LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference...

36
b3 b6 b7E 3/15/2012 s Agenda What they are 'what they can do ETflNOFORN LJNCLASSlAED UNCLASSIFIED ssues Conference 2010 \ '! I I t I I " , I SEC N

Transcript of LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference...

Page 1: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

b3b6

b7E

3/15/2012

s

Agenda

What they are

'what they can do

•ETflNOFORN

LJNCLASSlAED

UNCLASSIFIED

.w..I.\.j~--'-I.egal ssuesConference 2010

\'!

IIt

I

I

",I

SEC N

Page 2: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

b3

10

3/15/2012

OFORN

work

s

· Howthe

"

2

Page 3: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

.' s~.'I Washinaton 0 e 20535 I

(S)€lassifieation:uSE

C aDeclassif

ved From: FBI NSISC-2009======================================================

hieb7E

(5j _

THIS E-MAIL MAY CONTA1N PRIVILEGED ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION AND ATTORNEYWORK PRODUCT. DO NOT DISSEMINATE WITHOUT OGC APPROVAL.

L~j

(g)

(S)

======================================================

Sounds ok, but nothing was attached. Can you please send?

From]I.- ......:;z:;:_~_3

b3

7Cb7E

Page 4: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

(S)

December 07

(S) .CJ..assification: .SE~tfNOFOm1I-·· _

======================================================

(Slj -----I

(S)

(S)

Et ~Dt~Sday, December 07, 2011 8:09~

Subject:RE;r------....,

cla.8ifieafi<>n,~11NoFORJ.\I...-----......

Clas . . d By: CllW58B93Declassify On: 07

Deriv om: FBI NSIS -

b1b3

======================================================

We feel your pain. In the land of common sense, our rationale as no pace nd I will take this issue up with ourmanagement and try to get it resolved. If it makes you feel any better, this has happened to others recently - althoughin not as egregious situation as this.

