J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant...

21
BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD PETITIONER: CNX Gas Company LLC DIVISION OF GAS AND OIL DOCKET NO: VGOB 00-1017-0830-03 RELIEF SOUGHT: (1) DISBURSEMENT FROM ESCROW REGARDING TRACT(S) 1B (2) AND AUTHORIZATION FOR DIRECT PAYMENT OF ROYALTIES HEARING DATE: December 15, 2015 DRILLING UNIT: FF24 BUCHANAN COUNTY, VIRGINIA PETITION FOR ORDER OF DISBURSEMENT OF ESCROW FUNDS 1. Petitioner and its counsel Petitioner is CNX Gas Company LLC, 627 Claypool Hill Mall Road, Cedar Bluff, VA 24609, (276) 596-5075. Petitioner's counsel is Mark A. Swartz, Hillard & Swartz, LLP, 122 Capital Street, Suite 201, Charleston, WV 25301. 2. Relief Sought (1) the disbursement of escrowed funds heretofore deposited with the Board's Escrow Agent, attributable to Tract 1B, as depicted upon the annexed table; and (2) authorization to begin paying royalties directly to the following parties: Pamela J. Keene, Jamie H. Hale & Jeffery C. Hale. 3. Legal Authority Va. Code Ann. () 45.1-361.1et seq., 4 VAC 25-160-140., and relevant Virginia Gas and Oil Board Orders (" Board" ) heretofore promulgated pursuant to law. 4. Type of Well(s) Coalbed Methane 5. Factual basis for relief requested Affidavit from Torch Oil & Gas Company dated August 5, 2015 stating they have no legal claim to CBM royalties based on the current state of Virginia law, therefore 100% of the royalty will be paid to the oil and gas owners, namely Pamela J. Keene, Jamie H. Hale and Jeffery C. Hale. The Designated Operator to pay royalties directly to the persons identified in Exhibit EE annexed hereto and the annexed Table, further, specifies how said royalties are to be divided and paid. 6. Attestation The foregoing Petition to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief is true and correct. Page Number 1.

Transcript of J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant...

Page 1: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

PETITIONER: CNX Gas Company LLC DIVISION OF GAS AND OIL

DOCKET NO: VGOB 00-1017-0830-03

RELIEF SOUGHT: (1) DISBURSEMENT FROM ESCROW REGARDING TRACT(S) 1B (2) ANDAUTHORIZATION FOR DIRECT PAYMENT OF ROYALTIES

HEARING DATE: December 15, 2015

DRILLING UNIT: FF24

BUCHANAN COUNTY, VIRGINIA

PETITION FOR ORDER OF DISBURSEMENT OF ESCROW FUNDS

1.Petitioner and its counsel

Petitioner is CNX Gas Company LLC, 627 Claypool Hill Mall Road, Cedar Bluff, VA 24609, (276)596-5075. Petitioner's counsel is Mark A. Swartz, Hillard & Swartz, LLP, 122 Capital Street, Suite201, Charleston, WV 25301.

2. Relief Sought

(1) the disbursement of escrowed funds heretofore deposited with the Board's Escrow Agent,attributable to Tract 1B, as depicted upon the annexed table; and (2) authorization to beginpaying royalties directly to the following parties: Pamela J. Keene, Jamie H. Hale & Jeffery C.Hale.

3. Legal Authority

Va. Code Ann. () 45.1-361.1et seq., 4 VAC 25-160-140., and relevant Virginia Gas and OilBoard Orders ("Board" ) heretofore promulgated pursuant to law.

4. Type of Well(s)

Coalbed Methane

5. Factual basis for relief requested

Affidavit from Torch Oil & Gas Company dated August 5, 2015 stating they have no legal claim toCBM royalties based on the current state of Virginia law, therefore 100% of the royalty will bepaid to the oil and gas owners, namely Pamela J. Keene, Jamie H. Hale and Jeffery C. Hale. TheDesignated Operator to pay royalties directly to the persons identified in Exhibit EE annexedhereto and the annexed Table, further, specifies how said royalties are to be divided and paid.

6. Attestation

The foregoing Petition to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief is true and correct.

Page Number 1.

Page 2: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

/IN 308.970.00

/ E 989,43904

~l~l

N 308.898.47E 988,297.95

.rfr. f

f

f

N 308,888 47E 988,394.14

f

f

l

f

f

f

f

f

f

f

N 309,8133tsE sss,22139

EXH[8fT A

OAKIIOOO FIELO UNlT. FF-2dFORCE POOL'IIilQ

VQOB-00-IOI7-OSNCt

, I...'.I-+:::-'I+w.pocahantas Gae pcrtnershlc 'sl I Nalrm ond IIuebsl UNPT PP24Ccep cay

tt'lsenshuntaJm .:"-'lsval!onQuadrants 9Tract No.

county Huchattcn elsfrlct Nurrf cane Eccl stThis plot le a new plat X I an update p lat I o 40 'Final pltIt„/+~~ ~ .'.'. <t:lt se" ii', Farm 00(HIQ"7

Licensed Prefssslcnal Enelneer or LI ce-~d Land eurv jg,'...,210 ."

