Management Control Systems

65
MANAGEMENT CONTROL SYSTEMS SANDEEP SAHASRABUDHE

Transcript of Management Control Systems

Page 1: Management Control Systems

MANAGEMENT CONTROL SYSTEMS

SANDEEP SAHASRABUDHE

Page 2: Management Control Systems

INTRODUCTION TO CONTROL FUNCTION

The management process includes:

1. Planning

2. Organizing

3. Staffing

4. Leading

5. Controlling

Page 3: Management Control Systems

The control function is concerned with ensuring that planning, organizing, staffing and leading functions result in the attainment of organizational objectives.

In other words, control is a tool that helps organizations measure and compare their actual progress with their established plan.

Supervision is a part of control; it helps identify deviations from the established standards of performance.

Page 4: Management Control Systems

CONTROL AS A FUNCTION

Control is one of the major functions of the manager at any level of the enterprise.

It will be readily seen that all the functions of the manager are so closely inter-related that is difficult in practice to ascertain when one function ends and another begins.

Planning and controlling are particularly closely related since the purpose of control is to make sure that plans are accomplished. Any attempt to control withoout planning would be meaningless since no one can tell whether his subordinates are doing what he wishes them to do unless he first knows what his wishes are.

Page 5: Management Control Systems

DEFINITION OF CONTROLControl is seeing that actual performance is guided towards expected performance. It is an important function of management and is related to all other management functions. Control is a comparison and verification process and with the help of this process, a balance in the organization activities directed towards predetermined goals can be achieved and maintained. It helps in taking corrective measure incase of deviation from the planned course of action.

Once a plan becomes operational, control is necessary to measure the progress, to uncover deviation from plans and to indicate and implement corrective action.

The end objective of control, is therefore, to ensure that the people’s effort in the organization is continuously directed towards the attainment of pre-determined objectives.

Page 6: Management Control Systems

WHAT IS THE MEANING AND PURPOSE OF CONTROL?

1. Knowing exactly what work is to be done as to

(a) Quantity

(b) Quality

(c) Time available

2. Knowing what resources are available for doing the work as to

(a) Personnel

(b) Materials

(c) Other facilities

Page 7: Management Control Systems

3. Knowing that the work has been done or is being done

(a) with the resources available

(b) within the time available

(c) at a reasonable cost

(d) in accordance with the required standard of quality

4. Knowing immediately of any delays, hold ups or variation as to

(a) what happened

(b) its cause

(c) remedy

Page 8: Management Control Systems

5. Knowing what is being done, remove such hindrances as to

(a) who is doing

(b) how is it being done

(c) what is it costing

(d) when will it be completed

6. Knowing about the completed work as to

(a) time finished

(b) quantity

(c) final cost

Page 9: Management Control Systems

7. Knowing that the resources are guarded against

(a) in what way

(b) by whom

(c) at what cost

(d) with what provision for periodic inspection

Page 10: Management Control Systems

WHAT ARE THE ELEMENTS OF CONTROL

There are six elements of control:

(a) Authority

(b) Knowledge

(c) Guidance

(d) Direction

(e) Constraint

(f) Restraint

To be in a position to exercise control, the manager must know what the situation is, what it should be and how to correct it. Besides, he must have the authority to take the appropriate action.

Page 11: Management Control Systems

WHAT ARE THE CHARACTERISTICS OF

MANAGERIAL CONTROL?Managerial control has the following characteristics:

1. The control process is cyclical.

2. Control is a function of management; a follow-up action to other functions of management.

3. Control is a dynamic process.

4. Controlling is often viewed negatively by employees.

5. Control is both, anticipatory and retrospective.

6. Ideally, each person in the business views control as his/her responsibility. The organizational culture should prevent a person walking away from a small problem which can be solved.

Page 12: Management Control Systems

7. Controlling is related to each of the functions of management. Controlling builds on planning, organizing and leading.

8. Control by its nature is both restrictive as well as regulative. However, the modern concept of control is concerned more with regulation than with restriction as the latter is a very limited form of activity.

