Luxembourg tax opportunities for US · PDF fileInternational Corporate Tax. Luxembourg tax...
Transcript of Luxembourg tax opportunities for US · PDF fileInternational Corporate Tax. Luxembourg tax...
International Corporate Tax
Luxembourg tax opportunities for US investorsHouston, 4 November 2010
Luc Alexandre
Senior Manager, KPMG Tax Luxembourg
2
Today’s agenda
I. Overview
II. Typical structures
I. Holding
II. Financing
III. Licensing
IV. Trading
3
I. Overview
4
OverviewLuxembourg country facts
•At the heart of Europe and founding member of the European Union (member since 1951)
•A renowned international financial centre
5
OverviewLuxembourg country facts
6
Statutory tax rate:28.59% in 201028.80% in 2011
Possible to maintain the ETR to a minimum for any type of activity through tax planning
Favorable IP tax regime: • Effective tax rate of 5.72% for royalty income• A tax ruling is in principle not required
Advance tax ruling system to secure upfront the tax treatment of transactions (prompt and flexible tax authorities – written confirmation is obtained within 2 to 6 weeks): pragmatic approach
No capital / stamp duties
Extensive network of tax treaties that helps reduce/eliminate withholding taxes on foreign income receipts
• Almost 60 treaties currently in force incl. Mexico, Brazil, HK, etc.• 14 treaties currently in negotiation
OverviewA favourable tax environment
7
No withholding tax on royalties, interest & liquidation proceeds (in principle)
No withholding tax on dividends paid to US corporations (subject to conditions)
Luxembourg participation exemption (incoming dividend and capital gain exempt)
No or minor taxation upon exit or refinancing strategy
Access to EU Directives (Parent/Subsidiary, Interest/Royalties, and Merger Directives)
No CFC rules
Bilateral Investment Treaties
OverviewA favourable tax environment (Cont’d)
8
OverviewHot topics in Luxembourg
Increase in aggregate corporate tax rate: from 28.59% (2010) to 28.80% (2011)
Transfer pricing studies for newly established back-to-back financing entities
Minimum flat tax of EUR 1,500 for corporate entities (SOPARFIs)• Of which financial assets (including transferable securities, receivables, bank deposit etc.)
exceed 90% of their total assets;• That do not perform activities subject to a business license or approval of supervisory authority;• in fiscal unity cases only applicable once at the level of the integrating Luxembourg parent
company or permanent establishment;• But not before 2012
9
II. Typical structures
USCo
Dividends
LuxCo
EU / non-EU
Typical structures : HoldingEU subsidiaries or “high-taxed” non-EU subsidiaries
Dividends Capital gains
Benefits• Full exemption on incoming dividends and capital gains
(participation exemption regime):• 10% ownership or acquisition price of EUR 1.2m
(dividends) / EUR 6m (capital gains)• 12 months holding period• “Subject to tax” requirement (except for EU subsidiairies)
• No Luxembourg withholding tax on dividends paid to USCo under domestic rules
• In principle, no foreign withholding tax on incoming dividends from EU/non-EU subsidiaries pursuant to EU Directive and tax treaties
Other Considerations• Luxembourg tax clearance• Luxembourg substance requirements
11
Typical structures : HoldingUtilisation of tax losses in Luxembourg
USCo
LuxCo1
OpCos
Benefits• Upon disposal of participations in OpCos to LuxCo2,
crystallisation of write-downs into permanent tax losses at the level of LuxCo1
• The tax losses of LuxCo1 becoming permanent, may be used against income deriving from e.g. financing, trading… activities
• Losses at the level of OpCos remain tax deductible
Other Considerations• Luxembourg tax clearance• Change of control at OpCos level
LuxCo2
OpCos
USCo
Dividends
LuxCo
Low-taxed non-EU
Typical structures : Holding“Low-taxed” non-EU subsidiaries (tax havens)
Dividends Capital gains
Benefits• No or low taxation on incoming dividends and capital gains from
“low-taxed” subsidiaries (e.g. Tax havens) that do not benefit from the Luxembourg participation exemption regime
• No Luxembourg withholding tax on the accrual (or payment) of yield on TPECs (Tracking Preferred Equity Certificates)
Tax analysis• TPECs are a hybrid and are treated as debt for Luxembourg tax
purposes – accrual yield treated as tax deductible interest expense
• TPECs bear (i) a fixed interest rate equal to 0.1% of the nominal value of the TPECs and (ii) a variable interest rate calculated as 99% of LuxCo’s net income
• LuxCo taxed on margin between the dividends/capital gains and the yield on TPECs – effective taxation can be as low as 0.3%
Other Considerations• Luxembourg tax clearance• For US purposes, TPECs are treated as equity under certain
conditions – as long as the yield is accrued but not paid there is no taxation in the US (no Luxembourg requirement to pay the yield before exit)
TPECs
13
Typical structures : HoldingUtilisation of foreign tax treaty PE losses
USCoBackground
• The tax rate applicable to income realised by a LuxCo in Luxembourg, should be determined as if LuxCo’s worldwide (i.e. domestic & foreign) income were subject to tax in Luxembourg (Circular on article 134 of Luxembourg Income Tax Law).
