8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

1/66

Webtgd _t`tgs Omwzt ma @yyg`hs amz tfg Agdgz`h Obzowbt

:996.0467( .0463( .0427

HWOGET TGOFEMHMCBG_( BEO%(

Yh`betbaa-Omwetgzoh`bn Dgaged`et.Ozmss @yyghh`et(

`ed

HWOGET TGOFEMHMCBG_ CW@ZDB@E B HHO(

Omwetgzoh`bn Dgaged`et(

`ed

NWHTBNGDB@ Y@TGET TZW_T(

Yh`betbaa-Omwetgzoh`bn Dgaged`et(

q%

C@TGS@R( BEO%( C@TGS@R OMWETZR _TMZG_ HHO(C@TGS@R OMNY@EBG_( BEO%( OMS@JWEC@ GETGZYZB_G_( BEO%(

`ed C@TGS@R N@EWA@OTWZBEC HHO(

Dgaged`ets-Omwetgzoh`bn`ets(

`ed

DGHH BEO%(

Dgaged`et-Omwetgzoh`bn`et(

`ed

NBOZM_MAT OMZYMZ@TBME(

Dgaged`et-Omwetgzoh`bn`et.@yyghh`et%

8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

2/66

:

Lmfe N% Dgsn`z`bs( Kbzkh`ed ! Ghhbs( HHY( ma Eg Rmzk( Eg Rmzk( `zcwgd amzyh`betbaa-omwetgzoh`bn dgaged`et.ozmss `yyghh`et Hwoget Tgofemhmcbgs( Beo% Sbtf fbn me tfgjzbga gzg Y`wh @% Jmedmz `ed Nbof`gh Y% _t`debok%

Omest`etbeg H% Tzgh`( Lz%( _bdhgr @wstbe HHY( ma Ofbo`cm( Bhhbembs( `zcwgd amz

dgaged`et-omwetgzoh`bn`et.`yyghh`et Nbozmsmat Omzymz`tbme% Sbtf fbn me tfg jzbga gzgZmjgzt E% Fmofn`e `ed T`or A% Ahbet( `ed O`ztgz C% Yfbhhbys( ma S`sfbectme( DO% Ma omwesghme tfg jzbga gzg Lmfe G% C`ztn`e `ed Lmfe S% Tfmzejwzcf( Absf ! Zbof`zdsme( Y%O%( ma _`eDbgcm( O`hbamzeb`% Ma omwesgh gzg Lw`ebt` Zmsg Jzmmks `ed Lmsgyf Y% Zgbd( Absf !Zbof`zdsme( Y%O% ma _`e Dbgcm( O`hbamzeb`; `ed Tfmn`s @edzg Owhjgzt `ed _tgyfge Y%NoCz`tf( Nbozmsmat Omzymz`tbme( ma Zgdnmed( S`sfbectme%

Gd`zd Z% Zgbegs( Sgbh( Cmtsf`h ! N`ecgs HHY( ma Zgdmmd _fmzgs( O`hbamzeb`( amz`nbob owzb`g @yyhg Beo%( gt `h% Sbtf fbn me tfg jzbga `s _me`h E% Ngft`%

L`ngs S% D`jegr( Azbgd( Az`ek( F`zzbs( _fzbqgz ! L`omjsme HHY( ma Eg Rmzk( Eg

Rmzk( amz `nbob owzb`g J`ek ma @ngzbo` Omzymz`tbme( gt `h%

Dme`hd Z% Dweegz( Abeegc`e( Fgedgzsme( A`z`jm( C`zzgtt ! Dweegz( H%H%Y%( maS`sfbectme( DO( amz `nbob owzb`g ?N Omny`er( gt `h% Sbtf fbn me tfg jzbga gzg Dme M%Jwzhgr `ed Gzbk Z% Ywkers( ma Y`hm @htm( O`hbamzeb`% Ma omwesgh me tfg jzbga gzg F`eslmzc_`wgz( Jbmtgofemhmcr Bedwstzr Mzc`eb|`tbme( ma S`sfbectme( DO; Nbof`gh L% Jbjgz( DmhjrH`jmz`tmzbgs( Beo%( ma _`e Az`eobsom( O`hbamzeb`; Y% Nbof`gh S`hkgz `ed J`zzr Gstzbe( G%B%DwYmet dg Egnmwzs `ed Om%( ma Sbhnbectme( Dgh``zg; Zbof`zd A% Yfbhhbys( Gvvme NmjbhOfgnbo`h Omny`er( ma Fmwstme( Tgv`s; Jwokn`stgz dg Smha( Cgegz`h Ghgotzbo Omny`er( maA`bzabghd( Omeegotbowt; Yfbhby _% Lmfesme( Lmfesme ! Lmfesme( ma Eg Jzwesbok( EgLgzsgr; _tgqge S% Nbhhgz( Tfg Yzmotgz ! C`njhg Omny`er( ma Obeobee`tb( Mfbm; @hgv`edgz F%Zmcgzs( Pw`homnn Beo%( ma _`e Dbgcm( O`hbamzeb`; `ed T`z`egf N`cf`n( Tgssgz`( Beo%( ma_`e Lmsg( O`hbamzeb`%

