Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

83
1 1 MALAYSIAN RESEARCH EXPERIENCE MALAYSIAN RESEARCH EXPERIENCE IN RAINWATER HARVESTING IN RAINWATER HARVESTING PRESENTED BY: IR. AHMAD JAMALLUDDIN SHAABAN NATIONAL HYDRAULICS RESEARCH INSTITUTE OF MALAYSIA NATIONAL HYDRAULICS RESEARCH INSTITUTE OF MALAYSIA

Transcript of Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

Page 1: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

11

MALAYSIAN RESEARCH EXPERIENCEMALAYSIAN RESEARCH EXPERIENCEIN RAINWATER HARVESTINGIN RAINWATER HARVESTING

PRESENTED BY:IR. AHMAD JAMALLUDDIN SHAABAN

NATIONAL HYDRAULICS RESEARCH INSTITUTE OF MALAYSIANATIONAL HYDRAULICS RESEARCH INSTITUTE OF MALAYSIA

Page 2: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

22

OUTLINEOUTLINE

INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION FOCUS OF RESEARCH FOCUS OF RESEARCH PILOT PROJECTSPILOT PROJECTSUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGEUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGECONCLUSIONCONCLUSION

Page 3: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

33

OUTLINEOUTLINE

INTRODUCTIONINTRODUCTIONFOCUS OF RESEARCHFOCUS OF RESEARCHFOCUS OF RESEARCHPILOT PROJECTSPILOT PROJECTSPILOT PROJECTSUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGEUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGEUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGECONCLUSIONCONCLUSIONCONCLUSION

Page 4: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

44

Drought ImpactsDrought ImpactsMelakaMelaka ––

•• 1998 Water Rationing + Transfer1998 Water Rationing + Transfer

SelangorSelangor ––•• 1998 Water Rationing from April to September1998 Water Rationing from April to September

KedahKedah ––•• Released 15 Released 15 CumecsCumecs for 10 Days to augment for 10 Days to augment Penang’sPenang’s

Water Need in 1998Water Need in 1998

KelantanKelantan --•• 1998 1998 –– KADA built temporary sand dyke to raise KADA built temporary sand dyke to raise

WL at WL at PasirPasir MasMas Pump HousePump House

Page 5: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

55

Drought Impacts Drought Impacts cont…cont…

SabahSabah –– (1998)(1998)•• State Wide RF Deficit ranging from 4 to 9 monthsState Wide RF Deficit ranging from 4 to 9 months•• 2,797 sq. km and 170,000 people affected2,797 sq. km and 170,000 people affected•• 1580 sq. km affected by wild fire1580 sq. km affected by wild fire•• Of these, 100 sq. km are agricultural lands Of these, 100 sq. km are agricultural lands •• 7,200 Farmers affected and Damage Cost ~ RM 7.0 Mil.7,200 Farmers affected and Damage Cost ~ RM 7.0 Mil.•• Water Rationing and Food AidsWater Rationing and Food Aids

Sarawak Sarawak –– (1998)(1998)•• Wild FiresWild Fires•• Air Pollution Air Pollution -- Schools Shut DownSchools Shut Down•• Coastal Areas Coastal Areas –– Water Shortage Water Shortage

Page 6: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

66

STRAITS OFMALACCA

LEGEND :Rainfall Station

WL/Gauging Station

Island

State Boundary

Existing Dam

Proposed Dam

Water Treat. Plant

Town

River

NEGERI SEMBILAN

100o40’ 102o10’102o00’

02o40’

02o50’

03o00’

03o10’

03o20’

03o30’

03o50’

03o40’

PERAK

100o50’

PAHANG

KTengi River

Bernam River

101o00’

SELANGOR

G IH

J

L

Selangor River

Kuala KubuBharu

BatuCA = 50km2

Petaling River

101o20’101o10’

E

Klang River

KlangCA = 77.16km2

Petaling

D

LangatCA = 41km2

ALangat River

101o30’ 101o40’ 101o50’

W 2 B

C

FW1

KUALA LUMPU

R

FEDERAL TERRITOR

Y

SemenyihCA= 56km2

Semenyih W.T Plant

LangatW.T Plant

KUALA SELANGO

R

PETALING JAYA

KAJANGKLANG

SEPANG KLIA

SHAH ALAM

Limit of Inference

LEGEND FOR SPI DROUGHT SEVERITY:

Severe

Moderate

Normal/Near Normal

Figure 5 : Spatial Distribution of the SPI Drought Severity

Page 7: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

77

Evaporation360 bill. m3

(36%)

groundwater64 bill. m3

(7%)

Surface runoff566 bill. m3

(57%)

Rainfall Rainfall –– 3000 mm per yr.3000 mm per yr.Volume Volume –– 990 billion m990 billion m33

-- Annual rainwater approximately 990 billion cubic meter. (Area = Annual rainwater approximately 990 billion cubic meter. (Area = 330,000km square with Average Annual Rainfall 3,000mm).330,000km square with Average Annual Rainfall 3,000mm).

