Jus Post Bellum - ELAC - Two Emerging... · III T • M • C • ASSER PRESS Carsten Stahn / Jann...

I

Jus Post Bellum

Towards a Law of TransitionFrom Conflict to Peace

III

T M C ASSER PRESS

Carsten Stahn / Jann K. Kleffner

Editors

Jus Post BellumTowards a Law of Transition

From Conflict to Peace

IV

Published by t.m.c.Asser pressP.O. Box 16163, 2500 BD The Hague, The Netherlands

t.m.c.Asser press English language books are distributed exclusively by:

Cambridge University Press, The Edinburgh Building, Shaftesbury Road,Cambridge CB2 2RU, UK,

orfor customers in the USA, Canada and Mexico:

Cambridge University Press, 100 Brook Hill Drive, West Nyack, NY 10994-2133, USA

ISBN 978-90-6704-272-7

All rights reserved. 2008, t.m.c.Asser press, The Hague, The Netherlands and the Authors

No part of the material protected by this copyright notice may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by anymeans, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage and

retrieval system, without written permission from the copyright owner.

PRINTED IN THE NETHERLANDS

V

FOREWORD

!"#$## !

$#%$" &'$$%"##""($# !) *#%$$$##$#

!

#$"# #"#####(#$##

!"# ##

##""## & # $$ %$ +'$$%# "#$"$ ,$$)#$" -$#$%"$" !

#$$ & # $ $" . '""(

!

$$$)/+"001%," 2 # &/3# 4"#/ 5 2 # & / # 4" #5 !,$$#/-6"#+5##

! $ $ $$#$#$$""$

VI

7#

'$## # $$ ! $$#$ !"'"##)"%

7$"$ !$",$"$""##$ !.$$###$$"#,)

6#$$ *"$.##$## &""$$ &$

#

$%"'$

foreword

Prof. Andr NollkaemperUniversity of Amsterdam

Prof. Nico SchrijverUniversity of Leiden

VII

SUMMARY OF CONTENTS

+"7# 58Nollkaemper7# -Schrijver 9

!# &:

/# :9

&(+ 6

Part IFoundations of a Jus Post Bellum

2$(;

VIII

2$1(+&/C$(;

summary of contents

IX

TABLE OF CONTENTS

+"7# 58Nollkaemper7# -Schrijver 9

3"# 9&&

/# :9

&(+ 6

Part IFoundations of a Jus Post Bellum

2$(; #

X table of contents

A 7$"$" A0A @ B AA A 7 AA 2$ AA ; A 37$#+7%?;2

7 A !#)# A !$# A 22 A> ?E A> ; @ G 1 2

2$@(! !# >D

XItable of contents

#=$" >> &$ >> @ C#)$ 0 @ 2$ 0 @ 2"$ 0 @ @ ;#) 0 !3$5 0@ !#$ 0@ + 0@ *"" 0@ / 0 3$#$$ 0 ! 01 @

XII table of contents

2$D(!;#(5;-7#A 9""

$"# > "$$ >> @ 4-"$ 0@ !;#$2#;(#

$/3$2#-F4-3# 0A 2

XIIItable of contents

2$(

XIV table of contents

XV

LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS

!"

# #$

%

& &'()&

*' & &

)& & &

) ))+) )))%,,-. )%

& &/ /

+01 +%01

2,3405 2$2) 2

XVI

(

!

, 6 6 &$+#

+ +' + 1 1' $'" &+ &%+.-,, !

$

,-,

7+' 7+

0',, 0'

14 114 14

0&' 0&'02' 0!"0 0

' '"') '

)' ''04 40'' '

$ $%%

, +' $+ "

list of abbreviations

XVII

%'+8'1 +812 !2

& &&0 &%$0

40 4040) 40)40!)7' 40)%'40+ 40+3540+# 40%+402 402$40+ 4035.35+402' 402$'401 401 "

4017 401740'+' 40+40''1 401

40& 40&4& 4&

*& *9

// //

# #$

%

:;* :

1from here to there... and the law in the middle

!"#" "$%!&"'() ** "+,-!$+

./0"

!!!!+!&

1

!234

Carsten Stahn & Jann K. Kleffner (eds.), Jus Post Bellum 2008, T.M.C.ASSER PRESS, The Hague, The Netherlands and the Authors

* !!"#####!$%&'#(&

2 introduction

!

