Madras HC Quashes Bar Council of India Notification Relaxing the Age Limit for Three-year Law Course

8/20/2019 Madras HC Quashes Bar Council of India Notification Relaxing the Age Limit for Three-year Law Course

1/212

1

BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT

DATED : 07.08.2015

CORAM

THE HON'BLE Mr. JUSTICE S.MANIKUMAR

AND

THE HON'BLE Ms. JUSTICE V.M.VELUMANI

W.P.(MD)No.95 o! 2015M.P(MD)No".1 #o o! 2015

B.A"$o% .. P'#'o&vs.

1. T$& S&*+,- M''"#, o! U'o +/ + "#'*&- Go3&4&# o! I'+- N&/ D&$'.

2. T$& S&*+,- M''"#, o! +/ + "#'*&-

Go3&4&# o! T+4' N+- C$&+'.

. N+#'o+ &6+ o/&6& Co*'- N&/ D&$'.

. T$& S&*+,-

B+ Co*' o! I'+- 21- Ro"& A3&& I"#'##'o+ A&+- N&+ B+ B$+3+- N&/ D&$'.

5. T$& C$+'4+- &6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&&-


2/212

2

B+ Co*' o! I'+- 21- Ro"& A3&& I"#'##'o+ A&+- N&+ B+ B$+3+-

N&/ D&$'.

. T$& C$+'4+- B+ Co*' o! T+4' N+ + Po'*$&,- H'6$ Co# C+4"- C$&+' ; 00 10.

7. T$& S&*+,- U'o G+#" Co44'""'o-

B+6+ S$+$


3/212

3

"#+#& ' #$& &6+ E*+#'o R&- 2008 &'#$& o #$& &6+ E*+#'o

Co44'##&& o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ o o #$& N+#'o+ &6+ o/&6&

Co*'.

(P+,& +4&& +" & o& o! #$'" Co#- +#& 02.07.2015- 4+& 'M.P.(MD) No. o! 2015)

Fo P'#'o& ... M.G.P+=$ R+@++' !o M...R+4+%'"$+

Fo R1 ... M.G.R.S/+4'+#$+ A""'"#+# So'*'#o G&&+

o! I'+

Fo R2 ... M.A..So4+,+@' A3o*+#& G&&+

!o M.M.A+6+&3+- S&*'+ Go3&4&# P&+&

Fo R ... M.S.R.R+@+6o+

Fo R ... M.D.S&3+4 !o M.M.S=+"$ B+=

Fo R8 ... M.R.A+6+"+4,

ORDER

(Order of ths Co!rt "#s $#de %& S. MANIKUMAR J.

M.B.A"$o%- + +*#'"'6 A3o*+#& o! M++' B&*$ o! #$& M++"

H'6$ Co#- $+" "o6$# !o + W'# o! C&#'o+'- #o ?+"$ #$& o#'!'*+#'o

o! #$& S&*+,- B+ Co*' o! I'+- N&/ D&$'- #$& #$ &"o&#


4/212

4

$&&'- +#& 28.09.201- G.O.(M")No.19- +/ (S) D&+#4&#- +#&

0.0.2015 + #$& *o"&?&#'+ +4'""'o o#'!'*+#'o o! #$& R&6'"#+-

D.A4=&%+ +/ U'3&"'#,- C$&+'- #$& 8#$ &"o&# $&&'- +#&

0.0.2015 + *o"&?&#,- &#"# #$& !*#'o" "#+#& ' #$& R&" o!

&6+ E*+#'o- 2008- &'#$& #o #$& &6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&& o! #$&

B+ Co*' o! I'+ o o #$& N+#'o+ &6+ o/&6& Co*'. T$&

'46& o#'!'*+#'o o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- +#& 28.09.201-

G.O.(M")No.19- +/ (S) D&+#4&#- +#& 0.0.2015 + #$&

+4'""'o o#'!'*+#'o o! #$& R&6'"#+- T+4' N+ D.A4=&%+ +/

U'3&"'#,- C$&+'- +#& 0.0.2015- +& &#+*#& $&&&:

BAR COUNCIL OF INDIA

NOTIFICTION

New Delhi, the 28th September, 2013

Report re!r"i# Cl!$%e&28, S'he"$le&III, R$le&11 o( the R$le% o( Le!l

)"$'!tio#&2008

Re%ol$tio# No*231+2013*&&The B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i! i"e Re%ol$tio#

No*182+2013 !''epte" the report %$bmitte" b- the .o#/ble ember

r*S*r!b!!r!# i# re!r" to Cl!$%e 28, S'he"$le&III, R$le&11 o( the R$le% o(

Le!l )"$'!tio#&2008*

A 'op- o( report "!te" 28**2013 !lo# with Re%ol$tio# o( the B!r

Co$#'il o( I#"i! i# thi% re!r" h!% bee# p$bli%he" i# the 4!5ette o( I#"i! i"e

)6tr!or"i#!r-, !rt&III, Se'tio#&7, $bli%he" b- A$thorit-, No*21, New Delhi,


5/212

5

S!t$r"!-, September 28, 2013* There!(ter .o#/ble ember h!% m!"e (ew

'orre'tio#% !#" "elete" three li#e% o( the (ir%t p!e o( thi% report*

.e h!% %$b%tit$te" 9limi#e9, wor" i# pl!'e o( :%i#le li#e9i# the report

i# !r!&3 o( (ir%t p!e !#" he h!% ($rther "elete" three li#e% whi'h !re

repro"$'e" below;

:The .o#/ble S$preme Co$rt !ltho$h "i%mi%%e" the writ

petitio#% (ile" b- the petitio#er 'h!lle#i# the or"er p!%%e"

b- !"r!% .ih Co$rt, b$t, .o#/ble %$preme Co$rt h!% #ot

p!%%e" !#- %pe!i# or"er*9

The B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i! !t it% meeti# hel" o# 2


6/212

6

)"$'!tio# R$le% re!r"i# m!6im$m !e (or !"mi%%io# i#to l!w 'o$r%e%> h!%

bee# 'h!lle#e" be(ore !rio$% .ih Co$rt% where i#terim or"er% to t!e

!"mi%%io# h!% bee# ie# b- the Co$rt% !#" the %!me h!% bee# (ile" be(ore the

S$preme Co$rt !#" the T**h!% bee# !llowe" !% T*C* B$t it i% %till pe#"i#*

The %eri'e h!% #ot bee# 'omplete" be'!$%e the Re%po#"e#t%/ !""re%%e%

were #ot (o$#"* The %!me h!" bee# pl!'e" be(ore the Co$#'il whi'h "e'i"e"

to p$bli%h their #!me% i# the N!tio#!l New%p!per* I# the p$bli'!tio#,

e6pe#"it$re i% too hih*

I# the me!#while, the !"r!% .ih Co$rt h!% ie# ! "et!ile" or"er i#

the m!tter o( *S!#to%h A#to#- ?!ree" =@**No*178+200 !#" the

!riee" petitio#er h!" (ile" the SL No*13837+2010 !!i#%t the %!i" or"er

be(ore the S$preme Co$rt !#" the S$preme Co$rt h!% "i%mi%%e" i# limi#e*

The or"er "!te" 11*03*2013;&&

:Upo# he!ri# 'o$#'il, the 'o$rt m!"e the (ollowi# Or"er;&

Di%mi%%e"*:

I# ! %imil!r m!tter, i# A#it Bh!r"w! %* B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i! 1228+2011,

$#!b !#" .!r-!#! .ih Co$rt h!% %et !%i"e o$r r$le !% (ollow%;&

:@e (i#" th!t the proi%io#% o( Cl!$%e&28 o( S'he"$le&III

!ppe#"e" to the R$le% !re be-o#" the lei%l!tie 'ompete#'e o(

the B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i!* Cl!$%e&28 $ltr! ire% the proi%io#% o(

Se'tio# =1> !#" =l>, 27=1>='>=iii> !#" =iii!> or Se'tio# 7=!(>,

=!> !#" ="> o( the A"o'!te% A't* )e# otherwi%e, the R$le i%

!rbitr!r- !% it i#tro"$'e% !#" i#i"io$% 'l!%%i(i'!tio# b- "ii"i#o#e Cl!%% o( %t$"e#t i#to two !rti(i'i!l !#" irr!tio#!l 'l!%%e% b-

pre%'ribi# the m!6im$m !e (or !"mi%%io# to l!w 'o$r%e%*

A% ! %e$el to the !boe "i%'$%%io#, the writ petitio#% !re

!llowe"* The petitio#er% who h!e bee# !"mitte" o# the b!%i% o(


7/212

7

the I#terim or"er wo$l" 'o#ti#$e !#" their !"mi%%io# %ho$l" #ot

be '!#'elle" o# the ro$#" th!t the- "i" #ot ($l(il the 'riteri! o(

m!6im$m !e* :

Simil!r or"er h!% bee# p!%%e" b- the .o#/ble Co$rt i# the m!tter below;

1*Nitt!# 4$pt! ?%* B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i! 28+2010

2*R!!# Sh!rm! ?%* B!r Co$#'il o(IN"i! 20


8/212

8

Co$#'il o( I#"i! to (r!me r$le% (or '!rr-i# o$t !ll it% ($#'tio#%*

O# 17*0=h> !#" =I>, 27=1='>=ii> !#" =iii!>,

7=!(>, =!> !#" ="> o( the A"o'!te% A't*

S'he"$le&III !ppe#"e" to /the r$le/ pre%'ribe% the mi#im$m

i#(r!%tr$'t$r!l (!'ilitie% re$ire" i# ! Ce#tre o( Le!l )"$'!tio# (or !ppl-i#

permi%%io# to r$# l!w 'o$r%e with !((ili!tio# (rom !# I#"i!# U#ier%it-*

Cl!$%e&28 o( S'he"$le&III rel!te% to !e o# !"mi%%io# !#" %tip$l!te% the !e

limit (or !"mi%%io# i# 3 -e!r !#" -e!r l!w 'o$r%e%* It re!"% !% $#"er;&&

:28*Ae o# !"mi%%io#;&&

=!>S$be't to the 'o#"itio# %tip$l!te" b- ! U#ier%it- o#

thi% beh!l( !#" the hih "eree o( pro(e%%io#!l 'ommitme#t

re$ire", the m!6im$m !e (or %eei# !"mi%%io# i#to ! %tre!m

o( i#ter!te" B!'helor o( L!w "eree pror!mme% i% limite" to

twe#t- -e!r% i# '!%e o( e#er!l '!teor- o( !ppli'!#t% !#" to

twe#t- two -e!r% i# '!%e o( !ppli'!#t% (rom SC, ST !#" other

B!'w!r" 'omm$#itie%*

=b>S$be't to the 'o#"itio# %tip$l!te" b- ! U#ier%it-, !#"

the e#er!l %o'i!l 'o#"itio# o( the !ppli'!#t% %eei# le!l

e"$'!tio# bel!te"l-, the m!6im$m !e (or %eei# !"mi%%io# i#to! %tre!m o( Three -e!r B!'helor Deree Co$r%e i# L!w, i% limite"

to thirt- -e!r% with riht o( the U#ier%it- to ie 'o#'e%%io# o(

($rther -e!r (or the !ppli'!#t belo#i# to SC or ST or !#- other

B!'w!r" Comm$#it-*9


9/212

9

A b!re per$%!l o( Cl!$%e&28=!> %how% th!t the m!6im$m !e (or %eei#

!"mi%%io# i#to ! %tre!m o( i#ter!te" B!'helor o( L!w "eree pror!mme

=whi'h i% o( -e!r% "$r!tio#> the !e h!% bee# limite" to 20 -e!r% i# '!%e o(

4e#er!l '!teor- !ppli'!#t% !#" 22 -e!r% i# '!%e o( !ppli'!#t% belo#i# to SC,

ST !#" Other B!'w!r" Comm$#itie%* Simil!rl-, Cl!$%e&28=b> pre%'ribe% ! '!p

o( 30 -e!r% i# re%pe't o( 4e#er!l '!teor- !ppli'!#t% !% the m!6im$m !e

limit (or %eei# !"mi%%io# i#to ! 3 -e!r% B!'helor Deree Co$r%e i# L!w*

.oweer, i# the '!%e o( SC, ST !#" Other B!'w!r" Comm$#it- !ppli'!#t%, the

'o#'er#e" U#ier%it- h!% the riht to ie ! 'o#'e%%io# o( -e!r%*

The $e%tio# !ri%e%, !% to whether the B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i! i% 'ompete#t

to (r!me the R$le% b!rri# ! per%o# !boe the !e o( 7 -e!r% (rom e#rolme#t

!% !# A"o'!te w!% 'o#%i"ere" b- .o#/ble the S$preme Co$rt i# the '!%e o(

I#"i!# Co$#'il o( Le!l Ai" !#" !"i'e !#" other% ?%* B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i! !#"

!#other =1


10/212

10

the B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i! $#"er Se'tio# 7 o( the A't !re i#

%ee# p!rt%, e!'h p!rt h!i# it ow# 'h!pter* !rt&?I i% e#title"