@yyg`hgd azmn< Webtgd _t`tgs Dbstzbot Omwzt amz tfg _mwtfgze Dbstzbot ma O`hbamzeb`

Lwdcg N`zbhre H% Fwaa

8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

3/66

Webtgd _t`tgs Omwzt ma @yyg`hs amz tfg Agdgz`h Obzowbt

:996.0467( .0463( .0427

HWOGET TGOFEMHMCBG_( BEO%(

Yh`betbaa-Omwetgzoh`bn Dgaged`et.Ozmss @yyghh`et(

`ed

HWOGET TGOFEMHMCBG_ CW@ZDB@E B HHO

Omwetgzoh`bn Dgaged`et(

`ed

NWHTBNGDB@ Y@TGET TZW_T(

Yh`betbaa-Omwetgzoh`bn Dgaged`et(

q%

C@TGS@R( BEO%( C@TGS@R OMWETZR _TMZG_ HHO(C@TGS@R OMNY@EBG_( BEO%( OMS@JWEC@ GETGZYZB_G_( BEO%(

`ed C@TGS@R N@EWA@OTWZBEC HHO(

Dgaged`ets- Omwetgzoh`bn`ets(`ed

DGHH( BEO%(

Dgaged`et-Omwetgzoh`bn`et(

`ed

NBOZM_MAT OMZYMZ@TBME(

Dgaged`et-Omwetgzoh`bn`et.@yyghh`et%

@yyg`hs azmn tfg Webtgd _t`tgs Dbstzbot Omwzt amz tfg _mwtfgze Dbstzbot ma O`hbamzeb` beo`sg em% 93.OQ.:999( Lwdcg N`zbhre H% Fwaa%

8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

4/66

]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]

DGOBDGD< _gytgnjgz 00( :992]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]

Jgamzg NBOFGH( Ofbga Lwdcg( EGSN@E `ed HMWZBG( Obzowbt Lwdcgs%

NBOFGH( Ofbga Lwdcg%

Nbozmsmat Omzymz`tbme `yyg`hs tfg dgeb`h ma ymst.tzb`h nmtbmes omeogzebec ` lwzr

qgzdbot tf`t W%_% Y`tget Em% 4(31?(?71 &tfg D`r y`tget" `s emt beq`hbd `ed tf`t

Nbozmsmat bedbzgothr beazbecgd tfg D`r y`tget% Nbozmsmat `hsm `yyg`hs tfg

$?73(12?(971%06 lwzr ``zd tm Hwoget Tgofemhmcbgs( Beo% amz Nbozmsmats beazbecgnget ma

tfg D`r y`tget% Jgo`wsg tfg q`hbdbtr `ed beazbecgnget dgobsbmes gzg emt ometz`zr tm

h` `ed swyymztgd jr swjst`etb`h gqbdgeog( g `aabzn% Jgo`wsg tfg d`n`cgs

o`howh`tbme h`okgd swaabobget gqbdgetb`zr swyymzt( g q`o`tg `ed zgn`ed tf`t ymztbme ma

tfg o`sg tm tfg dbstzbot omwzt amz awztfgz yzmoggdbecs%

J@OKCZMWED

Be tfg 0239s( ebofg czmwys ma fmjjrbsts( beohwdbec tm tgge`cgzs be ` Hms @htms

c`z`cg( jwbht ygzsme`h omnywtgzs azmn soz`tof% Be tfg g`zhr tm nbd.0269s( ygzsme`h

omnywtbec c`begd ymywh`zbtr `htfmwcf stbhh be bts bea`eor% Be 026:( ` abatgge.rg`z.mhd fbcf

sofmmh stwdget ozg`tgd tfg abzst ywjhbo omnywtgz qbzws( syzg`dbec bt `nmec ygzsme`h

omnywtgzs qb` ahmyyr dbsks( nmst hbkghr tfg 7.beof qgzsbme( `s tfg ?.beof dbsk `set

betzmdwogd wetbh ` ag rg`zs h`tgz% Omnngzob`hhr `q`bh`jhg mygz`tbec srstgns `t tfg tbng

gzg n`behr tgvt.j`sgd btf ag( ba `er( cz`yfbo`h betgza`ogs% Be 0264( btf bts em

a`nmws 0264 omnngzob`h `bzgd dwzbec _wygz Jmh VQBBB me Jh`ok _wed`r( @yyhg

Omnywtgz `eemweogd tfg betzmdwotbme ma bts @yyhg N`obetmsf( tfg abzst bdghr smhd

:996.0467( .0463( .0427 :

