Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
Transcript of Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
1/38
Environmental Impacts of
a Major Marine Oil Spill
Prepared by
Stafford ReidEnvironmental Emergency Planner
Enforcement and Environmental
Emergencies Branch
BC Ministry of Water, Land and
Air Protection
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
2/38
Presentation Outline
Major Marine Oil Spill Incidents
Oil Spill Risk In British Columbia
Oil Types and Characteristics Oil Behaviour (Fate and Effects)
Oil Impacts
A Case Study -Exxon Valdez
Coastal Inventory and Oil Sensitivity Mapping
Shore Cleanup and Assessment
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
3/38
Torrey Canyon - England
(March 1967)
A Liberian-registered
tankeren route from the
Persian Gulf was strandedby an error in ship
manoeuvring, releasing
93,000 tonnes of crude
oil. Contaminated 300kilometres of both
England and France.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
4/38
Amoco Cadiz- France
(1978)
A Liberian-registered
tankeren route to
England grounded on
a reef off the coast of
Brittany (France) and
releasing 260,000
tonnes of crude oil.
Contaminated 400 km
of coast. Took sixmonths to collect and
dispose of the drifting
oil.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
5/38
Sea Empress - Wales
(February 15, 1996)
The single-hulled
Liberian oil tanker ran
aground on St. AnnsHead at the mouth of
Milford Haven estuary,
Wales, rupturing several
tanks. It released 72,000tonnes of light North
Sea Crude.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
6/38
Braer- Scotland
(January 5, 1993)
An 18 years old, American
owned, but Liberian-
registered, oil tanker that
ran aground at Garth Ness
in the Shetlands in severe
weather conditions. Cause
was complete enginefailure. Spilled its entire
cargo of 85,000 tonnes of
North Sea Crude.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
7/38
Exxon Valdez- United States
(March 24, 1989)
A US-flagged tankeren
route to Long Beach
California wrecked on
Bligh Reef in PrinceWilliam Sound, Alaska
due to Captain error.
Eight of the eleven tanks
damaged, releasing
41,000 tonnes of AlaskaNorthslope Crude Oil.
Contaminated 1,900
kilometers of coast.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
8/38
Nestucca - United States (December 23, 1988)
The fuel bargeNestucca and
its tender tug Ocean Service
collided of the mouth of
Grays Harbour, State ofWashington. An estimated
890 tonnes of heavy Bunker
C oil spilled from the
ruptured barge. The oil
drifted past Cape Flattery andstranded along the west coast
of Vancouver Island, British
Columbia.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
9/38
Tenyo Maru - United States
(July 22, 1991)
Off the entrance to the Juan de Fuca Strait,
the Japanese fishing vessel Tenyo Maru and
Chinese freighterTuo Hai collided. The
Tenyo Maru sank, releasing 365 tonnes ofbunker fuel. The slick travelled southwest to
the State of Washingtons Cape Flattery
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
10/38
New Carissa - United States
(February 3, 1999)
A Japanese-owned, but
Panamanian-flagged bulk
carrier on its way to Coos
Bay, Oregon (US) lost
anchor during storm
conditions and grounded
outside of Coos Harbour. It
held 1,490 tonnes of bunkerfuel, spilling 268 tonnes
when it broke in half.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
11/38
Kuroshima - United States
(November 26, 1997)
A 368 foot seafood
freighter broke away
from its anchorage
during a severe stormand ran aground spilling
145 tonnes of Bunker C
oil. Contaminated
approximately 10
kilometres of shorelineof Summer Bay on the
Aleutian Island of
Unalaska.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
12/38
Quantities of Oil Spilled 1970 - 1999
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
13/38
Spill Trend - 1970 to 1999
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
14/38
Oil Barge & Tanker Routes
Nestucca
Exxon Valdez
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
15/38
The Great Circle Route
- Major Vessels
New Carissa
Kuroshima
Tenyo Maru
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
16/38
Relative Spill Risk - British Columbia
Oil Tankers
(e.g. US TAPS)
Risk = Function of Probability &
Consequences
Major Vessels (e.g.Cargo,
Container, Bulk Carriers)
Bulk Oil Barges
Fuel Handling Facilities
High Probability,Low
Consequences
Low Probability, High
Consequences
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
17/38
Spill Scenario 1 - Outer Juan de Fuca Strait
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
18/38
Spill Scenario 2 - Rosario Strait
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
19/38
Fate and Effect of Spilled Oil
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
20/38
Fate & Affect by Oil Type
DENSITY EXAMPLES
Group I less than 0.8 Gasoline, Kerosene
Group II 0.8 - 0.85 Gas Oil, Abu Dhabi Crude
Group III 0.85-0.95 Arabian Light Crude, North Sea Crude
Group IV greater than 0.95 Heavy Fuel Oil, Venezuelan Crude Oils
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
21/38
Impacts of a Major Oil Spill
Destroys Marine Life
Destabilizes MarineCommunities
Degrades Shore Amenities
Harms Economic Activities
Impacts Human Welfare
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
22/38
Destroys Marine Life
Physical contamination and smothering are primary
mechanisms that adversely affecting marine life -
particularly inter-tidal organisms. Oil can also change the
physical characteristics of a habitat.
Clean-up activities can add to these effects by crushing,
removing, and damaging marine life.
Birds and mammals suffer the greatest acute impact whenthey meet the oil/water interface and become contaminated.
Reduction in thermal capability, and directed toxicity from
fumes and ingestion are the greatest causes of mortality.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
23/38
Destabilizes Marine Communities
and Populations
Marine communities, such as planktonic waters,
wetlands (estuaries/marshes), kelp-beds and mud-
flats, and marine populations such as seabirds, seals
sea otters, and whales have variable resiliency to oilspills - from highly tolerant (plankton, kelp beds) to
very intolerant (estuaries and sea otters).