-- 566 billion meter cubic becomes surface runoff566 billion meter cubic becomes surface runoff-- 360 billion meter cubic evaporated360 billion meter cubic evaporated-- 64 billion meter cubic discharges as groundwater64 billion meter cubic discharges as groundwater-- Water consumption approximately 12.5 billion meter cubic (year Water consumption approximately 12.5 billion meter cubic (year

2000) 2000) –– only about 2.2% of the surface runoff.only about 2.2% of the surface runoff.-- But.. Malaysia still have water supply disruption?? (1998 droughBut.. Malaysia still have water supply disruption?? (1998 drought t

brought unpleasant water supply disruptions to 1.8 million residbrought unpleasant water supply disruptions to 1.8 million residents ents of of KlangKlang Valley)Valley)

Page 8: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

88

Can Rainwater reduce the problem?Can Rainwater reduce the problem?What are the benefits of using rainwater??What are the benefits of using rainwater??

Reduce the dependence and demand of public water supply

Reduction of water bills (more attractive monetary Saving from SPAH with increase in water tariff in future)

Additional water supply for fire protection or emergency use

Benefits ofRainwaterHarvesting

To increase soil moisture levels for urban greenery

Reduction of Peak Discharge, Time to Peak Discharge & Volume of Runoff

Reduce salt accumulation in soil which can be harmful to root growth

To increase the ground water table through artificial recharge

Reduce land erosion and flooding

Contribute in overcoming shortage of waterduring extreme droughts

Page 9: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

99

OUTLINEOUTLINE

INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION FOCUS OF RESEARCHFOCUS OF RESEARCHPILOT PROJECTSPILOT PROJECTSPILOT PROJECTSUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGEUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGEUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGECONCLUSIONCONCLUSIONCONCLUSION

Page 10: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

1010

FOCUS OF RESEARCHFOCUS OF RESEARCH

1)1) Supplementing public water supplySupplementing public water supply2)2) Peak Runoff ReductionPeak Runoff Reduction3)3) AestheticsAesthetics4)4) EconomicsEconomics5)5) QualityQuality

Page 11: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

1111

OUTLINEOUTLINE

INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION FOCUS OF RESEARCHFOCUS OF RESEARCHFOCUS OF RESEARCHPILOT PROJECTSPILOT PROJECTSUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGEUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGEUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGECONCLUSIONCONCLUSIONCONCLUSION

Page 12: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

1212

NAHRIM’S PILOT SPAH PROJECTSNAHRIM’S PILOT SPAH PROJECTS

DOMESTICDOMESTIC- A double storey terrace house at Taman Wangsa Melawati,

Kuala Lumpur

PUBLIC FACILITYPUBLIC FACILITY- A mosque Complex at Taman Bukit Indah, Ampang- Secondary School, Sri Aman Girls’ School- Bukit Jalil Secondary School

OFFICE COMPLEXOFFICE COMPLEX- Head Quarters of Department of Irrigation and Drainage (DID), Kuala

Lumpur- NAHRIM Complex

Page 13: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

1313

Rainwater System ComponentsRainwater System Components

Catchment Catchment -- roofroofConveyance Conveyance –– gutters and downpipesgutters and downpipesFiltering Filtering –– first flushfirst flushStorage Tank Storage Tank Booster pump Booster pump Roof tank Roof tank Distribution Distribution -- plumbing (to toilets, washing plumbing (to toilets, washing machine and general use) machine and general use)

Page 14: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

1414

150mm. Gutter

150 mm Gutter

75mm. Conveyance pVc Pipe

75 mm. Conveyance pVc Pipe

Ultrasonic

Flow meter

20mm. Overflow Pipe

Rainwater collected from roof

Rainwater collected from roof

First Flush Device

40mm. Scour Valve

Filter Media (mesh)

Filter Media (mesh)

5,000 liters Storage Tank

Pumpset(Electrical)25 mm

Valve

25mm. valve

1” valve

Roof Storage Tank

25mm Main

15 mm. Distribution pipe

W.C W.C

Connected to separate roof tank W.C

50mm. Scour Valve

1st FLOOR

Bathroom 2

Bathroom 115 mm.Tap

Bathroom 3

Rainfall Station

Water Level Indicator

Page 15: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

1515

Page 16: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

1616

Page 17: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

1717

Storage Cum Detention TankStorage Cum Detention Tank

Page 18: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

1818

Rainwater Use for various facilitiesRainwater Use for various facilities

14141,9501,9506565General Cleaning General Cleaning (including car and (including car and motorcycle washing)motorcycle washing)

10010013,65013,650455455TotalTotal

20202,7002,7009090Toilet Flushing (3 Toilet Flushing (3 W.CsW.Cs))

66669,0009,000300300Washing clothesWashing clothes

%%Average monthly Average monthly use (liters)use (liters)

Average daily use Average daily use (liters)(liters)

