Limitations of cultural studies

11
Name - Khalani Shabana. M Roll no : 30 Paper no-8 Year -2013&2014 Sem-2 M.K.B.University.Bhavnagar English Department Submit by – Dr. D.P.Barad Topic – Limitation of cultural studies

Transcript of Limitations of cultural studies

Page 1: Limitations of cultural studies

Name - Khalani Shabana. MRoll no : 30Paper no-8

Year -2013&2014Sem-2

M.K.B.University.BhavnagarEnglish Department

Submit by – Dr. D.P.BaradTopic – Limitation of cultural studies

Page 2: Limitations of cultural studies

LIMITATION OF CULTURAL STUDIES

Page 3: Limitations of cultural studies
Page 4: Limitations of cultural studies

-> The weaknesses of cultural studies lie in its very strengths , particularly upon diversity of approach

and subject matter .-> Cultural studies time seem merely

and intellectual .-> Culture means how culture have interacted .

-> Cultural knowledge of the “ deep play “ of meanings or “ thick description “ that

ethnographer Clifford Geerez identified in his studies of the Balinese .

Page 5: Limitations of cultural studies

-> Devid Richter describes cultural studies as “ about whatever is happening at the movement ,

about body of text created in the past ”

-> ‘Happening’ , topics , generally speaking , is the mass media , post

modern culture , dominate culture , lives , in habitants or

topics .

Page 6: Limitations of cultural studies

-> Hamlet or Huckleberry Finn were written they were not

intended for elite discussions in English class room but popular

consumption .-> Marxist TERRY Eagleton has

written the current “ crisis “ in the humanities can be seen as a failure of humanities “ body of discourses

“ about imperishable value .S

Page 7: Limitations of cultural studies
Page 8: Limitations of cultural studies

Ideological state apparatus > TV Soap Operas, Ads, popular moviesKhans > their movies, marriages with hindu women, styamev jayate (all about India’s dark side)Awards to the books on downside of Indian culture > Adiga’s White Tiger, Wendy Doniger’s Hindus , etc .

Page 9: Limitations of cultural studies

At regular interval TV news channels (sponsored by MNCs) will do sting operations to unearth sexual perversion in Hindu sects > swamis, sadhvi’s caught etcStudy of Culture with deconstructive angle > doubting self integrity > what maccaulay cannot do, new American edu system’s project would be able to do so > First produce cheap cultural artefacts > then inspire people for serious study > production > marketing (so MBAs will be in demand) > consumption > authenticate by doing academic research.Articles – JSTOR – Warner and Siskin: Stopping CS

Page 10: Limitations of cultural studies

હે� ! પ્રિ�ય વા�ચક મિ�ત્રો , હે�� જે� કઈ લખું�� છું�� તે� પરં� પરં�ગતે છું� જે નહે��. ક ઈ પ� વા� પરં� પરં�ન� અન�સરં�ન� હે�� લખુંતે નથી�.

આવા�� હેશે� એ� જાણી� ��નશે નહે��. લ%પ્રિકક ન્ય�ય પણી નહે�� લ�ગ� , સ�� દરં લ�ગવા�ન તે સવા�લ જે નથી�. શ્રદ્ધા�ન�

પ ષન�રું� તે છું� જે નહે��, ઊલટું�� શ્રદ્ધા� અન� અ�ધશ્રદ્ધા� બં�ન� ન� તે ડન�રં બંન� રંહે� તે� વા� શેક્યતે� છું� . ન� તે હે��

�સિસદ્ધા છું�� , ન� તે પ�જ્ય છું�� . બંનવા�� પણી નથી�. પણી તે��રં� પ્રિવાવા� ક બં� સિદ્ધાથી� ખુંરું� લ�ગ� તે જે ��નશે , સ્વા�ક�રંશે . ~

Bhupendrasinh Raol

Page 11: Limitations of cultural studies