KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary...

44
KY

Transcript of KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary...

Page 1: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

KY

Page 2: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Load Rating of Bridge Size Culverts

Department of Civil Engineering University of Kentucky Kentucky Transportation Center

by Abheetha Peiris, Issam Harik, & Others

7th KEC Bridge Seminar January 31st 2018

Page 3: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

The Others2016-2017 Structures Group

Page 4: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Outline- Kentucky’s Culverts- RC Box Culverts- BRASS Program- Field Measurements- Conclusions- Acknowledgment

Page 5: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

1241

29 25 10 10 6 2 20

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

Box RC RC Arch Metal Arch Concrete Arch RC Slab Conspan Arch Masonary Arch Metal Tunnel

Num

ber

of S

truc

ture

s

Structure Type

RC Box Culverts

009B00069L091B00026N

RC Arch CulvertsMetal Arch Culverts

076B00068N

Concrete Arch Culverts

059B00034N

Page 6: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Outline- Kentucky’s Culverts

- RC Box Culverts- BRASS Program- Field Measurements- Conclusions- Acknowledgment

Page 7: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

RC Box Culverts

009B00069L

Page 8: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

117

164

139

427

183

5151

79

31

2

96

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

450

1910-1919 1920-1929 1930-1939 1940-1949 1950-1959 1960-1969 1970-1979 1980-1989 1990-1999 2000-2009 2010-2019 No Data

Num

ber

of C

ulve

rts

Design Year for RC Box Culverts

1241 Culverts

34%

Page 9: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

162

846

223

8 1 0 10

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

1 2 3 4 5 6 7

Num

ber

of C

ulve

rts

Number of Cells

Number of Cells for RC Box Culverts

1241 Culverts

68%

Page 10: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

65

1048

106

1 210

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

0'-9' 10'-19' 20'-30' 31'-35' No Data

Num

ber

of C

ulve

rts

Cell Clear Span Lentgh (ft)

Cell Clear Span for RC Box Culverts

1241 Culverts

84%

Page 11: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

270

821

124

4 121

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

0'-5' 6'-10' 11'-15' 16'-20' 21'-25' No Data

Num

ber

of C

ulve

rts

Cell Clear Height (ft)

Cell Clear Height for RC Box Culverts

1241 Culverts

66%

Page 12: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

126

757

118146

49 45

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

-1 0'-5' 6'-8' 8'-15' 16'-20' 21'-50'

Num

ber

of C

ulve

rts

Fill Height (ft)

Fill Height for RC Box Culverts

1241 Culverts

61%

Page 13: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

828

397

160

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

900

YES NO No Data

Num

ber

of C

ulve

rts

Bottom Slab for RC Box Culverts

1241 Culverts

67%

Page 14: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

1191

32 180

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

SIMPLE FIXED No Data

Num

ber

of C

ulve

rts

Moment Continuity for RC Box Culverts

1241 Culverts

96%

Page 15: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Outline- Kentucky’s Culverts- RC Box Culverts

- BRASS Program- Field Measurements- Conclusions- Acknowledgment

Page 16: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

AASHTO MBE 2011

(2nd Edition)

Page 17: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

AASHTO MBE 2011

(2nd Edition)For bridges rated in

ASD or LFD

Page 18: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

BRASS Culvert

Page 19: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N
Page 20: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

RC Box Culvert Rating Results

Page 21: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Total PercentageRF = 0.0 153 13.1

0.0 < RF < 0.5 130 11.10.5 < RF < 1.0 475 40.6

RF > 1.0 411 35.2

Total 1169 100.0

LFR HS 20 Inventory Rating for RC Box Culverts

153 (13.1%)130 (11.1%)

475 (40.6%)

411 (35.2%)

0

100

200

300

400

500

RF = 0.0 0.0 < RF < 0.5 0.5 < RF < 1.0 RF > 1.0

Num

ber

of C

ulve

rts

LFR HS20 INV Rating Factor for all counties

Page 22: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Failure Type Total Percentage

Flexural failure – Top slab 868 74.3

Flexural Failure – Wall 19 1.6

Flexural Failure – Bottom slab 40 3.4

Shear Failure – Top slab 236 20.2

Shear Failure – Wall 5 0.4

Shear Failure – Bottom slab 1 0.1

Total 1169 100.0

LFR HS 20 Inventory Rating for RC Box Culverts

Page 23: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Outline- Kentucky’s Culverts- RC Box Culverts- BRASS Program

- Field Measurements- Conclusions- Acknowledgment

Page 24: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Culvert Fill Height Measurement in Bourbon County

University of KentuckyKentucky Transportation Center

Page 25: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Link to Culvert Map: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1f290bzsz_JFsZWMKEN9BN7PnTaQ&usp=sharing

Page 26: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N
Page 27: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

009B00054N

Database Field MeasurementFill (ft) 6.0 1.5LFR Inv. RF 0.49 1.23

Page 28: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

009B00026N

Database Field MeasurementFill (ft) 14.0 13.0LFR Inv. RF 0.00 0.67

Page 29: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

009B00069L

Database Field MeasurementFill (ft) 10.0 5LFR Inv. RF 0.00 1.09

Page 30: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

009B00069R

Database Field MeasurementFill (ft) 10.0 6LFR Inv. RF 0.00 0.92

Page 31: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Arch Culverts

Page 32: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Metal Arch Culverts

076B00068N

Page 33: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N
Page 34: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

STAAD Pro.

Page 35: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

RC, Concrete, Masonry Arch Culverts

059B00034N

Page 36: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N
Page 37: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

STAAD Pro.

Page 38: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Outline- Kentucky’s Culverts- RC Box Culverts- BRASS Program- Field Measurements

- Conclusions- Acknowledgment

Page 39: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Conclusion

Culvert Rating- Simple Analysis (BRASS)- FE Modeling- Field Testing

Page 40: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Outline- Kentucky’s Culverts- RC Box Culverts- BRASS Program- Field Measurements- Conclusions

- Acknowledgment

Page 41: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Acknowledgment- Kentucky Transportation Cabinet

- Federal Highway Administration

David Steele Anne Irish Erin Van Zee Dora Alexander Michael Edwards Tyler Blair

Page 42: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Questions?

Page 43: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

Thank Youand

Have a Nice Day

Page 44: KY - cdn.ymaws.com · Box RC. RC Arch. Metal Arch. Concrete Arch. RC Slab. Conspan Arch. Masonary Arch. Metal Tunnel. Number of Structures. Structure Type. RC Box Culverts 009B00069L091B00026N

KY