9. The authority to control vests with the higher levels of management because it is the superior who has delegated authority to the subordinate to carry out certain activity. Each higher level of management seeks to ensure that the plans are adhered to by those over whom they have authority.

10. Controls are a method measuring progress and the present direction of management thinking is towards the desirability of self-discipline in this respect.

Page 13: Management Control Systems

IMPORTANCE OF CONTROL

The control function is gaining importance in today’s organizations due to a number of factors. These factors include:

(a) The need for accountability.

(b) The need to detect environmental changes that significantly affect organizations.

(c) The growing complexity of present day organizations and the need to identify operational errors in organizations to avoid incurring excessive costs.

Page 14: Management Control Systems

BASIC CONTROL PROCESS When exercising the control function, a manager measures the

performance of an individual, a plan, or a program against certain pre-determined standards and takes corrective action if there are any deviations. The process involves the following steps:

1. Determining areas to control: It covers all the areas of business, namely, policies, procedures, men, money, machines and equipment, public relations, human relations, research and development and so on.

2. Establishing standards: Although the temptation may be great, lowering standards to what has been attained is not a solution to performance problems. The need to lower standards arises when they are unattainable due to resource restrictions and factors external to the business.

Page 15: Management Control Systems

3. Measuring performance

4. Comparing performance against standards

5. Recognizing good or positive performance.

6. Taking corrective action when necessary

7. Adjusting standards and measures when necessary.

Page 16: Management Control Systems

REQUIREMENTS OF EFFECTIVE CONTROL

1. Control should reflect plans, positions and structures

2. They should be understandable.

3. They should be cost-effective

4. Controls should identify only major/important exceptions.

5. Control systems should be flexible

6. Control systems should provide accurate information.

Page 17: Management Control Systems

CHARACTERISTICS OF EFFECTIVE CONTROL SYSTEMS

Effective control systems have the following characteristics:

1. Control at all levels in the business

2. Acceptability to those who will enforce decisions

3. Flexibility

4. Accuracy

5. Timeliness

6. Cost effectiveness

7. Understanding

8. Balance between objectivity and subjectivity

9. Coordinated with planning, organizing and leading.

Page 18: Management Control Systems

DYSFUNCTIONAL CONSEQUENCES OF CONTROL

Employee resistance can easily make control efforts dysfunctional. The following behavior demonstrate means by which the manager’s control efforts can be frustrated:

1. Game playing

2. Resisting control

3. Providing inaccurate information

4. Following rules to the letter

5. Sabotaging

6. Playing one manager off against another.

Page 19: Management Control Systems

WHAT IS MANAGEMENT CONTROL

Management control is the process of assuring that resources are obtained, used effectively and efficiently in the accomplishment of the organization’s objectives.

The purpose of management control system is to encourage managers to take actions which are in the best interests of the company.

Page 20: Management Control Systems

DEFINITION OF MANAGEMENT CONTROL

Management control can be defined as a systematic effort by business management to compare performance to predetermined standards, plans or objectives in order to determine whether performance is in line with these standards and presumable in order to take any remedial action required to see that the business and human and other corporate resources are being used in the most effective and efficient way possible in acquiring corporate objectives.

The actual performance is compared with the expected. Depending upon the evaluation of any variation from standard, some sort of action is taken.

Page 21: Management Control Systems

MANAGEMENT CONTROL AND PLANNING

Management control is designed to help a corporation reach its long-term objectives, hence the exercise begins with corporate planning. Corporate planning is an intellectual process which requires analysis of future circumstances, both external (environment) and internal (company) and the development of an objective, policies, and programmes within the context of that future.

In order to understand how performance is controlled and control decisions are made, it is necessary to examine in detail the two major management control process.

The first is the process followed in solving control problems and in setting up effective effective controls or a system for effective control

The second, is the process of controlling the operation and making decisions once the control system is established.

