LISTING OF CITATIONS - ABERDEEN CITY VALUATION …...noor ahmed premier tandoori ltd premier...
Transcript of LISTING OF CITATIONS - ABERDEEN CITY VALUATION …...noor ahmed premier tandoori ltd premier...
16/03/2018 Page 1 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation
LISTING OF CITATIONS - ABERDEEN CITY VALUATION APPEAL COMMITTEE
Hearing on 27th June 2018 at 10.00 am in Committee Room 3, Woodhill House, Westburn Road, Aberdeen
Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
84240/58743
2526/53061
2529/54629
2529/56061
2657/59033
2664/59076
2664/62680
2668/59075
2669/55969
2670/58886
2679/63766
33185/54643
39276/54966
T
T
O
O
P
P
O
P
T
T
P
T
T
13,500
58,000
41,500
41,500
24,250
19,250
19,250
49,000
75,000
40,500
27,250
18,000
82,500
13,500
58,000
41,500
41,500
24,250
19,250
19,250
49,000
75,000
40,500
27,250
18,000
82,500
CAFE
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
CAFE
SHOP
SHOP
OFFICE
SUPERMARKET
CAFE
SHOP
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
SAINSBURYS LOCAL
UNIT 2
SMITHFIELD ROAD
13 ROSE STREET
19 ROSE STREET
19 ROSE STREET
464 UNION STREET
478 UNION STREET
478 UNION STREET
484 UNION STREET
492 UNION STREET
496 UNION STREET
510 UNION STREET
28 ADELPHI
QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
TEJJ BUSINESS SOLUTIONS LTD
NOOR AHMED
PREMIER TANDOORI LTD
PREMIER TANDOORI LTD
PATTERSONS OF ABERDEEN
NORWARD PROPERTIES LTD
JOHNSONS APPARELMASTER LTD
NORWARD PROPERTIES LTD
SAINSBURY'S SUPERMARKETS LTD
STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD
BLACK & LIZARS LTD
MARK CAVANAGH
THE RESTAURANT GROUP
T/A CAFE CREO
PER A C MORRISON & RICHARDS
PER A C MORRISON & RICHARDS
PER G L HEARN
C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP
T/A CHIQUITO'SPER GERALD EVE
RYDEN LLP
RYDEN LLP
RYDEN LLP
RYDEN LLP
RYDEN LLP
G L HEARN LIMITED
RYDEN LLP
CBRE LTD
MONTAGU EVANS
J & E SHEPHERD
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
16/03/2018 Page 2 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
39276/62723
80932/53427
80932/62727
38161/62728
37010/53024
37010/62726
37009/58270
37009/62724
37008/53448
37008/62725
3955/56442
3955/61775
3957/64112
3958/64191
P
T
P
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
T
P
82,500
79,000
79,000
56,000
85,000
85,000
75,000
75,000
110,000
110,000
18,000
18,000
29,750
32,500
82,500
79,000
79,000
56,000
85,000
85,000
75,000
75,000
110,000
110,000
18,000
18,000
29,750
32,500
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
UNIT 2
UNIT 6
UNIT 6
UNIT 7
UNIT 5
UNIT 5
UNIT 4
UNIT 4
UNIT 3
UNIT 3
QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK
QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK
QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK
QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK
QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK
QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK
QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK
QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK
QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK
QUEEN'S LINKS LEISURE PARK
17 UNION STREET
17 UNION STREET
23 UNION STREET
25 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED
TRAGUS GROUP
PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED
PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED
THE RESTAURANT GROUP
PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED
PIZZA HUT (UK) LTD
PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED
TGI FRIDAYS UK LTD
PAVILION PROPERTY TRUSTEES LIMITED
DUNASKIN PROPERTIES LTD
MARTIN THE NEWSAGENT LTD
VISIT SCOTLAND
ELINOR J ANDERSON
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
T/A FRANKIE & BENNY'S
PER MARGARET CRAWFORD
PER PETERKINS
PER GERALD EVE
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
GERALD EVE LLP
DALTON WARNER DAVIS
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
GRAHAM & SIBBALD
BURNETT & REID
16/03/2018 Page 3 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
3959/62713
3961/54630
3961/58556
3962/58559
3976/55492
3976/63687
30225/58332
30225/59074
4009/56408
4009/61916
87635/53067
87635/55683
86487/53464
4011/56500
T
P
T
T
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
T
24,500
23,000
23,000
26,750
68,500
68,500
25,000
25,000
33,500
33,500
27,500
27,500
33,000
46,000
24,500
23,000
23,000
26,750
68,500
68,500
25,000
25,000
33,500
33,500
27,500
27,500
33,000
46,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
BETTING OFFICE
SHOP
27 UNION STREET
31 UNION STREET
31 UNION STREET
33 UNION STREET
43 UNION STREET
43 UNION STREET
47 UNION STREET
47 UNION STREET
49 UNION STREET
49 UNION STREET
51 UNION STREET
51 UNION STREET
53 UNION STREET
55 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
INSTANT CASH LOANS LTD
M C LEISURE LTD
BRITISH HEART FOUNDATION
AMPLIFON LIMITED
POUNDSTRETCHER PROPERTIES LIMITED
PRESTIGIC HOLDINGS LIMITED
FIRST ABERDEEN LTD
NORWARD PROPERTIES LTD
SCOTTISH MIDLAND CO-OP
DONGEM SUPPLIES LTD
CCHG LTD
FLOWER OF SCOTLAND LTD
PADDY POWER BOOKMAKERS
GREGGS PLC
PER A B ROBB
RETIREMENT BENEFITS SCHEME
PER A C MORRISON & RICHARDS
T/A VAPORIZED
T/A BAKERS OVEN NORTH
PER SAM TRUSTEES LIMITED
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
A B ROBB
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
MONTAGU EVANS
RYDEN LLP
GVA
RYDEN LLP
RYDEN LLP
RYDEN LLP
CARNDEARG CONSULTANTS T/A PCA
RYDEN LLP
GRIFFIN WEBSTER PARTNERSHIP
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
16/03/2018 Page 4 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
52545/56111
53996/53046
54222/52992
54222/56123
53463/56035
4598/53032
4625/59247
38479/55462
38745/62092
38481/53037
31127/64096
31127/64663
31128/58251
31128/64664
T
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
T
T
T
P
T
P
275,000
156,000
18,500
18,500
46,000
33,250
33,000
63,500
57,000
15,000
29,750
29,750
90,000
90,000
275,000
156,000
18,500
18,500
46,000
33,250
33,000
63,500
57,000
15,000
29,750
29,750
90,000
90,000
SHOP
SHOP
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
SUPERMARKET
RESTAURANT
CAFE
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
UNIT 10
UNIT 13
UNIT 15
CABERSTONE HOUSE
THE ACADEMY
THE ACADEMY
THE ACADEMY
UNIT 1
UNIT 1
UNIT 2
UNIT 2
57 UNION STREET
57 UNION STREET
136 CAUSEWAYEND
136 CAUSEWAYEND
138 CAUSEWAYEND
47 BELMONT STREET
24 BELMONT STREET
BELMONT STREET
BELMONT STREET
BELMONT STREET
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
SPORTSDIRECT.COM RETAIL LTD
POUNDLAND LTD
MATTHEW NG & AMY NG
FIRST CLASS DINING LTD
MATTHEW NG & AMY NG
PIZZA EXPRESS (RESTAURANTS) LTD
ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL
NANDO'S CHICKENLAND LIMITED
JACK WILLS LTD
COSTA LTD
MR PRETZEL (UK) RETAIL LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
VODAFONE LIMITED
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
PER GERALD EVE
T/A MANCHURIAN
PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM
CBRE LTD
GERALD EVE LLP
RYDEN LLP
RYDEN LLP
RYDEN LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
RYDEN LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
WYMRE
GERALD EVE LLP
CVS
ERIC YOUNG & CO
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
ERIC YOUNG & CO
16/03/2018 Page 5 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
31130/59065
31130/64665
31133/63170
31133/64666
31211/56039
31211/64667
31135/56436
31135/64668
31136/62361
31136/64669
31137/55896
31137/64670
31138/64671
31816/61843
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
118,000
118,000
134,000
134,000
264,000
264,000
135,000
135,000
138,000
138,000
111,000
111,000
210,000
122,000
118,000
118,000
134,000
134,000
264,000
264,000
135,000
135,000
138,000
138,000
111,000
111,000
210,000
122,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
UNIT 3
UNIT 3
UNIT 4
UNIT 4
UNIT 5 & 33
UNIT 5 & 33
UNIT 6
UNIT 6
UNIT 7
UNIT 7
UNIT 8
UNIT 8
UNIT 9 & 10
UNIT 11
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
TELEFONICA UK LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
THE CARPHONE WAREHOUSE
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
MONSOON ACCESSORIZE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
CHISHOLM & HUNTER
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ARCADIA GROUP PLC
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
SWAROVSKI UK LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
KURT GEIGER
T/A WALLIS FASHION GROUP LTDPER SGP PROPERTY SERVICES LTD
CLUTTONS LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
CBRE LTD
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
JONES LANG LASALLE
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
MONTAGU EVANS
