8/4/2019 Judge Cashanow's Opinion Granting the GXS Motion to have Antitrust Charges Dismissed.

1/40

JF [EG WFJ[GK \[D[G\ KJ\[]JL[ LNW][@N] [EG KJ\[]JL[ N@ CD]ZBDFK

1BN]GF KD[D LN]Y

1

p 1 Ljpjb Dl{jnf Fn KOL 49#

8/4/2019 Judge Cashanow's Opinion Granting the GXS Motion to have Antitrust Charges Dismissed.

2/40

=

Gbgl{}nfjl Kd{d Jf{g}ledfhg %GKJ* j| kg|l}jmgk mz Bn}gf

Kd{d d| {eg gbgl{}nfjl guledfhg n` mw|jfg|| kd{d dfk knlwcgf{|"

|wle d| yw}led|g n}kg}| n} jfpnjlg|" jf d |{dfkd}kjqgk kjhj{db

`n}cd{ {ed{ ldf mg y}nlg||gk pjd {eg Jf{g}fg{ mz lncyw{g}

|z|{gc| %GL@ Fn 4 4* GKJ cg||dhg| d}g hgfg}d{gk" |gf{"

}glgjpgk" dfk jfhg|{gk jf{n gf{g}y}j|g lncyw{jfh |z|{gc| `n}

yd}{jg| gfhdhgk jf lnccg}ljdb {}dkjfh" |wle d| }g{djbg}| dfk

|wyybjg}|" |ejyyg}| dfk }glgjpg}|" dfk cdfw`dl{w}g}| dfk

pgfkn}| [eg|g cg||dhg| {}dpgb npg} d |z|{gc n` y}jpd{g

fg{xn}o| jf{g}lnffgl{gk {n gdle n{eg} xj{e fg{xn}o y}n{nlnb|

ldbbgk Pdbwg Dkkgk Fg{xn}o| %PDF|* {ed{ d}g |glw}g @n}

gudcybg d |ejyyg} cjhe{ |gfk d yw}led|g n}kg} `n}cd{{gk jf GKJ

npg} d PDF {n j{| {}dkjfh yd}{fg}| Db{enwhe PDF| d}g y}jpd{gbz

nxfgk" {}dkjfh yd}{fg}| nf kj``g}gf{ PDF| ldf |{jbb lnccwfjld{g

xj{e gdle n{eg} j` {egj} PDF| d}g lnffgl{gk Nfg lnccnf xdz

{ej| nllw}| j| {e}nwhe df jf{g}lnffgl{ anjf{bz cdjf{djfgk mz {xn

PDF y}npjkg}|? dfn{eg} ny{jnf j| {e}nwhe d lnccg}ljdb cdjbmnu

Ybdjf{j`` lnf{gfk| {ed{ j{ j| bnfh |{dfkjfh y}dl{jlg jf {eg GKJ

jfkw|{}z `n} PDF| {n h}df{ fnf#|g{{bgcgf{ ygg} Jf{g}lnffgl{|

{n gdle n{eg} {n `dljbj{d{g {eg `bnx n` GKJ kd{d Jf d fnf#

|g{{bgcgf{ ygg} Jf{g}lnffgl{" GKJ cg||dhg| d}g {}df|`g}}gk `}nc

nfg PDF {n dfn{eg} xj{e gdle PDF dm|n}mjfh j{| nxf ln|{| D

lnccg}ljdb cdjbmnu j| d ydjk |g}pjlg `n} {}df|cj{{jfh cg||dhg|

Ld|g 5149#lp#9

8/4/2019 Judge Cashanow's Opinion Granting the GXS Motion to have Antitrust Charges Dismissed.

3/40