Klus von Heusinger and Ken Turner (eds.) Where Semantics Meets Pragmatics › content › files ›...

flffi-Jfl ~1iJf?EJ ~ 8 -8- (2006 ~) pp.l23-l30 @2006~ B;;.j>;lffiJtlfiiii"f:~

Klus von Heusinger and Ken Turner (eds.) Where Semantics Meets Pragmatics

Amsterdam: Elsevier ltd. pp.XIII +534.ISBN-13; 978-0-08-044976-0

:.<js:iJHi, v'b~J.:, I~P;f:~~t~f.ffl~~cO):i;[1'i!-J 'i-3=.J~JH: Lt.:mftr)(~-c·&;)J.:, o J!Jl$!1c~~)( li 19

*ii:O),i'J.:. o ~ilfii* 2 AI: J:: J.:,~)..~~)CO)&i) t, 6 -:JO):lt7·7-YO)-fl: 2 - 5 mftr)(Hictl L

--c v' 6 o Wt nlUHJ l;- 0) ;ID I? -r:· &;) 6 ( ID1. ajj 0) .ti~i;-J::, -lT 7· 7 - "" , ~iill)C ': -f- h ·f' h :iffi L i!i'-'i5- 'i-

-:Jit'lv'o) o

CD Introduction (Klaus von Heusinger and Ken Turner)

I . Semantics-Pragmatics Interface

® The boarder wars: A neo-Gricean perspective (Laurence R. Horn)

@A 'just that' lexical meaning for most (Mira Ariel)

II . Pragmatics and Nominal Reference

@ How to deny a presupposition (Ariel Cohen)

® Type shifting of entities in discourse (Michael Hegarty)

® The hidden path of semantic content within pragmatic context: A frequency study of

the definite article the (Ring Mei-Han Low)

(j) Referential expressions and syntax-semantics (-pragmatics) interface (Mayumi

Masuko)

Ill. Bare Nouns and Generics

® General number and the semantics and pragmatics of indefinite bare nouns in

Mandarin Chinese (Hotze Rullmann and Aili You)

®Tolerating exceptions with 'descriptive' and 'in virtue of generics: Two types of

modality and reduced vagueness (Yael Greenberg)

N. Context and Quantification

- 123-

® Binding symmetries and nominal dualities (Antonio Branco)

(jJ) Superlative quantifiers and the dynamics of context dependence (Javier Gutierrez

Rexach)

@Information dependency in quantificational subordination(Linton Wang, Eric

McCready and Nicholas Asher)

V. Information Structure and Underspecification

@ Semantic underspecification and the interpretation of copular clauses in English

(Ronnie Cann)

®Mapping VPs to restrictors: Anti-Diesing effects in Mandarin Chinese (Daniel Hole)

®Contrastive topic/focus and polarity in discourse (Chungmin Lee)

® Implicating and focusing on lexically underspecified information (Luis Paris)

VI. Mood and Intensionality

@Mood, propositional attitude and metarepresentation in Spanish (Aoife Ahern)

@Futurity in default semantics (Katarzyna M.Jaszczolt)

@Temporal reference inside and outside propositional attitudes (Hans Kamp)

ri':l!t:~iilicllffflWifli0)1lJfi~~1±J;.7J'It, 5HI'L <b..t>v'lik~~J I:.IMJ-t..t>MN!!Ii, fk:i!J:cJ;.I: iiS'

J6- l:~iHiili ~ n "'C v' ..t> 1.1\ ~ < O)~Jf~::tfO)fi~lliilii.l{i-IH* L. "'C .il I? , c·.::. i "C1.J{:;j('f!f89fiiHiiliiP, ib

..t> Hilli~ ..t> ffl~frO)~v' ~0)1.J>1,){7J'1,)> I? 1: < C ~{tO) J!im L.i.l{~ < ~-::> "'C v' ..t>;I!~1.J{ib ..t> o

*•0)•-0)••~ • .::.O)rml!t:•tam•O)*w~•J~ML.,£*~•=~~m-t..t>.::.

ci:J: I? r.~~t~J ~~;t..t>.::.c-e<b..t> o •=!:, ~;j1t~i§l!i·;I!~"CO), .::.O)r"~fmO)Jt1,){t)

