J/ y production at high transverse momentum in p+p and A+A collisions
description
Transcript of J/ y production at high transverse momentum in p+p and A+A collisions
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 1
J/ production at high transverse momentum
in p+p and A+A collisions
Zebo Tang (USTC)
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 2
Outline
• Introduction– Quark Gluon Plasma (QGP) – J/ as a probe of QGP– J/ production mechanism in p+p collisions
• High pT J/ reconstruction– Electron identification– High pT J/e+e- reconstruction
• Results– J/ spectra in p+p collisions– J/ spectra in Cu+Cu collisions– J/-hadron correlation in p+p collisions
• Summary and outlook
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 3
Quark-Hadron phase transition
Net Baryon Density
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 4
Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider (RHIC)
Animation M. Lisa
RHIC BRAHMSPHOBOS
PHENIXSTAR
AGS
TANDEMS
v = 0.99995c = 186,000 miles/sec Au + Au at 200 GeV
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 5
J/ melting in QGP
J/ dissociation due to color screening Signature of the QGP formation
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 6
J/ measurements in Heavy Ion Collisions
SPS: Anomalous suppression Significant evidence of deconfinement in central Pb+Pb PLB 477,28 (2000)
NA 50, PLB 477,28 (2000)
RHIC: Similar suppression as SPS, why? Balance of dissociation and regeneration? Or sequential suppression?
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 7
Sequential suppression
H. Satz, Nucl. Phys. A (783):249-260(2007)
J/ suppression at low pT maybe only from excited stats (’, c) F. Karsch, D. Kharzeev and H. Satz, PLB 637, 75 (2006)
60% from direct J/: not suppressed30% c and 10% ’: dissociated
NA50, EPJ39,335NA60, QM05
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 8
Sur
viva
l pos
sibi
lity
pT
Direct J/ suppression
J/
H. Liu, K. Rajagopal and U.A. WiedemannPRL 98, 182301(2007) and hep-ph/0607062M. Chernicoff, J. A. Garcia, A. Guijosa hep-th/0607089
T. Gunji, QM08
Can we observed direct J/ suppression?
Hot wind dissociation high pT direct J/ suppression
Hot wind dissociationAdS/CFT calculation
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 9
Charmonium production mechanism
NRQCD
Color singlet
Color octet
Color singlet model (CSM), LO
underpredicted CDF data by order of magnitude
Color octet model (COM), LO
good agreement with CDF cross section
disagreement with CDF polarization
LO
Know your reference!LO CSM LO COM
J/3S1
J/
CDF measurement: PRL79,572
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 10
Charmonium production mechanism
NRQCD
Color singlet
Color octet
Color singlet model (CSM), LO
underpredicted CDF data by order of magnitude
Color octet model (COM), LO
good agreement with CDF cross section
disagreement with CDF polarization
CSM*, NLO
better agreement
NNLO* applicable at pT>5-7 GeV/c
COM*
improvement of polarization,
NLO will come, valid at pT>3 GeV/c
Decay feeddown (CDF):
(2s): 7%-15%, slightly increase with pT
c0,1,2: ~30%, slightly decrease with pT
B: Strong pT dependence
LO
Know your reference!
