LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia...

27
LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

description

Most well known example of a LPB is the AXION proposed to solve the strong CP problem. It is characterized by the relation with k = O(1).

Transcript of LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia...

Page 1: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE

PULSAR J0737-3039

Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

Page 2: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS

Light pseudoscalar bosons (LPBs) are described by

and so are labelled by m and M. LPBs are present in many extensions of the

SM.

FF

ML ~

41

Page 3: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

Most well known example of a LPB is the AXION proposed to solve the strong CP problem. It is characterized by the relation

with k = O(1).

eVMGeVk

10107.0m

Page 4: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

As a rule, LPBs are very WEAKLY coupled to matter …. quite ELUSIVE in collider experiments.

In the presence of an EXTERNAL magnetic field B, mass eigenstates of photon-LPB system DIFFER from interaction eigenstates …. photon-LPB INTERCONVERSION occurs.

N.B. ANALOGY with neutrino oscillations BUT here nonvanishing B necessary to account for spin mismatch.

Page 5: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

…. High-precision optics experiments CAN detect LPBs.

Two remarks:

• Transition probability becomes energy-INDEPENDENT for oscillation wavenumber DOMINATED by photon-LPB mixing term.

Page 6: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

• As long as photon/LPB energy is MUCH LARGER than m – WKB approximation – the SECOND-order propagation equation for a monochromatic beam reduces to a FIRST-order one.

Page 7: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

PHOTON PROPAGATIONPhoton beam propagates along z-axis. Only

TRANSVERSE B component is relevant.Suppose B is homogeneous. DEF : PARALLEL photons are polarized in B-z

plane, PERPENDICULAR photons have polarization normal to that plane.

It turns out that

Page 8: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

• PARALLEL photons MIX with LPBs.• PERPENDICULAR photons do NOT ….

they propagate UNDISTURBED.Because of this fact• Exchange of a virtual LPB ….

BIREFRINGENCE.• Production of a real LPB ….

DICHROISM.

Page 9: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

Consider a photon beam LINEALY polarized at the beginning. Then

• Owing to BIREFRINGENCE it devolops an ELLIPTICAL polarization.

• Due to DICHROISM, the ellipse’s major axis is ROTATED.

Measuring both ellipticity and rotation angle …. both m and M can be DETERMINED.

Page 10: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

ASTROPHYSICAL CONSTRAINT

Thermal photons produced in central regions of stars can become LPBs in the fluctuating EM field of stellar plasma. These LPBs escape …. star looses energy …. central temperature increases ….

observed properties change. Agreement between standard stellar models and observations …. unwanted LPB effects have to be sufficiently suppressed ….

Page 11: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

lower bound

N.B. SAME conclusion reached from CAST experiment (no observation of LPBs from

the Sun).

GeVM 1010

Page 12: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

PVLAS EXPERIMENT

Actually PVLAS collaboration implemented above strategy and reported positive evidence for a LPB with

A look back at m-M relation …. this LPB is NOT the axion. Moreover, astrophysical bound

eV310mGeVM 5108.3

Page 13: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

VIOLATED by 5 orders of magnitudes ….

…. not only a NEW PARTICLE has been discovered (?) but also NEW PHYSICS al low-energy MUST exist!

Sic stantibus rebus…. INDEPENDENT CHECKS of PVLAS claim are COMPELLING!

Page 14: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039

Discovered in 2003.• Orbital period T = 2.45 h.• Rotation periods P(A) = 23 ms, P(B) = 2.8 s.• Inclination of orbital plane i = 90.29 deg ….

it is seen almost EDGE-ON.Focus on emission from A.

Page 15: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)
Page 16: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

Pulsar B has DIPOLAR magnetic field B on the surface.• LARGE impact parameter …. NOTHING

interesting happens.• SMALL impact parameter …. beam from A

traverses magnetosphere of B …. photon-LPB conversion IMPORTANT

(depending on m, M).

G1210

Page 17: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

TWO effects are expected.

• Production of real LPBs …. periodic attenuation of photon beam which depends on T, P(B). N.B. Analog of DICHROISM in PVLAS

experiment.

Page 18: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

• Exchange of virtual LPBs …. periodic LENSING which depends on T, P(B).

N.B. Analog of BIREFRINGENCE in PVLAS experiment.

Here I consider only attenuation effect (A. Dupays, C. Rizzo, M. R., G. F. Bignami, Phys. Rev.Lett. 95 211302 (2005)).

Page 19: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

We work within WKB approximation and solve numerically the first-order propagation equation for an UNPOLARIZED, monochromatic beam travelling in the dipolar B produced by pulsar B. Resulting transition probability as a function of beam frequency is

Page 20: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)
Page 21: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

N.B. Effect relevant ABOVE 10 MeV …. remarkable result!

For,• J0737-3039 is expected to be a gamma-

ray SOURCE.• Interaction of photon beam with plasma in

magnetosphere of B is NEGLIGIBLE.• WKB approximation JUSTIFIED.

Page 22: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

INTUITIVE explanation assuming B constant i.e.

for

• Mixing effects important for mixing angle in photon-LPB system of order 1 …. OK with THRESHOLD behaviour.

GB 4106.1 km3min 104

Page 23: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

• Transition probability becomes energy-independent for oscillation wavenumber dominated by photon-LPB mixing term …. OK with FLAT behaviour.

TEMPORAL behaviour best described by TRANSMISSION = 1 – P. We find beam attenuation up to 50 % as

Page 24: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)
Page 25: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

This effect turns out to be OBSERVABLE with GLAST.

For example, ABSENCE of attenuation A at 10 % level yields the exclusion plot

Page 26: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)
Page 27: LIGHT PSEUDOSCALAR BOSONS, PVLAS AND DOUBLE PULSAR J0737-3039 Marco Roncadelli, INFN – Pavia (Italy)

This attenuation requires 100 counts during observation time. For 2 weeks

in agreement with expectations and about 1000 times LARGER that GLAST sensitivity threshold for point sources.

scmA //102 27