Longterm Deflection Comparison With Etabs

download Longterm Deflection Comparison With Etabs

of 6

description

sdad

Transcript of Longterm Deflection Comparison With Etabs

  • Structural Design Calculation

    Published by:

    E.G Navarro

    CE- Mindanao University of Science and Technology

    20-May-14

    LONGTERM DEFLECTION(AS PER ACI318M-11)

    1

  • Structural Design Calculation

    METHOD-1 (Manual)

    Ms = 2161.88 KN-m (sustained service maximum moment LC:DL+0.5LL)

    i = 17.66 mm (immediate deflection LC: DL+LL)

    fc' = 32.0 MPa (concrete compressive strength)

    b = 600.0 mm (breadth of cross section)

    h= 1300.0 mm (thickness of cross section)

    d= 1210.0 mm (effective depth based on tension steel)

    d'= 310.0 mm (effective depth based on compression steel)

    As= 8000.0 mm (area of steel of tension steel)

    As' 6450.0 mm (area of steel of compression steel)

    = 2 (time-dependent factor)

    L = 14000.00 mm (total clear span of the beam)

    Ec = 4700 x fc' = 4700 x 32.00=

    fr = 0.62 x fc' = 0.62 x 32.00=

    Ig = bh3/12 = 600.0 x1,300.00^3 /12=

    n= Es/Ec = 26,587.2 /200,000.00= 7.52

    (Neutral axis determination)

    B1 = 1000/ n As = 1000/7.5 x8,000.00= 0.0166

    r = (n-1) x As' / n As = (7.5 -1) x6,450.00/7.522 x 8,000.00= 0.69907

    kd = ( ( (2 x d x B1 ( 1+(r x d')/d)) + (1+r2) ) - (1+r) ) / B1

    kd =( ((2 x1,210.0x0.0166(1+(0.699x310.000)/1,210.00)+(1+0.6992) ) - (1+0.699) ) / 0.0166)

    kd= 324.6 mm

    (Cracking Moment)

    Mcr = fr. Ig /yt 1 x 10^6 = 3.5 x109,850,000,000.00/650.00x 1 x 10^6 =

    (Cracking Moment of inertia)

    Icr = b.kd3/3 + n.As. (d-kd)2 + (n-1). As' . (kd-d')2

    Icr =((600.0)(324.573)/3) +(7.5)(8,000.0)(1,210.0-324.6^2 + (7.52-1)(6,450.00((324.57)-(310.00^2)

    Icr =

    Ie = (Mcr/Ms)^3 x Ig + ( 1 -(Mcr/Ms)^3 ) x Icr

    Ie = (592.73/2,161.88)^3 x 109,850,000,000.000 + ( 1 -(592.73/2,161.88^3)(54,027,208,977.863))

    Ie =

    f = Ie / Ig = 55,177,683,339.73/109,850,000,000.00

    f = 0.50

    LONG TERM DEFLECTION

    CALCULATION

    PARAMETERS

    26587.2 MPa

    3.5 MPa

    109850000000.0 mm3

    592.73 KN-m

    54027208977.9 mm3

    55177683339.7 mm3

    2

  • Structural Design Calculation

    (Reinforcement ratio for compression reinforcement)

    ' = As' / b x d = 0.0089

    (Multiplier for long-term deflection to account for creep and shrinkage)

    = / ( 1 + 50 ') =

    =

    i = 17.66 mm

    all = L/240 =

    all = = 14,000.00 /240

    all = 58.33 mm

    L = i x x Ig / Ie = (17.66)(1.385)/(0.50)

    L = 48.69 mm < 58.33 mm

    Calculated deflection is within permissible range - SAFE!

    METHOD-2 (ETABS)

    3D MODEL

    (2 / (1+ 50 x 0.0089))

    1.384835

    3

  • Structural Design Calculation

    TO ACCOUNT FOR CRACKING OF SECTION INCLUDING CREEP AND SHRINKAGE

    GROSS INERTIA HAS TO BE REDUCE AS PER RECOMMENDATION BELOW.

    4

  • Structural Design Calculation

    THEREFORE,

    MODIFIER FOR BEAMS

    MODIFIER FOR COLUMNS

    5

  • Structural Design Calculation

    L = 48.77 mm < all = 58.33 mm SAFE!

    RESULTS:

    SERVICE LONGTERM MOMENT (LC: DL +0.5LL)

    6