LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy...

36
1 LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects (USACOE G roundwater M odeling S ystem) Bruce Phillips - Portage Environmental Steve Hampson – UK KRCEE Dr. Chandramouli Viswanathan – UK Civil Engineering Josh Sexton – UK-Geological Sciences Dr. John Volpe - KRCEE

Transcript of LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy...

Page 1: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

1

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects

(USACOE Groundwater Modeling System)

Bruce Phillips - Portage EnvironmentalSteve Hampson – UK KRCEE

Dr. Chandramouli Viswanathan – UK Civil EngineeringJosh Sexton – UK-Geological Sciences

Dr. John Volpe - KRCEE

Page 2: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

2

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsObjectives

• Identify and Test Modeling Programs for PGDP Data & Lithostratigraphic Visualization (Sexton,2006)– Golden Software Rockware & Surfer– ARCGIS/ARCMAP

• Evaluate USACOE Groundwater Modeling System (GMS) for use of Groundwater Modeling and Lithologic Database at PGDP– Grids, Tins, Solids, Contouring and Cross-Section Modeling – Presentation

• Evaluate Other Visualization and Modeling Programs for interoperability with DWGIS– Grids, Tins, Solids, Contouring and Cross-Section Modeling

– Presentation

Page 3: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

3

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects

CTECH EVSCTECH Development Corporation

CDMTracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky

Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania

Page 4: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

4

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsSWMU 4

Trichloroethylene Soil Sampling Results

Page 5: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

5

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsSWMU 4

Lithology Distribution

Page 6: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

6

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsSWMU 4

Trichloroethylene Soil Sampling Results - Solids

Page 7: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

7

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsSWMU 4

Trichloroethylene Soil Sampling Results – Uncertainty Plot

Page 8: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

8

Surfer 7.0Golden Software

Josh Sexton/UK-Geological Science, 2005Steve Hampson/UK-KRCEE, 2006-7

Page 9: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

9

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsSurfer Generated Contour Plots (Red-Blue Figure = Base LCD)

Page 10: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

10

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsSurfer Wireframe (5 mins from xls file)

240

250

260

270

280

290

300

310

320

330

340

350

360

370

380

390

0 5000 10000 15000 20000

Page 11: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

11

SADA

Dr. John Volpe, KRCEEDr. Rich Bonczek (SAIC)

Page 12: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

12

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects

Page 13: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

13

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects

Page 14: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

14

GMS 6.0Copyright 2002

Brigham Young University

PGDP Preview Work by USACOE Waterways Station

Recent PGDP WorkBruce Phillips, Portage

Steve Hampson, KRCEEDr. Chandramouli Viswanathan

Page 15: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

15

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsSurfer Wireframe (5 mins from xls file)

8(Top Miss. Limestone)Bottom of Rubble Zone 10(Top Rubble Zone)Bottom of McNairy Formation 10

Bottom of McNairy LevingsMember

22Top of McNairy Levings Member 440(Top McNairy Fmn.)

Base of Lower Continental Deposits

567(Top LCD)Base of Upper Continental Deposits

# BoringsNoteUnit

Stratigraphic Boreholes

Page 16: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

16

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsSolids Model for McNairy, LCD, UCD

Page 17: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

17

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsBase of LCD 3-D Contour Plan View

Dark Blue = Low Elevation, Red – Highest

Plant N

Page 18: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

18

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects(Terrace & McNairy Ridge Under PGDP from ENE; VE=20x)

McNairy Ridge, E-W

Terrace

Page 19: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

19

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsTop of McNairy/Porters Creek Clay

Dark Blue = Low Elevation, Red – Highest

McNairy Ridge, E-W

Terrace

Plant N

Page 20: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

20

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsPlant Cross-section A-B

A

B

Page 21: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

21

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsPlant Cross-section A-B

S-12

S-10 S-18S-8 S-1 F3 E4G3400’

350’

300’

250’

200’

Vertical Exag. = 20x

A B

Gravel / SandSilt / Clay

SandSilty Sand

Clayey SandLignite

Eocene Sands

Porters Creek Clay

Lower Continental Deposits

McNairy Fm.

Page 22: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

22

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsCross Section F - G

F

G

Page 23: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

23

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsCross Section F - G

F7 F6 F1 F2 F3 F4 F5

400’

350’

300’

250’

200’

Vertical Exag. = 20x

F G

Gravel / SandSilt / Clay

SandSilty Sand

Clayey SandLignite

Lower Continental Deposits

McNairy Fm.

