KinChem: A Computational Resource for Teaching and ... · KinChem: A Computational Resource for...

3
KinChem: A Computational Resource for Teaching and Learning Chemical Kinetics Jose ́ Nunes da Silva Jú nior,* ,Mary Anne Sousa Lima, Eduardo Henrique Silva Sousa, Francisco Serra Oliveira Alexandre, and Antonio Jose ́ Melo Leite Jú nior Departamento de Química Orgâ nica e Inorgâ nica, Universidade Federal do Ceara ́ , Fortaleza, Ceara ́ 60451-970, Brasil Instituto UFC Virtual, Universidade Federal do Ceara ́ , Fortaleza, Ceara ́ 60440-554, Brasil * S Supporting Information ABSTRACT: This paper presents a piece of educational software covering a comprehensive number of topics of chemical kinetics, which is available free of charge in Portuguese and English. The software was developed to support chemistry educators and students in the teaching-learning process of chemical kinetics by using animations, calculations, and simulations. Furthermore, this software was thoroughly evaluated by several chemistry educators from many universities in Brazil and abroad; they agreed the software has comprehensive content, is easy to use, and should be employed along with textbooks. KEYWORDS: First-Year Undergraduate/General, Chemoinformatics, Computer-Based Learning, Kinetics, Undergraduate Research INTRODUCTION During the past few years, popularization of computers and smartphones along with the wider access to the Internet by students have motivated the use of educational software as teaching tools, 1 and several educational software packages were developed for improvement of the teaching and learning process in all areas of Chemistry. 2-11 However, there are only a few software or applications available in the Internet for chemical kinetics, and those are still quite basic, exploring a limited number of topics and mostly not very well presented and organized. Due to these issues, we have developed a student-friendly educational software available for download free of charge in Portuguese and English that covers several topics of chemical kinetics. (See the Supporting Information.) This software works mainly on interactivity aiming to support chemistry educators and students beyond textbook to improve the teaching-learning of chemical kinetics. SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT The software structure and interface was developed following ve major points: 1. The software should be easy to use. 2. The language should be easy to understand. 3. The content should be comprehensive and suitable for use in higher education. 4. The software should assist the educator in the teaching process when used in the classroom. 5. The software should contribute to the improvement of the teaching and learning processes. The software KinChem is user-friendly and easy to navigate and was developed using the Adobe Flash platform 12 because it allows easy and ecient development of many functionalities, while making it possible to run in Microsoft Windows. Its content treats in a pedagogically useful manner many introductory chemical kinetics topics encountered in the majority of undergraduate textbooks of general chemistry and in physical chemistry and was organized in 13 dierent topics: introduction, reaction rates, instantaneous and average rate, rate laws, order of reaction, integrated rate laws, half-life, Arrhenius equation, collision model, catalysis, homogeneous and hetero- geneous catalysis, and enzymatic catalysis. KinChem uses a combo box to access all chemical kinetics principles, which are presented through short introductory texts along with graphical simulations and animations. They were prepared and carefully designed by aiming to build a connection to the text and concepts making them easier to be remembered by the user, facilitating the teaching and learning processes. For example, the users can simulate graphs by entering variables in the software such as temperature and nature of gases to study the eect on Arrehnius equations behavior (Figure 1) or can visualize an animation illustrating a mechanism of a heterogeneous catalysis, which occurs in automotive exhaust (Figure 2). Published: September 16, 2014 Technology Report pubs.acs.org/jchemeduc © 2014 American Chemical Society and Division of Chemical Education, Inc. 2203 dx.doi.org/10.1021/ed500433c | J. Chem. Educ. 2014, 91, 2203-2205

Transcript of KinChem: A Computational Resource for Teaching and ... · KinChem: A Computational Resource for...

