Key Rating Factors - Business and Financial Risks in the Retail Industry (1)

15
ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The Retail Industry Primary Credit Analysts: Jerry A Hirschberg, New York (1) 212-438-1000; [email protected] Stella Kapur, New York (1) 212-438-1262; [email protected] Nicolas Baudouin, Paris (33) 1-4420-6672; [email protected] Table Of Contents Relationship Between Business And Financial Risks Part 1--Business Risk Analysis Keys To Competitive Success Part 2--Financial Risk Analysis WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 1 THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA. NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED. 1386220 | 301983604

description

key rating factors

Transcript of Key Rating Factors - Business and Financial Risks in the Retail Industry (1)

  • ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials:

    Key Credit Factors: Business AndFinancial Risks In The Retail Industry

    Primary Credit Analysts:

    Jerry A Hirschberg, New York (1) 212-438-1000; [email protected]

    Stella Kapur, New York (1) 212-438-1262; [email protected]

    Nicolas Baudouin, Paris (33) 1-4420-6672; [email protected]

    Table Of Contents

    Relationship Between Business And Financial Risks

    Part 1--Business Risk Analysis

    Keys To Competitive Success

    Part 2--Financial Risk Analysis

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 1

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

  • ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials:

    Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial RisksIn The Retail Industry(Editor's Note: This criteria article is no longer current. It has been superseded by the article titled, "Key Credit Factors For The

    Retail And Restaurants Industry," published on Nov. 19, 2013. Previously, this article was partially superseded. The section

    describing liquidity/short-term factors was partially superseded by the article titled, "Methodology And Assumptions: Liquidity

    Descriptors For Global Corporate Issuers," published on Sept. 28, 2011. The section describing management evaluation was

    superseded by "Methodology: Management And Governance Credit Factors For Corporate Entities And Insurers," published on

    Nov. 13, 2012. Tables 1, 2, and 3were superseded by the business risk and financial risk matrix found in "Methodology: Business

    Risk/Financial Risk Matrix Expanded," published Sept. 18, 2012.)

    Standard & Poor's Ratings Services' analytic methodology evaluates the qualitative and quantitative factors of an issuer

    to determine a credit rating opinion on that issuer. The analytic framework for industrial companies in all sectors,

    including retailers, is divided into two major segments: The first part is fundamental business risk analysis. This step

    forms the basis and provides the industry and business context for the second segment of the analysis, an in-depth

    financial risk analysis of the company.

    Our rating analysis of retailers begins with the industry, business, management, and competitive positions of the entity

    before we consider the financial risk profile. The company's business risk profile determines the financial risk it can

    bear at a given rating level.

    Relationship Between Business And Financial Risks

    Before discussing the specific factors we analyze in our methodological framework, it is important to understand how

    we view the relationship between business and financial risks. Table 1 displays this relationship and its implications for

    a company's rating.

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 2

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

  • Table 1

    Chart 1 summarizes the rating process.

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 3

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • Chart 1

    Part 1--Business Risk Analysis

    Business risk is analyzed in four categories: country risk, industry risk, competitive position, and profitability. We

    determine a score for the overall business risk based on the scale shown in table 2.

    Table 2

    Business Risk Measures

    Description Rating equivalent

    Excellent AAA/AA

    Strong A

    Satisfactory BBB

    Weak BB

    Vulnerable B/CCC

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 4

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • Analysis of business risk factors is supported by factual data, including statistics, but ultimately involves a fair amount

    of subjective judgment. Understanding business risk provides a context in which to judge financial risk, which covers

    analysis of cash flow generation, capitalization, and liquidity. In all cases, the analysis uses historical experience to

    make estimates of future performance and risk.

    1. Country risk and macroeconomic factors (economic, political, and social environments)

    Country risk plays a critical role in determining all ratings on companies in a given national domicile. Sovereign-related

    stress can have an overwhelming effect on company creditworthiness, both directly and indirectly.

    Sovereign credit ratings are suggestive of the general risk that local entities face, but the ratings may not fully capture

    the risk applicable to the private sector. As a result, when rating corporate companies, we look beyond the sovereign

    rating to evaluate the specific economic or country risks that may affect the entity's creditworthiness. Such risks

    pertain to the effect of government policies and other country risk factors on the obligor's business and financial

    environments, and an entity's ability to insulate itself from these risks.