C i*~ ~~T.::. C "'C'iPJ..t>o

CDc. -+J-7"7-? I O)=•x®®li. *•O)m.A.l~M:<PJt.: ..t> b 0)-c, :f&O)~~iili~Jli!.Wt-t ..t>

~~0)-B"C<bt), £*~~ ~;{_ ~, -~. ~&O)<PJt)~#m~~h..t>o ®~ L~r~~

Horn O)Jil!;f::Wifli-llB-ffl•O)*W~ ~ <" ..t> ~:7·7 1 7. i*89 ~ J!fl!UqU91'191:.~rZ G n "'C v' ..t> o

®li Mira Ariel O).R.Jt~li-8· 'most'~~<" ..t>J!Wt-c·<PJ I?, "not all"c v'-) J::~~~l£69~%);.~

implicature t L. "'Clli"~T ..t,O)"Cii~ <, ~P.ti:*JLJ;.:i6i nt.: default fl!HR-c·<PJ..t, c T ..t>o @

0) Ariel Cohen O)llifliJtli"The King of France ... " c v'-) J: < ~n G ht.:JtO)JWom:sl:EI: ~ L. "'C,

-t-0)1§J£0)~fl;jd1: ~ ~P.tllifli89 Hill-!i·ffl~iilii'l9 c J;. 6"'- ~ 1.1' c v'-) ~J'Ufrlr~ HU~ L. "'C v' ..t>o @

0) Michael Hegarty li , :$t1'f-t ..t>~-~~~t ..t> }§'~{-\;~fin] 2:: Aft1i:~f,Pj0)3({i;;l!~ ~ DRT

-em~ L.J: 1 2:: T 6 b O)"'(:'·<PJ..t> o @0) Ring Mei-Han Low O)~WJiJtlil£J&;f,P] the O)H:\~J'IJ~Jtl:

-:::>v>"'(O)~WJi~""C·;bl), -fijtO)'f7.LH:.)5lL. "'(, ~~ftlUtA9 (non-anaphoric, antecedent-less) ~

-124-

~ I

Klus von Heusinger and Ken Turner (eds.) Where Semantics Meets Pragmatics 2006

the il{jli/jv'.lt$ ~ 6 ~ 1.>:: til{~~ n "'C v' 1.> o (fH: ;13 "' "'C Mayumi Masuko li, B :<fs:~frO)

r §53' J 1:-:::> "' "'C context logic 1: J: 0 "'C MiflJriiJii~"C· :: t ~ J!!.IJ;!ci* < :iffi «. "'C "' 1.> o @ 0)

Hotze Rullmann t? O)ij~)Cii, !:f:l OO~frO):/f)Efi'-J bare noun 0)1\fr)fl~ · :lif.P-*il~B91~1.> ~H:-:::>

v'"'CmaA-t 1.> ~ O)"'C'iliJ 1.> o ®I: ;Jov'"'C Yael Greenberg li/Gk:!f!~£H~. t ;flt;ft£<:J'J.0){7JJ:$'Hi

~ ~H~-t 1.>-f!E~I:mJ-t 1.> r",ill! ~t~Hiii L- "'C "' l.> o @"C· Antonio Branco li.Bl:t.t:tJ*O)IZ!Jji(If~ ~

t 1J :: t ~ 3:.~-t 1.> o ([DO) Javier

Guntierrez-Rexach O)~MI: J: nl.t', %~~~0)it.l.*&.O)M~Ril{JtJ!JiU:~:ff:-t 1.>:: t li DRT

O);j$~:1.1..7t- "C-? ;t < t'E.:t t? nl.> t 3:.~-t 1.> o @0) Linton Wang O)ij~Jtli Every hunter who

saw a deer shot it. *It was a female/ It died immediately 0) J:-? tj, )C~~;t t.::Zlft£WH:

J: 1.>{-t;:tAAjO)sRMJ-~1,%~~ < O)j'- ?' ~jf- !...-, jf~:r.\;B91:1J~ l:f.:: ~ O)"("~IJ;!ci*v'o ~ t? 1:@

