHE TECHNISCHE HOCHSCHULE AACHE N
UNIVERSIDAD COMPLUTENSE DE MADRID
ORT FRANCE
EIDGENOESSISCHE TECHNISCHE HOCHSCHULE ZUERICH
KATHOLIEKE UNIVERSITEIT LEUVEN
BUNDESMINISTERIUM FÜR UNTERRICHT, KUNST UND KULTUR
MINISTERIO DA EDUCACAO
SENTER FOR IKT I UTDANNINGEN
INDIRE ISTITUTO NAZIONALE DI DOCUMENTAZIONE PER L'I NNOVAZIONE E LA RICERCA EDUCATIVA
MAKASH - ADVANCING CMC APPLICATIONS IN EDUCATION, C ULTURE AND SCIENCE
EDUCATIO PUBLIC SERVICES NON-PROFIT LLC
SMART TECHNOLOGIES (GERMANY) GMBH
FUTURELAB EDUCATION
PROMETHEAN LIMITED
THE UNIVERSITY OF BOLTON
ICODEON LIMITED
NATIONAL MINISTRY OF EDUCATION
EDUCA.CH INSTITUT SUISSSE DES MEDIAS POUR LA FORMAT ION ET LA CULTURE
UNIVERSIDAD DE VIGO
ELFA S.R.O.
INSTITUTO DE EDUCAÇÃO DA UNIVERSIDADE DE LISBOA
EDUBIT VZW
KNOWLEDGE MARKETS CONSULTING GMBH
THE MANCHESTER METROPOLITAN UNIVERSITY
TIIGRIHUPPE SIHTASUTUS
EUN PARTNERSHIP AISBLUNI-C, DANMARKS EDB-CENTER FOR FORSKNING OG UDDANNE LSE
CENTRE NATIONAL DE DOCUMENTATION PEDAGOGIQUE
SVIETIMO INFORMACINIU TECHNOLOGIJU CENTRAS
FACULTES UNIVERSITAIRES NOTRE-DAME DE LA PAIX ASBL
UNIVERSITA DEGLI STUDI DELL'AQUILA
UNIVERSITA DEGLI STUDI DI PADOVA
UNIVERSIDAD DE SALAMANCA
AMNIN D.O.O CENTR ZA ZNANSTVENO VIZUALIZACIJO
LIBERA UNIVERSITA DI BOLZANO
UNIVERSITA DEGLI STUDI DI VERONA
FONDAZIONE BRUNO KESSLER
MOHOLY-NAGY MUVESZETI EGYETEM
SIVECO ROMANIA SA
UNIVERSITY OF SUSSEX
GIUNTI LABS S.R.L.
HOGSKOLEN I OSLO
JYVASKYLAN YLIOPISTO
ZENTRUM FUER SOZIALE INNOVATION
KUNGLIGA TEKNISKA HOEGSKOLAN
BRUNEL UNIVERSITY
NATIONAL UNIVERSITY CORPORATION, KYOTO UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITAET AUGSBURG
WAGENINGEN UNIVERSITEIT
GAKO HOJIN SEIKEI GAKUEN
UNIVERSITY OF SUNDERLAND
JACOBS UNIVERSITY BREMEN GGMBH
TAKOMAT JOHNE, SCHNATMANN, SCHWARZ GBR
TESTALUNA SRL
UNIVERSITY OF LEICESTER
ZENTRUM FUER GRAPHISCHE DATENVERARBEITUNG E.V.