:r$le% oer#i# A"o'!te%9!#" the %!i" p!rt h!% three 'h!pter%*

Ch!pter&I %et% o$t the re%tri'tio#% o# %e#ior !"o'!te% !#" i%

rel!t!ble to Se'tio#% 1=3>!#" 7=> o( the A't* Ch!pter&II l!-%

"ow# the %t!#"!r"% o( pro(e%%io#!l 'o#"$'t !#" eti$ette !#" i%

rel!t!ble to Se'tio# 7


11/212

11

there(ore, re'eie the %helter o( 'l!$%e =!h> o( Se'tio# 7 o(

the A't* U#"er the %!i" 'l!$%e 'o#"itio#% !ppli'!ble to !#

!"o'!te to$'hi# hi% riht to pr!'ti'e '!# be l!i" "ow# !#" i(

l!i" "ow# he m$%t e6er'i%e hi% riht %$be't to tho%e

'o#"itio#%* B$t the l!#$!e o( the %!i" 'l!$%e "oe% #ot permit

l!-i# "ow# o( 'o#"itio#% (or e#tr- i#to the pro(e%%io#* @e

h!e, there(ore, #o he%it!tio# i# 'omi# to the 'o#'l$%io# th!t

'l!$%e =!h> o( Se'tio# 7 o( the A't "oe% #ot empower the

B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i! to (r!me ! r$le b!rri# per%o#% who h!e

'omplete" 7 -e!r% o( !e (rom the "!te o( e#rolme#t !% !#

!"o'!te* The imp$#e" r$le i%, there(ore, $ltr! ire% the %!i"

proi%io#*9

The imp$#e" Cl!$%e&28 "e!li# with the !e o# !"mi%%io# o''$rri# i#

S'he"$le&III,!ppe#"e" to the R$le% h!e bee# (r!me" $#"er Se'tio#&=1>=h>

!#" =I> !#" 27=1>='>=iii> !#" =iii!>, 7=!(>, =!> !#" ="> o( the A"o'!te% A't*

Se'tio#& o( the A"o'!te% A't "e!l% with the ($#'tio# o( the B!r Co$#'il o(

I#"i! !#" Cl!$%e&=1>=h> !#" =I> o#l- "e!lt with %$'h ($#'tio#% o( the b!r

'o$#'il o( I#"i!, whi'h !re !ime" !t promoti# to le!l e"$'!tio# !#" to l!-

"ow# %t!#"!r"% o( %$'h e"$'!tio# i# 'o#%$lt!tio# with the U#ier%itie% i# I#"i!

imp!rti# %$'h e"$'!tio# !#" to re'o#i5e the U#ier%itie% who%e "eree i#

l!w %h!ll be ! $!li(i'!tio# (or e#rolme#t !% !# A"o'!te* There(ore, thi%

'l!$%e wo$l" #ot !rm the B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i! to i#'orpor!te the proi%io#% i#

the R$le% lie Cl!$%e&28 'o#'er#i# the !e o# !"mi%%io# to LL*,B* Co$r%e*Liewi%e, Se'tio#&27=1>='> "e!l% with per%o# who m!- be !"mitte" !% !#

A"o'!te o# ! St!te Roll* It h!% ot #othi# to "o with the !e o# !"mi%%io#

!#" '!##ot be 'o#%tr$e" to h!e 'o#(erre" power o# the B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i!

to pre%'ribe the m!6im$m !e (or the p$rpo%e o( !"mi%%io# to LL*B* Fie


12/212

12

-e!r%/ Co$r%e or LL*B*, three -e!r%/ Co$r%e*

I (i#" th!t the proi%io#% o( Cl!$%e&28 o( S'he"$le&III !ppe#"e" to the

R$le% !re be-o#" the lei%l!tie 'ompete#'e o( the B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i!*

Cl!$%e&28 $ltr! ire% the proi%io# o( Se'tio# =1>=h> !#" =I> !#" 27=1>='>=iii>

!#" =iii!> o( Se'tio# 7=!(>, =!> !#" ="> o( the A"o'!te% A't* )e#

otherwi%e, the R$le i% !rbitr!r- !% it i#tro"$'e% !# i#i"io$% 'l!%%i(i'!tio# b-

"ii"i# o#e Cl!%% o( %t$"e#t i#to two !rti(i'i!l !#" irr!tio#!l Cl!%%e% b-

pre%'ribi# the m!6im$m !e (or !"mi%%io# to l!w 'o$r%e%*

Some o( the per%o#%, ee# !(ter 'omplete" the !e o( more th!# 70 or

7 -e!r% 'omplete" the "eree !#" e#rolle" i# #$mber o( St!te B!r Co$#'il

!#" m!#- o( them !ppe!re" i# the All I#"i! B!r )6!m !#" obt!i#e" Certi(i'!te

o( r!'ti'e* I# %$'h ! 'ir'$m%t!#'e%, lot o( !mbi$it- i# the !boe R$le !#"

%trii# "ow# Cl!$%e&28 o( S'he"$le&III !ppe#"e" to the R$le o( Le!l

)"$'!tio#, 2008 =(or breit-, /the R$le%/>, (r!me" b- the B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i!

bei# $ltr! ire%, $#'o#%tit$tio#!l !#" !rbitr!r- !#" !p!rt, the Cl!$%e&28 i%

tot!l iol!tio# o( #ot o#l- ($#"!me#t!l riht% b$t !l%o iol!tio# o( the

pri#'iple o( #!t$r!l $%ti'e*

I# the l!rer i#tere%t i# m!#- o( the St!te !(ter "$e "eliber!tio#%, the

opi#io#% h!% bee# (orme", the Cl!$%e&28, S'he"$le&III, R$le&11 o( the R$le% o(

le!l )"$'!tio#&2008, i% $ltr! ire%, $#'o#%tit$tio#!l !#" !!i#%t the pri#'iple%

o( the #!t$r!l $%ti'e* I# %$'h 'ir'$m%t!#'e%, eepi# i# iew the bro!"er

!%pe't !#" !(ore%!i" re!%o#%, the %!i" Cl!$%e&28, S'he"$le&III, R$le&11 o( the

R$le% o( le!l )"$'!tio#&2008 i% hereb- with"r!w#* E*R*Sh!rm!, Se'-*,

AD?T*III+7+)6t-+


13/212

13

Le!l )"$'!tio# H re%'riptio# o( !e limit (or !"mi%%io# to 3 -e!r !#"

-e!r L!w "eree 'o$r%e% H Or"er% H i%%$e"*

L!w =LS> Dep!rtme#t

4*O*=%>No*1From the Dire'tor o( Le!l St$"ie% Letter R'*No*

From the Rei%tr!r =i+'>, T!mil N!"$ Dr*Ambe"!r L!w

U#ier%it- Letter No*C*F*ANo*For the -e!r i#ter!te" B*L*pror!mme, 20 -e!r% (or e#er!l

'!teor- !ppli'!#t% !#" 22 -e!r% (or SC+ST+OBC !ppli'!#t%*


14/212

14

=ii>For the 3 -e!r B*L*'o$r%e, 30 -e!r% (or e#er!l '!teor- !ppli'!#t%

!#" 3 -e!r% (or SC+ST+OBC !ppli'!#t%*

3*S$b%e$e#t to the B!r Co$#'il o( I#"i!/% R$le% o( Le!l )"$'!tio#,

(rom the !'!"emi' -e!r 200, T!mil N!"$ Dr*Ambe"!r L!w U#ier%it-, Che##!i

i# hi% letter 2#" re!" !boe, h!% re$e%te" the 4oer#me#t to i%%$e #e'e%%!r-

i#%tr$'tio#%+or"er% !% to whether !"mi%%io# to !rio$% l!w 'o$r%e% o((ere" i#

the e6i%ti# !((ili!te" 4oer#me#t L!w Collee% b- the T!mil N!"$

Dr*Ambe"!r L!w U#ier%it- i% to (ollow the e6i%ti# eliibilit- 'riteri! (or !e

!% it i% i# pr!'ti'e till the !'!"emi' -e!r 2017&201*

*The 4oer#me#t !(ter '!re($l 'o#%i"er!tio# h!e "e'i"e" to reert to


15/212

15

the pre 2008&200< po%itio# !#" !''or"i#l-, the T!mil N!"$ Dr*Ambe"!r L!w

U#ier%it- i% "ire'te" to pre%'ribe #o !e limit (or 3 -e!r L!w "eree 'o$r%e

!#" !# $pper !e limit o( 21 -e!r% =e6'ept (or SC+ST '!#"i"!te%> (or -e!r

i#ter!te" L!w "eree 'o$r%e i# the 4oer#me#t L!w Collee% !#" i# the

T!mil N!"$ Dr*Ambe"!r L!w U#ier%it-, !% (ollowe" $pto the !'!"emi' -e!r

2008&200

S*S*OO?ALIN4A,

S)CR)TARJ TO 4O?)RN)NT =i+'>*9

THE TAMIL NADU Dr.AMBEDKAR LAW UNIVERSITY

(State Universit Esta!"is#e$ ! A%t N&.' &) *++,-

:oompo5hil9, , Dr*D*4*S*Dhi#!!r!# S!l!i, Che##!i&00 028*

A"t*No*


16/212

16

Deree Co$r%e )6!mi#!tio#% re'o#i5e"

!% e$i!le#t thereto*

Ae Je!r%

Limit

B*B*A*LL*B*=.o#%*>

Deree Co$r%e

Je!r% .SC=10M2> with

Commer'e ro$p%$be't%+Other

)6!mi#!tio#% with

rele!#t %$be't%

re'o#i%e" !% e$i!le#t

thereto*+

B*C*A*LL*B*=.o#%*>

Deree Co$r%e

Je!r% .SC =10M2> with Comp$ter

S'ie#'e !% o#e o( the

%$be't+Other

e6!mi#!tio#% with

rele!#t %$be't%

re'o#i%e" !% e$i!le#t

thereto*LL*B*=.o#%*>

Deree Co$r%e*

3 Je!r% A#- Deree i5*,

B*A*+B*S'*,+B*Com*+B*B*A

*+B*)*+B*Te'h*+*B*B*S*+

B*h!rm*, et'*

0 No Ae Limit

NRI '!#"i"!te%; )liibilit- i#im$m m!r% (or !ll -e!r I#ter!te" .o#o$r%

Co$r%e%; 0 !#" 3 -e!r LL*B*=.o#%>*

*4*RO4RA)S =C*B*C*S*> =R)4ULAR>

Co$r%e D$r!tio# Br!#'h Spe'i!li%!tio# )liibilit-

LL**Deree 2 -e!r%

I

II

III

I?

?

I#telle't$!l ropert-

L!w

B$%i#e%% l!w

Co#%tit$tio#!l L!w .$m!#

Riht%

I#ter#!tio#!l L!w !#"

Or!#i5!tio#

)#iro#me#t!l L!w !#" Le!l

Or"er

Crimi#!l L!w !#" Crimi#!l E$%ti'e

A p!%% i#

B*L*+LL*B* =either

-e!r% or 3 -e!r%

with 7 $#"er

#ew re$l!tio#% or

70 $#"er ol"

re$l!tio#%


17/212

17

?I

?II

?III

IK

A"mi#i%tr!tio#

.$m!# Riht% !#" D$tie%

)"$'!tio#

L!bo$r !#" A"mi#i%tr!tie L!w

T!6!tio# L!w

DISTANC) )DUCTION RO4RA)S

Co$r%e D$r!tio# Spe'i!li%!tio# )liibilit-

*C*L* 2Je!r% !%ter o( Corpor!te L!w% =*C*L*> A p!%% i# !#- Deree

Co$r%e+C!#"i"!te% who

!re p$r%$i# other

'o$r%e% !(ter r!"$!tio#

m!- !l%o !ppl-*

o%t 4r!"$!te

Diplom!

