Let the Sunshine In: An Assessment of the Open Government Partnership
Let the sunshine in, and let the data out! a revolution of ... · szabolcs dancs, acting director...
Transcript of Let the sunshine in, and let the data out! a revolution of ... · szabolcs dancs, acting director...
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
Let the sunshine in, and let the data out!
– a revolution of library standards,
copyright (and access policies?)
Szabolcs Dancs
acting director of national library services at NSL
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
Revolution of Access
Digitisation? What for?
e.g. tool for refuting [refutability: requirement of scientific statements and theories (i.e. not falsifiable ones are unscientific) (Karl Popper)]
A professor vs a teenager
Professor Richard Jensen (2002): “No Irish Need Apply” signs and ads were only a myth, and there were no significant discrimination against the Irish in the job market in the late 18th and the early 19th century
14 year old Rebecca Fried (2015): "Just for the fun of it, I started to run a few quick searches on an online newspaper database that I found on Google, I was really surprised when I started finding examples of NINA ads in old 19th-century newspapers pretty quickly."
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
„A quick search”
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
Revolution of Cataloguing
Statement of International Cataloguing Principles ICP 2009
1. Convenience of the user 2. Common usage 3. Representation 4. Accuracy 5. Sufficiency and necessity 6. Significance 7. Economy 8. Consistency and
standardization 9. Integration
ICP 2016 + 10. Interoperability. Ensure reuse of bib. and auth. data within and outside the library community. 11. Openness. Restrictions on data should be minimal. 12. Accessibility. The access to bib. and auth. Data should comply with international standards for accessibility 13. Rationality. Defensible and not arbitrary rules.
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
Interoperability!
Openness!
Accessibility!
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
(R)evolution of library reference models
• high-level conceptual reference model developed within an entity-relationship modelling framework
• the consolidation of former IFLA conceptual models: FRBR, FRAD, FRSAD
• designed to be used in linked data environments
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
Overview of Relationships
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
RDA-HU
• interinstitutional working group with 21 members, from December 2017
Responsibilities:
• coordinating translation and implementation of RDA
• terminology, training materials, training courses
• HUNMARC-MARC 21: mapping, translation, conversion preparations
• technical conversion (test environment, technical specification, data publication in RDF, etc.)
8
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
Outcomes
translation and review of ICP and IFLA LRM
translation of RDA Reference (old version)
HUNMARC-MARC 21 mapping (incl. instructions for automated data enrichment)
MARC 21 translation (bib., auth. and holding fields, relator terms)
training materials, e-learning
EURIG Meeting and international conference in NSL (May 2019)
Linked Data pilot project
9
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA 10
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA 11
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
KOHA (Molnár-athon) Project
• partly inspired by RIMMF3, Jane-athons („hackathon for creating RDA linked data about the works of Jane Austen and related resources”)
KOHA: open source ILS we use as
1. sandbox: modelling technical implementation in MARC 21 environment
2. training tool: demonstrating RDA-based description processes in MARC 21 (before that: RIMMF3; screenshots: Virtua, OliSuite)
12
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
Linked Data Pilot Project
Aim:
• to figure it out how we shall do it down the road
• RDA training: demonstrating the purpose of implementing the new standard
Project steps:
• data set related to Ferenc Molnár was created in KOHA (in MARC 21 with RDA spec. fields)
• converted in BIBFRAME
• published through Virtuoso
• can be queried using Flint SPARQL Editor
13
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA 14
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
Revolution of terminology
15
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA 16
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA 17
• a coherent and comprehensive terminology (documentation, libraries, archives, media, museums, records management, conservation as well as legal aspects of documentation)
• full translation?
• translation of a subset (library terms?)
• published in 2017 and built on obsolete models (FRBR, FRAD, FRSAD) a revision is anticipated for IFLA LRM-compliance
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
Orphan Work Directive: A nice try of the copyright octopus
Sources of Diligent Search in Gov. Decr. 138/2014 (IV. 30)
a) the database of the Hungarian National Union Catalogue (MOKKA);
b) legal deposit, Hungarian National Bibliography;
c) library catalogues and authority files maintained by libraries and other institutions;
d) the publishers' and authors' associations;
e) existing databases and registries, WATCH (Writers, Artists and their Copyright Holders), the ISBN (International Standard Book Number) and databases listing books in print;
f) the databases of the relevant collecting societies;
g) sources that integrate multiple databases and registries, including VIAF (Virtual International Authority Files) and ARROW (Accessible Registries of Rights Information and Orphan Works);
h) database of the National Electronic Document Delivery System.
18
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
8 sources = 8 tentacles of the Copyright Clearance octopus
a) the database of the Hungarian National Union Catalogue (MOKKA);
b) legal deposit, Hungarian National Bibliography;
c) library catalogues and authority files maintained by libraries and other institutions;
d) the publishers' and authors' associations;
e) existing databases and registries, WATCH (Writers, Artists and their Copyright Holders), the ISBN (International Standard Book Number) and databases listing books in print;
f) the databases of the relevant collecting societies;
g) sources that integrate multiple databases and registries, including VIAF (Virtual International Authority Files) and ARROW (Accessible Registries of Rights Information and Orphan Works);
h) database of the National Electronic Document Delivery System.
19
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
20
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
21
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
Not cooperating tentacles
Aim:
• automated queries of relevant databases
• automated data exchange with EUIPO database
Problems:
• lack of relevant databases (those of listed in the directive)
• lack of relevant databases with standard interface
• no use of standards (ONIX)
• lack of relevant metadata in library databases (requirement of autopsy; in the future: RDA? GDPR?)
22
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
DSM – another nice try?
Directive on copyright in the Digital Single Market (DSM Directive) – voted by the Council on 15th of April, published on 17th of May
• a new regime enabling easier access to works defined as out-of-commerce
• text and data mining exception serves as an opportunity to establish projects such as Corpus in BnF (supporting researchers in data mining of copyrighted materials [e.g. legal deposit])
23
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
“Access problem” – “Let the user in!”
The Good Example of the Rijksmuseum
Digitized works available
- in high quality (high resolution, TIFFs)
- published through Wikimedia
- in Creative Commons “0” licence (even for commercial use)
new vision (see:
Convenience of the
user) new strategy
new business
models new access
policies
NATIONAL SZÉCHÉNYI LIBRARY, HUNGARY
SZABOLCS DANCS, ACTING DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL LIBRARY SERVICES AT NSL
LET THE SUNSHINE IN, AND LET THE DATA OUT! – A REVOLUTION OF LIBRARY STANDARDS, COPYRIGHT (AND
ACCESS POLICIES?)
8TH COLLOQUIUM OF LIBRARY AND INFORMATION EXPERTS OF THE V4+
18 JUNE 2019, UNIVERSITY LIBRARY IN BRATISLAVA
Thank you!