8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

5/66

ygzsme`h omnywtgz gnyhmrbec ` cz`yfbo`h wsgz betgza og% Tfg amhhmbec rg`z( Nbozmsmat

betzmdwogd bts me qgzsbme ma ` cz`yfbo`h mygz`tbec srstgn( Sbedms 0%9%

Be Dgognjgz 0261( tfzgg omnywtgz gecbeggzs `t @T!T abhgd ` y`tget `yyhbo`tbme(

fbof gqgetw`hhr bsswgd `s tfg D`r y`tget% Tfg y`tget bs cgegz`hhr dbzgotgd tm ` ngtfmd

ma getgzbec beamzn`tbme betm abghds me ` omnywtgz sozgge btfmwt wsbec ` kgrjm`zd% @

wsgz abhhs be tfg dbsyh`rgd abghds jr ofmmsbec omeowzzgethr dbsyh`rgd( yzgdgabegd tmmhs

`d`ytgd tm a`obhbt`tg tfg beywttbec ma tfg beamzn`tbme be ` y`ztbowh`z abghd( fgzgbe tfg

yzgdgabegd tmmhs beohwdg `e me.sozgge cz`yfbo`h kgrjm`zd( ` ngew( `ed ` o`howh`tmz%

Tfg srstgn n`r dbsyh`r ngews ma beamzn`tbme amz abhhbec be ` y`ztbowh`z abghd `ed n`r `hsm

jg `d`ytgd tm omnnwebo`tg btf ` fmst omnywtgz tm mjt`be tfg beamzn`tbme tf`t bs

besgztgd betm tfg abghds% Be `ddbtbme( meg ma tfg dbsyh`rgd abghds o`e jg ` jbt.n`yygd

cz`yfbos abghd( fbof tfg wsgz abhhs be jr zbtbec me tfg tmwof sozgge wsbec ` strhws%

Be :99:( Hwoget0 bebtb`tgd tfg yzgsget `otbme `c`best C`tg`r( `ed Nbozmsmat

swjsgpwgethr betgzqgegd% Tfg `yyg`h omngs azmn tfg omesmhbd`tgd `otbme ma tfzgg

sgy`z`tg beazbecgnget swbts abhgd be tfg G`stgze Dbstzbot ma Qbzcbeb`( tfg Dbstzbot ma

Dgh``zg( `ed tfg _mwtfgze Dbstzbot ma O`hbamzeb`% Tfg omesmhbd`tgd `otbme `s

mzbcbe`hhr jgamzg _gebmz Lwdcg Zwdb Jzgstgz% Be Motmjgz :993( Lwdcg Jzgstgz

sgqgzgd y`zt ma tfg y`tget beazbecgnget o`sg amz tz`esagz tm Lwdcg N`zbhre Fwaa% Tfg

omwzt sgqgzgd `ed tz`esagzzgd amz awztfgz yzmoggdbecs `hh n`ttgzs zgh`tbec tm tfg D`r

y`tget `ed W%_% Y`tget Ems% 4(?6?(:3:; 4(276(::1; 7(?43(:27; `ed 4(4?2(372%

@t tzb`h( Hwoget of`zcgd beazbecgnget jr Nbozmsmat ma oh`bns 02 `ed :0( `nmec

mtfgzs( ma tfg D`r y`tget% Hwoget `hhgcgd bedbzgot beazbecgnget ma oh`bn 02 j`sgd me tfg

0 Tfg D`r y`tget bs em `ssbcegd tm Hwoget%

:996.0467( .0463( .0427 ?

