It Gov Books

download It Gov Books

of 53

Transcript of It Gov Books

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    1/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Some thoughts on how IT risk, control,

    audit and assurance is evolving beyond COBITtoward the broader concept of IT

    governance; why IT governance should be onthe board agenda wherever IT is strategic to

    the business; how it fits in the broaderconcepts of enterprise governance and howmanagement and boards can address it.

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    2/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    &Are they doing the right things?

    &Are they doing them the right way?&Are they being done well?

    &Are we getting benefits?

    What ITproblem?

    IT governance is the responsibility of the board of

    directors and consists of the leadership, organisational

    structures and processes that ensure that the

    organisations IT sustains and extends the organisations

    strategies and objectives.

    What doesthe board

    do?

    &Cascading strategy and goals&Organisational alignment

    &A control framework

    &Balanced business scorecard

    How doesmanagement

    react?

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    3/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    & Stakeholders& Governance Framework& IT Alignment & Value Delivery& Performance Measurement

    & Risk Management& Security& Conclusions

    & Stakeholders& Governance Framework& IT Alignment & Value Delivery& Performance Measurement

    & Risk Management& Security& Conclusions

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    4/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Stakeholders Apply PressureStakeholders Apply Pressure

    Shareholders and Executive

    Lower cost, higher profitability andLower cost, higher profitability andincreased market shareincreased market share

    Customers and Staff More functionality at lower cost andMore functionality at lower cost andgreater ease of usegreater ease of use

    Society Greater accountability for executives inGreater accountability for executives in

    private and public sectorprivate and public sector

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    5/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    EE--biz Factsbiz FactsGuarantee of delivery

    Customer loyalty

    Ease ofuse

    Customer serviceSecurity

    WhatWhat AArere CCustomersustomers SSaying ?aying ?

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    6/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Focus on operational risk within which

    security and IT are very significant

    All major risk issues have been caused by

    breakdowns in

    Internal control

    Oversight

    Information technology

    WhatWhat SSignalsignals AArere RRegulatorsegulators GGiving?iving?Federal ReserveFederal Reserve

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    7/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Concern for extreme dependence of industryon IT

    Two recommendations Awareness of senior company officers

    Need to address three technical improvementsAuthenticateSegregate

    Make accountable

    President Clintons Commission onPresident Clintons Commission on

    Critical Infrastructure ProtectionCritical Infrastructure Protection

    WhatWhat SSignalsignals AArere RRegulatorsegulators GGiving?iving?

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    8/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Cadbury: strengthen internal controlboards need to set

    strategic aims, provide leadership, supervise management and

    report to shareholders on their stewardship.

    Turnbull: board to assure appropriate and effective processes

    to monitor risk and effectiveness of the system of internal control

    broader corporate governance role for audit committees...monitor

    and report on risks...

    BIS: ...governance arrangements for critical systems should be

    effective, accountable and transparent

    WhatWhat DDoo SStandardstandards SSay ?ay ?

    Stewardship is extending to IT as boards question the depth ofStewardship is extending to IT as boards question the depth of

    their enterprises reliance on IT.their enterprises reliance on IT.

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    9/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    IT has been the longest running disappointment in business in the last 30 years!

    Jack Welch, Chairman, General Electric, World Economic Forum, Davos, 1997Jack Welch, Chairman, General Electric, World Economic Forum, Davos, 1997

    Personal & visualPersonal & visual

    contactcontact

    Uncertainty,Uncertainty,

    complexity &complexity &

    growthgrowth

    Technology can help fulfil a visionary dream, but often its use is closer to a

    sobering nightmare!

    Vesa Vaino, CEO Merita Bank, SIBOS, Helsinki, 1998Vesa Vaino, CEO Merita Bank, SIBOS, Helsinki, 1998

    WhatWhat IIss MManagementanagement TThinking ?hinking ?

    I am writing a book on the history of information technologyin order to better

    understand why it is such a mess!

