Leukocyte-depleted blood transfusion is associated with decreased survival in resected early-stage...

5
Leukocyte-depleted blood transfusion is associated with decreased survival in resected early-stage lung cancer Thomas Ng, MD, a Beth A. Ryder, MD, a Hueylan Chern, MD, a Frank W. Sellke, MD, a Jason T. Machan, PhD, a,b David T. Harrington, MD, a and William G. Cioffi, MD a Objectives: Blood transfusion has been shown to have deleterious effect on lung cancer survival, but little data are available that assess whether leukocyte-depleted (LD) blood has a similar adverse effect. Our institution has been using LD red cells since 2001. We sought to determine whether LD blood has an effect on survival after resection of early-stage lung cancer. Methods: From a prospective database, we evaluated all patients with pathologic stage I non–small cell lung cancer. Patients receiving LD blood were compared with those receiving no transfusion. Survival was estimated using the Kaplan-Meier method and compared using the log–rank test. Multivariate analysis by Cox regression was used to identify independent risk factors affecting survival. Results: From 2001 to 2009, 361 patients were evaluated; 63 received LD red cell cell transfusion and 298 re- ceived no transfusion. Median follow-up was 48 months. Disease-free survival (P <.001) and overall survival (P<.001) were worse in patients receiving LD blood. Stratifying for stage, disease-free survival continued to be worse with transfusion for stage IA (P ¼ .002) and IB (P ¼ .002). Similarly, overall survival continued to be worse with transfusion for stage IA (P<.001) and IB (P<.001). For disease-free and overall survival, univariate analysis revealed increased age, male gender, anemia, transfusion, and higher stage to be adverse factors, with transfusion and higher stage continuing to be significant adverse factors after multivariate analysis. Conclusions: Our data suggest that transfusion of LD blood is associated with a worse disease-free and overall survival in patients with resected stage I non–small cell lung cancer. (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2012;143:815-9) Much has been written regarding the potential harm of blood transfusion to the anemic surgical oncology patient. This effect is thought to be due in part to transfusion- related immune modulation from leukocytes in allogeneic donor blood. It was first demonstrated in the transplant pop- ulation, with better allograft survival observed when the re- cipient had a history of transfusion, implying transfusion led to a downregulation of the host immune response to the transplanted organ. 1 It was postulated that transfusion- related immune modulation could similarly affect outcomes from oncologic procedures, leading to increased local re- currence and decreased survival. 1,2 To avoid the potential immunologic side effects of transfusion, many have turned to leukocyte-depleted (LD) blood when transfusion is necessary, citing potential advantages of fewer febrile transfusion reactions, less alloimmunization, less transfusion-associated graft-versus-host disease, less viral transmission (such as cytomegalovirus, Epstein-Barr virus, and human immunodeficiency virus), and lower risk of can- cer recurrence. 2 Perioperative blood transfusion has been studied in lung cancer with some authors showing a deleterious effect on survival 3-8 whereas others have not. 9-13 Many of these studies, however, involve a heterogeneous group of patients in terms of stage and extent of resection. In addition, there are no published reports evaluating the affects of LD blood on lung cancer survival. The aim of our study was to determine whether transfusion of LD blood affected disease-free and overall survival in a uniform group of patients with stage I non–small cell lung cancer re- sected by lobectomy. METHODS From a prospective database, we evaluated all patients with pathologic stage I non–small cell lung cancer resected by lobectomy. Patients under- going sublobar resection, sleeve lobectomy, or pneumonectomy and pa- tients receiving preoperative or postoperative chemotherapy were excluded. Staging positron emission tomography and mediastinoscopy were routinely performed before pulmonary resection. During lobectomy, mediastinal lymph node sampling was performed. All surgical procedures were performed by a single surgeon (T.N.). Patients who received allogenic LD red cells (in-hospital or within 30 days of surgery) were compared with those who received no transfusion. Leukocyte reduction of red cells was performed before storage using either a whole blood in-line filter (Sepacell RZ2000; Fenwal, Deerfield, Ill) or a red cell in-line filter (RCM1 filter; PALL Medical, Covina, Calif). These filters consistently manufacture leukocyte-reduced red cell concentrates that meet the Food and Drug From the Department of Surgery, a The Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown Uni- versity, and Biostatistics, b Rhode Island Hospital, Providence, RI. Disclosures: Authors have nothing to disclose with regard to commercial support. Read at the 37th Annual Meeting of The Western Thoracic Surgical Association, Colorado Springs, Colorado, June 22-25, 2011. Received for publication June 19, 2011; revisions received Nov 24, 2011; accepted for publication Dec 14, 2011; available ahead of print Feb 9, 2012. Address for reprints: Thomas Ng, MD, 2 Dudley St, Suite 470, Providence, RI 02905 (E-mail: [email protected]). 0022-5223/$36.00 Copyright Ó 2012 by The American Association for Thoracic Surgery doi:10.1016/j.jtcvs.2011.12.031 The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery c Volume 143, Number 4 815 Ng et al General Thoracic Surgery GTS

