July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission...

34
College of Communication Arts & Sciences Department of Telecommunication, Information Studies, & Media 404 Wilson Road Room 409 East Lansing, MI 48824 517-355-8372 Fax: 517-355-1292 [email protected] http://tism.msu.edu July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street SW, Washington, DC 20554 RE: Study Submitted To: “Protecting the Privacy of Customers of Broadband and Other Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern: Enclosed please find a copy of a new study I recently co-authored with Dr. Anne Oeldorf-Hirsch entitled “The biggest lie on the internet: Ignoring the privacy policies and terms of service policies of social networking services.” The study, currently under peer review, demonstrates the extent to which individuals ignore privacy policies and terms of service policies when engaging with social networking services. While numerous studies have previously addressed the extent to which users understand policies and how long it might take to read policies, little evidence previously existed demonstrating empirically that users often ignore these policies. The results suggest that the !notice and choice" privacy model does not adequately provide the necessary deliverables to ensure protections. Transparency and access are terrific places to start, but terrible places to finish. More needs to be done to ensure that users are aware of what they are agreeing to, and protected from threats associated with data sharing and data use, especially when it comes to eligibility decision-making. Here is a copy of the study abstract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lease feel free to contact me, should you require any further information. Sincerely, Jonathan A. Obar, PhD Research Associate, Quello Center for Telecommunication Management and Law Michigan State University [email protected]

Transcript of July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission...

Page 1: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

!

!

College of Communication Arts & Sciences

Department of

Telecommunication, Information Studies,

& Media

404 Wilson Road Room 409

East Lansing, MI 48824

517-355-8372

Fax: 517-355-1292 [email protected]

http://tism.msu.edu

!

July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission 445 12th Street SW, Washington, DC 20554 RE: Study Submitted To: “Protecting the Privacy of Customers of Broadband and Other Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern: Enclosed please find a copy of a new study I recently co-authored with Dr. Anne Oeldorf-Hirsch entitled “The biggest lie on the internet: Ignoring the privacy policies and terms of service policies of social networking services.” The study, currently under peer review, demonstrates the extent to which individuals ignore privacy policies and terms of service policies when engaging with social networking services. While numerous studies have previously addressed the extent to which users understand policies and how long it might take to read policies, little evidence previously existed demonstrating empirically that users often ignore these policies. The results suggest that the !notice and choice" privacy model does not adequately provide the necessary deliverables to ensure protections. Transparency and access are terrific places to start, but terrible places to finish. More needs to be done to ensure that users are aware of what they are agreeing to, and protected from threats associated with data sharing and data use, especially when it comes to eligibility decision-making. Here is a copy of the study abstract: !"#$%&'&()%'**)($$($%+,"(%-#..($,%/#(%01%,"(%#1,()1(,2%3#,"%'1%(4&#)#5'/%#16($,#.',#01%07%&)#6'58%&0/#58%9::;%'1*%,()4$%07%$()6#5(%9!<=;%&0/#58%)('*#1.%-("'6#0)>%%?1%(@&()#4(1,'/%$A)6(8%9!BCDE;%'$$($$(*%,"(%(@,(1,%,0%3"#5"%#1*#6#*A'/$%#.10)(%::%'1*%!<=%3"(1%F0#1#1.%'%7#5,#,#0A$%$05#'/%1(,30)G#1.%$#,(H%I'4(J)0&>%K($A/,$%)(6('/%LDM%$G#&&(*%::H%$(/(5,#1.%+NA#5G%F0#1>2%O0)%)('*()$H%'6()'.(%::%)('*#1.%,#4(%3'$%LE%$(501*$H%'1*%'6()'.(%!<=%)('*#1.%,#4(%3'$%CP%$(501*$>%%?%)(.)($$#01%'1'/8$#$%)(6('/(*%#170)4',#01%06()/0'*%'$%'%$#.1#7#5'1,%1(.',#6(%&)(*#5,0)%07%)('*#1.%!<=%A&01%$#.1A&H%3"(1%!<=%5"'1.($H%'1*%3"(1%::%5"'1.($>%QA'/#,',#6(%7#1*#1.$%7A),"()%$A..($,%,"',%&'),#5#&'1,$%6#(3%&0/#5#($%'$%1A#$'15(H%#.10)#1.%,"(4%,0%&A)$A(%,"(%(1*$%07%*#.#,'/%&)0*A5,#01H%3#,"0A,%-(#1.%#1"#-#,(*%-8%,"(%4('1$>%R4&/#5',#01$%3()(%)(6('/(*%'$%STM%4#$$(*%I'4(J)0&%!<=%+.0,5"'%5/'A$($2%'-0A,%*','%$"')#1.%3#,"%,"(%I=?%'1*%(4&/08()$H%'1*%'-0A,%&)06#*#1.%'%7#)$,U-0)1%5"#/*%'$%&'84(1,%70)%=I=%'55($$> Please feel free to contact me, should you require any further information. Sincerely,

Jonathan A. Obar, PhD Research Associate, Quello Center for Telecommunication Management and Law Michigan State University [email protected]

Page 2: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! -!

,.//0/1!+2345!"#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!!

!

!

!

!"#$%&''#()$*&#$+,$)"#$&,)#-,#).$/',+-&,'$)"#$0-&1234$0+*&3&#($2,5$)#-6($+7$(#-1&3#$

0+*&3&#($+7$(+3&2*$,#)8+-9&,'$(#-1&3#($

!

!

67/3893/!:;!)<3=>!

://2!)2?47=@A+0=BC9>>!

!

>D7=E!F/0G2=B08HI!J.2??7!K2/82=L!M0C9013/!&8382!F/0G2=B08H!

>>F/0G2=B08H!7@!K7//2C80C.8!

!

!

!

N),O#*$!P:P%,!

!

6.?H!QL!RS-T!

!!!!!!!

Page 3: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! R!

!"#$%&''#()$*&#$+,$)"#$&,)#-,#).$/',+-&,'$)"#$0-&1234$0+*&3&#($2,5$)#-6($+7$(#-1&3#$

0+*&3&#($+7$(+3&2*$,#)8+-9&,'$(#-1&3#($

:;<!=:>!$

'90B!U3U2=!344=2BB2B!V892!<0112B8!?02!7/!892!0/82=/28W!X089!3/!2YU0=0C3?!0/G2B8013807/!7@!

U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!ZPP[!3/4!82=YB!7@!B2=G0C2!Z')&[!U7?0CH!=2340/1!<293G07=;!!:/!2\U2=0Y2/83?!

B.=G2H!Z!]^_`[!3BB2BB24!892!2\82/8!87!X90C9!0/40G04.3?B!01/7=2!PP!3/4!')&!X92/!a70/0/1!3!

@0C80807.B!B7C03?!/28X7=E0/1!B082L!*3Y2b=7U;!,2B.?8B!=2G23?!Q_c!BE0UU24!PPL!B2?2C80/1!

Vd.0CE!a70/;W!e7=!=2342=BL!3G2=312!PP!=2340/1!80Y2!X3B!Q`!B2C7/4BL!3/4!3G2=312!')&!=2340/1!

80Y2!X3B!^-!B2C7/4B;!!:!=21=2BB07/!3/3?HB0B!=2G23?24!0/@7=Y3807/!7G2=?734!3B!3!B01/0@0C3/8!

/21380G2!U=240C87=!7@!=2340/1!')&!.U7/!B01/.UL!X92/!')&!C93/12BL!3/4!X92/!PP!C93/12B;!

J.3?08380G2!@0/40/1B!@.=892=!B.112B8!8938!U3=80C0U3/8B!G02X!U7?0C02B!3B!/.0B3/C2L!01/7=0/1!

892Y!87!U.=B.2!892!2/4B!7@!401083?!U=74.C807/L!X0897.8!<20/1!0/90<0824!<H!892!Y23/B;!

#YU?0C3807/B!X2=2!=2G23?24!3B!fgc!Y0BB24!*3Y2b=7U!')&!V178C93!C?3.B2BW!3<7.8!4383!

B93=0/1!X089!892!*&:!3/4!2YU?7H2=BL!3/4!3<7.8!U=7G040/1!3!@0=B8A<7=/!C90?4!3B!U3HY2/8!@7=!

&*&!3CC2BB; !

Page 4: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! `!

!"#$%&''#()$*&#$+,$)"#$&,)#-,#).$/',+-&,'$)"#$0-&1234$0+*&3&#($2,5$)#-6($+7$(#-1&3#$

0+*&3&#($+7$(+3&2*$,#)8+-9&,'$(#-1&3#($

! %@@2C80G2!B8=382102B!@7=!=23?0h0/1!401083?!=2U.83807/!3/4!U=0G3CH!U=782C807/B!=2Y30/!

./C?23=;!N90?2!B2?@A17G2=/3/C2!2@@7=8B!<H!U=7U=0283=H!U?38@7=YB!U=7G042!42!@3C87!

U=782C807/B!Zb2*3=40B!3/4!+3CE?L!RS-^[L!?23G0/1!U=0G3CH!3/4!=2U.83807/!87!C7YU3/02B!

Y7/280h24!89=7.19!4383A4=0G2/!<.B0/2BB!Y742?B!B22YB!U=7<?2Y380C;!b383!=2B0B83/C2!

82C9/7?7102B!3/4!7892=!U=0G3CHA2/93/C0/1!B2=G0C2B!7@@2=!892!U7BB0<0?08H!7@!<7887YA.U!

U=782C807/BI!97X2G2=L!.<0d.087.B!3/4!C7/80/.7.B?H!2@@2C80G2!347U807/!0/!892!@3C2!7@!892!"01!

b383!42?.12!B22YB!3/!./38830/3<?2!0423?!Z)<3=L!RS-^[;!)892=B!B0YU?H!B.112B8!8938!U=0G3CH!0B!

4234!Z&3/42=BL!RS--I!M7=13/L!RS-_[;!b0@@2=0/1!@=7Y!892B2!B8=382102B!42@0/24!<H!

/27?0<2=3?0BY!3/[email protected]?08H!0B!3/7892=!3UU=73C9!87!B7?G0/1!40@@0C.?8!U=7<?2YB!A!17G2=/Y2/8!

0/82=G2/807/;!

! '7UA47X/!3UU=73C92B!87!U=0G3CH!3/4!0/C=23B0/1?H!=2U.83807/!U=782C807/B!<H!

17G2=/Y2/8B!89=7.197.8!892!X7=?4!7@82/!4=3X!@=7Y!3!C7/82/807.B!Y742?!=2@2==24!87!3B!892!

V/780C2!3/4!C970C2W!U=0G3CH!@=3Y2X7=E;!*780C2!3/4!C970C2!2G7?G24!@=7Y!892!F;&;!e242=3?!

'=342!K7YY0BB07/WB!Ze'K[!e30=!#/@7=Y3807/!P=3C80C2!P=0/C0U?2BL!42G2?7U24!0/!892!-fQSB!87!

344=2BB!1=7X0/1!0/@7=Y3807/!U=0G3CH!C7/C2=/B!=30B24!<H!401080h3807/;!#/!892!23=?H!-fgSBL!

892!e#PPB!X2=2!U=7Y7824!<H!892!)%Kb!3B!U3=8!7@!3/!0/82=/3807/3?!B28!7@!U=0G3CH!1.042?0/2B!

Z)%KbL!-fgS[L!C7/8=0<.80/1!87!892!0YU?2Y2/83807/!7@!4383!U=782C807/!?3XB!3/4!1.042?0/2B!0/!

892!F;&;L!K3/343L!892!%FL!:.B8=3?03!3/4!2?B2X92=2L!7@82/!X089!?3/1.312!Y0==7=0/1!892!e#PPB!

@=7Y!892!-fQSB;!%G2/!0/!892!@3C2!7@!C7/B042=3<?2!C=080C0BY!ZB225!K382L!RSSTI!&7?7G2L!RS-RI!

,2042/<2=1!28!3?L!RS-^I!)<3=L!RS-^[L!7/170/1!2@@7=8B!87!B8=2/1892/!4383!U=782C807/B!

C7/80/.2!87!4=3X!7/!892!7?4!@=3Y2X7=E;!!

Page 5: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! _!

! '92!/780C2!3/4!C970C2!U=0G3CH!@=3Y2X7=E!X3B!42B01/24!87!iU.8!0/40G04.3?B!0/!C93=12!

7@!892!C7??2C807/!3/4!.B2!7@!8920=!U2=B7/3?!0/@7=Y3807/j!Z,2042/<2=1!28!3?L!RS-_5!`[;!'97.19!

0YU?2Y2/83807/!40@@2=B!<H!C7/82\8L!892!C970C2!C7YU7/2/8B!C7/B0B8!7@!3!G3=028H!7@!3CC2BBL!

C7/8=7?!3/4!B2C.=08H!Y2C93/0BYB!8938!=2C7YY2/4!97X!.B2=B!Y0198!C92CEL!C7==2C8!3/4k7=!

3UU=7G2!U2=B7/3?!4383!Y3/3124!3/4!.B24!<H!40@@2=2/8!7=13/0h3807/BL!B0Y0?3=!87!97X!7/2!

Y7/087=B!C=2408!=2U7=8B!<2@7=2!3UU?H0/1!@7=!3!?73/;!

! '[email protected]!7@!7.=!C.==2/8!0/d.0=H!97X2G2=!0B!7/!892!/780C2!C7YU7/2/8L!/7824!<H!892!

e'K!3B!i892!Y7B8!@./43Y2/83?!U=0/C0U?2j!Ze'KL!-ffg5!Q[!7@!U2=B7/3?!0/@7=Y3807/!U=782C807/;!

*780C2!C7/B0B8B!7@!2@@7=8B!<H!3/!2/808H!87!0/@7=Y!892!B7.=C2!7@!4383!C7??2C807/L!B93=0/1L!28C;!

8938!892!3C807/!0/!d.2B807/!0B!83E0/1!U?3C2;!:B!892!e'K!Z-ffg[!/782BL!C970C2!3/4!=2?3824!

U=0/C0U?2B!3882YU80/1!87!7@@2=!4383!C7/8=7?!i3=2!7/?H!Y23/0/1@.?!X92/!3!C7/B.Y2=!93B!

/780C2!7@!3/!2/808HWB!U7?0C02BL!3/4!90B!7=!92=!=0198B!X089!=2BU2C8!892=287;j!ZQ[!*780C2!U7?0C02B!

8HU0C3??H!0/C?.42!?3/1.312!4=3X/!@=7Y!892!)%KbWB!i7U2//2BB!U=0/C0U?2j!X90C9!B8382B5!

! l8m92=2!B97.?4!<2!3!12/2=3?!U7?0CH!7@!7U2//2BB!3<7.8!42G2?7UY2/8BL!U=3C80C2B!