Page Number 2.

Page 3: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

POCAHOh I~NS 3'AcYEA=RSHir".Vnit FF-24

Tract tdenttScsttcns

Hug", MacRse Lars Trust- TR 9-CoalConvclhagcs Ccm Company - Below Tgler cost LeasedPermec, Inc - Tkle and saeva coal Leased

- Pocshcntss Qes Psrlnership -CBM LeasedFJlenFletchsr et el- ON & GasFloyd Blankanshlp dr.- Surface1320acres 14.78329%

19 Hugh MscRae Land Trust- TR 9-'CoalConsotfdsNcn Coal Company - Below Tglsr coal LeasedPennao. Inc, -Tiller and above coat LeasedPocehontes Qss Partnership- CBM LeasedCartes Hale Heka-Burhrce, ON &Gas40.87acres 45;77220%

1C. Hugh MecRse Lml Trust- TR 9-CoalCcffda88tfon tnud Company Below Tlllsl'ost LeasedPsnnso, Inc. -Titter and shove coal LeasedPccahontas Qas Partnership - CSM LeasedPocshontss Gss Partnership -Surface, 08 8 Gas13,39acres 14.99808%

1D. Hugh MacRsa Land Trust-TR 9-CoalConsolkfslhn Coal Company- Below TNlsr coal LeasedPermsc, Inc, - Tgler and shove coal LeasedPccshonlas Gas Partnershfp - CSM LeasedAmctd 8.Pete - Scrfsos, ON & Gee13,21 acres 14.79449%

Hugh Msogss Land Trust TR 9-CoatConsolktslnn Coal Company- Below Tiler coal LeasedParmeo. Inc. Tgisr and above coal LeasedPocahontst Gas Partnership - CSM LeasedPocshonhrv Qas Parmershlp Surlacs, ON 8 Gss5.12acres 5.7S412%

Hugh Macitas Lard Tinct- TR 9 - CoalConvogdatksr Coat Company-Behw Tiger cost LeasedPennac, tnn -Tgier and abpvs coat Leasedpocshcntas Gss cattnsrship - CBM LeasedLany Hale - ON & QasOh3 acme 0.69M7%

Carlos Hale Heks -Pee.2.7Sso~ MI7985%

Page t 9(13r00

Page Number 3.

Page 4: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

r OCAiiVPsTA8 i348 r~R7ir-rtb(9iF""Unit FF-24

Tract!dendllcstione

Bockhom Coal Mlnlng -Tr.1-Coal, 03 &CasConiolIegon Cool Company- Belovr TNer oonl Lensed

- Penneo, tno. - Tiller end shove coal LensedPocshontss Oes Pnrtnershfp - CBM Lensedagg acres . az4939Q

Page 2 9/1 380

Page Number 4.

Page 5: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

VGOB Disbursement

Unit FF24

VGOB-00-1017-0830-03

Fractional Net Acreage

Ownershi Ownership

P

in Tract in Tract

Royalty

Split

Agreement Disbursed Disbursed

Escrowed Percent of Disbursement

Acres EscrowedFunds

Table 1

Tracts: 1B

Item Tract Disbursement Table

Total acreage in escrow before disbursement 43.05000

1B Tract 1B (total acreage)1B Pamela Jo Keenet3707 Garden Creek Rd, Rowe, VA 24646

1B Jamie Henry Hale)1901 Lum Hollow Rd, Haysi, VA 24256

1B Jeffery Carlos Halet1926 Zacks Fork Rd., Lenoir, NC 28645

1B Pamela Jo Keenet3707 Garden Creek Rd, Rowe, VA 24646

1B Jamie Henry Hale)1901 Lum Hollow Rd, Haysi, VA 24256

1B Jeffery Carlos Halet1926 Zacks Fork Rd., Lenoir, NC 28645

Wells contributing to the escrow account: PGP FF24 W/PL

40.871/9

1/9

1/9

2/9

2/9

2/9

4.54114.54114.54119.0822

9.0822

9.0822

100.00%100.00%100.00%100.00%100.00%100.00%

4.541 1 1 0.5485%4.541 1 1 0.5485%

4.541 1 1 0.5485%9.0822 21.0969%9.0822 21.0969%9.0822 21.0969%

$16,879.69$16,879.69

$16,879.69$33,759.38$33,759.38$33,759.38

Page Number 5.