ItemItem

Monthly Rainwater useMonthly Rainwater use : 13,650 liters (34%): 13,650 liters (34%)Monthly water use (from public water supply)Monthly water use (from public water supply) : 27,000 liters (66%): 27,000 liters (66%)Total Monthly Household Water UseTotal Monthly Household Water Use : 40,650 liters : 40,650 liters

Page 19: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

1919

SYSTEM COST (Double Terrace House)SYSTEM COST (Double Terrace House)

4,3004,300TotalTotal

750750Water Pump (electrical)Water Pump (electrical)

2,5002,5001 No1 NoBrick Tank (ground) 5,000 liters capacityBrick Tank (ground) 5,000 liters capacity

2002001 No1 NoWater Tank (top)Water Tank (top)

400400Plumbing WorksPlumbing Works

200200Conveyance SystemConveyance System

150150Gutter (Gutter (uPVCuPVC))Amount (RM)Amount (RM)UnitUnitItemsItems

Page 20: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

2020

UNIT COST OF RAINWATERUNIT COST OF RAINWATER(Brick Tank)(Brick Tank)

C = Initial Capital CostC = Initial Capital CostN = Expected system lifeN = Expected system lifeC = RM 4,300.00C = RM 4,300.00N = 20N = 20C/N C/N = RM 215.00= RM 215.00Operating CostOperating Cost = RM 53.08= RM 53.08Total Annual CostTotal Annual Cost = RM 268.00= RM 268.00YieldYield = 102 meter cubic= 102 meter cubicUnit Cost of RainwaterUnit Cost of Rainwater = Annual Cost/ Yield= Annual Cost/ Yield

= RM 2.63/ meter cubic= RM 2.63/ meter cubic

-- The rainwater system (storage 5mThe rainwater system (storage 5m³³, 6 person) could meet up to , 6 person) could meet up to 34% of the domestic non34% of the domestic non--potable household water requirement.potable household water requirement.

-- Peak storm runoff reduction )when rainwater cum detention Peak storm runoff reduction )when rainwater cum detention storage systems are installed at all the houses) at the storage systems are installed at all the houses) at the catchmentcatchment outlet achieved is 24% (can be up to 70% if extend to outlet achieved is 24% (can be up to 70% if extend to the shop house, mosque, kindergarten and the community the shop house, mosque, kindergarten and the community recreational park.recreational park.

Page 21: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

2121

Figure 3 : Reliability (%) for 60 m2 and 100 m2 Roof Catchment Areas vs various Tank Sizes - Water Demand of 455 litres/day -

(Roof Runoff Coefficient = 0.8)

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45

TANK SIZE (m3)

REL

IAB

ILIT

Y (%

)

Roof Catchment = 100 m2

Roof Catchment = 60 m2

Page 22: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

2222

A Mosque Complex at Taman A Mosque Complex at Taman Bukit Indah, AmpangBukit Indah, Ampang

151 .723

47 ’33°

20"

123°

31.682

47’10"

20"47’

123°

10"

80.905

Page 23: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

2323

HDPE SHEET

TANK MODULE

The Installation of SPAH at Mosque Complex,The Installation of SPAH at Mosque Complex,Taman Bukit Indah (During Investigation)Taman Bukit Indah (During Investigation)

MASJID BUKIT INDAH, AMPANG

Page 24: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

2424

Page 25: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

2525

HDPE SHEET

TANK MODULE

Page 26: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

2626

Figure 3 : Underground Storage Tank (Cross-section)

12440

890

200

500

200

1300 200

PARKING AREA

200

8360 2040 2040

EXCAVATION EDGE250mm Ø INLET PIPE

EXIST. SUMP

HDPE LINER

1:50

SUBMERSIBLE PUMPWITH FLOATING INLET1 LAYER DRAINAGE CELL

1224Om x 5785m x 0.89m DEPTH

200mm THK. SAND BEDDING

PARKING SURFACE COMPACTED EARTHHYDRONET

200mm THK. SAND

ATLANTIS STORAGE TANK

HEAVY DUTY COVER ATLANTIS STORAGE TANK1224Om x 5785m x 0.89m DEPTH225mm THK BRICK

4mm THK. CHEQUE PLATE

HYDRONETOR APPROVE EQUIVALENT

EXCAVATION EDGE

Page 27: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

2727

STRIP FILTER PIPE

Page 28: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

2828

RAIN WATER SENSOR UNIT

Page 29: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

2929

Page 30: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

3030

CONSTANT PRESSURESTARTER PANEL

Sump

PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY

Permanently marked50mm Ø discharge pipe

RAINWATER / STORMWATER CONVEYANCE PIPE

RAINWATER / STORMWATER CONVEYANCE PIPE

GRUNDFOS PUMPSQE 3-65

FLOW METER

PRESSURE TANK,PRESSURE GAUGE,PRESSURE TRANSMITTERAND FLOW SWITCH

SENSOR CABLE

COLD WATER TANK COLD WATER TANK

COLD WATER TANK

Mechanism for automatic switching on of Public Water Supply in the case of power failure (i.e. pumps not working)