5

*"#55##$+'55'!6!#'*

*

7!! !!

6$+'52$+'8##'3$+

23"! ! # !9! 5

!

&

)%#*!+&!&!,,--.#,-/+,-0


6'

5 : : 0; 0"050;

230

6*

#'?&

@9

4'!?&*'(4'+*

;

4 introduction

'B;9 *

;

* '4

/

6##

#'C,6

; /9";45'D

*#@23

#' E'F !

;/9;#'A&5

"

,'


9

@'4

6###

6 introduction

7reconsidering the jus ad bellum / jus in bello distinction

8 chapter 1


Introduction

!


!"#

$%&''()&

10 chapter 1

! "#

" !#$

$$ %

!

% !&

' !#

$!!

&!(

)*+*+#,- . ./$

$

&

& !

.%

*+ , -./01102333(2%422 5 !" #$ %

6.-78

%&&9(&' 75657:#78 (

& ' $:10233)(2'42&


$$

0(

11

1. Evolution of the Jus Ad Bellum/Jus In Bello Distinction

2 3

& 4, ("&(

$(

51

66

.&&

".

& %.# .#7.

.#&,(,.

%.)-& 8# 1)#

&

;"

12 chapter 1

9.#& :.# .#

'(!

.#

!

0(

$

;,

. .- %.-#

0

)3

#.:$:6:.6645:#:#''*%' ::0!"#%&)%(#5.#45:F1=.7:=7B#7=7 (7!.!

-./0E.%&&%(%)@> 861$& ' 6:5%&'2(23,

$:6:%'&1;B'223 $:6:"$1%'22%4222 =$G::=693HF$::%H$.#

6I # (*")!$ 56456!"#2332(29%


&

9%,&

)

!

6<

.&)

# %

*

!

"-

%

%6="""3>"#-.>#)# > . >&)# >#

0$$"! F%&&3(,' E*568#165# (''

($ *10.

:56233)(22? 5 %?' ;D2# C:% ,(H5:

7:I$67. (&!$ 5656!"#%&&%(,3,

14 chapter 1

5)?@8# .""!)#>#

/ )ABC

*+#

>

)# ""

+ $+!

.$#

!

."..3"!;

;

.-

9)% = .6 .


(A

>

3"

) #(7&.93

6D

*

%

095: 9$&1

$,$ !

.

9#&&.,

1 6=EF 3 & &6F, )/A#

0 &

8E:#! 61.=--66 ((!$=$E0; 5656!"#2332(,,%

16 chapter 1

(- #

,-

./!

0

(

.6F4>

-

+

!

%%6F&)

#

>36G

H

)

-# .

)#-(

)#

)# .

#3"$*% '''57:5#D:#.-56%@9?9

D#310,%2FD:#.-66:#7:: -./0$*%&'2(,',

82% !"#%&'&(%@& 7B:+41

:69@"# %&@%(@,2 0%99%


)#

6E

>4& $%I! 11I

::6::6.::J

18 chapter 1

!

- A

6GKK.19, %$ (

&

3/L'&)#

75:4

:46.7:7:H$6=067=77B# (' '*#

-./0E.%&&3(


,( *+$

0

20 chapter 1

( &!

$ 0

*

!

.

%

;

;

%-HIA5

+

45!

35%-). % -

M# %-

$ & !#)#

5 A

A

;7+#6:


9/

4545

4 5

45!

'

&

A.7#I#%%,I

A.7#I

23), "# "#6

)!

. , I(HA",A.7$

I I'

+*

23),!

L)#'

%';,-

. A.7# 2

E:7;7:$H4067:4:*#;8:

22 chapter 1

( 2 &$,&

('7

($! 78 +

)

.

/ )

9!

.7&

)

#;&;

$$


!!