    2. Industry business and credit risk characteristics

    In establishing a view of the degree of credit risk in a given industry for rating purposes, it is useful to consider how its

    risk profile compares to that of other industries. Although the industry risk characteristic categories are broadly similar

    across industries, the effect of these factors on credit risk can vary markedly among industries. Chart 2 below

    illustrates how the effects of these credit-risk factors vary among some major industries. The key industry factors are

    scored as follows: High risk (H), medium/high risk (M/H), medium risk (M), low/medium risk (L/M), and low risk (L).

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 5

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • Chart 2

    We believe the retail industry in many developed countries has an elevated level of business risk because of the

    confluence of higher risk industry factors including:

    Susceptibility to demand volatility driven by economic and product cycles;

    Intensity of competition in many developed markets;

    Slim operating margins and the increasingly commoditized nature of many retail product offerings;

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 6

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • Capital intensity;

    Operating leverage;

    Retail overcapacity or oversupply; and

    Reliance on growth in consumer credit purchases, which has been a major spur to sales in recent years. However,

    growth in consumer spending may become increasingly constrained by record levels of household debt.

    The retail industry in developed countries is also being pressured by economic and demographic maturation, which is

    slowing growth and driving consolidation. While consolidation reduces the number of competitors and often improves

    operating efficiency, it only tends to reduce pricing competition once an industry subsector has become highly

    concentrated. In earlier stages of consolidation, price competition is often exacerbated by the development of a

    two-tiered industry structure, where larger consolidators benefit from economies of scale. Their improved operating

    efficiency allows them to compete on price against smaller second-tier survivors (that are forced to compete by

    discounting). While these competitive dynamics are often very positive for consumers as it drives prices down, it is

    negative from the perspective of bond and equity holders as it erodes profitability and debt coverage. Internationally,

    exceptions to this higher risk industry profile can sometimes occur in certain developed country markets--particularly

    those with small or mid-sized populations, where the domestic industry is highly consolidated--and market size may

    not be attractive to large foreign operators. This is true, for example of the Australian and New Zealand supermarket

    industries, which have among the most favorable operating environments in the world.

    In rapidly industrializing developing countries, the retail industry's growth prospects are significantly stronger than in

    the developed world, driven by higher economic and demographic growth. These dynamics create rising disposable

    incomes and the expansion/penetration of Western style consumerism into traditional sectors of the economy.

    Companies operating in the retail sector have a fairly wide dispersion in their business risk profiles dependent on:

    The industry subsector in which they operate;

    Their competitive positions within a subsector; and

    The price segment served.

    Industry subsectors

    The retail industry is composed of various subsectors, with many similarities in their profiles, but also some significant

    differences. Subsectors types that have similar traits, and compete directly with each other for the consumer wallet,

    can be grouped together for purposes of industry risk analysis. In North America, we group the following subsectors

    together for analytic purposes:

    Supermarkets, pharmacies, and convenience stores;

    Department stores, general merchandise discounters, and apparel stores; and

    Nonapparel retailers (including electronics and appliances, home improvement/hardware, furniture and

    housewares, books, music, hobbies, sporting goods, and other specialty goods and services).

    The effect of cyclicality is the main risk differentiator between subsectors. Retailers selling staples, such as

    supermarkets and pharmacies, are less susceptible to economic downturns than are retailers in home improvement,

    appliances and apparel, where consumer purchases can be postponed when economic times become tougher.

    In all subsectors, sales growth and volume are critical to profitability, because of the high fixed cost base and property

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 7

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • intensity of these businesses (i.e., high operating leverage). The need to invest in new stores, undertake costly

    renovations of existing properties to maintain existing sales, and expand geographically to drive sales growth makes

    the business capital- and borrowing-intensive. Outdated and/or poorly maintained stores are susceptible to material

    sales erosions.