Page 1: KinChem: A Computational Resource for Teaching and ... · KinChem: A Computational Resource for Teaching and Learning Chemical Kinetics JoséNunes da Silva Júnior, *,† Mary Anne

KinChem: A Computational Resource for Teaching and LearningChemical KineticsJose Nunes da Silva Junior,*,† Mary Anne Sousa Lima,† Eduardo Henrique Silva Sousa,†

Francisco Serra Oliveira Alexandre,† and Antonio Jose Melo Leite Junior‡

†Departamento de Química Organica e Inorganica, Universidade Federal do Ceara, Fortaleza, Ceara 60451-970, Brasil‡Instituto UFC Virtual, Universidade Federal do Ceara, Fortaleza, Ceara 60440-554, Brasil

*S Supporting Information

ABSTRACT: This paper presents a piece of educational software covering acomprehensive number of topics of chemical kinetics, which is available free ofcharge in Portuguese and English. The software was developed to supportchemistry educators and students in the teaching−learning process of chemicalkinetics by using animations, calculations, and simulations. Furthermore, thissoftware was thoroughly evaluated by several chemistry educators from manyuniversities in Brazil and abroad; they agreed the software has comprehensivecontent, is easy to use, and should be employed along with textbooks.

KEYWORDS: First-Year Undergraduate/General, Chemoinformatics, Computer-Based Learning, Kinetics, Undergraduate Research

■ INTRODUCTION

During the past few years, popularization of computers andsmartphones along with the wider access to the Internet bystudents have motivated the use of educational software asteaching tools,1 and several educational software packages weredeveloped for improvement of the teaching and learningprocess in all areas of Chemistry.2−11 However, there are only afew software or applications available in the Internet forchemical kinetics, and those are still quite basic, exploring alimited number of topics and mostly not very well presentedand organized. Due to these issues, we have developed astudent-friendly educational software available for downloadfree of charge in Portuguese and English that covers severaltopics of chemical kinetics. (See the Supporting Information.)This software works mainly on interactivity aiming to supportchemistry educators and students beyond textbook to improvethe teaching−learning of chemical kinetics.

■ SOFTWARE DEVELOPMENT

The software structure and interface was developed followingfive major points:

1. The software should be easy to use.

2. The language should be easy to understand.

3. The content should be comprehensive and suitable for

use in higher education.4. The software should assist the educator in the teaching

process when used in the classroom.

5. The software should contribute to the improvement ofthe teaching and learning processes.

The software KinChem is user-friendly and easy to navigateand was developed using the Adobe Flash platform12 because itallows easy and efficient development of many functionalities,while making it possible to run in Microsoft Windows. Itscontent treats in a pedagogically useful manner manyintroductory chemical kinetics topics encountered in themajority of undergraduate textbooks of general chemistry andin physical chemistry and was organized in 13 different topics:introduction, reaction rates, instantaneous and average rate, ratelaws, order of reaction, integrated rate laws, half-life, Arrheniusequation, collision model, catalysis, homogeneous and hetero-geneous catalysis, and enzymatic catalysis.KinChem uses a combo box to access all chemical kinetics

principles, which are presented through short introductory textsalong with graphical simulations and animations. They wereprepared and carefully designed by aiming to build aconnection to the text and concepts making them easier tobe remembered by the user, facilitating the teaching andlearning processes. For example, the users can simulate graphsby entering variables in the software such as temperature andnature of gases to study the effect on Arrehnius equationsbehavior (Figure 1) or can visualize an animation illustrating amechanism of a heterogeneous catalysis, which occurs inautomotive exhaust (Figure 2).

Published: September 16, 2014

Technology Report

pubs.acs.org/jchemeduc

© 2014 American Chemical Society andDivision of Chemical Education, Inc. 2203 dx.doi.org/10.1021/ed500433c | J. Chem. Educ. 2014, 91, 2203−2205

Page 2: KinChem: A Computational Resource for Teaching and ... · KinChem: A Computational Resource for Teaching and Learning Chemical Kinetics JoséNunes da Silva Júnior, *,† Mary Anne

Additionally, the software offers a quiz containing 30questions covering all topics presented, where they can verifytheir knowledge.