IT UNIVERSITY OF COPENHAGEN
UNIVERSITY OF BATH
THE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA
NATIONAL TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY OF ATHENSINSTITUT FÜR ANGEWANDTE SYSTEMTECHNIK BREMEN GMBH
EESTI OPETAJATE LIIT
INI DOO
FACULTY OF ORGANIZATIONAL SCIENCES, UNIVERSITY OF B ELGRADE
TALLINNA ULIKOOL
ATHABASCA UNIVERSITY
VOLKSWAGEN AG
THE HEBREW UNIVERSITY OF JERUSALEM
KATHOLISCHE UNIVERSITAT EICHSTATT-INGOLSTADT
SAXO BANK AS
ERASMUS UNIVERSITEIT ROTTERDAM
BLEKINGE TEKNISKA HOEGSKOLA
UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL
SCIENTER SCRL
ECOLE POLYTECHNIQUE FEDERALE DE LAUSANNE
LUDWIG-MAXIMILIANS-UNIVERSITAET MUENCHEN
ALBERT-LUDWIGS-UNIVERSITAET FREIBURG
FUNDAÇÃO UNIVERSIDADE DE BRASILIA
CENTRAL LABORATORY OF GENERAL ECOLOGY - ZENTRALNA L ABORATORIYA PO OBSCHTA EKOLOGIYA
UNIVERSIDAD POLITECNICA DE MADRID
TEL AVIV UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITAET FUER BODENKULTUR WIEN
UNIVERSITY OF HULL
UNIVERSITEIT VAN AMSTERDAM
THE BRITISH INSTITUTE FOR LEARNINGAND DEVELOPMENT L BG
U&I LEARNING NV
FESTO LERNZENTRUM SAAR GMBHSHANGHAI JIAO TONG UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITAET KOBLENZ-LANDAU
UPPSALA UNIVERSITET
FRAUNHOFER IAF
UNIVERSITY OF HAIFA
BAR ILAN UNIVERSITY
MORPHEUS SOFTWARE VOF
LANDESINITIATIVE NEUE KOMMUNIKATIONSWEGE MECKLENBUR G-VORPOMMERN E.V.
EXTRIM MINTIA SOLOUSIONS ETAIREIA PLIROFORIKIS KAI TILEPIKOINONION ETAIREIA PERIORISMENIS EFTHINIS
UNIVERSITY OF PIRAEUS RESEARCH CENTER
STIFTUNG UNIVERSITAT HILDESHEIM
SPACE APPLICATIONS SERVICES NV
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-16
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Project collaborations
UNIVERSITE CATHOLIQUE DE LOUVAIN
UNIVERSITAET GRAZ
TECHNISCHE UNIVERSITEIT DELFT
OPEN UNIVERSITEIT NEDERLAND
UNIVERSITA DELLA SVIZZERA ITALIANA
ATOS ORIGIN SOCIEDAD ANONIMA ESPANOLA
THE CHANCELLOR, MASTERS AND SCHOLARS OF THE UNIVERS ITY OF CAMBRIDGE
EBERHARD KARLS UNIVERSITAET TUEBINGEN
UNIVERSITEIT UTRECHT
UNIVERSITATEA POLITEHNICA DIN BUCURESTI
BIT MEDIA E-LEARNING SOLUTION GMBH AND CO KG
THE UNIVERSITY OF MANCHESTER
THE OPEN UNIVERSITY
WIRTSCHAFTSUNIVERSITAET WIEN
UNIVERSITE JOSEPH FOURIER GRENOBLE 1
STIFTELSEN SINTEF TECHNOLOGY & SOCIETY
SIEMENS AKTIENGESELLSCHAFT OESTERREICH
CLEAR COMMUNICATION ASSOCIATES LIMITED - CCA
LEAN ENTERPRISE INSTITUTE POLSKA SPOLKA Z OGRANICZO NA ODPOWIEDZIALNOSC IA
NORGES TEKNISK-NATURVITENSKAPELIGE UNIVERSITET NTNU
POLITECNICO DI MILANO
AALTO-KORKEAKOULUSAATIO
VIRTECH LTD
BIBA - BREMER INSTITUT FUER PRODUKTION UND LOGISTIK GMBH
INESC ID - INSTITUTO DE ENGENHARIA DE SISTEMAS E CO MPUTADORES, INVESTIGACAO E DESENVOLVIMENTO EM LISBO A
CYNTELIX CORPORATION LIMITED
NOKIA OYJ
UNIVERSITY COLLEGE LONDON
COVENTRY UNIVERSITY
UNIVERSITA DEGLI STUDI DI GENOVA
CONSIGLIO NAZIONALE DELLE RICERCHE
THE UNIVERSITY OF NOTTINGHAM
PLAYGEN LTD
UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST OF SCOTLAND
FUNDACION ESADE
MINISTERUL APARARII NATIONALE
NATO UNDERSEA RESEARCH CENTRE
CENTRE EUROPEEN D'EDUCATION PERMANENTE
UNIVERSITE PAUL SABATIER TOULOUSE III
TTY-SAATIO
SERIOUS GAMES INTERACTIVEAALBORG UNIVERSITET
CYNTELIX CORPORATION BV
HERIOT-WATT UNIVERSITY
RHEINISCH-WESTFAELISCHE TECHNISCHE HOCHSCHULE AACHE N
UNIVERSIDAD COMPLUTENSE DE MADRID
ORT FRANCE
EIDGENOESSISCHE TECHNISCHE HOCHSCHULE ZUERICH
KATHOLIEKE UNIVERSITEIT LEUVEN
EDUCATIO PUBLIC SERVICES NON-PROFIT LLC
FUTURELAB EDUCATION
THE UNIVERSITY OF BOLTON
UNIVERSITA DEGLI STUDI DELL'AQUILA
UNIVERSITA DEGLI STUDI DI VERONA
GIUNTI LABS S.R.L.