&5#&)#9%;&;- $ $

&

1 !&*+*+

9

! 70: $)#.:)%

! A,

669'%@@ =:0"*'"5 1780

%&)3( 7**.081F%: !"#2333(>=7B+-5:#*+7:P!

24 chapter 1

5 )# .

5

;$4-;


!

!

:

-!

%

&

"&%

H -

%&.&

26 chapter 1

!'()5; # "&'&4$

+ 2) 0

&!

.-

%.

0&

!

0

* !

.$


(

. 1

(

)#-

' ; ; -M%,&

$

7)+7!

-,&$./)#)*

+$# 7 .%-A.7#I $&

5 I

$

( ;3

28 chapter 1

6..B"6$

(#$#3"2


7)" ;1F7:%)" 2332(9,4@)F@2)?

# %

)*

3. Conclusion: Towards A Jus Post Bellum?

- . ;;& # $((

&2

#

7&(

##2# %##&)#

.%-#

L#.#$0# %*+ %-

30 chapter 1

$::545

:F##. 66 :.. 4.#55:6I

$:6:%'&1;B'223

0& #(

)#%#

#%;#;

.

'(!

0(

'

#%#;;

31jus post bellum: a just war theory perspective

!

"

!#

$!$

Introduction

! " #

! $

!

!%"

!

$

&!

# " " ! "


!"#!$%#&$

'()*+),- .)/*00*$&!!",)%)*102 10)3"

32 chapter 2

!!%'

!('! ! " " %) !' * +*

) !", -+.!!

)"

)!!

, '! /$'!

"'"/(

)!

"

!

, -!

#

'"0

&

1 !

!

!" &" !

450 .)/**$&36"789 .)/*8:; $&33"785


! '

1. Explaining the Historical Rejection

1

!

$!"')

! '/

2 %!

#! !'

!

!' %!

*

!

!"

3*! 4

" . ".$0

5677

1 !#

8

'

#%! "!

!(

!%

!9

* !'!)")!

!)!!")#'

:

"'

=5 $&>?"#G$#3H7BI$ =(%1J.)/*=(1$&&$"6$#%6$3

-$$&%$3

34 chapter 2

1

"

$/, "/*

'

)'%9)

'! /* 9!%' #%'"

#!: ":

:

:

'

"

)!!! ! ' ! # ! /(

0

!

* "

))!" !)!)

! "!

*!

!" !"566;& $0$

' "

!,%!#

)

!

" "

) !

"!

2. Kants Contribution

% ""' -3 " %"5?;>

-$>!%6>


.'!6" 02 &!'( 5

"$#%>& 9)$$80. $&"$3&%$!$

6?>%?&" 02C9@4'@* $&&&"66%6#6

36 chapter 2


(

!' "4%

0!

"-

,0 #B ! !!

! "

& !! 1

! ! '

'

1"!

@' '"(.! 566="6C( "! '

")" "* %9) !! ! !

"

@ "9'" (

!

$ "! "

! '

4. Suggested Principles of a Jus Post Bellum in General

9# /$ !!

,,,0101 ,:(86"7,0(*2 .)/*=(1$&&>"

:

-$&/, .)/*($&"72$&>%$$

38 chapter 2

/$

&

" 9' " (%! "

"

!!

"

"8 4

B'

!"

!"*

)


!'

" ! 0 1!# !

:

!

0!"

:

!!

!9 "

& )" )!& #::!/9!

!# ! ! !

!

# !"'9" '+0

!! "D !!

)

!

"9! ""

!

!

" '

!*

$$%%( !"!* "

:

*!! -'E$+!!0FG!!! **

*!1"

2$66%?702* $&""3 10)"

-$$&%$? =L-$+$$

40 chapter 2

!

! !" !

!&

"

9 $0!

@$ D1

' !

"D1 $0!"!!!

D1!

%

!"

"!

"

"

$'D1%9=;;A"

!'' "

!!

!!''

$ ) "

!)/

! !"

! #

>5

!