5

I·c;t AM

~~~.===:====.~========================

From:1Se""t-·ToCC,1....-_---,r-- ---f

(S) SUbj ect: R11...-_----------'

(S) Classification:

Page 5: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

(5 )

(5 )

-=----.-...".--...,.--"..,.....",.2"""01-1-4-:0"""S-P--M

b '7r! ~

E

615

==================================================~===

(5) 1/1...- .....1

If we can't do this with this particular factual scenario, then I can't see a clearer one coming along. Common sense

doesn't always win.

(5 )

(5)

======================================================

(5) I

I. IAssIStant GeneraL Counsel

M

7

Page 6: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

From:Sent:To:Subject:

~I

O1iJ 11-05-2012

i 1=====:-1------------I==~ber14 20108-38'_-----,

b7Cb7E

___Iwell, I'm glad people paid attention to my presentation. I always think that people will tune out during the legalportion.

Anyway, you asked what legal authority is required td

km1~"""rT. ". 20535

IFor that, you Willi I

From:Sent:To:Subject:

~II am the former CDC iDnd I am currently assigneJ :pne of our agents just returned from some trainingwhere you gave some guidance r~ Fd our agent's notes weren't completely clear on whatyour guidance had been so I am reaching out to you c:ince I have been advised that lOU are the subject matter expert.Our new CDC is not really up on this matter from th~L- _

...---------------.Basically...the question in a nutshell is what legal authority is currently required tJ I

I have seen some things on thJ Ithat Suggest we alwavs ged Ibut it seems to me thadF======~=======~:::;;:;.L===""4lTl::!!il"'"hle"'='ot;"':h'=le""r;thr""il""ng""'":-rth ....iis....t:=tv..........Dle ....o;..;to..=rd~,e;r........l

usually caved I

1

b5

b7E

Page 7: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

=Fr-o-m-:---....--=,..,...,........,....-..,.....,.,......,="..."...,."..,,,.,...F~~t IFridav March 13 2009 6'46 PM

Subject:

UNCLASSIFIEDNON·RECORD

« FiI~ Ihbn" «Filel ~OC» «FileDdOC·"

I know we've talked about this~beforebut not in a form,?l setting. I wanted to pass thiSIr-------~nto youbecause I hear you understan~ts we go through as case agents and are willing to help us out when we need it. 1don't even know if you can helo directly bllt at lerst you can look at :~i$.and get1feeling of how im ortant this is to allcase agents who work wit~ tyhich is almost all. __ _ases these days as ourrepresentative from your unit and now I hear he has left. I'm hoping at you cou awork with me on IS Issue ecause it isbigger than I can handle on my own.

a routme case.

I'll be in San Diego all next week but my UC is cc'd and I'll have my Blackberry. I think you should maybe come to ournext class May 13-15, and see what we're doing. It's good stuff and we could use someone to talk about legality. They'resupposed to let me know whenl land then we'll have 14 days to make comments. I'd like tomeet with you or at least have spoken with you by the 23rd when I get back, so J can start making our second response-tothe posting.

Thanks,

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIE

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIED

3

Page 8: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

To:

Subject:

Based on my rudimentary understanding o~ pnd the guidance we've been given from

DOJ and in turn disseminated to the field, etc., I agree with your response.

From:

~:ct, ~-=:::::SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

b5

h7E

Please read the following and let me know if you agree with my response to the

**************************

You have asked whethel

The sim Ie answer to our

If ou are also seekin to

Please let me know if you need further information or if [ have failed to adequately answer your question.

1

Page 9: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

h t t OEO (Off f, Offid t h I Th U S Atth tlkI tblNo pro em... e me nowwa can o 0 ep. e . . orney S Ice can a so reac ou 0 Ice 0

Enforcement Operations) at main DOJ if they want other go-by's. I have found OEO to be very helpful and your USA'soffice can reach out to them ifthey want DOJ, instead of FBI, guidance.

I II rFrom:

Sent: Friday, December 12 2008 3:48 PMTo:

~I :

Subject: ISENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED b3NON-RECORD b6

I Ib7E

Thanks for getting back to me so quicklY: I appreciate your help, and I will probably need your gUidance as I discuss thiswith the U.S. Attorney's Office.