    Industry strengths:

    Pivotal role of the retailing sector and consumerism in the economy;

    Rapid industrialization of China, India, Eastern Asia, and the old Soviet Block countries spurring global retail

    demand, and overseas growth opportunities;

    Development of much-improved operating supply & inventory management capabilities, which has lowered costs,

    inventory, and working-capital risk;

    Availability of consumer finance in developed markets, spurring demand;

    Advent of low-cost, high-quality goods from emerging industrial countries has stretched the consumer dollar in

    developed countries, helping spur consumer demand;

    Consolidation in various subsectors (e.g., home improvement, electronics, and books) has created significant

    leverage over suppliers, economies of scale, and strong national retail name brand recognition; and

    Internet shopping provides a new high-growth distribution channel for traditional retailers.

    Industry challenges/risks:

    Intense price competition in many subsectors in the developed world;

    Maturing population means slowing demand growth in many developed countries;

    Cyclicality of demand tied to economic, consumer, and housing cycles;

    Overbuilt retail space in many developed markets;

    Seasonality and fashion risk;

    High consumer leverage in a growing number of major developed countries will likely crimp credit-driven growth

    for the foreseeable future--credit expansion/low interest rates have been a mainstay of retail sector growth in many

    developed markets in recent years; and

    Rapid growth of on-line shopping may erode traditional store sales demand, exacerbating retail space overcapacity,

    and undermine competitive position of traditional retailers that have not develop profitable on-line capabilities.

    Keys To Competitive Success

    As part of our industry analysis, we identify the keys to success that are typical for a company in a given industry. We

    consider the following factors to be primary drivers of business success in the retail industry:

    Size; strong relative market share and position;

    Geographic diversity of earnings, regionally and/or internationally;

    Presence in higher-growth segments, markets, or regions;

    Store sizes and appeal (efficient square footage, locations, layouts, and merchandizing);

    Well-established franchise, with strong retail brand loyalty;

    Operating efficiency, with effective management information systems, logistics/supply management, inventory

    controls, and efficient buying programs;

    Portfolio of profitable private-label products;

    Development of strong on-line shopping capabilities and distribution channels;

    Effective marketing programs;

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 8

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • History of successful repositioning to deal with competitive, demographic, fashion, product, and technology

    changes;

    Proven track record in profitably executing acquisitions; and

    Financial strength.

    3. Company competitive position

    In analyzing a company's competitive position, we consider the following:

    Market position and share;

    Actual and target client demographics;

    Brand and customer value proposition;

    Store locations, appeal, layout, and merchandizing;

    Competition;

    Operating strategy, capability, performance, and efficiency;

    Distribution and marketing;

    Extent of diversification and concentrations;

    Management evaluation;

    Business risk appetite and record of growth strategy;

    Governance and other corporate culture and organizational considerations; and

    Earnings and profitability, volatility of earnings and cash flows.

    Market share. Size alone does not ensure profitability and growth. However, in retailing, high market shares allow

    companies to spread out costs and enjoy more economies of scale than their competitors. It influences a company's

    ability to purchase goods and reorder fast-moving lines cost effectively. It can provide economies of scale in

    distribution, advertising, overhead, and information systems. Market share leadership creates clout with suppliers. Size

    is often closely correlated with, and is an outgrowth of, diversification. To achieve greater size, companies usually need

    to operate across multiple geographies. Smaller and medium sized operators will usually be precluded from reaching

    the highest ratings levels despite having strong profitability and solid financials characteristics because of lack of

    product, segment, and geographic diversification. International operators usually have stronger diversification and

    economies of scale.

    Diversification. We view diversification in terms of geography: Retailers generally are not diversified across

    subsegments. Rather, their concentration in one subsector tends to create a concentration of risk to cyclicality and

    competition in that sector.

    Regions may be in different stages of the business cycle, and experience different severity of cyclicality, with

    downdrafts in some areas offset by upswings in others. A company's ability to tailor strategies to the needs of local

    markets and to manage foreign exchange risks also is important. Diversification across different national markets is

    also critical because there are different levels of market maturity and growth opportunities; there are risks associated

    with a given national jurisdictions (particularly in the emerging markets); and there are differing levels of

    competitiveness and profitability in different national markets.

