King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in...

16
1 2BA (Hons) Fieldwork in Human Geography: Kerala Field Visit Department of Geography King’s College London December 2013

Transcript of King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in...

Page 1: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

1

2BA (Hons) Fieldwork in Human Geography: Kerala Field Visit Department of Geography King’s College London December 2013

Page 2: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

2

Table of Contents

INTRODUCTION Prof. Mark Pelling .......................................................................................... 3

CASE STUDIES ................................................................................................................................... 4

1. Do small-scale marine fisheries provide a sustainable livelihood for fishing communities in Kerala State, India? By Georgina Howe, Emma Roberts and Nicole Yih ......................................................................................................................................................... 4

2. The impacts of ICTs on the Keralan fishing industry. By Dan Hosking, Luke Beardsley and Sophian Dahmani ................................................................................................ 5

3. Have increasing fish prices financially benefited members along the domestic supply chain of fish in Alleppey (Alappuzha)? By Alexandra Oratore, Viran Patel and Caleb Stone ................................................................................................................................ 6

4. Kerala: Gender Equality in the Division of Labour in Local Fisheries. By Vera Gulbrandsen and Waseem Meghjee ........................................................................................... 7

5. What constitutes a successful woman? By Farzana Ahmed, Frances Hancock and Shabana Khanum ............................................................................................................................. 8

6. How and why has the increase of women in politics altered the perception of women in society? By Lydia McSweeney and Ines Nebi ....................................................... 9

7. Is there an existing correlation between education and migration patterns in rural/semi-urban Kerala? By Pierre Swaelus, Xavier Nukajam, and Katie Matthews ............................................................................................................................................................. 10

8. Keralites’ migration to the Gulf: public and private responses. By Alesha de Fonseka, Janice Leung and Neehar Ravi ................................................................................. 11

9. What are the perceptions of male students on gulf migration and how are these views reflected in returned migrants? By Jack Bathe and Louis Pattison .................. 12

10. To What Extend has the Kudumbashree Initiative Helped Alleviate Poverty in Kerala? By Sam Mitchell, Geoffrey-Peter Ross and Rodolphe Bichot ............................. 13

11. To what extent are disabled people integrated into society in Kerala? By Shahd Hammou, Elisabeth Pramendorfer and Agnieszka Zajac .................................................. 14

12. How are patterns of dress among young women being influenced by social, economic and cultural change? By Owen Dawson, Rachael Morey, Nikita Shah and Stella Tsellingas ............................................................................................................................. 15

Page 3: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

3

INTRODUCTION

Prof. Mark Pelling

This report brings together snap shots of research undertaken by second year undergraduate

Geography students from King's College London in 2013. Projects are designed by students

with support from academic members of staff and implemented in collaboration with students

from Kerala acting as guides and translators – and becoming friends. Each project is a pilot,

with data collection limited to three days. Preparatory reading and lectures on Kerala's

development history and contemporary challenges alongside methodological literature help

provide a solid base from which student teams of three identify and develop their mini-

projects. In the field work focuses on testing the validity of research questions and the

appropriateness of core hypotheses and chosen methods. The results are necessarily

indicative and reflect the views of a limited number of respondents. They are not

representative or analytically robust – but together they provide a vision of Kerala that is

open to an initial academic investigation; a set of studies that scratch beneath the surface and

in so doing raise more questions than can be answered by our visiting students!

Kerala continues to stand out as a global example of development that has succeeded in

raising overall wellbeing through placing emphasis on social development. At the same time

Kerala is tightly connected to India's and the global economy and to cultural fashions

accessed increasingly through the internet. Changing aspirations are reflected in choices

Keralites make on how to make a living, with many moving from agriculture into service

sector work. International migration to the Gulf states and further afield, and the sending of

remittances is important for the economy, but so to is the hosting of labour migrants from

Tamil Nadu and northern India. These influences produce an increasingly diverse cultural

context for study.

Our field work and projects often reveal the deep shifts taking place in Kerala at this time.

