Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
-
Upload
uwe-graduate-school -
Category
Documents
-
view
220 -
download
0
Transcript of Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
1/48
Gina Wisker
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
2/48
Some thoughtsThe best masters or doctorate is the
one you finish and hand in.
2
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
3/48
This research and these ideas arise from working atpostgraduate level, then with postgraduates
AskingWhat makes good research learning?
How do you know you are working at a conceptualcritical and creative enough level for successfulpostgraduate work?
What are the signs of this and how do they relate tothe stages of the research learning?
How do you move beyond stuck places? How can supervisors, communities and your own
behaviours nudge the learning development andrecognition of it?
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
4/48
Overview Threshold concepts (Meyer and Land 2006)
Conceptual threshold crossings (Wisker, Kiley, Robinson 2008--)
Early work (Wisker, Kiley, Trafford & Leshem) has started toidentify threshold concepts and conceptual thresholds at theresearch education level (EARLI 2007, QPR 2006, 2008, Threshold
concepts conferences 2006,2008, 2010, 2012; EARLI 2009) Postgraduates experiences with threshold concepts and
conceptual threshold crossing
Supervisors experiences of identifying students conceptual
threshold crossing and
nudging
them across. 4
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
5/48
Conceptual Threshold Crossing in Doctoral Learning
Journeys
We developed the notion ofconceptual threshold
crossings to identify moments when postgraduate students
make learning leaps and begin to work at a more
conceptual critical and creative fashion- Developed from threshold concepts in the disciplines
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
6/48
The absolutely essential concepts for understanding how knowledgeis constructed and the world is seen in a discipline
Akin to a portal, opening up a new and previously inaccessible wayof thinking about something. It represents a transformed way ofunderstanding, or interpreting, or viewing something without whichthe learner cannot progress. (Meyer & Land, 2003)
Threshold concept
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
7/48
Threshold concept
Transformative
Irreversible
Integrative
Troublesome Knowledge
Conceptual threshold crossing - learning leaps
Ontological change
Epistemological contribution
Threshold concept & conceptual threshold
crossing
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
8/48
Wisker, Kiley, Robinson, Trafford & Leshem identified threshold
concepts and conceptual thresholds at the research education
level (EARLI 2007, QPR 2006, 2008, Threshold Conceptsconferences 2006, 2008)
Doctoral learning journeys 2007-2010
Survey (350 doc students) Journalling and narrative interviews 30 down to 20 students over
3 yrs
Interviewing 20 supervisors
11 examiners
Parallel project
Interviewing students , supervisors and examiners internationally
Swedish project- interviewing 40 postgraduate students and
supervisors (including medical scientists) 8
Early work and DLJ
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
9/48
Research questions
How dodoctoral students signify their awareness of workingconceptually?
How do students conceptual grasp and comments display
crossing of subject-specific and generic doctoral thresholds?
How do supervisors recognise students conceptual grasp ofresearch?
What strategies and activities do supervisors use to encourageor nudge conceptual grasp by doctoral students?
How do examiners identify and assess conceptually-robust
research outcomes and skills developments? 9
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
10/48
The Journey
Intellectual /cognitive
Ontological
Personal / EmotionalProfessional
Instrumental:meeting courserequirements
Research learning journeys: multi-dimensional
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
11/48
Ontology / Identity
We argue that when a candidates behaviour
changes it suggests that they have crossed aparticular conceptual threshold and that thisindicates an ontological shift, a change in identity
Behaviours such as:Working conceptually, critically and creatively rather
than just busily
Production of an abstract and a conclusions chapterwhich deal with concepts not merely facts
Being able to put forward an argument supported by
evidence
11
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
12/48
Question Please consider
Does the idea of
crossing a threshold,
making a learning leap,
working at a new level,
working at a conceptual, critical, creative level
Sound like a way of describing your own experiences ofkey moments in your development as a learner,particularly as a researcher, a postgraduate?
12
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
13/48
emes rom e survey odoctoral students in the UK Discovery the identification of a new theory, theorist or
concept that encapsulates thinking
Synthesis the bringing together of two or more conceptsto create a new concept
Verbal the discovery of new ways of thinking as a resultof discussion or the recognition of knowledge sufficient todefend a position
However-
Mechanical almost superficial adoption of conceptualposition to satisfy requirements of discipline
InnateI always thought this way
13
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
14/48
learning moments/ crossing conceptual thresholds
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
15/48
Learning moments where students indicate
conceptual threshold crossingIn both the survey and interviews, postgraduate students have used a
variety of metaphors to describe their learning journeys andexperiences.
Learning leaps are often described metaphorically, in visual terms (alightbulb moment) or kinaesthetic terms (things clicked into place)
as are moments where students feel they are stuck, e.g. I hit a brickwall.