Transcript of Leukocyte-depleted blood transfusion is associated with decreased survival in resected early-stage...

Page 1: Leukocyte-depleted blood transfusion is associated with decreased survival in resected early-stage lung cancer

Ng et al General Thoracic Surgery

Leukocyte-depleted blood transfusion is associated with decreasedsurvival in resected early-stage lung cancer

Thomas Ng, MD,a Beth A. Ryder, MD,a Hueylan Chern, MD,a Frank W. Sellke, MD,a

Jason T. Machan, PhD,a,b David T. Harrington, MD,a and William G. Cioffi, MDa

From th

versit

Disclos

Read at

Color

Receive

for pu

Address

(E-m

0022-52

Copyrig

doi:10.1

GTS

Objectives: Blood transfusion has been shown to have deleterious effect on lung cancer survival, but little dataare available that assess whether leukocyte-depleted (LD) blood has a similar adverse effect. Our institution hasbeen using LD red cells since 2001. We sought to determine whether LD blood has an effect on survival afterresection of early-stage lung cancer.

Methods: From a prospective database, we evaluated all patients with pathologic stage I non–small cell lungcancer. Patients receiving LD blood were compared with those receiving no transfusion. Survival was estimatedusing the Kaplan-Meier method and compared using the log–rank test. Multivariate analysis by Cox regressionwas used to identify independent risk factors affecting survival.

Results: From 2001 to 2009, 361 patients were evaluated; 63 received LD red cell cell transfusion and 298 re-ceived no transfusion. Median follow-up was 48 months. Disease-free survival (P<.001) and overall survival(P<.001) were worse in patients receiving LD blood. Stratifying for stage, disease-free survival continued to beworse with transfusion for stage IA (P ¼ .002) and IB (P ¼ .002). Similarly, overall survival continued to beworse with transfusion for stage IA (P<.001) and IB (P<.001). For disease-free and overall survival, univariateanalysis revealed increased age, male gender, anemia, transfusion, and higher stage to be adverse factors, withtransfusion and higher stage continuing to be significant adverse factors after multivariate analysis.

Conclusions: Our data suggest that transfusion of LD blood is associated with a worse disease-free and overallsurvival in patients with resected stage I non–small cell lung cancer. (J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2012;143:815-9)

Much has been written regarding the potential harm ofblood transfusion to the anemic surgical oncology patient.This effect is thought to be due in part to transfusion-related immune modulation from leukocytes in allogeneicdonor blood. It was first demonstrated in the transplant pop-ulation, with better allograft survival observed when the re-cipient had a history of transfusion, implying transfusionled to a downregulation of the host immune response tothe transplanted organ.1 It was postulated that transfusion-related immunemodulation could similarly affect outcomesfrom oncologic procedures, leading to increased local re-currence and decreased survival.1,2 To avoid the potentialimmunologic side effects of transfusion, many haveturned to leukocyte-depleted (LD) blood when transfusionis necessary, citing potential advantages of fewer febriletransfusion reactions, less alloimmunization, lesstransfusion-associated graft-versus-host disease, less viral

e Department of Surgery,a The Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown Uni-

y, and Biostatistics,b Rhode Island Hospital, Providence, RI.