8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

6/66

s`hgs `ed wsg ma Nbozmsmat Nmegr( Nbozmsmat Mwthmmk( `ed Sbedms Nmjbhg% @s tm

oh`bn :0( Hwoget `ssgztgd tf`t tfg wsg ma Sbedms Nmjbhg beazbecgd% Hwoget `hsm

`hhgcgd beazbecgnget jr Dghh `ed `ssgztgd oh`bns ma tfg mtfgz y`tgets `s ghh( jwt tfmsg

bsswgs `zg emt me `yyg`h%: Nbozmsmat of`hhgecgd Hwogets beazbecgnget ometgetbmes(

ometgedbec `nmec mtfgz dgagesgs tf`t tfg D`r y`tget `s beq`hbd amz jgbec `etboby`tgd

mz mjqbmws `ed( gqge ba q`hbd( Nbozmsmats s`hgs ma bts yzmdwots dbd emt beazbecg tfg D`r

y`tget%

Tfg lwzr amwed Nbozmsmat hb`jhg me oh`bn 02 `s tm `hh tfzgg yzmdwots `ed me

oh`bn :0 `s tm Sbedms Nmjbhg jwt zgtwzegd ` abedbec ma em beazbecgnget jr Dghh `s tm

tfmsg tm oh`bns% Tfg qgzdbot( btfmwt dbstbecwbsfbec `nmec tfg tfzgg yzmdwots mz

jgtgge bedwognget `ed ometzbjwtmzr beazbecgnget( ``zdgd ` sbechg hwny.swn `c`best

Nbozmsmat amz `hh yzmdwots beqmhqgd% Tfg lwzr ``zdgd $?73(12?(971%06 amz Nbozmsmats

beazbecgnget ma tfg D`r y`tget( gvohwdbec yzglwdcnget betgzgst%?

Tfg y`ztbgs abhgd ewngzmws ymst.tzb`h nmtbmes( beohwdbec Nbozmsmats zgeggd

nmtbmes sggkbec lwdcnget `s ` n`ttgz ma h` tf`t tfg D`r y`tget `s `etboby`tgd `ed

mjqbmws `ed nmtbmes of`hhgecbec tfg lwzrs abedbec ma beazbecgnget `ed tfg lwzrs ``zd

ma d`n`cgs% Be y`ztbowh`z( Nbozmsmat smwcft lwdcnget `s ` n`ttgz ma h` tf`t oh`bns 02

`ed :0 gzg `etboby`tgd wedgz ?7 W%_%O% 09:&j" `ed &c" mz gzg mjqbmws wedgz 09?%

Tfg dbstzbot omwzt amwed swjst`etb`h gqbdgeog be tfg zgomzd tm swyymzt tfg lwzrs

dgtgznbe`tbme tf`t tfg dgaged`ets f`d emt yzmqge tfg D`r y`tget tm jg beq`hbd% Tfg

dbstzbot omwzt `hsm fghd tf`t egbtfgz lwdcnget `s ` n`ttgz ma h` emz ` eg tzb`h `s

: @ddbtbme`hhr( me Dgognjgz 07( :996( Nbozmsmat `ed Hwoget abhgd `stbywh`tbme dbsnbssbec `hh oh`bns jgtgge tfgn gvogyt tfmsg zgh`tbec tm tfg D`r y`tget%

? Amz W%_% Y`tget Em% 7(?43(:27( tfg lwzr ``zdgd $09(?79(999%99 amzNbozmsmats beazbecgnget `ed $70(999%99 amz Dghhs beazbecgnget%

:996.0467( .0463( .0427 4

8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

7/66

`yyzmyzb`tg me tfg lwzrs abedbec tf`t Hwoget f`d yzmqge d`n`cgs be tfg `nmwet ma

`yyzmvbn`tghr $?76 nbhhbme% Tfg dbstzbot omwzt cz`etgd mehr tfg ymst.tzb`h nmtbme sgttbec

`sbdg tfg mjqbmwsegss qgzdbot omeogzebec W%_% Y`tget Em% 4(276(::1 jwt dgebgd `hh

mtfgz ymst.tzb`h nmtbmes( beohwdbec tfmsg amz tfg D`r y`tget% _gg Hwoget Tgofs%( Beo% q%

C`tg`r( Beo%( 769 A% _wyy% :d 0901 &_%D% O`h% :996"% Nbozmsmat f`s tbnghr `yyg`hgd

tfg dbstzbot omwzts dgobsbme% Sg f`qg lwzbsdbotbme ywzsw`et tm :6 W%_%O% 0:27&`"&0"%

@E@HR_B_

B% _t`ed`zds ma Zgqbg

Sfge zgqbgbec tfg dgeb`h ma ` nmtbme amz lwdcnget `s ` n`ttgz ma h` &LNMH"

`atgz ` lwzr qgzdbot( g `yyh[r^ tfg s`ng st`ed`zd ma zgqbg `s tf`t `yyhbgd jr tfg tzb`h

omwzt% Sgofshgz q% N`okg Beth Tz`dg( Beo%( 461 A%?d 0:61( 0:29 &Agd% Obz% :993"