! 3/4!U7?0C02B!X089!=2BU2C8!87!U2=B7/3?!4383;!M23/B!B97.?4!<2!=2340?H!3G30?3<?2!!7@!

! 2B83<?0B90/1!892!2\0B82/C2!3/4!/38.=2!7@!U2=B7/3?!4383L!3/4!892!Y30/!U.=U7B2B!7@!

! 8920=!.B2L!3B!X2??!3B!892!042/808H!3/4!.B.3?!=2B042/C2!7@!892!4383!C7/8=7??2=;!Z)%KbL!

! -fgS[!

! :C=7BB!C7/82\8BL!2/80802B!0/G7?G24!0/!4383!Y3/312Y2/8!3882YU8!87!3<042!<H!/780C2!

U7?0CH!<H!U=7G040/1!0/40G04.3?B!X089!C7/B2/8!Y382=03?BL!8HU0C3??H!0/!892!@7=Y!7@!U=0G3CH!

U7?0C02B!3/4!82=YB!7@!B2=G0C2!U7?0C02B;!'92B2!U7?0C02B!3UU23=!7/!X2<B082BL!3UU?0C3807/BL!3=2!

B2/8!0/!892!Y30?L!U=7G0424!0/AU2=B7/L!12/2=3??H!X92/!3/!0/40G04.3?!C7//2C8B!X089!892!2/808H!

0/!d.2B807/!@7=!892!@0=B8!80Y2L!3/4!0/C=23B0/1?H!X92/!U7?0C02B!C93/12;!b2BU082!B.112B807/B!

Page 6: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! ^!

8938!/780C2!U7?0CH!0/!U3=80C.?3=!0B!422U?H!@?3X24!Z2;1;!MCb7/3?4!3/4!K=3/7=L!RSSgI!

,2042/<2=1!28!3?L!RS-^I!)<3=L!RS-^[L!B8=382102B!@7=!B8=2/1892/0/1!/780C2!U7?0CH!C7/80/.2!87!

<2!B22/!3B!C2/8=3?!87!344=2BB0/1L!@7=!2\3YU?2L!U=0G3CH!C7/C2=/B!3BB7C03824!X089!C7=U7=382!

3/4!17G2=/Y2/8!B.=G20??3/C2L!3/4!C7/B.Y2=!U=782C807/!C7/C2=/B!3<7.8!"01!b383L!4383!

<=7E2=312!3/4!2?010<0?08H!42C0B07/AY3E0/1!ZB225!e'KL!RS-R[;!!

! '90B!<=0/1B!.B!87!892!<0112B8!?02!7/!892!0/82=/28L!X90C9!3/2C4783??HL!0B!E/7X/!3B!i#!

31=22!87!892B2!82=YB!3/4!C7/40807/B;j!'92!82=Y!i3/2C4783??Hj!0B!C97B2/!42?0<2=382?H!0/!890B!

C7/82\8L!3B!Y.C9!7@!892!2G042/C2!7@!892!<0112B8!?02L!87!890B!U70/8L!C7Y2B!0/!892!@7=Y!7@!

3/2C4782;!FU7/!40BC.BB0/1!892!C.==2/8!B8.4H!X089!C7??231.2BL!Y7B8!31=22!8938!01/7=0/1!

U=0G3CH!3/4!82=YB!7@!B2=G0C2!Z')&[!U7?0C02B!0B!<789!3!=23?08H!3/4!3!U=7<?2Y;!i#!/2G2=!=234!

897B2!890/1Bj!3/4!i/7<74H!=234B!892Yj!3=2!C7YY7/!=2BU7/B2B;!'92!/7/AU=7@08!'7&Ib,!

Z'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2I!b04/W8!,234[!34G3/C2B!3!B0Y0?3=!3/2C4783?!3BB2=807/;!'92!@=7/8!U312!7@!

8920=!X2<B082!=234B!iV#!93G2!=234!3/4!31=22!87!892!'2=YBW!0B!892!<0112B8!?02!7/!892!X2<;!N2!

30Y!87!@0\!8938;j!:!?2BB!X2??AE/7X/!B082L!XXX;<0112B8?02;C7Y!B8382B!7/!08B!B082!i(28WB!&')P!

892!<0112B8!?02!7/!892!X2<nj!3/4!3BEB!.B2=B!87!C7/@2BB!3/4!U=782B8!3130/B8!892!?02!<H!C?0CE0/1!

i#!C7/@2BB!o!3/4!U=782B8nj!o!3<7.8!_L^SS!B.C9!C7/@2BB07/B!93G2!<22/!Y342!B0/C2!RS-R;!#/!

<789!C3B2BL!/20892=!7=13/0h3807/!C082B!3/H!3C342Y0C!=2B23=C9!87!B.<B83/80382!8920=!C?30YB;!

! P7?0CHY3E2=B!7@82/!34G3/C2!3!B0Y0?3=!./B.<B83/803824!C?30Y;!e7=!2\3YU?2L!0/!RSSQ!

e'K!K7YY0BB07/2=!67/!(20<7X08h!B304L!X0897.8!C080/1!3/H!2YU0=0C3?!2G042/C2L!

#/0803??HL!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!B22Y24!?0E2!3!1774!0423;!".8!0/!U=3C80C2L!892H!7@82/!?23G2!3!

?78!87!<2!42B0=24;!#/!Y3/H!C3B2BL!C7/B.Y2=B!47/W8!/780C2L!=234L!7=!./42=B83/4!892!

U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B;!Z(20<7X08hL!RSSQ5!_[!

Page 7: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! T!

! :!RS-S!=2U7=8!7/!4383!U=0G3CH!<H!892!b2U3=8Y2/8!7@!K7YY2=C2!/7824L!3130/!X0897.8!

C080/1!2YU0=0C3?!2G042/C2L!i'92!B97=8C7Y0/1B!7@!Y3/H!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!lpm!3=2!X042?H!

=2C71/0h245!892H!C3/!<2!lpm!i7G2=X92?Y0/1j!87!892!@2X!C7/B.Y2=B!X97!3C8.3??H!G2/8.=2!87!

=234!892Y;j!Zb)KL!RS-S5!`R[!:!=2C2/8!e'K!U=0G3CH!=2U7=8!B0Y0?3=?H!/7824L!i,2C2/8!=2B23=C9!

3/4!B.=G2HB!B.112B8B!8938!Y3/H!C7/B.Y2=B!lpm!47!/78!=234!7=!./42=B83/4!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02Bj!

Ze'KL!RS-R5!T-[;!)/2!B.=G2HL!C7/4.C824!<H!q71<H!#/82=/3807/3?!Z/7!2G042/C2!7@!U22=!=2G02X!

U=7G0424[!X3B!=2@2=2/C24L!B.YY3=0h24!0/!3!C7YY2/8!B.<Y08824!87!892!e'K!<H!K7YY7/!

&2/B2!M2403;!'92!C7YY2/8!97X2G2=!Y3E2B!/7!Y2/807/!7@!.B2=B!01/7=0/1!U7?0C02BL!<.8!

0/B8234!/782B!8938!0/40G04.3?B!X7.?4!i83E2!Y7=2!80Y2!87!=234j!U7?0C02B!0@!892H!X2=2!B97=82=!

3/4!C?23=2=!ZK&ML!RS-S5!-[;!

! N92892=!7=!/78!892!Y31/08.42!7@!892!?02!0B!87!892!421=22!892!3/2C4782!B.112B8BL!892!

0423!8938!892!U=3C80C2!7@!01/7=0/1!U=0G3CH!3/4!')&!31=22Y2/8B!0B!C7YY7/!E/7X?2412L!

U70/8B!87!C7/B042=3<?2!=21.?387=H!@30?.=2;!#@!08!0B!8=.2!8938!U27U?2!8HU0C3??H!01/7=2!U7?0C02B!

X92/!2/1310/1!401083?!Y2403L!08!B.112B8B!8938!/780C2!U7?0CH!472B/W8!X7=EL!3/4!U2=93UB!8938!

C7YY08824!3/4!C7/80/.24!=2B7.=C2B!42G7824!87!/780C2!2@@7=8B!3=2!<20/1!X3B824;!

:CE/7X?241Y2/8!7@!890B!=21.?387=H!@30?.=2!X7.?4!<2!3!@0=B8!B82U!87X3=4B!Y7=2!U=31Y380C!

3UU=73C92B!8938!Y0198!3C8.3??H!U=7G042!U=782C807/B;!"2@7=2!B.C9!3/!3CE/7X?2412Y2/8!C3/!

<2!Y342!97X2G2=L!892!2\82/8!87!X90C9!0/40G04.3?B!01/7=2!U=0G3CH!3/4!82=YB!7@!B2=G0C2!

U7?0C02B!X92/!2/1310/1!X089!401083?!Y2403!B2=G0C2B!3.198!87!<2!344=2BB24;!

! '90B!B.=G2H!3/3?HB0B!7@!^_`!U3=80C0U3/8B!344=2BB2B!892!2\82/8!87!X90C9!0/40G04.3?B!

01/7=2!U=0G3CH!3/4!82=YB!7@!B2=G0C2!U7?0C02B!X92/!a70/0/1!B7C03?!Y2403!B2=G0C2B!@7=!892!@0=B8!

80Y2!3B!X2??!3B!X92/!U7?0C02B!3=2!.U43824;!#8!3?B7!344=2BB2B!892!=23B7/B!0/40G04.3?B!01/7=2!

Page 8: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! Q!

U7?0C02B;!#/!X938!@7??7XBL!3!=2G02X!7@!892!<=02@!3G30?3<?2!?082=38.=2!7/!U=0G3CH!3/4!')&!U7?0CH!

2/1312Y2/8!X0??!<2!40BC.BB24;!'90B!0B!@7??7X24!<H!892!B.=G2H!3/3?HB0B;!

!"#$?#%2)#$@1#-$A+)&3#$B+*&34$

! '92!42B0=2!87!./42=B83/4!3/4!U=7Y782!C7//2C807/B!<28X22/!892!0/@7=Y24!

0/40G04.3?!3/4!B2?@A17G2=/3/C2!U=2C242B!40BC.BB07/B!7@!401083?!4383;!e7=!2\3YU?2L!0/!-gRRL!

63Y2B!M340B7/L!C7/B042=24!892!Ve3892=W!7@!892!F;&;!K7/B808.807/!3/4!"0??!7@!,0198B!X=7825!!

:!U7U.?3=!$7G2=/Y2/8L!X0897.8!U7U.?3=!0/@7=Y3807/L!7=!892!Y23/B!7@!3Cd.0=0/1!08L!0B!

<.8!3!P=7?71.2!87!3!e3=C2!7=!3!'=3124HI!7=L!U2=93UB!<789;!O/7X?2412!X0??!@7=2G2=!

17G2=/!01/7=3/C25!:/4!3!U27U?2!X97!Y23/!87!<2!8920=!7X/!$7G2=/7=BL!Y.B8!3=Y!

892YB2?G2B!X089!892!U7X2=!X90C9!E/7X?2412!10G2B;!ZM340B7/L!-gRR[!

! N089!892B2!X7=4BL!M340B7/!<.88=2BB24!B.<B2d.2/8!=21.?387=H!2@@7=8B!30Y24!38!

U=7Y780/1!C7=U7=382!3/4!17G2=/Y2/8!8=3/BU3=2/CHL!3/4!92?U24!C3=G2!3!U389!87!892!F;&;!

e=2247Y!7@!#/@7=Y3807/!:C8!3/4!<2H7/4!Z&C9.4B7/L!RS-^[;!#/4224L!3CC2BB!87!0/@7=Y3807/L!

3/4!7U2//2BB!3<7.8!U=7C24.=2B!3/4!U=7C2BB2B!8938!0YU3C8!3/!0/40G04.3?!93G2!90B87=0C3??H!

<22/!G02X24!3B!2BB2/803?!87!2/B.=0/1!3.87/7YH!3/4!?0<2=8HL!/78!7/?H!0/!892!U7?080C3?!C7/82\8L!

<.8!0/!892!C7/B.Y2=!C7/82\8!3B!X2??!Z"7X?2BL!+3Y0?87/!3/4!(2GHL!RS-`[;!'92!/7=Y380G2!

=21.?387=H!U90?7B7U9H!2Y<24424!X0890/!2@@7=8B!87!U=7Y782!8=3/BU3=2/CH!3BB.Y2B!8938!892!

G70C2!7@!892!3G2=312!0/40G04.3?!C3/!U=7G042!3!C92CE!7/!0/B808.807/3?!U7X2=!B8=.C8.=2BL!

U=782C8!3130/B8!2C7/7Y0CL!B7C03?!3/4!2G2/!Y7=3?!B8=380@0C3807/BL!<03B!3/4!0/!B7Y2!0/B83/C2BL!

8H=3//H!ZN3?E2=L!-fTTI!$=3Y<2=12=L!RSS-I!)<3=!RS-S[;!:B!3!=2B.?8L!i8=3/BU3=2/CH!0B!89.B!3!

9019?H!G3?.24!0/B8=.Y2/83?!1774L!B0/C2!08!0B!3/!0/U.8!0/87!3!U=7C2BB!7@!Y7/087=0/1!8938!

0/C=23B2B!892!744B!8938!G782=B!7=!C7/B.Y2=B!128!X938!892H!X3/8!@=7Y!0/B808.807/3?!3C87=B;j!

Z"7X?2B!28!3?L!RS-`5!\G[;!'92B2!G02XB!C7/80/.2!87!<2!2BU7.B24!8743HL!X089!@23=B!3BB7C03824!

Page 9: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! g!

X089!=2Y7G3?!7@!/780C2!C7YU7/2/8B!?0/E24!87!892!?7BB!7@!<2/2@08B!90B87=0C3??H!?0/E24!87!

8=3/BU3=2/CHL!/3Y2?HL!?0<2=8HL!3.87/7YH!3/4!892!3<0?08H!87!97?4!897B2!0/!U7X2=!87!3CC7./8!

ZB225!)PKL!RS-T[;!'90B!3BB.Y2BL!U2=93UB!0/C7==2C8?HL!8938!<H!Y30/830/0/1!/780C2!U7?0CH!8938!

3440807/3?!U=782C807/B!=2B.?8!o!890B!=2Y30/B!./C?23=;!

! N90?2!B7Y2!7@!892!B8=7/12B8!=2B23=C9!?77E0/1!38!.B2=!2/1312Y2/8!X089!U=0G3CH!

U7?0C02B!344=2BB2B!892!2\82/8!87!X90C9!.B2=B!./42=B83/4!892Y!Z,2042/<2=1!28!3?L!RS-^[!3/4!

