Lower Freezing DEF For Higher NOx Reduction … Formate/Urea Based DEF TerraCairPlus (TCP) “Lower...
Transcript of Lower Freezing DEF For Higher NOx Reduction … Formate/Urea Based DEF TerraCairPlus (TCP) “Lower...
Ammonium Formate/Urea Based DEF TerraCairPlus (TCP)
“Lower Freezing DEF For Higher NOx
Reduction Attainment”
Presented To DEER Conference Detroit, Michigan
October 3-6, 2011
1
TerraCairPlus Chemistry TerraCairPlus and DEF fluid compositions Advantages of the New Compositions
Vehicle Testing DEF Vehicle performance results DEF Injector Tip Temperature TerraCairPlus Vehicle Test – 500 Hours
• DEF Injector PRE-Test Spray Characteristics • Injector Evaluation
Bench Testing Photographs of Injector Hole Orifices Summary of Injector Hole Orifices
Corrosion Testing
Presentation Agenda 2
Traditional DEF is a binary mixture of Urea in Demineralized water at a concentration of 32.5%
TerraCairPlus is a tertiary mixture of Ammonium Formate, Urea and Water 26% Ammonium Formate 20% Urea 54% Water
While there is no comparable ISO standard for TCP,
all the trace element parameters are identical to DEF
3
TerraCairP lus Chemistry
TerraCairP lus vs. DEF Specifications DEF Spec Spec Spec Typical
ISO 22241-1 units Min Max TerraCairPlus
Refractive Index 20C 1.3814 1.3843 Urea % 31.8 33.2
Density kg/m3 1087 1093 Biuret % -- 0.3
Alkalinity % -- 0.2 <0.45 Insoluble matter mg/Kg -- 20 <10
Aldehydes mg/Kg -- 5 ND PO4 mg/Kg -- 0.5 ND Ca mg/Kg -- 0.5 ND Fe mg/Kg -- 0.5 ND Cu mg/Kg -- 0.2 ND Zn mg/Kg -- 0.2 ND Cr mg/Kg -- 0.2 ND Ni mg/Kg -- 0.2 ND Al mg/Kg -- 0.5 ND Mg mg/Kg -- 0.5 ND Na mg/Kg -- 0.5 ND K mg/Kg -- 0.5 ND
pH 8 - 9
TerraCairPlus is fully Neutralized with a pH of 8-9.
-31,1
-11
-26,7
-35
-30
-25
-20
-15
-10
32.5 0
28.5 8.4 26.5 12.6
24.5 16.8
23.5 18.9
22.5 21.0
21.5 23.1
20.5 25.2
19.5 27.3
18.5 29.4
17.5 31.5
Tem
pera
ture
[C]
Concentration [w-%]
Freezing point of TerraCair Plus as a function of Urea and Ammonium Formate concentration
lower limit
upper limit
Urea w-% Ammonium Formate w-%
Freezing Point of TerraCairPlus with Different Urea to Ammonium Formate Ratios
MAXIMUM Urea = 20.1 wt% Ammonium Formate = 26.2 wt%
Fully substitutable! TerraCairPlus can be interchange with DEF systems and deliver the same ammonia requirements for NOx conversion
TerraCairP lus Freezing Point (-25 to -35 C)
Better stability in high temperature when vehicles or tanks are exposed to sunshine or extreme high temperatures.
Expansion of volume during freezing is smaller than with water or urea resulting in less damage.
Interchangeable with DEF systems (no system draining needed). Reduced heating systems needed in logistics chain or vehicle. Ammonium formate does not polymerize like urea. Broader temperature stability adds significant operating advantages
across the supply chain up to and including the vehicle. NOx reduction capacity of TerraCairPlus remains comparable to DEF
at higher exhaust temperatures and potentially better NOx reduction at lower exhaust temperatures because of lower decomposition temperatures of TerraCairPlus.