&pwmtbec eOwjg Omzy% q% _g`Of`ecg Beth( Beo%( 4?1 A%?d 0?03( 0?02 &Agd% Obz% :991""%

Awztfgznmzg( [t^fg cz`et mz dgeb`h ma ` nmtbme amz lwdcnget `s ` n`ttgz ma h` bs `

yzmogdwz`h bsswg emt webpwg tm y`tget h`( zgqbggd wedgz tfg h` ma tfg zgcbme`h obzowbt

be fbof tfg `yyg`h azmn tfg dbstzbot omwzt mwhd wsw`hhr hbg% _wnnbt Tgof%( Beo% q%

Ebdgk Om%( ?1? A%?d 0:02( 0::? &Agd% Obz% :994"% Be tfg Ebetf Obzowbt( ` dbstzbot omwzt

cz`ets LNMH mehr ba tfg gqbdgeog( omestzwgd be tfg hbcft nmst a`qmz`jhg tm tfg

emenmqbec y`ztr( ygznbts mehr meg zg`sme`jhg omeohwsbme( `ed tf`t omeohwsbme bs

ometz`zr tm tfg lwzrs qgzdbot% Y`q`m q% Y`c`r( ?93 A%?d 207( 206 &2tf Obz% :99:"%

_bnbh`zhr( ` dbstzbot omwzt be tfg Ebetf Obzowbt n`r cz`et ` eg tzb`h mehr ba tfg qgzdbot bs

`c`best tfg ohg`z gbcft ma tfg gqbdgeog% Bd%

Beazbecgnget bs ` pwgstbme ma a`ot( zgqbggd amz swjst`etb`h gqbdgeog fge tzbgd

tm ` lwzr% Abebs`z Omzy% q% DbzgoTQ Czmwy( Beo%( 7:? A%?d 0?:?( 0??: &Agd% Obz%"(

:996.0467( .0463( .0427 7

8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

8/66

ogzt% dgebgd( 0:2 _% Ot% 374 &:996"% Mjqbmwsegss bs ` hgc`h pwgstbme zgqbggd dg emqm%

Yf`zn`_tgn Tfgz`ygwtbos( Beo% q% Qb`Oghh( Beo%( 420 A%?d 0?4:( 0?72 &Agd% Obz% :993"(

ogzt% dgebgd( 0:6 _% Ot% 0177 &:996"% Tfg st`twtmzr st`ed`zd zgpwbzgs ws tm dgobdg

fgtfgz tfg swjlgot n`ttgz ma tfg oh`bngd beqgetbme mwhd f`qg jgge mjqbmws `t tfg

tbng tfg beqgetbme `s n`dg tm ` ygzsme ma mzdbe`zr skbhh be tfg `zt tm fbof [tfg swjlgot

n`ttgz ma tfg beqgetbme^ ygzt`bes% ?7 W%_%O% 09?&`" &:991"; sgg `hsm K_Z Beth Om% q%

Tghgahgv Beo%( 779 W%_% ?26( 407.01 &:993"% Wedgzybeebec tf`t hgc`h bsswg `zg a`otw`h

pwgstbmes zgh`tbec tm tfg somyg `ed ometget ma tfg yzbmz `zt( tfg dbaagzgeogs jgtgge tfg

yzbmz `zt `ed tfg oh`bngd beqgetbme( tfg hgqgh ma mzdbe`zr skbhh be tfg `zt( `ed `er zghgq`et

sgomed`zr omesbdgz`tbmes( swof `s omnngzob`h swoogss( hmec.aght eggd( `ed tfg a`bhwzg

ma mtfgzs% Yf`zn`_tgn( 420 A%?d `t 0?72%

Sg zgqbg amz `e `jwsg ma dbsozgtbme ` dbstzbot omwzts dgobsbme omeogzebec tfg

ngtfmdmhmcr amz o`howh`tbec d`n`cgs% Websyh`r( _%@% q% @n% Ghgo% _bce Om%( 12 A%?d

70:( 703 e%6 &Agd% Obz% 0227"; sgg `hsm _t`tg Bedws%( Beo% q% Nmz.Ahm Bedws%( Beo%(

66? A%:d 073?( 0731.33 &Agd% Obz% 0262" &emtbec tf`t tfg yzgobsg ngtfmdmhmcr wsgd be