NON RETURN VALVE

Page 31: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

3131

WATER DEMANDWATER DEMAND-- Daily water demand = 15,000 liters (based on 2,500 person utilizDaily water demand = 15,000 liters (based on 2,500 person utilizing 6 liters per ing 6 liters per

toilet flush)toilet flush)-- Total daily water demand = 26,250 liters (for Total daily water demand = 26,250 liters (for wudhuwudhu, toilet flushing and general , toilet flushing and general

cleaning)cleaning)SYSTEM COSTSYSTEM COST

System Cost (C) = RM 95,000.00System Cost (C) = RM 95,000.00Life Expectancy (N) = 25 YearsLife Expectancy (N) = 25 YearsC/N = RM 3,800.00C/N = RM 3,800.00Operating Cost (est.) = RM 300.00Operating Cost (est.) = RM 300.00Total Annual Cost = RM 4,100.00Total Annual Cost = RM 4,100.00Rainwater Utilized = 3249 Rainwater Utilized = 3249 m³m³ per annumper annumUnit cost of Water = RM 1.26 per Unit cost of Water = RM 1.26 per m³m³

For comparison purposes the water rates in Kuala Lumpur and SelaFor comparison purposes the water rates in Kuala Lumpur and Selangorngorfor selected categories are given below:for selected categories are given below:--Religious Institution = RM 0.46 per Religious Institution = RM 0.46 per m³m³--Residential houses = RM 2.00 per meter cubic (for consumption Residential houses = RM 2.00 per meter cubic (for consumption > 35 m> 35 m³³))--Government building = RM 1.61 per Government building = RM 1.61 per m³m³

Can save up to 34% of public water supply annually with unit Can save up to 34% of public water supply annually with unit cost RM 1.26 per m³.cost RM 1.26 per m³.

Page 32: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

3232

Mosque Complex at Taman Bukit Indah

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

60 90 120 150 180 210

Tank Size (m3)

Rel

iabi

lity

(%)

Catchment Area = 3569 m2 Catchment Area = 5477 m2

Page 33: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

3333

WATER QUALITY ASPECTSWATER QUALITY ASPECTSCollection and storage of rainwater introduces the potential forchemical, physical and microbial contamination.

The most common hazards in water sources obtained from surface catchments worldwide, including roof run-off, are microbial pathogens origin (enteric pathogens).

Collecting rainwater for drinking and cooking are not recommended in area affected by airborne pollution form very heavy traffic and industrial activities or agricultural crop dusting or spraying.

Microorganisms may be present in rainwater collected in domestictanks, but provided the systems are well maintained, the risk ofharmful organisms being present is low.

Page 34: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

3434

MAINTAINING RAINWATER QUALITYMAINTAINING RAINWATER QUALITYEnsuring the quality of rainwater collected requires sensible maintainance of rainwater tank and roof catchments. The following simple steps can be taken to help improve rainwater quality:

Regularly inspect and clean gutters, roof catchments and tank screens.Remove overhead branches.Consider installing gutter screens or guards.Ensure tank does not become a mosquito breeding site by preventing access and cleaning screens regularly.Examine tank for accumulation of sludge every 2 to 3 years and remove by siphon or by empting the tank.40 mm of liquids sodium hypo-chlorides or 7gm granular calcium hypo-chlorites per 1000 liters of water.

Page 35: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

3535

METHODOLOGYMETHODOLOGY

Chemical Parameters: Physical Parameters:

Dissolved Oxygen (DO) Turbidity

Water Quality Parameters

Measured are:

TemperaturepH

Sulphate

Ferum

PhosphateMicrobial Parameters:

CopperE- Coli

Ammoniac NitrogenColiform

Page 36: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

3636

WATER CLASSESWATER CLASSES

None of the aboveCLASS V

IrrigationCLASS IV

Water Supply III – extensive treatment required(Fishery III – common of economic value and tolerant species livestock drinking)

CLASS III

Recreational use with body contactCLASS II B

Water supply II – Conventional treatment required (Fishery II – sensitive aquatic species)

CLASS II A

Conservation of natural environment water supply 1 – practically n treatment necessary (Fishery 1 – very sensitive aquatic species)

CLASS 1USESCLASSES

Page 37: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

3737

INTERIM NATIONAL WATER QUALITY STANDARDS FOR MALAYSIAINTERIM NATIONAL WATER QUALITY STANDARDS FOR MALAYSIA

>50000500005000050005000100Total Caliform

-5000 (20000)*5000 (20000)*

40010010Faecal Coliform

---50505Turbidity / NTU

--Normal 2CNormal 2C-Temperature

300300-505025Total Suspended Solid

-4000--1000500Total Dissolved Solid

---150NNTaste

-2--10.5Salinity/ %

---15015015Colour/ (TCU)