Page 6: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

Exhibit EUnit FF.24

Docket ¹VGOB.00-1017-0830-03List of Respondents that require escrow

(89.29Acre Unit)

Acresin Unit

Interest in

Unit

Tract ¹14.13 20 acres

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9c/o Alan Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akin LLP1 Bryant ParkNew York, NY 10036-6715

1.65 acres1/8 of 13.20acres

1.8479%

By Assignment and Bill of Sale, HML 7devised a// of ils right, tit/e and interest (o/her than "Excluded Assets 0 fo

Torch Energy Advisors /nc. effective September 4, 1991 and recorded in Buchanan County under DB474 / PG384

Torch Oil & Gas Companyc/o Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, NM 88030

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

The ownership listed be/ow is currenl/y being reviewed end documentation is being requested to verify title.

(2) Laura Hale Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns, et al. (1/8/nt.)

1.65 acres 1.8479%1/8 of 13.20 acres

(a) Leah Vernie Baldwin Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a.1) Veiva Marie Charles2066 Watkins StGrundy, VA 24614

(a.2) Opal Mattie Hunt

263 Donna AvenueMorgantown, WV 265D5

(a.3) Pauline Baldwin

5931 Berkshire Ct.Alexandria, VA 22303

0 D125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0 D125 acres1/132 ot1.65 acres

0.0125 acresI/1 32 of 1 65 acres

0 0140e%%d

D 0140%

0 0140%

(a.4) Leah Mae Mullins

(a.5) Beulah Diane Boyd1124 Beulah Land RdVansant, VA 24656

i i reeiiddemeecdmeaerd erd d rsw

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65 acres

Q Q14Q'/

(a.6) Laura Virginia Manier4022 Leemaster Dr

Vansant, VA 24656

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

Q Q140%

(a.7) Henry Nathan Baldwin, Jr.403 Surface Dr

Vansant, VA 24656

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0.0140'/e

(a.8) Judy Elizabeth HagyPO Box 104Vansant, VA 24656

0 0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0.014D%

(a.9) Gary Raymond Baldwin Heirs

Devisees, Successors or Assigns

(a.9 1) Jody Baldwin341 Pennsylvania Ave

Salem, VA 24153

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1 65 acres

0 0140%

(a.10) Bradley Dean Baldwin1124 Beulah Land Rd.Vansant, VA 24656

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0.0140%

Page1of5 1 1/9/201 5

Page Number 6.

Page 7: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

Exhibit EUnit FF-24

Docket 6VGOB-00-1 017-0830-03List of Respondents that require escrow

(89.29Acre Unit)

Acresin Unit

InterestinUnit

(a.11) James Curtis Baldwin1261 Baldwin Rd.Vansant, VA 24656

(a.12) Samuel Marcus Baldwin, II

0 0292 acres7/396 of 1.65acres

i imsitous escvmvs id i svd dorsrf

0.0327%

(a.13) Brandon Scott Baldwin

P.O. Box 592Vansant, VA 24656

0.0042 acresI/396 of 1.65acres

0 0047%

(a 14) Samantha Leah Baldwin1947 Little PraterGrundy, VA 24614

(b) Lizzie Trula Greenwood4518 Maple Grove RoadHampstead, MD 21074

(c) Ada Nell Stiltner Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Asmgns

(c.1) Patnma G RiceRt I Box 425Vansant, VA 24656

0.0042 acres1/396 of 1.65acres

0 1500 acres1/11 of 1.65acres

0.0250 acres1/66 of 1.65 acres

0 0047%

0 1680%

0.0280%

(c.2) Teresa Church917 Russell Fork River Rd.Haysi, VA 24256

(c.3) Shelia Miller

4138 Bioomingdale RdKingsport, TN 37660

(c 4) Vickis ViersRt.1 Box 425AVansant, VA 24656

(c 5) Terry BoydRt.1 Box 425AVansant, VA 24656

(c.6) Wayne StiltnerRt.1 Box 425AVansant, VA 24656

(d) Marcus Boyd853 J E Evans AveSmithville, TN 37166

(e) Ireson Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(e.1) Hassie C. Boyd236 Greenacres Dr

Smithville, TN 37166

0.0250 acres1/66 of 1.65acres

0.0250 acres1/66 of 1.65acres

0.0250 acresI/66 of 1.65acres

0.0250 acres1/66 of 1.65 acres

0.0250 acres1/66 of 1.65acres

0.1500 acres1/11 of 1.65acres

0.1500 acresI/11 of 1.65acres

0.0280%

0.0280%

0.0280%

0.0280'/

0 0280%

0.1680%

0.1680%

(f) Charles Milton Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Asmgns

(f 1) Annie Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(f.1.1) Lester BoydBox 182Vansant, VA 24656

0.0250 acres1/66 of 1 65 acres

0 0280%

(f.1.2) Helen Viola Coleman4522 Lovers Gap RdVansant, VA 24656

0.0250 acres1/66 of 1 65 acres

0 0280%

Page 2 of 5 1 1/9/201 5

Page Number 7.