I II IFrom:

Sent: Friday, December 12, 2008 2:45 PMTo:

I I ISubject:

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIEDi

NON-

I II have aone throuah some old materials and have attache~ IGood talkina to vou a few minutes aao.

I Pam happy to work With you -on thislanguage It you or tne AuSA needS aC1dltlonal Intormatlon.

« Fil~ IWPd» «Fil~ hVPd» b:,

I also direct your attention to th~ I b7E

I hope you find this information helpful, and please do not hesitate to contact me should you have any additionalquestions.

IThanks.

IAsst. General CounselScience and Technology Law UnitFBIHQ!ROO~

IPRIVILEGED DEL/BERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

3

Page 10: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

uillbe in tomorrow and she may have more information on the issue.

b6

~m: I J:~:~: q'ow.. &rok 15 700' i_·3_7_P_M l:;_3__....I

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

Does.this reconcile with what you have researched/worked on?. .

From:Sent: .To:Subject:

Iqpeii!", IICloG" 15 '!I'il-H_E_, _

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

This information. below, is a si nificant chan e if it is correct as this ruling dictates tha

Could you check on this or point me in the right direction and I will check for us??

I'---A"rs-s'""'is""":t:'""a-nt:""G:=:-e-neral Counsel

Science and Technology Law UnitOffice of the General CounselFederal8ureau of Investigation

2

Page 11: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:

I ~G' 0""6,, 15, 2008 91 AM

I

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

I work with!

Thanks

I,-;:====------.SA I

uesl<Fax:Cell:

II iust wanted to let vou know that the US attornevs office is statina that OEO

b

From: I I~:~t' ray 071< 2008 2'09 jSubject: ~ .

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

From:Sent: I...-~IEa:ali.:seimm::E::2lICiB;T:~PMTo:Subject:

Thanks. Looking forward to seeing you presentation. October is filling up but November is open for me.

ASSISlal1 l Gel lei aJ CounselScience and Technology Law UnitOffice of the General Counsel

3

Page 12: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

From:Sent:To:Subject:

e er

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

Actually we finalized them last week and burnt a new CD, but in light of the new decisio~ Iwe have modifiedthe presentation once again. We are teaching a class tonight and I will get with my partner and get you are newestversion. Also, I did speak with our local Magistrate Judge regarding training in October; She recommended that weset the date(s) and they will try and get everyone there. So look at your calendar and come up with some dates thatwork for you in Oct/Nov.

From: 1---~~~t' (7'''' S-:j~b" 30 'j 9:25 AM

Subject: ~ __ .

UNCLASSIFIED.NON-RECORD

Did you ever finish this project? I would really like to see your slides.

-'"lrA~SS~I~st~a~nt~G"'e~n~e~rll CounselScience and Technology Law UnitOffice of the General CounselFeder . tion(Offil~ ~~

(CellL-..r- ----I---,

(Secure(Fa

From: I 11----.~~::ct, IJlNrslIay, bum 21.2008 3:13 PM

UNCLASSJFIEDNON-RECORD

b7b7E

\

111 1st ",:ntpd fO send you a~ulck email ref our conversation last nighl I will send you via bumall a copy of our. . I will try to include the teaching points that we use when talking about the slides (some of the

shdes are se explanatory, but others need explanation). As soon as we fiqure out how to marry those two up, I Will

send it out. I am 'looking into conducting training for the US Dist Ct and the US Attys office sometime in October. I willlet you know if we get some P~lble dates I would !ilse to have you or someone from OCG give a short presentationregarding legal issues involvin

1I

. .

Page 13: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:

s~R~x

EJandl__

...

_D_id_a_n_y_o_n_e_e_ve~~tJ_E_liJ_"'_"'.."_lL_I!J_"_lL_",_,._,,_r;;_It_"_"_l!_"_"_U<_lL_"'_l_1J._JJ_lf_U_",_Il_"'_dl_iJ!;...J low? We need to get this toR understand thereare a number 0 0

b3b5b

b E

From:Sent:To:Subject:

s

e:ra\\ June 30, 2008 1,07 PM

xxx

SSUnit~~/e=-r-----....I

Tracking Technology UnitOaerational TecyolOgy Division

From:Sent:To:Subject:

I~., '''0" 1!I "'''j_'''514_[_-----Jt)

xx

2

Page 14: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

Did you folks review aThanks,

raft? See below, and also please have someone answer the questions in the e-mail below.

Just wanted to follow-up on this issue and if oro had a chance to look at the draft sent overaddition