    Operating efficiency and flexibility. Retail companies must accommodate a high level of fixed and semi-fixed costs

    (including payrolls). For example, stores face ongoing costs such as property taxes, insurance, depreciation and

    amortization, interest, rent, and equipment leases. In addition, for a store to be operational, a minimum level of labor is

    necessary. Thus, a portion of a facility's labor costs can be viewed as fixed (of course, incremental labor may be added

    as business activity grows). Once revenues pass the breakeven point, however, a substantial percentage of incremental

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 9

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • revenues typically become profit. This is operating leverage. Putting pressure on vendors for better terms can be an

    effective way to hold down operating costs. The percentage of inventory that is "vendor financed" can be a good

    measure of cost efficiency. This metric is calculated by dividing accounts payable by inventory. Other traditional

    measures of operating efficiency include inventory days-on-hand and the size and frequency of inventory write-downs.

    Reducing in-store labor, damaged merchandise, and workers' compensation costs are key to lowering overall costs.

    Effective management information systems with up-to-date technology help ensure better control over daily

    operations, including labor scheduling. These systems improve the relationship between vendor and retailer by

    enabling electronic data interchange, and reducing inventories. This helps speed orders and reorders for most basic

    goods by quickly pinpointing which merchandise is selling well and needs restocking. It also identifies slow-moving

    inventory that needs to be marked down, making space available for fresh merchandise.

    In merchandising and buying, we believe there is no single best way to maximize efficiency. There are a variety of

    approaches, from centralized buying to team buying to autonomous purchasing. The key is to use the chosen approach

    successfully, be nimble enough to mix approaches when necessary, and recognize when a change needs to be made.

    On-going systems investments continue to be a priority for all retailers. To remain competitive, it is critical for retailers

    to invest in inventory management and point-of-sale systems to improve the flow of merchandise into stores (i.e.,

    inventory replenishment), to better match product mix and brands with consumer tastes and preferences in local

    markets, and give customers broader payment options.

    Managing capital. Retail companies must regularly re-invest in their properties, or build new properties to continue to

    attract customers, so the industry is capital intensive. Investment beyond normal maintenance spending is required to

    periodically reinvigorate a property, especially in more competitive markets.

    Capital intensity is a limiting ratings factor for retailers. This issue gives rise to a substantial amount of credit risk

    because management teams must plan capacity additions well in advance of new facility availability. When coupled

    with demand that is often linked to economic growth and therefore inherently difficult to forecast, retail companies can

    report wide variations in operating performance during the business cycle.

    Property development and refurbishment expertise. We view a company's renovation and development experience as a

    key competitive competency and advantage, considering the property risk and capital intensity inherent in the sector

    and the need to maintain an updated property portfolio.

    Inventory selection and merchandising. Selecting products that appeal to consumers' taste is key to attracting high

    consumer traffic, as is promoting product by developing strategies for effective display and publicity. Introduction of

    new items and moving into new categories and price points can reinvigorate sales and image. However, stocking

    merchandise and assortments that differ from customers' expectations or image of the store can bring problems.

    Management. Management is assessed for its ability to run and expand the business efficiently, while mitigating

    inherent business and financial risks. Retailing is a highly competitive business requiring experienced and successful

    management teams with a strong mix of the following disciplines:

    Marketing and brand management;

    Maximization of property cash flow;

    Operating efficiency and cost control;

    Customer service quality;

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 10

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • Labor relations and employee training;

    Asset, property, and project management;

    Value creation, and appealing prices, quality, and shopping experiences;

    Experience in successfully identifying, executing, and integrating acquisitions;

    Local government, zoning board, and regulatory relations management; and

    Capital access necessary to create and maintain property portfolios, and successfully manage leverage levels.

    4. Profitability

    Profitability is critical for retailers because of the need to fund investment in the business, and in making acquisitions.

    Profit potential is a critical determinant of credit protection. A company that generates higher operating margins and

    returns on capital also has a greater ability to fund growth internally, attract capital externally, and withstand business

    adversity. Earnings power ultimately attests to the value of the company's assets, as well. In fact, a company's profit

    performance offers a litmus test of its fundamental health and competitive position. Accordingly, the conclusions about

    profitability should confirm the assessment of business risk. Profitability measures include the following ratios, which

    need to be compared with both those of other participants and of rated entities in other industries:

    Pretax, pre-interest return on capital;

    Operating income plus D&A as a percentage of sales; and

    Earnings on business segment assets.