-5 – 95 – 96 – 96 – 96.5 –8.5pH

<1<33 – 55 – 75 – 77DO (mg/l)

>10010050252510COD (mg/l)

>12126331BOD (mg/l)

>2.72.70.90.30.30.1Ammoniacal Nitrogen (mg/l)

VIVIIIIIBIIAIPARAMETERS/ UNIT

CLASSES

Notes: N: No visible floatable materials or debris or No objectionable odors, or No objectionable taste.•: maximum not to be exceeded

Page 38: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

3838

ANALYSISANALYSIS

Table 1: Analysis readings of rainwater monitoring in 2003

0.02 – 0.20.01 – 0.060.01 – 0.08mg/lCopper

10.02 – 0.330.01 – 0.12mg/lAmmoniacalNitrogen

10.01 – 0.50.01 – 0.06mg/lFerum2501 – 120 – 1mg/lSO4

Normal +2C19.6 – 32.125 – 30.4( C )Temperature6 – 96.52 – 7.326.3 – 8.63pH5000<1 – 2419<1 – 980MPNColiform400<1 – 1986<1 – 410MPNE-Coli

5 – 73.4 – 5.363.4 – 5.9mg/lDO502.68 – 11.71.38 – 7.4NTUTurbidity

CLASS II B (INTERIM MALAYSIA

STANDARD)

MOSQUE COMPLEX

DOUBLE STOREY HOUSE

UNITPARAMETER

Page 39: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

3939

ANALYSISANALYSIS

Table 2: Analysis readings of rainwater monitoring in 2004

0.02 – 0.20.16 – 0.190.06 – 0.11mg/lCopper

10.07 – 0.410.1 – 0.19mg/lAmmoniacalNitrogen

10.05 – 0.80.02 – 0.03mg/lFerum2508 – 130 – 1mg/lSO4

Normal +2C2525 ( C )Temperature6 – 96.98 – 7.617.72 – 8.03pH5000184 – 829<1 – 1011MPNColiform40023 – 69<1 – 53MPNE-Coli

5 – 72.8 – 4.44.2 – 5.3mg/lDO501.11– 5.211.4 – 2.21NTUTurbidity

CLASS II B (INTERIM MALAYSIA

STANDARD)

MOSQUE COMPLEX

DOUBLE STOREY HOUSE

UNITPARAMETER

Page 40: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

4040

ANALYSISANALYSIS

Table 3: Analysis readings of rainwater monitoring in 2005

0.02 – 0.20.12 – 0.380.13 – 0.18mg/lCopper

10.01 – 0.150.01 – 0.18mg/lAmmoniacalNitrogen

10.10 – 0.350.01 – 0.03mg/lFerum2505 – 100 – 2mg/lSO4

Normal +2C25.1 – 29.025.1 – 30.4( C )Temperature6 – 96.98 – 7.967.42 – 8.08pH5000<1 – 2400<1 – 2400MPNColiform400<1 – 214<1 – 236MPNE-Coli

5 – 74.5 – 5.53.5 – 6.4mg/lDO500.13 – 7.380.4 – 2.74NTUTurbidity

CLASS II B (INTERIM MALAYSIA

STANDARD)

MOSQUE COMPLEX

DOUBLE STOREY HOUSE

UNITPARAMETER

Page 41: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

4141

RESULTRESULTThe quality of rainwater is within the acceptable limit except for E-Coli (2003).

Standard Class IIB – recreational use with body contact.

Not for drinking purpose but useful for other purpose such as toilet flushing, watering plants, washing car, cleaning up porch, gardening, etc.

Page 42: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

4242

POLICY DEVELOPMENTPOLICY DEVELOPMENT

RWU GUIDELINES BY KPKT IN 1999

NWRC RESOLUTION (ENCOURAGING RWU)

Page 43: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

4343

ECONOMIC INSTRUMENTS TO ECONOMIC INSTRUMENTS TO ENCOURAGE RAINWATER ENCOURAGE RAINWATER UTILISATIONUTILISATION

1- provision of subsidies2- tax and cost rebates3- education and raising awareness4- guidelines

Page 44: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

4444

1) 1) Provision of SubsidiesProvision of Subsidies

Higher cost of installation, maintenance and usage of rain water harvesting than piped water.

=>consideration for subsidies to encourage the public to install RWU systems.

In Japan, there is no national legislation governing the practice of RWU, but local governments are very active in promoting RWU by way of subsidies.

Page 45: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

4545

For example, In Yamata City of Kanagawa, the local authorities installed 19 rainwater tanks in all 19 municipal primary schools as a means of promoting environment education.

In the city of Kobe where a 150-200 liters rainwater tank costs between 30,000-50,000 yens, the government will subsidize up to 2/3 of the cost, as a step to encourage the installation of the system.

Page 46: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

4646

In Australia, Queensland’s state government have set up a new program, the Home Water Wise Service, which is a subsidized service that sees licensed plumbers visiting homes to install a range of water efficient devices and providing advice on water saving strategies.