This is marked on the landscape as much as in labour relations and population dynamics.

Environmental changes in the past have been driven by the agricultural economy and are

inscribed on the landscape through the intensive coconut and rice agriculture of the coastal

plane, giving way to rubber and tea in higher elevations inland. Damming of lakes to provide

irrigation water has changed the ecology as well as economy of the coast. Sea-level rise and

coastal erosion is evident and is set to be a growing concern for the low-lying villages we

work in. Reduction in fish stocks at sea and inland also attest to environmental changes and

human impact.

Finally the projects in this report reinforce Kerala's reputation for political inclusivity and

equity. These are aspirations of course, but continue to be defended, as you will see from

studies presented here, from the perspective of women in decision-making positions,

especially in local government, and of the disabled and their carers. That geography matters

is clear from these studies – Kerala's development vision and policy is fixed by

administrative boundaries and aligned with strong cultural traditions joined up by common

environmental and economic contexts. But this vision is dynamic and underlying economic

and cultural as well as environmental systems are increasingly in flux. This produces a Kerala

that is at once unique and yet entrained within global flows and pressures. We hope that a

little of the richness of our learning from Kerala can be shared through the pages of this

report.

Page 4: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

4

CASE STUDIES

1. Do small-scale marine fisheries provide a sustainable livelihood for fishing

communities in Kerala State, India? By Georgina Howe, Emma Roberts and Nicole Yih

With a coastline extending to 370 miles, Kerala’s fishing industry has long provided a food

source for the Keralites. However with the increasing competition posed by international

trawlers, the capacity of small-scale fisheries to provide a livelihood is continually

undermined. Thus our study set out to explore the aspects to which Keralites consider

important for the provision of a sustainable livelihood and how they are able to finance this.

In order to investigate, we used two methods: semi-structured interviews and focus groups.

Both of their flexible natures enable respondents to answer structured questions and discuss

particular issues at the same time. There are five topical themes: aspirations to progress, the

changing work force, money, management strategies, technology and the future. Overall, my

group conducted six focus groups at fishermen homes, two interviews with fishing authorities

and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

The overall finding of our project was the conclusion that due to international fishing

trawlers, the fish stocks are being over-fished. This lead to difficulties for traditional fishing

communities as fish stocks and average sizes of species are being diminished. The aspirations

of local communities are to seek jobs in more stable, tertiary sectors for the younger

generations. A certain sense of acceptance and even content was felt by the older generations

despite the consistent opinion that the traditional industry will be destroyed in the future. It

could be argued that in the wider context of development, the traditional industries are

inevitably going to be replaced by mechanised practices however efforts should be made to

make fishing more sustainable to maintain this natural resource for future generations.

Interview with fisherwomen along the Thaikal Beach Fish Market

Page 5: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

5

2. The impacts of ICTs on the Keralan fishing industry. By Dan Hosking, Luke Beardsley

and Sophian Dahmani

The introduction of ICTs during the past two decades has enabled emerging markets all over

the world to speed up how they communicate ideas and transfer money and resources to each

other. The Keralan fishing industry has major economic and social impacts due to this

introduction. The four major players in the market are the fishermen, auctioneers, buyers and

transporters. During our field research we carried you interviews with representatives of each

category, although fishermen received the highest proportion of time. We also observe

actions at the fish market and could see firsthand how the four actors in the fishing supply

chain make use of ICTs.

The buyers and transporters liken themselves to entrepreneurs, and so to run their business,

ease of communication is a necessity to source their products and to move it to where the

demand needs to be met. The fishermen and transporters saw improvements in their quality

of life, allowing them to spend more time with their families and friends. The actors in the

supply chain have benefited from the introduction of SONAR technology, which enabled the

time spent wasted waiting for the shoals to be found to be drastically reduced.

