Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita)...

16
Magnetic dynamo over Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical different astrophysical scales scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial (decay) diagnostic interest (CMB) AGN outflows MRI driven SS dynamo galactic LS dynamo helicity losses

Transcript of Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita)...

Page 1: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

Magnetic dynamo over different Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scalesastrophysical scales

Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita)with contributions from many others

seedfield

primordial (decay)

diagnostic interest (CMB)

AGN outflows MRI driven SS dynamo

galacticLS dynamo

helicity losses

Page 2: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

2

Early-Universe B-field may have Early-Universe B-field may have been helical: 3-D decay simulationsbeen helical: 3-D decay simulations

Initial slope E~k4

Christensson et al.(2001, PRE 64, 056405)

helical vsnonhelical

cosmological scale: ~3 cm

Page 3: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

3

Proposed helical decay lawProposed helical decay law

HkH H22

sI tHE 22/1/||

H not exactly constant

rHH ttkk 00 /Assume power law, not const

H follows power law iff r=1/2; thenstH 2

2diff

20

20 / HHH tktks

M. Christensson, M. Hindmarsh, A. Brandenburg: 2005, AN 326, 393M. Christensson, M. Hindmarsh, A. Brandenburg: 2005, AN 326, 393

Page 4: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

4

Many astrophysical sources of Many astrophysical sources of turbulence are potentialturbulence are potential

No dynamo action in nearly potential flows (at least not so far)

and t are also small

Examples: EW phase transition bubbles, SN explosions

f

Page 5: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

5

Nearly potential flowsNearly potential flows

ln22

2

Sωωuω

BBuB

t

t

neither nor B is produced, unless …M

ee & B

randenburg (2006, MN

RA

S 370, 415)

Page 6: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

6

Baroclinic and battery termsBaroclinic and battery terms

G10 s10

/

1/

19115

p

22

22

B

me

pt

pt

ωωuω

ωωuω

B

BBB

pp 21Analogy between and B eqns

even with baroclinicity

Kulsrud et al. (1996) relevance to oblique cosmological shocks

degreeof ionisation

Page 7: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

7

Alternative: Magnetisation from quasars?Alternative: Magnetisation from quasars?

10,000 galaxies for 1 Gyr, 1044 erg/s each

G182

tV

cMN

F

FB sw

kin

poyntrms

Similar figure also for outflows from protostellar disc

B. von Rekowski, A. Brandenburg, W. Dobler,B. von Rekowski, A. Brandenburg, W. Dobler,

A. Shukurov, 2003 A. Shukurov, 2003 A&A A&A 398398, , 825-844825-844

Poynting flux

205.0 scM

Page 8: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

8

To maintain equipartition-strength fieldsTo maintain equipartition-strength fields need dynamos: need dynamos: small-scale vs large-scalesmall-scale vs large-scale

B-scale larger than U-scale

B-scale smaller than U-scale

Wavenumber=1/scale

energy

injectionscale

Page 9: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

9

Small-scale vs large-scale dynamoSmall-scale vs large-scale dynamo

Page 10: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

10

Growth rate, applied to galaxyGrowth rate, applied to galaxy

=2x10-9 yr-1

urms=10 km/skf=2/70 pc=0.1 pc-1

urmskf=10-6 s-1

Re=109

=3x10-2 yr-1 (very fast)

)dynamo (

)dynamo ( 2

22

k

kk

t

t

Amplication factors: exp(t)=104 for 5 Gr

Page 11: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

11

Kick-start the GBF with strong BKick-start the GBF with strong B

Forced turbulence with shearand strong initial field at k=6

Page 12: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

12

Weaker initial fieldWeaker initial field

Kazantsev slope,exponential growth

Page 13: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

13

Reach full saturation: need helicity fluxesReach full saturation: need helicity fluxes evidence from different simulations evidence from different simulations

Convective dynamo in a boxwith shear and rotation

Käpylä, Korpi, Brandenburg(2008, A&A 491, 353)

Only weak field if box is closed

Forced turbulence in domain with solar-like shear

Brandenburg (2005, ApJ 625, 539)

3-D simulations, no mean-field modeling

Page 14: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

14

Saturation phase: here for convectionSaturation phase: here for convection

Käpylä et al (2008,A&A 491, 353)

with rotation without rotation

Page 15: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

15

It can take some time…It can take some time…

1

f

rms1t

1

ff

12

31

31

1t

k

k

u

U

k

UC

k

k

kkC

CCD

u

Rm

=121, B

y , 5123

LS dynamo not always excited

Page 16: Magnetic dynamo over different astrophysical scales Axel Brandenburg & Fabio Del Sordo (Nordita) with contributions from many others seed field primordial.

16

ConclusionConclusion

70 pc 10 pc

factor 500

slope 3/2

factor10,000