Homeowners can receive a water audit on their home, replace their old showerheads for water-efficient ones, fix leaking taps and receive information and advice on how to make their home water efficient.

Page 47: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

4747

2)2) Tax & Cost RebatesTax & Cost Rebates

Tax RebateTax Rebate

Consideration of offering homeowners/members of public who choose to participate in RWU and manufacturers and suppliers of RWU systems or equipment.

This tax rebate for home owners has been implemented successfully in India.

e.g. in the cities of Indore and Gwalior in the state of Madhya Pradesh, a rebate of 6 % on property tax has been offered by the municipal corporation as incentive to encourage the public for implementing RWU systems.

Page 48: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

4848

Consideration for tax rebate for various stakeholders such as manufacturers, suppliers, housing developers, contractors who are involved in RWU systems production and installation.

e.g. In Texas, USA, the State Government provides a Sales Tax Redemption for water efficiency equipment – including equipment for RWU. RWU materials are tax-free. Measures such as this willencourage the participation of the stakeholders.

Page 49: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

4949

Cost Rebates to Property OwnersCost Rebates to Property Owners

Providing rebates for the purchase and installation of RWU equipment and installation.

This has been implemented successfully in Australia where each state government implements its own scheme to implement and encourage RWU among homeowners.

e.g. in Queensland, under the Home Water Wise Rebate Scheme, most City Councils will offer various rebates for the purchase and installation of the water tanks and other related items such as showerheads, toilets, etc.

Page 50: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

5050

e.g. In Pine Rivers Shire, rebates are given to encourage homeowners to participate in RWU to reduce relying on piped water supply. Rebate is given for pumps and other RWU-friendly equipment, plumbing materials and installation cost. The council is also waiving the inspection fee. Rebate also given for the replacement from a single flush toilet to a dual flush toilet suite.

In Sydney, rebates are given for the installation of rainwater tanks. Eligibility and amount of the rebate is determined on the fulfillment of required conditions, size of the tank and whether the rainwater is connected to your toilet or washing machine.

Page 51: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

5151

e.g. Brisbane City Council provides rebates for homeowners who purchase water tanks and fulfill other conditions that has been set by the Council.

Residential or Body Corporate Rebate is provided for the purchase of tanks. An internal connection rebate is also available.

e.g. in Toowoomba, rebates are offered for homeowner who purchases a rainwater tank. To be eligible for the rebate, the tanks must have a capacity of at least 5,000 liters, and be connected to at least one toilet cistern or alternatively, to the washing machine; and to a garden tap.

Page 52: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

5252

3) 3) Education and Raising AwarenessEducation and Raising Awareness

Campaigns by various related Government Agencies and mass media to be conducted to promote benefit and importance of RWU.

Steps should be taken to incorporate RWU into school education curriculum.

In Australia, certain state governments have introduced a Rainwater Tanks in School Program whereby participating schools will be given a rebate for the installation of a rainwater tank. Besides that, awareness campaigns on importance of conserving water is also done in the schools.

Page 53: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

5353

4)4) GuidelinesGuidelines

Malaysia has “Guidelines for Installing a Rainwater Collection and Utilization System” It generally does not deal with cost and implementation issues. A standardized and user friendly guideline, will be more convenient for consumers to install and maintain suitable rainwater harvesting systems .

Page 54: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

5454

Each city council in the state of Queensland has its own Guidelines for Installation of Rainwater Tanks

In UK, although RWU is not mandatory, homeowners are free to install the system, but still need to comply with existing regulations and guidelines.

In Germany, RWU has yet to be made mandatory and no specific legislation is available. However, there is a national guidelines to regulate RWU.

Page 55: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

5555

RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS

With regard to Malaysia, it is recommended that a combination of the methods stated above should be implemented.

From a legal perspective, introducing RWU under a by law would be the more feasible method by amending the Uniform Building By-Laws to include a requirement for RWU installation in buildings.

Page 56: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

5656

Monetary or economic incentives like cash or tax rebates and subsidies in purchasing or installing RWU devices should be introduced to attract public interest.

Education and awareness campaigns should start from the early stages to instill a sense of awareness.

Page 57: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

5757

TANGKI NAHRIM (Software Application)TANGKI NAHRIM (Software Application)

NAHRIM has its own software called NAHRIM has its own software called TangkiTangki NAHRIM for NAHRIM for RWH research purpose.RWH research purpose.

contains meteorological data. contains meteorological data.

Beneficial to researchers or engineers to design an accurate Beneficial to researchers or engineers to design an accurate and suitable rainwater system.and suitable rainwater system.

Contain whole Malaysia rainfall data in its database software.Contain whole Malaysia rainfall data in its database software.

