STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 25 21 1 1

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 96 75 8 12

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 74 30 2 0

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 67 54 5 0

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 31 20 5 0 0

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 112 107 19 3

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 290 182 23 12

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 29 18 1 0

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 440 391 26 5

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 53 24 0 0

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 94 60 2 0

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 23 211 5 1

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 21 15 0 0

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 58 21 2 1

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 213 186 23 8

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

QUESTION # 1 I am aware of the current situation facing the Archdiocese, particularly with such issues as the decline in Church

attendance, shortage of priests, decreased financial stability, etc. For me this is a serious issue.

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 93 50 0 1

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 99

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 45 25 1 1

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 94 86 7 1

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 45 21 0 0

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 211 157 10 0 2

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 13 27 4 2

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 45 116 31 15

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 25 47 24 10

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 22 85 7 4

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 22 23 6 2 3

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 48 135 35 17

QUESTION # 2 (CONTINUED) I recognize the reality that some parishes will have to be closed or merged if the mission of the Archdiocese is to

remain viable.

QUESTION # 2 I recognize the reality that some parishes will have to be closed or merged if the mission of the Archdiocese is to

remain viable.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 96 208 107 133

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 16 22 8 4

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 212 500 91 16

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 30 39 5 6

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 7 25 4 0

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 31 81 124 3

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 12 20 11 1

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 27 48 5 1

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 79 184 102 59

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 42 80 21 2

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 99

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 21 41 10 1

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 34 116 27 8

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 19 42 3 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 81 204 80 9

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 110 233 63 12

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 57 67 13 5

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 99

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 32 34 5 0

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 34 121 32 0

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 19 42 3 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 103 241 21 6

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 10 26 3 6

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 63 117 10 7

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 44 53 5 4

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 20 87 14 2

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 22 31 3 0 0

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 87 128 17 6

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 187 239 27 12

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 12 27

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 257 499 86 15

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 34 36 5 3

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 42 97 8 5

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 40 42 147 10

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 12 20 11 1

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 17 58 7 0

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 110 233 63 12

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 57 67 13 5

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 0 99 0 0

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 32 34 5 0

QUESTION # 3 To determine parish viability, I believe it is important to look at parish weekday and Sunday Mass attendance.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 34 121 32 0

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 21 44 0 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 103 241 21 6 9

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini (Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 13 26 7 1

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 40 119 24 10

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 35 53 11 7

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 20 53 20 2

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 19 31 4 1 1

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 59 137 30 7

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 156 238 55 22

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 9 29 11 3

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 195 498 125 23

QUESTION # 4 (CONTINUED) To determine parish viability, I believe it is important to look at parish sacramental, i.e., how baptisms, communions,

marriages, funerals, etc.

QUESTION # 4 To determine parish viability, I believe it is important to look at parish sacramental, i.e., how baptisms, communions,

marriages, funerals, etc.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 22 42 9 5

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 27 93 26 8

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 14 45 140 40

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 9 17 10 0

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 9 50 17 4

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 101 237 63 12

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 52 75 17 4

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 99

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 17 35 20 0

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 26 111 47 1

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 16 41 7 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 78 241 44 6 11

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 16 23 8 1

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 58 114 15 3

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 37 54 8 7

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 27 62 8 1

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 18 34 4 0 0

QUESTION # 5 To determine parish viability, I believe it is important to look at parish programs, i.e., religious education, RCIA, outreach

to the poor, etc.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 67 137 18 3

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 207 294 26 10

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 14 30 8 0

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 297 453 63 11

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 28 38 7 3

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 40 87 24 1

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 45 44 148 2

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 11 17 13 0

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 23 51 7 2

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 124 216 43 13

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 53 83 14 2

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 0 99 0 0

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 26 37 9 0

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 55 112 16 1

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 16 36 11 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 95 249 33 1 7

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

QUESTION # 5 (CONTINUED) To determine parish viability, I believe it is important to look at parish programs, i.e., religious education, RCIA, outreach

to the poor, etc.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 10 31 5 1

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 39 113 11 8

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 29 59 10 8

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 23 64 10 1

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 14 31 8 0 3

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 53 155 23 4

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 156 266 45 9

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 15 27 9 1

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 247 470 89 15

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 29 41 9 0

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 46 80 22 3

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 30 82 125 2

QUESTION # 6 To determine parish viability, you should look at significant changes in the Catholic population of parishes.