ZENTRUM FUER SOZIALE INNOVATION
KUNGLIGA TEKNISKA HOEGSKOLAN
NATIONAL TECHNICAL UNIVERSITY OF ATHENSINI DOO
TALLINNA ULIKOOL
ATHABASCA UNIVERSITY
ERASMUS UNIVERSITEIT ROTTERDAM
UNIVERSITY OF BRISTOL
SCIENTER SCRL
ECOLE POLYTECHNIQUE FEDERALE DE LAUSANNE
LUDWIG-MAXIMILIANS-UNIVERSITAET MUENCHEN
ALBERT-LUDWIGS-UNIVERSITAET FREIBURG
MORPHEUS SOFTWARE VOF
EXTRIM MINTIA SOLOUSIONS ETAIREIA PLIROFORIKIS KAI TILEPIKOINONION ETAIREIA PERIORISMENIS EFTHINIS
UNIVERSITY OF PIRAEUS RESEARCH CENTER
STIFTUNG UNIVERSITAT HILDESHEIM
SPACE APPLICATIONS SERVICES NV
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-17
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Top collaborators in FP7
� Technische Universität Graz, Austria (82 conn. in 7 projects)
� Open Universiteit Nederland, Netherlands (67 / 5)
� Aalto-Korkeakoulusaatio, Finland (66 / 3)
� Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Belgium (63 / 4).
� ATOS Origin Sociedad Anonima Espanola, Spain (59 / 4)
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-18
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
605 organizations
in 77 projects
creating 9K+
collaboration ties
Project collaborations FP6,7, ECP
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-19
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Top 10 organizations
Organization PR ▼ BC LC DC CC Funding*
THE OPEN UNIVERSITY .0125 [1] .1209 [1] .2135 [603] 220 [1] .5421 [1] 3.55 [3]
KATHOLIEKE UNIVERSITEIT LEUVEN .0090 [2] .0770 [2] .1701 [605] 149 [3] .5628 [5] 2.56 [5]
OPEN UNIVERSITEIT NEDERLAND .0085 [3] .0411 [5] .2159 [602] 133 [7] .6014 [6] 3.45 [4]
JYVASKYLAN YLIOPISTO .0080 [4] .0667 [3] .3168 [590] 170 [2] .5480 [2] 1.26 [39]
DEUTSCHES FORSCHUNGSZENTRUM FUER KUENSTLICHE INTELLIGENZ GMBH
.0066 [5] .0409 [6] .1892 [604] 107 [25] .5550 [17] 3.68 [1]
ATOS ORIGIN SOCIEDAD ANONIMA ESPANOLA .0064 [6] .0237 [15] .4316 [565] 142 [5] .5335 [4] 1.33 [33]
UNIVERSITAET GRAZ .0064 [7] .0229 [18] .4016 [574] 148 [4] .5279 [3] 2.03 [10]
UNIVERSITEIT UTRECHT .0061 [8] .0204 [23] .4323 [564] 139 [6] .5279 [11] 1.62 [19]
INESC ID - INSTITUTO DE ENGENHARIA DE SISTEMAS E COMPUTADORES, INVESTIGACAO E DESENVOLVIMENTO EM LISBOA
.0061 [9] .0368 [7] .4741 [550] 130 [8] .5261 [19] 1.68 [16]
THE UNIVERSITY OF WARWICK .0058 [10] .0329 [8] .4754 [549] 129 [10] .5025 [10] 1.68 [17]
PR = PageRank | BC = Betweenness centrality | LC = Local clustering coefficient | DC = Degree centrality | CC = Closeness centrality
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-20
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Two clustering spheres
0
50
100
150
200
250
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
De
gre
e
Local clustering coefficient
KALEIDOSCOPE (100%), STELLAR (94%), PROLEARN (91%), RE.MATH (88%), GRAPPLE, ALICE, TEL-Map (80% each), ICOPER (74%) and IMREAL (72%).