Impacts to communities and populations are very
difficult to measure due to lack of scientific methodsto measure, long-term, sub-lethal, and chronic
ecological impacts
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
24/38
Degrades Shore Amenities
Contamination of coastal amenity areas is a common
feature with many marine oil spills, leading to public
disquiet and concern regarding impacts to boating, sun-bathing, swimming, angling and other recreational pursuits.
The prevailing question is how much and how long of an
impact? The degree of impact to recreation is largely based
on the season it occurred.. Summer being the highest impactperiod due to recreation and tourism.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
25/38
Harms Economic Activities
Economic activities that can be adversely affected by
an oil spill include: tourism, hotel and restaurant
businesses, dive and fishing charters, rentals, marinaoperations. There can also be direct impacts to
commercial fishing and aquaculture due to closures or
concerns about tainted products.
The impacts to a coastal communities economicactivities can be accentuated by media press, beyond
the actual impacts to the recreational and commercial
opportunities.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
26/38
Impacts Human Welfare
A spills impact to human welfare is often under-rated.
Coastal communities, and public in general, are deeply
passionate about a safe, clean marine environment. There is
no tolerance for accidental spills of oil of any quantity. Assuch a marine oil spill accentuates this passion, often
beyond rationale thinking.
During an incident, public stress and anxiety prevail over
the long-term economic uncertainty of lost welfare. Inaddition, a large influx of spill money can divide a
communities from those the volunteer from their
hearts and those the offer their services for a fee.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
27/38
Spill Impact Recovery
The recovery of the marine
environment from the effects of
a spill is generally thought to be
a return to the preciseconditions that preceded the
oil spill. However, this is very
unlikely to happen. As such,
the measurement of spill
recovery is based on a
comparison of unoiled sites
with oiled sites of similar
ecological characteristics.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
28/38
A Case Study -Exxon Valdez
This 1989 crude oil spill occurred in the most biological
active season
More than 1,900 kilometres of coast oiled
3,500 to 5,500 sea otter died
200 harbour seals
144 species of dead birds collectedEstimated bird loss ranges from 260,000 to 580,000
60 to 70% colony reduction in Common and Thick-
billed Murres
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
29/38
Case Study - Oil Reduction in
Intertidal Shorelines
Intertidal habitats of the Prince William Sound have shownsurprisingly good recovery. Many shorelines that were heavily
oil and then cleaned now appear much as they did before the
spill. There are, however, still oil vestiges 10 years later.
Surface oiling a study sites in
Prince William Sound
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
30/38
Case Study - Remaining Impacts to
Intertidal Habitats
Remaining impacts include:
some deeply penetrated oil continue to leach from
a few beaches, and weathered remnants of oil in a
few sites
some intertidal animals, such as mussels, are still
contaminated
some rock sites stripped by aggressive (e.g. high-pressure, hot-water) cleaning are still bare
a few rich clam beds that suffered high mortality
have not fully recovered.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
31/38
Case Study - Remaining Impacts to Wildlife
Though a high number of
individual animals may have
been killed, the actual initialimpacts to communities
(populations) of salmon, sea
otters, harbour seals and sea bird
was low. Indications show that
wildlife species populationshave recovered within their
natural range of variability.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
32/38
Case Study - Restoration Focus
The marine environment with its natural resiliency and
ability to recover required little work in restoration, beyond
initial cleaning. The bird and wildlife populations are more
threatened by upland activities such as logging, which
destroyed Marbled Murrelet nesting areas, bear foraging
sites, and salmon habitats.
Settlement funds - billions of dollars - enable purchase of a
million acres of forest lands to ensure a sustainable
environment. These purchases recognized that one can't
draw a line at the oceans edge.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
33/38
Case Study - Some Lessons Learned
Natural flushing action of waves
and storms is far more efficient
and better in restoration than
mops, hoses, and rakes.
Wildlife rescue and rehabilitation
efforts had a marginal beneficial
effect on the recovery of bird and
mammal populations.
Conventional wisdom is that
habitat protection is a better cure
than damage mitigation, no
matter how extensive or tender.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
34/38
Case Study - Conclusions
From an ecological perspective, the impacted area of the
Prince William Sound from theExxon Valdezhas shown
surprising resiliency - an ability to return to its natural state
within the range of natural variability. There are stillenvironmental scarring.
From a social perspective, the impact of theExxon Valdez
oil spill on those people who lived and experienced the
event remains as fresh in their minds as the day it happened.People still hurt.
In conclusion, the environment has a greater resiliency to an
oil spill than people.
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
35/38
British Columbias Ecological Approach to
Marine Oil Spill Management
TheExxon Valdezas well as many other major oil spills
has enable British Columbia to learn from the experiences
of what to do, or more importantly what not to do.
These lessons are reflected in two main areas that the
Province focuses on:
Coastal Inventory and Shoreline Oil Sensitivity
Mapping
Shore Cleanup and Assessment
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
36/38
Coastal Inventory and Shoreline Oil
Sensitivity Mapping
British Columbia has one
of the most extensive and
sophisticated coastal
inventory and shoreline
sensitivity mapping
program in the world.
Red = High Oil
Sensitivity
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
37/38
Coastal Mapping
Shoreline Oil
Sensitivity
Mapping ensures
the mostenvironmentally-
sound and
effective methods
are used. Based
on technical, not
political
evaluations
-
8/22/2019 Major Marine Oil Spill Impacts
38/38
Shoreline Cleanup and Assessment
When a spill occurs, Canada utilizes the Shoreline Cleanup and
Assessment Team (SCAT) process adopted from Alaska to determine
when and how each individual shoreline will be cleaned based on
geomorphological, ecological and archaeological factors.