ures: Authors have nothing to disclose with regard to commercial support.

the 37th Annual Meeting of The Western Thoracic Surgical Association,

ado Springs, Colorado, June 22-25, 2011.

d for publication June 19, 2011; revisions received Nov 24, 2011; accepted

blication Dec 14, 2011; available ahead of print Feb 9, 2012.

for reprints: Thomas Ng, MD, 2 Dudley St, Suite 470, Providence, RI 02905

ail: [email protected]).

23/$36.00

ht � 2012 by The American Association for Thoracic Surgery

016/j.jtcvs.2011.12.031

The Journal of Thoracic and Ca

transmission (such as cytomegalovirus, Epstein-Barr virus,and human immunodeficiency virus), and lower risk of can-cer recurrence.2

Perioperative blood transfusion has been studied in lungcancer with some authors showing a deleterious effect onsurvival3-8 whereas others have not.9-13 Many of thesestudies, however, involve a heterogeneous group ofpatients in terms of stage and extent of resection. Inaddition, there are no published reports evaluating theaffects of LD blood on lung cancer survival. The aim ofour study was to determine whether transfusion of LDblood affected disease-free and overall survival in a uniformgroup of patients with stage I non–small cell lung cancer re-sected by lobectomy.

METHODSFrom a prospective database, we evaluated all patients with pathologic

stage I non–small cell lung cancer resected by lobectomy. Patients under-

going sublobar resection, sleeve lobectomy, or pneumonectomy and pa-

tients receiving preoperative or postoperative chemotherapy were

excluded. Staging positron emission tomography and mediastinoscopy

were routinely performed before pulmonary resection. During lobectomy,

mediastinal lymph node sampling was performed. All surgical procedures

were performed by a single surgeon (T.N.). Patients who received allogenic

LD red cells (in-hospital or within 30 days of surgery) were compared with

those who received no transfusion. Leukocyte reduction of red cells was

performed before storage using either a whole blood in-line filter (Sepacell

RZ2000; Fenwal, Deerfield, Ill) or a red cell in-line filter (RCM1 filter;

PALL Medical, Covina, Calif). These filters consistently manufacture

leukocyte-reduced red cell concentrates that meet the Food and Drug

rdiovascular Surgery c Volume 143, Number 4 815

Page 2: Leukocyte-depleted blood transfusion is associated with decreased survival in resected early-stage lung cancer

TABLE 1. Patient characteristics

Characteristic

Transfusion*

(n ¼ 63)

No transfusion

(n ¼ 298)

P

value

Age years (percentile) 74 (66,78) 67 (60,75) <.001

Age>70 y 40 (63.5%) 115 (38.6%) <.001

Male 31 (49.2%) 130 (43.6%) .418

Hemoglobin g/dL

(percentile)

12.6 (11.5, 13.9) 13.5 (12.5, 14.4) .001

FEV1 L (percentile) 1.85 (1.47, 2.18) 2.07 (1.64, 2.45)y .029

Percent predicted FEV1

(percentile)

82 (64, 95) 84 (70, 99)y .333

Percent predicted

FEV1<60%

12 (19.0%) 36 (12.1%)y .142

Percent predicted DLCO

(percentile)

70 (55,84)z 79 (64,92)x .008

Percent predicted

DLCO<60%

21 (35.0%)z 50 (17.4%)x .002

EBL, mL (percentile) 250 (100, 500) 100 (50, 200) <.001

No. N2/N3 stations sampled

(percentile)

3 (3, 4) 3 (2, 4) .337

No. N2/N3 stations sampled

(count)

1 5 (7.9%) 30 (10.1%) .590

Abbreviation and AcronymLD ¼ leukocyte-depleted

General Thoracic Surgery Ng et al

GTS

Administration’s specification of less than 5 3 106 leukocytes per unit.