However, due to technological difficulties, the signal range could not penetrate deep into the

forested areas. The implementation of 4G technologies would allow more people to access

their data connections. English is now being taught at most state schools, which means that

use of the internet for the future generations will only increase, making it financially

equitable to implement these changes, and allowing the whole area to increase its sphere of

influence. Creating an application in the native Malayalam to instruct local resident and

fishermen of any impending natural or economic disasters and fluctuations will only be a

positive. The information age now means that those with access to it can profit more than

those who do not, leading to uneven development.

Dan, Luke and Sophian during an interview with a fisherman’s household

Page 6: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

6

3. Have increasing fish prices financially benefited members along the domestic supply

chain of fish in Alleppey (Alappuzha)? By Alexandra Oratore, Viran Patel and Caleb

Stone

Kerala is a South Indian state with one of the largest coastlines in India. Fishing has long

been a significant part of the Kerala economy, with hundreds of thousands depending on the

industry for their livelihoods. International fish prices have experienced a steady rise in

recent years and the aim of the project was to examine the distribution of the financial

benefits gained from increasing fish prices along the domestic supply chain of fish. Based on

academic and other literatures available, the general consensus was that fishermen were

receiving lesser benefits than what they should be. This therefore prompted us to also explore

the development of this increasingly dynamic industry at the fishermen’s level, and to

ascertain what was causing a potential irregularity in the distribution of benefits.

A variety of techniques were engaged in the field during the research process. The primary

method involved semi-structured interviews with individuals across all levels of the supply

chain. The questionnaires were frequently changed and adapted to fit the irregular nature of

the industry’s structure, whilst sampling methods also faced compromises for similar reasons.

Group interviews and focus groups were also used throughout, although to a lesser extent,

and the assigned translator for the project period was consulted on any changes made to the

methodology to assure clarity in the field and for advice and support on how communication

may be made more effective.

The project findings were clear and distinctive. Wholesale merchants were those most likely

to benefit from the increases in fish prices as they possessed the storage facilities allowing

them to sell their product according to more favourable supply and demand conditions. They

were also capable of engaging in value-adding activities such as cleaning, sorting and icing

the fish. Local retailer merchants and high-end restaurants were relatively unaffected,

whereas fishermen, low-end restaurants and vendors benefitted least due to their lack of

access to financial capital to help invest in equipment capable of adding value to their

product. Co-operatives and the Panchayat were seen to be helping the basic development of

fishermen communities and their role in the industry; however, it was apparent that the levels

of aid given were exaggerated or out-dated when compared to the claims made by fishermen.

Small-scale retailers at a local fish market

Page 7: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

7

4. Kerala: Gender Equality in the Division of Labour in Local Fisheries. By Vera

Gulbrandsen and Waseem Meghjee

The Kerala “model of development” is famous for its progress in human development,

scoring impressively high on indicators such as life expectancy, literacy, infant mortality and

mean years of schooling and there is also evidence of great progress concerning gender

equality, shown by the high scores of both men and women on these indicators. However, we

found that there has been a significant decrease of female participation in the labour force in

the last decade. Therefore, with this project, we wanted to discover what gender relations

looked like beyond official statistics like the HDI - how the traditional and cultural gender

norms affect the division of labour, labour participation and people’s livelihoods.

We chose to focus on an interesting form of livelihood that reflects significantly all the

various dimensions of development, including economic, social and political implication, is

fishing. Using mainly semi structured interviews but also focus groups and a survey, we

collected data from 110 individuals connected to the fishing industry in different ways - we

interviewed fishermen, fisherwomen, fish vendors, women from a Kudumbashree with

fishing industry-related jobs, students, head loaders and auctioneers.

Our findings show a clear division of labour where women are excluded from participating in

marine fishing, which is the most lucrative and highest-status occupation in the industry, and

that this exclusion creates large inequalities and vulnerabilities. We found three possible

sources of the male dominance in this activity: influence of traditional views and folklore,

protection of male identities, and structural inequalities. Furthermore, we found that it is

culturally desirable in the fishing community for women to be housewives and that it is

almost only families with

marine fishermen who can

afford this status position.