Page 8: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

Exhibit EUnit FF-24

Docket ¹VGOB-00-1017-0830-03List of Respondents that require escrow

(89.29Acre Unit)

Acresin Unit

InterestinUnit

(f.1.3) Betty Perkins5632 Leemaster Dr

Vansant, VA 24656

(f.1.4) Peggy Tiller3742 Leemaster Dr

Vansant, VA 24656

(f 1 5) Joan B. Boyd4055 Leemaster Dr.

Vansant, VA 24656

(f 1.6) Barbara Evans1685 Peach Grove AvenueHarrisonburg, VA 22801

0.0250 acres1/66 of 1.65acres

0.0250 acres1/66 of 1.65 acres

0.0250 acres1/66 of 1 65 acres

0 0250 acres1/66 of 1.65acres

0.0280%

0.0280%

0 0280%

0.0280%

(g) Mary Boyd Cook Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(g.l) Edward Cook Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(g 1 1) Nancy Cook, widow

1032 E. BreckenridgeFerndale, Ml 48220

0.0375 acres1/44 of 1.65acres

0.0420%

(g 2) Lloyd CookRt.5 Box 535Grundy, VA 24614

0.0375 acres1/44 of 1.65acres

0.0420%

(g.3) Willard Cook He/rs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(g 3 1) Samantha Rose Levine

6228 E. Owens Ave.Las Vegas, NV 89110

(g.3.2) Greg E. Cook966 Cherry Blossom Ct.Highlands Ranch, CO 80126

(g.4) Ercil Cook Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(g.4.1) Mark CookPO Box 1732Honaker, VA 24260

(g.4.2) Eral Cook, Jr401 Chalan Gums Yuus CourtSine)a, Guam 96926

(g.4.3) Ursula CookAddress Linknown

0 0188 acres1/88 of 1.65acres

0 0188 acres1/88 of 1.65acres

0 0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0 0210%

0.0210%

0.0140%

0.0140%

0.0140%

(h) Marion Boyd, Jr. Heirs, Devisees,Successsors or Assigns

(h 1) Sandra Boyd StreetP.O. Box 595Vansant, VA 24656

(h.2) Larry Ireson BoydPO Box 265Vansant, VA 24656

(h.3) Sherry Boyd StacyP O. Box 980Vansant, VA 24656

0.0375 acres1/44 of 1.65acres

0.0375 acres1/44 of 1.65 acres

0.0375 acres1/44 of 1.65acres

0.0420%

0.0420%

0.0420%

Page 3 of 5 11/9/2015

Page Number 8.

Page 9: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

Exhibit EUnit FF-24

Docket 9V GOB-00-1017-0830-03List of Respondents that require escrow

(89.29Acre Unit)

Acresin Unit

interest in

Unit

(h 4) Rodney BoydHCR Box 29HGrundy, VA 24614

(i) Ardue Guy Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successsors or Assigns

(i1) Marshall Boyd4797 Hayden Crest Drive

Hilliard, OH 43026

0.0375 acres1/44 of 1.65acres

0 0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0 0420%

0 0140v/

(i.2) Thelma Boyd Laster1012 Destiny Rd

Big Rock, VA 24603

(i 3) Ferreg Boyd3117Leemaster Dr

Vansant, VA 24656

(i.4) James H. Boyd5810 Deskins RdVansant, VA 24656

(i.5) Anna Lou Boyd Cogey3631 Murphy RdVansant, VA 24656

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65 acres

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1 65 acres

0 0140%

0.0140%

0.0140%

0.0140%

(i.6) Estil Boyd Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(i.6.1) Katherine Boyd116 Villa Ln

Taylorsvige, NC 28681

(i.7) Charles BoydRt 1 Box 578-AVansant, VA 24656

(i.8) William P BoydRt.2 Box 464Vansant, VA 24656

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65 acres

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1 65 acres

0.0140%

0.0140'/

Q Q14Q/

(i.9) David G. BoydBox 54Vansant, VA 24656

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0.0140%

(i.10) Steve BoydRt.1 Box 415Vansant, VA 24656

0 0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0 0140%

(i.11) Robert G Boyd1082 Ardue & Jane Rd.Vansant, VA 24656

0.0125 acres1/132 of 1.65acres

0 0140%

(i.12) Cariie B Clevinger Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(i.12.1) Donald Clevinger404 Dark Run RdEgiston, VA 24087

(i.12.2) Franklin ClevingerRt.1 Box 503AVansant, VA 24656

0 0063 acres1/264 of 1.65 acres

0.0063 acres1/264 of 1.65acres

0 0070%

0.0070%

(3) James D. RasnakePO Box 1914Honaker, VA 24260

0.3000 acres2/11 of 1 65 acres

0.3360%

Page 4 of 5 11/9/2015

Page Number 9.