" !" ! E 0"4

>=

!!!"' '"!!%

- $ $&%$? 36%3>7,- C@) (( $&"66

0)!4 .)/*(;?"7:1 5

1:11?"74="&" .)/*,0*J88;=?"


>A

H!! +!

" % !

""

>>

$!! "

"!

!$!/$

/ &!))@

8

1! ! "

&

8'9

'! !

!

>C

&!!!"*"

!! ! ! !'

>I

90!"

!2$0

!! ' 9!"' !

"%!

9

!

-$$$>

42 chapter 2

*!"!!* )!

!)!* )!) &

!

)")

. ' #

!'

'

*'

!' ! 9

) )"!

1" )

""

5. Suggested Principles for Forcible Post-War Regime Changein Particular

C5

" )!

)"*! 9

# / * '!# :

!

:

0 !1

!"

!

!,9'

'(1+)1+(L(()[email protected] " &+! 4(8)$&>"$?!%$3?

2$%?7==)-%: $&"


! " "!

": ": : : ! !

! '

: 9 9:

"!

%) ) "

""

:! ""

!9.

" "-56>C"56CC

! % 5;"

('

&"

2$$3%$&4! 5/$&, 6 . ,=:16"45/$ ,=:1?"

9 80. '&$ $&&$"$!

44 chapter 2

"


C=

$' ))'#

/&" #

'! D1 %9 !*!"-!

.!

+

!! ( ) "' ) !'' !"!

!" !!0)! !.*%9 '

' " D1!>;;;;; %9J@ !1)

) !"!0 "!

. " #

'"

! !

"! "' "! $ !D8"'!(

!"

!"! !=;5;;;

!0"" % ! * %9 ) ) ! ! #!@ !!1 )

)

F(2$$3%$& =((1#

$"?%?$7: %A"" )#!+$3$&&>

46 chapter 2

!'" "!

B 9" : " !

! !" !!"

!+"'

"3

K'! '!

1 "

9- '%

"!

** !#"!9 :

% ) !")

'! " D'

!

"!* %9(%9 !

0! " )


%

. )!4

@

-$ )9 " !!!

' ! : !"

!'%9=;;A

"

E ' !!!

!

& 56A;0!! "

!

2 %* !.3

%%$.!

%

!"

!

!

'

()*+)* *.$0'"

%

! !' "9 3")&( )0 !

-!!!! '

2I$#7AK2$$>$%>374'4

A1 "6 1=

48 chapter 2

'@ ' !: ' ! ' !!!:! '

!%!* %9'

!!"9!! 2" !( 8

+@

#

:

" @ "

"

%

,9' 2 )9" '

'

!2 "!

@

!*!"

!

" !:" !

0!

"$

D1."-$8!! #"! & "

" )

)!'

' '=;

#D11E:&1%:80-:%:8C)"!!' !1!:! @!)!' /@

("!

! $

0

7. Conclusion

, "'

@

)! )1 !

%! !"! #-+ "!%!

*%"" !'!"% !

""

53war termination and liability of soldiers for crimes of aggression

!

1. The Need for a Theory of Just War Termination

!" !# !#!$%! $


!

"#$$%&%'()*+,-.##$$/&00.1/'/2#

54 chapter 3

&%'(

")*+,

-)'*()

$

. "

).'('('('(

)"!)%"/ $ & / "0%%)

34, ,!!,'

5678

.9":44#$$$&202%#


) -$))'(

$&0/ )) )

1 %2)34442546744)544746

$&)544

202%#

56 chapter 3

8443944& 544 ,-)3444%844

$%'(%$%)%)

2. The Scope of Bellum Terminatio Law

))

).)-

$$ $ % %-$ )

&%1 %+%$


: :$)

0:,-2&

2%;

58 chapter 3

: )% %%

)"0 %$

&%$%$'( $ >!

$,-$?%$

0 )0 2 2,-


$),-2@2)"%%%

) " )

"!$$#!=%)

$%"!"!"!"!0

!

0%"&A

60 chapter 3

)-%%$

/ & !B 2%

$%:=/""))

"$).)