1 Je!r B$%i#e%% L!w =*4*D*B*L>

)#iro#me#t!l L!w =4*D*)*L>

I#(orm!tio# Te'h#olo- L!w =*4*D*I*T*L>

I#telle't$!l ropert- L!w =*4*D*I**L*>

L!bo$r L!w =*4*D*L*L*>

.$m!# Riht% D$tie% )"$'!tio#

=*4*D*.*R* D)>

C-ber Fore#%i' !#" I#ter#et Se'$rit-

=*4*D*C*F*I*S>

Crimi#!l L!w, Crimi#olo- Fore#%i'

S'ie#'e =*4*D*C*L*C*F*S>


18/212

18

L!w Libr!ri!#%hip =*4*D*L*L*>

e"i'o&Le!l A%pe't% =*4*D**L*A*>

Co#%$mer L!w rote'tio# =*4*D*C*L*>

!ritime L!w =*4*D*+L*>

Certi(i'!te mo#th% Co$r%e i# Do'$me#t!tio# .SC=10M2> or e$i!le#t

II*COURS)S OFF)R)D AT AFFILIAT)D 4O?)RN)NT LA@ COLL)4)S IN TAIL

NADU =R)4ULAR>

Co$r%e% D$r!tio# $!li(-i# )6!mi#!tio# )liible i#im$m

!r% =i# !ll

%$be't%>

SC+ST OT.)RS

!6im$m Ae

Limit =!% o#

01*0*201>

SC+ST OT.)RS

B*A*LL*B* Deree

Co$r%e

Je!r% .SC=10M2> + CBS) + Other

)6!mi#!tio#% re'o#i5e"

!% e$i!le#t thereto*

70 7 No Ae 21

Limit Je!r%

LL*B*Deree Co$r%e 3 Je!r% A#- U4 Deree ?i5*

B*A*,+B*S'*,+B*Com* )t'*,

70 7 No Ae Limit

2. I #$& "o#'6 +!!'+3'#- #$& '#'o& $+" *o#&& #$+#

*o"'&'6 #$& '4o#+*& o! ?+'#, &6+ &*+#'o- '6$# !o4 #$&

=&6''6- #$& 1#$ +/ Co44'""'o R&o# (195)- 11"# +/ Co44'""'o

R&o# (1998) + 18#$ +/ Co44'""'o R&o# (D&*&4=&- 2002)- #$&

N+#'o+ o/&6& Co44'""'o R&o#- 2007- $+3& &4$+"'& #$&

&!o4+#'3& "#&" #o =& #+%&- #o &3+4 + 6+& #$& &#'& &6+

&*+#'o.

. W'#$ #$& o=@&*# o! +*$'&3'6 $'6$ ?+'#, + "#++ &6+


19/212

19

&*+#'o- #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- N&/ D&$'- #$& #$ &"o&# $&&'-

'*oo+#& #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- ' P+# I o! #$& B+

Co*' o! I'+ R&"- =, &&*'"'6 #$& o/&"- & S&*#'o 7(1)($)

+ (')- 2(I)(*)(''') + ('''+)- 9(1)(+!)- (+6) + () o! #$& A3o*+#&" A*#-

191. T$&"& &" $+3& =&& !+4& =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- '

*o"#+#'o /'#$ #$& U'3&"'#'&" + #$& S#+#& B+ Co*'". A!#& &

+o3+- #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- +o#& #$& "+4&- ' '#" 4&'6 $&

o 1.09.2008- 3'& &"o#'o No.110 o! 2008.

. Fo #$& !'"# #'4& ' #$& $'"#o, o! &6+ &*+#'o- & +6&

'4'# $+" =&& !'&. T$& 4+'44 +6& '4'# !o +,'6 #o + #$&& ,&+

&6&& +/ *o"&- '" 0 ,&+"- /'#$ !'3& ,&+" o! &#&"'o !o SCST +

o#$& =+*%/+ *o44'#'&". A**o'6,- o"&*#" /+" '""& =, #$&

Go3&4&# o! T+4' N+. W.P.No.1877 o! 2009 /+" !'& =&!o& #$&

P'*'+ B&*$ o! #$'" Co#- /'#$ + +,&- *$+&6'6 #$& o"&*#"-

'""& !o #$&& ,&+ B..D&6&& Co"& 2009;10. A *o"&?&#'+ +,&

/+" +"o "o6$# !o- '&*#'6 #$& &"o&# #$&&'- #o +**&# #$&

+'*+#'o !o #$& #$&& ,&+ B.. Co"& +4'""'o- =, &+'6 #$&

'"#*#'o" "&*'!'& ' Co4 No.2(''') + #o *oo& #$& &*&"" &'6$#

+,". T$& "+' /'# '#'o /+" '"4'""&- $o'6 #$& +6& '4'# !o


20/212

20

+,'6 #o &6&& *o"& + #$+# #$& "+' &*'"'o '" &o#& ' )**+

(, MLJ -// 0M.S#1thosh A1to1& V#reed v. The Re2str#r T#$3 N#d!

Dr.A$%ed4#r L#" U1verst& Che11#5.

5. O& o! #$& 4&4=&" o! #$& M++' B+ A""o*'+#'o-

M.S.M#$%4+- $+" !'& W.P.No.1107 o! 201- !o + '&*#'o #o #$&

B+ Co*' o! I'+- #o '""& &*&""+, o&"- #o + #$& S#+#& B+

Co*'" o! I'+- &"#+''6 #$&4 !o4 &o'6 +, &"o- $+3'6 B

D&6&&- o=#+'& ' 3'o+#'o o! R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008.

Co"&?&#,- #$& '#'o& #$&&' $+" +"o "o6$# !o + '&*#'o #o

*+*& #$& &o4&# o! &"o"- $+3'6 B &6&&- o=#+'& '

*o#+3&#'o o! &6+ E*+#'o R&"- 2008.

. D'6 #$& *o"& o! $&+'6 ' W.P.No.1107 o! 201- #$&

B+ Co*' o! I'+ $+" !'& + *o#& +!!'+3'#- "#+#'6 #$+# #$& P@+=

+ H+,++ H'6$ Co# $+" +o/& + 4=& o! /'# '#'o"- ?+"$'6

C+"& 28- S*$&& III #o P+# I o! R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- !''6

+6& '4'# !o +4'""'o '*oo+#& ' #$& R&"- +" #+ 3'&" +

*o#+, #o #$& o3'"'o" o! #$& A3o*+#&" A*#- 191. I W.P.No.1107 o!

201- + '#&'4 o& /+" +""& =, #$'" Co#. B&'6 +66'&3& =, #$&


21/212

21

"+4&- #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ $+" &!&& S..P.(CC)No".108 #o

112 o! 201- =&!o& #$& Ho>=& A& Co#.

7. Co#& +!!'+3'# o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- ' #$& +=o3&"+'

/'# '#'o- '" #o #$& &!!&*# #$+# ' #$& /'# '#'o"- !'& =&!o& #$&

A$+ P+&"$- ++#+%+ + o#$& H'6$ Co#"- *$+&6'6 #$& &

+6& '4'# !o +4'""'o #o +/ Co&6&"- '#&'4 "#+, $+" =&& 6+#&

+ $&*&- #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ $+" !'& T+"!& P'#'o" '

T.C.M.P.No".857 #o 8 o! 2009 =&!o& #$& A& Co#- #o $&+ + #$&

4+##&"- +o6 /'#$ S..P.(CC)No".108 #o 112 o! 201.

8. A# #$& 4&'6 o! U.G. Bo+ o! S#'&" + #$& Bo+ o!

S#'&" !o #$& B.A.- B..- (Ho".) D&6&& Co"&- $& o 10.01.2009- '#

/+" &"o3& #o &*o44& #o #$& S,'*+#& !o #$& +o#'o o! +6& o

+4'""'o +" &"*'=& ' #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ R&"- 2008- !o4 #$&

+*+&4'* ,&+ 2009;10- &*o44&& =, '#" &6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&&-

!o '4&4&#+#'o =, #$& U'3&"'#'&" '4+#'6 &6+ &*+#'o. T$&

&"o#'o o! #$& "+' Bo+ o! S#'&" /+" +o3& =, #$& S,'*+#& +#

'#" 92 M&'6 $& o 21.01.2009. O 19.05.2009- #$& T+4' N+

Go3&4&#- ' '#" #& No.10718S2009- $+3& &*'& #o +o# #$&

+6& o +4'""'o !o #$& +/ &6&& *o"&"- +" &"*'=& =, #$& B+


22/212

22

Co*' o! I'+.

9. T$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- ' '#" *o#& +!!'+3'#- !'& '

W.P.(MD)No.1107 o! 201- $+" !#$& "#+#& #$+# ' S..P.No.227 o!

2008 0B#r Co!163 of I1d# v. Bo11e 7OI L#" Co33e2e #1d others5 #$&

Ho>=& S&4& Co# $+" +o'#& + T$&& M&4=& Co44'##&&- &

#$& C$+'4+"$' o! M.Go+ S=+4+'+4- #$& #$& So'*'#o G&&+ o!

I'+- M.N.N.'"$+4+'- #$& #$& P&"'&# o! #$& S&4& Co# B+

A""o*'+#'o + M.S.N.P.S'$+- #$& #$& C$+'4+ o! B+ Co*' o!

I'+- #o &+4'& #$& '""&"- &+#'6 #o +!!''+#'o + &*o6'#'o o! +/

*o&6&" + #$& S&4& Co# /&& &#"#& #$& #+"%- #o #$&

Co44'##&&- ' #$& !oo/'6 #&4"-

T$& &#'& !#& o! #$& &6+ o!&""'o &&" o

#'4+#& o*# o! #$&"& +/ *o&6&". oo%'6 #o #$& 6+3'#,

+ "&'o"&"" o! #$& 4+##&- /& &?&"# #$& &+&

So'*'#o G&&+ + P&"'&# o! #$& B+ A""o*'+#'o + #$&

C$+'4+- B+ Co*' o! I'+ #o oo% '#o #$& 4+##&

"&'o", + "=4'# + &o# #o #$'" Co#- +" &&'#'o",

+" o""'=&. T$&, /o =& +# '=&#, +""o*'+#& &&#" o +,o#$& &"o /$'*$ #$&, &&4 '# +o'+#&.

10. A**o'6 #o #$& '#'o&- #$& T$&& M&4=& Co44'##&&

"o6$# !o #$& 3'&/" o! #$& !oo/'6 &6+ 4'+'&" + &&#"-


23/212

23

S$' F.S. N+'4+- S&'o A3o*+#& S$' So'

So+=@&&- S&'o A3o*+#& + !o4& A##o&, G&&+

!o I'+ S$' P.P. R+o- S&'o A3o*+#& Po!. U&+

B+'- Po!&""o o! +/- U'3&"'#, o! W+/'*% Ho=&

D. "#'*& D$++@+,+ . C$++*$- 6&- Bo4=+,

H'6$ Co# Po!. (D.) N.R. M+$+3+ M&o- !o4&

D'&*#o- N+#'o+ +/ S*$oo o! I'+ U'3&"'#,-

B+6+o& J !o4& '*&;C$+*&o- N+#'o+ U'3&"'#,

o! ''*+ S*'&*&"- o%+#+ Po!. (D.) N.. M'#+-!o4& D'&*#o- N+#'o+ +/ S*$oo o! I'+ U'3&"'#,-

B+6+o& + !o4& '*&;C$+*&o- N+#'o+ +/

U'3&"'#,- o$ Po!. G. Mo$+ Go+- D'&*#o-

N+#'o+ '*'+ A*+&4,- B$o+ S$' D"$,+# D+3&-

S&'o A3o*+#& S$' S$,+4 D'3+- S&'o A3o*+#& D.

S+4 P'#o+- C$+'4+- N+#'o+ o/&6& Co44'""'o

Po!. B.B. P+&- NHRC C$+' Po!&""o- N+#'o+ +/

S*$oo o! I'+ U'3&"'#,- B+6+o& Po!. & 4+'-

Po!&""o o! +/- U'3&"'#, o! D&$' D. U"$+

R+4++#$+- M&4=&- A3'"o, Co*' !o I'+ S$' S.

Go+%4++ N+'- A3o*+#& J !o4& C$+'4+- B+

Co*' o! I'+ S$' A"$o% P+'@+- S&'o A3o*+#&

O'""+ H'6$ Co# S$' C.. S+4+ B++- A3o*+#&

G&&+- S#+#& o! A+*$+ P+&"$ S$' S+'%'"$+

R+@+6o+- A3o*+#& S$' D+,+ '"$+- A3o*+#& +

S$' S+@&&3 S+*$&3+- A3o*+#&.


24/212

24

11. Pro bo#o '#'6+# $+" !#$& "=4'##& #$+# +!#& *o"#'6

#$& &&#" + 3+'o" &4'&# &"o"- #$& Co44'##&& "=4'##& '#"

&o# o 0.10.2009- ' !+3o o! $o'6 #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o-

2008. I +'#'o- #$& Co44'##&& $+" +"o o'& #$+# #$& A I'+ B+

E+4'+#'o" "$o =& '#o*& =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- +" +

&?'&4&#- 'o #o &o4&# =, #$& S#+#& B+ Co*'". T$&

Co44'##&& $+" "=4'##& '#" &o# o 0.10.2009 + #$& Ho>=&

S&4& Co# o! I'+- '&*#& #$& &o# #o =& +*& =&!o& #$& B+

Co*' o! I'+. T$"- #$& &o# /+" #+=& =&!o& #$& B+ Co*' o!