@"C~, *•O)~:<fs:fii.Jtj~il!~~"Cibl.> r~MO) (•ill!tl.-"'CO))/G~~ttc~O)m~J ~

c I) ib 11·, ~I) Tlt't.::~~il~~ /.&1m L- "'( "' l.> o @U, Ronnie Cann il{ Copular JcO)M~R I:;Jolt

1.> :lif.IJ;!cB9*~R:k:'ti ~ Dynamic Syntax O);j$*Jl.lj. "('-~~il~ L-t.:~(/)"('\ ilfrJfliliii'!B9, Mflli'f (J91'jt§li

f"F-Jflil{~M)(Jl.JR"CO)f9t~RI*l$~?*5E-t 1.>:: t iJ{~~ n "'Cv'l.>o @0) Daniel Hole "Cii, !:f:lOO

1\frO)~)CO)-:g~li Diesing 0)-®:ft (VP 0) I*J$iJ{~)CO) A :J -71:}5t~;j ~ t'Ll.> ) 1:.& !...-,

v P li mu ~.ll! A :1 - 7· 1: r;: ~t ~ n 1.> J: 1 1: m *'R ~ n 1.> :: t ~ :iffi""' t.: b 0) "C o ® 0)

Chungmin Lee li, contrastive topic/focus t, ~il!"C·O);!;,)!ji3JI.~O)~;mt{¥:.t!:O)~f*~~

il~ L- "'C v' 1.> o @"C· Luis Paris li, ~~fr"C'I±aA~B91:1lE-~ t L- "'C 3'Rffl. ~ nl.>~!WJ!WJ~~O)~)i.~li,

A"' 1 Yi\'lf"C·Iiil!tJflil~B<JI::f!ti: (implicature) t VCf~)t ~ t'Ll.>:: t ~ !:f:l,[.,l::iffi«. "'C v'l.> o

@Hi Aoife Ahern 1: J: 1.> A"' 1 /~frO) subjunctive ~ ~ i!tHll!il~O);j$*IJ.lj. "('·:pj:f9t~R L-t.:: b 0)

"Cibl.> o @O) Katarzyna M. JaszczoltO)~)C ii, ~~frO) "will"O)t~fig"C·<bl.>, ( i ) RUIJ ,

(ii) -T::7' 1)7' -L (iii) jilij*l.:nt:~ 0)11? r**J O)~.;Tj.~, :'J*O)~P~Tl.>default

semantics O);j$*Jl.lj. "CilstaA L- J: 1 t T 1.> b 0)"('· o :: O);fl .. f*Jl.Jt, b DRT Jj[ililifl:~-:::5- < o llft1&

1:< 1.> Hans KampO)~)C@Hi, 1J1JJ.HJ91'jDRT:fll!ilfni~J.&!ml-, ~l'jl.>*r<~H:;Jov'"'C , lff.l-

0) agent 1.:~ t.l.> attitudinal change (-l.,B9t~~O)~ft) ~-?;-tr 2 -:::>0))( (mini-discourse)

(J)fiiHR~maA L- "'Cv'l.> o

(a) On Sunday Bill heard that Mary was in Paris.

(b) On Tuesday he learned that on the previous day she had left.

t "' 1 mini-discourse 1.: ;13 v' "'C, (b))CO)fllj:gi~O)flllf!fRii(a))CO)j9HR ~ Jt!l!R:IIH& t L- "'C ;flj)fj L

l'jltnli'l'j Gl'jv'o :::: "C'(b)Jt~i9HRi" 1.> l:£.~1'j saturation (!MD) il{DRT 1: J: IJ maA

"(" ~ 1.>:: t il{fJtllf.l ~ nl.>o

W.J::.i.J~:<js:i!O)fl\!t~"('·;bJ.:,iJ>, ~0)-9«."'(~:-:::>v '"'C~'f L- <If~ I) 1:.17"1.>:: t li"C~ l'jv'o :9\¥

"C'IH¥*7.J~>$:'!'"C·!ff.~.:~~"C· t ~ ;t 1.> r"~illi ~, *Jf;lifiO)~tt"$'b:lm"C'~iH~-t 1.> :: t t:-t l.> o