Since 2001, only LD blood has been used for transfusion at our institution.

In this study, there were no set criteria to trigger transfusion. The decision

to transfuse was at the discretion of the physician.

Patient follow-up was performed every 4 months for the first 2 years,

then every 6 months from years 3 to 5, then yearly thereafter. Time zero

was defined as the time of surgery. First radiographic evidence of recurrent

disease was used to define the time to recurrence. Pathologic confirmation

of recurrent disease was not mandatory in cases in which the clinical and

radiographic evaluation was clearly consistent with recurrence. Recurrent

disease was categorized as local if recurrence was found at the surgical

margins, regional if recurrence was within the ipsilateral thoracic cavity,

mediastinum, or supraclavicular region, and distant if recurrencewas found

outside the local and regional zones. Death events were confirmed using the

Social Security Death Index. Patients alive and without recurrent disease

were censored at the time of their last known follow-up.

Primary outcomes of our study were disease-free and overall survival.

Disease-free survival was defined as the time from surgery to first disease

recurrence. Overall survival was defined as the time from surgery to death.

Mortality was defined as any death occurring in-hospital or within 30 days

of surgery. Staging of the patient’s disease was according to the American

Joint Commission for Cancer, seventh edition, staging for lung cancer, with

stage I being divided into IA (tumor size� 3 cm and without visceral pleu-

ral invasion) and IB (tumor size>3 cm and� 5 cm but� 2 cm away from

the main carina, or tumor� 5 cm that invades the visceral pleura or causes

atelectasis not involving the entire lung).14

Continuous variables were reported as median with 25th and 75th per-

centiles and compared using the Mann-Whitney U test. Categorical vari-

ables were reported as count with the corresponding proportion and

compared using the c2 or Fisher’s exact test. Survival was estimated using

the Kaplan-Meier method and compared using the log–rank test. Multivar-

iate analysis by Cox regression was used to identify independent risk fac-

tors for disease-free and overall survival, entering variables with a P value

of< .10 found at univariate analysis. All tests were 2-tailed. The statistic

software SPSS 19.0 for Windows (SPSS, Inc, Chicago, Ill) was used for

data analysis. Our institutional review board approved this study and

waived consent inasmuch as this study was a retrospective review of data

from our prospective database and the treatment received by all patients

represented the standard of care.

2 6 (9.5%) 48 (16.1%)

3 26 (41.3%) 103 (34.6%)

4 16 (25.4%) 79 (26.5%)

5 10 (15.9%) 38 (12.8%)

Tumor size cm (percentile) 3.0 (1.5, 3.3) 2.2 (1.5, 3.0) .481

Cell type

Adenocarcinoma 43 (68.3%) 187 (62.8%) .514

Squamous cell 12 (19.0%) 69 (23.2%)

Large cell 6 (9.5%) 21 (7.0%)

Bronchoalveolar 2 (3.2%) 21 (7.0%)

Stage

IA 29 (46.0%) 170 (57.0%) .110

IB 34 (54.0%) 128 (43.0%)

Percentile, Indicates 25th and 75th percentiles; FEV1, forced expiratory volume in 1

second; DLCO, diffusion capacity of lung for carbon monoxide; EBL, estimated

blood loss. *Transfusion of leukocyte-depleted packed red blood cells. yFEV1 not

measured in 1 patient. zDLCO not measured in 3 patients. xDLCO not measured in

10 patients.

RESULTSFrom September 2001 to December 2009, 361 patients

underwent resection for pathologic stage I non–small celllung cancer by lobectomy. Survival was analyzed in 361 pa-tients, 63 (17%) who received LD blood transfusions and298 (83%) who did not receive a transfusion. No patientsin this study received platelet, fresh frozen plasma, or autol-ogous blood transfusions. Median follow-up time was 48months.