Women work purely out of

economic necessity, and are

only allowed to participate in

lower-status activities. This

norm is detrimental to

development as it causes

society to lose out on large

amounts of potential labour

power, and it also perpetuates

discrimination towards women

who are seen as subordinate.

Vera and Waseem during an interview with fishermen

Page 8: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

8

5. What constitutes a successful woman? By Farzana Ahmed, Frances Hancock and

Shabana Khanum

Kerala has been celebrated for its incredible social development in the absence of a strong

economic base, in particular achieving gender equality though education. However, despite

high educational achievements, women have very low work participation rates. Studies reveal

that women remain in the education stream longer, indicating a gendered division in course

choices, with a much lower presence in vocational courses, except for nursing and teaching.

This raises questions regarding the role of education if not for career advancement?

We were interested in women’s perception of what is makes women successful, what their

role is in society and barriers to success. Semi-structured interviews were conducted on

professional women, female heads of households and students in a focus group setting. A

participatory research activity was used during interviews with students to explore initial

ideas on the definitions of a successful woman and to prompt further inquiry.

Education is perceived as a crucial aspect of women’s life, primarily due to its capacity in

empowering women, giving them the courage to be independent. However, women’s duty

remains with their family. Women’s role in supporting the family is perceived as

irreplaceable, and thus what makes them successful. Furthermore, the barriers to success are

simultaneously viewed as the enablers of success. Decisions made at the family level

ultimately shape a woman’s future. As such, their support in encouraging women is perceived

as important in enabling women’s success. An area for further research includes focusing on

decision-making at the household level to thoroughly understand factors influencing

perceptions of women’s responsibilities.

Participatory activity with students at St. Michael’s College

Top traits of a successful woman

Page 9: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

9

6. How and why has the increase of women in politics altered the perception of women

in society? By Lydia McSweeney and Ines Nebi

Kerala is well known for its successful social development with the highest literacy rates for

women in the whole of India. It is these advancements for example that have propelled the

question of gender roles and the challenges imposed on women by the society. Yet there is

increasing evidence in the narrowing of the gender gap, with more women involved in the

political sphere. We therefore aimed to uncover whether the increase in women in politics has

changed how women are seen at various different levels. In addition, we also sought to look

at what the primary contributors to these changes have been.

In order to do this, we asked 3 groups of students aged, 15-18 a questionnaire consisting of

14 questions about themselves, their background, their views on women working and women

in politics. We also constructed semi structured interviews with women working within the

Panchayat, women in Kudumbashrees and women in households. These interviews asked the

women specific questions about themselves along with questions on a woman’s role in

society, their view of the equality laws, questions on women in politics and what they hope

for women in the future.

From our research we found that the increased participation of women in both the Panchayats

and Kudumbasrees encouraged self-sufficiency among women. They claim that if all women

have self-sufficiency, only then will they have true freedom and equality within society and

be less reliant on men. However, at a community level, it is apparent that the role of

Kudumbasrees has been more significant in improving women’s standing in society than that

of politics. Yet there is some consensus on the increased role of politics in the future, with the

potential to better implement legal frameworks for the advancement of the women’s cause for

equality.

Lydia and Ines with participants at a focus group

Page 10: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

10

7. Is there an existing correlation between education and migration patterns in

rural/semi-urban Kerala? By Pierre Swaelus, Xavier Nukajam, and Katie Matthews

In the words of Anil Gupta, professor in a prestigious managerial school in India; if the

country is to achieve a sustainable and equitable growth, the government must empower its

people through education. Today, Kerala’s 95% literacy rate ranks the state amongst the most

literate of India, perhaps of Asia and enjoys the highest Human Development Index (0.790);

nevertheless, this is not its only particularity. Beside, 25% of the region’s GDP is directly

stemmed from the remittance of three million Keralites, dispersed across the globe. For this

reason, our group has decided to enquire on the existing relationships between the high level

of education and young people’s aspirations in Alleppey, a costal semi-urban area.