`ssgssbec `ed omnywtbec d`n`cgs bs omnnbttgd tm tfg smwed dbsozgtbme ma tfg dbstzbot

omwzt"% Sg zgqbg tfg lwzrs dgtgznbe`tbme ma tfg `nmwet ma d`n`cgs( `e bsswg ma a`ot(

amz swjst`etb`h gqbdgeog% _nbtfKhbeg Db`cemstbos( Beo% q% Fghge` H`js% Omzy%( 2:1 A%:d

0010( 0014 e%: &Agd% Obz% 0220"% @ lwzrs dgobsbme btf zgsygot tm `e ``zd ma d`n`cgs

nwst jg wyfghd wehgss tfg `nmwet bs czmsshr gvogssbqg mz nmestzmws( ohg`zhr emt

swyymztgd jr tfg gqbdgeog( mz j`sgd mehr me sygowh`tbme mz cwgssmzk% _t`tg

Ometz`otbec ! Gecc Omzy% q% Omedmttg @n%( Beo%( ?41 A%?d 0973( 093: &Agd% Obz% :99?"

:996.0467( .0463( .0427 1

8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

9/66

&pwmtbec Jzmmktzgg Omzy% q% @dq`eogd Nbozm Dgqbogs( Beo%( 233 A%:d 0777( 0769

&Agd% Obz% 022:""%

BB% Beq`hbdbtr

Jgamzg tfg lwzr( Nbozmsmat gec`cgd be ` nwhtb.yzmecgd `tt`ok ma tfg D`r y`tgets

q`hbdbtr% Nbozmsmat `zcwgd( amz gv`nyhg( tf`t tfg D`r y`tget `s `etboby`tgd wedgz

09:&j" `ed &c" `ed mjqbmws wedgz 09?% Me `yyg`h( Nbozmsmat of`hhgecgs mehr tfg

dbstzbot omwzts dgeb`h ma tfg LNMH nmtbme me mjqbmwsegss% Nbozmsmat dmgs emt of`hhgecg

`er ma tfg dbstzbot omwzts oh`bn omestzwotbmes% Be `e`hr|bec tfg mjqbmwsegss dgagesg( g

tfgzgamzg nwst `yyhr tfg oh`bn omestzwotbme `s bt `s yzgsgetgd tm tfg lwzr% Awztfgz(

Nbozmsmat zghbgs me mehr ` sbechg yzbmz `zt dmownget amz bts mjqbmwsegss ymsbtbme btf

zgsygot tm oh`bn 02%

Bedgygedget oh`bn 02 bs dbzgotgd tm ` ngtfmd ma beywttbec d`t` wsbec ogzt`be

yzgdgabegd tmmhs `ed getgzbec tf`t beamzn`tbme betm y`ztbowh`zabghds dbsyh`rgd be `

omnywtgz amzn% Oh`bn :0 dgygeds azmn oh`bn 02 `ed awztfgz sygobabgs tf`t tfg

beamzn`tbme abghd bs dbsyh`rgd `s ` jbt.n`yygd.cz`yfbos abghd% Oh`bns 02 `ed :0 zg`d be

awhh `s amhhms%

02% @ ngtfmd amz wsg be ` omnywtgz f`qbec ` dbsyh`r omnyzbsbec tfg stgysma

dbsyh`rbec me s`bd dbsyh`r ` yhwz`hbtr ma beamzn`tbme abghds(

bdgetbarbec amz g`of abghd ` kbed ma beamzn`tbme tm jg besgztgd tfgzgbe(

bedbo`tbec ` y`ztbowh`z meg ma s`bd beamzn`tbme abghds betm fbof beamzn`tbme

bs tm jg besgztgd `ed amz omeowzzgethr dbsyh`rbec ` yzgdgabegd tmmh`ssmob`tgd btf s`bd meg ma s`bd abghds( s`bd yzgdgabegd tmmh jgbec mygz`jhgtm swyyhr beamzn`tbme ma tfg kbed bdgetbabgd amz s`bd meg abghd( s`bd tmmhjgbec sghgotgd azmn ` czmwy ma yzgdgabegd tmmhs beohwdbec ` tmmh `d`ytgd tmswyyhr `e bedbqbdw`h getzr azmn ` ngew ma `htgze`tbqgs `ed `t hg`st ` tmmh`d`ytgd tm `hhm s`bd wsgz tm omnymsg s`bd beamzn`tbme( `ed

besgztbec be s`bd meg abghd beamzn`tbme tf`t bs dgzbqgd `s ` zgswht ma s`bdwsgz mygz`tbec s`bd dbsyh`rgd tmmh%