Comparison between the 2 groups is shown in Table 1.The transfusion group was older, had a lower preoperativehemoglobin level, a lower percent predicted diffusion ca-pacity of lung for carbon monoxide, and a greater operativeblood loss. For the transfusion group, the median

816 The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surg

hemoglobin level at the time of transfusion was 8.2 g/dL(range, 6.0-10.0 g/dL) and the median number of unitstransfused was 2 (range, 1-7). Indications for transfusion in-cluded return to the operating room for bleeding in 4 pa-tients and symptomatic anemia in the other 59 patients.Comparison of postoperative complications between the 2groups is given in Table 2. The incidence of postoperativebleeding and postoperative death were higher in the transfu-sion group; with both complications not directly due to theblood transfusion itself.

Of the 17 patients in the transfusion group with recur-rence, 10 had pathologic confirmation and recurrenceswere local in 2, regional in 7, and distant in 8. Of the 30 pa-tients in the no transfusion group with recurrence, 18 hadpathologic confirmation and recurrences were local in 3,

ery c April 2012

Page 3: Leukocyte-depleted blood transfusion is associated with decreased survival in resected early-stage lung cancer

TABLE 2. Postoperative complications

Complication

Transfusion*

(n ¼ 63)

No transfusion

(n ¼ 298)

P

value

Atrial fibrillation 7 (11.1%) 22 (7.4%) .323

Bleeding (return to operating

room)

4 (6.3%) 0 .001

Pneumonia 3 (4.8%) 6 (2.0%) .195

Atelectasis requiring

bronchoscopy

2 (3.2%) 8 (2.7%) .235

Urinary tract infection 2 (3.2%) 2 (0.7%) .142

Empyema 2 (3.2%) 3 (1.0%) .211

Ileus 1 (1.6%) 1 (0.3%) .319

Myocardial infarction 1 (1.6%) 0 .175

Gastrointestinal bleed 1 (1.6%) 0 .175

Prolonged air leak (>7 days) 0 14 (4.7%) .142

Chylothorax 0 2 (0.7%) 1.000

Alcohol withdrawal 0 2 (0.7%) 1.000

Cerebral vascular accident 0 2 (0.7%) 1.000

Wound infection 0 1 (0.3%) 1.000

Perforated cecum 0 1 (0.3%) 1.000

Clostridium difficile 0 1 (0.3%) 1.000

Renal failure requiring dialysis 0 1 (0.3%) 1.000

Postoperative mortality 3 (4.8%)y 2 (0.7%)z .039

Patient with any complication 24 (38.1%) 60 (20.1%) .002

*Transfusion of leukocyte-depleted packed red blood cells. yDeath from pneumonia

in 2 and myocardial infarction in 1. zDeath from pneumonia and cerebral vascular

accident.

TABLE 3. Risk factors for survival, univariate analysis

Characteristic

Five-year

DFS

P value

DFS*

Five-year

OS

P value

OS*

Age

>70 79.2% .771 65.8% .001

�70 83.3% 83.4%

Gender

Male 74.8% .014 66.9% .001

Female 87.6% 83.6%

AnemiayYes 73.9% .025 63.6% .027

No 84.3% 80.1%

Percent predicted FEV1

<60% 70.3% .158 66.1% .289

�60% 83.9% 77.4%

Percent predicted DLCO

<60% 80.4% .897 73.1% .648

�60% 81.9% 76.7%

No. N2/N3 stations sampled

�4 81.6% .760 75.8% .654

<4 80.2% 74.5%

TransfusionzYes 58.0% <.001 53.5% <.001

No 86.8% 81.1%

Stage

IA 90.3% <.001 87.7% <.001

IB 70.7% 62.0%

DFS,Disease-free survival;OS, overall survival; FEV1, forced expiratory volume in 1

second; DLCO, diffusion capacity of lung for carbon monoxide. *Survival estimated

by Kaplan Meier method, compared using log–rank test. yWorld Health Organization

definition: male hemoglobin<13 g/dL; female hemoglobin<12 g/dL. zTransfusionof leukocyte-depleted packed red blood cells.