6
TerraCairP lus Advantages vs. DEF
TerraCairPlus Advantages Objectives TerraCairPlus and DEF fluid compositions
Vehicle Testing Control : DEF Vehicle performance results DEF Injector Tip Temperature TerraCairPlus Vehicle Test – 500 Hours
• DEF Injector PRE-Test Spray Characteristics • Injector Evaluation
Bench Testing Photographs of Injector Hole Orifices Summary of Injector Hole Orifices
Corrosion Testing
Presentation Agenda 7
Vehicle Testing Objectives 8
Demonstrate TerraCairPlus in on-road vehicle trial.
Demonstrate the NOx conversion of TerraCairPlus.
Demonstrate TerraCairPlus is fully substitutable for DEF.
Report observations of Injector Performance..
Report observations of Materials Compatibility.
1. Vehicle testing with a new Ford F250, 6.7L diesel truck, instrumented with ServoTech NOx monitoring and data logging system to measure SCR system while using TerraCairPlus.
2. Dosing Injector spray angles and patterns where characterized by Michigan Technological University (MTU).
3. DEF reservoir tank was completely drained and filled with TerraCairPlus.
4. 500 hours of 25/75 (city/highway) road testing using TerraCairPlus. 5. NOx efficiency measured during the road test (Detroit, Michigan). 6. DEF injectors were examined by microscopy and analysis of spray
angles before and after road testing.
TerraCairP lus Vehicle Test - Ford F-250, 6.7L Diesel Truck
9
Test Conditions
TerraCairP lus Vehicle Test - Ford F-250, 6.7L Diesel Truck
10
DOC SCR DPF
NOx RTD RTD
ServoTech Engineering Exhaust Monitoring System
T-Bef DOC T-Aft DPF
Nox_Bef DOC
Nox_Aft DPF
Abrev. Definition
T-Before DOC
Temperature Measurement Before DOC
T-Aft DPF Temperature Measurement After DPF
NOx_Eff NOX Efficiency
Injector TT Dosing Injector Tip Temperature
Abrev. Definition
IHT-SNK-T Injector Heat Sink Temperature
Urea – T DEF Fluid Inside Tank Temperature
Nox_Bef_DOC NOx Measurement Before DOC
Nox_Aft_DPF NOx Measurement After DPF
Exhaust P latform Instrumentation 11
DEF Injector Tip Temperature
Temperature probe placed on the tip of the DEF injector to record TCP Fluid temp in injector throughout drive cycles.
12
Objective: Document Actual Performance of the SCR system on Test Vehicle using DEF during Cold Weather (not a Soak Temp Experiment). Parameters Recorded 1. Length of time before DEF fluid is injected into the exhaust as
displayed by NOx removal efficiency.
2. Length of time heating element with DEF fluid remained on.
3. NOx efficiency during Cold Temperature Trial running DEF.
4. Temperature of exhaust gas before DOC and after DPF.
Control Vehicle Trial – On Road Cold Weather Performance Running DEF
13
DEF Vehicle Test – Cold Weather (-15 to -5°C Ambient)
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
-20.0
-10.0
0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
50.0
60.0
840 890 940 990 1040
T-Be
f DO
C, T
-Aft
DPF
, NO
x-1,
NO
x-2,
NO
x-EF
F
Inje
ctor
TT,
IHT-
SNK-
T, U
REA
-T, U
REA
_HRT
_sw
itch
, C
Time In [Minutes]
Injector TT
IHT-SNK-T
UREA-T
UREA_HTR_switch
T-Bef DOC
T-Aft DPF
NOx-1
NOx-2
NOx-EFF
NOx EFF
NOx Conversion begins 52 minutes after startup.