97X!?7/1!08!83E2B!87!=234!892Y!ZMCb7/3?4!3/4!K=3/7=L!RSSg[L!2YU0=0C3?!2G042/C2!

42Y7/B8=380/1!892!2\82/8!87!X90C9!.B2=B!01/7=2!U=0G3CH!3/4!82=YB!7@!B2=G0C2!U7?0C02B!0B!

?3CE0/1L!2BU2C03??H!0/!892!C7/82\8!7@!B7C03?!/28X7=E0/1!B2=G0C2B;!

! :/!7@82/AC0824!<77E!C93U82=!<H!K382!ZRSST[!2/808?24!"#$%&'()*+$%,-%&'(+%./-,+0'1(,/%

2+'31(3$%2+(/3(4)$5!472B!U=7G042!B7Y2!2YU0=0C3?!B.UU7=8!87!892!0423!8938!0/40G04.3?B!01/7=2!

U7?0C02BI!97X2G2=L!892!2G042/C2!U=7G0424!0B!/7X!43824!3/4!12/2=3??H!83/12/803?!87!C.==2/8!

C7/C2=/B;!K382!/782B!8938!i3/!3G3?3/C92!7@!/780C2B!3/4!C7/B2/8!7UU7=8./0802B!lpm!3=2!X042?H!

01/7=24!<H!892!U.<?0Cj!Z`TS[;!'7!B.<B83/80382!890B!3BB2=807/!K382!<210/B!<H!C080/1!3!-ffQ!

B8.4H!@=7Y!892!F;&;!P7B83?!&2=G0C2!X90C9!B.112B8B!8938!^R!U2=C2/8!7@!./B7?0C0824!Y30?!0/!892!

F;&;!0B!/2G2=!=234;!'90B!0B!@7??7X24!<H!X938!3UU23=B!87!<2!3/2C4783?!2G042/C2!@=7Y!RSSR!0/!

X90C9!3/!.//3Y24!#&P!/7824!8938!^g!U2=C2/8!7@!08B!Y3=E280/1!2Y30?B!=2Y30/!./7U2/24;!'92!

C7/@?3807/!7@!7U2/0/1!B/30?!Y30?!3/4!Y3=E280/1!2Y30?B!X089!U=0G3CH!3/4!')&!U7?0CH!

2/1312Y2/8!0B!U=7<?2Y380CI!97X2G2=L!892!B.112B807/!8938!892=2!3=2!C93??2/12B!12880/1!

U27U?2!87!=234!890/1B!892H!Y3H!/78!X3/8!87!472B!B7Y2X938!34G3/C2!892!3=1.Y2/8;!K382!

172B!7/!87!40BC.BB!97X!0/!RSS-!892!C902@!U=0G3CH!7@@0C2=!7@!#&P!%\C082r+7Y2!/7824!4.=0/1!

3/!e'K!X7=EB97U!i8938!892!43H!3@82=!67%8(/*1$5!@238.=24!90B!C7YU3/H!0/!3!B21Y2/8!7/!

#/82=/28!U=0G3CHL!7/?H!-SS!7.8!7@!RS!Y0??07/!./0d.2!G0B087=B!87!08B!X2<B082!3CC2BB24!8938!

Page 10: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! f!

C7YU3/HWB!U=0G3CH!U312Bj!ZC;@;!K382L!RSST5!RT-[;!b383!@=7Y!D3977!0B!892/!U=2B2/824!/780/1!

8938!3/!3G2=312!7@!S;`!U2=C2/8!7@!.B2=B!3CC2BB24!08B!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!0/!RSSRL!X089!892!/.Y<2=!

=0B0/1!87!-!U2=C2/8!4.=0/1!3!U=0G3CHAU.<?0C08H!i@0=2B87=Y;j!K382!U=7G042B!7/2!3440807/3?!

U02C2!7@!B8380B80C3?!2G042/C2!87!B.UU7=8!892!3BB2=807/L!42BC=0<0/1!97X!0/!RSS-L!0/!=2BU7/B2!

892!$=3YYA(23C9A"?0?2H!7@!-fffL!38!?23B8!R!<0??07/!U=0G3CH!/780C2B!X2=2!Y30?24!@=7Y!82/B!7@!

897.B3/4B!7@!@0/3/C03?!0/B808.807/B!87!C7/B.Y2=B;!:CC7=40/1!87!K382L!892B2!2@@7=8B!X2=2!

B.UU7=824!<H!C7/B042=3<?2!U=2BB!C7G2=312!3/4!U=7Y7807/!<H!U=0G3CH!34G7C382B;!:UU3=2/8?H!

0/!Y04ARSS-L!?2BB!893/!^!U2=C2/8!7@!C7/B.Y2=B!934!7U824!7.8!7@!4383!B93=0/1!31=22Y2/8BL!

3/4!3!&2U82Y<2=!B.=G2H!/7824!8938!`^!U2=C2/8!7@!=2BU7/42/8B!iC7.?4!/78!=2C3??!2G2/!

=2C20G0/1!3!U=0G3CH!/780C2j!Z#<045!`T-A`TR[;!#/!B.YL!X90?2!K382WB!2YU0=0C3?!2G042/C2!<210/B!

87!B.UU7=8!892!3=1.Y2/8L!08!0B!C?23=!8938!Y7=2!4383!0B!/22424L!2BU2C03??H!B0/C2!892!Y3a7=08H!

7@!892!2G042/C2!U=7G0424!U=24382B!B7C03?!Y2403!3/4!892!"01!b383!<77Y;!!

! M0?/2!3/4!K.?/3/!ZRSS_[!U=2B2/8!U2=93UB!892!<2B8!2YU0=0C3?!3BB2BBY2/8!7@!=2342=B!

G2=B.B!/7/A=2342=B!7@!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!87!4382L!/780/1!i892!?082=38.=2!93B!/78!2\3Y0/24!892!

82/42/CH!87!=234!/780C2Bj!Z-Q[;!'920=!=2B.?8B!B.112B8!8938!-Q;`!U2=C2/8!7@!892!RL_Tg!

0/40G04.3?B!B.=G2H24!X2=2!042/80@024!3B!i/7/A=2342=BLj!X90?2!g`;Q!U2=C2/8!7@!897B2!

B.=G2H24!=234!892!U7?0C02B;!)@!892!=2342=BL!``;`!U2=C2/8!/7824!8938!892H!i=3=2?H!=234!7/?0/2!

U=0G3CH!/780C2B;j!#8!B97.?4!<2!34424!8938!892!3.897=B!=3/!8920=!B.=G2H!0/!RSS-L!X90C9!

B.112B8B!3130/!8938!4383!=2U=2B2/80/1!892!C.==2/8!?3/4BC3U2!0B!?3CE0/1;!

! )/2!7892=!2\3YU?2!X7=89!/780/1!0B!@7./4!0/!*0BB2/<3.YWB!ZRSSf[!B2Y0/3?!X7=E!

2+(9'3:%(/%;,/1$<1;!&92!42G782B!3!B2C807/!0/!92=!<77E!87!3/!0BB.2!E/7X/!3B!892!U=0G3CH!

U3=347\!Z*7=<2=1L!+7=/2!3/4!+7=/2L!RSSQ[!i3!B83=E!C7/8=340C807/!38!X97B2!923=8!0B!890B5!

U27U?2!3UU23=!87!X3/8!3/4!G3?.2!U=0G3CHL!H28!B0Y.?83/27.B?H!3UU23=!/78!87!G3?.2!7=!X3/8!

Page 11: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! -S!

08;j!Z*0BB2/<3.YL!RSSf5!-S_[!#/!42BC=0<0/1!7/2!C7YU7/2/8!7@!890B!U3=347\L!BU2C0@0C3??H!8938!

i7/?H!RS!U2=C2/8!7@!.B2=B!C?30Y!87!=234!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!VY7B8!7@!892!80Y2Wj!Z-S^[L!

*0BB2/<3.Y!C082B!3!U=2BB!=2?23B2!7@!3!B8.4H!<H!',F&'2!@=7Y!RSSTL!3!B2?@A42BC=0<24!?2340/1!

b383!P=0G3CH!M3/312Y2/8!C7YU3/H!Z',F&'2L!RSST[;!

! '92!?3CE!7@!U22=A=2G02X24!3C342Y0C!=2B23=C9!0/!890B!3=23!B.112B8B!3!C7/B042=3<?2!

=2B23=C9!13UL!3/4!892!/224!@7=!2YU0=0C3?!2G042/C2;!#/!890B!U3U2=!X2!C7/4.C8!3/!2YU0=0C3?!

3BB2BBY2/8!7@!892!2\82/8!87!X90C9!0/40G04.3?B!01/7=2!U=0G3CH!3/4!')&!U7?0C02B!X92/!

2/1310/1!&*&;!N2!344=2BB!892!@7??7X0/1!=2B23=C9!d.2B807/B5!

! ,J-5!'7!X938!2\82/8!X0??!U3=80C0U3/8B!01/7=2!U=0G3CH!3/4!82=YB!7@!B2=G0C2!U7?0C02B!

@[email protected]!B7C03?!/28X7=E0/1!B2=G0C2!*3Y2b=7Us!

! ,JR5!'7!X938!2\82/8!X0??!U3=80C0U3/8B!@30?!87!/780C2!V178C93W!C?3.B2B!0/!892!*3Y2b=7U!

U7?0C02Bs!

! ,J`5!'7!X938!2\82/8!X0??!U3=80C0U3/8B!=234!U=0G3CH!3/4!82=YB!7@!B2=G0C2!U7?0C02B!@7=!

=23?!B7C03?!/28X7=E0/1!B2=G0C2Bs!

! ,J_5!N938!38808.42B!3<7.8!U=0G3CH!3/4!82=YB!7@!B2=G0C2B!U7?0C02B!U=240C8!892!2\82/8!

87!X90C9!U3=80C0U3/8B!01/7=2!892Ys!

C#)"+5$

<260*#$

! P3=80C0U3/8B!Z!!]!^_`[!C7/B0B824!7@!./42=1=34.382!B8.42/8B!=2C=.0824!@=7Y!3!?3=12!

C7YY./0C3807/!C?3BB!38!3!./0G2=B08H!0/!892!23B82=/!F/0824!&8382B;!'92!B3YU?2!X3B!_Qc!

@2Y3?2L!_^c!Y3?2!Zgc!./C?23=[L!3/4!892!3G2=312!312!X3B!-f!H23=B;!&0\8HA8X7!U2=C2/8!7@!

U3=80C0U3/8B!042/80@024!3B!K3.C3B03/L!-^c!:B03/L!Tc!"?3CEL!Rc!+0BU3/0C!7=!(380/7k3L!`c!3B!

Y0\24!=3C2k289/0C08HL!3/4!`c!3B!3/7892=!=3C2k289/0C08H!Zfc!./C?23=[;!:??!U3=80C0U3/8B!

Page 12: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! --!

=2C20G24!C7.=B2!C=2408!@7=!C7YU?280/1!892!B.=G2HL!97B824!7/!XXX;d.3?8=0CB;C7Y!0/!@3??!

RS-^;!

B-+3#5D-#$

! '92!B.=G2H!C7/B0B824!7@!8X7!B2C807/B5!Z-[!d.3/808380G2!3/4!d.3?08380G2!3BB2BBY2/8B!

7@!U3=80C0U3/8!0/82=3C807/!X089!3!U=0G3CH!3/4!3!')&!U7?0CH!@[email protected]!&*&L!3/4!ZR[!3!B2?@A

=2U7=8!B2C807/!3<7.8!=2340/1!U=0G3CH!3/4!')&!U7?0C02B!@7=!=23?!&*&;!'7!C7YU?282!Z-[!

=2B23=C92=B!42G2?7U24!892!@=7/8!U312!@[email protected]!&*&!C3??24!i*3Y2b=7Uj!ZB22!e01.=2!-[L!

3!9HU789280C3?!C7YU28087=!7@!(0/E240/;!!

le01.=2!-!:<7.8!+2=2m!

$ <#3)&+,$E.$B2-)&3&02,)$&,)#-23)&+,$8&)"$A26#?-+0$B-&1234$2,5$!@<$B+*&3&#($

! P3=80C0U3/8B!X2=2!0/@7=Y24!8938!8920=!./0G2=B08H!X3B!X7=E0/1!X089!*3Y2b=7U!3/4!

8938!892H!X7.?4!<2!C7/8=0<.80/1!87!3!U=2A?3./C9!2G3?.3807/!7@!892!&*&;!'90B!42C2U807/!

30Y24!87!C7/G0/C2!U3=80C0U3/8B!8938!892!2G3?.3807/!X7.?4!0/G7?G25!B01/0/1A.UL!=2G02X0/1!892!

&*&L!3/4!42?280/1!8920=!3CC7./8!0@!42B0=24;!:8!/7!U70/8!X3B!08!B83824!8938!U2=B7/3?!

0/@7=Y3807/!X7.?4!<2!=2Y7G24!.U7/!42?2807/;!:8!/7!U70/8!X3B!3/!&*&!2G3?.3824;!:@82=!

C7/B2/80/1L!892!VB01/A.UW!U=7C2BB!0/G7?G24!7/?H!3/!2/C7./82=!X089!892!*3Y2b=7U!U7?0C02B;!

! :@82=!G02X0/1!*3Y2b=7UWB!@=7/8!U312!ZB22!e01.=2!-[L!U3=80C0U3/8B!X2=2!10G2/!X938!

X2!82=Y!3!Vd.0CEAa70/W!7U807/L!3??7X0/1!892Y!87!BE0U!892!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!X0897.8!=2340/1!08;!

J.0CEAa70/!7U807/B!3=2!C7YY7/!87!&*&L!0/C?.40/1!e3C2<77EL!$771?2L!'X0882=!3/4!(0/E240/;!

P3=80C0U3/8B!C7.?4!C977B2!i&01/!FUn!Z"H!C?0CE0/1!&01/!FUL!H7.!31=22!87!*3Y2b=7UWB!U=0G3CH!

U7?0CH[j!7=!iK?0CE!92=2!87!=234!*3Y2b=7UWB!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH;j!:@82=!BE0UU0/1!7=!=2G02X0/1!892!

U7?0CHL!U3=80C0U3/8B!X2=2!3BE24!87!=2G02X!*3Y2b=7UWB!')&;!"789!U7?0C02B!C7.?4!<2!3CC2U824!

7=!=2a2C824;!

Page 13: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! -R!

! '92!*3Y2b=7U!U7?0C02B!X2=2!Y740@024!G2=B07/B!7@!(0/E240/WB!87!2/B.=2!C7YU3=3<?2!

?2/189!87!C.==2/8!&*&;!#/!3440807/!87!3BB2BB0/1!3CC2U8k=2a2C8L!892!B7@8X3=2!80Y24!97X!?7/1!