16/03/2018 Page 6 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
31816/64672
33773/64125
33773/64674
33506/62509
33506/64675
33531/63779
33531/64676
32891/56038
32891/64677
31726/62831
31726/64678
31240/56649
31240/64679
87416/53815
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
122,000
30,750
30,750
58,000
58,000
57,500
57,500
52,000
52,000
73,500
73,500
126,000
126,000
3,000
122,000
30,750
30,750
58,000
58,000
57,500
57,500
52,000
52,000
73,500
73,500
126,000
126,000
3,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
STANCEPHOTO-ME
UNIT 11
UNIT 12A
UNIT 12A
UNIT 13
UNIT 13
UNIT 14
UNIT 14
UNIT 15
UNIT 15
UNIT 16
UNIT 16
UNIT 17-18
UNIT 17-18
GEORGE STREET EXIT
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
TGFS (THE GOOD FOOD SHOP) LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
RADLEY & CO
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
JOJO MAMAN BEBE LIMITED
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
MONSOON ACCESSORIZE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
PHASE EIGHT
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
HOBBS LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC
ERIC YOUNG & CO
MONTAGU EVANS
ERIC YOUNG & CO
FREDERICK HOLT & COMPANY
ERIC YOUNG & CO
F G BURNETT LTD
ERIC YOUNG & CO
CBRE LTD
ERIC YOUNG & CO
FREDERICK HOLT & COMPANY
ERIC YOUNG & CO
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
16/03/2018 Page 7 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
87416/64650
31245/62366
31245/64680
31247/64486
31247/64681
31142/62704
31142/64685
31143/58653
31143/64686
31145/58651
31145/64687
31146/58652
31146/64688
31212/62359
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
3,000
409,000
409,000
380,000
380,000
177,000
177,000
159,000
159,000
137,000
137,000
159,000
159,000
347,000
3,000
409,000
409,000
380,000
380,000
177,000
177,000
159,000
159,000
137,000
137,000
159,000
159,000
347,000
STANCE
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
PHOTO-MEGEORGE STREET EXIT
UNIT 19A
UNIT 19A
UNIT 19B
UNIT 19B
UNIT 20
UNIT 20
UNIT 21
UNIT 21
UNIT 22
UNIT 22
UNIT 23
UNIT 23
UNIT 24
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
REDCASTLE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
RIVER ISLAND CLOTHING CO LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
AURORA
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
AURORA
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
AURORA
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
AURORA
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ARCADIA GROUP PLC
PER ARCADIA GROUP LTD
T/A OASIS
T/A WAREHOUSE
T/A COAST
T/A KAREN MILLEN
T/A BURTON RETAIL
T/A TOP SHOP
PER SGP PROPERTY SERVICES LTD
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
16/03/2018 Page 8 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
31212/64689
31147/62513
31147/64690
31148/59053
31148/65484
31149/58809
31149/64692
31129/63198
31129/64693
31131/63645
31131/64694
31132/56622
31132/64695
31134/64696
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
347,000
198,000
198,000
68,000
68,000
110,000
110,000
90,500
90,500
125,000
125,000
106,000
106,000
113,000
347,000
198,000
198,000
68,000
68,000
110,000
110,000
90,500
90,500
125,000
125,000
106,000
106,000
113,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
UNIT 24
UNIT 25
UNIT 25
UNIT 26A
UNIT 26A
UNIT 26B
UNIT 26B
UNIT 27
UNIT 27
UNIT 28
UNIT 28
UNIT 29
UNIT 29
UNIT 30
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
THE DISNEY STORE
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
SMIGGLE UK LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
SIGNET GROUP PLC
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
WARREN JAMES JEWELLERS LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
THOMAS COOK RETAIL LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
THORNTONS PLC
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
UK PROPERTY
ERIC YOUNG & CO
WYMRE
ERIC YOUNG & CO
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
DELOITTE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
WYMRE
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
16/03/2018 Page 9 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
31134/67040
31139/53034
31139/64697
31140/63563
31140/64701
31157/64702
31630/58765
31630/64703
31150/56102
31150/64704
31151/64705
31631/64706
31154/64491
31154/64707
T
T
P
T
P
P
T
P
T
P
P
P
T
P
113,000
233,000
233,000
53,500
53,500
48,750
48,000
48,000
57,000
57,000
63,000
96,000
112,000
112,000
113,000
233,000
233,000
53,500
53,500
48,750
48,000
48,000
57,000
57,000
63,000
96,000
112,000
112,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
UNIT 30
UNIT 31-32
UNIT 31-32
UNIT 34
UNIT 34
UNIT 35
UNIT 36
UNIT 36
UNIT 37
UNIT 37
UNIT 38
UNIT 39
UNIT 44-45
UNIT 44-45
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
EE LTD
VISION EXPRESS (UK) LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
AG RETAIL CARDS LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
TOBAR GROUP TRADING LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
BAKER ACQUISITIONS LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
LAURA ASHLEY LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
T/A CLINTON CARDS
PER DTZ
G L HEARN LIMITED
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
KNIGHT FRANK LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
16/03/2018 Page 10 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
31155/64708
63445/53041
63445/64641
31742/64195
31742/64682
84399/64646
86950/64644
87222/53822
87222/64651
83103/59248
83103/64709
87581/61849
87581/64645
87668/52971
P
T
P
T
P
P
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
49,000
60,000
60,000
99,000
99,000
1,000
3,000
3,000
3,000
50,000
50,000
18,000
18,000
18,000
49,000
60,000
60,000
99,000
99,000
1,000
3,000
3,000
3,000
50,000
50,000
18,000
18,000
18,000
SHOP
CAFE
CAFE
SHOP
SHOP
STANCES
STANCES
STANCE
STANCE
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
KIDDIE RIDES
COCA-COLA
PHOTO-ME
PHOTO-ME
UPPER LEVEL
UPPER LEVEL
FUEL JUICE BAR
FUEL JUICE BAR
MILLIE'S COOKIES
UNIT 46
ATRIUM
ATRIUM
UNIT 19
UNIT 19
LOCH STREET CAR PARK
LOCH STREET EXIT
LOCH STREET EXIT
LOCH STREET EXIT
BON ACCORD INDOOR BOWLING CENTRE
BON ACCORD INDOOR BOWLING CENTRE
LOWER MALL
LOWER MALL
LOWER MALL
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
COSTA LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
JIGSAW
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
FUEL JUICE BARS LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
MILLIE'S COOKIES LTD
PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM
C/O JONES LANG LASALLE
ERIC YOUNG & CO
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
CVS
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
RYDEN LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ALLSOP LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
GERALD EVE LLP
16/03/2018 Page 11 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
87668/64649
84032/56579
84032/64655
84033/56132
84033/64656
84034/62717
84034/64657
84035/56101
84035/64658
89931/64647
82764/64653
82765/64654
87086/64643
87181/64648
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
P
P
P
P
18,000
93,000
93,000
58,500
58,500
68,000
68,000
90,000
90,000
500
18,000
18,000
18,000
8,000
18,000
93,000
93,000
58,500
58,500
68,000
68,000
90,000
90,000
500
18,000
18,000
18,000
8,000
STANCE
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCES
MILLIE'S COOKIES
KIDDIE RIDES
RMU 2
RMU 3
C R SMITH
KIDDIE RIDES
LOWER MALL
FOOD UNIT 1
FOOD UNIT 1
FOOD UNIT 2
FOOD UNIT 2
FOOD UNIT 3
FOOD UNIT 3
FOOD UNIT 4
FOOD UNIT 4
LOWER MALL
UPPER MALL
LOWER MALL
UPPER MALL
UPPER MALL
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
DI MAGGIO'S FOODCOURT LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD
YO! SUSHI UK LIMITED
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD
ED'S EASY DINER GROUP LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD
PRET A MANGER
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ERIC YOUNG & CO
MONTAGU EVANS
ERIC YOUNG & CO
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
ERIC YOUNG & CO
MONTAGU EVANS
ERIC YOUNG & CO
CBRE LTD
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
16/03/2018 Page 12 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
72205/54029
72205/64652
4711/56844
54351/64216
4807/61813
4807/64753
4811/64756
36045/54596
4898/53754
4913/56377
38776/54352
38776/58857
81623/61023
81623/62996
T
P
P
P
T
P
P
P
P
P
P
T
P
T
18,000
18,000
25,250
37,500
38,250
38,250
178,000
15,500
19,000
18,000
42,000
42,000
23,500
23,500
18,000
18,000
25,250
37,500
38,250