Page 22: Management Control Systems

STEPS IN PROBLEM SOLVING/ DECISION MAKING PROCESS

1. Diagnose the situation and review all of the facts in order to find and define the problem.

2. Examine the problem and review the facts in order to find the key factors affecting the problem and its solution. This step is sometimes referred to as ‘premising’.

3. Develop alternative solutions to the problem.

4. Test and evaluate the alternatives to determine the best solution.

5. Construct a clear statement of the solution selected, and convert the decision into a plan of action.

Page 23: Management Control Systems

FACTORS AFFECTING MANAGERIAL PHILOSOPHY

Application of the concept of management control requires the following:

1. Identifying key factors in the business operation which need to be controlled in order to achieve a given over-all result.

2. Specifying the basis for establishing standards of performance for each control factor, such as forecasts, budgets, standard costs, turnover ratios and lead times.

3. Defining the information-accounting and operating data and statistics that must be accumulated to measure status and performance.

4. Establishing a reporting structure that identifies performance in each control area, relate causes and effects, signals, trends, and identifies results by responsibility under the plan of organizations.

Page 24: Management Control Systems

MANAGEMENT CONTROL SYSTEMS

A Management Control Systems (MCS) is a set of inter-related communication structures that facilitates the processing of information for the purpose of assisting managers in coordinating the parts and attaining the purpose of an organization on a continuous basis. All organizations use control system both formal and informal.

Page 25: Management Control Systems

ELEMENTS OF A CONTROL SYSTEM

Any control system has four basic elements:

1. A detector or sensor: a device that measures what is actually happening in the situation being controlled.

2. An assessor: A device for determining the significance of what is happening; i.e., comparison with some standard or expectation.

3. An effector: A device that alters behavior if the assessor indicates the need. This device is often called ‘feedback’.

4. A communication network: Devices that transmit information between the detector and the assessor and between the assessor and the effector.

Page 26: Management Control Systems

Control Device

Entity being

controlled

Detector Effector

Assessor

Fig: Elements of control process

Page 27: Management Control Systems

The management control process is more complicated than what has been described in detectors, assessors, effectors and a communication system. These are as follows:

1. The standard is not preset.

2. Like controlling an automobile, management control is not automatic.

3. Management control requires coordination among individuals. All the separate parts of an organization are required to work in harmony with each other.

4. The connection from perceiving the need for action and the action required to obtain the desired result, may not be clear.

5. Control in an organization does not come about solely or even as a consequence of actions. Much control is ‘self-control’

Page 28: Management Control Systems

SYSTEMS

A system is prescribed way of carrying out activity or activities, usually the activities are repeated. Most systems are less precise than computer programs, their instructions do not cover all eventualities and the user of the system must make judgments when these eventualities occur. Nevertheless, a system is characterized by more or less rhythmic, recurring, coordinated series of steps that are intended to accomplish a specific purpose.

Page 29: Management Control Systems

ACTIVITIES IN MANAGEMENT CONTROL

Management control involves a variety of activities including:

1. Planning what the organization should do.

2. Coordinating the activities of several parts of the organization.

3. Communicating information.

4. Evaluating information.

5. Deciding what, if any, action should be taken.

6. Influencing people to change their behavior.

Page 30: Management Control Systems

GOAL CONGRUENCE

Managers have personal as well as organizational goals.

Goal congruence means that as far as feasible, the goal of an organization’s individual members should be consistent with the goals of the organization itself.

Page 31: Management Control Systems

PURPOSE OF MANAGEMENT CONTROL SYSTEMS

The purpose of an organization can be analyzed as follows:

1. Mission of the organization, which is directed, first and foremost, towards meeting needs of customers and society.

2. The term objectives to refer to specific, short-term and predominantly quantitative pursuits of an organization. We can term goals to refer to specific long-term pursuits of an organization.

3. Each part of an organization has a purpose, objectives and goals. The MCS knots the organization together so that each part, by exercising autonomy given to it fulfils a purpose that is consistent with and contributes to the fulfillment of the overall purpose of the organization.