    Philippe Corniou, CIO, Renault, IT Governance Forum, Paris, 2001Philippe Corniou, CIO, Renault, IT Governance Forum, Paris, 2001

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    10/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    & Stakeholders& Governance Framework& IT Alignment & Value Delivery

    & Performance Measurement& Risk Management& Security& Conclusions

    & Stakeholders& Governance Framework& IT Alignment & Value Delivery

    & Performance Measurement& Risk Management& Security& Conclusions

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    11/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Due diligence

    IT is critical to the business

    IT is strategic to the business

    Expectations and reality dont match

    IT hasnt gotten the attention it deserves IT involves huge investments and large risks

    Why Get Into Governance?Why Get Into Governance?

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    12/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Due diligence

    y Infrastructure and productive functions

    y Skills, culture, operating environmenty Capabilities, risks, process knowledge and customer

    information

    y Service levels

    Why Get Into Governance?Why Get Into Governance?

    Enterprises should be equally inquisitive about themselves.Enterprises should be equally inquisitive about themselves.

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    13/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    This criticality arises from:

    y The increasing dependence on information and the systems andcommunications that deliver it

    y The dependence on entities beyond the direct control of the

    enterprisey IT failures increasingly impacting reputation and enterprise value

    y The potential for technologies to dramatically changeorganisations and business practices, create new opportunitiesand reduce costs

    y The risks of doing business in an interconnected worldy The need to build and maintain knowledge essential to sustain

    and grow the business

    IT Is Critical to Most BusinessesIT Is Critical to Most Businesses

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    14/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    If so, wouldnt you want to know whether your

    organisations information technology is:

    y Likely to achieve its objectives?y Resilient enough to learn and adapt?

    y Judiciously managing the risks it faces?

    y

    Appropriately recognising opportunities and acting onthem?

    IT Is Strategic to Most BusinessesIT Is Strategic to Most Businesses

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    15/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Harness and exploit IT to

    deliver business value

    Provide fast development,

    with appropriate quality and

    with securityAscertain that IT investments

    have a quantitative return and

    IT does more with less

    Move from efficiency and

    productivity gains towards

    value creation and businesseffectiveness, especially in

    industries requiring that the

    focus move from the back

    office to the front office

    Business losses, reputational damage

    or a weakened competitive position

    Enterprise effectiveness and core

    processes directly impacted by the

    quality ofIT deliverables

    The failure ofIT initiatives intended to

    bring innovation to the enterprise to

    achieve their promise

    Technology that is inadequate for the

    enterprise or obsolete too soon

    Poor support for the businessDeadlines that are not met

    Costs that are higher than expected

    and quality and efficiency lower than

    anticipated

    ExpectationsExpectations RealityReality

    Managing Information Technology

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    16/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    y IT requires more technical insight than do otherdisciplines to understand how IT

    Enables the enterprise Creates risks

    Gives rise to opportunities

    y IT has traditionally been treated as an entity separate to

    the businessy IT is complex, and even more so in the extended

    enterprise operating in a networked economy

    Why Has IT Not GottenWhy Has IT Not Gotten

    the Attention It Merits?the Attention It Merits?

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    17/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    IT Involves Huge Investments andIT Involves Huge Investments and

    Large RisksLarge Risksy October 1992: A new command and control

    system developed by the London ambulanceservice failed on the first day of operation.

    yAugust 1997: UK investment managers, Save &Prosper, abandoned a major new IT system,having spent 2 million pounds on its design andimplementation.

    y 1997: Barings Bank collapsed as a result ofunauthorized trading, in part enabled by the willfulmanipulation of management information.

    y October 1998: UK Internet bank Egg launched anew online-only credit card, only to find its technicalinfrastructure was unable to cope with the demand.

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    18/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    What Should Boards Do About It?

    yBe driven by stakeholder value

    yAdopt an IT governance framework

    y

    Ask the right questionsyFocus on ITsAlignment with the business

    Value delivery

    Risk managementyMeasure results

    IT Value

    Delivery

    Stakeholder

    Value Drivers

    Performance

    Measurement

    Risk

    Management

    IT

    Strategic

    Alignment

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    19/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    What Should Management Do About It?

    yAlign IT strategy with business goals

    yCascade strategy and goals down into the organisation

    ySet up organisational structures that facilitate strategy

    implementationyAdopt a control and governance framework

    yProvide IT infrastructures that facilitate creation and sharing ofbusiness information

    yEmbed responsibilities for risk management in the organisationy Focus on important IT processes and core IT competencies

    yMeasure performance (balanced business scorecard)

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    20/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Starts from the premise that IT needs todeliver the information that the enterprise

    needs to achieve its objectives.