Engine on here
Injector TT
IHT-SNK-T
14
DEF Vehicle Test – Cold Weather (-15 to -5°C Ambient)
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
-20.0
-10.0
0.0
10.0
20.0
30.0
40.0
50.0
60.0
840 860 880 900 920 940 960 980 1000 1020 1040
Tem
pera
ture
in
C T-
Bef D
OC,
T-A
ft P
DF,
NO
x-Ef
f
Tem
pera
ture
in
C
Ure
a-T,
Ure
a_H
TR_S
wit
ch, O
SATe
mp
Time In [Minutes]
UREA-T
UREA_HTR_switch
OSATemp
T-Bef DOC
T-Aft DPF
NOx-EFF NOx-EFF
UREA TANK HEATER POWER ON
UREA-T
UREA TANK HEATER POWER OFF
TG-MS AdBlue Formation of Ammonia Complete at 250 C
TG-MS TCP Formation of Ammonia Complete at 210 C
15
-18.0
-16.0
-14.0
-12.0
-10.0
-8.0
-6.0
-4.0
-2.0
0.0
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
12.0
14.0
16.0
18.0
20.0
840 860 880 900 920 940 960 980
Tem
pera
ture
and
Hea
ter
Off
/On
Time in Minutes
UREA-T
UREA_HTR_switch
Linear (UREA-T)
UREA TANK HEATER POWER ON
UREA TANK HEATER POWER OFF
Urea Tank Inside Temperature -11.9 C
Final Tank Inside Temperature -2.3 C
Total Time For Urea Tank Heater On/Off 106 mins.
Total Temperature Rise 9.6 C
DEF Vehicle Test - DEF Tank Heater Operation
16
1. Total vehicle operating time during cold weather trial; 201 minutes.
2. 53 minutes elapsed before DEF Injection began.
3. DEF tank heater element turned on 3 minutes after vehicle start-up.
Heater element remained on for 106 minutes before shutting off. Temperature rise within the DEF tank was 9.6 C.
4. Average NOx-EFF over 201 minutes of vehicle operation in this Control Trial was less then 20%.
5. DEF Injector Tip Temperature operated between 10 and 40 C. No DPF regeneration occurred.
DEF Vehicle NOx Efficiency – Summary of Observations
17
Objective 1: Document Performance of the SCR system on Test Vehicle using TerraCairPlus Diesel Exhaust Fluid. Parameters Recorded 1. NOx removal efficiency.
2. Any Onboard Diagnostic Warnings.
3. Evidence of Injector fouling.
TerraCairP lus Vehicle On Road (City/ Hwy) Trial
18
Vehicle Testing w ith a NEW Ford 250, 6.7L Diesel Truck Using TerraCairP lus DEF.
Vehicle Summary Data
Vehicle Start/Stop Test Trial 01/20-5/18
Additional Weight Added To Vehicle (Kg) 1043
Service Engine Lights to Report 0
Number of Durability Test Days 74
Number of Durability Test Engine Run Hours 500
Number of Durability Test Engine Idle Hours 86
Number of Engine Oil Changes 3
Total Number of Kilometers Traveled 41,986
City/Highway Kilometers 10,496/31,490
Approximate Liters of Diesel Consumed 5315
Liters of TerraCair Plus Consumed 102
19
TCP - 500 Hours of City/ Hwy Drive Cycle 20
TCP – Data @ The 370 Hours For 100 Minutes of Drive Cycle
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
22200 22210 22220 22230 22240 22250 22260 22270 22280 22290 22300
T-Be
f DO
C, T
-Aft
DPF
, NO
x_Be
f-D
OC,
NO
X_A
ft-D
PF, N
Ox_
EFF
Inje
ctor
TT,
IHT-
SNK-
T, U
rea
T
Time in Minutes
SNAP SHOT OF START UP TO 100 MINUTES @ 370 HOURS, NOx Efficiency AND Temps
Injector TT
IHT-SNK-T
Urea-T
T-Bef DOC
T-Aft DPF
NOx_Bef-DOC
NOx_Aft-DPF
NOx_EFF
T-Bef DOC T-Aft DPF
NOx_Bef-DOC
NOx_EFF
NOx Conversion begins here Approximately 8 minutes after startup
Engine on here
Injector TT
IHT-SNK-T
UREA_T
21
TCP and NOx Efficiency @ 370 Hour Mark for 100 Minutes of Drive Cycle
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
22200 22210 22220 22230 22240 22250 22260 22270 22280 22290 22300
T-Be
f_D
OC,
T-A
ft D
PF T
empe
ratu
re in
°C &
NO
x_EF
F %
Ure
a-T,
Tem
pera
ture
in °C
Time In Minutes
SNAP SHOT OF START UP TO 100 MINUTES @ 370 HOURS, NOx Efficiency AND Temps
Urea-T
NOx_EFF
T-Bef DOC
T-Aft DPF
UREA_T
NOx_EFF
T-Bef DOC
T-Aft DPF
22
TCP - Cumulative Time at Each NOx Efficiency Range Over The 500 Hour Trial
23
Photographs of the Actual Dosing Injector, 0 Hours and 500 Hours Using TCP only
Injector 0 Hours Injector After 500 Hours
Injector after 500 hours of actual vehicle service. No visual corrosion or fouling observed.