Page 58: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

5858

TangkiTangki NahrimNahrim Dialogue BoxDialogue Box

Page 59: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

5959

TangkiTangki NahrimNahrim Dialogue BoxDialogue Box

Page 60: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

6060

OBJECTIVES UPGRADING OBJECTIVES UPGRADING TANGKI NAHRIM SOFTWARETANGKI NAHRIM SOFTWARE

Tangki NAHRIM Objectives::

Measure an optimum storage tank size and its reliability

Measure total volume of collected and distributed rainwater

Measure rainwater system efficiency

To provide a user friendly software

To support in SPAH development project around Malaysia

Page 61: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

6161

BENEFITS OF NEW BENEFITS OF NEW TANGKI NAHRIM SOFTWARETANGKI NAHRIM SOFTWARE

Benefits:

User friendly

Allow user to import rainfall data in Microsoft Access Format through floppy disk, CD and etc.

Suitable to use for many states in Malaysiasince it contains a lot of rainfall data

in its software database.

Better simulation result (more accurate)

Flexible water demand input

Page 62: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

6262

Proposal of Rainwater Harvesting SystemProposal of Rainwater Harvesting System(SPAH) for NAHRIM Complex(SPAH) for NAHRIM Complex

NAHRIM Complex

Page 63: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

6363

PROPOSAL OBJECTIVEPROPOSAL OBJECTIVEFOR SPAH IN NAHRIMFOR SPAH IN NAHRIM

For general cleaning purpose For general cleaning purpose For toilet usage (at administration and For toilet usage (at administration and library buildings) at 2769.2 liter per day.library buildings) at 2769.2 liter per day.For landscaping purposeFor landscaping purpose

Page 64: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

6464

TangkiTangki NAHRIM ApplicationNAHRIM Application

101020202525

Tank Tank Size Size (m3)(m3)

10877.910877.912959.912959.913488.413488.4

Rainwater Rainwater Delivered Delivered (m3)(m3)

39769.839769.839769.839769.839769.839769.8

Rainwater Rainwater capturedcaptured

(m3)(m3)

29.5229.5233.9333.9335.1035.10

27.3527.3514.9814.9811.3911.39

29.2829.2814.9814.9811.3911.39

71.6971.6985.4185.4188.9088.90

Storage Storage Efficiency Efficiency (%)(%)

Coefficient Coefficient of of Rainwater Rainwater UtilisationUtilisation(%)(%)

% Time % Time Tank Empty Tank Empty

Reliability Reliability (%)(%)

--The size of rainwater storage tank estimated by using The size of rainwater storage tank estimated by using

TangkiTangki NAHRIM Software.NAHRIM Software.

--The Optimum size of storage tank is 20 mThe Optimum size of storage tank is 20 m³³ with with reliability about 85.41%.reliability about 85.41%.

--Propose to use Propose to use underground tankunderground tank to save the to save the construction cost and to save space.construction cost and to save space.

Page 65: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

6565

Propose Propose Rainwater TankRainwater Tank LocationLocation

PHASE 1 CONSTRUCTION AREA(GROUND AND FIRST FLOOR TOILET)

PHASE 1 CONSTRUCTION AREA(BILIK PENGARAH TOILET)

PHASE 1 CONSTRUCTION AREA(PUSAT SUMBER TOILET)

PHASE 1 CONSTRUCTION AREA(MAKMAL TOILET)

UnderGround Tank

Page 66: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

6666

SUMP

CATCHMENTS AREA

RAINWATER TANK

Page 67: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

6767

PIPE DIAGRAM FOR SPAH SYSTEM PIPE DIAGRAM FOR SPAH SYSTEM AT ADMINISTRATION BUILDING IN NAHRIM.AT ADMINISTRATION BUILDING IN NAHRIM.

Page 68: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

6868

PIPE DIAGRAM FOR SPAH SYSTEM PIPE DIAGRAM FOR SPAH SYSTEM AT LIBRARY BUILDING IN NAHRIM.AT LIBRARY BUILDING IN NAHRIM.

Page 69: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

6969

OUTLINEOUTLINE

INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION FOCUS OF RESEARCHFOCUS OF RESEARCHFOCUS OF RESEARCHPILOT PROJECTSPILOT PROJECTSPILOT PROJECTSUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGEUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGECONCLUSIONCONCLUSIONCONCLUSION

Page 70: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

7070

CLIMATE CHANGE PROJECTIONCLIMATE CHANGE PROJECTION

+11% to +43% +11% to +43% (Flood Flows)(Flood Flows)

--31% to 93% 31% to 93% (Low Flows)(Low Flows)

River Flows (m3/s)River Flows (m3/s)

+10% +10% (Kelantan, Terengganu & Pahang)(Kelantan, Terengganu & Pahang)

--5% 5% (Selangor & Johor)(Selangor & Johor)

Annual Rainfall (mm)Annual Rainfall (mm)

--0.210.21--0.480.48

Sea level rise (m)Sea level rise (m)(Emission Scenario SRES (Emission Scenario SRES

A1B)A1B)

1.51.52.82.81.61.6Surface temperature (ºC)Surface temperature (ºC)(Emission Scenario SRES (Emission Scenario SRES