-125 -

3. 1 . \; 'fJ ~~"Pragmatic intrusion into what is said"(:"?\-'-"(

r5~B9 Grice JJI!.~iilrt:'li, what is said ($~J!!i ~ O)f.[.Jlt-) iJ'~*!IHiftrO)J..)J c f.t ~ :tftM:

(implicature)~!:tlll(; L, 9e~O)JlJlt-iJ'm:nx ~ n~ t L "Cv't::.o LiJ' L Jli:ip, what is said

0){:1/f~l.:-:::> "' -c 'b, XRiiH.: 1:tf1-f-T ~ t.t !v G iJ>O):fft~iJ'00-9· T ~- ::. t iJ'llillliii ~ n -c "' ~ o fJlJ X.

If, "John's car" c v' -? *:ffl.--:::> t -::> "C J7. "C 'b John -z:·ff- ~ ~1. ~ :tj·~ c car t 0) 1M"! 1* R 0) :ff:iE iJ':\?f:I!U9t.: I iff-~ n ~ t.: It "C, ~JY.[ R 0){~ li)C}l)j( "Ci:k:5£ ~ ~1.-l;t It ;ftl;ftd: G id: v'o :~fq!? 1.: li ,

v' b ~ ~ !lP-*~lifiO)~J!tl& Uft*~ X. G n "C ~ t::.lii~im""-0)~-g: ffl~liiii399&JJI!.0)£~~1i (pragmatic

intrusion) ~~ (''~~j(ij*O):£f5tt::.i), "Tf.tbi) Sperber & Wilson, Carston, Recanati,

Levinson i?O)lliiJiXIi-@ri n "Cv'f.tv'o LiJ'"L, (D, ®lliiliXiJ'TI1l::t~, ::. O)ffijjj*'<!:-~¥~~ VC < n ~o ;li~t:J: ~ Introduction ."Cii, ::.O)J:-? id: what is said O)ff/t~l.:-:::>v'"C Levinson 0)

Generalized Conversational Implicature ~~j(fj (.IJ. r, TGCI) -".0) x:M'iJ'*a~ ~ ~1. ~ o J: < ~D G n -c v' ~ J:-? 1.:, IM"!J!ti:JJ!lJlifi (Sperber & Wilson 1995) "Cii"what is said" tv'-?~~

Iii~~ ;tt, 9ell!O)/f5t1E::id: ~illi JJI!.;Jf~~~i*M: (explicature) t L "C5t1E::t.tfr;-Jrni*J~I.:ff/tlll(; ~ n ~ t T ~ o ::_O)*M:O):fUiili:il~mui:tftM: t l<iJ - 0) 'b 0) t ~X. G n "Cv'~a Carston (2002)-z>li

~ G t:, *~ t :tft~li - J5'rtiJ·I:iO):Jl!1JJ!Li~l!f.'t:'li t.t <, iPHr!39, :i:l£!1'TJ39:JlHiili (backwards

inference) 'b '@! i ;ft~::. t i.J>ff-n~ ~ n -c "' ~ 0 ;ffni~t::. i:) li, IMJJ!11JJI!Jiili-r:·ffiit'J!: t ~ n ~ rlil~" a9:ttHiiliiJ\ /f5t1E::~frllilli.l' G ~1E::t.tfrl.~rn '<!:-tn~-t ~ *~O)*ili 1: ti1~ x. 1d: "' 0) -r:· lit ~r"', '<!:

¥ L, ~ G 1.: I~)J[ti)O):tft~iiliJ 0)~5£ t.:-:::> v' "C 'b &.:t.J· L "C v' ~ o Recanati (2002, 2004) -z'•li,

IUIJ!11JJI!.lliili t li:iiv', -llf;JrnO) @l1i~l!-z'•li r=-:::> O)'j:lj IV[ Gudgement) 0) r.ll O):fUiiliJ t "'-?