U3=80C0U3/8B!BU2/8!7/!23C9!U7?0CH;!'92!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!Y23B.=24!QLfQQ!X7=4B!3/4!892!')&!

_L`-T!X7=4B;!'92!?082=38.=2!B.112B8B!8938!3G2=312!34.?8!=2340/1!BU224L!@7=!0/40G04.3?B!X089!

3!1=342!-R!7=!C7??212!24.C3807/!0B!3UU=7\0Y382?H!R^SARgS!X7=4B!U2=!Y0/.82!Z'3H?7=L!

-fT^[;!'90B!B.112B8B!8938!08!B97.?4!83E2!892!3G2=312!34.?8!<28X22/!Rf!3/4!`R!Y0/.82B!87!

=234!*3Y2b=7UWB!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!3/4!-^!3/4!-Q!Y0/.82B!@7=!')&;!

! 'X7!V178C93W!C?3.B2B!X2=2!34424!87!')&!87!@.=892=!3BB2BB!01/7=0/1!<293G07=;!'92!

0/82/807/!X3B!87!U=2B2/8!C?3.B2B!B7!7.8=3127.B!8938!C7/C2=/!X7.?4!<2!2\U=2BB24!3@82=!

=2340/1;!'92!@0=B8!C?3.B2!423?8!X089!4383!B93=0/1L!892!*&:!3/4!2?010<0?08H!4282=Y0/3807/B5!

`;-;-!*3Y2b=7U!b383!lpm!:/H!3/4!3??!4383!12/2=3824!3/4k7=!C7??2C824!<H!

*3Y2b=7UL!<H!3/H!Y23/BL!Y3H!<2!B93=24!X089!890=4!U3=802B;!e7=!2\3YU?2L!

*3Y2b=7U!Y3H!<2!=2d.0=24!87!B93=2!4383!X089!17G2=/Y2/8!312/C02BL!0/C?.40/1!892!

F;&;!*3807/3?!&2C.=08H!:12/CHL!3/4!7892=!B2C.=08H!312/C02B!0/!892!F/0824!&8382B!3/4!

3<=734;!*3Y2b=7U!Y3H!3?B7!C977B2!87!B93=2!4383!X089!890=4!U3=802B!0/G7?G24!0/!892!

42G2?7UY2/8!7@!4383!U=74.C8B!42B01/24!87!3BB2BB!2?010<0?08H;!'90B!C7.?4!0YU3C8!

2?010<0?08H!0/!892!@7??7X0/1!3=23B5!2YU?7HY2/8L!@0/3/C03?!B2=G0C2!Z<3/E!?73/BL!

0/B.=3/C2L!28C;[L!./0G2=B08H!2/8=3/C2L!0/82=/3807/3?!8=3G2?L!892!C=0Y0/3?!a.B80C2!

BHB82YL!28C;!F/42=!/7!C0=C.YB83/C2B!X0??!*3Y2b=7U!<2!?03<?2!@7=!3/H!2G2/8.3?!

42C0B07/!Y342!3B!3!=2B.?8!7@!*3Y2b=7U!4383!B93=0/1;!!

! '92!B2C7/4!C?3.B2!X3B!Y7=2!2\8=2Y2L!B8380/1!8938!<H!31=220/1!87!')&L!U3=80C0U3/8B!

X7.?4!10G2!.U!8920=!@0=B8A<7=/!C90?4!87!*3Y2b=7U5!

Page 14: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! -`!

R;`;-!P3HY2/8!8HU2B!ZC90?4!3BB01/Y2/8!C?3.B2[5!#/!3440807/!87!3/H!Y7/283=H!

U3HY2/8!8938!892!.B2=!Y3H!Y3E2!87!*3Y2b=7UL!<H!31=220/1!87!892B2!'2=YB!7@!

&2=G0C2L!3/4!0/!2\C93/12!@7=!B2=G0C2L!3??!.B2=B!7@!890B!B082!31=22!87!0YY240382?H!3BB01/!

8920=!@0=B8A<7=/!C90?4!87!*3Y2b=7UL!#/C;!#@!892!.B2=!472B!/78!H28!93G2!C90?4=2/L!890B!

31=22Y2/8!X0??!<2!2/@7=C23<?2!./80?!892!H23=!RS^S;!:??!0/40G04.3?B!3BB01/24!87!

*3Y2b=7U!3.87Y380C3??H!<2C7Y2!892!U=7U2=8H!7@!*3Y2b=7UL!#/C;!*7!2\C2U807/B;!

! )U2/A2/424!d.2B807/B!X2=2!U7B24!3BE0/1!X92892=!U3=80C0U3/8B!934!3/H!C7/C2=/B!

3<7.8!892!U7?0C02B!3/4!3?B7!3<7.8!U2=C2U807/B!7@!d.0CEAa70/!7U807/B;!

! :!C740/1!0/B8=.Y2/8!X3B!.80?0h24!87!3BB2BB!892!3/BX2=B!87!892!7U2/A2/424!

d.2B807/B;!t3=03<?2B!-A^!042/80@024!C7/C2=/B!3BB7C03824!X089!892!*3Y2b=7U!U=0G3CH!3/4!

')&!U7?0C02B!Z0/C?.40/1!4383!B93=0/1L!892!*&:L!892!C90?4!3BB01/Y2/8!C?3.B2L!892!U7?0CH!?2/189!

3/4!12/2=3?!C7/C2=/[;!t3=03<?2B!TAQ!042/80@024!X92892=!d.0CEAa70/!7U807/B!3=2!.80?0h24!7@82/!

7=!B7Y280Y2B;!#/82=AC742=!=2?03<0?08H!X3B!C7/4.C824!.B0/1!8X7!8=30/24!C742=B!=2G02X0/1!

=2BU7/B2B!@=7Y!--f!U3=80C0U3/8B!ZRRc!7@!8783?[;!+7?B80WB!Z-fTf[!U2=C2/8312!31=22Y2/8!82B8!

=2G23?24!0/82=AC742=!=2?03<0?08H!BC7=2B!=3/10/1!@=7Y!U!]!;fQ!87!U!]!-;SSL!X089!3/!3G2=312!

3C=7BB!892!B2G2/!G3=03<?2B!7@!U!]!;ff;!!

$ <#3)&+,$F.$<#*7G=#0+-)$=#25&,'$+7$=#2*$<A<$B-&1234$2,5$!@<$B+*&3&#($

"(0$%54$/1%+$'=(/>%4+(9'3:%4,)(3($5?!P3=80C0U3/8B!X2=2!3BE24!97X!Y3/H!Y0/.82B!Z7/!

3!B?042=!=3/10/1!SATS!Y0/.82B[!892H!BU2/8!=2340/1!U=0G3CH!3/4!')&!U7?0C02B!@7=!892!

@7??7X0/1!B2=G0C2B!.U7/!B01/.U!3/4!3130/!X92/!U7?0C02B!C93/125!e3C2<77EL!'X0882=L!

#/B831=3YL!&EHU2L!&/3UK938L!D0E!D3EL!u<7\!(0G2L!0P97/2!M2BB2/12=L!$Y30?!3/4!0'./2B;!:??!

U=7G042!&*&!@./C807/3?08HL!2\C2U8!0'./2BL!X90C9!X3B!B2?2C824!87!3BB2BB!<293G07=B!

3BB7C03824!X089!3!40@@2=2/8!401083?!B2=G0C2;!!

Page 15: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! -_!

2+(9'3:%'/=%"@A%4,)(3:%+$'=(/>%B$#'9(,*+?!e7.=!Y38C924!U30=B!7@!082YB!Zg!082YB!

8783?[!Y23B.=24!U3=80C0U3/8BW!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!3/4!')&!=2340/1!<293G07=5!i#!31=22!87!U=0G3CH!

U7?0C02Bk'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!X0897.8!=2340/1!892YLj!i#!BE0Y!U=0G3CH!

U7?0C02Bk'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8BLj!i#!=234!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02Bk'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!

31=22Y2/8B!897=7.19?Hj!3/4!i#!=2G02X!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02Bk'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!X92/!

/780@024!8938!892=2!93G2!<22/!.U4382Bj;!'92B2!X2=2!Y23B.=24!3B!QAU70/8!(0E2=8A8HU2!BC3?2!

082YB!Z&8=7/1?H!b0B31=22!o!&8=7/1?H!:1=22[;!e7=!<789!BC3?2BL!=2?03<0?08H!X3B!0YU=7G24!X92/!

892!i#!BE0Yj!082Y!X3B!=2Y7G24L!=2B.?80/1!0/!=2?03<?2!89=22A082Y!BC3?2B!@7=!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!

01/7=0/1L!v!]!;QgL!3/4!')&!01/7=0/1L!v!]!;Q^;!

2+(9'3:%'/=%"@A%4,)(3:%'11(1*=$5?!&0\822/!Y38C924!U30=B!7@!082YB!Z`R!082YB!8783?[!

X2=2!42G2?7U24!87!Y23B.=2!U3=80C0U3/8BW!38808.42B!87X3=4!892!U7?0C02B;!'92B2!082YB!X2=2!

@3C87=!3/3?Hh24!.B0/1!P=0/C0U3?!:\0B!e3C87=0/1!3/4!t3=0Y3\!=783807/L!=2G23?0/1!3!89=22A

@3C87=!B8=.C8.=2;!FB0/1!3!C=082=07/!7@!082YB!?7340/1!38!;^!7=!90192=!7/!7/2!@3C87=!X089!/7!

C=7BBA?7340/1B!7@!;^!7=!90192=!7/!7892=!@3C87=BL!R`!082YB!?73424!7/87!892!89=22!@3C87=BL!

2\U?30/0/1!_Rc!7@!892!G3=03/C2;!&22!@.??!BC3?2B!3/4!@3C87=!082YB!0/!'3<?2!-;!

C$0,>+'4#(35?!P3=80C0U3/8B!X2=2!3BE24!87!0/40C382!8920=!312L!12/42=L!3/4!

=3C2k289/0C08H;!

=#(D*)($

<#3)&+,$E.$B2-)&3&02,)$/,)#-23)&+,$8&)"$A26#?-+0$B-&1234$2,5$!@<$B+*&3&#($

! ,J-!X3B!344=2BB24!<H!=2C7=40/1!X92892=!U3=80C0U3/8B!BE0UU24!892!*3Y2b=7U!

U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!G03!3!Vd.0CEAa70/W!7U807/L!3/4!892/!892!2\82/8!87!X90C9!892H!=234!892!U=0G3CH!

U7?0CH!Z@7=!897B2!42C?0/0/1!Vd.0CEAa70/W[!3/4!')&!U7?0CH;!!

"#$%DE*(3FGH,(/I%@41(,/%

Page 16: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! -^!

! FU7/!2/C7./82=0/1!892!d.0CEAa70/!7U807/!@7=!892!*3Y2b=7U!U=0G3CH!U7?0CHL!`ff!7@!

^_`!U3=80C0U3/8B!ZQ_c[!3CC2U824!892!7U807/!3/4!BE0UU24!=2340/1!892!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!

2/80=2?H;!'90B!Y23/B!8938!892B2!U3=80C0U3/8B!3CC2U824!*3Y2b=7UWB!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!X0897.8!

B220/1!7=!=2340/1!3/H!U3=8!7@!08;!

! '7!2\U3/4!.U7/!890B!@0/40/1L!=2BU7/B2B!87!7U2/A2/424!d.2B807/B!3<7.8!d.0CEAa70/!

7U807/B!X2=2!3BB2BB24;!e=7Y!892!^RQ!U3=80C0U3/8B!8938!U=7G0424!d.3?08380G2!=2BU7/B2BL!_--!

ZQgc[!B304!892H!.B2!892!d.0CEAa70/!Y28974!7@82/;!)@!892!=2Y30/0/1!U3=80C0U3/8BL!-Q!

B.112B824!8938!892H!B7Y280Y2B!d.0CEAa70/;!,2Y7G0/1!=2BU7/B2B!?3<2?24!i./C?23=j!ZY7B8!7@!

892B2!X2=2!C=080C3?!7@!892!U=7C2BB!7@!=2340/1!U7?0C02B!<.8!404/W8!3/BX2=!892!d.2B807/[L!Y7=2!

893/!fS!U2=C2/8!7@!897B2!B.=G2H24!B304!892H!.B2!d.0CEAa70/!7U807/B!7@82/!7=!B7Y280Y2BL!

X089!892!G3B8!Y3a7=08H!.B0/1!892Y!7@82/;!

! P3=80C0U3/8B!/780/1!8938!892H!7@82/!.B2!d.0CEAa70/!7U807/B!.B.3??H!U=7G0424!3/!

2\U?3/3807/;!:/!7G2=3=C90/1!892Y2!U=2B2/8!0/!Y3/H!7@!892!=2BU7/B2B!B.112B8B!8938!

U3=80C0U3/8B!3=2!12/2=3??H!./0/82=2B824!0/!892!/780C2!C7YU7/2/8!7@!&*&;!'92!d.0CEAa70/!

7U807/!X3B!7@82/!U=30B24!@7=!Y3E0/1!892!/780C2!U=7C2BB!i23BHLj!id.0CELj!iB0YU?2Lj!3/4!

iC7/G2/02/8;j!)/2!U3=80C0U3/8!/7824L!i08!2\U24082B!892!U=7C2BB;j!P3=80C0U3/8B!X2=2!C=080C3?!7@!

892!U7?0C02B!892YB2?G2BL!B.112B80/1!8938!892H!3=2!i877!?7/1j!3/4!iX7=4H;j!e22?0/1B!7@!3U389H!

[email protected]?08H!X2=2!C7YY7/L!X089!892!?3882=!B7Y280Y2B!?0/E24!87!892!U2=C2U807/!8938!

U7?0C02B!X7.?4/W8!<2!./42=B8774!2G2/!0@!892H!X2=2!=234;!

! %\U3/40/1!.U7/!892!id.0CEj!3/4!i23BHj!C7YY2/8B!X3B!892!B.112B807/!8938!

U3=80C0U3/8B!3=2!40B0/82=2B824!0/!892!/780C2!U=7C2BB!<2C3.B2!08!0B!U2=C20G24!3B!3/!./X3/824!

3/4k7=!.//2C2BB3=H!<3==02=!<28X22/!892!.B2=!3/4!892!42B0=24!&*&!2\U2=02/C2;!)/2!

U3=80C0U3/8!a.B80@024!.B0/1!892!d.0CEAa70/!7U807/!<H!B3H0/1L!!i=213=4?2BB!7@!892!U7?0CHL!0@!3!

Page 17: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! -T!