Ng et al General Thoracic Surgery

GTS

regional in 10, and distant in 17. There was no difference inthe pattern of recurrence between the 2 groups (P ¼ .817).Univariate analysis for factors affecting disease-free andoverall survival is shown in Table 3. Male gender, preoper-ative anemia, LD blood transfusion, and higher stage wereadverse factors for disease-free survival whereas olderage, male gender, preoperative anemia, LD blood transfu-sion, and higher stage were adverse factors for overall sur-vival. With multivariate analysis, only LD blood transfusionand higher stage remained adverse risk factors for freedomfrom disease, whereas male gender, LD blood transfusion,and higher stage remained adverse risk factors for overallsurvival (Table 4). Stratifying for stage, the negative effectof LD blood transfusion on disease-free and overall survivalis illustrated in Figure 1 for stage IA and Figure 2 forstage IB.

DISCUSSIONThere are conflicting data within the literature regarding

the effect of blood transfusion on lung cancer recurrenceand survival. However, many of the studies that show no ad-verse effects of blood transfusion evaluate a heterogeneousgroup of patients, including patients with various extents ofresection and stages of disease. In regard to the heterogene-ity in the extent of resection, sublobar resection in tumorsize greater than 2 cm in a good surgical candidate is likelysuboptimal, and until the result of the ongoing randomized

The Journal of Thoracic and Ca

Cancer and Leukemia Group B 140503 trial is known, it re-mains unknown whether sublobar resection is appropriatefor tumors sized 2 cm or less. The Lung Cancer StudyGroup published the only randomized trial evaluatinglobectomy versus sublobar resection for T1 N0 (�3 cm) tu-mors, finding a worse recurrence-free survival and overallsurvival (1-sided test determined a priori) when sublobar re-section was performed.15 Because wedge resection is un-likely to result in blood transfusion, transfusion trials thatinclude sublobar resection may result in a bias toward worsesurvival for the nontransfused group. In regard to the hetero-geneity in the stage of disease, owing to the poor baselinesurvival in patients with advanced stage lung cancer, the ad-verse affects of blood transfusion may not be evident in tri-als that include these patients.Studies with a more homogeneous group of patients,

evaluating those with stage I disease only, overwhelminglyshow worse survival in patients receiving blood transfu-sion.3,5,7,8 In a prospective study by Nosotti andassociates,7 evaluating a well-defined group of patientswith stage I disease undergoing lobectomy (excluding sub-lobar resection), blood transfusion resulted in decreaseddisease-free and overall survival. Inasmuch as randomized

rdiovascular Surgery c Volume 143, Number 4 817

Page 4: Leukocyte-depleted blood transfusion is associated with decreased survival in resected early-stage lung cancer

TABLE 4. Adverse risk factor for survival; multivariate analysis by Cox regression

Characteristic P value DFS Odds ratio DFS (95% CI) P value OS Odds ratio OS (95% CI)

Age>70 y — — .067 1.58 (0.97-2.58)

Anemia* .100 1.64 (0.91-2.96) .243 1.34 (0.82-2.17)

Gender, male .079 1.71 (0.94-3.10) .018 1.18 (1.10-2.94)

Transfusiony .003 2.46 (1.35-4.48) .001 2.26 (1.37-3.72)

Stage (IB) .001 2.90 (1.51-5.56) <.001 3.04 (1.76-5.26)

DFS, Disease-free survival; CI, confidence interval; OS, overall survival. *World Health Organization definition: male hemoglobin<13 g/dL; female hemoglobin<12 g/dL.

yTransfusion of leukocyte-depleted packed red blood cells.