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 11
Disentangle contributions via Correlations
• J/-hadron correlation can also shed light on different source contribution to J/ production
• CSM vs. COM
1)
no near side correlation
2)
strong near side correlation
g g g /J
g g b b hadron
B X /J X
PLB 200, 380(1988) and PLB 256,112(1991)
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 12
The STAR Detector
MRPC ToF barrelMRPC ToF barrel75% for run 975% for run 9
RPSD
PMD
FPD
FMS
EMC barrel
EMC End Cap
DAQ1000DAQ1000
Take data FGT
Complete
Ongoing
MTD (BNL LDRD)
R&DHFT: R&D
TPC
TPC+EMC for this analysis
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 13
Electron identification (TPC only)
With TPC only:• no electron ID at low pT
• difficult to get a good electron sample at high pT
• possible to get a electron sample with reasonable purity at intermediate pT
x sigma deviation from electron dE/dx curve
Note: electron yield is much less than hadrons
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 14
Electron ID (EMC)
Online fast trigger: • enhance high pT electron• enhance recorded luminosity
Offline deposited energy:Further suppress high pT hadrons
x0.05x0.05)
~5X0
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 15
Electron ID (SMD)
electron hadron
Shower Maximum Detector:• shower size• shower position
Further suppress hadron contamination
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 16
High pT J/ e+ e- reconstruction technique
PYTHIA decay
p+p run6
Trigger efficiencyTracking efficiency
acceptance
High pT electron
High pT J/ high pT electron (TPC+EMC) lower pT electron (TPC only)
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 17
High pT J/ in p+p at 200 GeVJ/ pT
J/ pT
EMC+TPC electrons:1, pT>2.5 GeV/c
TPC only electrons:1, pT>1.2 GeV/c
EMC+TPC electrons:1, pT>4.0 GeV/c
TPC only electrons:1, pT>1.2 GeV/c
No background at pT>5 GeV/c
Reach higher pT (~14 GeV/c)
p+p 2005
p+p 2006
STAR Preliminary
EMC (High Tower) trigger:5 < pT < 14 GeV/c
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 18
J/ spectra in p+p and Cu+Cu at 200 GeV
• Significantly extend pT range of previous measurements in p+p at RHIC to 14 GeV/c
• Agreement of charm measurements between STAR and PHENIX
~3 orders
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 19
Compare to pQCD and NRQCD
Model comparisons:
Color singlet model: direct NNLO still miss the high pT part. P. Artoisenet et al.,
Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 152001 (2008), and J.P.
Lansberg private communication.
LO CS+CO: better agreement with the measurements, leave little room for higher charmonium states and B feeddown contribution. G. C. Nayak, M. X. Liu, and F. Cooper, Phys. Rev. D68, 034003 (2003), and private communication.
CS and LO CS+CO have different power parameters different diagram contribution?
power parameter: n=8 for NNLO CS n=6 for LO CS+CO
STAR Preliminary
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 20
xT scaling in p+p collisions
n is related to thenumber of point-likeconstituents takingan active role in theinteraction
n=8: diquark scattering
n=4: QED-like scattering
pT>2 GeV/c
STAR Preliminary
pT>5 GeV/c
and proton at pT>2 GeV/c: n=6.6±0.1 (PLB 637, 161(2006))
J/ at high pT: n=5.6±0.2 (close to CS+CO prediction)
Soft processes affect low pT J/ production
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 21
Nuclear modification factor RAA
• Consistent with no suppression at high pT: RAA(pT>5 GeV/c) = 1.4± 0.4±0.2
• All RHIC measurements: RAA = 1.1 ± 0.3 ± 0.2
• Indicates RAA increase from low pT to high pT
STAR Preliminary
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 22
Nuclear modification factor RAA
• Consistent with no suppression at high pT: RAA(pT>5 GeV/c) = 1.4± 0.4±0.2
• All RHIC measurements:
RAA(pT>5 GeV/c) = 1.1 ± 0.3 ± 0.2
• Indicates RAA increase from low pT to high pT
• Contrast to AdS/CFT+ Hydro prediction H. Liu, K. Rajagopal and U.A. Wiedemann PRL 98, 182301(2007), T. Gunji, JPG 35, 104137(2008) • How does production mechanism (CS vs. CO) affect energy loss?• Good jobs:
• transport+hydro: from initial produced instead of regenerated Y.Liu, Zhen Qu, N. Xu and P. Zhuang, arXiv:0901.2757; N. Xu, QM2009 • two-component model: leakage and B feeddown is important R. Rapp, X. Zhao, arXiv:0806.1239
STAR Preliminary
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 23
Disentangle contributions via Correlations
• J/-hadron correlation can also shed light on different source contribution to J/ production
• CSM vs. COM
1)
no near side correlation
2)
strong near side correlation
g g g /J
g g b b hadron
B X /J X
PLB 200, 380(1988) and PLB 256,112(1991)
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 24
J/-hadron correlation
(S+B)/B: 54/14
5.4
Heavy quark fragmentation
Near side correlation
Good S/B ratio makes this measurement possible
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 25
J/hadron correlation in p+p
PRL 95,152301(2005)
h-h correlation• No significant near side J/-hadron azimuthal angle correlation
• Constrain B meson’s contribution to J/ yield
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 26
Constrain bottom yields
• Correlations shows low B contribution (13 5) %• Can used to further constrain B yields
STAR Preliminary
STAR Preliminary
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 27
Constrain bottom yields
• pQCD predicts significant BJ/ • Correlations shows low B contribution• Can used to further constrain B yields• Constrain Be
M. Cacciari, P. Nason and R. Vogt RL 95(2005),122001; CLEO collaboration PRL 89(2002),282001
STAR Preliminary
STAR Preliminary
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 28
Yields in near/away side
Associated hadron spectra with leading J/: • Away side: Consistent with leading charged hadron correlation measurement (h-h) away-side from gluon or light quark fragmentation • Near side: Consistent with no associated hadron production BJ/ not a dominant contributor to inclusive J/ constrain J/ production mechanism
STAR Preliminary
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 29
High-pT J/ in run8 d+Au
dAu EMC data sampled luminosity: 31 nb-1
p+p equivalent: 13 pb-1
•J/ spectra •(2S)•c
•J/-hadron correlation•Isolated J/•J/ in Jet
Reduced material budget by a factor of ~10
Efficiency under going
420 signals13
New 500 GeV p+p data is coming!Also 200 GeV p+p with higher lum.200 GeV Au+Au and Energy scan.
