LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted...

23
LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger. Cody Messick for the LIGO Scientific Collaboration

Transcript of LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted...

Page 1: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.

Cody Messick for the LIGO Scientific Collaboration

Page 2: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

LIGO NSF Proposal

● “The most certain of the sources is coalescence of neutron-star binaries.”

● Length of arms chosen to maximize chance of observing neutron star mergers

Page 3: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Evidence for binary neutron stars

Page 4: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Distribution of neutron stars

Page 5: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

2010 Predictions for compact binary merger rates

LIGO Scientific Collaboration, Virgo Collaboration, Classical and Quantum Gravity, Volume 27, Number 17 (2010)

Page 6: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Binary neutron star motivation

● Equation of state

● Short gamma-ray bursts

● Multi-messenger astrophysics

Figure credit: NSF/LIGO/Sonoma State University/Aurore Simonnet

Page 7: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Multi-messenger Astrophysics

● Event that can be detected through multiple channels; e.g. light, neutrinos, GWs

● Classic example: the Sun

● Modern example: binary neutron stars

Ɣ

Ɣ

Page 8: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Importance of Multi-messenger Astrophysics

● Different emissions provide different information about the source

● Can raise significance of quiet events

Page 9: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Neutron star summary

● Indirect evidence of GWs from a binary neutron star

● Have good handle on population statistics of neutron stars

● Important to multi-messenger astrophysics

Page 10: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

A worrisome start?

Figure credit: LSC/Sonoma State University/Aurore Simonnet

Page 11: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

August 17th, 2017 Timeline

● 12:41:04 UTC - Gravitational waves from binary neutron star merger reaches LIGO detectors

● 12:41:06 UTC - GRB reaches Fermi GBM

● 12:47:18 UTC - Single detector candidate identified with FAR 1 in 10,000 years LSC/Duncan Brown/Geoffery Lovelace/Duncan Macleod

Page 12: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

August 17th, 2017 Timeline

● 13:21:42 UTC - Initial GCN sent out

● 14:09:25 UTC - GCN sent out with Fermi skymap

● 17:54:51 UTC - First three-instrument LIGO/Virgo skymap sent out

https://gcn.gsfc.nasa.gov/gcn3/21505.gcn3

Page 13: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Offline Analysis Results

● Found by two independent matched-filter searches with false alarm rates of

○ 1 in 1.1M years

○ < 1 in 80k years

Page 14: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Searching for Gravitational Waves

Figure credit: Leslie Wade

Page 16: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Source Properties (Masses)

: dimensionless spin parameter, defined such that 1 corresponds to the max spin of a black hole

Image credit: B.P. Abbot et al., PRL 119, 161101 (2017)

Page 17: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Sources Properties

Table credit: B.P. Abbot et al., PRL 119, 161101 (2017)● Assuming low spin, upper bound of Λ for 1.4 M

☉ NS is 970, compared to

1000 derived from X-rays

Page 18: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Localization

Page 19: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Localization

Image credit: LVC/Greco, Arnaud, Vicerè (background image:HEASARC/Skyview)

Page 20: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Localization

Image credit: LVC/Greco, Arnaud, Vicerè (background image:HEASARC/Skyview)

Page 21: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Merger product and rate estimate

● If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz

● Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz after detection

● 1540+3200-1220 Gpc-3 yr-1

○ O1 Upper Limit: 12600 Gpc-3 yr-1 Image credit: NASA/AEI/ZIB/M. KOPPITZ AND L. REZZOLLA

Page 22: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

What can we do better next time?

● Lower search and skymap generation latency

● Low latency data quality

● Automated alerts, remove the human element

● Early warning system

Page 23: LIGO observation of a binary neutron star merger.Merger product and rate estimate If merger resulted in black hole, GWs would be emitted around 6kHz Saw no evidence of GWs up to 4kHz

Questions?

Frank Elavsky/Northwestern/LIGO-Virgo