Jose Santos Luna-Canales, A094 142 206 (BIA April 28, 2011)

8/13/2019 Jose Santos Luna-Canales, A094 142 206 (BIA April 28, 2011)

1/6

ELZH P. URIBE, ESQURELaw ce of Enrique evalo55 Msso SteetSouth asadea CA 910

Name: LNA CALES JOSE SOS

ee Juce

Executive Oce Igation Review

oard ofmigration ealsOce of he Clerk

S/07 L P uite Fl Ch V

HS/IE f of hef Counsel LOS88 S Olle Sree 8h FooLos ngeles CA 90014

M-142-206

Date o ts noce /201

nlosed s a copy of he Bo's dso e n e aboe-ec ce.

se

Pel Membes:ale, Roge

Sncee

Dna CrChe Cle

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished


2/6

D usceEv o Rviw

iio of o gio A

ia Fe: A094 142 2 - os gel omia

r JOSE STOS -CANALES

MOV POCEEGS

APE

ON BELF OF RESOND Et U E

ON BHF OF HS

CGE

d Ahenio Aoy

Dae APR B 201

oe Se 12a)(6)}i) & 8 .SC 82a)(6)()] sen ho ing o ped

PICATION Asyl\; wodg of rmova; Covon Ag ocial le ccellaion of rmoval

e pen o ome Sec ("DS'') apals m Iion JudgesMay 13 2010, dso g te rndens appcon -le celaon ofrmovalude so 203 o he ig Adjue d Cena c Relief c o 97

(ACA, b L No 10500 D 111 S. 2193, 216 (197), amended Pb. L o1053, 11 Sa 2 (99. See also 8 C.FR. 124066 (200) e den op tepd te Iio udge's ision. e apal wil dis.

e ndn a ve d c of El Svao, ds no spe e is ovabe te Unie Ses by vie o his a Seco 2 l 2(aX()(i) of te o doi Ac, 8 C 182(a)(6)(A)(i). Feor, te DHS ds no disp ta teen is elible ly i-le lo of rmova. Adgly te ie e o is wete te io udge ed en he deeined ta te rsenses te sbsive eibli uirmes suc rlie d eis i in he exi ofon.2

1 e Bo es Immion uges g o ac, ncung ngs o ecbitof mony, de te l eoo sdd. 8 C.F 1003 1( d)3i) The Bod qso o la, discon d jud al ohe iues in aps m disio ofImmon Jdgesde novo. 8 CF 1003l(d)(3)(ii)

e den o aplie yl, witholdng of rmova po de te Conveogans To b he mmon udge i no adjdica ho appcao hersns elibil tose of rie no r .


3/6

A094 2 206

Aoing e OHS e Imion udge ould ave d e sndent neibe si-e eon of mova s: ) ause he fai to sho t e s not

aen desdn on 24(b)(3B)[(i)] of e Act (latgtocuon of o)"see8 CFR. 240.66(a); (2) becuse Immon udge fed to apply e appropa entd (3) ause his ony wnotdble Te OHS also es at e Immaon Judgeshould ve de e ndent's ues sieion of mov e exeisof on. 8 CF.R 240a) We l adds h o en in

Scon241(bX3)B)(i) of e A 8 .S.C 23 bX3)B){)povdes at pit oldg of mo ot pon if e Atto Ge de he order ncit s or o pc n e uon of vd of divds lio naolity mmp n a pcl sa , or alopon" Ts se pscpone l pecr bppestapl r clle llon of moval by oon of son 203) of NAC 11 Sa 298Acco te S e ndent is v by e orba he m 1981

to 988 n a f bio, ncludg e notoo ento 3 o MliDcmt (M3 of the Svo y, a tesgen t at is o thveened dsped h ts abes, inluding ms lings, agas Svdocvls d g dng e of e ndent's ie (HS Br. at 58 2; E6.

e e OHS at e sndents sce n e DM3 ss a oale sicionat e o bay al t d e he s e ben of deog by apndee of e eviene at e b is naplable8 CF 12408(). s tesmony e miaon Judge e spondentes atdg s se he ag lossd avoded ll bales d combat at 27-34) Te respondent denied involvement i e

coission of y ua

e guell, e

fwoke or oe civilis,d w onev sent dng pu ; . at 44). Te Imiaon udged e nt ible n is d conluded at he w not subjet o e ob (J at 12).