Cc:

reviewed the draft brief and form and had some additional questions about the technique. So here they are:

~L.....-_-----------'It-------

51.... 1would think not, but please confirm.)

3

Page 15: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

6~~=================================..................==..=....,

Se, please pass thes1."estieo••0 Ie whemever en your side is mest familia' witJ IWs GaR't move forwardon getting approval ofl !Without more information about exactl~L.. ......I1

Thanks!

From:Sent:To:Subject:

ETR xx

b3

b6

E

Will do, thanks. WeIll be in touch.

I IASSistant General Counsel

From:Sent:To:Cc:,Subject:

~Rxx

Attached is a write"up O'L.-":,,:,,,,:,~~_--:-_~-:--~~-:-:--~ -..,.....,.-__:--...,.!that I prepared -- using informationfrom a variety of sources. Would you please distribute it to the appropriate Ie within the FBI to (a) make sure thefacts are accurate; and (b) get answers to my 0 the court that willneed to be reviewed at our end. But getting th own will bemore than half the battle.

pdf»

b3

hiE

From:Sent:To:Subject:

\OIednesda" Anri! 23 2008 11 ·25 AM

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

4

Page 16: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

Have we made any progress on this issue from your side of the house? We may have a case or twothat we can consider. I propose we get together and hammer out the remaining legal issues. Let meknow what you guys think.

I IASSistant General Counsel

1'-----_SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

DERIVEf'T-I:DI'\DECLASSIF'p"~u,,SEC

DERIV'I::'n-..£:.D1'\ 11/1

DECLASET

ourcesMPTION 1

DERIV·C"n-..£:.DAM: M' ourcesDECLASS EMPTION 1SE

DERIVEDDECLS RET

e SourcesTIO PTION 1

urcesEMPTION 1

DDECLA

ET

rcesEMPTION 1

5

Page 17: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

Subject: FW

Here is the latest co...r-re-s-p-on-d-e-n-ce....loQ You ca~ see near the bottem of the e~ail chain, what questions remain forthe FBI to address.

From:Sent:To:Subject:

x bb:Cb7E

What's up ... Still haven't heard from OTD, lIve got a call in and will find out where they're at withthis. So I hear your Falcons are going to start the rookie? My Vikes should be solid, but all dependson "fragile toes" aka Tarvaris Jackson. Talk to you later.

I IIAssistant General COunsel

From:Sent:To:Subject:

_It have taken over fori IDid you or OTD get a chance to get back to her on her questions below?Give me a call tomorrow if possible and lets discuss where we are on the questions below.

Thanks,

From:Sent:To:Subject:

~

From:

~~:t: iREldoesda~ June 25, ,008 ':58 PM

Subject: ~

~2

Page 18: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

IH

Ireviewed the draft brief and form and had some additional questions abo~

bSbE:blC

~o here they are: E

II

II

I5 I (Iwouldthil,1lrk not, but please confirm.)

6 I71~:---r---,r--'""n--l'~r----------....... ~I think we m~y beable to deal with thl1 I~~ayestjonson~~~

Thanks!

From:I I

I

.1IIalll\;;). be in touch.

ICounsel

b7C

From:Mav 21 200B 12:32 p~

~: I II. I

rSubject: RE:I......_-_.....~

3

Page 19: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

;!r.~""::':::~"='="'''"''l''lrr:::':":~~-::::T::=~=!'I::'':'':''l~~~~===~=~~Lt;~h;a=t I prepared -- using information. re the

that willnwillbe

Thanks very much.

« Eile:1

b3b5

From:Sent:To:Subject:

1-;::=mmzmi~mc:z::c:zI~~_---------,IW'"'..... Abo! " Z1" M ". 2S '"

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

Have we made any progress on this issue from your side of the house? We may have a case or twothat we can consider. I propose we get together and hammer out the remaining legal issues. Let meknow what you guys think.

I'--A-:-s-s""'is~ta-n~t~G=-e-n-e-ra-:-1"""C-o-un......lsel

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIED

ourcesEMPTION 1

DERIVE=r-t-c:.D1"'\1I1 ~~~e~S~o~ugrc~e~sDECLAS EMPTION 1

4

Page 20: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

I don't have experience with this and can't ,e"!'v ahm advice beyoad readioa "ba.Bas left 'e'ioa Thepresentation I was looking at is available herEl[

L...- ..... These and other documents are available from this pag

PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DfSCLOSUR

9QIITSIQE THE FBI WITfOUT PRIOR OGC APPROVAL

I LAssistant General Counsel, aGC STL "

I I-----Orig'"\U1liIU:1liiiai~====- ....,

From:Sent:To:

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

b3