QUESTION # 6 (CONTINUED) To determine parish viability, you should look at significant changes in the Catholic population of parishes.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 8 26 2 0

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 20 49 10 1

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 99 239 62 10

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 54 91 19 1

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 0 99 0 0

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 20 46 7 0

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 31 120 33 0

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 12 48 4 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 82 249 34 3 12

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 12 26 10 1

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 54 121 8 10

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 29 52 14 8

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 24 56 18 2

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 17 32 5 1 1

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 55 146 25 2

QUESTION # 7 To determine parish viability, you should examine if parish revenue is sufficient to support parish ministries,

Archdiocesan programs, and ordinary operating expenses .

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 157 271 60 15

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 12 25 9 3

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 208 405 175 38

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 22 48 7 1

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 42 73 30 4

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 51 52 55 81

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 10 19 5 2

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 20 43 15 3

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 86 251 58 14

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 46 73 20 5

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 0 99 0 0

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 15 44 12 1

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 34 113 36 4

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 19 41 3 2

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 81 237 49 6 7

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

QUESTION # 8 For parish viability, you should also examine if parish revenue is sufficient to support its priests and members of its

pastoral staff.

QUESTION # 7 (CONTINUED) To determine parish viability, you should examine if parish revenue is sufficient to support parish ministries,

Archdiocesan programs, and ordinary operating expenses .

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 14 23 9 2

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 46 127 3 13

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 36 55 10 3

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 23 57 14 3

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 16 30 8 1 1

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 48 164 18 0

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 175 252 58 19

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 12 27 0 0

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 209 399 158 39

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 24 44 7 2

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 40 76 28 4

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 2 151 80 4

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 10 19 6 2

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 18 50 11 1

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 95 206 58 28

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 53 68 27 1

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 0 99 0 0

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 15 41 15 1

QUESTION # 8 (CONTINUED) For parish viability, you should also examine if parish revenue is sufficient to support its priests and members of its

pastoral staff.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 28 124 32 2

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 21 40 4 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 75 241 51 3 10

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini (Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 17 20 7 2

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 37 118 23 10

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 31 54 16 3

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 21 61 15 1

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 18 28 6 0 4

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 46 133 29 9

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 176 270 58 21

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 16 26 3 2

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 223 422 127 38

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 29 43 6 2

QUESTION # 9 To determine parish viability, I feel it is important to know if a parish has a consistent operating deficit or owes money

for unpaid bills to outside vendors or to the Archdiocese.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 46 71 28 3

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 49 132 53 5

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 11 20 4 1

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 19 51 10 1

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 76 192 76 4

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 52 73 20 1

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 0 99 0 0

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 18 47 5 2

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 31 119 32 4

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 20 39 4 2

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 77 235 51 5 12

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 22 22 2 0

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 57 104 18 14

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 45 52 6 1

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 36 57 4 0

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 24 26 1 5 0

QUESTION # 9 (CONTINUED) To determine parish viability, I feel it is important to know if a parish has a consistent operating deficit or owes money

for unpaid bills to outside vendors or to the Archdiocese.

QUESTION # 11 I believe that if a parish has to close or merge, it is important to investigate whether the pastoral ministries of that parish

can be served by a neighboring parish.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 74 133 11 3

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 186 232 40 17

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 26 26 1 0

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 411 389 23 5

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 35 37 2 1

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 71 74 4 1

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 42 143 51 3

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 14 21 1 0

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 37 39 3 1

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 110 178 34 27

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 82 65 1 2

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 0 99 0 0

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 28 39 4 0

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 81 98 6 0

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 24 39 2 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 148 208 5 1 18

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

QUESTION # 11 (CONTINUED) I believe that if a parish has to close or merge, it is important to investigate whether the pastoral ministries of that parish

can be served by a neighboring parish.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 17 22 7 0

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 75 93 30 6

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 58 45 1 1

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 50 38 4 1

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 16 28 7 1 4

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 107 92 7 2

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 253 245 19 2

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 30 17 1 2

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 366 391 35 3

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 35 32 5 1

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 76 66 10 0

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 81 153 5 0

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 16 19 1 0

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 44 33 2 0

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 147 181 26 11

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 69 66 7 3

QUESTION # 12 If a parish has to close or merge, I believe the parish council should be consulted.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 1 98 0 0

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 29 41 2 0

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 97 85 4 0

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 41 19 4 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 152 177 20 5 26

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 13 26 9 0

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 64 89 25 1

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 58 45 1 1

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 46 41 1 1

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 15 31 5 1 4

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 84 139 10 2

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 228 235 21 3

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 30 20 2 2

QUESTION # 13 (CONTINUED) If a parish has to close or merge, I believe the finance council should be consulted.