■ METHODOLOGY OF EVALUATIONThis software was evaluated by chemistry educators using anelectronic form containing seven statements (Table 1). Allopinions regarding KinChem were registered using a Likertscale13 for each one of the resources: interface, language,content, and usefulness.

■ KINCHEM EVALUATION BY CHEMISTRYEDUCATORS

KinChem was tested and evaluated by 35 chemistry educators,where 15 of them were from our own university, 16 educatorswere from other 14 Brazilian universities, and 4 educators werefrom 4 universities abroad. The group of evaluators wascomposed of 67% of males and 33% of females, ranging from 1to 42 years of teaching experience in higher education. Thesenumbers are equivalent to an average of 10.1 years of teachingexperience for the evaluators, where 40% had over 10 years ofexperience and 89% had already taught chemical kinetics.

■ RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONCurrently, society has faced a fast growing and widespread useof personal computers and other portable electronic devices,which has caused a clear influence in scientific education.14,15

Some science educators believe computer animations (alsocalled computer simulators), particularly, can have a largeimpact on teaching and learning scientific concepts.16

The traditional chemistry teaching process can become muchmore appealing and effective to students when permeated withinteractive technological tools. Once the visualization ofgraphics such as molecular modeling and animations providea clearer and detailed idea of molecular dynamics andinteractions, it brings a new layer of learning into place.Textbooks usually do not provide enough information to createa clear picture of the phenomenon in the student’s mind.17,18

Figure 1. Section within Arrehnius equation topic. Figure 2. Section within heterogeneous catalysis topic.

Table 1. Distribution of Likert Categories

Chemistry EducatorResponses,a % (n = 35)

Statements for Response TA A M D TD

1. The software is easy to use. 50 44 6 0 02. Language used in the software is easy

to understand.58 42 0 0 0

3. Software contents are comprehensiveand suitable for use in highereducation.

47 42 6 6 0

4. The software can assist the educator inthe teaching process when used inthe classroom.

47 44 6 3 0

5. The software can contribute to theimprovement of student learning.

56 31 11 3 0

6. The use of the software during classcan increase student interest.

44 36 17 3 0

7. The software can be recommended tostudents as a supplementary resourceto textbooks.

58 33 6 0 3

aTA, totally agree; A, agree; M, maybe; D, disagree; TD, totallydisagree.

Journal of Chemical Education Technology Report

dx.doi.org/10.1021/ed500433c | J. Chem. Educ. 2014, 91, 2203−22052204

Page 3: KinChem: A Computational Resource for Teaching and ... · KinChem: A Computational Resource for Teaching and Learning Chemical Kinetics JoséNunes da Silva Júnior, *,† Mary Anne

Based on this, we decided to develop an organized and broadcontent software on chemical kinetics that could cover the mostcommon topics present in textbooks. This software, calledKinChem, is available free of charge for download at the Website http://www.quimica.ufc.br/KinChem.The majority of evaluators also agreed that KinChem covers

all five major points which motivated its development.Additionally, they also agree that the use of this softwareduring class can increase student interest and should berecommended as a supplementary resource to textbooks (Table1).

■ CONCLUSIONSThis software has been very well scored by all evaluators,showing their overwhelming satisfaction and likely usage ofKinChem in classes as well as an extra online tool tocomplement textbooks. The interactivity and multimediaapproaches offered by KinChem can have a significant impacton the teaching−learning process, where the evaluators and webelieve it can increase student motivation, interest andunderstanding. As this software is available in Portuguese andEnglish, it can reach a much broader audience and help toimprove the teaching−learning process of chemical kinetics.

■ ASSOCIATED CONTENT*S Supporting Information

Two Flash files (English and Portuguese versions); descriptionof the educational software. These materials are available viaInternet at http://pubs.acs.org.