Te S also llenges e Immaon Judge's intetaon ofNi ut aw de Ion Judge ould not ave a cve la t m oUnd Ss Ct Cosof Apal. For i, HS t e mmtion Judgedd not pperly ply Mran Avao v Goaes,449 F3d 915 97 ( C 006) d ae e w ent m e N Cruit e Iion Juge pyg ycve ent o outside e n Ciut3

Te OHS at e Immion uge poyi to m Gae497 .3d 990 (9 ) e OH is G p

ndg e Se Co Negie v Hoer 2 S. 59, 13-, 1178 (20),e Supe Co hel t i dision in Feorenk Unte tates 4 S 90 (8) doesnot n qeson e s a ds" o ivoliess" eepon to e o b in o 208b2)(A) of e on aonli A e s no

nnu. )

2


4/6

09442 206

e e OHS dies e on Judges inton d appicao of es n cul e 'n o " in some of e ve ent eIo ge d e t e n me coint Nn C lw. See

raAla v. Goales, sra For ice, cosen e ndvdli evonof o involvemt ps ic of p ts t is bran Av v. Goae e aio udge e ndet id ot poy e o w ot pent dng o d s a of povdg losalp w too moved om eo a J. at 11) See Mira Avado v oassupra g a pculz ealo of n involvement to a cupabil). TeIio udge d a e rnd dino ve y discon in dng wer tode nivds dd not ve e in e of ese indvds oc y wdetaed J. at 11-1). Id

st edence ae ndnt sony egg in o sud o cties,em of s sc he D-3 dg he 1980s is not cient to blish hepl "a, o o gel or civili See r Alvado oles sa dng [m]e acquie o membesp oo

,is c

o e uo exeo quoting Vrovc v Ahcro 362 F3 147 125 C20);Maer o/RoigezMajno 9&N D 8 8145 ( 988) (mp oro even oe wc gge n rsecuon is o sucet to b one om liebu o if oes acio o acon ht uo me . Wile we kowegee HS' s, we ll e iio uges denaon t e puto bis not mment to e sodets eigbl ie cello of eoval dACAR.

e OHS lso hallnges e Imo Judges favobe dibii deteo gg

e ent s ot of s exies coaned iccies a r teo ois p o concee e of his ac Le e OHS we ubld me of eiscies e sdets act o his mili sice in El Svdo. Desite chco e act rems at s Boa vew o uge's f d onlyde weer ose ds e cll eeous" CFR 003(X3(i} Corew is sicty defeti" o e e of , pue s om reveig e ctnder simpy ae we covnc" at we wod hve di e ce dinty, orwe the evde diny h we e t-de. oncree Pe and Producs ofaloi In v o Laborers Peon T u or e lorna508 U 60 623(1993); rson v o Bessemer i North olina 40 US 5 57374 195 Ieluc e mg of e cle te Supme epl i]t is no

enou migt ve e o cocio solve e bigies din dd a mo sse cas o cons ch e fder pnl m o." Uniedaes v a' Ass n oRea Eae B 339 U.S. 485 495 950. e con, w

3 coudds o invounness defese nvovd e c, d we d is iaopicion to a less e b e Iio Judge See Ma"er oSanos 9 I& D 0 984.

3


5/6

.

094 142 20

o issible ies o e eid, e de's coi em ot dmedclly Anderson v i esseer sura at 574 cit otte) Bef e ct-ner's obeaonavges, t deen mut be t nin ghe cibili o ess at 575 Fheo Immion Jdge is aoto placet weit on the fe conclio o q sss, ev if ot rhe OSwould ave dient cncluns n e e ft. neewsk v eviaion i 548 F3 257 12061 Cir 2008); ned Saes v Mvh 209 F3d22 232 (1 C 2000) Iord treves a acetn clly eneos," we

m, un onsidon of e ec" le e d nnvon a mise en cod." Uid S v. Ud aes m o 333 U 3, 39(948)

I iew o te ondes y at e time of is milit ce his event ack ophiian Q.J. at 4 56, 8), we concle ts nding wbed on apissible vi eevden T,aoug e maer is not m dot,o\ onsieon of e evdenc do

not ve a ete cnvcon amie i. Acngly,we w dee to e on Jues cibili nn d accet eher eone renden di not oy o ncie or pcipate in of peon" dn s n e Slvo mli QJ 8)

Fly, he DHS e e pnden ould dee ceJlaon of ov due t aJac of dord uehe es not mt ch elief e exei o sctn Hweer, teDHSpnpa n r ein ese iew is at they lieve e ndent pi or iible ony in s o s pon r lie Te In Jge expsly at sment, concing e dipcies n e ndent'caim weadeqately expained t the co er n a eliate eo eive. not

eiuly, we nd no ce rat dean, d we awe of no oer vee he sponents bkd woud wt a ding at he is deseg of a avoleeeise o e Atoy Ges scn Acorin we nd n is r ovln emiin Jge's ision e ondent is elibl r, deg of, a of iale llaon o See 8 FR 003 (d)(3Xii).

Acingly, e llog or l ene

OER: e ap is dsmiss

TH OR Pt t 8 CFR 1003l()(6), he is md to ion Jdge r e p o lowige Deentof omeld Syo mpl or uate idn eno o invesgo oeions dgs, i ns, re enof oer pdby 8 CF.R. I3.47

4


6/6

Jose Santos Luna-Canales, A094 142 206 (BIA April 28, 2011)

Documents

Transcript of Jose Santos Luna-Canales, A094 142 206 (BIA April 28, 2011)