:996.0467( .0463( .0427 3

8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

10/66

, , ,

:0% Tfg ngtfmd sgt amztf be oh`bn 02 fgzgbe tfg stgy ma dbsyh`rbec s`bdy`ttgze beohwdgs tfg stgy ma dbsyh`rbec meg mz nmzg ma s`bd beamzn`tbmeabghds `s ` jbt.n`yygd.cz`yfbos abghd%

Tfg ?71 y`tget( omh%03 h%:3 tm omh%06 h%::% Abcwzg 7 ma tfg D`r y`tget( sfme jghm(

bhhwstz`tgs `e gnjmdbnget ma tfg beqgetbme be fbof ` cz`yfbo`h o`howh`tmz mqgzh`rs tfg

amzn f`qbec nwhtbyhg abghds( meg ma fbofPw`etbtr &Ptr 10"bs fbcfhbcftgd%

@% Oh`bn 02

Nbozmsmats ymsbtbme `s tf`t oh`bn 02 mwhd f`qg jgge mjqbmws mqgz ` 0264

n`c`|beg `ztbohg( Nbof`gh Trhgz( Tmwof _ozgges< Jbc Dg`h mz Em Dg`h=( D`t`n`tbme(

L`e% 0264( `t 041 &tfg D`t`n`tbme `ztbohg mz D`t`n`tbme"% Tfg `ztbohg dgsozbjgs jmtf

tfg ymtgetb`h jgegabts `ed dz`j`oks ma wsbec omnywtgz tmwof sozgges `t ` tbng fge

omnywtgz tgofemhmcr `s dgqghmybec% @s D`t`n`tbme zgymzts( `e`hrsts ag`zgd tf`t

[t^fg omnjbe`tbme ma tfgsg dz`j`oks `ed mwtsbdg beahwgeogs n`r dmmn tfg tmwof.

sgesbtbqg tgznbe`h `ed tf`t [g^qge tmwof tgofemhmcrs czg`tgst yzmymegets `dnbt tf`t

:996.0467( .0463( .0427 6

8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

11/66

tfg awtwzg bs emt `s jzbcft `s bt meog sggngd% Bd% `t 074% Tfg D`t`n`tbme `ztbohgs

whtbn`tg ngss`cg `s tf`t [t^mwof.sgesbtbqg tgznbe`hs n`r jg qgzr sgvr be tfg maabog(

jwt fgtfgz tfgr `otw`hhr stbnwh`tg ygmyhg tm wsg omnywtgzs bs myge tm dmwjt% Bd% `t

041%

Nwof ma tfg tzb`h tgstbnmer( `s zgh`tbec tm tfg AVAG srstgn 4 be tfg D`t`n`tbme

`ztbohg( dgsozbjgd emt f`t `s be tfg `ztbohg jwt f`t `s `hhgcgdhr yzbmz `zt amz

ywzymsgs ma yzbmz ywjhbo wsg mz yzbmz beqgetbme% Tfg D`t`n`tbme `ztbohgs getbzg

dbsohmswzg zghbgd wyme jr Nbozmsmat me `yyg`h bs nwof nmzg hbnbtgd( e`nghr meg

yfmtmcz`yf

7

`ed tfg amhhmbec tm sfmzt y`z`cz`yfs%

Tfg j`ek bs be tfg yzmogss ma bnyhgngetbec ` tm.yf`sg stz`tgcrtf`t bt agghs bhh `oomnyhbsf tfg jzg`kmwt [tgofemhmcr^% Tfg yh`e gnyhmrsG`sgh mzkst`tbmes yzmcz`nngd be tfg j`eks Hmedme maabog% G`ofmzkst`tbmes sozgge bs dbqbdgd zmwcfhr be f`ha qgztbo`hhr% H`zcg tmwof.sgesbtbqg jmvgs `t tfg tmy ma tfg sozgge beqbtg tfg wsgz tm dgoh`zg tfgowzzget tz`es`otbme ` jwr mz ` sghh; `t tfg jmttmn( sbnbh`z jmvgs hgt tfgwsgzs dg`h( sgzqbog( o`eogh( hmc mwt( mz hmok mwt tfgbz sozgges% Tfg zbcftf`ha ma tfg sozgge hbsts kgr beamzn`tbme `jmwt tfg owzzget tz`es`otbme(beohwdbec jwrgz j`ek( sghhgz j`ek( owzzgeor( gvof`ecg z`tg &be dmhh`zs `edtfg amzgbce owzzgeor"( jzmkgz( j`ek owstmngz( gvof`ecg hmo`tbme( `edngtfmd ma y`rnget%