~~v,~P*-z'·O):ffHiiii-z'·li id: <, "primary pragmatic process" t ~-?It G ~1.t..:1!Pi:f:~llltr-r:·ffJJ < iil ~!39 id:{,i'l9f'r:ffl '<!:-~5£ L -c v' ~ o ::. nl:-:::> v' -c 'b, ffi~ G li ~0)~~0)/f+)J'- ~ '<!:-:t~titi L,

*!)ilj, Levinson 0) TGCI '<!:- a)Hiid:~)lf!ti ~:M'-:::> t L "Cx:M' L "Cv' ~ o LiJ' L, @O)lllifi)(l:.:l3

v'"C, ~~0) Horn li (~Btli Levinson t:Jli:v' t .'(!;l,;f?;ft "Cv' ~ iJ'), ~ 0) TGCI '<!:- 'b :tlt'¥U L -c

( 1 ) a. I haven't had breakfast {today).

b. John and Mary are married {to each other).

c. Robin ate the shrimp and { as a result} got food poisoning.

Levinson (2000)1:: J: ;ftl;f, I ·I O)'(j~)j-!;l:~~O) I Jjj(~, MP~ i'l91.: v' X. If I53;~0) ·11HIH''J~

'<!:-tJH~-tt J: J 1:: J: 0 -c$ ~ ili ~ n~ t T ~ o Horn li I ::. 0) J: -? f.ttJ.t5:1Hl'~)tliJ~O!Jl.~141:~

11-t ~J..J .. L Grice V[O):JftM:-r:·ti<b ~ 1~id:v' L, Jflt ~ ?W LOTtm-r:·<b~iJ' G, what is said 0) -

- 126 -

!~"t">b~v'J (p.23) C.i"i-J o *t'ff,U, ~!Ht lgiSL.--¥0)f:i~:itl.-J::-)c l.-t.::~P* (speakermean

ing) O)v' < -:::>i,p0)1JIIJ IT!Hi what is implicated "t">b what is said "t"b ~v'J t v' oJ Kent

Bach (1994, 2001) 0)3:.5JH::!IllmJL-, 1Jt5~~~~~ lh.~;bl-v'ffl~H'~Gbh61"t" implici

ture t ~ ,Z J:: -) J (p.24) u~~ vn\ 6 0

~'*B'6lf, Mfffl ~O):t;gy.~llb<. 6MiB6lili, .::. O)J:: -)~::i.~tif!!.tl..--cv'6il', *fif.U, l t!Hj{ijJ cv'

-? >bO)~ c' O)J::-) ~=t~X.61.1', &.>6H±Ar.,,ilt:f .. r-?-cv'6:JUj{ij#\Hllic l±::f>: gH±c'-J v' -? >bO)

~0)1.1', t v'-) p,~)m~::1\ff~i- 6 J::-) ~=-~,~?h6 o ~6~lm A ~"Rut~~:, reasoning ~r~-r~

Jm A'~:::J!E~-9 6 t v'-? ~D ~<J~~lli ~ ~Jtv'~'*O):Jffiffj{ij t Thli, ~ tL.W.9H::, J! v':f:P*O):JfHj{ij,

""9~bi?3liJ:itl-J::-? c""96!fUiflf1.1t, JIG1-T-96fUilfr1.1'C;:. < 6, ~6Hi~-::1< cv'-? .::c.~:~

1tv'""Cv'~lthli'~C;:.~v'cv'-Jfli!WJ~Iifl-t.:, ~~~f\rf"t"O), ~'Jti::Jli:v' 1 rn:1~J O) J::

-) ~ >b 0) >b t!E~I::~ilb -r~ X. 6.::. C. >b "t" ~ 6 O)iJ' >b l.-~1.~ v' (Recanati 2002, 2004) o ::f>:t!f"t"

li, .::. O)p.,,JI!JH:: J'iUHa~li~ X. G ;h.. ""Cit'~ v'o l-iJ' L-.::. ;h.. I: !Mli!: l-, Jaszczolt li:<fi:i!H~JiitO)

llj{ij)C@-t->, J'iijftO)~i!f (Jaszczolt 2005) "t", 17"7 :.t Jv r~'*llj{ijJ (Default Semantics) C.

v'-) ]Ltl}~t'!~ L- -c v' 6 0 ~.::. "t"li3£-~0)ff~Jll\3!(jf- (logical form) t 3£-~0)~'* t 0) r.l'l l:: If!