I'+- /$'*$ +o3& #$& R&o# +'4o",- "=@&*# #o o&

+4&4&#. I# /+" #$& "66&"#'o o! #$& B+ Co*' #$+# + #$& +/

"*$oo" + *o&6&" "$o =& 4++#o', &?'& #o &"#+='"$ &6+ +'

*''*"*&#&" #o o3'& '&&"'3& + &&'#'o" &6+ +3'*& #o #$&

&&, "&*#'o" o! o "o*',. T$'" "66&"#'o /+" +**&#& =, #$& T$&&

M&4=& Co44'##&& + "="&?&#, '*oo+#& ' #$& &o#. O*&

+6+'- #$& &o# /+" +*& =&!o& #$& Ho>=& S&4& Co#- /$'*$

'""& + '&*#'o #o #$& B+ Co*' #o '4&4&# #$& &o#. T$& *+"&

/+" o"#& !o $&+'6 o 1.12.2009. O #$+# +,- M.Go+


25/212

25

S=+4+'+4- #$& #$& So'*'#o G&&+ o! I'+- "=4'##& #$+# #$& !'"#

=+ &+4'+#'o /o =& *o*#& ' ,- 2010- =, + "&*'+,

*o"#'##& '&&&# =o,. T$& Ho>=& S&4& Co# $+" !#$&

'&*#& #$& C&#+ Go3&4&# #o &"& #$+# #$& &#'& o6+44&

!+4& =, #$& T$&& M&4=& Co44'##&&- '" o&+#'o+'"& !o#$/'#$.

T$"- #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- /+" '4'&, +o3& =, #$&

Ho>=& S&4& Co#- /$'*$ +"o *o#+'"- C+"& 28 o! S*$&& III o!

#$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- &6+'6 &"*'#'o o! & +6&

'4'# !o +,'6 #o #$&& ,&+ &6&& *o"&.

12. W$& #$& 4+##& "#oo #$"- #$& &/, &&*#& B+ Co*'

4&4=&"- /'#$o# *o"'&'6 #$& $'"#o, + =+*%6o- +" #o $o/- #$&

R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- /&& '*oo+#& ' #$& B+ Co*' o!

I'+ R&"- + /'#$o# *o"'&'6 #$& '"4'""+ o! #$& SP !'& +6+'"#

#$& @64&# o! #$'" Co# ' W.P.No.1877 o! 2009- +#& 09.09.2009-

&o#& ' )**+ (, MLJ -// 0M.S#1thosh A1to1& V#reed v. The

Re2str#r T#$3 N#d! Dr.A$%ed4#r L#" U1verst& Che11#5

+o'#& M.S.P+=+%++- +" O& M+ Co44'##&&- #o &;*o"'& #$&

+6& &"#'*#'o *+"&- '*oo+#& ' C+"& 28 o! S*$&& III o! #$&


26/212

26

R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008. T$& "+' O& M+ Co44'##&&- =,

o="&3'6 #$+# #$& +6& &"#'*#'o 3'o+#&" A#'*& 1 o! #$& Co"#'##'o o!

I'+- $+" &*o44&& !o '#" &'o. T$& Co44'##&&>"

&*o44&+#'o $+" =&& +**&#& =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ +

+""& + o#'!'*+#'o- +#& 28.09.201- /'#$+/'6 C+"& 28- S*$&&

III o! #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008. No#'!'*+#'o $+" =&& ='"$&

o 1.08.201.

1. Pro bo#! '#'6+# $+" !#$& "=4'##& #$+# /$& #$& B+

Co*' o! I'+ /+" #+%'6 "#&" #o '4&4&# #$& o#'!'*+#'o- +#&

1.08.201- ' #$& oo"& &o4&#- "*$&& !o #$& 4o#$ o!

O*#o=&- 201- M.S.M#$%4+- #$& '#'o& ' W.P.No.1107 o!

201- !'& !o + W'# o! M++4"- !o #$& &'&!"- "#+#& "+- +

'#&'4 "#+, o! #$& o&+#'o o! #$& o#'!'*+#'o /+" "o6$# !o. A# #$'"

@*#&- #$& &+& *o"& +&+'6 !o #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+-

&#oo% #$+# #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- /o o# '4&4&# #$& "+4&-

' #$& oo"& &o4&#- "*$&& !o #$& 4o#$ o! O*#o=&> 201.

T$"- #$& '4&4&#+#'o o! #$& o#'!'*+#'o /+" &!&&. Ho/&3&- =,

/+, o! +=+# *+#'o- #$& '#'o& #$&&'- $+" +"o !'& M.P.No.1


27/212

27

o! 201- "&&%'6 !o + +4&4&# o! #$& +,&- =, '*'6 + &'&! o!

&*++#'o o! /'#$+/+ o! o#'!'*+#'o o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+-

+#& 28.09.201- +" '&6+. A64&#" /&& $&+ =, #$& &+& "'6&

6&.

1. I #$& 4&+ /$'&- +o#$& W.P.No.1015 o! 201- /+" !'&

=, +o#$& A3o*+#&- M..R+4&"$. I #$& "+' /'# '#'o- +3&4&#"

/&& 4+& #$+# 4=& o! &"o" $+3& &o& =, #$& B+ Co*' o!

T+4' N+ + P*$&,- #$& #$ &"o&# $&&'- /$o 6o# +4'""'o

' +/ Co&6&"- +!#& &- 2009 ' 3+'o" *o&6&" o! #$& &'6$=o'6

S#+#&"- '6o'6 #$& +6& '4'# + "&""'6 *'4'+ *+"&". T$o6$ '#

/+" *o#&& #$+# #$& "+' R& $+" =&& '4&4&#& =, D.A4=&%+

+/ U'3&"'#,- C$&+'- 8#$ &"o&# $&&'- !o4 #$& A*+&4'* ,&+

2009 o/+"- #+%'6 o#& o! #$& '3+ "=4'""'o"- + &+& "'6&

6&- $+" +""& #$& !oo/'6 o&-

O& "*$ & '" R& 28 o! #$& &6+ E*+#'o R&"-

/'#$ &6+ #o *&''6 o +6& o! #$& *+'+#&" #o 6

+4'""'o '#o +/ *o&6&. T$o"& *+'+#&" /$o 6o#

+4'""'o ' 3'o+#'o o! +, o! #$& &" '*'6 R& 28 o!

#$& &6+ &*+#'o +& o# &#'#& #o 6 &o4&#. I!

+,=o, 6o# +&+, &o&- #$& B+ Co*' o! T+4' N+


28/212

28

$+" 6o# o/& #o #+%& +*#'o- '*'6 ""&"'o + #o

&4o3& +" & +/.

I 3'&/ o! #$+#- #$& B+ Co*' o! T+4' N+ '"

'&*#& #o !' o# #$& 3'o+#'o" ' #$& 4+##& o! &o4&#

o! *+'+#&" '*'6 #$o"& +=o3& #$&& *+'+#&" +

"'4'+, +*& &"o" + #$& *+'+#&" /$o 6o#

+4'""'o '#o +/ Co&6&- +!#& &- 2009 + #+%&

+o'+#& +*#'o '*'6 ""&"'o !'"# + #o &4o3&

#$& +!#& &?',.

15. P"+# #o #$& +=o3&- #$& B+ Co*' o! T+4' N+ +

P*$&,- C$&+'- $+" '""& "$o/ *+"& o#'*&" #o 4+, &"o". A

o& o! ""&"'o /+" +"o 4+&. No/- D.A4=&%+ +/ U'3&"'#,-

C$&+'- #$& 8#$

&"o&# $&&'- $+" '""& + +4'""'o o#'!'*+#'o-

+#& 0.0.2015- !o #$& #$&& ,&+ B.. D&6&& *o"&- ' /$'*$- #$&&

'" o +6& &"#'*#'o !o +4'""'o. C$+&6'6 #$& "+4&- #$& &"&# /'#

'#'o $+" =&& !'& !o #$& &'&!"- "#+#& "+.

1. A""+''6 #$& *o&*#&"" o! #$& o#'!'*+#'o o! #$& B+

Co*' o! I'+- +#& 28.09.201- M...R+4+%'"$+- &+&

*o"& !o #$& '#'o& "=4'##& #$+# !''6 #$& & +6& '4'# !o

+4'""'o #o +/ &6&& *o"&- '" o& o! #$& 4+' *o"'&+#'o" #o


29/212

29

4+'#+' #$& &6+ "#++"- ?+'#, ' &*+#'o + #$+# '" /$,- =&!o&

'*oo+#'6 #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- 3'&/" o! 4+, &&#"

/&& #+%& '#o *o"'&+#'o.

17. A**o'6 #o $'4- +" & S&*#'o 7(1)($) o! #$& A3o*+#&"

A*#- 191- #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ "$+ o4o#& &6+ &*+#'o + #o

+, o/ "#++" o! "*$ &*+#'o- ' *o"#+#'o /'#$ #$&

U'3&"'#'&" ' I'+- '4+#'6 "*$ &*+#'o + #$& S#+#& B+ Co*'".

A" & S&*#'o 10(2)(=) o! #$& "+' A*#- #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ "$+

*o"#'##& + &6+ &*+#'o *o44'##&&- *o"'"#'6 o! #& 4&4=&"- o!

/$o4- !'3& "$+ =& &"o" &&*#& =, #$& Co*' !o4 +4o6"# '#"

4&4=&" + !'3& "$+ =& &"o" *o;o#& =, #$& Co*'- /$o +& o#

4&4=&" #$&&o!. H& +"o '3'#& #$& +##&#'o o! #$'" Co# #o S&*#'o 15

o! #$& +=o3&"+' A*# + "=4'##& #$+# #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ '"

&4o/&& #o 4+%& &".

18. I3'#'6 #$& +##&#'o #o C$+#& III o! P+# II o! #$& B+

Co*' o! I'+ R&"- /$'*$ &+" /'#$ *o"#'##'o- !*#'o" +


30/212

30

o*&& #o =& !oo/& =, *o44'##&&" o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ +

' +#'*+- R& o! #$& "+' C$+#&- /$'*$ &+" /'#$ &6+

E*+#'o Co44'##&& + R& 8- &+'6 /'#$ #$& o/&" + #'&" o!

#$& &6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&&- M...R+4+%'"$+- &+& *o"&

!o #$& '#'o& "=4'##& #$+# "*$ Co44'##&& "$+ $+3& #$& o/&"

#o 4+%& '#" &*o44&+#'o" #o #$& Co*' !o +,'6 o/ #$&

"#++" o! &6+ &*+#'o !o #$& U'3&"'#'&"- #o 3'"'# + '"&*#

U'3&"'#'&" + &o# #$& &"#" #o #$& Co*'.

19. R&!&'6 #o P+# III o! #$& +=o3&"+' R&"- &+'6 /'#$ #$&

4+##&"- &+#'6 #o S#+#& Co*' + P+# I- &+'6 /'#$ #$& &" o!

&6+ &*+#'o- &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& "=4'##& #$+# #$&

R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- $+3& =&& !+4& #o 4o'#o #$&

"#++" o! &6+ &*+#'o + &*o6'#'o o! &6&&" ' +/- !o #$&

o"& o! &o4&# +" +3o*+#& + '"&*#'o o! U'3&"'#'&" !o

&*o6''6 '#" &6&& ' +/- & S&*#'o" 7(1)($) + (')- 2(1)(*)(''')

+ ('''+)- 9(1)(+!)- (+6) + () o! #$& A3o*+#&" A*#- 191. H&

"=4'##& #$+# #$& o#'!'*+#'o" o/ '46& ' #$'" /'# '#'o- +&

*o#+, #o #$& +=o3"+' S#+##o, o3'"'o".


31/212

31

20. A**o'6 #o #$& &+& *o"&- /$+# '" $& ' +

&*'"'o o! #$'" Co# ' M.S#1thosh A1to1& V#reed v. The Re2str#r

T#$3 N#d! Dr.A$%ed4#r L#" U1verst& Che11# &o#& ' )**+ (,

MLJ -// '" #$& &"*'#'o o! & +6& '4'# !o +4'""'o #o +/

&6&& *o"&" ' #$& S#+#& o! T+4' N+ + #$+# #$& "+4& 3'&/ $+"

=&& #+%& =, Ho>=& M. "#'*& .C$+- ' + "="&?&# /'#

'#'o.

21. I3'#'6 #$& +##&#'o o! #$'" Co# #o #$& 18#$ R&o# o! #$&

+/ Co44'""'o- & #$& C$+'4+"$' o! #$& Fo4& Ho>=& M.

"#'*& M.+6++$+ R+o- &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& "=4'##&

#$+# #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- ' '#" #&- +#& 0.08.2000- $+ +6&&

#o '4&4&# #$& &*o44&+#'o o! #$& &6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&&- o

#$& /o%'6 +& o! #$& +/ Co44'""'o- /'#$o# +'"'6 +, o=@&*#'o"

+ #$+# #$& oo"+" o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- ' '#" #&- +#&

0.08.2000- &6+'6 S&*#'o 7(1)($)- &+" +" !oo/":

#o +, o/ "#++" o! o!&""'o+ &6+ &*+#'o

' +**o+*& /'#$ #$& &*o44&+#'o" o! #$& &6+

E*+#'o Co44'##&& o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- /$'*$-


32/212

32

'#& +'+- '*&" *'*4- #&+*$'6 4$o"-

&+4'+#'o- #d$sso1 of st!de1ts- 4=& o! #&+*$&"-

o*+#'o + '!+"#*#& &?'&4&#"- + 4++6&4&#

' *o"#+#'o /'#$K

22. T$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- ' '#" #&- +#& 0.08.2000- $+"

+6&& #o '4&4&# #$& &*o44&+#'o" o! #$& &6+ E*+#'o

Co44'##&&- o #$& /o%'6 +& o! #$& +/ Co44'""'o- + #o +,

o/ S#++" o! &6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&& o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+-

o 4+, "=@&*#"- '*'6 +4'""'o o! "#&#".