Sorry, not me"

b7

-----Original Me, IFrom,~::.:__~L:::i~~~::&iWi~~m:liiUJt:L --.Sen,.: Atlnllc;!" ")") ?007 7~07 PMTo:

ec: I ~i:'"""--""""Ew:f-------"l------------------------.JSubJect: FW:I IImportance: Hig''''"rn-------....

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

Do any of you have any thoughts on the below or prior experience with these issues, iOabsence?

Assistant General CounselScience and Technology Law Unit

~rce of the General COrSeJ

PRIVILEGED DELIBERATlVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUTPRIOR OGC APPROVAL

-----Original Mess.i"""~~ ---.From:se~.....................::::wiBm1:&i9iEE:ZZ:zmIZ:3"~ PMTo:

3

Page 21: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

Subject: REf _

UNCLASSIFIEDNONwRECORD

Thank you!

-----Original MeSSfoe-----

From: L"":":"':'"-:----:--:--"""":""'==""==-:'~..".,..,.JI:~~ ~nesday AII~!5t 22 2~--'I:54 PM

Subject: -, [

UNCLASSIFIED .NONwRECORD

bb7Cb7E

Running irHo more meetings....will take a look later this afternoon and hope to get back to you soon,IhonefUlly l tomorrow morning.

--A'l!"'s~s""ls""t""a""'nt""G""""'en""'e~r""'a""l c...."..JolnselScience and Technology Law Unit

~{ee oftb. "'ana",1 jOll'Sel

PRIVILEGED DELIBERATIVE DOCUMENT w NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBt WITHOUTPRIOR OGC APPROVAL

-·-·-Original MjFrom: 1-,-:':':--:---:_....:----:'-=='-='=~~Sent:To:Subject:

UNCLASSIFIEDNONwRECORD

,----I nI sent the below message tUfor some legal assistance, but got her "out of office" reply. Wouldyou have time to address these questions?

Thanks,

-----Original MeFrom:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:

UNCLASSIFIEDNONwRECORD

I"}or 1,),1';'< PM

4

Page 22: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

From:Sent:To:Subject:

q Fefia",rv 08 2008 8·58 I\lIt1PSENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECOR

I have no idea.

ASSistant General coun1S~n wU~

PhoneCell phoneSecF..I.lI.IJWJ.l::....L..---,...__--.JFax

From: 11......",..,...,.. .....,--...,...,.-,..,..,..,...,....,..,...,..,.,...-~~t: ~. '"bm,ry 08. WOO 8:14~

Subject: ~ tr---------.....J

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

b6b7C

[ have seen this. but [ heard that it was never approved. uploaded. etc.. Do either of you know if it was approved?

~om: [~:~t: ~ay _ory n6 ,nor 3·15 PM

Subject: ~ .

SENSITIVE BUT UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

From:Sent:To:Subject:

___L...- I-- --JIWPd»

1

Page 23: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

From:Sent:To:

Subject:

NON-RECORD

Office of the General COluns,elFedera.LElu.£.l~Laflml.es.tiapjtion

(Office(Cell~----~

(Secure(Fa)(f.;;;.a...---"l--..J

From:sent:To:Cc:

UNCLASSIFlEDNON-RECORD b7

Thanks for taking the time to look into this. I re-read the e-mail fr.q.tIlL.CluU..l.S...!MI:!lI:.I:lJ~aJ:JJ:ii.u.si.:3.CJLaJ:ll.lJ.Cl1.JlU.ttiLu;l..JIl£io.lI.l~

in her mou h she stated: ...Althol.l h DOJ wants to take the 6siti6

Just wanted to pass this along as a trend that at least our US Attorneys office seems to be heading toward.

Fax:Cell:

1

Page 24: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

From:Sent: jr+"h"e II: '>I1I1Q :27 PM I

To:

Lmr1 i

Subject:I

UNCLASSIFIED INON-RECORD I

II I I

II will have to send this up to OGC for additional information. I haven't heard this from any other source. Thanks.

IAssistant General CounselScience and Technology Law UnitOffice of the General CounselFederJ:ll I:! , ,eo<:>, nf' tion(OffiM.J I

(ceHl~I

I(Sec r.:;'

(Fax) I

I rFrom:Sent: ~nesda~ Odob" 15, 20DB 9:13 AM ITo: b3

Cc:Subject:

UNCLASSIFIED I cE

NON-RECORD

EJII work witrl II just wanted to let you know that the US attorneys office is stating that

Thanks

I IsJ I

I I

DeshFax:Cell:

I FFrom:

i:~" ~'''''"'''' 14, j 2:09 prSubject:

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

. 2

Page 25: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

From: I--~~~t: ~tember 30 2008 r9 PM

Subject: ~

UNCLASSIFIED

Thanks. Looking forward to seeing you presentation. October is filling up but November is open for me.

II.......::-A-ss...,i~st~a-nt~G=-e-n-e-ral Counsel

Science and Technology Law UnitOffice of the General CounselFederal Bureau of Investi ation(Offi........ ....J

(Cel,L---.Jr------..L.-......(Sec4f-lL --L,

(Fax)

b3bb7 f:::

From:Sent:To:Subject:

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