A1B) A1B)

205020502100210020502050

MALAYSIA**MALAYSIA**GLOBAL*GLOBAL*

* IPCC WG1 4TH ASESSMENT REPORT (AR4), 2007** STUDY ON IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON HYDROLOGIC REGIME AND

WATER RESOURCES OF P MALAYSIA, NAHRIM, 2006

Page 71: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

7171

Future RainfallFuture RainfallIn annual rainfall:In annual rainfall:10% increase for Kelantan, Terengganu and Pahang10% increase for Kelantan, Terengganu and Pahang

5% decrease for Selangor and Johor5% decrease for Selangor and Johor

More droughts More droughts ieie ddryry years (2028, 2029, 2034, 2042 and 2044)years (2028, 2029, 2034, 2042 and 2044)

A increase in mean monthly rainfall over the North East Coastal A increase in mean monthly rainfall over the North East Coastal region and region and over Kelantanover Kelantan

A decrease in mean monthly rainfall over Selangor and JohorA decrease in mean monthly rainfall over Selangor and Johor

Higher maximum and lower minimum rainfall are observed in the fuHigher maximum and lower minimum rainfall are observed in the future in ture in many sub regionsmany sub regions

More extreme hydrological conditions may be expectedMore extreme hydrological conditions may be expected

Page 72: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

7272

Simulated annual rainfall (historical and future period) at sub regions of Peninsular Malaysia

Page 73: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

7373

Wet Year1989 2043

Page 74: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

7474

Dry Year1993 2044

Page 75: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

7575

Future River FlowsFuture River FlowsFuture monthly flows Future monthly flows -- the maximum monthly the maximum monthly flows will be significantly higher (11%flows will be significantly higher (11%--43%) for 43%) for Kelantan, Terengganu and Pahang and the Kelantan, Terengganu and Pahang and the minimum monthly flows significantly lower (31%minimum monthly flows significantly lower (31%--93%) for Selangor and Johor93%) for Selangor and Johor

An increase in interAn increase in inter--annual and intraannual and intra--seasonal seasonal variability with increased hydrologic extremes variability with increased hydrologic extremes (higher high flows, and lower low flows) in (higher high flows, and lower low flows) in Kelantan, Pahang, Terengganu and Kedah Kelantan, Pahang, Terengganu and Kedah watershedswatersheds

Page 76: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

7676

Periodic means and standard deviations of simulated monthly flows during thehistorical (1984-1993) and future (2025-2034 and 2041-2050) periods at

Jambatan. Jerangau, Dungun, Terengganu (region no. 4)

Page 77: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

7777

Periodic means and standard deviations of simulated monthly flows during thehistorical (1984-1993) and future (2025-2034 and 2041-2050) periods at Rantau

Panjang, Johor (region no. 9).

Page 78: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

7878

OUTLINEOUTLINE

INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION FOCUS OF RESEARCHFOCUS OF RESEARCHFOCUS OF RESEARCHPILOT PROJECTSPILOT PROJECTSPILOT PROJECTSUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGEUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGEUPCOMING WATER CHALLENGECONCLUSIONCONCLUSION

Page 79: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

7979

CONCLUSIONCONCLUSION

For the Double Storey Terrace House:

• The Rainwater system (storage 5 m3 , 6 persons) could meet up to 34 % of the domestic non-potable household water requirements.

• The unit cost is RM2.63/m3• Peak storm runoff reduction (when rainwater

cum detention storage systems are installed at all the houses) at the catchment outlet achieved is 24% (Can be up to 70% if extended to the shophouses, mosque, kindergarten and the community recreational park

Page 80: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

8080

CONCLUSION (contd)CONCLUSION (contd)

For the Mosque Complex:

•Can save up to 34% pf the public water supply annually•The unit cost is RM1.26/m3

Page 81: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

8181

CONCLUSION CONCLUSION ((contdcontd))RoofwaterRoofwater harvesting can make a substantial harvesting can make a substantial contribution to security of urban water supply especially contribution to security of urban water supply especially when existing system is already stressedwhen existing system is already stressedIt doesn’t drought proof urban area It doesn’t drought proof urban area Need Need contingency planscontingency plansDonDon’’t overlook social and institutional issues t overlook social and institutional issues RoofwaterRoofwater harvesting will only work if people properly harvesting will only work if people properly use and maintain it use and maintain it

Page 82: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

8282

CONCLUSIONCONCLUSIONRainwater Harvesting is a traditional practice picked

up by a group of scientists and development practitioners, as a focus of their interest, study, and practice to help poor and rural communities in their quest for water to drink.

Today we see the usefulness of the technology not only for the poor communities. It has made itself relevant in other aspects of living – flood/ disaster mitigation, food and water security, environmental rehabilitation and now, in coping with climate change.As ancient wisdom meets science, Rainwater Harvesting is born.

Page 83: Malaysian Research Experience in Rainwater Harvesting

8383