D)B2, -

$" /$$-)B= %

$%$;D) )22 )/)/?% ;D%),-=%)B2#&BC2*

)))

?0 ?*;?0 A!

?!-+B4

62 chapter 3

)%$

3. Post Bellum Justice: The Liability of Soldiers for Ad BellumCrimes

)D 2=""))1??$,-//

',-(2-',-($$,-+/7449)

&$.%)?)%

; " " ,? *7 + 3C,, D?!- ?D5&$'+(,!&


93

2 )/

$$*$%.'* ( &)$ $

&.2 )

3, !!8!E"

5859C@23",0,!, 0, ,! !"00,! !,0!'"!E!" !!8D, !0,E4;!"&

?+#,#$$#&33 5)6C, *76-%!$&$F.

(

-.!..4"2=12&00@2'%20 2=%2&)6C, *6;,-!-(!$&$F.(

-.!..4"2=12&00%#'(20 2=@(&

!"!" >!0' E?$22/+

66!

,66@00%=.'(..00(21'(##

64 chapter 3

2

$


%A%/%)%#'(/% / :/%$%

'% % (

2 %"/%?)%%$

&

30!,?+#,#$$#&002%@'2(.!,,060*6C!G3?0 65-%2==1&002(2'21=

5602%002(2'21=02(1 3!!!0 00

,E"!0, !'!"!!000,, ,!!E"5*"!E7-2@#$$(&00#2.'#./

66 chapter 3

:@ &)+

)%A%%);=/,+%-

99

0 $) %),% %-'DF 'D3((

& ! ) ,-'%-($ . )$.'

F, &$+"/

0%'1C!+A"&2, !, !2==2#H##H#@78!"40782@0.=

5?984$+$4"2=(/&02$$


(&'(

$ % % % $'(

9G

$$%) %2:

"/-"/';D4*0'67-..#$$/&00./'%@/@

!!!>"0

+7;

5782@2% +?"' , !6D2===&00=1'==

68 chapter 3

4. Two Forms of Asymmetry

$) )$ $

"#

$$$/'( / ' (")%

$":7

),-),-%


)$& ' ) ( 0

"!)0'% ) ( $2

5. A Contractarian Argument

)) %%

"$

70 chapter 3

%" /;&%%,B;"-

" $ " ) %$)%:) ""!

*? "!$

0 ?"-!, "00,,!!E5+?"2=(22===&

? *, ?7-2 2=(#&002/@'2%@

;,0>"!0 0003'?"00,E , !, "000003,0000, "0!D"000" 3 ,0

"""! !, 000


$ $

>!$)'( 846'()846+846$

#$ )74H2&$"% $$'()

;> 00+7;,'", )D),/

3A"9":42=%/40@%@&FF, &$+"/

!A"2=#/0.2.&& 0,":$+#,, !, !2=11&02%1

;,,0,0!, ;,0E"!!",, E";,' ,0,4

" ,,0" ,""",0,"4!, !" 0, ,, ,!", E""0 ,000!!!"*

72 chapter 3

"$&%

2'('(F$%.

:))'%($%

2 $ % %

"!)A$ >

D%D

;,4 E-",,,E 3 ,0 !0!!

,!'07, !,E! ,!,

C30 34,! , !' 0 0,0,,,, ,!


=

"?!" !B &%) %

&:%/;&:) 2

.//F'()

"!) &

3,0"

,"0, >!,! E

"" E5" >"",'0! 00 0 ,"

!!

0,,0 0,"0"0; !,0000

0!!

A,'A !! 0 ,," !5A,'A*A

74 chapter 3

+

66,40566@00%=.'(..0($#

+$':9($) $

"%

>$ )> $ $ $?:

-$


;3E,!!5?,5C@2&&!!!,,4 ,

$%"%)% - ,-

-&";- $ 2%?-*' (

0:)1)%)&/

$ ) 0) %

76 chapter 3

77conflict termination and peace-making in the law of nations

Introduction

!

"

#$%&

&'& "

()

*

1. The Old Jus Post Bellum The Medieval Jus Victoriae

+#,*#-

.&/-

.


78 chapter 4

-

.