QUESTION # 13 If a parish has to close or merge, I believe the finance council should be consulted.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 365 374 43 3

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 34 39 2 0

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 65 70 12 0

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 95 96 48 0

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 15 17 1 0

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 37 37 4 0

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 129 195 15 8

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 65 72 4 2

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 30 38 4 0

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 84 99 5 0

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 39 23 2 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 147 193 15 3 22

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 12 27 6 1

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 71 122 5 7

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 59 44 3 0

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 48 40 4 3

QUESTION # 14 If a parish has to close or merge, I think the "Making All Things New" committee should assist the pastor to create and

develop a response on behalf of the parish.

QUESTION # 14 (CONTINUED) If a parish has to close or merge, I think the "Making All Things New" committee should assist the pastor to create and

develop a response on behalf of the parish.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 16 23 6 2 9

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 85 134 8 3

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 215 243 23 0

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 26 24 0 3

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 346 395 44 9

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 37 32 5 0

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 61 76 10 3

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 55 178 6 0

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 15 17 3 0

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 44 29 5 1

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 109 189 27 15

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 71 61 9 2

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 0 99 0 0

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 33 35 3 1

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 80 88 9 2

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 26 32 2 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 130 187 20 12 31

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

QUESTION # 15 An Archdiocesan advisory panel should review the responses of parishes that could potentially close or merge and

provide their opinion to the Archbishop.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 15 27 4 1

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 73 106 2 4

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 58 42 3 3

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 40 52 3 1

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 18 26 3 2 7

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 80 131 10 3

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 221 238 33 7

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 20 26 3 2

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 345 410 34 10

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 34 35 3 2

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 76 68 4 1

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 68 128 42 1

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 15 19 1 1

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 39 37 2 2

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 71 131 29 17

QUESTION # 15 (CONTINUED) An Archdiocesan advisory panel should review the responses of parishes that could potentially close or merge and

provide their opinion to the Archbishop.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 74 67 3 0

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 1 99 0 0

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 34 39 1 0

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 79 88 10 4

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 31 31 1 1

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 142 199 21 2 16

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 7 8 21 10

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 19 75 52 43

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 13 28 31 32

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 7 27 36 21

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 2 13 17 17 7

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann 21 44 73 88

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena

QUESTION # 16 (CONTINUED) I think there are too many parishes in our area. Some could be closed or merged without presenting a great

inconvenience to people.

QUESTION # 16 I think there are too many parishes in our area. Some could be closed or merged without presenting a great

inconvenience to people.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 38 94 227 144

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 3 15 14 13

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 68 160 273 179

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 12 20 26 13

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 6 32 63 38

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 9 11 181 38

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 2 7 15 11

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 10 21 36 8

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 29 124 144 90

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 9 37 58 35

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 0 99 0 0

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 4 10 38 21

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 9 49 81 33

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 3 15 28 16

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 26 105 129 63 57

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

1 Rev. Msgr. Robert Richie St. Patick's Cathedral

5 Rev. Msgr. Leslie J. Ivers Epiphany

8 Rev. Victor Elia, C.M. Holy Agony, Our Lady of the Miraculous Medal

11 Rev. Robert J. Robbins Holy Family 22 19 3 1

14 Temp. A Rev. Basilio Alava, O.S.A. Holy Rosary 106 76 11 0

26 Rev. Kazimierz A. Kowalski Our Lady of Good Counsel 76 29 1 0

31 A Rev. Anthony Kelly, S.A.C. Our Lady of Mt. Carmel

33 A Rev. Bartholomew Daly, M.H.M. Our Lady of Peace 51 37 4 8

QUESTION # 17 I have confidence that, in the end, by God's grace and our good efforts, the Church will not only "get through" but

continue to grow.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

41 Rev. George W. Rutler Our Saviour 30 17 1 0 8

44 OL of the Scapular and St. Stephen Chapel of Sacred Hearts of Jesus & Mary Mission Rev. Msgr. Lawrence Connaughton, Admin.