Actually we finalized them last week and burnt a new CD, but in light of the new decisionc=Jwe have modified thepresentation once again. We are teaching a class tonight and I will get with my partner and get you are newest version.Also, I did speak with our local Magistrate Judge regarding training in October. She recommended that we set the date(s)and they will try and get everyone there. So look at your calendar and come up with some dates that work for you inOct/Nov.

I~~=-:S~e~t~em~b~e~r3~O~2~O~08l:":9~:2ll'l"5 AMFrom:Sent:To:Subject:_. I

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

Did you ever finish this project? I would really like to see your slides.

Assistant General CounselScience and Technology Law UnitOffice of the General CounselFederal Bureau of Investi ation(Offic;flJ- .....

(Cell)

3

Page 26: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

Subject:

UNCLASSIFIED

biC

~ted to send you aquick email ref our cOl"lversationlast night. Iwill send you via bumail acopy ofcuBwill try to include the teaching points that we use when talking about the slides (some of the slides are self

exp ana ory, ut others need explanation). As saari as we fiqure out how to marry those two up. I will send it out. I amlooking into conducting training for the US Dist Ct and the US Attys office sometime in October. I will let you know if weget som . ne from OCG give a short presentation regarding legal issuesinvolvin

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIE

UNCLASSIFIED

UNCLASSIFIEn I

4

Page 27: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

ALL T1Jlro'RMA'rTn.lJ LIJIYlAJ.l~lCJ.)

HEFEINDATE II--II.~-/.I"/ BY 65179/d:liIh/st-p/as

From:Sent:To:Cc:

Subject:

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

I sent the attached email aut in earlv November. rhis reflects aeneral Ded/eGC auidance as it went aut to all CDC's - Irecoaniz8 I

Also just Fyi it js my understanding that orp js workTg 0~L.. ......I

OGe Guidance1cerning Reque:

SectIon ChiefScience and Technology Law OfficeOffice of the-General Counsel

~%JVILEGED DEUBlTlVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGCAPPROVAL

From:Sent:To:Subjec~. "~,,

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

I Jplease review the below m:age from oneIISSAs. If there is a comprehensive OGC policy inregard tal Jease adVise. L--.JT

From:Sent: Wednesday, November 26,20081:15 PM

1

Page 28: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

DATE 1l-OS2012 BY 65179/dmh/stp/as

From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:

Flag: Follow up

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

b7::::

I did have a n"Qc:Hl'\n

IIt j.::: nnt mA wh::'lt j.::: • I

Also. I'm concerned about th~ --, ...J

OGe GuidanceDe"""q'""u'"e-": I

To:Subject:

I am assuming there is no proble"m with this so I am going to go ahead and send it out.

h7e

To:

1

Page 29: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

From:Sent:To:Cc:Subject:

IIMrl /I.

NON-RECORD

DATE 11-05-2012 BY 65179/dmh/stp/as

era,,, "'Wlls! W ZODS 'O"jl-"_fi_O

_

I I I

I r=-P.;.;;le;.;;;a;.;;;;s.,e seDwrite-up about this matter below, which I reviewed i~ ~bsence. I agree with

I lassessment that there does not seem to be anything else for OGe to do regarding this matter

right now.

Please let

I

or me know if you have any questions or would like us to take any further action.

-From:---II ~~t' f";rsdID' A,WI'" 07 71ll1ll"~SAM ISubject: ~ JUNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

did not get the opportu~ty to reid/take action on this yesterday. He asked that I forward it to you for your review'--:a:'::n"::Ta"l:'l!.tat you then pass it on t in case she had any questions.

Thanks.

I I-Fr-o-m-:---I IEea, ::;0_" Auaust 06, 2008'2UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

1

Page 30: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

~.~~-----------------------

Thanks,

I_IFrom:Sent:To:Subject:

IIMf'1

I Mnnrl,,\1 1I",,",,~ n<1 .,nnQ <1.1 Q DM II 1

NON-RECORD

No, he did not raise this issue with me. Is there anything you would like me to do?

oFrom: I I I~~~~: l'*""Va\l A!la,,"~ n<1 2n08 d·n?~

Subject: ~ JImportance: HighL....--------

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

I I

EQShar. anything aboot this with you? Please advise.

-Fr-o-m-:~--1I~~..,..-..,..._,.....,...,.."..,...,.."....,..."..,,....,,.,.,Jr;:'" L:'" A1n"st M",,, •.,,~

Subject: FWl IUNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

Where do we stand on the auidance related tl