Y3BB!Y3a7=08H!7@!YH!@=02/4B!3/4!@3Y0?H!3=2!7/!892!/28X7=E0/1!B082!#!X3/8!87!<2!0/C?.424!3B!

X2??!0/!7=42=!87!0/82=3C8!X089!892Y;j!:/7892=!/7824L!iYH!@=02/4B!.B2!890B!B7C03?!Y2403!0/!

742=!ZB0C[!87!C38C9!.U!X089!8920=!?0@2!0!ZB0C[!B01/.U!@7=!890B!3B!d.0CE!3B!U7BB0<?2;j!#/4224L!892!

42B0=2!87!2/a7H!892!2/4B!7@!401083?!Y2403!U=74.C807/!X0897.8!<20/1!0/90<0824!<H!892!Y23/B!

X3B!C?23=L!X089!7/2!U3=80C0U3/8!/780/1!i#wY!0/!3!9.==H!87!.B2!892!B2=G0C2Lj!X90?2!3/7892=!B304!

i08B!3!93BB?2!87!423?!X089!3!Y3BB0G2!3Y7./8!7@!<7=0/1!U312B!3<7.8!U=0G3CH!3/4!B2C.=08H!

X92/!892!B082!H7.!3=2!a70/0/1!0B!892=2!87!47!B7Y2890/1!Y.C9!Y7=2!0/82=2B80/1;j!#/4224L!892!

U2=C2U807/!8938!892B2!38808.42B!3=2!892!/7=Y!X3B!3CE/7X?24124L!i08!@22?B!?0E2!3!C.?8.=3?!

/7=Y!/78!87!=234!892Y!3/4!#wY!877!?3hH!87!=234!892Y!0/!42830?;j!

$ =#25&,'$+-$/',+-&,'$A26#?-+0$B+*&3&#($

! '92!3G2=312!34.?8!=2340/1!BU224!@7=!0/40G04.3?B!X089!3!1=342!8X2?G2!7=!C7??212!

24.C3807/!0B!3UU=7\0Y382?H!R^SARgS!X7=4B!U2=!Y0/.82!Z'3H?7=L!-fT^[;!'90B!B.112B8B!8938!08!

B97.?4!83E2!<28X22/!Rf!3/4!`R!Y0/.82B!87!=234!892!*3Y2b=7U!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!ZQLfQQ!

X7=4B[;!'92!3C8.3?!80Y2!BU2/8!=2340/1!=3/124!@=7Y!R;fT!B2C7/4B!87!RRRS;TQ!B2C7/4B!Z`Q!

Y0/.82B[L!X089!3!Y2403/!7@!-`;TS!B2C7/4B!!Z8%]!Q`;QRL!AC!]!R`Q;RT[;!:B!/7824!0/!e01.=2!RL!

gSc!7@!U3=80C0U3/8B!BU2/8!?2BB!893/!7/2!Y0/.82!=2340/1!892!*3Y2b=7U!U=0G3CH!U7?0CHL!X089!

3/!3440807/3?!-_c!U2=C2/8!=2340/1!@7=!?2BB!893/!@0G2!Y0/.82B;!

'92!*3Y2b=7U!')&!X3B!_L`-T!X7=4BL!B.112B80/1!08!B97.?4!83E2!-^!87!-Q!Y0/.82B;!

P3=80C0U3/8B!=234!<28X22/!`;_g!B2C7/4B!87!TTff;`^!B2C7/4B!38!Y7B8!Z---!Y0/.82B[!X089!3!

Y2403/!7@!-_;S_!B2C7/4B!Z8!]!^-;-R!B2C7/4BL!AC!]!RfQ;f`[;!&0Y0?3=!87!892!U=0G3CH!U7?0CHL!

gTc!7@!U3=80C0U3/8B!BU2/8!?2BB!893/!7/2!Y0/.82!=2340/1!892!')&L!X089!3/!3440807/3?!--c!

BU2/40/1!?2BB!893/!@0G2!Y0/.82B!Ze01.=2!R[;!#/!B.YL!fTc!7@!U3=80C0U3/8B!BU2/8!?2BB!893/!^!

Y0/.82B!7/!892!*3Y2b=7U!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!3/4!fQc!BU2/8!?2BB!893/!^!Y0/.82B!7/!')&;!

Page 18: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! -Q!

!le01.=2!R!:<7.8!+2=2m!

$ !"#$HI+)3"2J$>*2D(#($&,$)"#$A26#?-+0$!#-6($+7$<#-1&3#$B+*&34$

! ,JR!X3B!3BB2BB24!<H!C740/1!7U2/A2/424!=2BU7/B2B!3<7.8!*3Y2b=7UWB!U=0G3CH!3/4!

')&!U7?0C02B!@7=!3/H!Y2/807/!7@!892!i178C93j!C?3.B2B;!'92B2!=2BU7/B2B!=2G23?24!8938!a.B8!g`!

U3=80C0U3/8B!Z-^c[!934!C7/C2=/B!3<7.8!892!U7?0C02B;!)@!897B2L!/0/2!Z-;Qc!7@!897B2!

B.=G2H24[!Y2/807/24!892!C90?4!3BB01/Y2/8!C?3.B2!3/4!--!ZRc[!Y2/807/24!C7/C2=/B!X089!

4383!B93=0/1I!97X2G2=L!7/?H!7/2!7@!892!--!Y2/807/24!892!*&:;!'92!=2Y30/42=!7@!892!

C7YY2/8B!423?8!X089!3!G3=028H!7@!C7/C2=/B!0/C?.40/1!892!?2/189!7@!892!U7?0C02BL!3/4!892!

8=.B8X7=890/2BB!7@!892!&*&;!

! b2BU082!892B2!C7/C2=/BL!3/4!892!@0/40/1!8938!U7?0CHA=2340/1!80Y2B!X2=2!X2??!<2?7X!

892!2\U2C824!3G2=312L!-SSc!7@!U3=80C0U3/8B!31=224!87!<789!U7?0C02B;!

<#3)&+,$F.$<#*7G=#0+-)$=#25&,'$+7$=#2*$<A<$B-&1234$2,5$!@<$B+*&3&#($

! ,J`!X3B!344=2BB24!<H!3G2=310/1!=2U7=824!80Y2!BU2/8!=2340/1!892!')&!3/4!U=0G3CH!

U7?0C02B!@7=!G3=07.B!B2=G0C2B!X92/!U3=80C0U3/8B!B01/!.U!3/4!X92/!U7?0C02B!C93/12;!'90=8HA

/0/2!U2=C2/8!7@!U3=80C0U3/8B!B83824!892H!/2G2=!=234!')&!31=22Y2/8B!@7=!3/H!B2=G0C2B!X92/!

B01/0/1!.U;!e7=!23C9!10G2/!B2=G0C2L!^RAT^!U2=C2/8!B83824!8938!892H!01/7=2!892!')&!

C7YU?282?H!ZBU2/4!h2=7!Y0/.82B!=2340/1!08[!X92/!B01/0/1!.U;!e7=!897B2!8938!47!=234!

U7?0C02BL!=2U7=824!80Y2!BU2/8!=3/124!@=7Y!-!Y0/.82!87!_`!Y0/.82B!Z8!]!_;TgL!M2403/!]!

R;SS[;!

! ,2340/1!80Y2B!@7=!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!B97X24!3!B0Y0?3=!U3882=/;!'90=8HA@0G2!U2=C2/8!7@!

U3=80C0U3/8B!3CE/7X?24124!/78!=2340/1!892!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!@7=!3/H!B2=G0C2B!X92/!B01/0/1!.U;!

e7=!3/H!10G2/!B2=G0C2L!_RATQ!U2=C2/8!01/7=24!892!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!X92/!B01/0/1!.U;!,2U7=824!

Page 19: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! -g!

80Y2!BU2/8!=2340/1!=3/124!@=7Y!-!Y0/.82!87!TS!Y0/.82B!Z8!]!_;f-L!M2403/!]!R;`^[;!,2340/1!

U3882=/B!X92/!')&!3/4!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!C93/12!X2=2!B0Y0?3=;!$

$ K"2)$B-#5&3)($!&6#$<0#,)$=#25&,'$B+*&3&#(!

! '92!@3C87=!3/3?HB0B!=2G23?24!89=22!38808.42!@3C87=B;!'92!@0=B8L!./-,+0'1(,/%,9$+),'=!

Z-S!082YBL!v!]!;fS[L!C7/830/24!082YB!3<7.8!U3=80C0U3/8B!U2=C20G0/1!')&!3/4!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!

3B!<20/1!877!?7/1L!877!/.Y2=7.BL!3/4!83E0/1!.U!877!Y.C9!80Y2;!'92!B2C7/4!@3C87=L!!,1#(/>%

1,%#(=$!Zg!082YBL!v!]!;gQ[L!4=3X0/1!7/!&7?7G2!ZRSSQ[!2\U=2BB24!892!0423!8938!892!0/40G04.3?!

0/!d.2B807/!U2=C20G2B!8938!U7?0C02B!3=2!0==2?2G3/8!<2C3.B2!892!0/40G04.3?!0B!470/1!/7890/1!

X=7/1L!C7YU3/02B!X0??!/78!<7892=!892YL!3/4!7/?H!897B2!X97!3=2!<=23E0/1!892!=.?2B!3=2!

3@@2C824;!'92!890=4!@3C87=L!C(--(3*)1%1,%*/=$+51'/=!Z^!082YBL!v!]!;g^[L!0/40C3824!8938!

0/40G04.3?B!U2=C20G2!8938!892H!3=2!./3<?2!87!./42=B83/4!892!?3/1.312!0/!')&!3/4!U=0G3CH!

U7?0C02B!ZB22!'3<?2!-[;!

l!'3<?2!-!:<7.8!+2=2!m!

! '7!3/BX2=!,J_L!892B2!@3C87=B!X2=2!2/82=24!0/87!3!902=3=C90C3?!=21=2BB07/!Y742?!@7=!

892!@7.=!7.8C7Y2B5!3G2=312!80Y2!BU2/8!=2340/1!')&!3/4!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!X92/!B01/0/1!.U!

@7=!3!B2=G0C2!3/4!X92/!892!')&!3/4!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!C93/12;!'92!Y742?B!0/C?.424!312!3/4!

12/42=!3B!C7/8=7?!G3=03<?2B!0/!<?7CE!-L!=2U7=824!')&!3/4!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!=2340/1!<293G07=!0/!

<?7CE!RL!3/4!892!89=22!38808.42!@3C87=B!0/!<?7CE!`;!&22!@0/3?!Y742?B!0/!'3<?2!R;!

l!'3<?2!R!:<7.8!+2=2!m!

! )@!892!89=22!@3C87=BL!#/@7=Y3807/!7G2=?734!X3B!3!B01/0@0C3/8!/21380G2!U=240C87=!7@!

=2340/1!')&!X92/!B01/0/1!.UL!J!]!A;-QL!4%x!;S-L!3/4!7@!=2340/1!')&!X92/!892H!C93/12L!J!]!A

;R_L!4%x!;SS-;!e7=!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02BL!0/@7=Y3807/!7G2=?734!X3B!3!B01/0@0C3/8!/21380G2!U=240C87=!

7@!=2340/1!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!X92/!892H!C93/12L!J!]!A;RRL!4!x!;SS-L!<.8!/78!X92/!B01/0/1!.U!@7=!

Page 20: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! -f!

3!/2X!B2=G0C2L!J!]!A;S^L!4%]!;`g;!'92!Y7=2!0/40G04.3?B!2\U2=02/C2!0/@7=Y3807/!7G2=?734!

=213=40/1!')&L!3/4!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!X92/!892H!C93/12L!892!?2BB!80Y2!892H!BU2/8!3C8.3??H!

=2340/1!892B2!U7?0C02B;!+7X2G2=L!U3=80C0U3/8BW!38808.42B!8938!892H!93G2!/7890/1!87!9042!3/4!

8938!U7?0C02B!3=2!40@@0C.?8!87!./42=B83/4!404!/78!U=240C8!=2340/1!<293G07=!@7=!')&!7=!U=0G3CH!

U7?0C02B;!'938!0BL!X90?2!0/40G04.3?B!Y3H!97?4!892B2!<2?02@BL!892H!93G2!/7!2@@2C8!7/!3C8.3?!

=2340/1!<293G07=;!

?&(3D((&+,$

! '92!=2B.?8B!7@!890B!B8.4H!B.112B8!8938!0/40G04.3?B!7@82/!01/7=2!U=0G3CH!3/4!82=YB!7@!

B2=G0C2!U7?0C02B!@7=!B7C03?!/28X7=E0/1!B2=G0C2B;!'90B!<293G07=!3UU23=B!87!<2!C7YY7/!<789!

X92/!B01/0/1!.U!87!/2X!B2=G0C2B!3/4!X92/!U7?0C02B!C93/12!@7=!B2=G0C2B!0/40G04.3?B!3=2!

3?=234H!.B0/1;!N92/!U27U?2!47!=234!U7?0C02BL!892H!7@82/!=2Y30/!7/!892!=2?2G3/8!U312B!a.B8!

?7/1!2/7.19!87!BC=7??!87!892!i3CC2U8j!<.887/L!3/4!0/!892!@2X!0/B83/C2B!X92=2!42830?24!

=2340/1!83E2B!U?3C2L!3?Y7B8!3??!U3=80C0U3/8B!42Y7/B8=382!=2340/1!80Y2B!@3=!<2?7X!892!

3G2=312!=2340/1!80Y2!/22424;!#8!B97.?4!<2!E2U8!0/!Y0/4!8938!892!U3=80C0U3/8B!42BC=0<24!

92=20/!3=2!C7YY./0C3807/!B8.42/8B!X97!B8.4H!U=0G3CHL!B.=G20??3/C2!3/4!"01!b383!0BB.2B!0/!

C?3BB;!#@!C7YY./0C3807/!BC97?3=BA0/A8=30/0/1!C3//78!<2!<7892=24!87!=234!&*&!U7?0C02BL!?28!

3?7/2!42Y7/B8=382!C7/C2=/!3<7.8!892!0YU?0C3807/B!7@!01/7=0/1!/780C2!7UU7=8./0802BL!08!

B22YB!?0E2?H!8938!892!12/2=3?!U.<?0C!X7.?4!C7YY7/?H!01/7=2!U7?0C02B!3B!X2??;!P2=93UB!892=2!

0B!B7Y2!8=.89!87!892!i<0112B8!?02!7/!892!0/82=/28j!3/2C4782;!

! '90B!B8.4H!C7/8=0<.82B!3!./0d.2!2YU0=0C3?!3BB2BBY2/8!7@!0/40G04.3?B!0/82=3C80/1!X089!