2. I# '" #$& "=4'""'o o! #$& &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o&

#$+# /$& #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ $+ +6&& #o +, o/ #$& "#++"

o! &6+ &*+#'o- '*'6 +4'""'o o! "#&#" + /$& #$& &*'"'o

o! #$'" Co# ' M.S#1thosh A1to1& V#reed's *+"& (*'#& "+)- $+" =&&

$& =, #$& Ho>=& A& Co#- #$& #$&& '" o && !o +o'#4&#

o! + O& M+ Co44'##&&. H& +"o "=4'##& #$+# /$& #$& T$&& M&4=&

Co44'##&& R&o#" /&& '&*#& #o =& +*& =&!o& #$& B+ Co*' o!

I'+ + &6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&& + +**o'6,- /$& + &4&6&*,

4&'6 o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ + &6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&& /+"


33/212

33

$& +# 10.0 P.M.- o 1.0.2011 (S+#+,) + 17.0.2011 (S+,) '

N&/ D&$'- ' #$& &"&*& o! Ho>=& M.A.P.M'"+- Fo4& 6& o! #$&

S&4& Co# + o#$&" + /$& #$& &o#" "=4'##& =, #$& T$&&

M&4=& Co44'##&& /&& +**&#& + #$&&+!#&- +*& =&!o& #$&

Ho>=& S&4& Co#- #$&& '" +="o#&, o &*&""'#, !o +o'#4&#

o! + O& M+ Co44'##&& #o 6o '#o #$& '""&- &6+'6 #$& +6&

&"#'*#'o *+"&- '*oo+#& ' #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008.

2. &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& !#$& "=4'##& #$+#

/$& #$& *o#&#'o o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- =&!o& #$& Ho>=&

S&4& Co# o! I'+- /+" #o #$& &!!&*# #$+# C+"& 28 o! #$& &6+

E*+#'o R&"- '" ' *o!o4'#, /'#$ S&*#'o" 7(1)($) + (')-

2(1)(*)(''') + ('''+)- 9(1)(+!)- (+6) + () o! #$& A3o*+#&" A*#- 191

+ /$& #$& A& Co# $+" +**&#& #$& T$&& M&4=& Co44'##&&

R&o#"- &6+'6 #$& +6& o +4'""'o #o +/ *o"&"- o& o! #$& '""&"

'3o3& ' S..P.(C)No.227 o! 2008 + /$& #$& Ho>=& S&4&

Co# $+" '&*#& #$& C&#+ Go3&4&# #o &"& #$+# #$& &#'&

o6+44& !+4& =, #$& T$&& M&4=& Co44'##&&- #o =&

o&+#'o+'"& !o#$/'#$- +o'#4&# o! O& M+ Co44'##&& #o o*&


34/212

34

+6+' #o 6o '#o #$& '""&- &+#'6 #o +6& &"#'*#'o *+"&- '*oo+#&

' #$& &6+ E*+#'o R&"- 2008- /o +4o# #o '4'&, '!,'6

#$& &*'"'o o! #$& A& Co#- /$'*$ '" o# &4'""'=&.

25. &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& +"o '3'#& #$& +##&#'o

o! #$'" Co# #o #$& *o#& +!!'+3'# !'& =, #$& S&*+,- B+ Co*'

o! I'+- ' SL8(Cv3No.-9: of )*-* (M.S#1thosh A1to1& V#reed vs.

The Re2str#r T#$3 N#d! Dr.A$%ed4#r L#" U1verst& #1d others

+ "=4'##& #$+# /$& #$& & &"*'='6 & +6&- !o +4'""'o #o

+/ &6&& *o"&"- /+" *$+&6&- #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- +!!'4'6

#$& o*&"" !oo/& =&!o& 4+%'6 #$& &- $+" !'& + *o#& +!!'+3'#

=&!o& #$& Ho>=& S&4& Co# + "=4'##& #$+# #$& &" $+3& =&&

!+4&- o, +!#& *o"#+#'o /'#$ #$& U'3&"'#'&"- '4+#'6 &6+

&*+#'o + S#+#& B+ Co*'"- & S&*#'o 7(1)($)(') 2(1)(*)- /'#$

&!!&*# !o4 #$& +*+&4'* ,&+ 2008;09- + #$+# #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+

$+" +"o "=4'##& #$+# +, +*+&4'* *o"& &?'&" + "&*'!'* +6& '4'#-

!o +4'""'o. H& +"o "=4'##& #$+# #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- ' '#"

*o#& +!!'+3'#- =&!o& #$& Ho>=& A& Co#- $+" +"o "=4'##& #$+#

+ ,o6 4' *+ =& 4o&- + 4+#& 4' *+o# =& 4o&


35/212

35

3&, &+"',. H& #$&&!o& "=4'##& #$+# /$& #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+

$+ +**&#& #$& &o# + &'#&+#& #$& o*&& !oo/&- !o

+4&'6 #$& R&"- ?'#& *o#+, #o #$& "+4&- #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+

$+" +o'#& + O& M+ Co44'##&&- '6o'6 #$& o*&& $'#$&#o

!oo/&- + #$& "#+ #+%& =&!o& #$& Ho>=& S&4& Co#.

2. I3'#'6 #$& +##&#'o o! #$'" Co# #o #$& @64&# o! #$&

P@+= + H+,++ H'6$ Co#- &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o&

"=4'##& #$+# =&!o& #$& "+' Co#- #$&& /+" o &&"&#+#'o =, #$&

B+ Co*' o! I'+- /$& C+"& 28 o! #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o-

2008- /+" *$+&6&.

27. O #$& &*'"'o &o#& ' -++; (- SCC /9) 0I1d#1

Co!163 of Le2#3 Ad < Adv6e v. B#r Co!163 of I1d#5 /$'*$ &*'&

#$& ?&"#'o- +" #o /$$&- + &"o- /$o $+" *o4& #$& +6& o! 5

,&+"- o #$& +#& o! /$'*$- $& "=4'#" $'" +'*+#'o !o $'" &o4&#-

+" + A3o+#&- #o #$& S#+#& B+ Co*' + /$$& $& *+ =& &o&-

&+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& "=4'##& #$+# S&*#'o 7(1)($) o! #$&

A3o*+#&" A*#- 191- /+" o# *o"'&& ' #$& "+' @64&# + #$+#


36/212

36

#$&&!o&- #$& "+' @64&# *+o# =& +'& #o #$& !+*#" o $+.

28. &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& !#$& "=4'##& #$+# #$&

'46& o#'!'*+#'o- +#& 28.09.201- '" o#$'6 =# + +4&4&#-

#o C+"& 28 o! #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008 + #$& o*&& !o

+4&4&#- +" *o#&4+#& ' R& 7 o! C$+#& I o! P+# I o! #$&

R&"- $+" o# =&& !oo/& + #$"- #$&& '" + 3'o+#'o. H& !#$&

"=4'##& #$+# +" & R& 7 o! C$+#& I o! P+# I o! #$& R&"- +,

+4&4&# oo"& =, B+ Co*' o! I'+- ' #$& &" "$+ =& *+'&

o, #$o6$ *o"#+#'o /'#$ #$& U'3&"'#'&" + #$& S#+#& B+

Co*'"- =, /+, o! *'*+#'o o! #$& oo"+ #o #$& U'3&"'#'&" + #$&

S#+#& B+ Co*'" !o #$& /'##& "=4'""'o /'#$' #$& "*$&&

o#'!'& +#& + +!#& *o"'&+#'o o! "*$ /'##& "=4'""'o o 4&'#.

T$& &6+ E*#'o Co44'##&&B+ Co*' o! I'+ "$+ o *o"'&+#'o

o! #$& &&"&#+#'o !'+'"& #$& "+' +4&4&#"- /$'*$ "$+ *o4&

'#o !o*& =, /+, o! o#'!'*+#'o ' #$& /&="'#&. T$& B+ Co*' o! I'+

"$+ +"o "& #$& $+ *o, o! o#'!'*+#'o #o #$& U'3&"'#'&". Po3'&

#$+# +, o3'"'o ' #$& S*$&& 4+, =& +4&& =, #$& B+ Co*' o!

I'+ o #$& &*o44&+#'o o! #$& &6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&& + #$&


37/212

37

"+4& "$+ +"o =& o#'!'& ' #$& /&="'#& o! #$& BCI !o &!o*'6 #$&

o3'"'o.

29. A**o'6 #o #$& &+& *o"&- /$& #$& "&*'!'* "#+ o!

#$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- =&!o& #$& Ho>=& S&4& Co# '

SL8(Cv3No.-9: of )*-* (M.S#1thosh A1to1& V#reed vs. The

Re2str#r T#$3 N#d! Dr.A$%ed4#r L#" U1verst& #1d others /+"

#$+# #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- $+3& =&& !+4&- =, !oo/'6 +

o*&&- o/- /'#$o# !oo/'6 #$& +=o3&"+' o*&&- #$& B+

Co*' o! I'+- "&&4& #o $+3& +**&#& #$& &o# o! #$& O& M+

Co44'##&&- o #$& 6o" i#ter !li! #$+# #$&& '" + 3'o+#'o o!

'*'&" o! +#+ @"#'*&.

0. I# '" +"o $'" "=4'""'o #$+# #$& O& M+ Co44'##&& $+"

o*&&& o #$& "o& &4'"& #$+# #$&& /&& '3&6&# 3'&/" &&""&

=, '!!&&# Ho>=& H'6$ Co#" + $&*&- #$&& '" + 3'o+#'o o!

!+4&#+ '6$#". A**o'6 #o #$& O& M+ Co44'##&&- R& 28- '

S*$&& III #o P+# I o! #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- &"*'='6

#$& & +6& !o +4'""'o- '" #+ 3'&" + *o"#'##'o+.


38/212

38

1. T$"- #+%'6 " #$o6$ #$& 3+'o" "#+##o, o3'"'o"-

"#+ o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- =&!o& #$& Ho>=& S&4& Co# +

#$'" Co#- &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& "=4'##& #$+# /$& #$&&

'" + "&*'!'* o*&& !o +4&'6 #$& &" + /$& o3'"'o &

R& 7 o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ R&"- 4+%&" '# *&+ #$+# +,

+4&4&# oo"& =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- "$+ =& o, o #$&

*o"'&+#'o o! #$& &&"&#+#'o o! #$& &6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&&

+ ' #$& +="&*& o! +, 4+#&'+" #o ''*+#& #$+# #$& &6+ E*+#'o

Co44'##&& o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ $+" &*o44&& !o +,

+4&4&# #o #$& "*$&&- +o'#4&# o! O& M+ Co44'##&&- #o 6o

'#o #$& '""& o! +6& '4'# !o +4'""'o !o +/ D&6&& *o"&- '#"&! '"

'&6+- *o#+, #o #$& o*&&- *o#&4+#& & #$& S#+##o,

R&" + #$&&!o&- #$& &o# $+" o "+*#'#,.

2. I3'#'6 #$& +##&#'o o! #$'" Co# #o R& 5 o! #$& B+

Co*' o! I'+ R&"- &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& !#$&

"=4'##& #$+# +, &"o#'o +""& &+'& =, B+ Co*' o! I'+&6+

E*+#'o Co44'##&&- '*o"'"#&# /'#$ #$&"& R&"- "$+ o# =' #$&


39/212

39

B+ Co*' o! I'+ + + o#$& =o'&"- *o"#'##& ' "+*& o! #$&

A3o*+#&" A*#- 191- +!#& #$& &" *o4& '#o !o*&.

. A**o'6 #o $'4- +" & R& o! #$& "+' R&"- #$& &6+

E*+#'o Co44'##&& o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ "$+ =& #$& '"#&

&"o#'o =o, !o + '"#&" &+#'6 #o #$& &6+ &*+#'o- /$'*$

"$+ !oo/ + o*&& &"'6 +#+ @"#'*& !o "*$ '"#&

&"o#'o +" '" &4'& =, '#. H& $+" +"o &!&& #o #$& S+3'6

C+"& ' R& + "=4'##& #$+# +, +*#'o- &*'"'o o '&*#'o

#+%& o '&*#& =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ & +, & o &6+#'o

' !o*& +# +, #'4& &+'& #$+ #$&"& &" *o4'6 '#o !o*&- "$+ =&

3+'- =''6 o #$& '"#'##'o" +" #$& *+"& 4+, =&- + &4+' '

&!o*& o#/'#$"#+'6 +,#$'6 *o#+'& ' #$&"& R&".

. A**o'6 #o $'4- o/ #$& '"#& &+#&" #o &6+ &*+#'o

+ ' +#'*+ #o &"*'#'o o! & +6& '4'# !o +4'""'o #o +/

&6&& *o"&. I "*$ *'*4"#+*&"- $& "=4'##& #$+# #$& &6+

E*+#'o Co44'##&& o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ "$+ =& #$& *o4&#


40/212

40

+#$o'#, #o &"o3& #$& '"#& + #$+# #$& O& M+ Co44'##&& $+" o

@'"'*#'o #o 6o '#o #$& "+' '""&.