• This applies to the extent that foreign income is realised in a tax treaty country
LuxCo
Foreigntax treaty PE
14
Typical structures : HoldingUtilisation of foreign tax treaty PE losses (Cont’d)
USCo
LuxCo
Foreigntax treaty PE
Example (simplified)
AssumptionsLuxembourg profit/(loss): 100 millionForeign PE profit/(loss): (120 million)
Step 1Worldwide profit/(loss): (20 million)Tax rate computed thereon: 0% (due to
negative result)
Step 2Luxembourg income: 100 million
Step 3Luxembourg income: 100 millionApplicable tax rate (see step 1): 0%Luxembourg corporate tax due: -
15
Typical structures : Holding US Foreign tax credit
USCo
PECs
LuxCo
OpCos
Benefits• USCo is in excess of FTC carry forward and incurs an important
annual interest expense. USCo apportions interest expense using an asset method (Treas. Reg. 1.861 – 9T)
• USCo subscribes to PECs issued by LuxCo and contributes its foreign subsidiaries to LuxCo (Sect 351)
• Reduction of interest expense to be apportioned to foreign source and increasing USCo’s FTC limitation
• From US tax point of view, PECs treated as equity, not subject to US tax until repatriation
• Luxembourg participation exemption on OpCos dividends, capital gains, liquidation proceeds at the level of LuxCo.
Other Considerations• Luxembourg tax clearance• Terms/conditions of PEC (term of years, fixed interest, etc.) to
confirm hybrid treatment (US: equity / Lux: debt)
16
Typical structures : Holding
HavenCo
Background
• Existing HavenCo will re-domicile to Luxembourg
Benefits
• Access to EU Directives, extensive tax planning opportunities, absence of CFC rules
• Tax capital for dividend distribution free of Luxembourg withholding tax
LuxCo
GroupCos GroupCos
USCo
LuxCo
ForeignSubs
Typical structures : Holding & FinancingLuxembourg holding/financing company (CPECs)
Benefits• Taxation on a small margin in Luxembourg• No Luxembourg withholding tax on accrual (or payment) of yield on
CPECs (Convertible Preferred Equity Certificates)• Due to the hybrid nature of CPECs, USCo can push debt down to the
ForeignSubs to obtain local country interest expense deduction without incurring any additional US taxable income
Tax analysis• CPECs are a hybrid and are treated as debt for Luxembourg tax
purposes – accrual yield treated as tax deductible interest expense• Taxable margin between 3bp and 25bp
Other Considerations• Luxembourg tax clearance• For US purposes, CPECs are treated as equity under certain conditions
– as long as the yield is accrued but not paid there is no taxation in the US
• When financing activities are combined with holding activities in Luxembourg, there is no effective taxation in most cases as the interest expenses on the tranche of CPECs relating to the acquisition of shares (CPECs A) allows to offset the taxable margin left on the back-to-back financing activity. In this case, recapture should apply except in case of liquidation (disposal) of ForeignSubs
CPECs A
Loans
CPECs B
Shares
18
Typical structures : FinancingLuxembourg back-to-back hybrid
USCo
PECs
OpCos
Benefits
• Luxembourg participation exemption on OpCos’ dividends, capital gains and liquidation proceeds at the level of LuxCo
• From US point of view, PECs treated as equity, not subject to US tax until repatriation
• Interest income taxes on a margin in Luxembourg• No Luxembourg withholding tax on dividends (subject to
conditions) paid to USCo
Other Considerations
• Luxembourg tax clearance• Terms/conditions of PEC (term of years, fixed interest, etc.) to
confirm hybrid treatment (US: equity / Lux: debt)
LuxCo
Loan
19
Typical structures : FinancingOpCos financing using reverse hybrid entities
USCo
Loan
LuxCo
OpCos
Lux SNC/SCS
Loan
Benefits
• Interest deduction in OpCos with no corresponding pick up in the US (deferral) or in Luxembourg
• No withholding tax on interest (i) paid by OpCos to LuxCo (tax treaty, EU Directive) and (ii) from LuxCo to Lux SNC/SCS
• Small net margin left in LuxCo on financing activity• No withholding tax on dividends paid to LuxCo (tax treaty, EU
Directive)• Participation exemption on dividends, capital gains, liquidation
proceeds from OpCos• No withholding tax on dividends paid by LuxCo and Lux SNC/SCS
(subject to conditions)• Dividends and interest received by Lux SNC/SCS can be lent through
LuxCo (facility agreement)• Lux SNC/SCS has legal body (checkable)• One single holding and financing structure and cost reduction• No anti-debt creation rule
Points of attention
• Luxembourg tax clearance.