The learning moments are more likely to occur when researchers :
Identify research questions; Determine relationships between existing theories and their own work; devise methodology and engage with methods; Analyse and interpret data See self as researcher, practitioner within field, e.g. sociologist Become part of academic community Contribute knowledge, engaging in debate Take ownership of and responsibility for work Reach conclusions - conceptual as well as factual.
Present to peers and others. 15
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
16/48
Student responses: crossing a
conceptual threshold....
In terms of learning moments I think you have thosesmall or medium moments every now and again, dont
you, when you read and you are exposed to new ideas
and you think ah now, Ive got it and then actually acouple of weeks later youre a bit further but then youhave another one of those moments and so you kind of
gradually I guess get closer and closer to the final
thing, the final shape of your theories and ideas aboutit.
(2nd year Philosophy student)
16
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
17/48
A couple of weeks ago I found that things have stoppedmentally I found myself up against a brick wall I just feltthat I was kind of stuck and it wasnt moving and it was all
bitty, Id done all these chunks of work but I couldnt reallysee how they fitted together and yeah so I reached quite acrisis point. Especially when I got negative feedback I just
felt quite down hearted about it and, but like I say I thinkhaving the supervision, talking it through, taking a step
back from everything, taking it to bits and being questionedabout everything and then having to simplify everything, inorder to present. I mean over a couple of days - mysupervision was one day and my presentation was the nextday
I came out of that whole process feeling that I could kind ofsee it, I could see that there was shape there I can seeshapes.
(1st year Gender Studies student)
17
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
18/48
Well, actually, I wasnt talking about the thinking right, I wastalking about er I think more about the er I have the word, it is [?].To be more attuned to my task when I am coming here. So, I am
kind of collecting from the basket all the skills that I need to thetask. So, that is one thing. Er in the way of thinking er again, I feelthat I er, I tell you, I give you an example er yesterday night er Iwas going with in the car, we went to X , we were invited to X andsuddenly I heard, I saw the matrix that I want of the variables. I
said, yes, give me the paper, I have everything, you know. Likefrom this side and this side, I have everything written and it canbe also at home but if you are doing this brainstorming in thisatmosphere, I think that this thing can happen especially in timeslike that and this is something in the thinking in terms of er, er
joining variables and understanding like the er like thetriangulation which was much more clearer to me this time andthen I kind of said, ok triangulation this and this and this, youknow, so erI dont know if that answers more about the thinkinger process, ok.
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
19/48
A stage/stages when students develop project ownership andresearcher identity
New ideas- feeling the work becoming clever
Theoretical breakthrough-literature review
Fieldwork breakthrough Breakthrough in accepting supervisors guidance
New perspectives and more complex understanding enabled bydialogue, casting new light
A gradual process
A single process
A series of learning leaps
Identifying conceptual threshold crossings
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
20/48
Have there been moments when you are aware thatyour thinking , your understanding, your discoveryyour expression and articulation (any of those) havereached a higher level youve made a learningleap???
When was it?
How did it feel? How did you know?
Question Please consider
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
21/48
Becoming a researcher-identity
As time goes on and you start to, you almost
develop this skin that is academic and this personawithin yourself and as you get the feedback thatcomes back andyoure thinking about youre doingthis the right way and so you begin to start, its likewatching a butterfly I suppose emerge from
chrysalis pupa or pupa chrysalis and so on like thatand so you begin to develop and I think as that goeson then you gain a certain amount of confidence.
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
22/48
Taking ownershipThe balance in the relationship between us is tiltingslightly as well because where I was prepared to be guided,
going back to assignment one where you are at thebeginning stage, the actual balance itself is quite, its moreof an equal partnership in the discussions now.
So Im coming with more and more ideas and more andmore thoughts and more about, you know, can we meetquickly to discuss this as this has come up as opposed towaiting tilthe next session when we will sit and discuss.
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
23/48
Becoming part of an
Academic Community
A big learning experience for me has been that doing adoctorate is not a search for the truth but is really justtaking part in a conversation. This doesnt stop methinking that an 'expert' knows all of the answers and
I suppose this is about confidence on my part [Butthey dont have my experience] So how can they knoweverything? and what I have to offer is just asimportant as theirs, and I suppose that is also a
learning experience in that when I sit with the 'learned'in a conference I feel confident in challenging them asI now see myself as a peer.
