JAKARTA URGENT FLOOD MITIGATION PROJECT · PDF filejakarta urgent flood mitigation project...

download JAKARTA URGENT FLOOD MITIGATION PROJECT · PDF filejakarta urgent flood mitigation project (jufmp) consolidated summary of the environmental impact assessment september 2011 government

If you can't read please download the document

Transcript of JAKARTA URGENT FLOOD MITIGATION PROJECT · PDF filejakarta urgent flood mitigation project...

  • JAKARTA URGENT FLOOD

    MITIGATION PROJECT (JUFMP)

    CONSOLIDATED SUMMARY

    OF THE

    ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT

    ASSESSMENT

    SEPTEMBER 2011

    Government of the Republic of Indonesia

    Ministry of Public Works

    Directorate General of Water Resources

    Pub

    lic D

    iscl

    osur

    e A

    utho

    rized

    Pub

    lic D

    iscl

    osur

    e A

    utho

    rized

    Pub

    lic D

    iscl

    osur

    e A

    utho

    rized

    Pub

    lic D

    iscl

    osur

    e A

    utho

    rized

    Pub

    lic D

    iscl

    osur

    e A

    utho

    rized

    Pub

    lic D

    iscl

    osur

    e A

    utho

    rized

    Pub

    lic D

    iscl

    osur

    e A

    utho

    rized

    Pub

    lic D

    iscl

    osur

    e A

    utho

    rized

    wb406484Typewritten TextE2658 v12

  • i

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Contents 1 Executive Summary ......................................................................................................................... 1

    1.3 Safeguards Policies Triggered .................................................................................................. 2

    1.4 Approach for Environmental and Social Impact Assessment ..................................................... 3

    1.5 Significant Environmental and Social Impacts .......................................................................... 5

    1.6 Proposed Environmental and Social Impact Management ......................................................... 6

    1.7 Consultations ......................................................................................................................... 11

    1.8 Project Communication .......................................................................................................... 12

    1.9 Reputational Risks ................................................................................................................. 13

    2 Project Description ........................................................................................................................ 14

    2.1 Project Development Objective .............................................................................................. 14

    2.2 Summary of Project Component ............................................................................................. 15

    2.3 Project Sites ........................................................................................................................... 15

    2.4 Sequencing of Works ............................................................................................................. 17

    2.5 Volume of Works ................................................................................................................... 17

    2.6 Disposal Sites......................................................................................................................... 18

    2.6.1 Ancol confined disposal facility (CDF) ........................................................................... 19

    2.6.2 Bantar Gebang landfill facility ........................................................................................ 19

    2.6.3 PPLi hazardous waste landfill ......................................................................................... 20

    3 Environmental and Social Legal Requirements and Project Institutional and Implementation

    Arrangements ........................................................................................................................................ 20

    3.1 Government of Indonesia Environmental Impact Assessment ................................................. 20

    3.2 Government of Indonesia Land Acquisition ............................................................................ 21

    3.3 The World Banks Triggered Environmental Safeguards Policies and Compliance

    Requirements..................................................................................................................................... 22

    3.4 The World Banks Triggered Social Safeguards Policies and Compliance Requirements. ....... 23

    3.5 Package of Environment and Social Safeguards Documents. .................................................. 23

    3.5.1 Environmental safeguards documents ............................................................................. 23

    3.5.2 Social safeguards documents .......................................................................................... 27

    3.5.3 Preparation and disclosure of safeguards documents ....................................................... 27

    3.6 Institutional Arrangements ..................................................................................................... 29

    3.6.1 Institutional Arrangements (Phase 1 and Phase 2) ........................................................... 29

    3.6.2 Institutional Arrangements (Disposal sites) ..................................................................... 32

  • ii

    3.7 Implementation Arrangements (Environmental Safeguards) ................................................... 33

    3.7.1 For the Phase 1 and Phase 2 works ................................................................................. 33

    3.7.2 For the disposal sites (Ancol CDF, Bantar Gebang and PPLi) ......................................... 33

    3.8 Implementation Arrangements (Social Safeguards)................................................................. 36

    4 Relevant Environment and Social Baseline Data ............................................................................ 37

    4.1 Sediment Quality in JUFMP Sites .......................................................................................... 37

    4.1.1 ERM 2008 ...................................................................................................................... 38

    4.1.2 DHV 2008 ...................................................................................................................... 38

    4.1.3 AMDAL for Phase 2 activities, sampling and analysis 2010 ........................................... 38

    4.1.4 Results and interpretation ............................................................................................... 39

    4.2 Sediment Quality in Ancol ..................................................................................................... 40

    4.3 Water Quality in JUFMP Sites ............................................................................................... 41

    4.4 Ancol Sea Water Quality ........................................................................................................ 42

    4.5 Ancol Marine Biota ................................................................................................................ 45

    4.5.1 Plankton ......................................................................................................................... 45

    4.5.2 Benthos .......................................................................................................................... 45

    4.6 Social Economic Baseline ...................................................................................................... 46

    4.6.1 Population ...................................................................................................................... 46

    4.6.2 Social-economic Characteristics of the Population .......................................................... 46

    5 Summary of Potential Significant Environmental and Social Impacts ............................................. 48

    5.1 Environmental Impacts associated with the JUFMP project activities ..................................... 48

    5.1.1 Significant traffic disruption. .......................................................................................... 48

    5.1.2 Reduced air quality and foul odors. ................................................................................. 49

    5.1.3 Change of water discharge rate ....................................................................................... 49

    5.1.4 Change of surface water quality. ..................................................................................... 49

    5.1.5 Change of sea water quality ............................................................................................ 49

    5.1.6 Increase of solid waste .................................................................................................... 50

    5.1.7 Impact on Biota .............................................................................................................. 50

    5.1.8 Impact on Public health and environmental sanitation ..................................................... 50

    5.2 JUFMP Project Impacts on Ancol CDF .................................................................................. 50

    5.3 Offsite Impacts from Ancol CDF ............................................................................................ 52

    5.4 JUFMP Project Impacts on Bantar Gebang and PPLi facility .................................................. 52

    5.5 Social Impacts ........................................................................................................................ 52

  • iii

    5.5.1 PAPs Sites ...................................................................................................................... 52

    5.5.2 Non-PAPs sites...............