45 Rev. Richard T. Adams St. Agnes

51 Rev. Mario Guarino, FDP St. Ann

57 Rev. Jordan James Kelly, O.P. St. Catherine of Siena 152 70 3 0

58 Rev. Peter Mushi, A.J. St. Cecilia 375 141 7 0

65 Rev. Msgr. Patrick P. McCahill St. Elizabeth of Hungary 25 21 1 0

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

69 Rev. Victor Muzzin, FDP St. Francis de Sales

74 Rev. George W. Witt, S.J. St. Ignatius Loyola 408 313 39 18

76 Rev. Anthony Schueller, S.S.S. St. Jean Baptiste 41 27 3 2

78 Rev. Msgr. Douglas J. Mathers St. John the Evangelist 52 71 17 5

79 Rev. Martin J. Svitan St. John Nepomucene 89 140 10 0

80 Rev. Sean R. Harlow, O.Carm. St. John the Martyr 21 8 5 1

82 Rev. Boniface Ramsey St. Joseph (Yorkville) 32 34 7 0

86 A Rev. Msgr. Oscar A. Aquino St. Lucy 165 165 12 7

92 Rev. Msgr. Thomas A. Modugno St. Monica 80 54 9 1

95 Rev. Claudio Stewart, I.V.E. St. Paul 0 99 0 0

102 Rev.Msgr.Lawrence M. Connaughton Our Lady of the Scapular and St. Stephen 35 31 6 0

103 Rev. Angelus Gambatese, O.F.M. St. Stephen of Hungary 82 79 19 1

106 Rev. Msgr. John A. Boehning St. Thomas More 31 28 3 2

108 Rev. Walter Wagner, O.P. St. Vincent Ferrer 189 141 19 2 29

115 Rev. Peter A. Miqueli St. Frances Cabrini(Roosevelt Island)

QUESTION # 17 (CONTINUED) I have confidence that, in the end, by God's grace and our good efforts, the Church will not only "get through" but

continue to grow.

LISTING OF PASTORS AND ADMINISTRATORS BY VICARIATE

VICARIATE OF EAST MANHATTAN (29 Parishes)

NM CH EM SM WM NWB NEB EB SB S.I. Y SS CW NW/P R O D U S

Parish History (Valued, Needs To Be Considered) 3 2 19 7 5 3 8 2 12 8 5 8 6 5 3

Married Clergy 3 1 17 1 1 2 5 2 2 15 13 15 10 12 8 5

Lay Involvement 2 1 16 2 2 2 1 2 3 2 3 12 13 3 6 14 3 4

Schools Positive (We Need Our Schools) 2 16 3 4 2 3 1 30 7 4 9 4 8 8 12 5 3

Women (Ordination - Priests, Deacons) 16 3 1 1 7 1 4 10 10 7 10 7 3

RESPONSE TO QUESTION #10I THINK THE FOLLOWING ADDITIONAL AREAS SHOULD BE LOOKED AT TO ASSESS PARISH VIABILITY.

Masses (Quality Of Liturgies And Homilies) 1 14 5 4 1 1 2 3 1 3 8 6 1 3 4 3 1

Demographics 4 2 13 6 5 2 1 17 1 11 11 9 15 15 10 5

Strategic Planning (Effect Of Closing Parishes, Share Resources)

1 11 1 3 3 5 20 3 1 11 5 6 11 13 6 4

Ethnic Needs (Hispanic Communities and Immigrants)

2 2 10 1 6 2 1 2 9 3 4 8 6 2 3 4 2 1

NM CH EM SM WM NWB NEB EB SB S.I. Y SS CW NW/P R O D U S

RESPONSE TO QUESTION #10I THINK THE FOLLOWING ADDITIONAL AREAS SHOULD BE LOOKED AT TO ASSESS PARISH VIABILITY.

Distance Between Urban Parishes 1 1 10 6 6 3 2 2 1 13 5 4

Finances (Wealthier Parishes Assisting Poorer Parishes) 3 10 2 2 2 13 1 5 7 2 6 10 3 2

Clergy Abuse 1 10 2 1 2 7 5 7 1 6 3 3 2

Youth Ministry (Need To Get Young People More Involved) 3 9 1 3 3 4 4 1 21 4 3 9 5 9 15 9 11 2

Real Estate (Leasing, Selling) 1 9 2 4 1 1 9 1 3 11 2 9 6 6 1

Evangelizing 1 8 4 3 1 2 6 1 3 1 2 11 11 2 1 3 2 2

Parish (Should Have A More Welcoming Atmosphere) 1 8 5 3 1 1 14 2 1 3 2 4 5 4 7 1

Community Outreach (Parish Is Involved) 5 4 7 8 10 2 2 6 2 6 2 6 14 6 4 8 10 4 1

Buildings (Condition of Buildings) 1 7 2 2 2 2 15 1 1 4 5 2 6 3 6 3

NM CH EM SM WM NWB NEB EB SB S.I. Y SS CW NW/P R O D U S

RESPONSE TO QUESTION #10I THINK THE FOLLOWING ADDITIONAL AREAS SHOULD BE LOOKED AT TO ASSESS PARISH VIABILITY.