    Return on capital measures the underlying efficiency of invested assets and can be a leading indicator of long-term

    survival. This profitability ratio is indifferent to the mix of debt and equity in a company's capital structure, facilitating

    the comparison of one company to another.

    Part 2--Financial Risk Analysis

    Having evaluated a company's business risk, the analysis proceeds to several financial categories. The company's

    business risk profile determines the financial risk appropriate for any rating category. Financial risk is portrayed largely

    through quantitative means, particularly by using financial ratios.

    We analyze five risk categories: accounting characteristics; financial governance/policies and risk tolerance; cash flow

    adequacy; capital structure and leverage; and liquidity/short-term factors. We then determine a score for overall

    financial risk using the following scale:

    Table 3

    Financial Risk Measures

    Description Rating equivalent

    Minimal AAA/AA

    Modest A

    Intermediate BBB

    Aggressive BB

    Highly leveraged B

    A major goal of financial risk analysis is to determine the quality of a company's cash flow, which influences its

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 11

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • continued access to capital. An integral part of this analysis is also to evaluate the debt structure, including the mix of

    senior versus subordinated, fixed versus floating debt, as well as its maturity schedule. It is also important to analyze

    and form an opinion of management's financial policy, accounting elections, and risk tolerance. Using cash flow

    analysis as a building block, the analyst can then evaluate a company's liquidity profile. While often closely related, the

    analysis of a company's liquidity differs from that of its cash flow, as it also incorporates the evaluation of other

    sources and uses of funds, such as committed undrawn bank facilities, as well as contingent liabilities (e.g., guarantees,

    triggers, regulatory and legal settlements).

    1. Accounting characteristics

    A critical first step in evaluating a company's risk profile is to form an understanding of, and an opinion about, a

    company's accounting consistency, strategies and policiesand related implementation processes. Financial

    statements and related notes are the primary source of information about the financial condition and performance of a

    company. We also focus on the following areas:

    Analytical adjustments and areas of potential concern;

    Significant transactions and notable events that have accounting implications;

    Significant accounting and financial reporting policies and the underlying assumptions; and

    History of nonoperating results and extraordinary changes or adjustments and underlying accounting treatments,

    disclosures, and explanations.

    2. Financial governance/policies and risk tolerance

    The robustness of management's financial and accounting strategies is a key element in credit risk evaluation. We

    attach great importance to management's philosophies and policies involving financial risk. Transactions involving

    high debt levels may place a heavy burden on the company's cash flow and liquidity. Therefore, an evaluation of

    management's ability and commitment to managing debt leverage in line with a rating is an important consideration.

    Companies' financial accounting strategies and track records are critical to understanding the intent and risk appetite

    and profile of management, and can be a material negative rating factor in instances where over-aggressiveness and

    imprudence are evident. Understanding management's strategy for raising its share price, including its financial

    performance objectives, e.g., return on equity, can provide invaluable insights toward its financial and business risk

    appetite.

    3. Cash flow adequacy

    Cash-flow analysis is the single most critical element of all credit rating decisions. Although there usually is a strong

    relationship between cash flow and profitability, many transactions and accounting entries affect one and not the

    other. Analysis of cash-flow patterns can reveal a level of debt-servicing capability that is either stronger or weaker

    than might be apparent from earnings.

    Cash flow ratios. Ratios show the relationship of cash flow to debt and debt service, and also to the company's other

    financing needs. Because there are calls on cash other than repaying debt, it is important to know the extent to which

    those requirements will allow cash to be used for debt service or, alternatively, lead to greater need for borrowing:

    Funds from operations/total debt (adjusted for off-balance-sheet liabilities);

    Debt/EBITDA;

    EBITDA/interest;

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 12

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • Free operating cash flow + interest/interest;

    Free operating cash flow + interest/interest + annual principal repayment obligation (debt-service coverage);

    Total debt/discretionary cash flow (debt payback period);

    Funds from operations/capital spending requirements; and

    Capital expenditures/capital maintenance.

    Careful assessment of free cash flow and debt service burden is particularly important for speculative-grade

    acquisitions, because of the near-term vulnerabilities arising from either aggressive leverage and/or weaker

    competitive positions. The results of these ratio calculations should not be viewed exclusively on a standalone basis.