24
Summary 1. No service engine lights appeared throughout the trial. 2. Over 71% of the drive cycle time the NOx Removal Efficiency was
spent between the range of 75 to 100%. 3. No corrosion is observed on the injector tip after 500 hours of vehicle
operation using TCP only. 4. TerraCairPlus Fluid was fully substitutable for this trial.
Further Evaluation 1. MTU is scheduled to evaluate the spray characteristics of the dosing
injector used for the 500 hours of operation test trial.
Vehicle Trial Summary: TerraCairP lus 25
TerraCairPlus Advantages Objectives TerraCairPlus and DEF fluid compositions
Vehicle Testing DEF Vehicle performance results DEF Injector Tip Temperature TerraCairPlus Vehicle Test – 500 Hours
• DEF Injector PRE-Test Spray Characteristics • Injector Evaluation
Bench Testing Bench Test Design and Objectives Photographs of Injector Hole Orifices Summary of Injector Hole Orifices
Corrosion Testing
Presentation Agenda 26
Bench Tests of DEF Injectors
Objective: Investigate potential corrosion of DEF Dosing Injector using DEF and TCP fluids at constant injector temperature while cycling off and on.
Empty Tank Full Tank
27
Bench Testing Summary: DEF Versus TerraCairPlus
Temperature of Fluid 20 °C
Temperature of Injector 57 °C
Injector Inlet Pressure 482 kPa
Number of Operating Hours 328
Number of Injection Pulses 11,808,000
Injector Flow Rate of Fluid 11 g/min
DEF Injector Bench Testing: Experimental Conditions Experimental Conditions • Injectors operated 8 hours per day at the 57°C. • Injectors heated to 57°C with external heaters. • Injector pumps shut down and allowed to cool to room temperature next 16
hours. • Fluid remained in the injectors during shutdown period.
28
DEF Injector - After 50 Hours of Operation
• Observed white crystals (identified to be Urea) forming around the injector tip.
• The picture on the right clearly shows how the liquid spray keep the solid from forming.
• Slight urea formation around the injector mounting plate.
29
TerraCairP lus Injector - After 50 Hours of Operation
• No white crystal material formation around the injector tip. • Photograph on the right shows the position of the thermal couple which
controlled the constant temperature. • Slight crystal formation around the injector mounting plate.
30
TerraCairP lus versus DEF – Comparison of Injector Orifices
• Compared the injector orifice hole diameter changes after 328 hours of bench test cycling.
• MTU – Michigan Tech University photographed the injector and measure the injector orifice holes.
TerraCairP lus Injector: 3 Holes After 328 Hours of Service
32
DEF Injector: Hole Diameter 33
TerraCairP lus vs. DEF Injector Hole Size Comparison Chart After 328 Hours of Cycling Operation at 57 C.