Finances (Proper Management) 7 2 1 8 2 3 1 6 7 6 4

Parish Involvement (Consultation) 7 13 6 3 4 2 3

Parish (Declining numbers - Identify Why Catholics Are Not Attending Mass)

7 1 8 4 12 6 8 4 6 2

Parish Programs 2 2 6 5 8 2 2 4 2 13 4 5 10 6 1 7 8 10 2

Senior Citizens (Services, Homebound, Handicapped Access)

1 6 8 2 3 1 4 7 3 6 9 22 6 6 10 6 1

CCD Programs (Evaluate) 6 1 1 5 1 4 8 3 3 12 7 4 2

Mission of the Church (Favor Pre-Vatican) 6 2 1 1

Poor and Homeless (Ministry to Poor and Homeless) 6 2 6 2 1 3 1

Finances (Raise Revenue) 2 2 5 5 3 1 1 4 2 12 2 13 8 4 14 5 8 2

NM CH EM SM WM NWB NEB EB SB S.I. Y SS CW NW/P R O D U S

RESPONSE TO QUESTION #10I THINK THE FOLLOWING ADDITIONAL AREAS SHOULD BE LOOKED AT TO ASSESS PARISH VIABILITY.

Pastoral Concerns (Orthodoxy, Leadership) 2 5 3 3 1 1 4 15 1 1 6 13 2 6 3 2 1

Mass Schedules 3 5 3 2 2 4 1 1 5 8 2 8 8 3 6

Transparency (Finance, etc.) 1 5 4 2 1 1 13 1 2 3 3 3 4 3

Communication Issues (More Transparency) 5 2 3 1 5 1 2 15 1

Parish "At Risk" (Give Parish Opportunity To Formulate A Plan)

5 4 1 3 2 1 3 1

Young Adult Programs (Need To Get Young Adults Involved in Parish)

4 2 4 2 1 3 3 2 9 15 4 2 3 1 1

Parish (Spiritual Life) 3 2 4 5 5 1 3 4 2 14 4 4 5 9 1 8 7 3 1

Vatican Support (Financial) 3 1 4 3 5 5 4 1 1 1 1

Volunteers 1 1 4 3 1 1 5 16 1 7 3 2 6 10 3 3

NM CH EM SM WM NWB NEB EB SB S.I. Y SS CW NW/P R O D U S

RESPONSE TO QUESTION #10I THINK THE FOLLOWING ADDITIONAL AREAS SHOULD BE LOOKED AT TO ASSESS PARISH VIABILITY.

Finances (Need Archdiocesan Support) 4 1 2 1 1 15 1 3 4 3 4 1

Vocations 4 2 7 3 3 5 4

Women in Ministries 4 1 2 1 2 2 1

Finances (Consider Needs Of The Poor Parishes) 1 1 3 4 5 4 4 2 6 2 2 15 3 3 6 2

Deacons (More Involvement) 3 1 2 3 1 5 4 1 2 4 2 4

Economics (Impact On Community) 3 1 3 1 3 6 1 6 4 3 4

International Priests (Dialects Difficult To Understand) 3 1 1 4 2 1 2 1 2

Internet (Social Networking) 3 1 1 1 1 3 2

Pastor (Positive) 3 3 1 2 1 2 4 1 3 1 2

NM CH EM SM WM NWB NEB EB SB S.I. Y SS CW NW/P R O D U S

RESPONSE TO QUESTION #10I THINK THE FOLLOWING ADDITIONAL AREAS SHOULD BE LOOKED AT TO ASSESS PARISH VIABILITY.

Educating Catholics (Catechizing) 2 1 2 1 3 1 1 9 2 1 8 3 7 6 2 1

Finances (Second Collections - Objection To Sending Money To Other Countries - Keep Money Local)

2 4 1 2 1 1 6 1 2

Finances (Reduce Expenses) 2 1 2 1 2 8 1 4 8 2 5 7 3

Media (Impact On Social Values) 2 4 2 3 1 1 1 1 1

Parish Councils (Need Parish Councils) 2 2 2 2 1 3 2 3 3 2

Young Families (Children's Mass) 2 3 4 3 3 1 11 4 10 4 2 14 2 3

Finances (Parish Is Self-supporting - We're OK) 1 1 6 1 7 1 3 14 4 2 5 7 11 2

Schools Negative (Financial Concerns) 1 1 1 3 4 3 2 2 1 1

Declining Number Of Clergy 1 1 2 1 5 1 6 1 2 2 1 2

NM CH EM SM WM NWB NEB EB SB S.I. Y SS CW NW/P R O D U S

RESPONSE TO QUESTION #10I THINK THE FOLLOWING ADDITIONAL AREAS SHOULD BE LOOKED AT TO ASSESS PARISH VIABILITY.