In the space of this research, our group has meticulously sought to gather insightful and

intimate information on students, migrants, and teachers’ lives. Henceforth, focusing on

semi-structured interviews and focus groups, we interviewed around sixty people whose ages

stood between 16 and 72. This research methodology permitted our group to acquire a better

intelligence of the subject, in a short period of time. Moreover, feeling so close to these

people allowed us to understand the socio-cultural richness of Kerala on a broader spectrum.

Our research questionnaires were

divided into three different

sections:

1) The level of education and,

how Kerala’s system works and

evolves;

2) The level and trends/patterns of

migration;

3) The correlation between 1 & 2.

Students participating at a focus group

We found that education triggered students’ aspiration to improve their lives quality, but has

also helped, to a certain extent, to empower women in society. It is plausible that this

motivates student to take more specific subjects with hope to find better-paid jobs and more

employment opportunities overseas. In short, education embodies their passport for life and

triggers their aspirations. Moreover, we discovered that education is changing careers’

ambitions. Students’ qualifications are diversifying and it goes the same way for the

geographies of migration (more global) – in opposition to the 1980’s Gulf migration patterns.

Note that migration patterns may have changed due to changing employment policies and

availabilities in Gulf States since 2012. Furthermore, it can be added that such results could

provide interesting insights and indications for the prediction of future migration movements.

Page 11: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

11

8. Keralites’ migration to the Gulf: public and private responses. By Alesha de Fonseka,

Janice Leung and Neehar Ravi

This study focuses on the impacts of migration from Kerala, India to the Persian Gulf, and is

concerned with the resulting public and private responses to the migration trajectories.

International migration from Kerala has been steadily increasing since the 1940s, with 6.9%

of the total population of Kerala (33 million) living abroad. Consequently, both communities

in Kerala and abroad were impacted. In this research, public response is defined as

institutional or organisational reactions, such as policy making, whereas private response

refers to the ways families deal with the impacts of Gulf migration. The impacts and local

responses of Gulf migration on Kerala are thus examined.

To conduct our study we used two research methodologies- focus groups and interviews, we

conducted 15 household interviews (aimed at gathering impacts of migration on the families

left behind), a focus group with 11 students (aimed at understanding motivations for

emigration to the gulf, and the impacts of gulf emigration on the young generation). We also

conducted 3 interviews with organizations that support families left behind and migrants

abroad including the Catholic Church, the Parvasi organization that provides assistance to

migrants abroad through memberships to their organization and a government official.

We found that the main motives behind this phenomenon were a lack of well-paid jobs for

unskilled workers in Kerala, as well as the aim to gather enough wealth for dowries of sisters

and daughters. Spouses were often quoted to be unhappy with the lack of a central male

figure in the family, with few seeing it as an opportunity to assert female independence in

their husband’s absence but instead allowing their fathers or in-laws to control the major

decisions in this typically patriarchal society. The lack of any real current government action

means dowry is still a freely practised ceremony, even though it is prohibited by National

Law. This means many workers go abroad for this particular reason, with no awareness of the

mistreatment they face while under contract.

Kerala needs to move one step further

than just providing high school education

to ensure a high literacy rate; there needs

to be an increase in awareness about the

hidden truths behind Gulf migration and

questions need to be raised about why the

dowry system is still ingrained into the

practises of a state that is considered to be

so much more progressive than most of

India.

Neehar, Alesha and Janice visiting a family with

Gulf migrant relatives

Page 12: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

12

9. What are the perceptions of male students on gulf migration and how are these views

reflected in returned migrants? By Jack Bathe and Louis Pattison

Our aim within this project consisted of interviewing male secondary school pupils (ranging

from 15 years old to 20+) in a focus group setting in order to gauge their perceptions of

migration to the Gulf states and to try and figure out what might have influenced their

thinking on the subject. In addition to this, we conducted semi-structured interviews with

returned migrants; this, we felt, would allow us to get an indication as to the difference

between the perception and reality of working in the Gulf States.