Porters Creek Clay

Page 24: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

24

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsLower Continental Deposit Solid from East, VE=30x

Page 25: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

25

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsLCD solid from North, VE=30x

Page 26: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

26

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects

Page 27: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

27

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects

Page 28: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

28

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects

A

A’

3AH-500

AH-818

Page 29: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

29

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects

Page 30: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

30

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects

Delineation of Porters Creek ClayHU6Extrapolation of first Silt/Clay Horizon in upper McNairy HU6Extrapolation of McNairy sands contiguous to Lower Continental Deposits HU6

Extrapolation of Coarse Grained Sands and Gravels near base of Lower Continental Deposits HU5

Extrapolation of Fine and Medium Sands of Lower Continental Deposits HU4Extrapolation Site-wide relative to HU designation HU3Silt, Clay Horizons with varying sand content. HU2b

UCD/Loess Sand HorizonsFocus on Red gravel sand/horizon apparent in many areas of site HU2a

Lithostratigraphic & Hydrogeologic Model

Model faults at interpreted locations & Evaluate ResultsModel WideDetermine Loess Horizons to include Model WideVerify available boreholes are in modelModel WideVerify borehole stratigraphy/lithologyModel Wide

Existing Model

Page 31: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

31

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsGeneral Summary

• Utilized Modeling Programs for PGDP Data & Lithostratigraphic Visualizations

• Data formats differ but could be automated via DWGIS

• All have significant strengths – Golden Software Surfer (Sexton, 2006)– ARCGIS/ARCMAP/ARCScene (KRCEE, UK)– SADA (KRCEE)– Golden Software Rockware (KRCEE, UK)– C-Tech ESV (CDM, Portage?)– GMS– Golden Software Voxler (3D)

Page 32: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

32

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling ProjectsGMS Evaluation

• Evaluated USACOE Groundwater Modeling System (GMS) for use of Groundwater Modeling and Lithologic Database at PGDP through intense application– Tutorials– Setup USACOE files for viewing & evaluation of input data– PGDP Grids, Tins, Solids, – PGDP Contouring and Cross-Section creation– Groundwater Modeling (not accomplished per discussion with DOE and

USACOE regarding model status)

Page 33: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

33

LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects

Strengths– “one package fits all”

• conceptual model development• Borehole management• Flow & transport models (finite element & finite difference)• Parameter estimation, particle tracking & other advanced tools

– Free to government and government contractors– Data input formats compatible with automated DWGIS output

Maybe Not Strengths– Output format compatibility with other modeling software (tins, solids,

etc.)– Intuitive tools & application of tools– Intuitive training materials– Ability to manipulate output graphics (label, scale, etc.)

Page 34: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

34

1 Real-Time Remediation

a AOC 492 Field Demonstration

2 Groundwater Modeling

Support for Numerical GW Model Development

3 TCE Fate and Transport

a TCE Fate and Transport White Paper (Aerobic - NWP)

bScopinig TCE Fate and Transport & White Paper for Abiotic Mechanisms, Anaerobic Mechanisms for UCRS & Other Plumes

4 Groundwater Remediation

a Nano Particle TCE Dissolved Phase Remediation Field Demonstration

b Modified Fenton Reaction TCE Dissolved Phase Remediation Field Demonstration

c Source and secondary source applications of above

Page 35: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

35

5 Seismic (Regional & Local)

a Preliminary Geophysical Investigation of NWP & LBC Seeps (Phase 1)

b Temporary Seismic Network Monitoring (incl. Deep Hole)

c Structural & Quaternary Mapping of Joppa/Heath Quads

Page 36: LithoStratigraphic & GMS Modeling Projects · CTECH EVS CTECH Development Corporation CDM Tracy Brindley/Kevil, Kentucky Adam Locke/State College, Pennsylvania 4 LithoStratigraphic

36

6 Ecological Monitoring

a Implementation of Ecological Monitoring

7 DWGIS Data and Tool Development

a Document Indexing and Linkage Module

b Standardized Risk Assessment Module

c Ongoing Data Development (Additional GIS, format logs for retrieval, etc.)

d Development of Automated Site Reports

e Developmet of 3-D Data Linkage Layer

fDevelop of Automated Data Output Interface

8 SW Sediment Controls Demo

9 PGDP Area Garden Evaluation