Connectedness of the neighborhood
137 / 605 (23%) are on the “higher sphere”.
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-21
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Top partnership bonds
Organizational pairing, e.g. OUNL + Hannover, OU +
KUL (6), OU + OUNL / IMC / JYU (5), …
The most important projects where the 22 strongest
partnership pairs (4 or more projects) participated:
1. PROLEARN (FP6; 16 pairs),
2. ICOPER (eContentplus; 10 pairs),
3. OpenScout (eContentplus; 9 pairs),
4. GRAPPLE (FP7; 8 pairs),
5. STELLAR, ROLE (FP7; 5 pairs), and
7. PROLIX (FP6, 5 pairs)
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-22
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
∆t – Dynamic SNA
Organizations vs Collaborations
157
258
372424
477543
6054,199
4,989
6,0496,609
7,411
8,244
9,340
0
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Organizations
Collaborations
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-23
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Dynamic SNA
Introduction of new organizations
8
14 14
7 9
1213
19.6
7.28.1 7.4
5.9 5.5 4.8
0
5
10
15
20
25
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
New Projects
New Organizations per New Project
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-24
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Dynamic SNA
Fresh blood?!23.0
10.912.1 12.0
14.112.6 11.9
19.6
7.28.1 7.4
5.9 5.5 4.8
0
5
10
15
20
25
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Avg. Consortium Size of New Projects
New Organizations per New Project
85%
66% 67%62%
42% 44%40%
23.0
10.9 12.1 12.014.1 12.6 11.9
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
Ratio of New Organizations in Consortia of New Projects
Avg. Consortium Size of New Projects
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-25
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Want to explore?
Widget based query explorer
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-26
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
TEL projects SNA dashboard
Widget:
http://learningfrontiers.eu/extras/widgets/mediabase/?db=projects
Timeseries query (annotated timeline)select makedate(year(date_start), 1), avg(funding) as 'Avg Funds', max(funding) as 'Max Funds', sum(funding) as 'Sum F unds', count(*) as Projects from projectspace_projects where is_tel = 1 group by makedate(year(date_start), 1) order by 1 asc
SNA query (graph visualization)select a.acronym as Project1, b.acronym as Project2 , count(*) as 'Number of overlapping partners' from (select acron ym, pt.project_id, pt.participant_id from projectspace_project_participants pt, projectspace_ projects p where p.id=pt.project_id and p.is_tel=1 and program me='FP7') a, (select acronym, pt.project_id, pt.participant_id f rom projectspace_project_participants pt, projectspace_ projects p where p.id=pt.project_id and p.is_tel=1 and program me='FP7') b where a.project_id > b.project_id and a.participant _id = b.participant_id group by a.acronym, b.acronym orde r by 3 desc
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-27
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Key findings
� IPs and NoEs and large ECP consortia are most central projects (also: partnership bonds, clustering)
� “Multicultural” list of top organizations
� ECP as incubator for FP7 projects; strengthened weak ties. Research follows money.
� Two classes: clustered/loose neighborhood. Some achieve a clustering-paribus increase in SNA metrics
� Fresh blood is draining; bonds are growing stronger. We’re a family.
� SNA is capable of revealing clusters of organizations and projects that can be used as indicators of impact and sustainability
Lehrstuhl Informatik 5
(Informationssysteme)
Prof. Dr. M. Jarke
I5-MD-XXXX11-28
www.telmap.org
www.galanoe.eu
www.role-project.eu
Read and see more…
Stories, results, and widgets
http://learningfrontiers.eu
TEL-Map deliverable D4.3 (end Sept)
http://telmap.org
Stay tuned
#telroadmaps, @klamma, @quickmick