892!U=0G3CH!3/4!')&!U7?0C02B!7@!X938!892H!<2?02G2!87!<2!3!=23?!&*&;!*7/2!7@!892!U3=80C0U3/8B!

934!923=4!7@!892!B2=G0C2!<2@7=2L!3/4!/7/2!934!3/H!@=02/4B!7=!@3Y0?H!Y2Y<2=B!87!G7.C9!@7=!

08B!d.3?08H;!:??!U3=80C0U3/8B!X2=2!87?4!X3B!8938!8920=!./0G2=B08H!934!2/82=24!0/87!3/!

Page 21: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! RS!

31=22Y2/8!X089!3!B83=8.U!8938!X3B!0/82=2B824!0/!93G0/1!892!B082!82B824;!'92!7/?H!3440807/3?!

0/@7=Y3807/!3<7.8!892!B2=G0C2!U=7G0424!X3B!3/!0Y312!7@!892!B2=G0C2WB!97Y2U312!3/4!8938!

892HW4!93G2!892!7U807/!7@!42?280/1!8920=!U=7@0?2!3@82=!C7YU?280/1!892!2G3?.3807/;!:8!/7!U70/8!

X3B!08!C7YY./0C3824!8938!4383!C7??2C824!X3B!87!<2!42?2824L!3/!0YU7=83/8!/.3/C2!87!892!4383!

U=0G3CH!42<382!2BU7.B24!<H!U=0G3CH!34G7C382B!ZP044L!RS--[;!%G2/!X089!/7!=23B7/!87!8=.B8!

892!/2X!B2=G0C2L!<2H7/4!U2=93UB!3BB.YU807/B!3<7.8!892!./0G2=B08HWB!G2880/1!7@!892!B83=8.UL!

7=!892!U2=C2U807/!2\U=2BB24!<H!B7Y2!U3=80C0U3/8B!8938!3??!&*&!3=2!892!B3Y2L!Y7B8!7@!892!

U3=80C0U3/8B!31=224!87!*3Y2b=7UWB!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!X0897.8!2G2/!?77E0/1!38!08;!)@!892!^_`!

0/40G04.3?B!B.=G2H24L!Q_!U2=C2/8!3CC2U824!892!U7?0CH!G03!892!d.0CEAa70/!7U807/!X90C9!

3??7X24!U3=80C0U3/8B!87!<HAU3BB!892!U=0G3CH!U7?0CH!X0897.8!2G2/!=2d.0=0/1!3!1?0YUB2;!

J.3?08380G2!=2BU7/B2B!B.112B8!8938!Qg!U2=C2/8!7@!0/40G04.3?B!7@82/!.B2!892!d.0CEAa70/!7U807/!

3/4!Y7=2!893/!fS!U2=C2/8!.B2!08!7@82/!7=!B7Y280Y2B;!

! %G2/!X92/!U3=80C0U3/8B!47!/78!01/7=2!U7?0C02BL!892!G3B8!Y3a7=08H!<3=2?H!BU2/4B!3/H!

80Y2!=2340/1!892Y;!M7B8!3UU23=!87!83E2!3!d.0CE!?77E!3/4!892/!B0YU?H!BC=7??!87!892!<7887Y!

3/4!C?0CE!i3CC2U8;j!'92!*3Y2b=7U!U=0G3CH!U7?0CHL!X90C9!0B!892!B3Y2!?2/189!3B!(0/E240/WB!

U7?0CHL!B97.?4!93G2!83E2/!Y7=2!893/!93?@!3/!97.=!87!=234I!892!')&L!Y7=2!893/!-^!Y0/.82B;!

&7Y2!2/1310/1!X089!*3Y2b=7UWB!U=0G3CH!3/4!')&!U7?0C02B!BU2/8!8X7!3/4!89=22!B2C7/4B!7/!

892!U7?0C02BL!=2BU2C80G2?H;!'92!3G2=312!=2340/1!80Y2!3C=7BB!U3=80C0U3/8B!@7=!892!U=0G3CH!

U7?0CH!X3B!Q_!B2C7/4BL!3/4!^-!B2C7/4B!@7=!892!')&;!'97.19!892B2!3G2=312B!42Y7/B8=382!

=2340/1!80Y2B!X2??!<2?7X!892!80Y2!=2d.0=24L!892!3G2=312B!X2=2!BE2X24!<H!3!@2X!7.8?02=B;!

'92!Y2403/!@7=!<789!U=0G3CH!3/4!')&!U7?0C02B!0B!3!Y7=2!3CC.=382!=2U=2B2/83807/!7@!892!

12/2=3?!8=2/4L!38!3UU=7\0Y382?H!-_!B2C7/4B!@7=!<789;!e7.=822/!B2C7/4B!0B!93=4?H!2/7.19!

80Y2!87!=234L!./42=B83/4!3/4!U=7G042!0/@7=Y24!C7/B2/8!87!U7?0C02B!<28X22/!_LSSS!3/4!

Page 22: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! R-!

gLSSS!X7=4B!0/!?2/189;!&U2/40/1!-_!B2C7/4B!Z7=!TS!B2C7/4B!@7=!8938!Y3882=[!0B!3E0/!87!/78!

=2340/1!892!U7?0C02B!38!3??;!&304!3/7892=!X3HL!7@!897B2!8938!=234!892!U=0G3CH!U7?0CHL!gSc!

BU2/8!?2BB!893/!3!Y0/.82!=2340/1L!3/4!f_c!?2BB!893/!@0G2!Y0/.82B;!%0198HAB0\!U2=C2/8!7@!

U3=80C0U3/8B!BU2/8!?2BB!893/!3!Y0/.82!=2340/1!892!')&L!fQc!?2BB!893/!@0G2!Y0/.82B;!!

! '7!3!?2BB2=!421=22L!<.8!B80??!C7/B0B82/8!X089!892!*3Y2b=7U!3/3?HB0BL!892!B2?@A=2U7=8!

Y23B.=2B!=2G23?24!B0Y0?3=!@0/40/1B;!N92/!3BE24!3<7.8!2/1310/1!X089!U7?0C02B!@7=!e3C2<77EL!

'X0882=L!#/B831=3YL!&EHU2L!&/3UK938L!D0E!D3EL!u<7\!(0G2L!0P97/2!M2BB2/12=L!$Y30?!3/4!

0'./2BL!`^A`f!U2=C2/8!B304!892H!01/7=2!U7?0C02B;!)@!897B2!8938!=234L!892!3G2=312!80Y2!

=2U7=824!X3B!3<7.8!@0G2!Y0/.82BL!X089!892!Y2403/!3UU=7\0Y382?H!8X7!Y0/.82B;!'97.19!

0'./2B!0B!/78!3/!&*&!38!892!Y7Y2/8L!08!X3B!=2G23?0/1!87!B22!8938!892!82/42/CH!87!01/7=2!

U7?0C02B!172B!<2H7/4!&*&!2/1312Y2/8!3/4!0/C?.42B!7892=!401083?!Y2403!B2=G0C2B;!'90B!

B.112B8B!3130/!8938L!3B!7/2!U3=80C0U3/8!/7824L!i08!@22?B!?0E2!3!C.?8.=3?!/7=Y!/78!87!=234!

ZU7?0C02B[;j!!

!"#$B-&1234$B2-25+L$

! N90?2!3?Y7B8!3??!U3=80C0U3/8B!42Y7/B8=3824!8938!892H!20892=!01/7=2!7=!U3H!

0/B.@@0C02/8!3882/807/!87!892!U7?0C02BL!892!B?0198!40@@2=2/C2B!0/!=2340/1!80Y2!<28X22/!892!

*3Y2b=7U!3/3?HB0B!3/4!892!B2?@A=2U7=8!3/3?HB0B!47!90/8!38!892!U=0G3CH!U3=347\;!'92!

U3=347\!B.112B8B!8938!X92/!3BE24L!0/40G04.3?B!3UU23=!87!G3?.2!U=0G3CHL!<.8!X92/!<293G07=B!

3=2!2\3Y0/24L!0/40G04.3?!3C807/B!B.112B8!8938!U=0G3CH!0B!/78!3!9019!U=07=08H!Z*7=<2=1L!RSSQI!

*0BB2/<3.YL!RSSf[;!'7!3!BY3??!421=22L!890B!0B!X938!X3B!=2G23?24!<H!892!3/3?HB0B;!N92/!

U3=80C0U3/8B!X2=2!3BE24!87!B2?@A=2U7=8!8920=!2/1312Y2/8!X089!U=0G3CH!3/4!')&!U7?0C02BL!

=2B.?8B!B.112B824!3G2=312!=2340/1!80Y2B!7@!3UU=7\0Y382?H!@0G2!Y0/.82B;!'92!*3Y2b=7U!

3/3?HB0BL!X90C9!82B824!3C8.3?!2/1312Y2/8!X089!&*&!U7?0C02B!.U7/!B01/.U!=2G23?24!3G2=312!

Page 23: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! RR!

=2340/1!80Y2B!3=7./4!7/2!Y0/.82L!X089!Y2403/B!7@!-_!B2C7/4B;!'92!d.3?08380G2!B2C807/!

@.=892=!B.112B8B!X938!3C8.3?!U=0G3CH!<293G07=B!3=2!?0E2L!3B!fgc!7@!U3=80C0U3/8B!Y342!/7!

Y2/807/!7@!4383!B93=0/1!C7/C2=/BL!3/4!7/?H!7/2!U3=80C0U3/8!0/!892!2/80=2!B8.4H!Y2/807/24!

892!*&:;!#8!B97.?4!<2!/7824!8938!892!7/?H!*&:!Y2/807/!X3B!0/!=2BU7/B2!87!892!d.2B807/!

3<7.8!C7/C2=/B!3BB7C03824!X089!892!*3Y2b=7U!U7?0C02B;!'90B!Y23/B!8938!08!0B!?0E2?H!8938!892!

7/2!0/40G04.3?!X97!Y2/807/24!892!*&:!X3B!890/E0/1!3<7.8!892!*&:!<2C3.B2!892!V178C93!

C?3.B2W!0/!892!*3Y2b=7U!U7?0CH!X3B!/780C24;!'90B!0B!3/!0YU7=83/8!42830?!<2C3.B2!892!?0E2?H!

=23B7/!@7=!U=0G3CH!U3=347\!@0/40/1B!<210/B!X089!892!U7BB0<0?08H!8938!0/40G04.3?B!2\U=2BB!

U=0G3CH!C7/C2=/B!X92/!=2B23=C92=B!Y3E2!U3=80C0U3/8B!3X3=2!7@!890/1B!?0E2!4383!B93=0/1L!892!

*&:L!28C;!N92/!=2B23=C92=B!3=2!/78!U3=8!7@!892!&*&!2\U2=02/C2L!.B2=B!3=2!/78!3B!?0E2?H!87!<2!

890/E0/1!3<7.8!U=0G3CH!7=!4383!B93=0/1!C7/C2=/[email protected]/1!7/!X938!892H!X2/8!

7/?0/2!87!@0/4L!&*&!3@@7=43/C2B;!

BD-(D&,'$)"#$M,5($+7$?&'&)2*$B-+5D3)&+,$K&)"+D)$;#&,'$/,"&%&)#5$%4$)"#$C#2,($

! #8!0B!0YU7=83/8!87!C7/B042=!U=0G3CH!U3=347\!@0/40/1B!0/!C7Y<0/3807/!X089!892!

38808.40/3?!3/4!d.3?08380G2!3/3?HB2B;!"789!3/3?HB2B!B.112B8!3!B0Y0?3=!@0/40/1L!8938!892!

Y3a7=08H!7@!U3=80C0U3/8B!B22!/780C2!C7YU7/2/8B!3B!/7890/1!Y7=2!893/!3/!./X3/824!

0YU240Y2/8!87!892!=23?!U.=U7B2!.B2=B!17!7/?0/2!o!892!42B0=2!87!2/a7H!892!2/4B!7@!401083?!

U=74.C807/!Z0;2;!3CC2BB0/1!&*&[;!'92!7/?H!U=240C87=!@7./4!X3B!3!C7/C2=/!7G2=!0/@7=Y3807/!

7G2=?734L!X90C9!0/C?.424!C7/C2=/B!B.C9!3B!iP=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!3=2!877!?7/1Lj!i'92=2!3=2!877!

Y3/H!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!87!=234Lj!3/4!i#!47/w8!93G2!80Y2!87!=234!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!

@7=!2G2=H!B082!8938!#!G0B08;j!P=0G3CH!3/4!')&!U7?0C02B!X2=2!B22/!3B!Y7=2!7@!3!/.0B3/C2!893/!

3/H890/1!2?B2;!

Page 24: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! R`!

! '92!d.3?08380G2!3BB2BBY2/8!=20/@7=C24!890B!@0/40/1;!N90?2!3!BY3??!Y0/7=08H!7@!

U3=80C0U3/8B!404!2\U=2BB!U=0G3CH!C7/C2=/BL!892!G3B8!Y3a7=08H!U=30B24!d.0CEAa70/!7U807/B!@7=!

92?U0/1!892Y!<HAU3BB!/780C2!C7YU7/2/8B;!#8WB!/78!a.B8!8938!U=0G3CH!3/4!')&!U7?0C02B!3=2!

U2=C20G24!3B!<7=0/1!7=!2G2/!U70/8?2BBL!08WB!8938!.B2=B!3=2!170/1!7/?0/2!3/4!2/1310/1!X089!

&*&!87!C7YU?282!3!?0B8!7@!42B0=24!83BEBL!/3Y2?HL!2/1310/1!X089!@=02/4B!3/4!@3Y0?H!7/?0/2L!3/4!

3??!7@!892!7892=!3@@7=43/C2B!7@@2=24!<H!&*&;!:B!7/2!U3=80C0U3/8!/7824L!iYH!@=02/4B!.B2!890B!

B7C03?!Y2403!0/!742=!ZB0C[!87!C38C9!.U!X089!8920=!?0@2!0!ZB0C[!B01/.U!@7=!890B!3B!d.0CE!3B!

U7BB0<?2j!X90?2!3/7892=!B304!i08B!3!93BB?2!87!423?!X089!3!Y3BB0G2!3Y7./8!7@!<7=0/1!U312B!

3<7.8!U=0G3CH!3/4!B2C.=08H!X92/!892!B082!H7.!3=2!a70/0/1!0B!892=2!87!47!B7Y2890/1!Y.C9!

Y7=2!0/82=2B80/1;j!

! #8!0B!C?23=!8938!12880/1!0/87!3!?213?!40BC.BB07/!3<7.8!4383!B93=0/1L!892!*&:!3/4!U=0G3CH!