5. I# '" +"o #$& "=4'""'o o! #$& &+& *o"& !o #$&

'#'o& #$+# &3& #+%'6 '# !o 6+#& #$+# #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ $+

#+%& o#& o! #$& &*'"'o o! #$& P@+= + H+,++ H'6$ Co# + #$&

'3&6&# 3'&/"- &&""& =, o#$& H'6$ Co#"- o #$& +"&*# o!

&"*'='6 & +6& !o +4'""'o #o +/ &6&& *o"&- #$& B+

Co*' o! I'+- "$o $+3& &!&& #$& '"#& #o #$& &6+ E*+#'o

Co44'##&& o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- /$o "$+ =& #$& '"#&

&"o#'o =o, !o + '"#&" &+#'6 #o &6+ &*+#'o + #$+# + O&

M+ Co44'##&& o6$# o# #o $+3& +o'#& + *o"&?&#,- #$&

+**&#+*& o! #$& &o# o! #$& O& M+ Co44'##&&- =, #$& B+ Co*'

o! I'+ + &'o o! C+"& 28 o! #$& &6+ E*+#'o R&"- 2008- '"

/$o,- /'#$o# @'"'*#'o + '*o"'"#&# /'#$ R& o! #$& B+

Co*' o! I'+ R&".

. &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& "=4'##& #$+# #$o6$ #$&

B+ Co*' o! I'+- ' '#" &"o#'o- +#& 29.08.201- $+" +**&#& #$&

O& M+ Co44'##&&>" &o# + '""& #$& '46& o#'!'*+#'o- +#&

0.0.2015- #$& "+4& *+o# =& "+3&- &3& & R& o! #$& B+


41/212

41

Co*' o! I'+ R&"- /$&&'- #$& "+3'6 *+"& *+ o#&*# o, #$&

+*#'o- &*'"'o o '&*#'o #+%& =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- & #$&

R&" + R&6+#'o"- ' !o*& +# +, #'4& + #$&&!o&- #$& &*'"'o o!

#$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- #o +o'# #$& O& M+ Co44'##&&- +!#&

*o4'6 '#o !o*& o! #$& R&"- '" o# ' +**o+*& /'#$ #$& "#+##o,

&".

7. &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& !#$& "=4'##& #$+#

/'#$+/+ o! SP" !'& =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ $+" o &" /'#$ #$&

o=@&*# "o6$# #o =& +*$'&3&. H& !#$& +& #$+# #$& +/ Co44'""'o

R&o#"- !o #$& o"& o! '4o3'6 #$& "#++" + ?+'#, o! &6+

E*+#'o $+3& =&& +**&#& =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ + !#$&

&o#" o! #$& T$&& M&4=& Co44'##&& *o"#'##& + +*& =&!o&

#$& A& Co#- *+o# =& 6'3& + 6o;=,- =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+-

"o&, o #$& =+"'" o! + O& M+ Co44'##&&. A# #$'" @*#&- +##&#'o

o! #$'" Co# /+" +"o =o6$# #o #$& &o# o! #$& T$&& M&4=&

Co44'##&&- /$&&'- #$& Co44'##&& $+" o'& +" !oo/":

The Co$$ttee therefore s of the ve" th#t the

st#1d#rds of 3e2#3 ed!6#to1 =rovded for 1 the )**, BCI

R!3es 163!d12 the =rovso1s o1 1s=e6to1 re6o21to1


42/212

42

#1d #66redt#to1 #re 1 6o1so1#16e "th the

re>!re$e1ts of the t$e #1d 1 f#6t #re s!ted to e1s!re

the h2hest >!#3t& of 3e2#3 ed!6#to1.

8. H& +"o "=4'##& #$+# +" &6+" C$+#& I- #$& T$&&

M&4=& Co44'##&& $+" +"o o'& #$+# C$+#& I o! #$& 2008 BCI R&"

*o#+'" o3'"'o" 3'";L; 3'" #$& D'&*#o+#& o! &6+ E*+#'o- #$&

&"o"'=''#, o! /$'*$ '*&: (+) Co#''6 &6+ &*+#'o- (=)

T&+*$&" #+''6- (*) A3+*& "&*'+'& o!&""'o+ *o"&"- ()

E*+#'o o6+4 !o I'+ "#&#" "&&%'6 &6'"#+#'o +!#& o=#+''6

+/ D&6&& !o4 + Fo&'6 U'3&"'#,- (&) R&"&+*$ o o!&""'o+ &6+

E*+#'o + S#++'+#'o- (!) S&4'+ + /o%"$o- (6) &6+

R&"&+*$- ($) +, o#$& +""'64&# #$+# 4+, =& +""'6& #o '# =, #$&

&6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&& + #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+.

9. &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& !#$& "=4'##& #$+#

#$o6$ #$& T$&& M&4=& Co44'##&&- $+" "=4'##& '#" &o# o

0.10.2009 + o #$& '&*#'o" o! #$& Ho>=& A& Co#- #$& &o#

/+" #+=& =&!o& #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- /$'*$ +o3& #$& R&o#

+'4o",- "=@&*# #o o, o& +4&4&#- "&,- #$& B+ Co*'


43/212

43

o! I'+ $+" &*'& #o +o'# + O& M+ Co44'##&& #o *o"'& #$&

?&"#'o o! &"*'#'o o! & +6& !o +4'""'o #o +/ D&6&& *o"&"

+ #$& "+4& '" '&6+. A**o'6 #o $'4- #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ $+"

&*'& #o '4&4&# #$& &6+ E*+#'o R&"- 2008- "#'*#, +

#$&&!o&- '# *+o# 6o =+*%.

0. P+*'6 &'+*& o + &*'"'o o! #$'" Co# ' K.S#4th R#1

v. The Se6ret#r& B#r Co!163 of T#$3 N#d! &o#& ' )*-* () L?

/: &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& "=4'##& #$+# /$& #$&

+'*+=''#, o! #$& &6+ E*+#'o R&"- 2008- #o #$& *+"& o! #$&

'#'o&" #$&&'- *+4& !o *o"'&+#'o- #$& Ho>=& D'3'"'o B&*$

o! #$'" Co#- +!#& *o"'&'6 #$& '3+ "=4'""'o"- +# P++6+$ 92- $+"

*+#&6o'*+, $& #$+# #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- +& !+4& '

+**o+*& /'#$ #$& o/&" *o!&& & S&*#'o" 7(1)($) J (')-

2(1)(*)(''') + ('''+)- 9(+)(+!)- (+6) + () o! #$& A3o*+#&" A*#- 191

+ $&*&- #$&, +& *o"#'##'o+, 3+'. H& #$&&!o& "=4'##& #$+#

/$& #$& Ho>=& D'3'"'o B&*$ o! #$'" Co# $+" $& #$& 3+''#, o!

#$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- +o'#4&# o! O& M+ Co44'##&&-

#o 6o '#o #$& '""&- =+"& o #$& &*'"'o o! #$& P@+= + H+,++


44/212

44

H'6$ Co# + +**&#'6 $'" &o#- /$'*$ '" &, =+"& o $'" o/

3'&/" + #$"- +""'6 + &"o#'o- /o +4o# #o '!,'6 #$&

&*'"'o o! #$'" Co# + #$& A& Co# ' S#1thosh A1to1& V#reed's

*+"& (*'#& "+) + #$+# #$& "+4& *+o# =& +**&#&. I #$'" *o#&#-

+##&#'o o! #$'" Co# /+" +"o '3'#& #o P++6+$ 19 o! K.S#4th R#1's

*+"& (*'#& "+)- /$&&'- #$& Ho>=& D'3'"'o B&*$ o! #$'" Co# $+"

!+4& + "&*'!'* ?&"#'o- +" #o /$$&- #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o-

2008- +& ' +**o+*& /'#$ #$& o/&" *o!&& & S&*#'o" 7(1)($)

J (')- 2(1)(*)(''') + ('''+)- 9(+)(+!)- (+6) + () o! #$& A3o*+#&" A*#-

191 o o#

1. R&'+*& /+" +"o +*& o + &*'"'o o! #$'" Co# ' St#te

of T#$3 N#d! v. K.Sh$ S!1der &o#& ' )*-- (: CTC ,/: o #$&

+"&*# o! '!,'6 #$& &*'"'o o! + Co# + !#$& *o#&#'o" /&&

4+& #$+# &+'&- #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ $+" !+4& #$& &6+ E*+#'

R&"- 2008- ' *o"#+#'o /'#$ #$& &&#" + #+%& + "&*'!'* "#+

=&!o& #$& Ho>=& S&4& Co# #$+# &"*'#'o o! +6&- /+" #o

o4o#& #$& "#++" o! &6+ &*+#'o- 6o# '# +o3& +

"="&?&#,- o/ + '!!&&# "#+ '" #+%& =&!o& #$'" Co#.


45/212

45

2. I"o!+ +" De3h H2h Co!rt's *+"&- &'& o =, #$& &+&

*o"& !o #$& &"o&#"- &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& "=4'##&

#$+# #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- /&& o# *$+&6& + /$+#

/+" *$+&6& /+" o, #$& o#'!'*+#'o '""& =, #$& U'3&"'#, +

$&*&- &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& "=4'##& #$+# #$& "+' &*'"'o

'" o# +'*+=& #o #$& "+' *+"&. H& !#$& "=4'##& #$+# #$&

'46& o#'!'*+#'o- +#& 28.09.201 o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- o&"

o# "+, +,#$'6 +=o# #$& o*&& #$+# /+" !oo/&- =&!o& 4+%'6

#$& +4&4&# #o #$& R&".

. &+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& !#$& "=4'##& #$+# +

+o6 #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ + #$& &6+ E*+#'o Co44'##&& o! #$&

B+ Co*' o! I'+ $+3& &*'& #o '4&4&# #$& R&" o! &6+

E*+#'o- 2008 + #$&& '" o &+"o- +" #o /$, '# "$o =& *$+6&.

. R&!&'6 #o #$& *o#& +!!'+3'# !'& =, #$& B+ Co*' o!

T+4' N+ + Po'*$&,- C$&+'- ' #$& &"&# /'# '#'o-

&+& *o"& !o #$& '#'o& "=4'##& #$+# /$& #$& R&" o! &6+

E*+#'o- 2008- /&& !+4& ' *o"#+#'o /'#$ #$& &&#" + +" &

S&*#'o 7(1)($)- #$& !*#'o" o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- "$+ =& #o


46/212

46

o4o#& &6+ &*+#'o + #o +, o/ "#++" o! "*$ &*+#'o '

*o"#+#'o /'#$ #$& U'3&"'#'&" ' I'+- '4+#'6 "*$ &*+#'o +

S#+#& B+ Co*'"- #$& *o#&#'o o! #$& B+ Co*' o! T+4'+ +

Po'*$&,- C$&+' #$+# '# $+" o o& #o +, ' o4o#'o o! &6+

&*+#'o + +,'6 o/ #$& "#++"- /o #+#+4o# #o "$##'6

'#" &"o"'=''#'&". H& !#$& "=4'##& #$+# #$& B+ Co*' o! #$&

S#+#& *+o# +3o' '#" &"o"'=''#'&"- #$&&=,- +='*+#& '#" o/&" #o #$&

B+ Co*' o! I'+- '6o'6 '#" o& #o =& +,&- ' #$& 4+##& o!

o4o#'o o! &6+ E*+#'o + +,'6 o/ #$& "#++" o! "*$

&*+#'o. H& "=4'##& #$+# #$& S#+#& Go3&4&# *+o# =& + "'&#

"&*#+#o.

5. R&!&'6 #o *+"& 2. o! #$& U'3&"'#, G+#" Co44'""'o

(A!!''+#'o o! Co&6&" =, U'3&"'#'&") R&6+#'o"- 2009- &+& *o"&

!o #$& '#'o& "=4'##& #$+# B+ Co*' o! I'+ '" +

S#+##o,R&6+#o, =o,- #o 4+'#+' "#++" o! &6+ &*+#'o.

. I3'#'6 #$& +##&#'o o! #$'" Co# #o G.O.(M")No.19- +/

(S) D&+#4&#- +#& 0.0.2015- =, /$'*$- #$& Go3&4&# $+3&


47/212

47

'""& o&"- &"*'='6 +6& '4'# !o +4'""'o #o #$&& ,&+" + !'3&

,&+" +/ &6&& *o"&"- $& !#$& "=4'##& #$+# /$& #$& D'&*#o o!