38,250
178,000
15,500
19,000
18,000
42,000
42,000
23,500
23,500
STANCE
STANCE
SHOP
HOTEL
SHOP ETC
SHOP ETC
SUPERMARKET
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
SKY RETAIL
SKY RETAIL
SUITE B & E
SUITE B & E
LOWER MALL
LOWER MALL
THE COFFEE HOUSE HOTEL
UNIT 1-2
CAFE 52
PATAGONIAN HEIGHTS
PATAGONIAN HEIGHTS
BON ACCORD CENTRE
BON ACCORD CENTRE
19 CORRECTION WYND
1 GAELIC LANE
1 GEORGE STREET
1-5 GEORGE STREET
107 GEORGE STREET
GREEN
52 GREEN
12-16 GUILD STREET
80-82 HUNTLY STREET
80-82 HUNTLY STREET
15 BELMONT STREET
15 BELMONT STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
SKY RETAIL STORES LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ELINOR J ANDERSON
WILLIAM YOUNG ( ANTIQUES) LTD
L'OCCITANE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
CARLTON ROCK LTD
STEVEN BOTHWELL
MICHAEL WOO & SUE WAH LI WOO
MRS MARJORIE DU PON
AMORE SCOTLAND LTD
ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL
BALAMURALI BALAJI
PER PETERKINS
T/A MI AMORE
PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM
T/A SHRI BHEEMA'S
WYMRE
ERIC YOUNG & CO
J & E SHEPHERD
J & E SHEPHERD
MONTAGU EVANS
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
A B ROBB
SAVILLS
RYDEN LLP
16/03/2018 Page 13 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
5025/64171
5119/52873
5119/55678
33780/54384
33780/63452
39610/54216
33242/52917
30435/58747
5242/58532
88496/58840
88668/52970
88718/55948
76624/61025
76624/67364
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
P
T
T
T
T
P
T
48,250
42,750
42,750
19,500
19,500
34,250
48,000
72,500
110,000
168,000
157,000
195,000
7,000
7,000
48,250
42,750
42,750
19,500
19,500
34,250
48,000
72,500
110,000
168,000
157,000
195,000
7,000
7,000
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
CAFE
CAFE
RESTAURANT
SHOP
FUNERAL REST ROOM
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
STANCE
STANCE
THE STAGE DOOR
ANDERSON HOUSE
UNIT 3
UNIT 2
UNIT 4
7 LITTLE BELMONT STREET
37 NETHERKIRKGATE
37 NETHERKIRKGATE
14 NETHERKIRKGATE
14 NETHERKIRKGATE
26 NORTH SILVER STREET
ROSE STREET
44 ROSE STREET
3 ST NICHOLAS STREET
7 ST NICHOLAS STREET
7 ST NICHOLAS STREET
7 ST NICHOLAS STREET
ST NICHOLAS STREET
ST NICHOLAS STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
L A GODINI & MRS GODINI
THE CITY CAFE & RESTAURANT
DRUMROSSIE LAND DEVELOPMENT CO LTD
THE CAT IN THE WINDOW CAFE LTD
ALEXANDER W ADAM &
QUATRO VENTURE LTD
PLENDERLEATH RUNCIE LLP
CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD
TUI UK LTD
SCHUH LTD
FIVE GUYS JV LTD
TSB BANK PLC
ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL
BAHAA EDIN MAHMOUD
JAMES G ADAM
FUNERAL CARE
T/A THOMSON
PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM
ALLIED SURVEYORS SCOTLAND PLC
RYDEN LLP
RYDEN LLP
F G BURNETT LTD
RYDEN LLP
A B ROBB
RYDEN LLP
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE
GERALD EVE LLP
CBRE LTD
RYDEN LLP
16/03/2018 Page 14 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
81003/59457
81003/67365
5249/55975
5249/64718
82392/64728
5250/55477
5250/64719
38984/53424
38984/64720
5252/64721
5253/58750
5253/64722
5254/63763
5254/64723
P
T
T
P
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
P
T
P
7,000
7,000
169,000
169,000
20,000
110,000
110,000
73,000
73,000
73,000
72,500
72,500
150,000
150,000
7,000
7,000
169,000
169,000
20,000
110,000
110,000
73,000
73,000
73,000
72,500
72,500
150,000
150,000
STANCE
STANCE
SUPERMARKET
SUPERMARKET
STORE
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
BASEMENT
UNIT W1
UNIT W1
UNIT W1
UNIT W2
UNIT W2
UNIT W3
UNIT W3
UNIT W4
UNIT W5
UNIT W5
UNIT W6
UNIT W6
ST NICHOLAS STREET
ST NICHOLAS STREET
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
ABERDEEN CITY COUNCIL
BAHAA EDIN MAHMOUD
SAINSBURY'S SUPERMARKETS LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
SPORTSWIFT LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
HUTCHISON 3G UK LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
SIGNET GROUP PLC
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
KAST RETAIL LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
PER ASSET MANAGEMENT TEAM
PER G L HEARN
T/A CARD FACTORY
PER GERALD EVE
T/A QUIZ
RYDEN LLP
CBRE LTD
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
BEACON BROOKE
ERIC YOUNG & CO
16/03/2018 Page 15 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
5255/58953
5255/64724
5256/56592
5256/64725
5257/53304
5257/64726
40572/58959
40572/64727
5258/57905
5258/65483
5259/54445
5259/64712
5260/58746
5260/64713
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
72,500
72,500
92,500
92,500
33,500
33,500
57,500
57,500
181,000
181,000
161,000
161,000
93,500
93,500
72,500
72,500
92,500
92,500
33,500
33,500
57,500
57,500
181,000
181,000
161,000
161,000
93,500
93,500
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
UNIT W7
UNIT W7
UNIT W8
UNIT W8
UNIT W9A
UNIT W9A
UNIT W9B
UNIT W9B
UNIT E1
UNIT E1
UNIT E2-E3
UNIT E2-E3
UNIT E4
UNIT E4
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
CLAIRE'S ACCESSORIES UK LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
THE BODY SHOP INTERNATIONAL PLC
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
THE PERFUME SHOP LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
SUPERDRUG STORES PLC
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
OFFICE HOLDINGS
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
HOLLAND & BARRETT RETAIL LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP
LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON
ERIC YOUNG & CO
BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE
ERIC YOUNG & CO
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
MONTAGU EVANS
ERIC YOUNG & CO
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
16/03/2018 Page 16 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
5261/61802
5261/64714
38071/62640
38071/64716
83747/55479
83747/64715
5265/62363
5265/64717
5266/62780
5266/64710
87223/53818
87223/64732
87477/64733
34621/64353
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
219,000
219,000
170,000
170,000
291,000
291,000
162,000
162,000
18,000
18,000
4,500
4,500
18,000
31,250
219,000
219,000
170,000
170,000
291,000
291,000
162,000
162,000
18,000
18,000
4,500
4,500
18,000
31,250
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
STANCES
STANCES
STANCE
CAFE
UNIT E5
UNIT E5
UNIT E8
UNIT E8
UNIT E6
UNIT E6
UNIT E9
UNIT E9
(KIOSK)
(KIOSK)
PHOTO-ME & CANDY VAN
PHOTO-ME & CANDY VAN
SCOOPY DOO
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
ST NICHOLAS CENTRE
13 THISTLE STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
W H SMITH GROUP PLC
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
CURRY'S & PC WORLD LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
H & M HENNES & MAURITZ (UK) LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ARCADIA GROUP PLC
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
TIMPSON LIMITED
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE (NO 2) LTD
FOODSTORY LTD
PER G L HEARN MANAGEMENT LTD
PER DIXONS GROUP STORES
T/A MISS SELFRIDGE LTD
T/A WATCH WORKSHOP
PROPERTY LEDGERS RATES/ACCOUNTS
PER SGP PROPERTY SERVICES LTD
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
MONTAGU EVANS
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
16/03/2018 Page 17 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
5382/53142
5382/53423
5383/58834
5385/55983
5391/55982
5391/64490
5400/53425
5400/54798
5401/64505
31639/61801
31640/57848
5403/61705
5404/61704
5405/58534
P
T
T
T
T
P
T
P
T
T
T
T
T
T
82,000
82,000
42,500
92,000
215,000
215,000
82,000
82,000
105,000
155,000
174,000
79,000
73,000
81,000
82,000
82,000
42,500
92,000
215,000
215,000
82,000
82,000
105,000
155,000
174,000
79,000
73,000
81,000
CAFE
CAFE
SHOP
SHOP
BANK
BANK
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
73 UNION STREET
73 UNION STREET
81 UNION STREET
87 UNION STREET
95 UNION STREET
95 UNION STREET
105 UNION STREET
105 UNION STREET
107 UNION STREET
111 UNION STREET
117 UNION STREET
121 UNION STREET
123 UNION STREET
125 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
RRSG PROPERTIES LTD
NERO HOLDINGS LTD
LUSH RETAIL LTD
BEACONSFIELD FOOTWEAR LTD
HSBC BANK PLC
ZURICH ASSURANCE LTD
HUTCHISON 3G UK LTD
DEEDREAM LIMITED
JD SPORTS FASHION PLC
SHOE ZONE LTD
CRAIGTON FOODS LTD
AURUM HOLDINGS LTD
C & J CLARK INTERNATIONAL LTD
CANCER RESEARCH UK
PER CB RICHARD ELLIS
PER WORKMAN & PARTNERS
PER GERALD EVE
C/O TAYLORS INDUSTRIAL SERVICES LTD
C/O COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
RYDEN LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
GERALD EVE LLP
CBRE LTD
G L HEARN LIMITED
GERALD EVE LLP
RYDEN LLP