Diocesan Leadership 1 2 3 1 5 3 1 2 2

Priest (More Availability) 1 4 5 2 4 1 1 1

Finances (Lack Knowledge Of Financial Issues) 1 1 1 6 2 3 8 2 5 6 5

Parish (Our Paris Has Signs Of Growth) 1 1 2 2 2 4 3 1 1

Distance Between Suburban Parishes 12 22 9 26 28 24 18

Regulations (Too Rigid) 1 1 5 3 4 4 2 1

Religious Women and Men (More Involvement) 1 3 2

RESPONSES TO SURVEYS BY PARISHIONERSALL VICARIATES

STRONGLY AGREE AGREE DISAGREE STRONGLY

DISAGREENOT

APPLICABLE

QUESTION # 1 I am aware of the current situation facing the Archdiocese, particularly with such issues as the decline in Church attendance, shortage of priests, decreased financial stability, etc. For me, this is a serious issue. 55.23% 40.27% 3.00% 1.50%

QUESTION # 2 I recognize the reality that some parishes will have to be closed or merged if the mission of the Archdiocese is to remain viable. 22.54% 53.83% 15.29% 8.35%

QUESTION # 3 To determine parish viability, I believe it is important to look at parish weekday and Sunday Massattendance. 31.61% 55.43% 10.28% 2.67%

QUESTION # 4 To determine parish viability, I believe it is important to look at parish sacramental, i.e., howbaptisms, communions, marriages, funerals, etc. 26.50% 54.99% 15.48% 3.03%

QUESTION # 5 To determine parish viability, I believe it is important to look at parish programs, i.e., religious education, RCIA, outreach to the poor, etc. 33.26% 55.93% 8.51% 2.29%

QUESTION # 6 To determine parish viability, you should look at significant changes in the Catholic populationof parishes. 29.04% 56.89% 11.46% 2.61%

QUESTION # 7 To determine parish viability, you should examine if parish revenue is sufficient to support parish ministries, Archdiocesan programs, and ordinary operating expenses. 27.77% 55.30% 13.57% 3.36%

QUESTION # 8 For parish viability, you should also examine if parish revenue is sufficient to support its priests and members of its pastoral staff. 27.18% 57.48% 12.61% 2.73%

QUESTION # 9 To determine parish viability, I feel it is important to know if a parish has a consistent operating deficit or owes money for unpaid bills to outside vendors or to the Archdiocese. 27.83% 56.20% 12.96% 3.01%

QUESTION #10 I think the following additional areas should be looked at to assess parish viability Individual comments received from parishioners were tabulatedQUESTION #10 I think the following additional areas should be looked at to assess parish viability

QUESTION # 11 I believe that if a parish has to close or merge, it is important to investigate whether the pastoral ministries of that parish can be served by a neighboring parish. 40.41% 51.17% 5.83% 2.60%

QUESTION # 12 If a parish has to close or merge, I believe the parish council should be consulted. 47.96% 46.65% 4.20% 1.19%

QUESTION # 13 If a parish has to close or merge, I believe the finance council should be consulted. 44.63% 49.48% 4.60% 1.29%

QUESTION # 14 If a parish has to close or merge, I think the "Making All Things New" committee should assistthe pastor to create and develop a response on behalf of the parish. 41.74% 50.16% 5.81% 2.29%

QUESTION # 15 An Archdiocesan advisory panel should review the responses of parishes that couldpotentially close or merge and provide their opinion to the Archbishop. 42.51% 48.61% 6.37% 2.50%

QUESTION # 16 I think there are too many parishes in our area. Some could be closed or merged without presenting a great inconvenience to people. 6.97% 17.60% 44.08% 31.35%

QUESTION # 17 I have confidence that, in the end, by God's grace and our good efforts, the Church will not only "get through" but continue to grow. 52.30% 40.18% 5.24% 2.20% 0.07%

Individual comments received from parishioners were tabulated