General Thoracic Surgery Ng et al

GTS

trials on this topic are unethical, this study by Nosotti andcolleagues7 represents the strongest evidence currentlyavailable given its prospective nature and the homogeneousgroup of patients that was evaluated. However, no trial hasassessed whether LD blood transfusion similarly affectslung cancer survival, which is the objective of our currentstudy. As discussed in the introduction, leukocytes in trans-fused blood have been implicated in transfusion-related im-mune modulation, which in turn may increase the risk ofcancer recurrence. Our study indicates that transfusion ofLD blood is associated with worse disease-free and overallsurvival. It would seem that the negative effect of bloodtransfusion on lung cancer survival is not solely due to leu-kocytes and that other factors in blood, currently not known,are involved.

The relationship between LD red cell transfusion andcancer survival has been explored in gastrointestinal malig-nant diseases, particularly in patients undergoing resectionfor colon cancer. Randomized trials by van de Watering,16

Jensen,17 Skanberg,18 Lange,19 and their associates, com-paring LD blood versus non-LD blood, showed no onco-logic advantage to LD blood inasmuch as recurrence-free

FIGURE 1. Effect of leukocyte-depleted red cell transfusion for stage IA stra

95% confidence intervals.

818 The Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surg

and overall survival were not different. These trials also per-formed nonrandomized comparisons between the trans-fused group (LD and non-LD blood) versus thenontransfused group, finding worse survival outcomes inpatients receiving transfusion. These results are in agree-ment with the results from our study and carry significantimplications for clinical practice. Blood transfusion, evenof LD blood, should be avoided whenever possible. Ahigh threshold for transfusion should be maintained. Metic-ulous hemostasis during each step of pulmonary resectionbecomes even more important from an oncologic perspec-tive. The result of this study has led to changes in ourown clinical practice. Since 2009, when the data of thisstudy matured, our transfusion requirement in patients un-dergoing major pulmonary resection has decreased to10% (18/174), which compares favorably with the transfu-sion requirement of 17% seen in this current study.

The strength of our study lies in the uniform group of pa-tients evaluated (stage I, lobectomy only, surgery performedby a single surgeon), the use of the new seventh edition stag-ing system, and the long duration of follow-up. Our studydoes have several limitations. First, this is a retrospective

tum. A, Disease-free survival. B, Overall survival. Vertical lines represent

ery c April 2012

Page 5: Leukocyte-depleted blood transfusion is associated with decreased survival in resected early-stage lung cancer

FIGURE 2. Effect of leukocyte-depleted red cell transfusion for stage IB stratum. A, Disease-free survival. B, Overall survival. Vertical lines represent

95% confidence intervals.

Ng et al General Thoracic Surgery

GTS

study and despite evaluating a uniform group of patients,there may be other factors we did not control for that canaffect survival. Also, data regarding the time to recurrenceand the existence of recurrence in a patient who has diedis less accurate in retrospective studies. However, a random-ized trial would not be ethical inasmuch as it would be un-acceptable to administer a transfusion without a clinicalindication or to withhold transfusion from a patient whoneeded blood. Although retrospectively analyzed, our dataare collected prospectively, which allows for a more accu-rate data set than data acquired retrospectively. Second,the number of patients in our study is small. The small num-ber did not allow for more detailed analysis, such as the ef-fect of increasing number of units transfused on lung cancersurvival. However, despite the small number of patients,owing to the large difference in survival, our data stronglysuggest a negative effect on lung cancer survival with LDblood transfusion.

References1. Weber RS, Jabbour N, Martin RC 2nd. Anemia and transfusions in patients un-

dergoing surgery for cancer. Ann Surg Oncol. 2008;15:34-45.

2. Bordin JO, Heddle NM, BlajchmanMA. Biologic effects of leukocytes present in

transfused cellular blood products. Blood. 1994;84:1703-21.

3. Tartter PI, Burrows L, Kirschner P. Perioperative blood transfusion adversely af-

fects prognosis after resection of stage I (subset N0) non–oat cell lung cancer. J

Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1984;88:659-62.

4. Hyman NH, Foster RS Jr, DeMeules JE, Costanza MC. Blood transfusions and

survival after lung cancer resection. Am J Surg. 1985;149:502-7.