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
24/48
As time goes on and you start to, you almost develop this skin
that is academic and this persona within yourself and as you
get the feedback that comes back and youre thinking about
youre doing this the right way and so you begin to start, its
like watching a butterfly I suppose emerge from chrysalis pupa
or pupa chrysalis and so on like that and so you begin todevelop and I think as that goes on then you gain a certain
amount of confidence. (S3)
Transformation
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
25/48
Integration
And then there are these wonderful moments where things just slot
into place, but only after a long engagement and in depthknowledge then suddenly all relates to each other, like my
argument is revealing itself to me. Of course this isntthe case I
cantreally explain what happens, but it does feel like the pieces of
my puzzle physically move towards each other. (S10)
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
26/48
Our work with supervisors to support the developmentof the literature review/theoretical perspectiveschapter crucial moment for learning leap conceptual
threshold crossing
Where students begin to see their own work in adialogue with
Theorists Others using similar/ same theories in critical practice
See how they contribute to the field
Literature review
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
27/48
NudgesSome of the visual prompts and
metaphors I use to support students
thinking then acting
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
28/48
Identifying a research question
Whole cake whole field, all the questions you can ask in all the ways
our slice of the cake
boundaries
A di t ti /th i i b ildi
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
29/48
Research is a journey
A dissertation/thesis is a buildin
It looks mapped but -risks, surprises,deviations Ordered, coherent, organised, link
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
30/48
(student) A beautifully architected building is fairly
misleading. It is the work, the result of being up hereon the journey.
No wonder it is so daunting for the rest of us to considerconstructing such a building, because we are notactually anywhere near where we could build it. A mudhut is as much as I could hand in at the moment.
30
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
31/48
Stuckness, troublesome issues and
emotional resilience Our research project with Education postgraduates on
troublesome encounters looked at
Intellectual and personal, emotional, moments of
stuckness and ways of managing and overcomingthem.
Some of these truly hold you up- find ways of
managing them and using them
Some of these are necessary a liminal space beforeenlightenment and breakthrough
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
32/48
I think a couple of weeks ago I found that things have stopped.
Partly because they actually had physically stopped and Ihavent
been able to get back to my PhD for a while but also mentally I
found myself up against a brick wall and felt that, I think I wasworried that I didnt have my conceptual framework or my
analytical framework ready I just felt that I was kind of stuck
and itwasntmoving and it was all bitty,Iddone all these chunks
of work but Icouldntreally see how they fitted together and yeahso I reached quite a crisis point. (1styear student, Gender studies)
Stuck places
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
33/48
Stuck placesAt this point I feel like I've reached a plateau - I nowknow exactly what I need to do to finish my work and doit well. It is like finally coming to an understanding ofwhere I am in my career and where I'm going and theconfidence that I can get there. However, I am also, for
the first time, more aware of just how little time I haveleft in my course. It seems the more I read, the more Ineed to read, because I can now pinpoint what exactly Idon't know and need to learn more about, but I havebegun to worry that the time constraints may limit just
how much I need to do. I have spoken with several of mycolleagues and they say they feel the same way. It's a bitof a mid-course panic.
C)what they are capable of and in terms of what they
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
34/48
C)what they are capable of and in terms of what theywrite I am very impressed. So often these are peoplewho are adults, they have problems, they have families,a couple of them have had crises.
Int) and that stops them from working at anythingother than university level?
Sup: It stops them from working at all, once they havefinished their coursework, and they have gone off todeal with their family issues.
34
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
35/48
1 Troublesome encounters project
2 Priceless- stuck places in writing project
Masters and doctoral Education students consideringwellbeing and emotional resilience
Working through stuck places in writing
Recognise feeling an imposter, unconfident, stuck is
all normalWork life balance
Determining strategies which enable you to step backsee the whole shape- return and renew energy and
focus , do something different/related to or unrelatedto project
use support from critical friends, family, community
Perseverence, self knowledge, confidence
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
36/48
Supervisors
Supervisors comments (from parallel research)on recognising students work that evidences thatthey have: acquired and owned various threshold concepts, and
crossed conceptual thresholds In the following discussions, posts and interviews,
supervisors identify their recognition of thresholdcrossing, and their thoughts about what nudgesstudents across.
How can they identify the crossing moments and thequalities?
How can they nudge? Please read and discuss theircomments and inputs-
what are YOUR views? 36
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
37/48
Support provided by supervisors and community
Confidence building
Suggestions on literature search
Encourage students to experiment
Students involvement with research community
(seminars, conferences, and group study)
37
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
38/48
A Indicators of change
A) I think er the skill of helping somebody through
this thought process in terms of research er camefrom my own PhD. I mean, it has to, er because Ithink that I had such a struggle and because I hadsuch a struggle, I knew where I was coming upagainst brick walls and er where I could have done
with understanding the process better as I wentalong. And so I think that it was out of my ownsort of conflicts that, that I recognised those inother people. Is, is being able to see that problemand then just sort of say, well, what do youthink? You know, which way do you think thatyou are going to go? and
this is the reason why I think you should know.