    For example, retailers with mature portfolios, with static or falling profit margins, may generate what appear to be

    healthy levels of net cash because of the lack of growth opportunities that might otherwise require cash to be utilized

    in working capital or fixed asset investment. However, the sustainability of such cash flow generation capacity may be

    suspect if profit margins are eroding, or are likely to decline over the short or medium term. Conversely, companies

    operating in growth markets may generate weak cash flow because of the need to fund growing working and fixed

    capital needs, yet be underpinned by improving profit margins and healthy business risk dynamics.

    4. Capital structure/asset protection

    The following are useful indicators of leverage:

    Total debt + present value of operating leases/EBITDAR;

    Total debt/total debt + equity;

    Total debt + off-balance-sheet liabilities/total debt + off-balance-sheet liabilities + equity; and

    Total debt/total debt + market value of equity.

    A company's assets and related cash flow mix are a critical determinant of the appropriate leverage for a given rating

    level. Assets and brands producing greater cash flow with clear marketability justify a higher level of debt than assets

    with weaker cash generation and market value characteristics.

    5. Liquidity/short-term factors

    The analysis of liquidity and short-term factors are a critical component of all corporate credit analyses. We try to

    determine the likelihood that a company might run out of cash and be unable to service its debt. We focus on

    assessing a company's ability to meet its financial obligations on an ongoing basis, given the challenges the company

    faces in its industry, its competitive position, its earnings and cash flow-generating ability, and its debt-service

    requirements. Gradual erosion in a company's fundamentals can ultimately lead to liquidity problems. Yet, even a

    company with a solid business position and moderate debt use can, when faced with sudden adversity, experience an

    actual or potential liquidity crisis, or an inability to access public debt markets. In considering liquidity, the analytical

    context is focused on the downside: the concern is whether the company can meet its obligations on a rainy day,

    rather than just under the expected circumstances. Speculative-grade issuers are more susceptible to liquidity crises,

    therefore necessitating even tighter scrutiny regarding upcoming interest and principal payments, financial covenants,

    and availability on revolving credit facilities. In analyzing liquidity, we review cash and components, debt maturities,

    internal and external sources of liquidity, and management strategy for ensuring adequate liquidity.

    The starting point of any liquidity analysis is looking at how much cash is on the balance sheet relative to the

    company's needs. This includes cash in the bank, cash equivalents, and short- and long-term marketable securities. It is

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 13

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • also important to identify the company's maturity schedule for debt and other long-term obligations. Near-term

    maturities include commercial paper; sinking fund payments and final maturity payments of long-term debt;

    borrowings under bank credit facilities with approaching expiration dates; and mandatory redemptions of preferred

    stock. Other significant financial obligations may also need to be considered--for example, lease obligations,

    contingent obligations such as letters of credit, required pension fund contributions, postretirement employment

    payments, and tax payments. Even when analyzing highly creditworthy companies, it is necessary to be aware of the

    overall maturity structure and potential for refinancing risk.

    External sources of funding. In terms of the need for external financing, some retail subsectors are more working

    capital intensive than others. Inventory is the major consideration in a retailer's working capital cycle and short term

    financing needs. For example, department stores, general merchandisers, and consumer electronics are very

    working-capital-intensive, with the most important seasonal peak representing the inventory buildup for the year-end

    holiday season in many countries. Because most operators have sold their proprietary credit card operations in recent

    years, accounts receivable financing no longer represents an important call on funds as it had for many years. In

    cyclical downturns, reduced financing requirements for working capital and capital expenditures temper deterioration

    of debt leverage and cash flow protection measures.

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 14

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    ARCHIVE | Criteria | Corporates | Industrials: Key Credit Factors: Business And Financial Risks In The RetailIndustry

  • S&P may receive compensation for its ratings and certain analyses, normally from issuers or underwriters of securities or from obligors. S&P

    reserves the right to disseminate its opinions and analyses. S&P's public ratings and analyses are made available on its Web sites,

    www.standardandpoors.com (free of charge), and www.ratingsdirect.com and www.globalcreditportal.com (subscription) and www.spcapitaliq.com

    (subscription) and may be distributed through other means, including via S&P publications and third-party redistributors. Additional information

    about our ratings fees is available at www.standardandpoors.com/usratingsfees.