%#

01$%#%#

/

$%& &+,#*# 2 #3&+,0'-.*

$

* 4&

5$%##*6##

*'#4'-.7#

! "# !#$%! !! &'%()! &'%(!!! !!!&*#"#+,-%. . /001&!!21#34


#&

&8 9*#

%: ;"!

8,+##,%#-./# :2+*

,

*$%*

-.

*+, *

80 chapter 4

'4#%''

& * #& 3*

1-.

&/2

% *

#-.'

#/=%##&-.>/-.%

*% - #

*=!!!.> !6?@)%


.*&

&

&

4# & & =: *:=+,+,&

+, 18 ?;! +@A ', # B,/

+

##,

2. The Decline of the Jus Victoriae

!-#.

1 ? !>'-.&

;9!!/84#/88'?;*>A%

82 chapter 4

*'3

-/:CD ? E

/ !

8

+,'18

8,+,

C-8,.+,+**

,%2C' 98+@A'#,'

&

'FF'/'#'+,+

',

* +,

;B#!6797:79/4% /81,70*=

!!!!# )!

7/*7:392/% /:8

54!910 !913 6#6B ( - %6-

7:1/&!917 !!913#91:


-+,.&

"

:

-.$ *

'-.0

DC,'$ !G!-:=.

>C !"!->. :,'*%H !? F,'>I0 !";

+,#,

>#>0% 82>0 ")G482

-/: .

*82+,& *

*#*82&0

% "

**

+=#,;!#?/*742470/% /8,1'!#,70@ 748474:% 700,9

*#*)70+74:7729% 739,7'.#6! )7:,!7481747% /7,/

5C.8&'709%7802&

84 chapter 4

!?!


.:,:, -

+,.:

&'+

%

%:

#, :

%

%-#.

:'*-.K%

-

.

3. After the Great War

C44#2 H60 D606 -

.&&

-

./00'$#*HD6

H0 D60*$*% - .H0+@A,

+H,&'*6'%#-% - .0.

H0% "

,/97 ,/9/

86 chapter 4

2H%&&+,+,=% - .

/

C

4*% " "( /0 ")G-.4> !?" !!G0/* H%*% " ")G0' "("0

% "+',H%%0 1 #% "8

"E9#% " 6H-/

>4

.

D60'H0% - .0/2C0*+,-%E".%0,#

'D6*% "H0'0 # % G D6:%+#,&&+,

B#.*!. /0%


HD6 2 HF "E(%CC=HC*C5$FF0CDC2+,>>-J

/. "(! $H%

%

5D6C5& & D605

88 chapter 4

3&&D6C0

* ";9C2C0+C2', "9?0+#$1 , +@A@A , "" C0J

-0

* 2J.

D6:%K "?"1 # >:%+@A>,

4. General Considerations and a Look Towards the Future

144 #&

$

'

'

-.3

.77479


*

**

%80 H

'

'&'

3/#*

0-C5.

/

7

'

/'-.

7%

K&

+,-.

# *+,

5./9+78387711. 997,19

90 chapter 4

-3B/

$*&"),*&)!)2"!"-&K8I0"/(2.3441-B'%&)"-&'&-0/&2,*$8300"(.00I--/:/J3.

2,**7,%& ,) ,%,-,*-))","!"5$%%52"'%&$!,"* -.60 )0+83EL)EL)

%&.00J--3.I3B.C!- ('/00

@EL)%&.00B--3:434B$#0 ))836@ 23($!+,*.00B

101mapping the discipline(s)

$+

' "' 1 #"' @'&&''

1'&

)/G )

' '&

%" " &>

"

)/G) +

%%

'

$*&D */-+..=.,)).00I

$*?"*,!""'2)4GBF/ 260 )/ '3=3(.+- 2!!N!N:JN!JN%I).3+-.00J-30C2;/

102 chapter 5

&

'' &

)/G/ +

$'&"

''&'"B

"'&'&&

" 9' %'+,11

1#

@'"'1&

%

)/GG ;#

3''

+"*"",L) ,& ,,),),,-)

$,--,,&%&,?*,%2,!,*!,* ,,,),,7)%&,$&!$2,-),?*,%2,!,*!,*6 .-.0:

'-*"'T*


& '&

+#

5 #'

2. The Scholarship Agenda

%&% &

/)

'&$95 &&!