■ AUTHOR INFORMATIONCorresponding Author

*E-mail: [email protected].

Notes

The authors declare no competing financial interest.

■ ACKNOWLEDGMENTSThe authors are thankful to all chemistry educators thatprovided their evaluation of KinChem.

■ REFERENCES(1) Valente, J. A. Computadores e Conhecimento: Repensando aEducaca o; Grafica da Unicamp: Campinas, Brasil, 1993.(2) Marson, G. A.; Torres, B. B. Fostering Multi-representationalLevels of Chemical Concepts: A Framework to Develop EducationalSoftware. J. Chem. Educ. 2011, 88, 1616−1622.(3) Marson, G. A.; Torres, B. B. Principles of Gel PermeationChromatography. J. Chem. Educ. 2006, 83, 1567−1568.(4) Yokaichiya, D. K.; Fraceto, L. F.; Miranda, M. A.; Galembeck, E.;Torres, B. B. AMPc-Sinalizacao Intracelular: Um Software Educa-cional. Quim. Nova 2004, 27, 489−491.(5) Yokaichiya, D. K.; Galembeck, E. Radicais Livres de Oxigenio:Um Software Introdutorio. Quim. Nova 2000, 23, 267−269.(6) Lona, L. M. F.; F, A. N.; Roque, M. C.; Rodrigues, S. Developingand Educational Software for Heat Exchangers and Heat ExchangersNetworks Projects. Comput. Chem. Eng. 2000, 24, 1247−1252.(7) Eichler, M.; Pino, J. C. D. Computadores em Educacao Quımica:Estrutura Atomica e Tabela Periodica. Quim. Nova 2000, 23, 835−840.(8) Benite, A. M. C.; Benite, C. R. M.; Silva Filho, S. M. Ciberculturaem Ensino de Quımica: Elaboracao de um Objeto Virtual deAprendizagem para o Ensino de Modelos Atomicos. Quım. NovaEsc. 2011, 33, 71−76.

(9) Ayres, A. C. S.; Sousa, M. P.; Mercon, F.; Santos, N.; Rapello, C.N. Titulando 2004: Um Software para o Ensino de Quımica. Quım.Nova Esc. 2005, 22, 35−37.(10) Silva, J. N., Jr.; Barbosa, F. G.; Leite, A. J. M., Jr.; Eduardo, V. M.Ressonancia: Desenvolvimento, Utilizacao e Avaliacao de um SoftwareEducacional. Quim. Nova 2014, 37, 373−376.(11) Silva, J. N., Jr.; Barbosa, F. G.; Leite, A. J. M., Jr. PolarımetroVirtual: Desenvolvimento, Utilizacao e Avaliacao de um SoftwareEducacional. Quim. Nova 2012, 35, 1884−1886.(12) Adobe Flash, Adobe Systems Incorporated, 2013.(13) Likert, R. Arch. Psychol. 1932, 140, 1.(14) Ellis, J. D. A Rationale for Using Computers in ScienceEducation. Am. Biol. Teach. 1984, 46, 200−206.(15) Marks, G. H. Computer Simulations in Science Teaching: AnIntroduction. J. Comput. Math. Sci. Teach. 1982, 1, 18−20.(16) Gladwin, R. P.; Margerison, D.; Walker, S. M. Comput. Educ.1992, 19, 17−25.(17) Gili Marbach-Ad, G.; Rotbain, Y.; Stavy, R. Using ComputerAnimation and Illustration Activities to Improve High SchoolStudents’ Achievement in Molecular Genetics. J. Res. Sci. Teach.2008, 45, 273−292.(18) Smith, S.; Stowall, I. Networked Instructional Chemistry: UsingTechnology to Teach Chemistry. J. Chem. Educ. 1996, 73, 911−915.

Journal of Chemical Education Technology Report

dx.doi.org/10.1021/ed500433c | J. Chem. Educ. 2014, 91, 2203−22052205