Page 32: Management Control Systems

Management Control ProcessTwo aspects involved; namely:

(a) System

(b) Process

System outlines the following:

(c) Authority relationships

(d) Autonomy delegation

(e) Intra-organizational relationships (among sub-units)

(f) Parameters for performance

(g) Rewards and punishments for achievement and non-achievement

(h) Information flow among responsibility centers in the organization

Page 33: Management Control Systems

Process involves the managerial processes involved in:

(a) Establishing goals and objectives

(b) Performance appraisal of responsibility centers

(c) Ensuring achievement of targets and budgets by various organizational sub-units

(d) Follow-up of remedial action plans

(e) Implementation of decisions taken in performance review meetings

Page 34: Management Control Systems

The quality of decisions depends on the feedback and information provided by the control process.

The effectiveness of the control process depends on the quality of feedback received and its usage in performance appraisal.

Generally the process of control is as follows:

(a) Review of past performance of various units of the organizations and targets and specifications for the next year

(b) Periodical review of actual results and its comparison with targets

(c) Identification of areas which require improvement. This also includes identification of shortfalls and their reasons

(d) Deciding remedial actions

Page 35: Management Control Systems

Designing Management Controls

There are a few subtleties which must be considered while designing a control process. These are as follows:

(a) The process of control should be constructive

(b) Standards should be challenging but attainable

(c) Objectives should be expressed in measurable terms

(d) Control should focus on the objectives and key results of an activity and should be limited in number.

(e) A single person must be assigned the responsibility of achieving a single objective.

(f) For achieving true control in the current period, projected performance should be compared with the desired performance.

Page 36: Management Control Systems

(g) It is necessary to identify early warning predictors of the variables that the management seeks to control.

(h) It is better to carry out sampling by direct observation.

(i) An acceptable range of variation for the value of each variable that has to be controlled.

(j) The severity of the problems should be considered and its causes should also be reviewed.

Page 37: Management Control Systems

The Control Process Hierarchy

The organization consists of many responsibility centers. This gives rise to superior-subordinate relationships.

This in turn creates a means-end chain.

The goals of the superior are communicated to the subordinate, who devises a means to achieve those ends.

These means become ends for the subordinate and facilitate supervision in the next level.

Page 38: Management Control Systems

The Process• Superior meets subordinate to review past performance, negotiate

goals, new objectives and targets for key variables for the next year.

• periodic meetings of superiors and subordinates are conducted to review performance. In these meetings, areas requiring improvement are identified.

• In the next review session, the progress on past corrective action is reviewed, together with current performance to arrive at targets and actions for the next period.

• Negotiations are made between superior and subordinate regarding goals and targets.

• All targets should be specific and if possible measurable. They should be limited in number.

Page 39: Management Control Systems

Formal Control Process and Role Played by Accounting and Information Handling systems

Responsibility Center Structure

Budgeting

Programming

Operating

Analyzing performance reports

Management Compensation

Page 40: Management Control Systems

Summary of the process

• Determination of standards or norms to be used in measuring actual results.

• Measurement of actual results vis-à-vis planned results in the same lines.

• Identification and analysis of the gap between the expected and actual results.

• Initiating remedial action to correct the shortfall or to provide an acceptable basis for revising norms.

• Recycling the information relating to the actual performance for its use in developing future plans.

Page 41: Management Control Systems

Design of the MCSThe MCS is designed by incorporating the following basic steps:-

1. The classification of organization into responsibility centers.

The term responsibility center is used to denote any organization unit that headed by a responsible manager.

A responsibility center exists to accomplish one or more purposes known as objectives.

There are four types of responsibility centers:

(a) Revenue centers

(b) Expense centers

(c) Profit centers

(d) Investment centers

Page 42: Management Control Systems

2. Fixing up responsibility in accordance with the firm’s objectives and deciding critical variables/ key factors for each responsibility centers:

• A critical variable is that aspect of operation at the responsibility center, which affects the realization of goals and objectives; if it is carried out ineffectively.