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 30
Summary
J/ spectra in 200 GeV p+p collisions at STAR Significantly extend previous measurement from 5 GeV/c to ~14 GeV/c, provide powerful tool to constrain model calculations High pT J/ follows xT scaling with n=5.6, consistent with COM slope Low pT J/ deviates from xT scaling suggests soft process can affect low pT J/ production.
J/ spectra in 200 GeV Cu+Cu collisions
First observation of no suppression for hadron at high pT at STAR Indication of RAA increasing from low pT to high pT
Jhadron azimuthal correlation in p+p First quarknonium-hadron correlation measurement at RHIC No significant near side correlation BJ/ contribution = 135% Can be used to constrain B production, and help to separate be from ce
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 31
Extra slides
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 32
What I am going to try (low pT)
500 GeV p+p, 2009, preliminary calibration
TPC+TOF
Low pT J/ee:• Total cross section• <pT
2>
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 33
What I am going to try (other charmonia)
TOF: /K upto 1.6 GeV/c, p/(,K) upto 3 GeV/c
With extended PID from TOF and high luminosity of RHICII:The reconstruction of the other charmonium states through their hadronic channels are possible and worth to try
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 34
Future dramatic improvement of J / at low pT
EMC+TOF+HFT (large acceptance):
• J/ production
• Different states predicted to melt at different T in color medium
• Charmonia (J/), bottonia ()
Quarkonium dissociation temperatures – Digal, Karsch, Satz
pT (e)>1.5 GeV/c
PHENIX Acceptance: ||<0.35,=2*/2 STAR TOF-Upgrade Acceptance: ||<0.9,=2*
J/ yields from 1 billion minbias Au+Au events: 43.8x10-9/0.040x109*292*0.5*1.8*0.5= 144,0000.3% v2 errorJ/pp N Nbin y RAA
dE/dx after TOF cut
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 35
Detector upgrades: HFT and MTD
Heavy Flavor Tracker:
Muon Telescope Detector:
n>0
STAR Preliminary
Prototype in run VII
e+e- rejection
Topologically reconstructJ/ from B decay
Rejection power: ~16
Muon identification simulation
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 36
MRPC ToF barrelMRPC ToF barrelReady for run 10Ready for run 10
RPSD
PMD
FPD
FMS
EMC barrel
EMC End Cap
DAQ1000DAQ1000Ready for run 9 FGT
Complete
Ongoing
MTD (BNL LDRD)
R&DHFT
TPC
The STAR Detector
Run8: without any inner tracker
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 37
Jpsi-h correlation from PYTHIA
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 38
High pT J/ in heavy ion collisions (Cont.)