0/!12/2=3?!0B!@3=!@=7Y!892!=23B7/!8938!0/40G04.3?B!C977B2!87!17!7/?0/2;!&7?7G2!ZRS-R[!

U=7U2=?H!3/3?710h2B!2/1312Y2/8!X089!U7?0C02B!87!892!U=7C2BB!7@!B8.42/8B!=2C20G0/1!

97Y2X7=E;!'92!C7/82\8!&7?7G2!=2@2=B!87!0B!892!C7/C2=/!3<7.8!Y.?80U?2!823C92=B!3BB01/0/1!

877!Y.C9!=2340/1L!C=2380/1!3!C93??2/10/1!BC2/3=07!@7=!U=7G040/1!C7/B2/8;!N90?2!890B!3/3?71H!

C7==2C8?H!42BC=0<2B!7/2!7@!892!U=7<?2YB!3BB7C03824!X089!3C902G0/1!4383!U=0G3CH!B2?@A

Y3/312Y2/8!3C=7BB!3??!2/80802B!0/G7?G24!0/!4383!Y3/312Y2/8L!892!3/3?71H!9019?0198B!3!

U70/8!Y7=2!=2?2G3/8!87!892!C.==2/8!3/3?HB0B;!FB2=B!3=2/W8!?77E0/1!@7=!97Y2X7=E!X92/!892H!

17!7/?0/2L!d.082!892!C7/8=3=HL!08!0B!?0E2?H!8938!Y3/H!.B2=B!3=2!?77E0/1!@7=!3/!2BC3U2!@=7Y!

8920=!97Y2X7=E!X92/!3CC2BB0/1!&*&;!FB2=B!X3/8!87!2/1312!X089!892!2/4B!7@!401083?!

U=74.C807/L!X0897.8!<20/1!0/90<0824!<H!3/!24.C3807/!7=!3!40BC.BB07/!3<7.8!892!Y23/B;!

! '92!/21380G2!0YU?0C3807/B!7@!890B!<293G07=!X2=2!B.112B824!<H!892!V178C93!C?3.B2W!

3/3?HB0B;!#/B8234!7@!/780C2!C7YU7/2/8B!92?U0/1!.B2=B!C7/8=7?!8920=!401083?!42B80/02B!3/4!

Page 25: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! R_!

C7==2BU7/40/1!C7/B2d.2/C2B!0/!<789!7/?0/2!3/4!7@@?0/2!C7/82\8BL!892!G3B8!Y3a7=08H!7@!

U3=80C0U3/8B!C7YU?282?H!Y0BB24!3!G3=028H!7@!U782/803??H!43/12=7.B!3/4!?0@2AC93/10/1!

C?3.B2B;!:B!/7824!0/!892!@0=B8!178C93!C?3.B2L!4383!C7.?4!<2!B93=24!iX089!17G2=/Y2/8!

312/C02BL!0/C?.40/1!892!F;&;!*3807/3?!&2C.=08H!:12/CHL!3/4!7892=!B2C.=08H!312/C02B!0/!892!

F/0824!&8382B!3/4!3<=734;j!e.=892=Y7=2L!4383!C7.?4!<2!B93=24!iX089!890=4!U3=802B!0/G7?G24!

0/!892!42G2?7UY2/8!7@!4383!U=74.C8B!42B01/24!87!3BB2BB!2?010<0?08H;!'90B!C7.?4!0YU3C8!

2?010<0?08H!0/!892!@7??7X0/1!3=23B5!2YU?7HY2/8L!@0/3/C03?!B2=G0C2!Z<3/E!?73/BL!0/B.=3/C2L!

28C;[L!./0G2=B08H!2/8=3/C2L!0/82=/3807/3?!8=3G2?L!892!C=0Y0/3?!a.B80C2!BHB82Y;j!'92B2!4383!

B93=0/1!U7BB0<0?0802B!3=2!=23?L!3/4!=30B2!3!97B8!7@!2\U3/40/1!C7/C2=/B!3BB7C03824!X089!4383!

C7??2C807/!3/4!.B2!ZB225!P3Bd.3?2L!RS-^[;!*78!C3=0/1!3<7.8!/780C2!0B!=2?2G3/8!87!&7?7G2WB!

ZRSSQ[!C=080d.2!7@!892!i#WG2!178!/7890/1!87!9042j!3=1.Y2/8;!:!C7YY7/!a.B80@0C3807/!@7=!

U=0G3CH!40B0/82=2B8L!890B!@3??3CH!0/C7==2C8?H!3BB.Y2BL!3B!7/2!U3=80C0U3/8!0/!890B!B8.4H!/7824!

X92/!a.B80@H0/1!d.0CEAa70/!.B2L!i*7890/1!877!<34!93UU2/24!H28L!<.8!08wB!/78!?0E2!#!U7B8!

3/H890/1!0/82=2B80/1!7=!X7=89H;j!"H!40BY0BB0/1!=2BU7/B0<0?08H!0/!7=42=!87!128!87!892!

2/a7HY2/8!7@!&*&L!897B2!X97!42Y7/B8=382!&7?7G2WB!@3??3CH!01/7=2!U7BB0<?2!0YU?0C3807/B!8938!

892H!Y0198!/78!2G2/!<2!3X3=2!7@;!:B!&7?7G2!/782BL!

08!0B!93=4!87!C?30Y!8938!U=71=3YB!?0E2!892!*&:!4383!Y0/0/1!U=71=3Y!X0??!/78!=2G23?!

0/@7=Y3807/!U27U?2!Y0198!X3/8!87!9042L!3B!X2!47!/78!E/7X!U=2C0B2?H!X938!0B!

=2G23?24;!lpm!4383!Y0/0/1!30YB!87!<2!U=240C80G2!7@!<293G07=L!B8=0G0/1!87!

U=71/7B80C382!3<[email protected].=2!3C807/B;!P27U?2!X97!Y38C9!C2=830/!U=7@0?2B!3=2!

422Y24!?0E2?H!87!2/1312!0/!3!B0Y0?3=!U3882=/!7@!<293G07=;!#8!0B!d.082!40@@[email protected]!

3C807/B!8938!7/2!93B!/78!H28!47/2;!+3G0/1!/7890/1!87!9042!X0??!/78!3?X3HB!40BU2?!

U=240C807/B!7@[email protected].=2!3C80G08H;!ZU;!QTT[!

Page 26: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! R^!

! *78!7/[email protected].=2!<293G07=!40@@[email protected].=2!.B2B!3/4!

C7/C2=/B!3BB7C03824!X089!892!"01!b383!0/4.B8=H;!'90B!0B!U=2C0B2?H!892!=23B7/!X2!0/C?.424!892!

C90?4!3BB01/Y2/8!C?3.B2!0/!890B!B8.4HL!X90C9!Y7=2!893/!fgc!7@!U3=80C0U3/8B!31=224!87!

X0897.8!2\U=2BB0/1!C7/C2=/;!N938!C7.?4!<2!X7=B2!893/!3!C7=U7=3807/!83E0/1!H7.=!C90?4!

3X3H!0/!U3HY2/8!@7=!.B2!7@!8920=!B2=G0C2Bs!"20/1!01/7=3/8!7=!=2B01/24!87!892!8=342A7@@B!

3BB7C03824!X089!401083?!Y2403!.B312!ZB225!'.=7X!28!3?L!RS-^[!0B!./3CC2U83<?2!0@!X2!3=2!87!

U=782C8!7.=B2?G2B!@=7Y!U782/803?!0YU?0C3807/B!/7X!3/4!0/[email protected].=2;!

! '92!U7?0CH!0YU?0C3807/B!7@!892B2!@0/40/1B!C7/8=0<.82!87!892!C7YY./08H!7@!C=080d.2!

B.112B80/1!8938!/780C2!3/4!C970C2!U7?0CH!0B!422U?H!@?3X24L!0@!/78!3/!3<B7?.82!@30?.=2!Z)<3=L!

RS-^I!,2042/<2=1!28!3?L!RS-^[;!'=3/BU3=2/CH!0B!3!1=238!U?3C2!87!B83=8L!3B!0B!/780C2!3/4!C970C2!

U7?0CHI!97X2G2=L!3??!3=2!82==0<?2!U?3C2B!87!@0/0B9;!'92H!?23G2!401083?!C080h2/B!X089!/7890/1!

Y7=2!893/!3/!2YU8H!U=7Y0B2!7@!U=782C807/L!3/!0YU=3C80C3?!7UU7=8./08H!@7=!4383!U=0G3CH!

B2?@AY3/312Y2/8L!3/4!3B!b3/02?!&7?7G2!ZRS-R[!3/3?710h2BL!877!Y.C9!97Y2X7=E;!'90B!

472B/W8!2G2/!<210/!87!344=2BB!892!C93??2/12B!./0d.2!87!C90?4=2/!0/!892!=23?Y!7@!401083?!

=2U.83807/L!3B!0@!892=2!0B!?088?2!97U2!@7=!34.?8BL!X938!C93/C2!0B!892=2!@7=!C90?4=2/!87!U=782C8!

892YB2?G2Bs!M7=2!/224B!87!<2!47/2!87!40BC7G2=!U=31Y380C!3?82=/380G2B!8938!U=74.C2!

U=0G3CH!3/4!=2U.83807/!42?0G2=3<?2B!ZB225!)<3=L!RS-^[;!#@!17G2=/Y2/8B!C7/80/.2!87!C?0/1!87!

=7Y3/80C!0423?B!3/4!@3??3CHL!892!0/82=/28WB!<0112B8!?02!X0??!B.=2?H!Y7G2!@=7Y!3/2C4782!87!

?03<0?08H;!

K+-9($>&)#5$

"7X?2BL!*L!+3Y0?87/L!6'!3/4!(2GHL!b!Z24B[!ZRS-`[!"+'/54'+$/3:%(/%4,)(1(35%'/=%1#$%0$=('K%

'33,*/1'B()(1:%'/=%,4$/%>,9$+/0$/1;!(7/47/5!#"!'3.=0B;!

Page 27: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! RT!

K382L!e+!ZRSST[!'92!@30?.=2!7@!@30=!0/@7=Y3807/!U=3C80C2!U=0/C0U?2B;!#/5!N0//L!6O!Z24[!

;,/5*0$+%2+,1$31(,/%(/%1#$%L>$%,-%1#$%./-,+0'1(,/%M3,/,0:?!&.==2HL!FO5!:B91382!

P.<?0B90/1L!UU;!`_`A`Qf;!

K7YY7/!&2/B2!M2403!ZRS-S[!K7YY2/8!B.<Y08824!87!:!P=2?0Y0/3=H!e'K!&83@@!,2U7=8!7/!

P=782C80/1!K7/B.Y2=!P=0G3CH!0/!3/!%=3!)@!,3U04!K93/12L!e0?2!*7;!PSf^_-TL!C7YY2/8!

/.Y<2=!SS_^Q;!

b2*3=40BL!(!3/4!+3CE?L!:M!ZRS-^[!#/82=/28!17G2=/3/C2!<H!B7C03?!Y2403!U?38@7=YB;!

"$)$3,00*/(3'1(,/5%2,)(3:L!NOZf[5!QT-AQQS;!

b2U3=8Y2/8!7@!K7YY2=C2!ZRS-S[!K7YY2=C03?!4383!U=0G3CH!3/4!0//7G3807/!0/!892!0/82=/28!

2C7/7YH5!:!4H/3Y0C!U7?0CH!@=3Y2X7=E;!,2U7=8!7@!'92!b2U3=8Y2/8!7@!K7YY2=C2!

#/82=/28!P7?0CH!'3BE!e7=C2;!

e242=3?!'=342!K7YY0BB07/!Z-ffg[!P=0G3CH!7/?0/25!:!=2U7=8!87!K7/1=2BB;!P'5#(/>1,/Q%C;Q%

H*/$5!-AQ-;!

e242=3?!'=342!K7YY0BB07/!ZRS-R[!P=782C80/1!C7/B.Y2=!U=0G3CH!0/!3/!2=3!7@!=3U04!C93/12;!

&";%+$4,+1;!

$=3Y<2=12=L!M!ZRSS-[!K080h2/B!3B!U3=8/2=B5!)%Kb!93/4<77E!7/!0/@7=Y3807/L!!C7/B.?83807/!

3/4!U.<?0C!U3=80C0U3807/!0/!U7?0CH!Y3E0/1;!)%Kb!,2U7=8;!

+7?B80L!),!Z-fTf[!;,/1$/1%L/'):5(5%-,+%1#$%A,3(')%A3($/3$5%'/=%R*0'/(1($5?%b7/!M0??BL!

! )/83=075!:440B7/AN2B?2H;!

(20<7X08hL!6!ZRSSQ[!A,%4+(9'1$Q%5,%4*B)(3K%./=(9(=*')5Q%1#$%(/1$+/$1%S%1#$%4'+'=,<%,-%B$#'9(,+')%

0'+F$1(/>;!,2Y3=4B!38!e'K!'7X/!+3??!M2280/1!7/!i%93G07=3?!:4G2=80B0/15!'=3CE0/1L!

'3=1280/1!y!'2C9/7?71Hj!*7G2Y<2=!-L!RSSQ;!

Page 28: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! RQ!

MCb7/3?4L!:M!3/4!K=3/7=L!(e!ZRSSg[!'92!C7B8!7@!=2340/1!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B;!.AHT2L!U5!^_SA

^T^;!

M340B7/L!6!Z-gRR[!%U0?71.25!&2C.=0/1!892!,2U.<?0C;!63Y2B!M340B7/!87!N;';!"2==HL!_!:.1!

-gRR;!

M0?/2L!$,!3/4!K.?/3/L!M6!ZRSS_[!&8=382102B!@7=!=24.C0/1!7/?0/2!U=0G3CH!=0BEB5!N9H!

C7/B.Y2=B!=234!Z7=!47/w8!=234[!7/?0/2!U=0G3CH!/780C2B;!H,*+/')%,-%./1$+'31(9$%

8'+F$1(/>L!VWZ`[5!-^ARf;!

M7=13/L!6!ZRS-_[;!P=0G3CH!0B!C7YU?282?H!3/4!.442=?H!4234L!3/4!X2!E0??24!08;!&,+B$5Q%f!!:.1;!

*0BB2/<3.YL!+!ZRSSf[!2+(9'3:%(/%3,/1$<1K%"$3#/,),>:Q%4,)(3:Q%'/=%1#$%(/1$>+(1:%,-%5,3(')%)(-$;!

,24X774!K08HL!K:5!&83/@7=4!F/0G2=B08H!P=2BB;!

*7=<2=1L!P:L!+7=/2L!b,!3/4!+7=/2L!b:!ZRSSQ[!'92!U=0G3CH!U3=347\5!P2=B7/3?!#/@7=Y3807/!