&6+ S&3'*&"- =, $'" #& +#& 2.0.2015- $+" &*o44&& #$& +6&

&"#'*#'o /$'*$ '" ' !o*&- +# &"&#- !o +4'""'o #o Go3&4&# +/

*o&6&"- #o *o#'& ' #$& '#&&"# o! &6+ &*+#'o- o &+"o" $+3&

=&& +""'6& =, #$& Go3&4&#- +" #o /$, #$& Go3&4&# $+3&

&*'& #o &3&# #o #$& & 2008;2009 o"'#'o + '""& o&"

'&*#'6- D.A4=&%+ +/ U'3&"'#, #o &"*'=& o +6& '4'# !o #$&&

,&+" +/ &6&& *o"& + & +6& '4'# o! 21 ,&+" (&*&# !o SCST

*+'+#&") !o !'3& ,&+" '#&6+#& +/ &6&& *o"&" ' Go3&4&#

+/ Co&6&" + ' T+4' N+ D.A4=&%+ +/ U'3&"'#,- +" !oo/&

#o #$& +*+&4'* ,&+ 2008;2009. H& +"o "=4'##& #$+# #$&& '"

+="o#&, o &+"o +" #o /$, #$&& "$o =& '"*'4'+#'o =/&& +

#$&& ,&+" +/ &6&& *o"& + !'3& ,&+" +/ &6&& *o"&- ' #$&

4+##& o! &"*'='6 & +6& '4'# !o +4'""'o #o +/ &6&& *o"&".

7. B+"& o #$& *o#& +!!'+3'# !'& =, D.A4=&%+ +/

U'3&"'#,- &&"&#& =, '#" R&6'"#+- C$&+'- M.A..So4+,+@'-

&+& A3o*+#& G&&+ "=4'##& #$+# o, ' #$& ,&+ 2008- &


48/212

48

+6& '4'# $+" =&& !'& =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- !o #$& +/ &6&&

*o"&". T$& "+' &"#'*#'o /+" !oo/& =, #$& U'3&"'#,. C+"& 28

o! #$& &6+ E*+#'o R&" /+" /'#$+/ =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+.

T$& U'3&"'#, "o6$# !o *+'!'*+#'o" !o4 #$& Go3&4&# o!

T+4'+- 3'& #& No.C.F.No.959R&6+/ A4'""'o 2015- +#&

27.0.2015. Go3&4&# o! T+4' N+ '""& + o& '

G.O.(M")No.19- +/ (S) D&+#4&#- +#& 0.0.2015- /$&&' #$&

Go3&4&# $+3& &*'& #o &3&# #o #$& &;2008;2009 o"'#'o +

+**o'6,- T+4' N+ D.A4=&%+ +/ U'3&"'#, /+" '&*#& #o

&"*'=& o +6& '4'# !o #$&& ,&+ +/ &6&& *o"& + & +6&

'4'# o! 21 ,&+" (&*&# !o SCST *+'+#&") !o 5 ,&+ '#&6+#& +/

&6&& *o"& ' Go3&4&# +/ Co&6&" ' T+4' N+ D.A4=&%+

+/ U'3&"'#,- +" !oo/& #o #$& +*+&4'* ,&+ 2008;2009. T$&

S,'*+#& o! D.A4=&%+ +/ U'3&"'#,- C$&+'- $+" +""& +

&"o#'o #o +o# #$& ?+'!'*+#'o + o4" &"*'=& =, #$&

Go3&4&# ' G.O.(M")No.19- +/ (S) D&+#4&#- +#& 0.0.2015.

B+"& o #$& &"o#'o +#& 0.0.2015 +""& =, #$& S,'*+#& + #$&

Go3&4&# O&- D.A4=&%+ +/ U'3&"'#,- &&"&#& =, '#"

R&6'"#+- C$&+'- $+" '""& #$& '46& +4'""'o o#'!'*+#'o- +#&


49/212

49

0.0.2015.

8. &+& A3o*+#& G&&+ !#$& "=4'##& #$+#

D.A4=&%+ +/ U'3&"'#,- C$&+'- '" + S#+#& U'3&"'#, &"#+='"$& =,

+ A*# o! S#+#& &6'"+#& + '# !*#'o" +" & #$& o3'"'o" o! #$&

A*# + S#+##&" 4+& #$&&&. A" & S&*#'o (1)(=) o! #$& T+4'

N+ D.A4=&%+ +/ U'3&"'#, A*#- 199- #$& U'3&"'#, *+ +4'#

*+'+#&"- /$o !!'" #$& *o'#'o" &"*'=& #$&&'.

9. &+& A3o*+#& G&&+ !#$& "=4'##& #$+# ' "o !+ +"

#$& ?+'!'*+#'o" !o o#$& o!&""'o+ *o"&" '%&- M&'*'& +

E6'&&'6- '" *o*&&- #$&& '" o & +6& '4'# &"*'=& !o

+4'""'o o! "#&#" + #$&&!o&- #$& '46& o#'!'*+#'o *+o# =&

"+' #o =& 3'o+#'3& o! A#'*& 1 o! #$& Co"#'##'o o! I'+.

50. P+*'6 &'+*& o #$& &*'"'o o! #$& P@+= + H+,++

H'6$ Co# ' A14t Bh#rd"#@ vs. B#r Co!163 of I1d# (?.8.No.-);),

of )*-- d#ted )*.-*.)*-- #$& &+& A3o*+#& G&&+ "=4'##&

#$+# *+"& 28 o! "*$&& III +&& #o #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o-

2008- $+" +&+, =&& $& +" +='#+, + =&,o #$& &6'"+#'3&

*o4&*& o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ + #$+# #$&&!o&- #$& &*'"'o


50/212

50

o! #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- #o &4o3& #$& & +6& '4'#- !o +4'""'o

#o #$&& ,&+" +/ &6&& *o"&- *+o# =& "+' #o =& +='#+, o

3'o+#'3& o! #$& "#+##o, o3'"'o" o! &'#$& #$& A3o*+#&" A*#- 191 o

#$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ R&". H& '3'#& #$& +##&#'o o! #$'" Co# #o

++6+$ 7 o! #$& +=o3& @64&#.

51. &+& A3o*+#& G&&+ !#$& "=4'##& #$+# #$& SP

!'& =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ +6+'"# #$& @64&# ' A14t Bh#rd"#@

vs. B#r Co!163 of I1d# (?.8.No.-);), of )*-- d#ted )*.-*.)*--

/+" '"4'""& o 05.01.2015. R&!&'6 #o #$& @64&# ' K.S#4th R#1

vs. The Se6ret#r& to B#r Co!163 of T#$31#d! &o#& ' )*-* ()

L.?. /: $& "=4'##& #$+# #$& *$+&6& ' #$& +=o3&"+' *+"& /+" '

&+#'o #o #$& &o4&# o! #$& *+'+#&" +=o3& 5 ,&+" +

#$&&!o&- #$& "+' @64&# '" '+o"'#& #o #$'" *+"&.

52. R&!&'6 #o #$& @64&# o! #$& Ho>=& D'3'"'o B&*$

@64&#" o! #$& P@+= + H+,++ H'6$ Co# ' R#@#1 Sh#r$# Vs.

The B#r Co!163 of I1d# #1d #1other 0C.?.8.No.)*+ of )*-* d#ted

)*.-*.)*--5 + A14t Bh#rd"#@ vs. B#r Co!163 of I1d#

(?.8.No.-);), of )*-- d#ted )*.-*.)*-- &+& A3o*+#& G&&+

"=4'##& #$+# /$& #$& '#'o&" #$&&'- "o6$# !o + +,& #o "#'%&


51/212

51

o/ *+"& 28 o! #$& R&" o! &6+ E*+#'o- 2008- #$& Ho>=& D'3'"'o

B&*$ o! #$& P@+= + H+,++ H'6$ Co# *o"'&& #$& 3+''#, o!

#$& R&"- /'#$ &!&&*& #o #$& o3'"'o" o! #$& A3o*+#&" A*#- 191

+ #+%'6 o#& o! #$& &*'"'o o! #$& Ho>=& A& Co# ' I1d#1

Co!163 of Le2#3 Ad #1d Adv6e #1d others v. B#r Co!163 of I1d# #1d

#1other &o#& ' (-++; - SCC /9) $& #$+# #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+

'" o# +4& /'#$ +, o/& #o '*oo+#& + o3'"'o ' #$& &"- '%&

*+"& 28- *o*&'6 #$& +6& o +4'""'o #o +/ &6&& *o"&.

5. A##&#'o o! #$'" Co# /+" '3'#& #o ++6+$ 8 o! #$&

@64&# ' I1d#1 Co!163 of Le2#3 Ad #1d Adv6e #1d others v. B#r

Co!163 of I1d# #1d #1other &o#& ' (-++; - SCC /9) *o"'&&

=, #$& Ho>=& D'3'"'o B&*$. T$& "+' ++6+$ '" &#+*#&

$&&&:;

8. T$& &/, +& & "&&%" #o =+ #$& &#, o!

&"o" /$o $+3& *o4& #$& +6& o! 5 ,&+" o #$& +#& o!

+'*+#'o !o &o4&# +" + +3o*+#& !o4 =&'6 &o& +""*$ =, #$& S#+#& B+ Co*' *o*&&. W$'& S&*#'o 2 o!

#$& A*# &"*'=&" #$& 4''44 +6& !o &o4&# +" #/&#,;

o& ,&+" *o4&- #$&& '" o o3'"'o ' #$& A*# /$'*$ *+

=& "+' #o &"*'=& #$& 4+'44 +6& !o &#, '#o #$&


52/212

52

o!&""'o. S'*& #$& A*# '" "'&# o #$'" o'# #$& B+ Co*'

o! I'+ /+" &?'& #o &"o# #o '#" &;4+%'6 o/&. T$&

&" 4+& =, #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ & S&*#'o 9(1) o!

#$& A*# +& ' "&3& +#"- &+*$ +# $+3'6 '#" o/ *$+#&".

P+# I '" &#'#& R&" Go3&'6 A3o*+#&" + #$& "+' +#

$+" #$&& *$+#&". C$+#& I "" o# #$& &"#'*#'o" o "&'o

+3o*+#&" + '" &+#+=& #o S&*#'o" 1() + 9(1)(6) o! #$&

A*#- C$+#& II +," o/ #$& "#++" o! o!&""'o+ *o*#

+ '?#& + '" &+#+=& #o S&*#'o 9(1)(*) &+ /'#$ #$&o3'"o #$&o + C$+#& III &+" /'#$ Co'#'o" !o '6$#

#o +*#'*& + '" "#+#& #o =& 4+& ' &&*'"& o! o/& &

*+"& (+$) o! "=;"&*#'o (1) o! S&*#'o 9 o! #$& A*#. T$+#

*+"& &+" +" &:

(+$) #$& *o'#'o" "=@&*# #o /$'*$ + +3o*+#& "$+ $+3&

#$& '6$# #o +*#'*& + #$& *'*4"#+*&" & /$'*$ +

&"o "$+ =& &&4& #o +*#'*& +" + +3o*+#& ' + *o#

O #$& +' +6+6& o! #$& "+' *+"& '# "&&4" *&+ #o "

#$+# & #$& "+' o3'"'o #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ *+ +,

o/ #$& >*o'#'o"> "=@&*# #o /$'*$ + +3o*+#& "$+ $+3&

#$& '6$# #o +*#'*&. T$&"& *o'#'o" /$'*$ #$& B+ Co*' o!

I'+ *+ +, o/ +& +'*+=& #o + +3o*+#&- '.&.- + &"o

/$o $+" +&+, =&& &o& +" + +3o*+#& =, #$& S#+#& B+

Co*' *o*&&. T$& *o'#'o" /$'*$ *+ =& &"*'=&

4"# +, +# #$& o"#;&o4&# "#+6& "'*& #$&, +& &&*#&

#o &+#& #o #$& '6$# #o +*#'*&. T$&, *+- #$&&!o&- o#

o&+#& +# #$& &; &o4&# "#+6&. B, #$& '46& &- #$&


53/212

53

&#, o! #$o"& /$o $+3& *o4& 5 ,&+" +# #$& +#& o!

+'*+#'o !o &o4&# '" "o6$# #o =& =+&. T$& &

*&+, o&+#&" +# #$& &; &o4&# "#+6& + *+o#-

#$&&!o&- &*&'3& #$& "$&#& o! *+"& (+$) o! S&*#'o 9(1) o!

#$& A*#. U& #$& "+' *+"& *o'#'o" +'*+=& #o +

+3o*+#& #o*$'6 $'" '6$# #o +*#'*& *+ =& +' o/- + '!

+' o/ $& 4"# &&*'"& $'" '6$# "=@&*# #o #$o"& *o'#'o".

B# #$& +6+6& o! #$& "+' *+"& o&" o# &4'# +,'6 o/

o! *o'#'o" !o &#, '#o #$& o!&""'o. W& $+3&- #$&&!o&-o $&"'#+#'o ' *o4'6 #o #$& *o*"'o #$+# *+"& (+$) o!

S&*#'o 9(1) o! #$& A*# o&" o# &4o/& #$& B+ Co*' o!

I'+ #o !+4& + & =+'6 &"o" /$o $+3& *o4& 5

,&+" o! +6& !o4 &o4&# +" + +3o*+#&. T$& '46& &

'"- #$&&!o&- #+ 3'&" #$& "+' o3'"'o.