rt6 A9~P-*3!(ff-O) v-"' Jv ~ ~~ilOT, -9--< -c 0)•11-H&.i.lr:r.t~ ~ j'tflf"t"~-f;$:0)f1:'* 0)..g. fiX: 1:: 1M! b IJ ,

i:'*3!(ff- 1.1'11= C;:. ;h.. 6 t v'-? M..g.3!(jf- (merger representation) O)ff {E il'.:l:.~~ ~ ~1- -r It' 6

(p.475)o .::. ;h.. I: J:: tlli', j[;~l::!f.T-5£1~ ~;h.. -r v' ~ v' i:P-*3!(ff- (underspecified meaning) ;?>,

tUfni~:: J:: IJ je~~~M*ff- ~:: ~ 6 t ~X. 6 O)""C· Ii ~ < , ffi~!..g.*ff- ~:: s v' -c)C¥*, .(.,~g;t~·li

(intentionality) ~ c'3£-ffi!ii::M b 6 ~·lff~;?t-@-JiX: ~ h~'*f9~~R1.1'11·b~1-6 t 1&5£ ~ ~1- -cv' 6 o

:9\ O)fJiJ ~h. -c h. J:: -) 0

( 2) The youngest contestant won the piano competition.

a. Jimmy Brown won the piano competition.

b. The youngest contestant, whoever he or she was, won the piano competition.

(2) O)~~~PJ 1iJ~::ooL--r, :mff-~9~nh. C2a) c., -"'fi~9Meh. (2b) l::!lf~"t"~6c~x.e;,

h6 o :::..0)/.i."t" ( 2 ) l:: li ~'*O)::fjC~fiil'<b6C..!,;btL.6 o l.-i.Pl.-, Jaszczoltli~:i!UlllWf

1::1;1: c ~-J"Z"<b6cf9lfJ¥R~nt.:: ) lliS*O)'t,a9:t:~ ·ii>bi'Alb60)"t"~IJ, ~~~PJ1iJO)tJ}..g., :t:

r~iJ't11Jt~ftlv'c (2a) O)mff-a<J~?'th., ~~v'c (2b) O)~tUnh-1::~6c~'I!JIJ¥~tt.6c L-, 7"7

:.t - Jv r "t"liit~tili )~ v' t 1.1EX. G tL.6 0) "t", lii~-€i-3!(ff-"t" li C ..C n~::Btt" 6 ·li'f~il'~ X. C;:. n ~v'1Ci%) (2a) 0)11J¥Jf!RO),h.;?t1t]jj(;~;h..6cv'oJ (p.476) o .::.0) lii!::~tiJ I± Searle (1983)

~::~-::1( bO)"t", ~P-*<b61~~~::~-?""Cv'6o l-iJ'l-, l:t:iolttJ O),t,t'J9~{E ;?t~i£1lj]~;h..60)

"t" ~ v' ~R IJ , -~ ~:: 7" 7 :.t Jv r ~919UR ~ .!}X. G tL.6 Wth. ~ I..C hli:t:~tti.lt!MJ~ L- -c v' 6 J

tv'-) O)"t"li~~~j{ijO)~~~~=~'a 0 -c v' 6 t v'Vbli~ C;:. ~ v'o 7"7 :.t Jv r ~"*~1::-:::>v>-c li

- 127 -

. I

3. 2 . ~~~~(J)~:J'ei:tt (underspecification) l:?l. '"t

;;jq~: "t: !i, - !& 1: ~ P-* 0) :If' 7'C ~·ii 0) fJJJ c l "OR.~ ~ ;h. J., .fJI, ~~ PJ 91-f: b -l* 4 7'j. * il' c '? ;h If

Gn '""Cv'"C!1l!-'*i~v' o f?UX.If, Gutierrez-Rexach O)~iili:t@"C'I±Jii...t;Wkii';J;f-::Jil£'*ti~ c I') ih

lf'""Cv'l.>o

( 3) John went to the mall. He bought his wife the most expensive present. (p.242)

( 3) "t:, ~_t$& ~ ~'?~ 2 0))(1± 4 :1m I') !:19t~f!Jrii]'~~-e;h J., c v'-) o :::: "t: he c his wife t 1:~.\':\ ~ ih '""C t..:f!IU.R ( 1!1!.0)~ "C' b ;/j < John il'~ b j';jljfrlli 7j: 7" v -t! )' 1- ~ ~ -? t..:, 1t!!.O)~"C· b