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
G L HEARN LIMITED
MONTAGU EVANS
LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON
G L HEARN LIMITED
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
16/03/2018 Page 18 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
5405/67029
48975/53971
48975/67028
5406/63765
5406/67038
5410/56623
5413/62620
5414/57726
5414/66961
5415/57729
5415/58737
5416/57730
5417/57731
5417/63777
P
T
P
P
T
T
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
81,000
35,250
35,250
73,500
73,500
60,000
47,750
96,000
96,000
50,000
50,000
52,000
57,000
57,000
81,000
35,250
35,250
73,500
73,500
60,000
47,750
96,000
96,000
50,000
50,000
52,000
57,000
57,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
UNIT 1A
UNIT 1
UNIT 1
UNIT 2
UNIT 2
UNIT 3
UNIT 4
UNIT 4
1ST FLOOR & 2ND FLOOR
1ST FLOOR & 2ND FLOOR
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
125 UNION STREET
125 UNION STREET
125 UNION STREET
127 UNION STREET
127 UNION STREET
131 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
THE UNION STREET TRUST
BRAVISSIMO LTD
STAINTON CAPITAL (FOXHOUND) LTD
CB RICHARD ELLIS
EE LTD
THORNTONS PLC
DUNCAN & TODD LTD
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
THE WORKS STORES LTD
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
HOLLAND & BARRETT RETAIL LTD
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
KAST RETAIL LTD
C/O TEMPLE PROPERTY SOLUTIONS LTD
PER COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
COLLECTIVE INVESTORS LIMITED
T/A QUIZ
RYDEN LLP
WYMRE
RYDEN LLP
CBRE LTD
G L HEARN LIMITED
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
GRAHAM & SIBBALD
ERIC YOUNG & CO
LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
BEACON BROOKE
16/03/2018 Page 19 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
5419/57732
5419/62554
5421/57734
5421/58696
5422/57735
5423/56501
5423/57736
38974/57737
38974/63564
35474/53047
35474/57738
5427/55476
5427/57739
5428/57740
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
T
P
T
P
P
274,000
274,000
60,000
60,000
47,250
58,500
58,500
108,000
108,000
117,000
117,000
89,500
89,500
33,750
274,000
274,000
60,000
60,000
47,250
58,500
58,500
108,000
108,000
117,000
117,000
89,500
89,500
33,750
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP ETC
SHOP ETC
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
UNIT 5-6
UNIT 5-6
UNIT 8
UNIT 8
UNIT 9
UNIT 10
UNIT 10
UNIT 11-12
UNIT 11-12
UNIT 13
UNIT 13
UNIT 18
UNIT 18
UNIT 19
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
ARGOS LTD
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
SCHUH LTD
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
GREGGS PLC
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
AG RETAIL CARDS LTD
SUPERDRUG STORES PLC
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
SPORTSWIFT LTD
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
T/A CLINTON CARDS
T/A CARD FACTORY
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
KNIGHT FRANK LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
GERALD EVE LLP
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
16/03/2018 Page 20 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
5428/58818
5429/57741
5429/58966
5430/57742
5430/58740
5431/57743
5431/64514
5433/57744
5434/57745
5434/62777
82845/57747
49909/57748
5438/57749
5438/63200
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
P
P
P
T
33,750
41,250
41,250
33,250
33,250
94,000
94,000
21,000
28,750
28,750
27,500
37,500
35,500
35,500
33,750
41,250
41,250
33,250
33,250
94,000
94,000
21,000
28,750
28,750
27,500
37,500
35,500
35,500
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
UNIT 19
UNIT 20
UNIT 20
UNIT 21
UNIT 21
UNIT 22-25
UNIT 22-25
UNIT 26
UNIT 27
UNIT 27
UNIT 28
UNIT 29
UNIT 30
UNIT 30
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
SIGNET GROUP PLC
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
CLAIRE'S ACCESSORIES UK LTD
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
SIGNET GROUP PLC
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
TRESPASS EUROPE LTD
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
TIMPSON LTD
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
WARREN JAMES JEWELLERS LTD
T/A ERNEST JONES
T/A H SAMUEL
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
DALTON WARNER DAVIS
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
DELOITTE LLP
16/03/2018 Page 21 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
88488/57756
51844/57754
88719/57757
51847/57759
88281/57753
88281/63448
64284/57751
72223/55385
72223/57763
81779/57758
81780/57760
82822/57762
82440/53821
82440/57761
P
P
P
P
P
T
P
T
P
P
P
P
T
P
15,000
15,000
15,000
15,000
6,000
6,000
15,000
15,000
15,000
15,000
15,000
6,000
6,000
6,000
15,000
15,000
15,000
15,000
6,000
6,000
15,000
15,000
15,000
15,000
15,000
6,000
6,000
6,000
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCES
STANCES
STANCES
IMAGES2IMAGES
BEST GIFT
INSTEP FASHION
KIOSK
AMAZON LOCKERS
AMAZON LOCKERS
ZUMO
SKY TV
SKY TV
KAAYA
KIOSK
RIDE ON ENTERTAINMENT
PHOTO-ME
PHOTO-ME
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
TRINITY CENTRE
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
155 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
AMAZON UK SERVICES LTD
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
YOU ME TV LIMITED
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
FAO RICHARD PRICE
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON
ERIC YOUNG & CO
WYMRE
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
ERIC YOUNG & CO
16/03/2018 Page 22 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
82441/57755
5441/57764
5442/57765
5442/62702
5446/57766
35566/56540
35566/64512
33052/52827
33052/56624
35567/56065
35567/63203
5452/61887
5474/63181
5475/55248
P
P
P
T
P
P
T
T
P
T
P
T
T
T
5,000
85,500
316,000
316,000
247,000
58,500
58,500
88,500
88,500
102,000
102,000
46,000
36,500
46,000
5,000
85,500
316,000
316,000
247,000
58,500
58,500
88,500
88,500
102,000
102,000
46,000
36,500
46,000
STANCES
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
BANK
BANK
SHOP
SHOP
BETTING OFFICE
COCA-COLATRINITY CENTRE
1 UNION BRIDGE
3-7 UNION BRIDGE
3-7 UNION BRIDGE
11 UNION BRIDGE
155 UNION STREET
UNION STREET
UNION STREET
UNION STREET
UNION STREET
159 UNION STREET
159 UNION STREET
161 UNION STREET
161 UNION STREET
163 UNION STREET
163 UNION STREET
46 UNION STREET
48 UNION STREET
50 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
WATERSTONES PLC
LSREF3 TIGER ABERDEEN S A R L
GREATER MANCHESTER PENSION FUND
BLACK OUTDOOR RETAIL
BOOTS UK LIMITED
GREATER MANCHESTER PENSION FUND
BARCLAYS BANK PLC
GREATER MANCHESTER PENSION FUND
CEX LTD
WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD
LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD
T/A WATERSTONES BOOKSHOP
FAO HEATHER RYDER
PER GERALD EVE LLP
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
ERIC YOUNG & CO
G L HEARN LIMITED
ERIC YOUNG & CO
MONTAGU EVANS
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
GERALD EVE LLP
MONTAGU EVANS
CBRE LTD
MONTAGU EVANS
ALLSOP LLP
G L HEARN LIMITED
MONTAGU EVANS
16/03/2018 Page 23 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
5476/56113
5479/54968
5482/61808
5482/64057
5484/56084
5485/56928
5486/56927
5486/62682
5487/58409
5488/58250
33082/59060
5490/54223
5496/64600
54143/54035
P
T
T
P
T
P
P
T
O
T
T
P
P
P
95,500
70,000
205,000
205,000
173,000
38,500
34,250
34,250
36,750
60,500
56,500
19,000
60,000
51,500
95,500
70,000
205,000
205,000
173,000
38,500
34,250
34,250
36,750
60,500
56,500
19,000
60,000
51,500
OFFICE
SHOP
BANK
BANK
BANK
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
52 UNION STREET
56 UNION STREET
62 UNION STREET
62 UNION STREET
78 UNION STREET
82 UNION STREET
86 UNION STREET
86 UNION STREET
88 UNION STREET
92 UNION STREET
98 UNION STREET
104 UNION STREET
114-116 UNION STREET
118 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
HALIFAX PLC
SPECSAVERS OPTICAL STORES LTD
CLYDESDALE BANK PLC
THE UNION STREET PARTNERSHIP
THE ROYAL BANK OF SCOTLAND GROUP
BRIDGEPORT ESTATES LTD
BRIDGEPORT ESTATES LTD
TIMPSON LIMITED
MICHAEL JAMES (JEWELLERS) LTD
VODAFONE LTD
TELEFONICA UK LTD
HELLISTER LTD
BEAVERBROOKS THE JEWELLERS LTD
MILVERTON PROPERTIES LTD
PER DTZ
PER AB ROBB LTD
CBRE LTD
GERALD EVE LLP
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
SMART & CO
GVA
WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED
WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED
G L HEARN LIMITED
381 CONSULTANCY
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
CLUTTONS LLP
A B ROBB
KENNEY MOORE
RYDEN LLP
16/03/2018 Page 24 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