Before coming to Kerala we had done some reading on the subject which suggested that the

life of the “Gulfan”, a term used to describe a young male who travels out to the Gulf in

search of financial gain, had been glamorised in films and by the media. We therefore

predicted that many young men would be interested in working in the Gulf due to this

implied reality. Further reading suggested that many Indians are exploited during their time

in the Gulf and, as such, we predicted that many returned migrants would speak negatively of

their time in the Gulf, contradicting the views of the students. What we found was the

complete opposite.

It was the students that mainly held a negative view of working in the Gulf and although few

had family members in the Gulf to use

as a source of information the media

seemed to be playing its part in

creating a negative view of the Gulf.

Other reasons listed by students for

their reluctance to work in the Gulf

included a slowing economy in the

Gulf, decreasing exchange rates, poor

climatic conditions, and exploitation

of workers. However, many students

expressed a desire to migrate

elsewhere, to locations such as

Australia, the United States, and the

UK. This indicated to us that views of

Gulf migration in India were

undergoing reformation.

Jack and Louis with participants at a focus group

When we interviewed returned migrants we were surprised to discover that many spoke

highly of working in the Gulf and all of them recommended that others should go there to

work. Most migrants found that Gulf work provided the financial stability they needed to

support their family; however they also identified the problem of exploitation existing mainly

within labour forces and less so amongst qualified workers. From this research we could

draw two conclusions; firstly it would seem that the students have been heavily influenced by

media representations of exploitation in the Gulf when in fact it appears to be less wide

spread than is perceived, indicating a media focus on negative aspects in the Gulf. Secondly,

we can assume upon speaking to returned migrants themselves many students may change

their mind about migrating to the Gulf and would perhaps be more open to the idea; however,

with that said, a growing movement towards migration to the West and Australia, as well as a

rapidly advancing India economy, may be enough to dissuade future migrations to the Gulf.

Page 13: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

13

10. To What Extend has the Kudumbashree Initiative Helped Alleviate Poverty in

Kerala? By Sam Mitchell, Geoffrey-Peter Ross and Rodolphe Bichot

During the first week of December, myself and two other researchers aimed to find out how

the Kudumbashree initiative, launched in 1998 has helped combat poverty in the state of

Kerala. The initiative is open only to females, but the literal meaning translates to prosperity

of the family. In order to attempt to see if the scheme was a success, we undertook 3 days of

data collection, in the form of group and personal interviews at the North Mararikulam

panchayat and 10 local Kudumbashrees. By asking sets of questions designed to gauge

opinions and insight into the initiative, we were able to gain interesting data and opinions on

the extent to the Kudumbashree’s impact towards alleviating poverty. Using participatory

methods of research, in the form of focus groups, we gained interesting knowledge on the

Kudumbashree system, its benefits and the criticisms surrounding it.

Our main findings demonstrated the benefits the initiative is bringing to alleviating poverty in

Kerala. Whilst a grassroots scheme, its multifaceted aspects such as improving financial

independence, social cohesion and additional income gained large amount of praise from the

women involved. There are clearly some difficulties with the scheme, including eligibility,

unsuccessful enterprises, widely varied rates of repayment (as high as 12%) on some loans

and a lack of proper training provided by the panchayat, however, as an overall scheme, it is

evident that the Kudumbashree is benefitting Kerala and Keralans, both economically and

socially.

As a recommendation for policy action, we would suggest closer ties between the panchayat

and kudumbashree. The panchayat is the essential link which delivers much of the

Kudumbashree’s investment and

teaching of vital skills, and it

appears in some Kudumbashrees,

these ties have broken down in

some aspects. Whilst the financial

aspects of the initiative seem to be

outweighed by the social benefits

of the scheme, it would be naïve

to judge the scheme solely on

monetary profits, without

considering the huge gains to

empowerment and inclusiveness

the initiative has bought to many

people’s lives.

