Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of...

33
Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, SCDOT

Transcript of Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of...

Page 1: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

Jay Thompson, PE

State Pavement Design Engineer, SCDOT

Page 2: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 3: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 4: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 5: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 6: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 7: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 8: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 9: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage

Water is one attacker that can create damage in different ways

Today we are going to focus on a typically slow mode of attack

Stripping

Page 10: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

Loss of bond between aggregate and asphalt binder

Observed as the asphalt binder having been stripped from the aggregate.

Page 11: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 12: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

Detachment

Displacement

Emulsification

Pore Pressure Induced Damage

Scour

Environmental Factors

(Taylor and Khosla 1983, Kiggundu and Roberts 1988, Terrel and Al-Swailmi 1994)

Page 13: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

1986 – Bushing, Burati, Amirkhanian – Clemson

Found widespread occurrences of stripping statewide

Commonly see stripping on older pavements, especially where maintenance has been deferred

Page 14: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

Mix Design Anti-Stripping Additives – Lime – LASA

Effectiveness can be sensitive to aggregate type

Testing – ITS/TSR – Boiling Test

Anything that keeps water out Preservation – Different Types

Rehabilitation

Drainage – Cross-slope and shoulders

Good construction practices Joint compaction

Mix type selection and porosity

Duration of exposure to weather for coarse mixes

Page 15: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 16: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 17: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

Normal crown, inside lane I-126

Superelevation, inside lane, no water, no distress I-126

Page 18: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 19: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 20: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 21: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 22: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 23: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 24: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 25: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 26: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 28: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

The attackers are known. While predicting susceptibility is complicated. We know how to design tower defenses for the attack.

Good mix design and testing

Good construction practices

Good drainage

Keep it good – regular preservation/maintenance

Page 29: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

The attackers are known but their path is undefined. Investigation may be required to understand risks.

What happens if we place traffic on a milled surface?

Can we get compaction on the new lifts?

Page 30: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

When does stripped HMA have to be replaced? That’s a good question, here are a few more:

How bad is it? Is it isolated or wide spread?

How deep in the structure is it?

What is the significance of the road and what types of traffic does it carry?

Do we have enough money? Is there another project coming along? Can we seal it off for now to stop the mechanism of attack?

How long will that last?

What if stripping is just begining? Can we seal it off and fix it later? What if our funding gets decreased later?

Page 31: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

When does stripped HMA have to be replaced?

I’m always going to start with the fix it approach. If a problem is fixed we can have a higher degree of certainty concerning future funding needs.

Reality is that decisions must be made based on available funding and risk. Risk to the immediate area first

Risk to the system next

Last but not least, risk considering future cost

Page 32: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different
Page 33: Jay Thompson, PE State Pavement Design Engineer, …...Pavement must be defended from many types of attackers and resulting damage Water is one attacker that can create damage in different

Jay Thompson, PE

State Pavement Design Engineer, SCDOT

[email protected]