Journal article critique compare
-
Upload
stanley-lee -
Category
Education
-
view
113 -
download
0
Transcript of Journal article critique compare
Journal Article Critique
GOOD BADTitle and abstract is brief and simple. Easy to understand the whole research carried out
The abstract and title is not very will related due to lacking of information and justification
Using scientific measurement to carry out the research and make it systematic in data presentation
Standard scientific representation used in this articles is not accurate – unit and scientific naming is not accurate
The source for the substance of interest, propolin in the research is stated which is the Autralia Honeybee
The source is not well justify and confusing reader about the source of the propolin is a type of propolin or the company selling it
Research carried out using two concentration making it easier to present the result of the research obtained
Research conducted is not using wide range of concentration. Hence, the result obtained is not persuasive and convincing enough
The methodology conducted is only using the propolin to study the antimicrobial properties. It is easier to understand and simple data presentation.
The methodology does not have control to compare the effectiveness of the propolin. Thus, the result obtain is barely only about the effect of propolin but reader are not able to make comparison of the result obtained.