7'j < his wife 1: John li~ b f.11ifrlli;lj 7 v -t! )' 1- ~ Jl-? t..:) U:$'}0) = '?O)~J'G.;Tj. ~~X. J., c,

( i ) :: O)iJt-c·- iJ.tf.11ifrlli 7'j 7 -v -e)' " ~ Jr "? t..: (;f.@Mml1-)

( ii) 4'1-e-e-il.tiWifrlli;lj 7 -v-e )' "~ Jl "? t..: (1§Mml1-)

0)= -::J 0)1W~Ril{1~ G ttl.> o :: O)f!JURPJ~~·ii li , I ( 3) )(0)3£~ffilifriO)XIJIRK 1: ~-)( ~1.10 X.

t..::tJllit~-@'CO)r::f:lf:;B v''""C, 1t!1.0)(:<0)7vf!)' 1- y b x J: t)f.11ifrlli;/jbO)Ii;/jv', -t-O)J:-) 7'j

x~Johnli*I:Jl-?t..: J cv'-3*7Fii{DRS!:J: -?'""C.!f X.Gtt.J.>ci'l.> o ( i) ( ii ) O)f!JUR

O):iiH±:tllJR-c·O)M* y O)fJEX. :1J l:il@!Ni' 7.> t ,\!!,;b ttl.> o DRT O)~-::J*~;r.\ B9 fiJI7Ftt O) :fJ JfHi

l:)n.1til' ~;h. J., ~~~nli-c· ih J., 0

Ronnie Cann O)~n1JX@"t:li, :iUs~ (copula) 0) be WJJ~il{t!H¥ c l-r:t&vn, -J 1 7"

<e -+ t> 0) ;1. -J ~~ c m~ ~;h.-cIt' J., ( '? 1 I') :ili!Jtf~P] be ~ predicate pro form c 73'1Jfi' J., ) 0

:iUtf~P]O) be li(a)#~~B9 be, (b)~;c.\89 be, (c) *f7E1t be, ;/j t··l::)}~ ~ ;h.J., il' Cann 1: J: ;h.

IJunderspecified ;/jj1;]1§t:O))~Jij~P] be ~~'?Xil' (be 0)) 1±\J=JI,~:ti, 96iffi)()JJH::J: -?'""C~ P;IC

~iili89, ~-afflffiftrB91:f!IIP!R~.!fX.Gtt.J.>ci'J.> (p.319) o ~;{_1JO)'Jd1i~, tHfij8g1JIIJYtiH:I±.A.G

i\ MP1&B~J!:l1--c;B::-J o TO) (4) liA,BO)~~~, (5) lii9URI:~J!i'J.>~~"t:ibl.>o

( 4 ) A: Oh no, someone has drunk the last of the milk again.

B: John is the culprit.

( 5 ) a. )(IJIR·MH~ : :3 xDrink(m)(x) [~~h -c v' t..: ~ Jv :7 ~ ~lv t.==ttii{v ' J.,]

b. a ~i~t..:-911~~ : (£, x, Drink(m)(x))

c.~~ : Drink(m )(a.) f-- Wrongdoer( a.)

d. culprit 0):\['*: Culprit(a.) f-- Wrongdoer( a.)

- 128 -

I .I


" ' o .:: .:: "t"Ji:JlfRil' t? 17)t-? -c "\ t.:-~ Jv 7 i-~ lv "(' L.. i -::d..: if J O)ff:t£1.1{1~ t? n (=> 5a)' ~fJ

fl'H~B9~5E (5c) ~= J: ~, I ~1~~:7)t-::> t..: ~ Jv 7 i-~u=>~'-''1T'-''J t "' ") W$)ffl.i.J{~ in, ~ t? ~: culprit 0):\f.J!til' t? l~!fJEif"t" ih 6 if li~ '-''1Tv' i- L.. t..:if J tv' -J WP¥Ri.l{~ in 6 o .-f