38
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
39/48
Supervisors:
Increased confidence
Well, theyve got an extra dose of confidence. Theyve
got an extra dose of clarity. Theyre more confident,
theyre clearer, and theyre probably very inspired to
go and do something else quickly, to take advantage of
those changes. I thinkthats right. (S8)
39
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
40/48
Writing
In terms of the reports they can give to you, you can
see theyve become more sophisticated in their
thought process, theyre more sophisticated in theiranalysis of what theyre looking at and as to how
theyre thinking (S9)
40
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
41/48
Improved writing
Well, there are times when students startbringing you written work that begins to look like
it could go in the final thesis, whereas initially itdoesnt. In that sense, you know, theres a point atwhich the first time you say to a student, Look
youve written something here which I could seecould go in the finalthesis,that for them is a very
significant moment, I think. In that sense theirwhole thinking has moved forward between thatand the last piece of written work (S7)
41
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
42/48
Conference presentation
They could be things that happen externally,
they could be somebody does a conference
presentation and they realise that their work iscomparable with other people presenting (S6)
42
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
43/48
Confidence building through challengingI thinkits very important that, you know, the supervisorsare able to challenge what the student is writing downand actually saying about the literature. Sometimesstudents are a bit frightened about critically appraising
otherpeoples work. its not until they get to the end oftheir PhD, when theyve transferred, and you say right,now its time to go back and have a look at this chapter,see what you think about thesepeoples writing now, andit comes back and its quite different. So I think there issomething in there about building confidence and I think
you can do that, you can try to do it early on.(S7)
43
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
44/48
Allow / encourage students to experiment
Well exactly, thats what I say, there is a risk
that you might lose some time but if you cometo realise thats not the best way to do things
then thats something thattheyve learnt (S8)
44
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
45/48
When they are writing thats when I work really hardwith the students. They send me each chaptersometimes several chapters. Its me that goes through
the threshold.
45
Overall what helps-
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
46/48
Overall what helps-
Ensuring a boundaried (doable) and conceptual
enough questionEarly focus on conceptual framework,
methodology and methodsVery close reading and focus on dialoguing with
experts in the literature review/theoreticalperspectives chapterOral prompting of conceptual, critical work
individually in supervisions and in groups
Prompt feedback encouraging conceptual andcritical workModels, dialogues, pointing out contradictions
and tensions and urging incorporation for criticalconceptual engagement
46
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
47/48
Encouragement of careful data analysis developingthemes, engaging with theories
Encouraging early writing and much editing-
sharing and reflection Focus on using the language of research learning
e.g. conceptual framework, and the ideas, theresearch and theories of learning e.g.
Metacognition Developing coping skills, perseverence, emotional
resilience Setting up and enabling communities to support ,
share, help develop each other maintainsmomentum through and beyond the masters anddoctorate
Kiley, M., & Mullins, G. (2006). Opening the black box: How examiners assess your thesis. InC Denholm & T Evans (Eds ) Doctorates downunder: Keys to successful doctoral study in
-
7/23/2019 Learning Journeys and Success (Wisker)
48/48
C. Denholm & T. Evans (Eds.), Doctorates downunder: Keys to successful doctoral study inAustralia and New Zealand(pp. 200-207). Melbourne: ACER.examiners approach theassessment of research theses. International Journal of
Kiley, M., & Wisker, G. (2008, June 2008). Now you see it, now you dont: Identifying andsupporting the achievement of doctoral work which embraces threshold concepts and crossesconceptual thresholds. Paper presented at the Threshold concepts: From theory to practice,
Queen's University, Kingston Ontario Canada. Kiley, M., & Wisker, G. (2010). Threshold concepts in research education and evidence of
threshold crossing. Higher Education Research and Development.
Mullins, G., & Kiley, M. (2002). 'It's a PhD, not a Nobel Prize': How experienced examinersassess research theses. Studies in Higher Education, 27(4), 369-386
Wisker,G, Morris,C, Warnes, M, ,Lilly,J (2009 ) Doctoral learning journeys inAssessment
Learning and Teaching journal, Leeds Metropolitan university. Wisker, G. (2005, 2012 ). The good supervisor: Supervising postgraduate and undergraduate
research for doctoral theses and dissertations. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan
Wisker, G., Robinson, G., & Kiley, M. (2008). Crossing liminal spaces: Encouragingpostgraduate students to cross conceptual thresholds and achieve threshold concepts in theirresearch. In M. Kiley & G. Mullins (Eds.), Quality in postgraduate research: Research educationin the new global environment - Part 2: Conference Proceedings. Canberra: CEDAM, ANU.
Wisker, G., Robinson, G., Trafford, V., Lilly, J., & Warnes, M. (2004).Achieving a Doctorate:Meta-learning and Research Development Programmes Supporting Success for InternationalDistance students. Paper presented at the Quality in Postgraduate Research: Re-imaging
research education, Adelaide, Australia.