54143/62515
5498/54429
5499/62087
5499/63224
5505/56926
5505/58377
5506/61783
40390/62711
5508/56650
5516/55661
5521/63335
5528/63706
5529/56689
5534/53039
T
T
P
T
P
T
T
T
T
P
T
P
P
T
51,500
155,000
35,000
35,000
33,500
33,500
29,000
47,000
88,000
124,000
74,000
87,000
94,000
57,000
51,500
155,000
35,000
35,000
33,500
33,500
29,000
47,000
88,000
124,000
74,000
87,000
94,000
57,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOWROOM
CAFE
118 UNION STREET
122 UNION STREET
122A UNION STREET
122A UNION STREET
128 UNION STREET
128 UNION STREET
130 UNION STREET
132 UNION STREET
136 UNION STREET
140 UNION STREET
152 UNION STREET
154A UNION STREET
156 UNION STREET
162 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
MOLTON BROWN
POUNDWORLD RETAIL TD
ESSON PENSION FUND
WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD
BRIDGEPORT ESTATES LTD
RAMSDENS FINANCIAL LTD
MARTIN THE NEWSAGENT LTD
INSTANT CASH LOANS LTD
ALL SAINTS RETAIL LTD
JAMIESON & CARRY
HERBEL NORTHERN LTD
BRAEFORTH LTD
SSE RETAIL LTD
NERO HOLDINGS LTD
PER ESSON PROPERTIES LTD
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
T/A THE MONEY SHOP
C/O SCOTCO RESTAURANTS LTD
PER MONTAGU EVANS LLP
FAO ESTATES SURVEYOR
DALTON WARNER DAVIS
PRESTON TAIT
RYDEN LLP
G L HEARN LIMITED
WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED
LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON
GERALD EVE LLP
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
GERALD EVE LLP
RYDEN LLP
HAMILTON CHARTERED SURVEYORS
MONTAGU EVANS
GERALD EVE LLP
16/03/2018 Page 25 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
5536/55202
5538/53882
5540/56604
5540/58022
5541/55250
5541/58023
5542/58024
5542/63295
5543/58025
5543/58549
5544/58028
5544/58772
5545/55970
5548/58957
T
T
T
P
T
P
P
T
P
T
P
T
T
T
44,750
91,000
41,250
41,250
46,000
46,000
44,000
44,000
45,250
45,250
260,000
260,000
84,500
61,000
44,750
91,000
41,250
41,250
46,000
46,000
44,000
44,000
45,250
45,250
260,000
260,000
84,500
61,000
BETTING OFFICE
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
BETTING OFFICE
BETTING OFFICE
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SUPERMARKET
SUPERMARKET
SUPERMARKET
CAFE
164 UNION STREET
172 UNION STREET
196 UNION STREET
196 UNION STREET
198 UNION STREET
198 UNION STREET
200 UNION STREET
200 UNION STREET
202 UNION STREET
202 UNION STREET
204 UNION STREET
204 UNION STREET
206 UNION STREET
208 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
DONE BROTHERS
FLIGHT CENTRE (UK) LTD
1US (ABERDEEN) LTD
PENSIONS TRUST
LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD
PENSIONS TRUST
PENSIONS TRUST
BARNARDOS
PENSIONS TRUST
BRITISH HEART FOUNDATION
PENSIONS TRUST
THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD
SAINSBURY'S SUPERMARKETS LTD
STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD
(CASH BETTING) LTD
PER CB RICHARD ELLIS
PER CB RICHARD ELLIS
PER CB RICHARD ELLIS
PER CB RICHARD ELLIS
PER CB RICHARD ELLIS
PER G L HEARN
C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
WYMRE
WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED
CBRE LTD
MONTAGU EVANS
CBRE LTD
CBRE LTD
G L HEARN LIMITED
CBRE LTD
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
CBRE LTD
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
CBRE LTD
MONTAGU EVANS
16/03/2018 Page 26 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
5558/58850
5561/56600
5561/58598
5568/55932
5568/66964
5570/56324
33523/56053
5575/58412
5579/63788
5584/63986
5585/63989
5587/54967
5589/55052
5595/56127
T
P
T
P
P
P
T
T
P
P
P
P
T
P
35,000
42,000
42,000
41,250
41,250
42,000
50,000
81,500
49,500
21,250
16,250
79,000
42,500
136,000
35,000
42,000
42,000
41,250
41,250
42,000
50,000
81,500
49,500
21,250
16,250
79,000
42,500
136,000
SURGERY
OFFICE
OFFICE
BANK
BANK
OFFICE
CAFE
SHOP
OFFICE
SHOP
SHOP
RESTAURANT
SHOP
BANK
GROUND FLOOR
GROUND FLOOR
CALEDONIAN HOUSE
CALEDONIAN HOUSE
FILLING STATION
218 UNION STREET
220 UNION STREET
220 UNION STREET
226 UNION STREET
226 UNION STREET
230 UNION STREET
234 UNION STREET
238 UNION STREET
250 UNION STREET
252A UNION STREET
252B UNION STREET
254 UNION STREET
256 UNION STREET
262 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
JASWINDER S DHARIWAL
H & N DEVELOPMENTS LLP
DIGBY BROWN SOLICITORS
TSB BANK PLC
FLOWER OF SCOTLAND LTD
SKIPTON BUILDING SOCIETY
PRET A MANGER (EUROPE) LIMITED
BRITISH HEART FOUNDATION
NATIONWIDE BUILDING SOCIETY
JOHN SEABROOK & JOHN C REAL
JOHN SEABROOK & JOHN C REAL
THE RESTAURANT GROUP
GROSVENOR (ABERDEEN) LTD
NATWEST GROUP PROPERTY
T/A SMILE DENTAL CARE
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
PER GERALD EVE
T/A SIGNATURE 2
PER DTZ
WYMRE
WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED
GVA
CBRE LTD
F G BURNETT LTD
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
CBRE LTD
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON
RYDEN LLP
RYDEN LLP
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
F G BURNETT LTD
GVA
16/03/2018 Page 27 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
5598/53031
5600/63791
5601/61926
5602/64783
5607/56690
5608/58782
5609/53040
80799/52831
5655/58958
5655/64735
31182/56104
31182/64747
5857/53158
6113/54229
T
T
T
P
P
T
T
T
T
P
T
P
P
P
42,750
54,000
36,000
60,000
53,500
41,500
33,000
16,000
34,750
34,750
200,000
200,000
72,500
23,500
42,750
54,000
36,000
60,000
53,500
41,500
33,000
16,000
34,750
34,750
200,000
200,000
72,500
23,500
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOP
OFFICE
OFFICE
SHOP
CAFE
SHOP
CAFE
CAFE
BANK
BANK
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANTCIAO NAPOLI
404 UNION STREET
408 UNION STREET
414 UNION STREET
420 UNION STREET
440 UNION STREET
446 UNION STREET
454 UNION STREET
450 UNION STREET
2 UPPERKIRKGATE
2-4 UPPERKIRKGATE
50 UPPERKIRKGATE
50 UPPERKIRKGATE
46 GREAT WESTERN ROAD
10 BON-ACCORD CRESCENT
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
PIZZA EXPRESS (RESTAURANTS) LTD
W H SMITH GROUP PLC
THE WORKS STORES LTD
STANDARD LIFE TRUSTEE CO LTD
BRYANT PENSION FUND
ALLDAYS STORES LTD
NERO HOLDINGS LTD
ANTHONY JAMES DAWSON & OTHERS
STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
BANK OF SCOTLAND
ABERDEEN SHOPPING CENTRE LTD
THE ASHVALE FISH RESTAURANT
HELLISTER LTD
PER G L HEARN MANAGEMENT LTD
PER LEDINGHAM CHALMERS
PER HILARY WITTS
PER JAMES & GEORGE COLLIE
C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP
PER CBRE
PER AB ROBB LTD
RATING MANAGER
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON
RYDEN LLP
A B ROBB
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
GERALD EVE LLP
RYDEN LLP
MONTAGU EVANS
ERIC YOUNG & CO
CBRE LTD
ERIC YOUNG & CO
RYDEN LLP
A B ROBB
16/03/2018 Page 28 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
6122/54461
33733/54625
36456/54626
36456/59010
6419/54277
6419/63644
77203/54281
6420/54290
6420/56378
6427/54295
6428/54298
6428/55053
6430/53828
6435/53004
T
P
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
P
P
T
P
T
23,500
81,000
43,250
43,250
41,000
41,000
34,250
57,000
57,000
48,500
33,500
33,500
26,250
90,000
23,500
81,000
43,250
43,250
41,000
41,000
34,250
57,000
57,000
48,500
33,500
33,500
26,250
90,000
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOP
OFFICE
RESTAURANT
16 BON-ACCORD CRESCENT
10 BON-ACCORD STREET
10 BON-ACCORD STREET
10 BON-ACCORD STREET
335 UNION STREET
335 UNION STREET
339 UNION STREET
345 UNION STREET
345 UNION STREET
347 UNION STREET
349 UNION STREET
349 UNION STREET
355 UNION STREET
367 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
LANNADALE LTD
SLATER MENSWEAR LTD
SLATER MENSWEAR LTD
EFB HOLDINGS LLP
PRIME PROPERTIES
THOMAS COOK RETAIL LTD
PRIME PROPERTIES
PRIME PROPERTIES
STUART CRICHTON
PRIME PROPERTIES
PRIME PROPERTIES
GROSVENOR (ABERDEEN) LTD
YORKSHIRE BUILDING SOCIETY
LA TASCA RESTAURANTS LTD
WHITTALLS WINE MERCHANTS
PER A B ROBB
UK PROPERTY
PER A B ROBB
PER A B ROBB
T/A DR NOODLES
PER A B ROBB
PER A B ROBB
T/A SIGNATURE
A B ROBB
WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES
WHITELAW BAIKIE FIGES
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
A B ROBB
WYMRE
A B ROBB
A B ROBB
A B ROBB
A B ROBB
F G BURNETT LTD
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
16/03/2018 Page 29 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
6435/54309
77783/54304
6436/58581
6441/53893
6441/58580
6444/58537
6445/55026
6453/66982
6454/57626
88740/55655
88740/67042
6468/54312
6475/58977
31217/55319
P
P
P
T
P
T
T
T
T
T
P
P
P
T
90,000
47,500
36,500
44,000
44,000
62,500
86,500
39,250
39,250
450
450
32,750
42,500
35,500
90,000
47,500
36,500
44,000
44,000
62,500
86,500
39,250
39,250
450
450
32,750
42,500
35,500
