IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM…...

23
IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T LIKE THAT ONE?! The Evolution of Modern Liberalism

Transcript of IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM…...

Page 1: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDESUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM…

OPPOSE CAPITALISM.SUPPORT SOCIALISM…OPPOSE COMMUNISM.

SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM… NOW WE DON’T LIKE THAT ONE?!

The Evolution of Modern Liberalism

Page 2: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.
Page 3: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Evolution of the idea of freedoms Classical liberalism – negative freedoms

“Freedom from…” (oppression, control, e.g. freedom of conscience)

Industrial Rev – growth of capitalism, equality of opportunity can create inequality

Modern liberalism – positive freedoms “Freedom to…” (you cannot be free if your basic needs

aren’t met –e.g. freedom to access education, health care)

Great Depression, World Wars, urbanization, globalization = progressives: gov intervention to ensure equality of outcome

Page 4: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Post World War Two

Liberal philosophy drifted further left acceptance of programs part of the

welfare state supported by liberals. e.g. universal health care & CPP

Page 5: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Journal Entry

Discuss the bias in the video clip by providing examples.

Do you agree or disagree with the producer? Explain your reasoning

Page 6: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Can you see any bias?

Page 7: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Journal Entry

Discuss the bias in the video clip by providing examples.

Do you agree or disagree with the producer? Explain your reasoning

Page 8: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Stop and reflect-journal entry

After we have gone through the discussion, record the following

How does supply side economics differ from demand side economics?

Which theory do you support more? Why?

Page 9: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Neo-conservative reaction

Like modern liberals, there are many ways to define a neo-con. Most common characteristic:

Reaction to liberal principles that had “gone too far”• Civil rights movement leads to affirmative action• Weakness of using diplomacy in dealing with enemies

(détente efforts in Cold War)• Increasing debts and abuse of tax dollars by liberal

programs like health care• Failure of public education • Lack of morality in society by focusing on individual rights,

or allowing faith based tribunals like Sharia law

Page 10: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

USA in the 1970s

Growing government debtHigh levels of taxationIncreased costs to business due to higher wages,

benefits and working conditions (unions), and government regulations (like minimum wage and environmental laws)

Increased cost of living (especially after 1973 OPEC embargo)

= inflation (due to government spending and high cost of managing debt) and unemployment (due to economy that provided few incentives for investment)

Page 11: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.
Page 12: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

A trillion dollars (see the little guy beside it?!) – these are $100, not $1

bills.

Page 13: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Supply Side Economics

Page 14: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Chicago School – Friedrich von Hayek

Believed that government intervention in the economy was first step towards totalitarianism

Pure free-market principles were the best way to encourage economic growthOpposed demand-side economics

Demand side felt the government would give money to the people to spur the economy

Supply side felt that the government should let people keep their money to invest in the economy

Page 15: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Milton Freidman

economic systems have “leakages” that cause the extremes in the business cycle by limiting demand “leakages” - individual income saved in banks, income lost to taxes,

monies spent on imported goods

These can be balanced with “injections” “injections” - businesses borrowing for investment, government

spending, exports

Keynes (demand-side) wanted gov. to increase injections (fiscal policy) – Friedman felt government should prevent the leakages (monetary policy) felt changes in the business cycle were due to inept politicians

mismanaging the stock of money

government should be limited to protecting property rights, printing money, and maintaining law and order

Page 16: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Friedman

Page 17: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Friedman, part two

Page 18: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

“Trickle-down Economics” “Reaganomics” “Thatcherism”

(Klein in Alberta)

Stagflation (USA) – while fiscal and monetary policy worked in the 1960s, it was not working in the 1970s.

1980 - Ronald Reagan elected on platform of decreasing government involvement in economy to reduce national debt cut government regulations, social program spending

and income taxes (corporate and personal) to encourage production (although he did not cut military spending).

Initially this system worked, but in the end it left the economy with a greater debt (military spending)

Page 19: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Reagan on Reaganomics

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZzVGefEo2yU&feature=related

Page 20: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.
Page 21: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.
Page 22: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

Stop and reflect-journal entry

How does supply side economics differ from demand side economics?

Which theory do you support more? Why?

Page 23: IT’S A ROLLERCOASTER RIDE SUPPORT CLASSIC LIBERALISM… OPPOSE CAPITALISM. SUPPORT SOCIALISM… OPPOSE COMMUNISM. SUPPORT MODIFIED LIBERALISM … NOW WE DON’T.

An argument against it - Buffet