20
Typical structures : Financing UK financing using UK LLP: Same country exception
USCo
UK OpCo
Equity
UK LLP
LuxCo
Loan
Summary of Tax Consequences
• UK OpCo deducts interest paid to LuxCo
• UK – Lux tax treaty eliminates UK withholding tax
• Interest paid by UK OpCo qualifies for same country exception (since LuxCo is disregarded)
• Minimum fully taxable margin left in Luxembourg
• No Luxembourg withholding tax on interest paid to UK LLP (under Luxembourg domestic law)
Benefits
• Interest deduction in UK; no corresponding UK . Deferral of US taxes
• Only minimal tax in Luxembourg, which should be creditable
Other Considerations
• Luxembourg tax clearance
•Can use Scottish Partnership instead of UK LLP
• UK thin capitalization, worldwide debt cap and transfer pricing rules
Loan
21
Typical structures : FinancingCanada financing using Can LP: Same country exception
USCo
PECs
LuxCo
Can OpCoCan LPLoan
Summary of Tax Consequences
• Can Opco deducts interest paid to Can LP
• Interest subject to 10% Canadian withholding tax under Canada –Luxembourg tax treaty
• Interest paid by Can OpCo qualifies for same country exception
• Minimum fully taxable margin left in Luxembourg
Benefits
• Net tax savings in Canada (interest deduction, less 10% withholding tax); no corresponding US taxes
• Only minimal Luxembourg tax
Other Considerations
• Luxembourg tax clearance
• Canadian thin cap limitation (2:1)
•Fifth Protocol to US-Canada tax treaty
•Can LP: Permanent establishment
USCo
LuxCo
Typical structures : FinancingCash & treasury management
Benefits
• LuxCo taxed on a margin between (i) its net interest income and (ii) the yield on TPECs – effective taxation approx. 0.3%
• No foreign exchange exposure on short-term loans in multiple currencies in the context of treasury management and cash pooling activities
• No Luxembourg withholding tax on the accrual (or payment) of yield on TPECs (Tracking Preferred Equity Certificates)
Other Considerations
• Luxembourg tax clearance
TPECs
Intra-group short-term loans in
Intra-group short-term loans out
Cash pooling activities
23
Typical structures : FinancingLuxBranch of a Hungarian company
USCo
GroupCos
Benefits
• Financing and holding activities can be located at the level of the LuxBranch including FX and derivatives
• Small Hungarian tax• Luxembourg effective tax rate approx. 1.2% – 1.5%
Other Considerations
• Luxembourg tax clearance• Substance
HungCo
LuxBranch
Loans
24
Typical structures : FinancingBeneficial ownership test
USCo
0% MRPS
LuxCo2
OpCo
LuxCo1
IB Loan
PECs
USCo
LuxCo2
OpCo
LuxCo1
IB Loan
US branch
IF Loan or
IB Loan
USCo
LuxIPCo
ForeignSubs
Typical structures : LicensingLuxembourg IP tax regime
Benefits
• 80% exemption is granted for income and gains deriving from a wide range of qualifying IP assets (software copyrights, patents, trademarks, domain names, designs & models) resulting in an effective taxation of approx. 5.72%
• Connected or third party acquisition, or self-developed• R&D of IP can be carried out in Luxembourg or abroad (e.g. US) by
means of cost-sharing agreement – also Law of 5 June 2009 on Research, Development and Innovation providing State-backed financial incentives for R&D activities carried out in Luxembourg
• No capital or stamp duties due on the injection of cash by USCo to LuxIPCo for incorporation or future financing of the activities
LicensingIP
Royalties
USCo
LuxIPCo
ForeignSubs
Typical structures : LicensingTPEC structure for licensing activities
Benefits
• LuxIPCo taxed on a margin equal to the difference between its net royalty income and the yield on the TPECs – effective taxation between approx. 0.5% and 1.5%
Tax analysis
• No Luxembourg withholding tax on accrual (or payment) of yield on the TPECs
Other Considerations
• Luxembourg tax clearance
TPECs
Licensing
IP
Royalties
27
Typical structures : Licensing Migration of IP – Lux/Swiss hybrid
USCo
LuxCo
Background
• Migration of TaxHavenCo from TaxHaven to Luxembourg• Immediately thereafter, incorporation by LuxCo of SwissCo
and transfer of IP thereto against a hybrid instrument• SwissCo performs licensing activities with the IP it owns
against royalty income
Benefits
• Hybrid instrument should qualify as equity for Luxembourg corporate tax purposes, and as debt in Switzerland
• Income should qualify for the Luxembourg participation exemption at LuxCo level.