Page 10: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

Exhibit EUnit FF.24

Docket SVGOB-00-1017-0830-03List of Respondents that require escrow

(89.29Acre Unit)

Acresin Unit

Interest inUnit

Tmrr 0fP .0 52 ncn c

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr 9cfo Alan Senegal EsqGamp, Strauss, Akin LLP1 Bryant ParkNew York, NY 10036-6715

0.53 acres 0.5936%

CBM Rovaltv Owner IClaim from the Coal Estate Owner):

Torch Of 8 Gas CompanyMo Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDemmg, NM 88030

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

The ownership listed below is currendy being reviewed end documentation is being requested to verify title.

(1) Larry Hale

1910 Breckenndge RdOakwood, VA 24631

0.53 acres 0.5936%

Page 5 of 5 11/9/2015

Page Number 10.

Page 11: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

Exhibit EEUnit FF-24

Docket SVGO8 00.1017-083043List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements or Court Orders

Net Acresih Unit

InterestinUnit

Percent0'I Escrow

Tn 151A.1320

COAL OWNERSHIP

(I) Hugh Macrae Lend Trust, Tr.9do Alen Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akm LLPI Bryant ParkNew York, NY 10036-6715

1155 acres 12 9354'7 n/4

7/8 of 13.20 acres

By Assignment and Big of sa/e, HMLTdevrssd ag of rts ngnl, bffe end inleresl (alber than "Excluded Assets ) loTorch Energy Adv sore inc sf/seine Septembei 4, 1991and recorded in Buchanan County under DB4/4 /PG384

Torch Oil & Gas Companyr/o Sue Ann Creddock670 Done Ana Road SIV

Darning, NM 88030

OIL It GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) EE & E Fletcher Enterprisesdo Eddie Fletcher3652 Garden Creek RoadRows, VA 24646(piewously Ellen Flelchei)

11 55 acres 12 9354% n/a

7/8 of 13.20 acres

7 .rtHB -dll 87

COAL OWNERSHIP

(I) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9r/o Alan Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akin LLPI Bryant ParkNew York, NY 10036-6715

4087 acres 45.7722%

By Assrgnmenl end Bit at sale, HMLT devned sy of ils rUhl, liffe snd inferesl father than "Excluded Assels0 lo

Torch Energy Advisors Inc effeclt e september 4, 1991 and recorded in Buchanan counly under DB474 / pG384

Torch Dil!I Gas Companyc/o Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SW

Darning, NM 88030

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

Affidavit fiam Torch Oil & Gas Co., dated August 5, 2015 slating they make no claim to the CBM due to the current stsfe of law

The owners listed below am Plantilfs in Case Noi 1710-cv59

(I) Jeffery C Hale, et al

(ska Car/os Hen~/ Hale Hers)40.87 acres 45 7722%

(a) Lorene Hale Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns (I/3)

Psr will, hei rnlerssl rs lo be di idsd equayy among her 3 chrldren (DQD 10/3/2014)

(a I) Pamela Jo Keene3707 Garden Creek RoadRows, VA 24646

454 acresI/O of 40 87 acres

5 0856'4 10.5485% -100%

(a 2) Jamie Henry Hale

1901 Lum Hogow RoadHaysu VA 24256

4 54 I!cmsU9 of 40.87 acres

5 0858% 10.5485'/ -100'4

(a 3) Jetfery Carlos Hale1926 Zacks Fork RoadLenoir, NC 28645

4.54 acres1/9 of 40.87 acres

50858'y lb.5485'/ -1004

(b) Psmels Jo Keene3707 Garden Creek RoadRows, VA 24646

9.08 acres2/9 of 40 87 acres

lb.1716% 21.0969% -100'4

(c) Jamie Henry Hale1901 Lum Hollow RoadHaysi, VA 24256

9.08 acres2/9 of 40 87 acres

lb.1716% 21.0969% -100%

(d) Jeffery Carlos Hale1926 Zacks Fork RoadLenoir, NC 28645

908 acres2/9 of4087acres

10 1716% 21.0969% -100'4

Page I of 3 11/9I2015

Page Number 11.