• The point selected for control should be critical

• this facilitates the manager to increase his span management, effect cost savings and improve communication.

Page 43: Management Control Systems

3. Developing information system which facilitates real time information regarding operations which deviate from desired results, specially critical variables and relate results to individual accountability.

The word information means data relevant for a particular purpose.

Information about a critical variable is a must for managerial control process.

The formal information system should be structured such that it:

(a) Provides regular collection of data regarding each and every responsibility center.

(b) Yields, processes and summarizes data

(c) Presents relevant information to managers for control as and when needed.

Page 44: Management Control Systems

Information SystemsAll managers require information to perform their managerial functions of planning and controlling, and make effective decisions.

The information that managers will require will vary depending upon the nature of work they do and the tasks they seek to accomplish.

The information needs vary as per the organizational hierarchy.

.

Page 45: Management Control Systems

Information SystemsThe information that originates within the organization is referred to as internal information. This type of information is essential for managing day-to-day operations.

The information that originates outside the organization is referred to as external information. Such information is required by top level managers to plan and guide the organization successfully

Page 46: Management Control Systems

Different Levels of Information Systems

Decision support system

Marketing Info system

Office Automation System

Transaction Processing System

Executive

Info. System

Senior level managers

Middle level managers

Front end personnel

Page 47: Management Control Systems

Performance Measures

Performance measures are a central component of management information and reporting system.

It deals with performance measures for different organizational units and their managers.

Page 48: Management Control Systems

Levels of Performance Measures

1. Customer/ Market Level

2. Total Organizational Level

3. Individual Facility Level

4. Individual activity Level

5. By product

Page 49: Management Control Systems

Performance ReportsFormat and Essential Features

1. Tailored to the organization Structure and Controllability:

The performance report should be designed according to the structure and requirements of the organization.

2. Designed to implement the exception principle in management:

Performance report must clearly distinguish between controllable and non-controllable items

3. Repetitive:

Performance should be repetitive; generally on a monthly basis.

Page 50: Management Control Systems

4. Adapted to the requirements of the principal user:

According to the level of management, the performance reports must be altered.

5. Simple, Understandable and report only essential information:

Report should not be too long and complex. It should be carefully screened to eliminate all non-essential information.

6. Prepared and presented promptly:

Consistent with the cost of detailed recording record keeping and reporting, performance reports should be available on a timely basis.

7. Effective Management Follow-up Procedures:

Effective follow-up procedures form a key aspect of effective control.

Page 51: Management Control Systems

Types of reports for different management levels

TOP MANAGEMENT

(i) Balance sheet

(ii) Profit &Loss Statement

(iii) Position of stock

(iv) Disposition of funds

(v) Cash flow statements

(vi) Capital expenditure and financial commitments

(vii) Sales, production and other appropriate statistics

Page 52: Management Control Systems

SALES MANAGEMENT

(i) Actual sales compared with budgeted sales

(ii) Standard profit and loss by product for fixing selling prices

(iii) Selling expenses in relation to budget and sales value analysis

(iv) Bad debts and accounts which are slow and difficult to collect

(v) Status report on new doubtful customers

Page 53: Management Control Systems

PRODUCTION MANAGEMENT

(i) To buyer: price variations on purchases analyzed by commodities

(ii) To foremen/ shop leader:

(a) Operational efficiency for individual operations duly summarized

(b) Labor utilization report and causes of lost time and controlled time

(c) Indirect shop expenses against standard allowed

(d) Scrap report

Page 54: Management Control Systems

SPECIFIC REPORT

These reports are usually prepared at the request of the general management or at the initiative of the controller. They provide detailed information regarding areas under control. Some of these areas are:

(i) Taxation legislation and its effects on profits

(ii) Break-even analysis

(iii) Estimates of the earning capacity of a new project

(iv) Replacement of capital equipment

(v) Special pricing analysis

(vi) Make or buy certain components

(vii) Statement of surplus available for making bonus payment.