2-component approach: dissociation + recombination
RAA decreases slightly or flat with pT X. Zhao and R. Rapp, hep-ph/07122407
RAA increase slightly with pT including formation time and B decay X. Zhao, WWND2008
Color singlet model:
RAA increase with pT (formed out of medium) F. Karsch and R. Petronzio, PLB 193(1987), 105 ;
J.P. Blaizot and J.Y. Ollitrault, PLB 199(1987),499
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 39
Datasets
p+p data sample: 1. EMC triggered events in year 2005 ET>3.5 GeV Integrated luminosity: 3 (pb)-1
2. EMC triggered events in year 2006 ET>5.4 GeV Integrated luminosity: 11 (pb)-1
Cu+Cu data sample: 1. EMC triggered events in year 2005 ET>3.75 GeV Integrated luminosity: 0.9 (nb)-1
pp-equivalent: 3 (pb)-1
High-pT J/p+p data sample:• 1. J/ψ triggered events in year 2006
• Integrated luminosity: 377 (nb)-1
• 2. Υ triggered events in year 2006
• Integrated luminosity: 9(pb)-1
Au+Au data sample:• 1. Υ triggered events in year 2007
Integrated luminosity: 300(μb)-1
pp-equivalent: 12(pb)-1
Triggered data
Lectures on Physics of High-Energy Nuclear Collisions
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 200940
Heavy Quark Potential
rr
TrV
25.0),(
Cornell-potential:
At zero temperature, V(r,0) r, Confinement ! At high temperature, the confinement potential ‘melted’ De-confinement ! J/ suppression ! T.Matsui and H.Satz, Phys. Lett. B178, 416(1986)
F. Karsch, E. Laermann, A. Peikert, Nucl. Phys. B605, 579(2001)
Nu Xu, Lecture at USTC, Oct. 2006
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 41
J/ measurements in Heavy Ion Collisions
• Due to color screening, J/ was thought be dissociated in the medium. T. Masui
and H. Satz, Phys. Lett. B178, 416 (1986). • At RHIC, the suppression at low pT is similar to at SPS at similar Npart: recombination due to large charm cross section. P. Braun-Munzinger and J. Stachel, Phys. Lett. B490,196 (2000); L. Grandchamp and R. Rapp, Phys. Lett. B523, 60 (2001); M. I. Gorenstein et al., Phys. Lett. B524, 265 (2002); R. L. Thews, M. Schroedter, and J. Rafelski, Phys. Rev. C63, 054905 (2001); Yan, Zhang and Xu, Phys.Rev.Lett.97, 232301 (2006); PHENIX: Phys.Rev.Lett.98, 232301,2007.
• At SPS, suppression decreases versus pT: Cronin effect , Nuclear absorption and formation time effect. M. C. Abreu et al., Phys. Lett. B499, 85 (2001); X. Zhao, WWND2008; X. Zhao and R. Rapp, hep-ph/07122407; X. Zhu, P. Zhuang, PRC67, 067901(2003)
NA60, QM08
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 42
High pT J/ in heavy ion collisions
How the formation time effect, jet energy loss and hot wind dissociation affect the
high pT J/psi in the medium:
2-component approach: dissociation + recombinationRAA increases slightly with pT including formation time and B decay X. Zhao, WWND2008; X.Zhao and R. Rapp, hep-ph/07122407
Formation time effect: RAA increases with pT
(formed out of medium) K. Farsch and R. Petronzio, PLB 193(1987), 105 ; J.P. Blaizot and J.Y. Ollitrault, PLB 199(1987),499
Jet energy loss: open charm strongly suppressed observed in the medium
AdS/CFT + Hydro: RAA decreases versus pT
STAR: PRL98(2007) 192301
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 43
Compare to SPS
Similar trend also observed at SPS, might from different physics origin
RHIC: Cu+Cu, , consistent with no suppression at pT > 5 GeV/c
17.3NNs GeV SPS: In+In, , consistent with no suppression at pT > 1.8 GeV/c
200NNs GeV
NA60, QM08
NA50, 158 AGeV
PLB499,85 and NPA774,59
R CP
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 44
J/-h correlation from PYTHIA
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 45
Summary
J/ in p+p and Cu+Cu collisions: pT spectra in p+p: • extended to ~14 GeV/c• follows xT scaling with n=5.6 at pT>5
GeV/c, deviates from scaling at low pT
J/-hadron azimuthal correlation in p+p:• no significant near side correlation
constrain the contribution from BJ/+X
• away-side spectra consistent with h-h correlation gluon or light quark
fragmentation J/ RAA
• indication of RAA increasing at high pT
production mechanisms: • described by NRQCD• soft processes affect low pT
production
• constrain decay contribution• constrain B production and
Be• constrain production
mechanism: CSM or COM
• medium properties
08/10/2009 Zebo Tang, Weihai 2009 46
Sequential suppression
H. Satz, Nucl. Phys. A (783):249-260(2007)
J/ suppression at low pT maybe only from excited stats (’, c) F. Karsch, D. Kharzeev and H. Satz, PLB 637, 75 (2006)
60% from direct J/: not suppressed30% c and 10% ’: dissociated
NA50, EPJ39,335NA60, QM05
?
Plasma thermometer