Page 12: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

Exhibit EEUnit FF-24

Docket ¹VGOB 00-1017-0830-03List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements or Court Orders

Net Acresin Unit

IhtereetlhUnit

Percentof Escrow

7 .t ltIC - 13:ia

COAL OWNERSHIP

(I) tiugh Macrae land Trust, Tr 9c/o Alan Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Ak n LLPI Bryant ParkNew York, NY 10036-6715

1339 acres 14.9981 /. n/a

By Assrgnment and Br¹oi sale, HML 7 devised ag of its rrghl, etre and in/areal folb sr fhen "Exc/uded A see tag loTorch Energy Advisors inc efie cave September 4, 1991and recorded rn Buchanan Co only under DB4 74 / pG 384

Torch Oil 8 Gas Companydo Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, NM 88030

OIL Ii GAS OWNERSHIP

(I) CNX Gas Company LLC627 Claypool Hill Mall RdCedar Bluff, VA 24609/Prevously Pocahanlas Gas Parlnershrp)

7 r¹ID-13.21

13 39 acres ie 9981 /. n/a

COAL OWNERSHIP

(I) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr 9r/o Alen Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akr ~ LLpI Bryant ParkNew York, N Y 10036-6715

13.21 acres 14 7948/. n/a

By Assignmenl and Br/i of Sale, HML 7 devised ag of ils right, ti lie and in/eresi (o/her than "Excluded Assets) to

Torch Energy Advisors Inc. elfectrve Sap tembe 4, 1991and recorded rn Buchanan County under DB474 / PG 384

Torch Oil 8 Gas Companydo Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ans Road SWDarning, NM 88030

OIL Ii GAS OWNERSHIP

(I) Arnold S Hale Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assrgns

1321 acres 14.7879'/

440 4.9293% n/aI/3 of 13 21 acres

(s) Jane Hale (mdow)PO Box223Mavisdale, VA 24627(Conveyed by Deed of Gift detod Alrgusl 9, 2010 io Lrnda Dye and Tony R Hale)

(bl Linda Kay Dye6282 Swords Creek RoadSwords Creek, VA 24649

4.40 4 9293% n/sI/3 of 13.21 acres

(c) Tony R HalePO Box 3Mavisdale. VA 24627

440 4 9293'/ n/aI/3 of1321 acres

NOTE: Jane Hale recerved a check for 100% of the Disbursement from First Bank & TrustDeed of gift was received after the disbursement petition was filed and approved by the Board on 8/I 7/1 0Direct payment of future royaltres will be pard 1/3 each to the owners as listed above

Tract ¹IF.6 12

COAL OWNERSHIP

(I) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.gdo Alan Siegel EsqGump, Strauss, Akin LLPI Bryant ParkNew York, NY 10036-6715

512 acres 5 7341'4 n/a

By Assignmenl and Bi)/of Sale, HMLT dewsed allot Ss nghi, trt/e and rnteresl (olher loan 'Excluded Asse/s') toTorch Energy Advrsors inc effectrve September', 1991and recorded m Buchanan Couniy under DB4/4 /PG384

Page 2 of 3 11/9/2015

Page Number 12.

Page 13: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

Exhibit EEUnit FF-24

Docket ¹VGOB00-1gt 74I830-03List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements or Court Orders

Net Acresin Unit

InterestinUnit

Percent01 Escro

Torch Oil lt Ges CompanyNo Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SW

Darning, NM 88030

OIL IL GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) CNX Gas Company LLC

627 Claypooi Hill Mall RdCedar Bluff. VA 24500(Prevnus/y Pocahon/as Gas Parfnership/

5.12 acres 5 7341% n/e

Page 3 of 3 11/0/2015

Page Number 13.

Page 14: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

AFFIDAVIT OF MAILING

COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF BUCHANAN

Applicant: CNX Gas Company LLCRelief Sought: Disbursement Petition for FF24

VGOB: 00-1017-0830-03

I, Anita D. Duty, after being duly sworn upon oath, state as follows;

1. I am the Pooling Supervisor for CNX Land Resources, Inc. and am responsible for the notification

process required by Va. Code Ann. t'145.1-361.19of the Code of Virginia and 4VAC25-160-40.

2. That on November 12.2015 a true and correct copy of the Notice of Hearing and Exhibits were

mailed, via certified mail return receipt requested, based upon information and belief, the names and last-known

addresses, where such addresses are known, of the parties owning an interest in this cause are set forth and attached

hereto.

3. Notice of this cause has therefore been served by mail pursuant to the applicable statues and rules

of the Board.

r~a D. DutyPoo 'pervisorfor CNX Land LLC

STATE OF WEST VIRGINIA

COUNTY OF MERCER, TO-WIT:

TAKEN, SUBSCRmKD AND SWORN to before me this 544 day of Dts r ryyvh her

2015.

NotarfPublic

My commission expires: Inc,' I 3A 33I

OFFICIAL SLNotary Puhiio, Btste ol w

MELISSyh CVM2424 John NoshBlueheld, Wy 24

My oommtss n eepir e A

Page Number 14.