5. Little AG, Wu HS, Ferguson MK, Ho CH, Bowers VD, Segalin A, et al. Perio-

perative blood transfusion adversely affects prognosis of patients with stage I

non-small-cell lung cancer. Am J Surg. 1990;160:630-2.

6. Piantadosi S, Moores DW, McKneally MF. The adverse effect of perioperative

blood transfusion in lung cancer. Chest. 1994;106:382S-4S.

The Journal of Thoracic and Ca

7. Nosotti M, Rebulla P, Riccardi D, Baisi A, Bellaviti N, Rosso L, et al. Correlation

between perioperative blood transfusion and prognosis of patients subjected to

surgery for stage I lung cancer. Chest. 2003;124:102-7.

8. Panagopoulos ND, Karakantza M, Koletsis E, Apostolakis E,

Sakellaropoulos GC, Filos KS, et al. Influence of blood transfusions and preop-

erative anemia on long-term survival in patients operated for non-small cell lung

cancer. Lung Cancer. 2008;62:273-80.

9. Pastorino U, Valente M, Cataldo I, Lequaglie C, Ravasi G. Perioperative blood

transfusion and prognosis of resected stage Ia lung cancer. Eur J Cancer Clin On-

col. 1986;22:1375-8.

10. Keller SM, Groshen S, Martini N, Kaiser LR. Blood transfusion and lung cancer

recurrence. Cancer. 1988;62:606-10.

11. Pena CM, Rice TW, Ahmad M, Medendorp SV. Significance of perioperative

blood transfusions in patients undergoing resection of stage I and II non-small-

cell lung cancers. Chest. 1992;102:84-8.

12. Rzyman W, Dziadziuszko R, Skokowski J, Wilimski R, Raiter A,

Szymanowska A, et al. The influence of blood transfusion on survival in operated

non–small cell lung cancer patients. J ThoracCardiovasc Surg. 2003;126:755-60.

13. Berardi R, Brunelli A, Tamburrano T, Verdecchia L, Onofri A, Zuccatosta L,

et al. Perioperative anemia and blood transfusions as prognostic factors in pa-

tients undergoing resection for non-small cell lung cancers. Lung Cancer.

2005;49:371-6.

14. Goldstraw P, Crowley J, Chansky K, Giroux DJ, Groome PA, Rami-Porta R, et al.

The IASLC Lung Cancer Staging Project: proposals for the revision of the TNM

stage groupings in the forthcoming (seventh) edition of the TNM classification of

malignant tumours. J Thorac Oncol. 2007;2:706-14.

15. Ginsberg RJ, Rubinstein LV. Randomized trial of lobectomy versus limited resec-

tion for T1 N0 non-small cell lung cancer. Ann Thorac Surg. 1995;60:615-22.

16. van de Watering LM, Brand A, Houbiers JG, Klein KranenbargWM, Hermans J,

van de Velde C. Perioperative blood transfusions, with or without allogeneic leu-

cocytes, relate to survival, not to cancer recurrence. Br J Surg. 2001;88:267-72.

17. Jensen LS, Puho E, Pedersen L, Mortensen FV, Sorensen HT. Long-term survival

after colorectal surgery associated with buffy-coat-poor and leucocyte-depleted

blood transfusion: a follow-up study. Lancet. 2005;365:681-2.

18. Skanberg J, Lundholm K, Haglind E. Effects of blood transfusion with leucocyte

depletion on length of hospital stay, respiratory assistance and survival after cu-

rative surgery for colorectal cancer. Acta Oncol. 2007;46:1123-30.

19. Lange MM, van Hilten JA, van de Watering LM, Bijnen BA, Roumen RM,

Putter H, et al. Leucocyte depletion of perioperative blood transfusion does not

affect long-term survival and recurrence in patients with gastrointestinal cancer.

Br J Surg. 2009;96:734-40.

rdiovascular Surgery c Volume 143, Number 4 819