5. R&3&#'6 #o #$& Ho>=& D'3'"'o B&*$ @64&# o! #$&

P@+= + H+,++ H'6$ Co#- &+& A3o*+#& G&&+ +"o &!&&

#o ++6+$" 9- 10 + 12- /$'*$ +& &#+*#& $&&&:;

9. T$& '46& C+"& 28 &+'6 /'#$ #$& +6& o

+4'""'o o**'6 ' S*$&&;III +&& #o #$& R&" $+3&

=&& !+4& & S&*#'o 7(1)($) + (') + 2(1)(*)(''') +

('''+)- 9(1)(+!)- (+6)- + () o! #$& A3o*+#&" A*#. S&*#'o 7 o!

#$& A3o*+#&" A*# &+" /'#$ #$& !*#'o o! #$& B+ Co*' o!

I'+ + C+"& 7(1)($) + (') o, &+" /'#$ "*$ !*#'o" o!


54/212

54

#$& B+ Co*' o! I'+- /$'*$ +& +'4& +# o4o#'6 #o &6+

&*+#'o + #o +, o/ "#++" o! "*$ &*+#'o '

*o"#+#'o /'#$ #$& U'3&"'#'&" ' I'+ '4+#'6 "*$

&*+#'o + #o &*o6'& #$& U'3&"'#'&" /$o"& &6&& ' +/

"$+ =& + ?+'!'*+#'o !o &o4&# +" + A3o*+#&.

T$&&!o&- #$'" *+"& /o o# +4 #$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ #o

'*oo+#& #$& o3'"'o" ' #$& R&" '%& *+"& 28 *o*&'6

#$& +6& o +4'""'o #o ..B. Co"&. '%&/'"&- S&*#'o 2(')(*)

&+" /'#$ &"o /$o 4+, =& +4'##& +" + A3o*+#& o +S#+#& o. I# $+" 6o# o#$'6 #o o /'#$ #$& +6& o +4'""'o

+ *+o# =& *o"#& #o $+3& *o!&& o/& o #$& B+

Co*' o! I'+ #o &"*'=& #$& 4+'44 +6& !o #$& o"&"

o! +4'""'o #o ..B. F'3& ,&+"> Co"& o ..B. T$&& &+">

Co"& .

10. W& +& &!# #o &+ /'#$ S&*#'o 9(1)(+!) + (+6) o!

#$& A3o*+#&" A*#. T$& +!o&"+' *+"& (+!) &+" /'#$ #$&

4''44 ?+'!'*+#'o &?'& !o +4'""'o #o + *o"& o!

&6&& ' +/ ' +, &*o6'& U'3&"'#, + *+"& (+6) &+"

/'#$ #$& *+"" o *+#&6o, o! #$& &"o" &#'#& #o =& &o&

+" A3o*+#&". C+"& () o! S&*#'o 9 (') o! #$& A3o*+#&" A*#

&+" /'#$ #$& "#++" o! &6+ &*+#'o #o =& o="&3& =,

'3&"'#'&" ' I'+ + #$& '"&*#'o o! '3&"'#'&" !o #$+#

o"&. W& +& +!+' #$+# &3& #$'" C+"& /o o# &#&

#o 6+# *o4&*& #o B+ Co*' o! I'+ #o '*oo+#& +

o3'"'o *o*&'6 #$& 4+'44 +6& !o +4'""'o #o ..B.

Co"&. T$& 4+##& $+" =&& '"*""& ' +' ' I'+


55/212

55

Co*' o! &6+ A' + A3'*&>" *+"& ("+) =, Ho>=& #$&

S&4& Co#. I# '" +"o &&3+# #o 4&#'o #$+# + "'4'+ 3'&/

/+" #+%& =, + D'3'"'o B&*$ o! M++" H'6$ Co# ' #$& *+"&

o! M. R#dh#4rsh1#1 v. The Se6ret#r& the B#r Co!163 of

I1d# AIR )**/ M#dr#s -*,. T$&&!o&- /& !' #$+# #$&

o3'"'o" o! C+"& 28 o! S*$&&;III +&& #o #$& R&"

+& =&,o #$& &6'"+#'3& *o4&*& o! #$& B+ Co*' o!

I'+. C+"& 28 #+ 3'&" #$& o3'"'o" o! S&*#'o" 7(1)($) +

(')- 2(1)(*) (''') + ('''+) o S&*#'o 9(1)(+!) (+6) + () o!#$& A3o*+#& A*#. E3& o#$&/'"&- #$& R& '" +='#+, +" '#

'#o*&" + '3''o" *+""'!'*+#'o =, '3''6 o& C+"" o!

"#&# '#o #/o +#'!'*'+ + '+#'o+ C+""&" =, &"*'='6

#$& 4+'44 +6& !o +4'""'o #o +/ *o"&".

12. A" + "&?& #o #$& +=o3& '"*""'o- #$& /'# '#'o"

+& +o/&. T$& '#'o&" /$o $+3& =&& +4'##& o #$&

=+"'" o! #$& '#&'4 o& /o *o#'& + #$&' +4'""'o"

"$o o# =& *+*&& o #$& 6o #$+# #$&, ' o# !!'

#$& *'#&'+ o! 4+'44 +6&.

55. &+& A3o*+#& G&&+ +"o &'& o + &*'"'o '

Mr.Ksht@ Sh#r$# #1d #1other vs. The B#r Co!163 of I1d# #1d

#1other (?rt(8IL 8etto1 No.):+/)*-; d#ted *:.*9.)*-; o! #$&

Ho>=& D'3'"'o B&*$ @64&# o! #$& R+@+"#$+ H'6$ Co# +# +'

B&*$ + "=4'##& #$+# /$& #$& U'3&"'#, '""& + o#'!'*+#'o-


56/212

56

&"*'='6 +6& '4'# !o +4'""'o #o +/ &6&& *o"&"- !oo/'6 #$&

&*'"'o o! #$& P@+= + H+,++ H'6$ Co#- "#+#& "+ + #+%'6

o#& o! #$& !+*# #$+# + +6& 4=& o! /'# '#'o" $+3& =&& !'& '

#$& H'6$ Co#"- +*o"" #$& *o#, /'#$ &!&&*& #o #$& +6& !+*#o- #$&

Ho>=& +' B&*$ /+" o! #$& 3'&/ #$+# +'*+#'o o! #$& "#&#" !o

Co44o +/ A4'""'o T&"# 2015- "$o o# =& &@&*#& o #$& 6o"

o! &"*'#'o o! & +6&. H& +"o &'& o + &*'"'o o! #$&

A+$+=+ H'6$ Co# ' Dev#sheesh 8#th#4 #1d )* others vs. B#r

Co!163 of I1d# thro!2h Se6ret#r& #1d ) others (?rt C No.;)-+ of

)*-; d#ted ).*).)*-; ' /$'*$ &"*'#'o o! #$& 4+'44 +6&

'4'# !o +4'""'o #o +/ &6&& *o"& ' #$& Co44o +/ A4'""'o

T&"# 2015 (' "$o# CAT;2015) /+" "o6$# #o =& ?+"$&. H&& +6+'-

#$& A+$+=+ H'6$ Co# +!#& *o"'&'6 #$& @64&#" ' A14t

Bh#rd"#@ vs. B#r Co!163 of I1d# (?.8.No.-);), of )*-- d#ted

)*.-*.)*-- R#@#1 Sh#r$# Vs. The B#r Co!163 of I1d# #1d #1other

0C.?.8.No.)*+ of )*-* d#ted )*.-*.)*--5 ?+"$& #$&

o#'!'*+#'o.

5. P+*'6 &'+*& o #$& &*'"'o ' K!s!$ I12ots < A33o&s


57/212

57

Ltd. vs. U1o1 of I1d# &o#& ' )**: ( SCC );: + #$& &*'"'o"

o! #$& P@+= + H+,++ H'6$ Co# ' A14t Bh#rd"#@ vs. B#r Co!163

of I1d# (?.8.No.-);), of )*-- d#ted )*.-*.)*-- Mr.Ksht@

Sh#r$# #1d #1other vs. The B#r Co!163 of I1d# #1d #1other

(?rt(8IL 8etto1 No.):+/)*-; d#ted *:.*9.)*-; &+&

A3o*+#& G&&+ !#$& "=4'##& #$+# #$& o#$& H'6$ Co#" $+3&

&&*'"& #$&' @'"'*#'o- + +' o/ #$& +/ &6+'6 #$& 3+''#,

o! *+"& 28 o! #$& &6+ E*+#'o R&".

57. &+& A3o*+#& G&&+ !#$& "=4'##& #$+# o*& #$&

3+''#, o! + *&#+ &+*#4&# '" #&"#&- o*#'& o! *o4'#, *o4&" '#o

&!!&*# + #$+# #$&&!o&- '# '" =''6 o o#$& *o#". R&!&&*& /+"

4+& #o #$& &*'"'o" 4+& ' K!s!$ I12ots < A33o&s Ltd. vs. U1o1 of

I1d# &o#& ' )**: ( SCC );: U1o1 of I1d# vs. Tet3e

Te6h16#3 Tr#des$e1 Asso6#to1 &o#& ' )*-: ( CTC :)/ Shv

K!$#r vs. U1o1 of I1d# &o#& ' AIR )*-: K#r1#t#4# /9. A" #$&

&*'"'o o! #$& P@+= + H+,++ H'6$ Co# + o#$& *o#" &+#& #o

C&#+ +/ + #$& &" !+4& #$&&& + *o"'&'6 #$+#

'!o4'#, $+" #o =& !oo/& #$o6$o# #$& *o#,- '# '" =''6 o #$'"


58/212

58

Co# +" /&. H& '"#'6'"$& #$& @64&# ' M.S#1thosh A1to1&

V#reed vs. Re2str#r T#$3 N#d! Dr.A$%ed4#r L#" U1verst&

&o#& ' )**+ (, MLJ -// "#+#'6 #$+# ' #$& +=o3&"+' @64&#-

#$&& /+" o *$+&6& #o #$& &".

58. A**o'6 #o $'4- #$&& '" o *+"& o! '!,'6 #$& @64&#

o! #$& Co#" + o #$& *o#+- '# '" + '4&4&#+#'o o! #$& &*'"'o"

o! #$& P@+= + H+,++ H'6$ Co#- R+@+"#$+ + o#$& H'6$ Co#"-

#o $+3& '!o4'#, #$o6$o# #$& *o#,- ' "o !+ +" #$& & +6&

'4'# '" *o*&&- !o +4'""'o #o +/ &6&& *o"&"- '" *o*&&. H&

!#$& "=4'##& #$+# /$+# /+" *o"'&& ' K.S#4th R#1 vs. The

Se6ret#r& to B#r Co!163 of T#$31#d! &o#& ' )*-* () L.?. /:

/+" o, + *$+&6& #o *+*&+#'o o! &o4&# o! #$o"& /$o $+

+&+, *o4& +/ &6&& *o"& +# #$& #'4& o! *o4'6 '#o !o*& o!

#$& &6+ &*+#'o &" 2008 + #$+# #$& "+4& '" '+'*+=& #o #$&

!+*#" o! #$'" *+"&.

59. H& !#$& "=4'##& #$+# &3& ' D.A4=&%+ +/

U'3&"'#, S#+##&" o O'+*&- #$&& '" o o3'"'o &"#'*#'6 #$&


59/212

59

*+'+#&" !o +4'""'o- =, &"*'='6 +, & +6& '4'# +

#$&&!o&- #$& Go3&4&# o! T+4' N+ $+3& &*'& #o '4&4&# #$&

B+ Co*' o! I'+>" &*'"'o. I# '" +"o $'" !#$& *o#&#'o #$+# #$&

&"o#'o o! #$& S,'*+#& $+" o# =&& *$+&6& + #$&&!o&- '# '"

o# o& #o #$& '#'o&- #o "&&% !o +, +4&4&#- *$+&6'6

G.O.(M")No.19- +/ (S) D&+#4&#- +#& 0.0.2015. Fo #$&

+=o3&"+' &+"o"- &+& A3o*+#& G&&+ +,& !o '"4'""+ o! #$&

/'# '#'o.

0. B+"& o #$& *o#& +!!'+3'# !'& =, #$& o'# S&*+,-

B+ Co*' o! I'+- N&/ D&$'- M.S.R.R+@+6o+- &+& *o"& !o

#$& B+ Co*' o! I'+ "=4'##& #$+# S&*#'o 7(1)($) o! #$& A3o*+#&"

A*#- 191 &+ /'#$ S&*#'o 9(1)() o! #$& A3o*+#&" A*#- &4o/&" #$&

B+ Co*' o! I'+ #o 4+%& &"- &"*'='6 "#++" o! &6+

&*+#'o #o =& o="&3& =, #$& U'3&"'#'&" ' I'+ + '"&

Madras HC Quashes Bar Council of India Notification Relaxing the Age Limit for Three-year Law Course

Documents

Transcript of Madras HC Quashes Bar Council of India Notification Relaxing the Age Limit for Three-year Law Course