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
HAIRDRESSING SALON
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
OFFICE
STORE
STORE
OFFICE
OFFICE
SHOP
LEVEL B4
LEVEL B4
BASEMENT
THE CAPITOL
THE CAPITOL
367 UNION STREET
367 UNION STREET
373 UNION STREET
377 UNION STREET
377 UNION STREET
383 UNION STREET
387 UNION STREET
395 UNION STREET
399 UNION STREET
431 UNION STREET
431 UNION STREET
441 UNION STREET
463 UNION STREET
469 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
PRIME PROPERTIES
PRIME PROPERTIES
HANSTEEN PROPERTY INVESTMENTS LTD
SCOTTISH ENTERPRISE
HANSTEEN OFFICE & RETAIL LIMITED
SKILLS DEVELOPMENT SCOTLAND
CHARLES MICHIE (CHEMIST)
VIRGIN MONEY PLC
RAEBURN CHRISTIE CLARK & WALLACE
PRICEWATERHOUSECOOPERS LLP
BRITISH OVERSEAS BANK NOMINEES LTD
PRIME PROPERTIES
BRITISH AIRWAYS PENSION
LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD
PER A B ROBB
PER A B ROBB
C/O SALTIRE PROPERTY MANAGEMENT LTD
& WGTC NOMINEES LTD
PER A B ROBB
TRUSTEES LTD
A B ROBB
A B ROBB
GERALD EVE LLP
WYMRE
GERALD EVE LLP
GVA
F G BURNETT LTD
LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON
F G BURNETT LTD
CBRE LTD
CBRE LTD
A B ROBB
GVA
MONTAGU EVANS
16/03/2018 Page 30 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
61103/63228
6488/56925
6492/53166
6492/58262
6563/64063
82077/61693
82077/63526
82078/56057
82078/61688
82306/58602
82306/61695
82079/61690
82079/64498
82080/61689
T
P
P
T
P
P
T
T
P
T
P
P
T
P
53,000
74,000
82,000
82,000
24,250
250,000
250,000
295,000
295,000
284,000
284,000
500,000
500,000
286,000
53,000
74,000
82,000
82,000
24,250
250,000
250,000
295,000
295,000
284,000
284,000
500,000
500,000
286,000
BETTING OFFICE
POST OFFICE
SUPERMARKET
SUPERMARKET
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
TESCO EXPRESS
TESCO EXPRESS
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
475 UNION STREET
489 UNION STREET
501 UNION STREET
501 UNION STREET
4 BRIDGE STREET
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD
ROYAL MAIL GROUP PROPERTY
TRS OF THE CLYDE IMPORTERS LIMITED
TESCO STORES LTD
JOSHUA HALPERN & SAMUEL HALPERN
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
CULT RETAIL LLP
REPUBLIC.COM RETAIL LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
DEICHMANN SHOES LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
RIVER ISLAND CLOTHING CO LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
RETIREMENT BENEFITS SCHEME
PER PRESTBURY MANAGEMENT LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
G L HEARN LIMITED
BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE
RYDEN LLP
GVA
A B ROBB
G L HEARN
KBW CHARTERED SURVEYORS
CBRE LTD
G L HEARN
GVA
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
G L HEARN LIMITED
G L HEARN
16/03/2018 Page 31 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
82080/62062
82081/61601
82082/61644
82082/64483
83308/61643
83308/61739
82083/61641
82916/55725
82916/61642
83641/55747
83641/61619
83641/64401
85910/56846
85910/61573
T
P
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
T
P
286,000
305,000
174,000
174,000
173,000
173,000
172,000
173,000
173,000
137,000
137,000
137,000
225,000
225,000
286,000
305,000
174,000
174,000
173,000
173,000
172,000
173,000
173,000
137,000
137,000
137,000
225,000
225,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
FAT FACE LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
JOULES LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
VF NORTHERN EUROPE LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
CATH KIDSTON
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
ESTEE LAUDER
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
ESTEE LAUDER
THE WHITE COMPANY
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
G L HEARN LIMITED
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
G L HEARN LIMITED
G L HEARN
BNP PARIBAS REAL ESTATE
G L HEARN
CBRE LTD
G L HEARN
JONES LANG LASALLE
G L HEARN
WYMRE
G L HEARN LIMITED
G L HEARN
16/03/2018 Page 32 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
82085/61684
82085/66970
84740/58488
84740/61880
82086/56043
82086/61625
82087/55806
82087/61567
83611/59067
83611/61666
83492/61667
83492/63173
83999/56435
83999/61669
P
T
P
T
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
T
P
196,000
196,000
75,000
75,000
143,000
143,000
189,000
189,000
180,000
180,000
182,000
182,000
182,000
182,000
196,000
196,000
75,000
75,000
143,000
143,000
189,000
189,000
180,000
180,000
182,000
182,000
182,000
182,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
BESTSELLER RETAIL UK LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
SATSUMAHILL PROPERTIES LTD
ROX (UK) LIMITED
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
MICHAEL KORS (UK) LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
TELEFONICA UK LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
THE CARPHONE WAREHOUSE
THE DUNE GROUP
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
T/A HOTEL CHOCOLAT
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
G L HEARN
KNIGHT FRANK LLP
G L HEARN
ALLSOP LLP
GVA
G L HEARN
CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD
G L HEARN
CLUTTONS LLP
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
G L HEARN LIMITED
WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED
G L HEARN
16/03/2018 Page 33 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
82088/55478
82088/58955
82436/53317
82436/61602
84105/61685
84105/62510
82089/58884
82089/61569
82090/61646
82090/62522
82091/61648
82091/62586
83114/61590
82094/53396
T
P
T
P
P
T
T
P
P
T
P
T
P
T
355,000
355,000
322,000
322,000
203,000
203,000
191,000
191,000
174,000
174,000
176,000
176,000
180,000
310,000
355,000
355,000
322,000
322,000
203,000
203,000
191,000
191,000
174,000
174,000
176,000
176,000
180,000
310,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
H & M HENNES & MAURITZ (UK) LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
AFH STORES (UK) LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
HUGO BOSS
BOUX AVENUE LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PAPERCHASE PRODUCTS LIMITED
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
T M LEWIN & SONS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
APPLE RETAIL UK LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
ACCOUNTS DEPARTMENT
PER GL HEARN LTD
C/O BAYRAM VICKERY MEECH
MONTAGU EVANS
G L HEARN
DALTON WARNER DAVIS
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
FREDERICK HOLT & COMPANY
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
CVS
G L HEARN
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
G L HEARN
DALTON WARNER DAVIS
16/03/2018 Page 34 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
82094/61670
83106/58009
83106/61635
82098/55880
82098/61671
82130/65464
82939/57702
82939/61714
88481/67330
82075/55884
82075/58485
87839/61886
83310/56605
83310/58487
P
T
P
T
P
T
T
P
P
T
P
T
T
P
310,000
160,000
160,000
325,000
325,000
27,000
6,000
6,000
27,000
64,000
64,000
27,000
71,000
71,000
310,000
160,000
160,000
325,000
325,000
27,000
6,000
6,000
27,000
64,000
64,000
27,000
71,000
71,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
STANCE
STANCES
STANCES
STANCE
CAFE
CAFE
STANCE
CAFE
CAFE
R5
R7
LM4
GROUND LEVEL MALL
29 GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
EAST MALL
EAST MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
EAST MALL
EAST MALL
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
FOSSIL UK LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
NEXT PLC
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
C R SMITH GLAZIERS
CLEARHILL
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
OLUYOMI ADEBOWALE
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
FUEL JUICE BARS LTD
SUBWAY SCOTLAND NORTH
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
ESTATES DEPARTMENT
PER GL HEARN LTD
(DUNFERMLINE) LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
T/A MUFFIN BREAK
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
G L HEARN
HARPER DENNIS HOBBS
G L HEARN
G L HEARN LIMITED
G L HEARN
ANDREW REILLY ASSOCIATES
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
BEACON BROOKE
G L HEARN
ALLSOP LLP
WILLIAMS YOUNG MCKAIG LIMITED
G L HEARN
16/03/2018 Page 35 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
84029/56541
84029/58483
83268/61592
83266/64106
84350/64609
85579/58792
82915/61583
82915/62606
84858/58675
84858/63338
82076/63790
87837/64173
82103/61628
82103/67197
T
P
P
T
T
T
P
T
P
O
T
T
P
T
24,500
24,500
23,000
27,000
27,000
27,000
99,500
99,500
186,000
186,000
30,000
33,000
150,000
150,000
24,500
24,500
23,000
27,000
27,000
27,000
99,500
99,500
186,000
186,000
30,000
33,000
150,000
150,000
SHOP