Page 15: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

Unit FF24I/GOB 00-1017-0830-03Disbursement

CERTIFICATION OF NOTICE

CNX Gas Company LLC

Last NameHale

Hale

Keene

Shaver

First NameJeffery C

Jamie

Fernale J

Jen

MAILED RECEIPT ¹

11/13/2015 700916800001089111/13/2015 700916800001089111/13/2015 700916800001089111/13/2015 7009168000010891

136613591342

1373

Receiyedll11/17/201511/17/201511/18/201511/18/2015 Courtesy copy

Page Number 15.

Page 16: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

8 I169 I 51EEEE41IIIIEEN8EENIMNI ENsreril

~ Complete Items 1, 2, and 3. Also completeitem 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired.

~ Print your name and address on the reverseso that we can return the card to you.

~ Attach this card to the back of the magpiece,or on the front if space permits.

I 1. Article Addressed to:

Ewvx IN8EINI I8NIENIIE Ni Nieve(Nv

A. Signature

fAddressee

S, Repfivdby (Prrnled Name), C. Date of Delivery

j' ~ 6 0.~ i I /8 CWD. Is delivery address different from Item 1'I O Yvs

If YES, enter delivery address below: Cf No

pamela Jo Keene

3707 GARDEN CREEK RD

Rowe VA 24646

700'l 1680 0001Ii

PS Form 3811,February 2004

S. Service Type

a& Mall E3 Expnas Mall

Cl Registered CI Return Receipt for Merchandise

Cf Insured Mail Cl C.O.D.

4. Restricted Dellveryf (Exfis Fee) CI Yes

08S1 13u2 &L ~9 Fr=2.Lj PFKDomestic Rgm Receipt Q jJJ

S'1EIIlela Nwvsviwawsaas IL%fENsrer

~ Complete items 1, 2, and 3.Also completeI

item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired.~ Piint your name and address on the reverse

so that we can return the card to you.~ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,

or on the front if space permits.

1. Article Addressed to:

Jeffery Carlos Hale

1926 ZACKS FORK RD

LENOIR NC 28645-7665

A Signature ~fyxdyt j~Cf Agent

CI Addressee

B. Received by (Pifnred Name) [ C. Date of Delivery

;TF Z(er6 LJAL.el.D. Is delivery ifgfs fi)lm item 12 O Yes

If YES elivery sd gfsg~+c'94

NOV17 Ã~<

3. Serv Type

LS Cert Mali Mall

CI Reglste, stum Receipt for Merchandise

C3 Insured Mail E3 C.O.D.

4. Restricted Deliveryf IExfis Fee) C3 Ves

7009 1680 0001 08'll 1366 FL~V Fj gQ F/-25i PS Form 3811,February 2004 Domestic Return Reggae 'Q "J-| 152525-52-M-1 540

$9d iv I st Esfavreiiwaawsaas iswEEN8181 I EIIMEIIweatvwwrl, Nlewwvl vw wII eel IEII'

Complete items 1, 2, and 3.Also complete

item 4 if Restricted Delivery is desired.

~ Print your name and address on the reverse

so that ws can return the card to you.

~ Attach this card to the back of the mailpiece,

or on the front If space permits.

1. Article Addressed to:

(S~celvsdby (Printed (feme) C. Date of Delivery

..Icfry) E'+ l f /(-(7- IKD. Is delivery address digsieia from Item 12 0 Yss

If YES, enter delivery address below: I4HNO

Jamie Henry Hale

1901 LUM HOI LOW RD

HAYS I VA 24256-5271

IIII19 168II IIIIII1 58

PS Form 3811,February 2004

3. Service Type

ag Certified Mall Cl Express Mail

E3 Registered Ci Return Receipt for Merchandise

0 Insured Mail 0 C.O.D.

4. Restricted Delivsryf (Extra Fee) 0 Yes

a1 1359 6+2.g PF Z.t(.'Pl 2,5Domestic Return Receipt- 1 Iewp'f $0I 15255552.M 1545

Page Number 16.

Page 17: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

USPS.comfg) - USPS Tracking Page 1 of 2

E giin c st mere ice Usne u bil R 9 t* IS>9

m&USPS.CON'SPS

Tracking EBCustomer Service >

Have questions? We'e here to help.

Get Easy Tracking Updates >

Sign up for My USPS.