40BC?7B.=2!0/82/807/B!G2=B.B!<293G07=B;!H,*+/')%,-%;,/5*0$+%L--'(+5L!UVZ-[5!-SSA-RT;!

)<3=L!6:!ZRS-S[!C$0,3+'3:%,+%1$3#/,3+'3:X%L/%'/'):5(5%,-%4*B)(3%'/=%$<4$+1%4'+1(3(4'1(,/%(/%

&;;%4,)(3:0'F(/>!ZF/U.<?0B924!b7C87=3?!40BB2=83807/L!'92!P2//BH?G3/03!&8382!

F/0G2=B08H[;!

)<3=L!6:!ZRS-^[!"01!b383!3/4!'92!P93/87Y!P.<?0C5!N3?82=!(0UUY3//!3/4!892!@3??3CH!7@!4383!

U=0G3CH!B2?@AY3/312Y2/8;!Y(>%C'1'%S%A,3($1:L!ZZR[5!-A-T;!

)%Kb!Z-fgS[!)%Kb!$.042?0/2B!7/!892!P=782C807/!7@!P=0G3CH!3/4!'=3/B<7=42=!e?7XB!7@!

P2=B7/3?!b383;!,2C7YY2/43807/!7@!892!K7./C0?!C7/C2=/0/1!$.042?0/2B!!$7G2=/0/1!

892!P=782C807/!7@!P=0G3CH!3/4!'=3/B<7=42=!e?7XB!7@!P2=B7/3?!b383;!

)@@0C2!7@!892!P=0G3CH!K7YY0BB07/2=!7@!K3/343!ZRS-T[!:!40BC.BB07/!U3U2=!2\U?7=0/1!

U782/803?!2/93/C2Y2/8B!87!C7/B2/8!./42=!892!P2=B7/3?!#/@7=Y3807/!P=782C807/!3/4!

%?2C8=7/0C!b7C.Y2/8B!:C8;!

Page 29: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! Rg!

P3Bd.3?2L!e!ZRS-^[!"#$%Y)'3F%Y,<%A,3($1:K%"#$%A$3+$1%L)>,+(1#05%"#'1%;,/1+,)%8,/$:%% '/=%

./-,+0'1(,/;!K3Y<=0412L!M:5!+3=G3=4!F/0G2=B08H!P=2BB;!

P044L!+!ZRS--[!e3C2<77E!C7.?4!@3C2!-SSLSSS!@0/2!@7=!97?40/1!4383!8938!.B2=B!93G2!42?2824;!

"#$%[*'+=('/L!RS!)C8;!

,2042/<2=1L!6,L!,.BB2??L!*KL!K3??2/L!:6L!J3B0=L!&!3/4!*7=87/L!'"!ZRS-_[!P=0G3CH!93=YB!!3/4!

892!2@@2C80G2/2BB!7@!892!/780C2!3/4!C970C2!@=3Y2X7=E;!Z7VU%"2\;%;,/-$+$/3$%2'4$+;!

,2042/<2=1L!6,L!"=23.\L!'L!K=3/7=L!(eL!e=2/C9L!"L!$=3//0BL!:L!$=3G2BL!6'L!(0.L!eL!!MCb7/3?4L!:L!

*7=87/L!'"L!,3Y3/389L!,L!,.BB2??L!*KL!&3429L!*!3/4!&C93.<L!e!ZRS-^[!b0B31=223<?2!

U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B5!M0BY38C92B!<28X22/!Y23/0/1!3/4!.B2=Bw!./42=B83/40/1;!Y$+F$)$:%

"$3#/,),>:%T']%H,*+/')L!N7^V_K!`fATg;!

&3/42=BL!&b!ZRS--[!P=0G3CH!0B!42345!'92!<0=89!7@!B7C03?!Y2403!<3CE1=7./4!C92CEB;!A`T%\$9?L!

NOK%R_`ART_;!

&C9.4B7/L!M!ZRS-^[!"#$%\(5$%,-%1#$%\(>#1%1,%a/,]K%2,)(1(35%'/=%1#$%;*)1*+$%,-%"+'/54'+$/3:Q%

VOUbGVOcb;!K3Y<=0412L!M:5!+3=G3=4!F/0G2=B08H!P=2BB;!

&7?7G2L!b6!ZRSSQ[!w#wG2!178!/7890/1!87!9042w!3/4!7892=!Y0B./42=B83/40/1B!7@!U=0G3CH;!!A'/%

C($>,%)']%+$9($]L!UU5!Q_^AQQR;!

&7?7G2L!b6!ZRS-R[!#/8=74.C807/5!P=0G3CH!B2?@AY3/312Y2/8!3/4!892!C7/B2/8!40?2YY3;!

R'+9'+=%T']%\$9($]Q!VZ6L!-ggSA-fS`;!

'3H?7=L!&%!Z-fT^[!%H2!Y7G2Y2/8B!0/!=2340/15!e3C8B!3/4!@3??3C02B;!L0$+(3'/%M=*3'1(,/')%

\$5$'+3#%H,*+/')L!ZZ_[5!-gQARSR;!

',F&'2!ZRSST[!K7/B.Y2=B!93G2!@3?B2!B2/B2!7@!B2C.=08H!3<7.8!7/?0/2!U=0G3CH!o!3C807/B!

0/C7/B0B82/8!X089!38808.42B;!P,*2XBX0=2;!

Page 30: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! Rf!

'.=7XL!6L!+2//2BBHL!M!3/4!b=3U2=L!*!ZRS-^[!'92!'=342!)@@!e3??3CH5!+7X!Y3=E282=B!3=2!

Y0B=2U=2B2/80/1!:Y2=0C3/!C7/B.Y2=B!3/4!7U2/0/1!892Y!.U!87!!2\U?7083807/;!

F/0G2=B08H!7@!P2//BH?G3/03!=2U7=8;!!

N3?E2=L!6(!Z-fTT[!:!C=080d.2!7@!892!2?080B8!8927=H!7@!42Y7C=3CH;!L0$+(3'/%2,)(1(3')%A3($/3$%

\$9($]L!67ZR[5!Rg^ARf^;!

q71<H!#/82=/3807/3?!ZRS-S[!,2B.?8B!@=7Y!0/82=3C80G2!B.=G2H!7@!34.?8BL!0/C?.40/1!3!B.<B28!7@!

U3=2/8B!X089!C90?4=2/!312!-g!3/4!./42=;!K7YY2/8!87!:!P=2?0Y0/3=H!e'K!&83@@!,2U7=8!

7/!P=782C80/1!K7/B.Y2=!P=0G3CH!0/!3/!%=3!)@!,3U04!K93/12L!e0?2!*7;!PSf^_-TL!

C7YY2/8!/.Y<2=!SS_^Q;!

!! !

Page 31: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! `S!

!

!&(>*+$%V;!e=7/8!U312!7@[email protected]!&*&!V*3Y2b=7UW!!

Page 32: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! `-!

&(>*+$%Z;!'0Y2!BU2/8!=2340/1!*3Y2b=7U!P=0G3CH!P7?0CH!3/4!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2;!!'3<?2!-;!P7?0CH!38808.42B!@3C87=!3/3?HB0B!!! e3C87=B!3/4!082Y!?7340/1B!

#82YB!#/@7=Y3807/!7G2=?734!

*7890/1!87!9042!

b0@@0C.?8!87!./42=B83/4!

P=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!3=2!877!?7/1! NOEP$ ;Sf`! ;Sgg!

'92=2!3=2!877!Y3/H!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!87!=234! NOQF$ ;-_f! ;SgT!

'92=2!3=2!877!Y3/H!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!87!=234! NRSF$ ;Sf`! ;SgT!

'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!3=2!877!?7/1! NRFQ$ ;S_g! ;SQ`!

#!47/w8!93G2!80Y2!87!=234!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!@7=!2G2=H!B082!8938!#!G0B08! NTSQ$ ;RS`! ;-Qg!

#!47/w8!93G2!80Y2!87!=234!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!@7=!2G2=H!B082!8938!#!G0B08! NTQP$ ;-T-! ;-QQ!

#8!0B!/7=Y3?!87!B01/!.U!@7=!X2<B082Bk3UUB!X0897.8!=2340/1!892!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B! NUPS$ ;-_^! ;--S!

#8!0B!/7=Y3?!87!B01/!.U!@7=!X2<B082Bk3UUB!X0897.8!=2340/1!892!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B! NUUT$ ;-TS! ;-^`!

S;Sc!-S;Sc!RS;Sc!`S;Sc!_S;Sc!^S;Sc!TS;Sc!QS;Sc!gS;Sc!fS;Sc!

-SS;Sc!

-!Y0/.82!7=!?2BB! R!Y0/.82B! `!Y0/.82B! _!Y0/.82B! ^!Y0/.82B!7=!Y7=2!

'0Y2!BU2/8!=2340/1!*3Y2b=7U!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!3/4!P=0G3CH!P7?0CH!

P=0G3CH!P7?0CH! '2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!

Page 33: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! `R!

M7B8!U27U?2!47/W8!=234!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B! NUSP$ ;SgT! A;S^S!

M7B8!U27U?2!47/W8!=234!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B! NUFT$ ;--f! A;SRR!

M7B8!U27U?2!47/W8!./42=B83/4!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B! ;_^^! ;S-S! ;_Rg!

#!47/W8!93G2!80Y2!87!=234!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B! ;__^! ;R-f! ;-f^!

#!47/W8!93G2!80Y2!87!=234!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B! ;_RS! ;R-f! ;R_-!

#!3Y!/78!470/1!3/H890/1!X=7/1L!B7!X938!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!B3H!472B/W8!Y3882=! ;-Qf! NRRT$ A;SRf!

#!3Y!/78!470/1!3/H890/1!X=7/1L!B7!X938!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!B3H!472B/W8!Y3882=! ;R-Q! NREV$ A;S__!

'92!7/?H!.B2=B!B2=07.B?H!3@@2C824!<H!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!3=2!U27U?2!X97!<=23E!892!=.?2B! ;-^S! NTSV$ A;-_f!

K7YU3/02B!X0??!/2G2=!<7892=!H7.!X92892=!H7.!=234!8920=!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!7=!/78! ;--^! NTFT$ ;S_R!

K7YU3/02B!X0??!/2G2=!<7892=!H7.!X92892=!H7.!=234!8920=!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!7=!/78! ;-RQ! NUOE$ ;SSS!

'92!7/?H!.B2=B!B2=07.B?H!3@@2C824!<H!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!3=2!U27U?2!X97!<=23E!892!=.?2B! ;SfQ! NUSF$ A;R-^!

#wG2!178!/7890/1!87!9042!ZU=0G3CH!U7?0C02B[! ;RTf! NUER$ A;-TQ!

#wG2!178!/7890/1!87!9042!Z82=YB!7@!B2=G0C2[! ;R^S! NUQE$ A;-Qg!

K7YU3/02B!X0??!47!X938!892H!X3/8L!=213=4?2BB!7@!X92892=!#!=234!892!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B! ;SfT! ;_ff! ;-gg!

#8WB!0YU7=83/8!87!=234!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!87!3G704!8=7.<?2! A;SSQ! A;_g`! A;R^R!

#8WB!0YU7=83/8!87!=234!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!87!3G704!8=7.<?2! ;SfS! A;_g`! A;RQ^!

K7YU3/02B!X0??!47!X938!892H!X3/8L!=213=4?2BB!7@!X92892=!#!=234!892!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B! ;SfT! ;_RT! ;-Rf!

'92!?3/1.312!0/!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!0B!C?23=! A;-``! ;-RS! GNREE$

'92!?3/1.312!0/!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!0B!C?23=! A;-^R! ;-``! GNTPS$

P=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!3=2!40@@0C.?8!87!./42=B83/4! ;_S`! A;S_-! NURU$

Page 34: July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ......July 8, 2016 Federal Communications Commission ... Telecommunications Services,” WC Docket No. 16-106 To Whom It May Concern:

! ! "#$$%&'!(#%!)*!'+%!#*'%,*%'!

! ``!

'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!3=2!40@@0C.?8!87!./42=B83/4! ;_`Q! A;STf! NUSR$

M7B8!U27U?2!47/W8!./42=B83/4!U=0G3CH!U7?0C02B! ;_Rf! A;SS`! NUEE$

P=0G3CH!U7?0C02B!U=7G042!92?U@.?!0/@7=Y3807/! ;-SS! A;`^^! A;_^S!

'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!31=22Y2/8B!U=7G042!92?U@.?!0/@7=Y3807/! A;S`S! A;RQg! A;__S!

!'3<?2!R;!e0/3?!,21=2BB07/!M742?B!P=240C80/1!'0Y2!&U2/8!,2340/1!'2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2!3/4!P=0G3CH!P7?0C02B!.U7/!&01/.U!3/4!X92/!U7?0C02B!C93/12!!! '2=YB!7@!&2=G0C2! P=0G3CH!P7?0C02B!

! FU7/!B01/!.U! N92/!892H!C93/12! FU7/!B01/!.U! N92/!892H!C93/12!

% Y% AM%Y% J% Y% AM%Y% J% Y% AM%Y% J% Y% AM%Y% J%

:12! ;`f! ;-T! ;Sf>! A;SQ! ;-_! A;SR! A;Sf! ;-g! A;SR! A;RR! ;-T! A;ST!

$2/42=! ;-f! ;_Q! ;SR! A;S^! ;_R! A;S-! A;ST! ;^R! A;S-! A;_T! ;_T! A;S_!

')&!=2340/1! R;-_! ;`-! ;_S>>>! -;^Q! ;Rg! ;`Q>>>! -;TS! ;`_! ;Rf>>>! -;`T! ;`-! ;Rg>>>!

PP!=2340/1! ;R-! ;Rf! ;S_! ;Sf! ;RT! ;SR! -;-f! ;`R! ;R_>>>! ;TR! ;Rg! ;-_>!

#/@7=Y3807/!7G2=?734! A-;`^! ;_-! A;-Q>>>! A-;^_! ;`T! A;R_>>>! A;_S! ;_T! A;S^! A-;^_! ;_S! A;RR>>>!

*7890/1!87!9042! ;-^! ;RR! ;S`! ;R`! ;-f! ;ST! A;S-! ;R_! A;SS! ;-Q! ;RR! ;S_!

b0@@0C.?8!87!./42=B83/4! ;R`! ;RR! ;S^! ;Rf! ;-f! ;SQ! A;S^! ;R_! A;S-! ;R_! ;R-! ;S^!

M742?!\R! ;`S>>>! ;RQ>>>! ;RQ>>>! ;RQ>>>!

*782;!4!x!;SS-;!>4!x!;S^L!>>4!x!;S-L!>>>4!x!;SS-!!