Geoff, Sam and Rodolphe with participants at a focus group

Page 14: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

14

11. To what extent are disabled people integrated into society in Kerala? By Shahd

Hammou, Elisabeth Pramendorfer and Agnieszka Zajac

The aim of this project was to investigate different factors in which contribute to the

integration of disabled citizens into Kerala’s society. The three main focuses were on 1)

appropriate policy 2) economic access and 3) social stigma. All three evaluative factors

supported us in exploring how society perceives disabled people in Kerala and how they are

integrated into society. On the basis of our prior knowledge of developing countries, we

formulated the hypothesis that disabled citizens are marginalized in Kerala’s society due to

lack of services and public awareness.

The research was mainly conducted through the use of interviews. They were conducted in

consideration of three subcategories: group, expert and semi-structured interviews. Medical

students were interviewed in groups as well as some parents, whereas the expert interviews

(Panchayat leaders, NGO’s etc) were done individually. Semi-structured interviews were

used to enhance the data gathered, it was common for the interviewees to naturally secede a

question by something of interest to us, particularly the parents of the disabled children we

had met at the World Disability’s Fair, allowing further uncategorized scope.

The general findings of the research were that, indeed, disabled citizens and specifically elder

disabled people were significantly disadvantaged in society and struggled with very little

financial means. It was clear to see that a lack of economic access and appropriate policy lead

to social exclusion which birthed social stigma as people were unaware of the hardships

faced and unaware of how to include disabled citizens into society. We found that most

organisations relied on public donations, but the private and public disability services that

were available specifically for disabled children were of good standard, with qualified staff

and useful facilities, which parents and workers praised. However, employees of these

services hope for there to be more disabled schools in the future, preferably one in each

Panchayat, making it more accessible for all in need.

A traditional Kerala style meal with parents of

the disabled children at the World Disability Fair

Page 15: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

15

12. How are patterns of dress among young women being influenced by social, economic

and cultural change? By Owen Dawson, Rachael Morey, Nikita Shah and Stella Tsellingas

To research if clothing styles are being

influenced by western cultures. How

women access western cultures through

various types of media? Does

Bollywood have any influence in the

way women dress? How are Northern

styles influencing and homogenising

with the South?

We used semi-structured interviews to

gain the opinions and views of women,

mainly students and shoppers, aged 16-

30. We also conducted focus groups

with students from St Michaels

College. We also conducted short

interviews with shopkeepers in Allepey

and used personal observation as a

method to collect information about

shopkeepers and their establishments. Clothing store in Alleppey

There has been a variety of social, economic and cultural influences that have alerted dress

patterns within Kerala amongst young women. Women commonly stated that they did not

like western clothing and do not wear it, particularly due to cultural constrains. Our results

highlighted that rather than global influences altering dress patterns in Kerala, national

influences are more common. North Indian influences are heavily incorporated into Keralan

culture; women commonly wear more north Indian clothing such as the Churidar and the

North Indian Sari.

The Keralan culture is in fact disappearing; however a national homogenisation in clothing

worn by women is occurring rather than global homogenisation through processes such as

globalisation. The shopkeepers informed us that the most common item sold is a North Indian

churidar. They decide what to sell based on consumer demand mostly; this suggested people

were more interested in wearing North Indian clothes rather than Western. Regarding places

where clothes are manufactured, Keralan styles are produced in South India whereas

Northern Indian and Western styles are produced all over the country. 66.7% of the

shopkeepers interviewed would like to sell Western clothes in their shops; they said they are

quite popular within towns. The shopkeepers who did not want to sell Western clothes stated

that they are too culturally inappropriate for Kerala.

Page 16: King’s College London · and Caleb Stone ... Geography students from King's College London in 2013. ... and nine fish market interviews over the course of three days.

16

We would like to express our special gratitude to Dax Gueizelar

for his contribution to the organization of the activities in India,

for providing us with skilful and enthusiastic translators,

and for always being supportive towards our students and staff.

A great THANK YOU to all those people who made our experience unforgettable!

Academic staff participating in the Kerala Field Visit 2013:

Prof. Mark Pelling

Prof. Linda Newton

Dr. Michal Chadwick

Dr. Andrew Brooks

Dr. Mirela Barbu