Tracking Number: 70091680000108911373

Updated Delivery Day: Wednesday, November 18, 2015

Product 8 Tracking Information Available Actions

Postal Product: Features:Certified Mail Text Updates

DATE & TIME STATUS OF ITEM LOCATION Email Updates

November 18, 2015, 12:50pm

Delivered ABING DON, VA 24210

Your ifsm was delivered at 12 50 pm on November 18 2015 in ABINGDON, VA 24210

November 18, 2015, 9 08am

Available for Pickup ABINGDON, VA 24212

November 18, 2015, 9.05am

Amved at Unit ABINGDON, VA 24210

November 16, 2015, 4 37em

Departed USPS Faulity KNOXVILLE, TN 37950

November 15, 2015, 11 35pm

Arrived et USPS Faolity KNOXVILLE, TN 37950

November 14, 2015, 3:28am

Departed USPS Faolily CHARLESTON, INV 25350

November 13, 2015, 10 09pm

Aaived at USPS Faulity CHARLESTON, VW 25350

Track Another PackageTracking (or receipt) number

70091880000108911373 Track It

Manage Incoming PackagesTrack aa your packages from a dashboardNo tracking numters necessary

Sign up for My USPS >

https://tools.nsps.corn/go/TrackconfirmAction?qtc tLabels1=70091680000108911373 12/4/2015Page Number 17.

Page 18: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

0 0 WWW 0d

W

08 Odd 00

0W

I 0 d

I I

Q t0

0

0 d

00

d 0

I

0 0

0 Q

d

d

dW 0

W 00

0

0Q 0 0 Q d d d 0ddddddddddddddddddd'''''d Odd 0 8 0t

W

C0

CO~I

C0

C C~ OC

C

CDD

2CtC

0 0d d o o o o o o 0 0 0 0 0

0 0 o o o o o o o o o o o 0 o o o o o o o o 00 0 0 0 0 0 o o Q o o o o o o o o 0 0 o Q o o o o o o 0 o 8d o d d d d o 0 0 0 o o o o o d o 0 0 0 o o o o ' d 0 0

0 0 o o d o 'I0 0 0 0 d d d 0ddddddddddddddddddd'd'0''''od''dw'

0 0 I 00

0 t

0

0 0

00

W

0

00

'0

00

0

W

0 00

W

0SKKK88KKKZ

00

Dt 00

0

0

0 d

0

00

W00 0

d00 0

WI

8

0

0D0

0 0d0

tI

0d 0

d

'I'0I

d

8 00 0

W

00 0d

d

Page Number 18.

Page 19: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

W

0

00

06 I

00 W46 0 0

00 8 $ 80

0W d

0 0d

e 0

0 0d

W

IWI

N

W dt d

0 0 0 0I

d"8 I 6 0

Xt

d 6 I

d

60'4

6O

0 00 06 o 6 0 00 o o o o 00 0 0 0 o o o o o o 0 0 0 o o 0 o o o o 0 0 0 o o 0 o o o 0 o o 0 Q o 5 o o o 0 06 6 6 o 6 6 0 0 0 6 o o 6 6 0 0 o o o o 6 6 6 6 o o o 6 0 o o 6 6 o 0 o 6 0 o o 6

aC~ OCO

0Ct

OWWW0 t

o e I

W

0e 0 0 0

d WW

W0

t

WI

00

0'I

00 0

d 6 0t

0W

0

Xe

0

00

0

0

0 00

0

00

00 8

00

W

0 0

t

O Cj

'I

0 0I g 6

5W0 0 0

0 0

000

0

8

00 0 0

0I

0

W

0 00

0 00

W

W W

00

I

Page Number 19.

Page 20: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

C

0

I I I I

d

iWAR

d

W

0

08 d

WW

0d0W

g

0

dd d

d

I

d 0d 0

0d'i

00F

d'

NI 0 d

W

4 d d 00 0

A

N 0 d Wd I d d d

W

0 0

00aCC

Ã8 o

0 0

40 OI

0 IP0Ci Q

Cd

0

W W

d dd d d

dI I 0

0 d o I dI0 d II

0 W

D

O o Nd 6

00

W d

W

00

0 00 0

0 0

0

0 0d

d

I

00 0 0 0

0I

0 0KNB I 0 0

0 N

W

D I I

0 6I

0 8 0 8 8 0 0

00 0 0 0

00

888 0

0 00

00

0 0

I

d0 0 00

0

0 08

0 8 8

I

d d

880

0

8

e

0

Page Number 20.

Page 21: J.€¦ · (1) Hugh Macrae Land Trust, Tr.9 c/o Alan Siegel Esq Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP 1 Bryant Park New York, NY 10036-6715 1.65 acres 1/8 of 13.20acres 1.8479% By Assignment andBill

0

0 E

06 0

0 0

0ccCl

Cl

Ã

sl el

CIIODD

I=e

0 I

OI

P. 00 Q

ce

0 00

,8

U

0

II«I I

0I

I II

c00I II

DI

I

CD

'0ClC

Ee

0

El ~E

0O cc.5 .50 60 0

ECl

t'OCl

Ct

CD

CI

e0

M

W

CI

CCD

0

Page Number 21.