SHOP
CAFE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
KIOSK
STANCE
SHOP
SHOP
R6
R8
R11
R1
EAST MALL
EAST MALL
EAST MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
GROUND LEVEL MALL
EAST MALL
EAST MALL
EAST MALL
EAST MALL
EAST MALL
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
GREGGS PLC
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
MOBILE SNAP
DEAD SEA
KRISPY KREME UK LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
CASPIAN FOOD RETAILERS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
SAKURA MANAGEMENT LTD
W H SMITH RETAIL HOLDINGS
MR PRETZEL (UK) RETAIL LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
KIKO UK LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
C/O LMT COMMUNICATIONS LTD
PER BAZ MANAGEMENT LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
T/A BURGER KING
PER GL HEARN LTD
T/A COSMO ABERDEEN
PER GL HEARN LTD
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
MCCAFFERY & CO
MONTAGU EVANS
G L HEARN
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
DEVILLIERS CHARTERED SURVEYORS
GERALD EVE LLP
CVS
G L HEARN
MONTAGU EVANS
16/03/2018 Page 36 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
82100/58280
82100/58494
82101/55470
82101/61603
82093/56302
82093/58638
83519/62661
84354/58793
82818/61626
82818/62060
82307/56106
82307/61604
82092/58769
82092/61677
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
P
T
T
P
T
P
82,500
82,500
128,000
128,000
184,000
184,000
4,900
33,000
148,000
148,000
129,000
129,000
360,000
360,000
82,500
82,500
128,000
128,000
184,000
184,000
4,900
33,000
148,000
148,000
129,000
129,000
360,000
360,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
STORE
STANCE
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
STORE 36 REAR OF
R2
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
THE PERFUME SHOP LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PYRRHA LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
BARRHEAD TRAVEL SERVICES LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
KRISPY KREME UK LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
STONEBEACH LTD
MONSOON ACCESSORIZE LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
NEW LOOK RETAILERS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
T/A PANDORA
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
T/A PATISSERIE VALERIE
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
WYMRE
G L HEARN
BEACON BROOKE
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
MONTAGU EVANS
G L HEARN
G L HEARN LIMITED
CBRE LTD
G L HEARN
G L HEARN LIMITED
G L HEARN
16/03/2018 Page 37 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
82095/58963
82095/61672
82097/53042
82097/61683
82110/58889
82110/61568
82913/58484
82913/67375
82510/53033
82510/61582
86600/53045
87534/58796
87535/58795
87537/53023
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
T
P
T
T
T
T
339,000
339,000
195,000
195,000
190,000
190,000
50,000
50,000
151,000
151,000
2,200
2,600
2,500
2,500
339,000
339,000
195,000
195,000
190,000
190,000
50,000
50,000
151,000
151,000
2,200
2,600
2,500
2,500
SHOP
SHOP
CAFE
CAFE
CAFE
CAFE
SHOP
SHOP
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
STORE
STORE
STORE
STORE
STORE 24 REAR OF FS13
STORE 26 REAR OF FS13
STORE 27 REAR OF FS13
STORE 31 REAR OF FS13
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
THE ATRIUM
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
3 FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
COTSWOLD OUTDOOR LIMITED
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
COSTA LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
STARBUCKS COFFEE CO (UK) LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
ARIANNA PROPERTIES LIMITED
PIZZA EXPRESS (RESTAURANTS) LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PIZZA EXPRESS (RESTAURANTS) LTD
KRISPY KREME UK LTD
KRISPY KREME UK LTD
COAST TO COAST
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
C/O MONTAGU EVANS LLP
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
T/A MOZZA
PER GL HEARN LTD
G L HEARN LIMITED
G L HEARN
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
MONTAGU EVANS
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
MONTAGU EVANS
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
GERALD EVE LLP
MONTAGU EVANS
MONTAGU EVANS
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
16/03/2018 Page 38 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
87412/53022
87412/61686
85486/61657
85486/63795
85653/62552
82594/58493
82594/64603
82068/54431
82068/61640
82069/61622
82070/55469
82070/61633
82411/58269
82411/58677
T
P
P
T
T
P
T
T
P
P
T
P
T
P
256,000
256,000
180,000
180,000
4,900
81,000
81,000
171,000
171,000
141,000
159,000
159,000
206,000
206,000
256,000
256,000
180,000
180,000
4,900
81,000
81,000
171,000
171,000
141,000
159,000
159,000
206,000
206,000
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
STORE
SALON
SALON
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
STORE 16 REAR OF FS14
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
7 FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
COAST TO COAST
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
CARLUCCIO'S
JOULES LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
THE NAIL & BEAUTY ZONE LTD
BYRON HAMBURGERS
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
NANDO'S CHICKENLAND LIMITED
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PIZZA HUT (UK) LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
T/A PURE SPA
PER GERALD EVE LLP
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
GVA
G L HEARN LIMITED
G L HEARN
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
DALTON WARNER DAVIS
G L HEARN
16/03/2018 Page 39 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
84335/53450
84336/57792
84337/53043
84340/56133
83631/53449
83631/61698
82071/56134
82071/61679
82072/53003
82072/61571
82817/53005
82817/61639
83092/53006
83092/61620
T
T
T
T
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
1,550
2,350
2,300
2,400
273,000
273,000
119,000
119,000
209,000
209,000
170,000
170,000
139,000
139,000
1,550
2,350
2,300
2,400
273,000
273,000
119,000
119,000
209,000
209,000
170,000
170,000
139,000
139,000
STORE
STORE
STORE
STORE
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 1
CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 3
CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 4
CENTRE MANAGEMENT STORE 7
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
TGI FRIDAYS UK LTD
COSTA LTD
COSTA LTD
YO! SUSHI UK LIMITED
TGI FRIDAYS UK LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
YO! SUSHI UK LIMITED
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
LAS IGUANAS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
ASK RESTAURANTS LIMITED
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
WAGAMAMA LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GERALD EVE
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
CUSHMAN & WAKEFIELD
G L HEARN
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
16/03/2018 Page 40 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
82934/53453
82934/61623
82073/53026
82073/61572
82074/53027
82074/58676
82105/52968
82105/61637
82937/55302
82937/58639
82104/56204
82104/61629
82107/61593
82107/64033
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
P
T
143,000
143,000
224,000
224,000
189,000
189,000
162,000
162,000
185,000
185,000
155,000
155,000
54,000
54,000
143,000
143,000
224,000
224,000
189,000
189,000
162,000
162,000
185,000
185,000
155,000
155,000
54,000
54,000
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
30 FIRST LEVEL MALL
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
GIRAFFE CONCEPTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
THE RESTAURANT GROUP
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
THE RESTAURANT GROUP
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
ASK RESTAURANTS LIMITED
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PREZZO LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
THAIKHUN
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
BARBURRITOS
PER GL HEARN LTD
T/A FRANKIE & BENNY'S
PER GL HEARN LTD
T/A CHIQUITO'S
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GERALD EVE
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GERALD EVE
PER GERALD EVE
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
G L HEARN
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
G L HEARN
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
CB RICHARD ELLIS LTD
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
SIMON ALEXANDER CONSULTING LTD
