KYTC – Kentucky Transportation...

49
KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinet Date: January 11, 2015

Transcript of KYTC – Kentucky Transportation...

Page 1: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinet

Date: January 11, 2015

Page 2: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

2

KY – 6 over Stewarts Creek

Reasons For Using ABC

• Bridge & Superstructure Replacements

• Urban - High Traffic Volumes

• Rural Areas – Substandard or Non Existent Detours

Page 3: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

3

KY’s ABC Experience

Harlan County – KY 219 over Wallins Creek

Page 4: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

4

KY’s ABC Experience

Franklin County – Indian Gap Road

Page 5: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

5

KY’s ABC Experience

Estill County – KY 82 over Twin Creek

Page 6: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

6

KY’s ABC Experience

Page 7: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

7

KY’s ABC Experience

Page 8: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

8

KY’s ABC Experience

Page 9: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

9

KY’s ABC Experience

Page 10: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

10

KY’s ABC Experience

Page 11: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

11

KY’s ABC Experience

Page 12: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

12

KY – 6 over Stewarts Creek

Selecting Kentucky’s SHRP2 Project

Knox County, KY 6 over Stewart’s Creek Short Single Span Use Rolled Steel Girders Duplex Coating System

• Galvanizing• Painting

Concrete Protection• Stains• Deck Sealers

Page 13: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

131/16/2015

KY-6 Existing Structures

Lynn Camp Creek Stewarts Creek

Page 14: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

14

KYTC Highway District 11

Page 15: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

15

Manchester ???

Page 16: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

16

Corbin, KY

Page 17: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

17

Corbin, KY

Page 18: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

18

Stewarts Creek Bridge Layout

Page 19: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

19

Lynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout

Page 20: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

20

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Design

Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting From July 2013 to August 2013 Diversions Epoxy Coated Rebar in Stewarts Creek Bridge Galvanized Rebar in Lynn Camp Creek Bridge

Page 21: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

211/16/2015

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Design

Texas T101 Rail KY Type II Rail

Page 22: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

22

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Design

Design Decisions Class M High Early Strength Concrete Conventional Lap Splices at Lynn Camp Creek with Galv. Rebar Mechanical Couplers at Stewarts Creek with Epoxy Rebar Skewed Transverse Rebar at Stewarts Creek Bridge

Page 23: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

23

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Design

Page 24: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

24

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Design

Page 25: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

25

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Design

Special Notes Kentucky Transportation Center, KTC

• Ted Hopwood • Bob Meade

A + B Bidding • ‘A’ – Normal Bid prices• ‘B’ – Days to complete x $10,000

Galvanization Preparation for Painting Deck Sealing and Concrete Staining Scheduling and various others

Page 26: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

26

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Letting - August 16, 2013

Page 27: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

27

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Bridge Only Costs

Stewarts Creek Bridge• Bid $498,269.80• Estimate $356,733.00

Lynn Camp Creek Bridge• Bid $614,969.00• Estimate $478,181.80

Page 28: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

28

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Beam Fabrication

Page 29: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

29

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

AZZ, Nashville

Page 30: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

30

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Page 31: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

31

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Page 32: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

32

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Page 33: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

33

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Page 34: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

34

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Galvanizing Weathering Process

Zinc Oxides Zinc Hydroxides Zinc Carbonates ASTM D6386

Page 35: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

35

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Page 36: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

36

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Page 37: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

37

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Lynn Camp Creek Bridge

Page 38: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

38

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Stewarts Creek Bridge

Page 39: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

39

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Page 40: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

40

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Page 41: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

41

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Page 42: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

42

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Page 43: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

43

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Page 44: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

44

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges - Construction

Time Savings over Conventional Construction ???

Page 45: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

45

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges

Lessons Learned

Decide Early to Use ABC Avoid Diversions Waive Precast Precertification Requirements Galvanization Issues

• Blast Clean Structural Steels to SSPC SP 10• Specify Si and P Content

Page 46: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

46

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges – Lessons Learned

Page 47: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

47

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges

Lessons Learned

Decide Early to Use ABC Avoid Diversions Waive Precast Precertification Requirements Galvanization Issues

• Blast Clean Structural Steels to SSPC SP 10• Specify Si and P Content• Pre-Heating• Chromate Quenching of Rebar• Price of Galvanized Rebar

Closure Pour Connection Details• Time• Price

Page 48: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

48

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges

Lessons Learned – Things that worked well.

Contractor who was accepting of ABC methods. Willing partners at the D-11 office Size of Precast Pieces Contractor’s concern for fit-up Fabrication and construction monitoring assistance from KTC

Page 49: KYTC – Kentucky Transportation Cabinetshrp2.transportation.org/documents/SHRP2_Presentation_KYTC.pdfLynn Camp Creek Bridge Layout. 20 ... Design Decisions Limited Time Slipped Letting

49

KYTC’s SHRP2 Bridges