O)M*, .::O)JtJ!fR"t"ti~!fJEifttia•0)~~7i-~lv~iftmM~n6 o ik~~~m~~

r ~ Jv 7 i-~lvt!if J t "' -J M~Ril{-'3- X. t? tl6o a~B9 1: r Y ='~ / li ~ Jv 7 i-~lvt! ~ O)""C·Ji.>

~, ~!fJEif t li ~ Jv 7 i-~lv t!if -c·;h 6 J .:: t 1.1q~ t? ;h, .:: n i-fr L.. -c B O)~~Jtp;jO) be

li, .-f O)i')tj:j~O)fE'jjf-t-j-~1.1{~- "(' ih 6.:: t i-:if-T~J;\;B9 be (equative be) t :J;!!!.~If. ~ h6 t

T6o

~~:, (j])O) Luis Paris O)~TI/iJt"t"li .A« 1 /m<l)~t))<l).fjjti~il{, ~9HfJ t liiiv':f:P-*89 i.::llfl:if

~ n -c "' 6 <7)"(' li t:t c 1t~ t t.... -c 1~ x. t? n6.:: t il{~_..z t? n -c "' 6 (p .42I ) o ~j(<l)fJJJ >K h.

t?nt..:v'o

( 6) a. El nino en tr6 a su habitaci6n .

(the child entered to his bedroom)

b. The child walked into his room.

(6b) <l)J:")~.::, ~~fJ-c·li l~v'-c:g:~)~H.::.A-::>t..:J 0) l~v>-cJ 0)$7J'Ii:f:J!t0)-:g:~tt....-r 7F

~n-cv ' 6<7)1.::t-tt....-c, .A«1 /~fJ-c·li (6a) O)J:-J 1: I.A-::>t..:J t!ltil{:f:llt 89i:7F~n,

-{-<7) ,¢,;:""C·:f$!f!JJJJJ%1 i--@;uJtli/f'%~-c·;h6 t T 6o I ~v'-c J t "' ") t!lti~li Levinson <7) I )Jj(

m "t":f!H~ ~ n 6 (.:: n i- Means Expanditure t v' ") ) o

r:t:P*~~ UfJ.ffl~(J)~wO)r"9JrnJ 1: !Ml-t 6 Jti!ikliiliif., ~~H:IJ:N ~ n -c "' 6 o *ilfli --f <7) r:p

"t" ~ ~tlit:t~!rn i-lflUJf.&-::> -c ;f3 ~, 1.HH:1~T 6 o :;;j;::m:-c·li , :f:P-*~~0)1Jt¢.i: i--~i:m.m~~

89th. t:t ~ ;11.6 ~lUfd:t9:M L..t..:ftf,r.r89, *J;\;89~~W~JO)~J1~~i.JL?-?~ "' J: ") i:.'~1,bh6il{, .::

0)7J'!Jl-J·"t"0)4-f~O)~i*] i' 'f1Jl ~ 1t 6 ~ 0)~ < ;.fn]!.lt) l ~J!ti~ lt>p;j~ i' t.f-:::> o

Bach, K. 1994. "Conversat ional Impliciture." Mind and Language 9, 124-162.

Bach , K. 2001. "You Don't Say?" Synthese 127, 15-44.

Carston, R. 2002. Thoughts and Utterances: The Pragmatics of Explicit Communication . Oxford:

Blackwell.

J aszczolt, K.M. 2005. Default Semantics: Foundations of a Compositional Theo1y of Acts of Communication.

Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Levinson , S.C. 2000. Presumptive Meanings: The Theory of Generalized Conversational Implicature.

- 129 -

··:r

I ·)

-I

: .... -

Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press.

Recanati, F. 2002. "Does Linguistic Communication Rest on Inference?" Mind and Language 17, 105-26.

Recanati, F. 2004. Literal Meaning. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Searle, J.R. 1983. Intentionality: An Essay in the Philosophy of Mind. Cambridge: Cambridge

University Press.

Sperber, D. and D.Wilson. 1995. Relevance: Communication and Cognition. (2nd Edition) Oxford:

Blackwell.

- 130-

Klus von Heusinger and Ken Turner (eds.) Where Semantics Meets Pragmatics › content › files ›...

Documents

Transcript of Klus von Heusinger and Ken Turner (eds.) Where Semantics Meets Pragmatics › content › files ›...