IL....--_--lSection ChiefScience and Technology Law OfficeOffice of the General CounselHot I

I I

I

bbl IPRIVILEGED DELlBERATlVE DOCUMENT - NOT FOR DISCLOSURE OUTSIDE THE FBI WITHOUT PRIOR OGCAPPROVAL

-From:-----11 ISent: Friday, August 01, 2008 7:45 PM

3

Page 31: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

To: ~Cc: r--------Subject: FW 1----1...-_-----UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

FYI. Did you know about this kerfluffle?

From:Sent:To:Subject:

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

I don't see you on this and thought you ought to at least know about the chatter. My understanding is that there isproposed policy in the AGG Implementation Guide that discusses the issue but I haven't seen it.

I IHead, Office of Integrity and ComplianceFBI Deputy Designated Agency Ethics Official

ole vveopagel I I b 7 E

From:Sent:To:

Cc:

Subject:

~~=~~~IFrida Au ust 01 2008 2:23 PM

UNCLASSIFIENON-RECORD

/L:JtOry as I understand it. I haven't spoken t( yet, but I understand that the acting ASAG has spoken tothis morning.

A fl'>\M . ~no theI I

As I thought. it doesn't sound like any effort was made by th1I I '------------

1'-------------------------4

Page 32: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

IHope that helps,

Jttlr.P. ntI

~nri ompliance

Learn about the ole a~This communication may be Privileged or otherwise Deliberative, and should not be disseminated outside of the FBI

.without the concurrence of OGC.

="Fr-o-m-:----II~~---~----....JSent:To:

Cc:

Subject: RE:

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD b6

c=JI believe you are referring to a paper b~ who was in OGC at the time.Doyou have (or recall) such aU I I

From:Sent: Frida Au ust 01 2008 10:13 AMTo:

Cc:

SUbject: R

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

All - we need to get back to the Staffer on thisD· this has been a recurring issue for years with us and I remembera white a er that was done that addressed our concerns. I am fairl certain it was an OTD document. Could you havesomeone see if that rings a bell?

CJFrom:Sent:To:Cc:

Subject:

UNCLASSIFIEDNON-RECORD

I 1 20084:59 PM

Page 33: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

From:Sent:To:- ..

I

Classification:~

b7E

Hey there legal beagle expert on all techie matters. [s the below still correct to

I I

Subject:

1

best of your knowledge as it

Page 34: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

(3) s~~)eCE"'REF-----I-.....I

b5

======================================================

(3 )

TEllS E-MAIL MAY CONTAIN PRIVILEGED ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION AND ATTORNEYWORK PRODUCT. DO NOT DISSEMINATE WITHOUT OGC APPROVAL.

(3) Classification: S-E~//NOFOL...::::,.,..-----I

(3)

2

Page 35: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

~ I~:r:'"T1,:,,:,ue:::-:S::-::l~r=ay:":'".-rD~e=-=c~em=be:::-:r:-lQ"I'l"b-.""12....01...1....4.,..,;,.,.,0'l"l'S....~...,Mr---

SUbject:Rl J--------

(S)Classification: .~/NOFORN, I

Q~;~~By: CIIW58B9Declassify 0 . 06

From: 'FBI NSISC-2======================================================

(S) I I

If we can't do this with this particular factual scenario, then I can't see a clearer one coming along. Common sensedoesn't always win.

(S) Classification: S~/NOFO

Clas .. By: F36M55K50Declassify 0 . 06D rom: FBI NSIsc-,m~nk

b5

======================================================

(S) I1...-_-------------------------------_---1J I

Assistant General Counsel

From1 ISent: Tuesday, December 06, 2011 3:34 PM

:l)jed'REI I~1

6

Page 36: LJNCLASSlAED s Agenda ssues Conference 2010epic.org/foia/fbi/stingray/FBI-FOIA-Release-06282013-s18...management and tryto get it resolved. Ifitmakes you feel any better, this has

!#W.llS.IL_ia Ave., N.W.

35

IE

5''It-· I=rirl::l\/ er 09 2011 2:15 PM

b

IJ

b

3Ject:RE

RtoSeToCc

(S) SU

(S~ Classifieation: '~TIINOFOOClas . . d By: J71J92TDeclassify 0 . 1209D From: FBI NSIS -======================================================

i (S)

THIS E-MAIL MAY CONTAIN PRIVILEGED ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNlCATION AND ATTORNEYWORK PRODUCT. DO NOT DlSSEMlNATE WITHOUT OGC APPROVAL.

L_J

(S)

~ ISe • -;::-:-~-:=:-~e--'-b-er~0~9"""2=0~1""1.....2:.....12.........PM,.,...-Tocc~---.....r------_...l-....,

SObject:

bl

b5b

b7C

(S) Classification:

======================================================

Sounds ok, but nothi~ttached.Can you please send?

S~T

2