Manifest Causality in QFT with Sources and Detectors
description
Transcript of Manifest Causality in QFT with Sources and Detectors
+
Manifest Causality in QFT with Sources and DetectorsPeter MillingtonConsortium for Fundamental Physics, University of ManchesterInstitute for Particle Physics Phenomenology, Durham University
IoP Joint HEPP and APP Group Meeting7th-9th April, 2014
+OutlineBased on R. Dickinson, J. Forshaw, PM and B. Cox, arXiv: 1312.3871.
Motivation
Observations from Thermal Field Theory
A Simple Example
Comparison with the S-matrix
Conclusions
Peter Millington (UoM & IPPP) IoP HEPP and APP, Royal Holloway, 7-9th April 2014 2/12
+Motivation
Question 1:
How are we to calculate transition amplitudes over finite space-time domains in QFT? S-matrix theory is no good.
Peter Millington (UoM & IPPP) IoP HEPP and APP, Royal Holloway, 7-9th April 2014 3/12
+Motivation
Question 2:
QFT is built to be causal, so where is the micro-causality condition in the path integral?
Peter Millington (UoM & IPPP) IoP HEPP and APP, Royal Holloway, 7-9th April 2014 4/12
+Observations
It only makes sense to talk of transition amplitudes over finite space-time domains in the presence of an observer.
Statistically, the production and scattering processes form an open subsystem held in contact with some reservoir of observers: a detector.
The relevant object is the partition function of the detector
The solution: thermal quantum field theory.
Peter Millington (UoM & IPPP) IoP HEPP and APP, Royal Holloway, 7-9th April 2014 5/12
+Encouragement
a posteriori, physical reaction rates are obtained from the absorptive parts of retarded functions.[R. Kobes, Phys. Rev. D43, 1269 (1991); M. A. van Eijck and C. G. van Weert, Phys. Lett. B278, 305 (1992)]
Three ‘anecdotal’ reasons:① This gives the correct statistical factors.
② Analytic continuation of imaginary-time self-energies gives the retarded self-energy.
③ The Breit-Wigner width of resummed equilibrium thermal propagators is obtained from the imaginary part of the retarded self-energy.
Peter Millington (UoM & IPPP) IoP HEPP and APP, Royal Holloway, 7-9th April 2014 6/12
+CTP Formalism
[J. Schwinger, J. Math. Phys. 2, 407 (1961); L. Keldysh, Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 47, 1515 (1964); E. Calzetta and B. L. Hu, Phys. Rev. D 35, 495 (1987), Phys. Rev. D 37, 2878 (1988)]
Peter Millington (UoM & IPPP) IoP HEPP and APP, Royal Holloway, 7-9th April 2014 7/12
+“Physical” Basis
By an orthogonal transformation, we can move to the so-called Keldysh or “physical” basis:[M. A. van Eijck, R. Kobes and C. G. van Weert, Phys. Rev. D50, 4097 (1994)]
Note that J couples only to the retarded propagator.
Peter Millington (UoM & IPPP) IoP HEPP and APP, Royal Holloway, 7-9th April 2014 8/12
+2 to 2 Scattering
Entanglement of Final States
Peter Millington (UoM & IPPP) IoP HEPP and APP, Royal Holloway, 7-9th April 2014 9/12
+S-matrix Limit
To compare with the S-matrix, we must project out plane waves by promoting J and K to operators in Fock space:
We can then sandwich the amplitude between in and out states to project out given initial and final states.
Peter Millington (UoM & IPPP) IoP HEPP and APP, Royal Holloway, 7-9th April 2014 10/12
+NJ to NK
Peter Millington (UoM & IPPP) IoP HEPP and APP, Royal Holloway, 7-9th April 2014 11/12
+Conclusions
Working within the paradigm of thermal field theory, one can write down a generating functional in which causality remains manifest.
Results are consistent with S-matrix amplitudes in the relevant limits, specifically if we restrict to positive energy flow forwards in time.
Analytic differences arise at the level of loops.
Potential relevance: Resummation in the presence of finite-time and volume effects, interplay of positive
and negative energy contributions. Role of CTP Effective Action QFT on non-stationary spacetimes, where Wick rotation does not always lead to a
Riemannian metric. …
Peter Millington (UoM & IPPP) IoP HEPP and APP, Royal Holloway, 7-9th April 2014 12/12