New Injector TerraCair Plus Injector DEF Injector
4 Pts. 12 Pts. 4 Pts. 12 Pts. 4 Pts. 12 Pts.
Hole No.1
128.1 Mean 127.6
Stdev 0.5
Average 128.4
Median 128.1
Stdev 1.23
Max
130.8
Min 126.7
Hole No.1
129.9 Mean 130.1
Stdev 0.3
Average 129.8
Median
130
Stdev 0.78
Max
131.1
Min 128.2
Hole No.1
129.9 Mean 130.2
Stdev 0.5
Average 129.5
Median 129.7
Stdev 1.10
Max
130.9
Min 126.7
128.1 130.4 130.9
127.1 130.3 129.9
127.2 129.9 130.2
Hole No.2
126.7 Mean 128.4
Stdev 1.3
Hole No.2
130.3 Mean 130.3
Stdev 0.6
Hole No.2
129.4 Mean 128.4
Stdev 1.2
127.9 131.1 129
129.4 130.3 128.5
129.5 129.6 126.7
Hole No.3
129 Mean 129.2
Stdev 1.4
Hole No.3
129.0 Mean 129.1
Stdev 0.8
Hole No.3
129 Mean 129.8
Stdev 0.6
127.4 128.2 130.3
129.4 129.0 130.3
130.8 130.1 129.5
Some erosion of hole diameter observed in both the DEF and TerraCairPlus holes vs. the New Injector.
We believe the DEF and TerraCairPlus hole diameters are comparable in diameter at the end of the trial.
We plan to Repeat these examinations with on-vehicle injector.
35
TerraCairP lus vs. DEF Injector - Hole Size Comparison Conclusions
TerraCairPlus Advantages Objectives TerraCairPlus and DEF fluid compositions
Vehicle Testing DEF Vehicle performance results DEF Injector Tip Temperature TerraCairPlus Vehicle Test – 500 Hours
• DEF Injector PRE-Test Spray Characteristics • Injector Evaluation
Bench Testing Bench Test Design and Objectives Photographs of Injector Hole Orifices Summary of Injector Hole Orifices
Corrosion Testing
Presentation Agenda 36
Objective: Compare Corrosion rate of various Alloys present in the DEF Injector when exposed to TerraCairPlus and Traditional DEF. Experimental Conditions 1. Measure corrosion on Coupons prepared by ASTM G1 and G31.
2. Coupons tested fully submerged.
3. 2, 3 and 7 Day Incubation at 30°C, 60°C and 80°C.
4. Incubation at Temperatures as high as 120°C boiled and
Decomposed the fluids causing radical corrosion of alloys with both DEF and TerraCairPlus - Not considered a realistic experiment.
Corrosion Testing : TerraCairP lus and DEF 37
Alloy AISI Equivalent
1.4310 AISI 301 1.4301 AISI 304 1.4436 AISI 316
CC13FM AISI 410 1.4016 AISI 430 1.4112 AISI 440
Corrosion Study – Alloys Tested 38
39
7-day Incubation at 60°C
40
7-day Incubation at 80°C
41
2-Day Incubation at 120°C – Fluids Boiled Off
TerraCairPlus and DEF have comparable corrosion rates on the Alloys tested.
DEF maybe more corrosive for 1.4016 (AISI430) steel than TCP but this needs to be repeated.
We plan to Repeat these experiments with actual injector components and for longer periods of exposure at Real World Injector Temps.
42
Corrosion Study Conclusions
TerraCairPlus Chemistry has Advantages over traditional DEF – Much Lower Freezing Point.
TerraCairPlus was fully substitutable for DEF in the Vehicle Trial with No OBD Warnings or Injector performance Issues.
TerraCairPlus demonstrated no DEF Injector fouling in Bench Trials.
TerraCairPlus demonstrated an equivalent corrosion rate to DEF for the alloys tested.
43
TerraCairP lus Presentation Summary
Thank-you
44
Does your Diesel Exhaust Fluid Freeze at -30°C? TerraCairP lus Doesn’t!