Page 55: Management Control Systems

Chapter 2

INFORMATION THEORY

Page 56: Management Control Systems

Meaning of Information

Information is a fact, datum, observation, perception that adds to knowledge.

Information is obtained either by direct observation or by communication.

Definition of Information

Information as commonly understood, refer to raw data, organized data, the capacity of a communication channel etc. Information is data that has been processed into a form that is meaningful to the recipient and is real or perceived value in current or prospective decisions.

Page 57: Management Control Systems

Value of Information

The concept of information has a value and cost. It must be preserved, protected and utilized like any other valuable asset.

In order to obtain information, additional costs are incurred. These additional costs may arise from the various surveys, consultancy services that an organization may resort to, in order to obtain the desired information.

This approach is used in order to create an optimum information system in an organization. By an optimum information system, it is meant that the difference between the expected value of sample information and the cost of obtaining the information is the maximum.

Page 58: Management Control Systems

Characteristics of Information

1. Purpose:

Any information that is transmitted, must have a purpose. Otherwise it shall be categorized as mere data. The purposes include identifying problems, solving problems, decision-making, planning and control.

2. Frequency:

The frequency with which information is supplied, affects its value. It depends on the needs of the receiver of the information. At times, very frequent information may be considered to be an interference.

Page 59: Management Control Systems

3. Cost:

Cost is a limiting factor in obtaining information. The value of the information must be evaluated against its cost.

4. Reliability:

Reliability is the degree of confidence that the decision maker places in the information. More reliable the information, higher is the cost of obtaining it.

5. Continuous or Discreet:

Information could be in either of the two forms.

6. Noise:

In case of information, ‘noise’ refers to the factors that may dilute information or add an element of ambiguity to it. Any element that reduces the clarity of information is considered to be noise.

Page 60: Management Control Systems

7. Relevance:

A business information system aims at filtering out unwanted information and retaining the required and important part. The information retained has to be in context of the area being analyzed; otherwise, it will prove to be futile.

8. Precision:

Most messages on a management information system are measurements and measurements are accurate only within a range. Thus, to ensure accuracy, the information must be concise and precise (to the point).

Page 61: Management Control Systems

Types of Information

Classification on the basis of flow of information:

(i) Systematic Information

It flows through a formal system and reaches the end user.

(ii) Unsystematic Information

The flow of information is not through a specified or set channel. This includes source like media, casual conversations, etc.

Page 62: Management Control Systems

Classification on the basis of source of information:

(i) External Information

Any information that is obtained from sources outside the organization is termed as external information. These sources may include reports of trade associations, govt. agencies, etc

(ii) Internal Information

Any information that is obtained from sources within the organization is termed as internal information. The sources include employees, company financial statements, etc.

Page 63: Management Control Systems

ACCOUNTING INFORMATION

Information can be accounting or non-accounting. More importance is given to accounting information as the management control system is built around the accounting core.

OPERATING INFORMATION

Operating information refers to information that is generated in the course of day-to-day operations. The largest quantity of information that flows through a business is operating information. It has been classified into the following streams:

(a) Production stream(b) Purchasing and materials stream(c) Payroll stream(d) Plant & equipment stream(e) Finance stream(f) Cost stream(g) Responsibility accounting stream(h) Sales and accounts receivables stream

Page 64: Management Control Systems

MANAGEMENT CONTROL INFORMATION

This information is received from the control reports which focus on actual performance compared with planned performance.

Each reader studies these reports to detect whether or not something is worth looking into. If nothing significant is noted, the report is set aside. If some peculiarity is identified, then action is taken.

The information in these reports comes from accounting reports and other sources .

Page 65: Management Control Systems

CONTROL INFORMATION AND PROCESS

• Strategic plan implements the goals of organization.

• The strategic plan is converted to annual budget, focussing on revenues and expenses.

• Responsibility centers perform activities according to rules set for them.

• Actual results are compared with those in the budget.

• If performance is satisfactory, feedback is given to the responsibility center in the form of reward or praise.

• If performance is not up to the mark, feedback leads to punitive measures and revision of the plan.