    S&P keeps certain activities of its business units separate from each other in order to preserve the independence and objectivity of their respective

    activities. As a result, certain business units of S&P may have information that is not available to other S&P business units. S&P has established

    policies and procedures to maintain the confidentiality of certain nonpublic information received in connection with each analytical process.

    To the extent that regulatory authorities allow a rating agency to acknowledge in one jurisdiction a rating issued in another jurisdiction for certain

    regulatory purposes, S&P reserves the right to assign, withdraw, or suspend such acknowledgement at any time and in its sole discretion. S&P

    Parties disclaim any duty whatsoever arising out of the assignment, withdrawal, or suspension of an acknowledgment as well as any liability for any

    damage alleged to have been suffered on account thereof.

    Credit-related and other analyses, including ratings, and statements in the Content are statements of opinion as of the date they are expressed and

    not statements of fact. S&P's opinions, analyses, and rating acknowledgment decisions (described below) are not recommendations to purchase,

    hold, or sell any securities or to make any investment decisions, and do not address the suitability of any security. S&P assumes no obligation to

    update the Content following publication in any form or format. The Content should not be relied on and is not a substitute for the skill, judgment

    and experience of the user, its management, employees, advisors and/or clients when making investment and other business decisions. S&P does

    not act as a fiduciary or an investment advisor except where registered as such. While S&P has obtained information from sources it believes to be

    reliable, S&P does not perform an audit and undertakes no duty of due diligence or independent verification of any information it receives.

    No content (including ratings, credit-related analyses and data, valuations, model, software or other application or output therefrom) or any part

    thereof (Content) may be modified, reverse engineered, reproduced or distributed in any form by any means, or stored in a database or retrieval

    system, without the prior written permission of Standard & Poor's Financial Services LLC or its affiliates (collectively, S&P). The Content shall not be

    used for any unlawful or unauthorized purposes. S&P and any third-party providers, as well as their directors, officers, shareholders, employees or

    agents (collectively S&P Parties) do not guarantee the accuracy, completeness, timeliness or availability of the Content. S&P Parties are not

    responsible for any errors or omissions (negligent or otherwise), regardless of the cause, for the results obtained from the use of the Content, or for

    the security or maintenance of any data input by the user. The Content is provided on an "as is" basis. S&P PARTIES DISCLAIM ANY AND ALL

    EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, ANY WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR

    A PARTICULAR PURPOSE OR USE, FREEDOM FROM BUGS, SOFTWARE ERRORS OR DEFECTS, THAT THE CONTENT'S FUNCTIONING

    WILL BE UNINTERRUPTED, OR THAT THE CONTENT WILL OPERATE WITH ANY SOFTWARE OR HARDWARE CONFIGURATION. In no

    event shall S&P Parties be liable to any party for any direct, indirect, incidental, exemplary, compensatory, punitive, special or consequential

    damages, costs, expenses, legal fees, or losses (including, without limitation, lost income or lost profits and opportunity costs or losses caused by

    negligence) in connection with any use of the Content even if advised of the possibility of such damages.

    Copyright 2015 Standard & Poor's Financial Services LLC, a part of McGraw Hill Financial. All rights reserved.

    WWW.STANDARDANDPOORS.COM/RATINGSDIRECT SEPTEMBER 18, 2008 15

    THIS WAS PREPARED EXCLUSIVELY FOR USER BARBORA MATOUSKOVA.

    NOT FOR REDISTRIBUTION UNLESS OTHERWISE PERMITTED.1386220 | 301983604

    Research:Relationship Between Business And Financial RisksPart 1--Business Risk Analysis1. Country risk and macroeconomic factors (economic, political, and social environments) 2. Industry business and credit risk characteristics Industry subsectorsIndustry strengths:Industry challenges/risks:

    Keys To Competitive Success3. Company competitive position4. Profitability

    Part 2--Financial Risk Analysis1. Accounting characteristics2. Financial governance/policies and risk tolerance3. Cash flow adequacy4. Capital structure/asset protection5. Liquidity/short-term factors