16/03/2018 Page 41 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
560
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
84628/54402
84628/61547
82111/52830
82111/61575
87023/63672
82126/53817
82126/61706
82127/53820
82127/61701
84355/61708
86372/53960
83232/53001
92073/67307
83234/53002
T
P
T
P
T
T
P
T
P
P
T
T
P
T
36,750
73,500
240,000
240,000
4,000
3,000
3,000
3,000
3,000
10,000
20,000
2,550
6,100
2,550
36,750
73,500
240,000
240,000
4,000
3,000
3,000
3,000
3,000
10,000
20,000
2,550
6,100
2,550
HAIRDRESSING SALON
HAIRDRESSING SALON
SHOP
SHOP
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STANCE
STORE
STORE
STORE
UM3
STORE 10 REAR OF FS2A
STORE 38 REAR OF FS2
STORE 12 REAR OF FS2A
31 FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
SOUTH TERRACE
SOUTH TERRACE
EAST MALL
EAST MALL
EAST MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
FIRST LEVEL MALL
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
UNION SQUARE
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
HAIR UNION SQUARE LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
BOOTS UK LIMITED
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
AMAZON UK SERVICES LTD
PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
SKY RETAIL STORES LTD
WAGAMAMA LTD
UNION SQUARE DEVELOPMENTS LTD
WAGAMAMA LTD
T/A SAKS HAIR & BEAUTY
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GERALD EVE LLP
PER GL HEARN LTD
FAO RICHARD PRICE
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
PER GL HEARN LTD
G L HEARN
GERALD EVE LLP
G L HEARN
LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
G L HEARN
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
G L HEARN
G L HEARN
WYMRE
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
16/03/2018 Page 42 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
574
575
576
577
578
579
580
581
582
583
584
585
586
587
7207/58517
7207/64064
7208/56904
7214/53465
33087/56044
7218/57981
7218/58771
53825/53926
53825/57978
53825/63073
7220/55489
7221/58589
7222/61660
7223/55231
T
P
T
T
T
P
O
T
P
O
T
T
T
P
64,500
64,500
71,500
37,750
40,500
64,000
64,000
32,500
32,500
32,500
56,000
22,250
35,750
31,000
64,500
64,500
71,500
37,750
40,500
64,000
64,000
32,500
32,500
32,500
56,000
22,250
35,750
31,000
SHOP
SHOP
BANK
BETTING OFFICE
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
RESTAURANTSHAPLA INDIAN RESTAURANT
167 UNION STREET
167 UNION STREET
171 UNION STREET
175 UNION STREET
177 UNION STREET
181 UNION STREET
181 UNION STREET
181B UNION STREET
181B UNION STREET
181B UNION STREET
183 UNION STREET
185 UNION STREET
187 UNION STREET
189 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
SALLY SALON SERVICES LTD
JOSHUA HALPERN & SAMUEL HALPERN
SANTANDER UK PLC
PADDY POWER BOOKMAKERS
GAME RETAIL LTD
AKZO NOBEL CIF NOMINEES LTD &
DUVETCO LTD
NHS GRAMPIAN
AKZO NOBEL CIF NOMINEES LTD &
CORAL RACING LTD
ANN SUMMERS
SUPERCUTS UK LTD
THE EDINBURGH WOOLLEN MILL LTD
SHABARO ALI
PER PARK LANE ESTATES
PER DTZ
AKZO NOBEL (CPS) PENSION SCHEME
AKZO NOBEL (CPS) PENSION SCHEME
CORAL GALA GROUP
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
A B ROBB
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
GRIFFIN WEBSTER PARTNERSHIP
GERALD EVE LLP
CBRE LTD
WYMRE
WYMRE
CBRE LTD
GERALD EVE LLP
MONTAGU EVANS
ALLSOP LLP
WYMRE
GRANT STEWART CHARTERED SURVEY
16/03/2018 Page 43 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
588
589
590
591
592
593
594
595
596
597
598
599
600
601
7224/56603
7224/61718
7224/66996
7225/56626
7225/66995
7226/56114
7228/53199
7228/63230
7229/53273
7229/61932
7230/55307
7230/64065
7232/59023
7233/59024
P
T
P
P
P
P
P
T
P
T
T
P
P
P
37,250
37,250
37,250
46,500
46,500
59,000
22,250
22,250
19,750
19,750
26,500
26,500
18,750
24,000
37,250
37,250
37,250
46,500
46,500
59,000
22,250
22,250
19,750
19,750
26,500
26,500
18,750
24,000
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
BANK
BETTING OFFICE
BETTING OFFICE
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
191 UNION STREET
191 UNION STREET
191 UNION STREET
195 UNION STREET
195 UNION STREET
201 UNION STREET
207 UNION STREET
207 UNION STREET
207A UNION STREET
207A UNION STREET
209 UNION STREET
209 UNION STREET
215 UNION STREET
219 UNION STREET
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
NUCLEAR LIABILITIES FUND LTD
BRITISH RED CROSS
FARCHANNEL LTD
NUCLEAR LIABILITIES FUND LTD
FARCHANNEL LTD
BANK OF SCOTLAND
KILKENNY PROPERTIES LTD
WILLIAM HILL ORGANIZATION LTD
KILKENNY PROPERTIES LIMITED
T M RETAIL PLC
LADBROKES BETTING & GAMING LTD
JOSHUA HALPERN & SAMUEL HALPERN
MACADAM LEISURE LTD
MACADAM LEISURE LTD
PER LASALLE INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
PER LASALLE INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT
PER CBRE
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
PER BISSETT KENNING & NEWISS
PER PARK LANE ESTATES
MONTAGU EVANS
LAMBERT SMITH HAMPTON
A B ROBB
MONTAGU EVANS
A B ROBB
CBRE LTD
RYDEN LLP
G L HEARN LIMITED
RYDEN LLP
GERALD EVE LLP
MONTAGU EVANS
A B ROBB
GRAHAM & SIBBALD
GRAHAM & SIBBALD
16/03/2018 Page 44 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
602
603
604
605
606
607
608
609
610
611
612
613
614
615
7234/62598
7236/64615
7237/56528
7239/63694
7241/56103
7245/54250
7245/56580
7251/55383
7251/62516
7253/63700
7253/64263
7257/54269
7257/54271
7599/55714
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
P
T
T
P
T
P
P
65,000
23,250
26,500
29,750
83,000
129,000
129,000
45,500
45,500
33,500
33,500
62,000
62,000
67,500
65,000
23,250
26,500
29,750
83,000
129,000
129,000
45,500
45,500
33,500
33,500
62,000
62,000
67,500
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
RESTAURANT
RESTAURANT
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
SHOP
CAFE
CAFE
SUPERMARKET
221 UNION STREET
225 UNION STREET
227 UNION STREET
231 UNION STREET
247 UNION STREET
257 UNION STREET
257 UNION STREET
261 UNION STREET
261 UNION STREET
265 UNION STREET
265 UNION STREET
269 UNION STREET
269 UNION STREET
78 VICTORIA ROAD
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
CASPIAN FOOD RETAILERS LTD
SCOTTISH EQUITABLE PLC
GREGGS PLC
AFZAL KHUSHI & AKMAL KHUSHI
CRUISE CLOTHING LTD
PRIME PROPERTIES
AMARONE RESTAURANTS LTD
MFW PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT LTD
LASERCARE CLINICS (HARROGATE) LTD
TRAILFINDERS
MUNRO'S TRAVEL GROUP
P B DEVELOPMENT CO LTD
PRIME PROPERTIES
C J LANG & SON LTD
T/A BURGER KING
PER GL HEARN MANAGEMENT LTD
PER A B ROBB
PER A B ROBB
GERALD EVE LLP
WYMRE
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
RYDEN LLP
CBRE LTD
A B ROBB
MONTAGU EVANS
A B ROBB
DALTON WARNER DAVIS
ALLSOP LLP
RYDEN LLP
A B ROBB
A B ROBB
J & E SHEPHERD
16/03/2018 Page 45 of 45
No Reference Description/Situation Appellant/Agent Proposed Values
NAV RV NAV RV Agreed Values
616
617
618
619
620
621
622
623
624
625
626
627
628
629
7708/62618
7708/62747
7783/55972
7789/53188
87829/53823
87091/58785
89913/55685
85555/55268
75763/55270
75764/55269
75765/55329
80697/55267
33938/55286
9707/67338
T
P
T
P
T
T
T
P
P
P
P
P
P
T
20,500
20,500
132,000
41,500
1,000
69,500
200,000
14,500
14,000
22,000
13,250
7,600
3,500
16,500
20,500
20,500
132,000
41,500
1,000
69,500
200,000
14,500
14,000
22,000
13,250
7,600
3,500
16,500
SHOP
SHOP
SUPERMARKET
OFFICE
STANCE
SUPERMARKET
SUPERMARKET
TICKET DESK
TICKET DESK
TICKET DESK
TICKET DESK
SITE
SITE
SHOP
PHOTO-ME
HA004 & HJ004
HI 112
HI 111
HA 002 & HJ 001
CHECK-IN MACHINES (4)
P234B
DYCE SHOPPING CENTRE
CO-OPERATIVE FOOD
MARKS & SPENCERS FOODHALL
TERMINAL BUILDING
TERMINAL BUILDING
TERMINAL BUILDING
TERMINAL BUILDING
TERMINAL BUILDING
TERMINAL BUILDING
CROOKFOLD
477 GREAT WESTERN ROAD
477 GREAT WESTERN ROAD
345 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD
379 NORTH DEESIDE ROAD
RIVERVIEW DRIVE
STONEYWOOD ROAD
BEECH MANOR
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT
4 BALGOWNIE CRESCENT
ABERDEEN
ABERDEEN
CULTS
CULTS
DYCE
STONEYWOOD
STONEYWOOD
DYCE
DYCE
DYCE
DYCE
DYCE
DYCE
BRIDGE OF DON
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
DUNCAN & TODD LTD
CITY ANGEL LTD
SAINSBURY'S SUPERMARKETS LTD
MACKINNONS
PHOTO-ME INTERNATIONAL PLC
THE CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LTD
MARKS & SPENCER PLC
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD
ABERDEEN INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT LTD
SIVANESAN THANGAVELAUTHAM
T/A DOUGLAS DICKIE
PER G L HEARN
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
PROPERTY DEPARTMENT
OPTICIANSGRAHAM & SIBBALD
GRAHAM & SIBBALD
CBRE LTD
RYDEN LLP
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
COLLIERS INTERNATIONAL
GERALD EVE LLP
DUNLOP HEYWOOD
DUNLOP HEYWOOD
DUNLOP HEYWOOD
DUNLOP HEYWOOD
DUNLOP HEYWOOD
DUNLOP HEYWOOD