/)) *

>

/))) 7

""# 5#

',*"& 2'E 8I*(

104 chapter 5

&1

C ! "'&

% "

" 1"'#

"

"

'&"

$'

&

!#

!))%&)K.000+"&-*",",L)*6$'"..:-/

$$)5&-),-,&./ $$$,"3 "8K"8#!,-3,

%" &,%,*&N*"&,)%

6 ,,""),7%$2'@@6+30 % !"*!"*%& .00.--3:J343

5%"-,-,&", ,**"$E&/./--.0J.I1

' %, %E()&0 2./"-8


/))/ 3

''

1 ' ! + # & > !

%'1

'

'

1&'

/)/ +

11'

%'%&

'

"%

$=..-.1B$!,..-B/3

106 chapter 5

1'&2++,11+'

1

1 # % !&'&'

% '"%& !''"$+;

2"'" ,

1$%$7$7&

&'@,'"1

$..4-I34


&'H1#

%&

1

//

'+#7

@ # #'7>

05' 7 "!

$E0 &/./--310313 $E("./--./..//0 &/

./--310313

108 chapter 5

-J03 $K7..1 !'


$,"%,-),$&(,"-"),-),--).0E.000+NBBNB0.-/3NN @*NN.JJ/I.33IJ30:.:J:.BN/31./:033IJ330:3:JJ:NK/:-)G"SK/:-)O

2,-&"**6)",-)% ),*,)*%"-*"&,,"@6-"G!"-%&G,-,,&*"%--&7"&G'&=#&

" 1''B?'N5:> 47& "&$ " '&B?@1:!>; !' @

'

"' @''

110 chapter 5

$#,&+>0 >!!

$''/*

1 %

512+5

,1%+5 '! 1


$T*.J1-3./ +*&-@-&%

112 chapter 5

3. Conclusion

'7' '%

&

#"/*""+&

"#

$& @

@ # ##1'"

1

?'$

&$'#

#+#'

113challenges of post-conflict intercession

114 chapter 6


!

"#

Introduction

!"!# $"

!

!% "


116 chapter 6

&'$

())(*

+,--./

0

% "12.334.3356

!

! ! 7 6!&'*8* 7

! 9" : %;

1. The Challenge of Sovereignty

$ ! ) 6

"!%)""

99

!"#$#%&'()*+,

-./#$00.0.%&&(


+!/&'0&'+,-4308?@

*!

1"

9

1:&':6;,-45$(A1"B:

$ !,--3 +!" ! / ;

" 9

12,0.,,!,0,3,404,5,4.%&6(7589%'%9:

%) 5;:%)6( 51/,.,43)*

%&&&()944.%&&:(=41#.

118 chapter 6

:!="

#89*

+/6 ! C9" &' $

C8*+#)*2%/"#

""

"

9;"A

8*"

0#!"

#+/

$+8*/9""

8#/!0-$0.

0.%&&:(

$,..E 4 4 ?B?B9:::(

8#,1B2.,A+,+,39:%((/%&&&(9*

>+,+(D#9::%(1 225/F8FFE-)09::6(

4 , 2B 2E5 7 G,.;?,##BH#I,J4I%::''69K


D$E*D8* 620

"8; % *

9* 8* $

"

""%F# ) ="*# +E/

$" " "

C!

"

A0DD8*

;"0 $$ +.33,/!*8*

F1/,,.3%%(2.'9::6(& 10.3.-07/D+4

45+>+.5%)L%609::B7?8,(,-,.(

D !',?B

Jus Post Bellum - ELAC - Two Emerging... · III T • M • C • ASSER PRESS Carsten Stahn / Jann...

Documents

Transcript of Jus Post Bellum - ELAC - Two Emerging... · III T • M • C • ASSER PRESS Carsten Stahn / Jann...