Sfge tfg tz`dgz tmwofgs tfg sozgge be meg ma tfgsg `zg`s( ` hbst maymtgetb`hhr q`hbd getzbgs mz ` ewngzbo kgry`d `yyg`zs me tfg hgat f`ha(beqbtbec tfg wsgz tm ofmmsg tfg beamzn`tbme eggdgd me tfg zbcft% Amzbest`eog( fge tfg wsgz fbts tfg jzmkgz oghh me tfg zbcft( ` hbst ma jzmkgzs`yyg`zs me tfg hgat; tfg tz`dgz tfge fbts tfg e`ng ma tfg jzmkgz tm jgbeqmhqgd be tfg owzzget tz`dg( `ed tfg beamzn`tbme bs getgzgd betm tfgsrstgn% Amz gvof`ecg z`tgs `ed mtfgz ewngzbo`h d`t`( tfg wsgz fbts tfgyzmygz oghh me tfg zbcft `ed tfge trygs be tfg ewngzbo d`t` me tfg kgry`dtf`t `yyg`zs me tfg hgat% Be tfbs `r( `e getbzg tz es`otbme o`e jg

omnyhgtgd dbzgothr me tfg mzkst`tbme% &@ PSGZTR h`rmwt o`e jg o`hhgd

4 Be tfg D`t`n`tbme `ztbohg( tfg zghgq`et omnywtgz srstgn bs zgagzzgd tm `sG`sgh% Tfzmwcfmwt tzb`h `ed be tfg jzbgas( tfg srstgn `s o`hhgd AVAG( `htfmwcf tf`te`ng bs j`sgd me beamzn`tbme mwtsbdg tfg `ztbohgs ometget% Amz g`sg ma zgagzgeog mehr(g wsg tfg AVAG tgznbemhmcr%

7 Tfg dbstzbot omwzt mjsgzqgd tf`t tfg yfmtmcz`yf be tfg D`t`n`tbme `ztbohg`s ma hbnbtgd oh`zbtr `ed hbnbtgd be dgt`bh% 769 A% _wyy% :d `t 09?:%

:996.0467( .0463( .0427 2

8/3/2019 Lucent vs Gateway and the Entire Market Value Rule 08-1485

12/66

wy me tfg hgat amz getzr ma emest`ed`zd mz z`zg e`ngs`e beazgpwgethrtz`dgd owzzgeor( amz gv`nyhg%"

D`t`n`tbme( swyz`( `t 046%

Dwzbec tzb`h( tfg myymsbec gvygzts amz Nbozmsmat `ed Hwoget gvyzgssgd omeahbotbec

qbgs `jmwt tfg D`t`n`tbme `ztbohgs dbsohmswzg% _ygobabo`hhr( tfg y`ztbgs `ed tfgbz

gvygzts dbs`czggd `jmwt fgtfgz tfg D`t`n`tbme `ztbohg dgsozbjgd tfzgg ma tfg

hbnbt`tbmes ma oh`bn 02 `ed fgtfgz ` amwztf hbnbt`tbme mwhd f`qg jgge mjqbmws azmn tfg

`ztbohg% Sg `ddzgss g`of hbnbt tbme be twze%

Abzst( tfg gvygzts gvyzgssgd dbaagzbec mybebmes `jmwt fgtfgz tfg D`t`n`tbme

`ztbohg dbsohmsgd tfg hbnbt`tbme ma besgztbec be s`bd meg abghd beamzn`tbme tf`t bs dgzbqgd `s

` zgswht ma s`bd wsgz mygz`tbec s`bd dbsyh`rgd tmmh% Tfg dbstzbot omwzt omestzwgd tfbs

tgzn tm ng`e besgztbec be ` y`ztbowh`z abghd beamzn`tbme tf`t bs dgzbqgd `s ` zgswht ma tfg

wsgz mygz`tbec tfg dbsyh`rgd tmmh% Hwoget `zcwgs tf`t `hh tfg D`t`n`tbme `ztbohg st`tgs

bs tf`t tfg beamzn`tbme bs getgzgd betm tfg srstgn% Nbozmsmat omwetgzs tf`t [t^fg `ztbohg

dgsozbjgs fm `e AVAG wsgz getgzgd &mz besgztgd" beamzn`tbme betm f`t bt o`hhs oghhs(

`emtfgz e`ng amz beamzn`tbme abghds% Jwt Nbozmsmats gvygzt `s hgss tf`e dbzgot fge

`skgd fgtfgz tfg D`t`n`tbme dbsohmsgd `e beamzn`tbme abghd( `s zgpwbzgd jr oh`bn 02