• Expenses should be deductible at Swiss level
Other considerations
• Safe harbour thin cap rules• Apply to related party debt• 30% equity for IP
• Luxembourg tax clearance• Arm’s length interest rate
USCo
TaxHavenCo
SwissCo
Hybrid
Licensing
IP
IP
28
Typical structures : TradingMaquiladora structure
Background
• USCo plans to reorganise part of its business, with the creation of a Luxembourg company, and the migration of profit from the US to a Luxembourg company
• Currently, most of the Group’s operations, personnel and intangible value is in the US. Outside the US, its activities are mainly limited to a Mexican manufacturing plan
Fact pattern
• USCo incorporates LuxCo, and contribute the shares in MexCo to LuxCo against share capital/share premium
• USCo sells existing equipment to LuxCo at book value• LuxCo enters into service agreements with MexCo, e.g.
•MexPlant agrees to make available personnel to LuxCo to work under the control of the latter•A plant manager, controller... will perform their services under the supervision, direction and control of LuxCo and shall be granted authority to represent and act on behalf of the latter in Mexico
USCo
LuxCo
MexCo
MexBranch
Sale of equipment at
book value
Services agreements
29
Typical structures : TradingMaquiladora structure (Cont’d)
Luxembourg tax treatment
• The sale of the Mexican assets to LuxCo should be made at book value. However, if the fair market value of the assets exceeds the book value, the difference should be considered non-taxable informal capital contribution at the level of LuxCo
• As a result of the activities realised by LuxCo in Mexico through the secondment and services agreements, LuxCohas a permanent establishment in Mexico within the meaning of the Luxembourg – Mexico double tax treaty
• An arm’s length margin of 8% – 12% of the costs (i.e. operating charges incurred in connection with the activities of the head-office, but not current or future interest expenses accrued on debt attributable to the holding or financing activities of LuxCo) in connection with the head-office’s commercial activity should be left at the level of the latter and fully taxable in Luxembourg, leading to a very low ETR in Luxembourg.
USCo
LuxCo
MexCo
MexBranch
Sale of equipment at
book value
Services agreements
30
Typical structures : Trading Carbon Trading
LuxCo
Background
• LuxCo is incorporated to acquire carbon dioxyde emission allownces (also called Carbon Credits), for resale on public markets
• LuxCo to be financed 99% with CPECs and 1% with equity
Benefits
• CPECs to be considered debt for Luxembourg corporate tax and net wealth tax purposes.
• Yield due under the CPECs to qualify as interest (and in principle free of Luxembourg withholding tax)
• Minimum net taxable margin to be left in Luxembourg, measured on the total outstanding annual average outstanding principal amount of CPECs.
Other considerations
• Luxembourg tax clearance
99% CPECs1% equity
ResalePurchase from third parties
Funds
CO2 emission allowances
31
USCo
TPECs
LuxCo
OpCos
Risk assumption agreement
Typical structures : TradingTrading structure – Assumption of risks
CV
USCo
TPECs
LuxCo
OpCos
NL BV
32
Typical structures : Trading and ForexLuxBranch / LuxCo
USCoBackground
• A notional deduction at LuxBranch level to offset interest income by LuxCo on its loan portfolio under the fiscal unity regime
• LuxBranch and LuxCo file a fiscal unity
Benefits
• Net wealth tax computed at LuxBranch and LuxColevels
• Arm’s length margin• Currency gain/losses effectively neutralised• Withholding tax at ForeignCo level may be reduced
where tax treaty applies
Other consideration
• Luxembourg tax clearance
ForeignCo
LuxBranch
Foreign currency loans
LuxCo
0% PEC
33
Contact Details
Luc AlexandreSenior Manager
Tel: ++352 22 51 51 – 5464Mobile: ++352 621 87 – 5464E-Mail: [email protected]
10, rue Antoine JansL-1820 LUXEMBOURG
34
Disclaimer
• This presentation provides for several tax planning ideas that may be implemented via Luxembourg.• Even though the information given in this presentation reflects the tax treatment as experienced in
implemented structures, the facts and circumstances of certain cases need to be analysed beforehand.
• As regards the tax treatment in foreign jurisdictions, our description should be understood as purely indicative. Should a restructuring be envisaged, the foreign tax treatment would have to be analysed by foreign tax advisors.
• The Luxembourg tax treatment of a structure has to be confirmed by the Luxembourg tax authorities – a common practice in Luxembourg with respect to important restructurings.