    Promotes process focus and process

    ownership

    Divides IT into 34 processes belonging to fourdomains and provides a high level control

    objective for each

    Looks at fiduciary, quality and security needs

    of enterprises,providing seven information

    criteria that can be used to generically define

    what the business requires from IT

    Is supported by a set of over 300 detailed

    control objectives

    Effectiveness

    EfficiencyAvailability

    Integrity

    Confidentiality

    Reliability

    Compliance

    Planning

    Acquiring & Implementing

    Delivery & Support

    Monitoring

    CCOBIOBIT: An IT Control FrameworkT: An IT Control Framework

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    21/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    CCOBIOBIT: An IT Control FrameworkT: An IT Control Framework

    Recent CRecent COBIOBIT developments added a management andT developments added a management and

    governance layer, providing management with a toolboxgovernance layer, providing management with a toolbox

    containing:containing:

    Performance measurement elements (outcome measures andperformance drivers for all IT processes)

    A list of critical success factors that provides succinct non-

    technical best practices for each IT process

    A maturity model to assist in benchmarking and decision-making

    for control overIT

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    22/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Several definitions with common elements:

    Responsibility of the board of directors

    Protects shareholder value

    Ensures risk transparency

    Directs and controls IT investment, opportunity, benefits and risks

    Aligns IT with the business while accepting IT is a critical input to

    and component of the strategic plan, influencing strategic

    opportunities Sustains the current operation and prepares for the future

    Is an integral part of a global governance structure

    IT Governance Defined (1)IT Governance Defined (1)

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    23/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    IT governance, like other governance subjects, is

    the responsibility of executives and shareholders

    (represented by the board of directors). It consistsof the leadership and organisational structures and

    processes that ensure that the organisations IT

    sustains and extends the organisations strategies

    and objectives.

    IT Governance Defined (2)IT Governance Defined (2)

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    24/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    SetSetmeasurablemeasurablegoalsgoals

    CompareCompareresultsresults

    MeasureMeasureperformanceperformance

    Act if notAct if notalignedaligned

    DeliverDeliveragainst theagainst the

    goalsgoals

    IT Governance FrameworkIT Governance Framework

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    25/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    IT Governance FrameworkIT Governance Framework

    Provide

    Direction

    Compare

    Measure

    Performance

    IT ActivitiesIncrease automation

    (make the business

    effective)

    Decrease cost

    (make the enterprise

    efficient)

    Manage risks

    (security, reliability and

    compliance)

    ITis aligned with thebusiness

    IT enables the

    business and

    maximises benefits

    IT resources are used

    responsibly

    IT-related risks are

    managed appropriately

    Set Objectives

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    26/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    IT Governance Activities BBooaarrdd aanndd//oorrMMaannaaggeemmeenntt

    AAccttiivviittyyTTyyppee

    Become informed of role and impact ofIT on the enterprise B/M Plan

    Set direction and expected return B Direct

    Determine required capabilities and investments M Plan

    Assign responsibilities B/M Direct

    Sustain current operations M Organise

    Make transformation happen B/M Direct

    Define constraints within which to operate B Direct

    Acquire and mobilise resources M Organise

    Measure performance B Control

    Manage risk B/M Control

    Obtain assurance B Control

    IT Governance Activities & SubjectsIT Governance Activities & Subjects

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    27/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    y The objectives ofInformation technologyhow it:- Improves cost-efficiencies- Creates revenue enhancement- Supports the building of new capabilities- Enables core business processes- Enables new business models

    y The opportunities and risks of new technology:- Internet and intranet- E-commerce- Mobile computing- Workflow technology- Knowledge systems, etc.

    y The key processes and core competencies:- The return on investment ofIT projects and initiatives, and how they deliver

    against expectations- Performance ofIT services against service level agreements- IT risks, asset protection and information security- IT acquisition and outsourcing strategies- Important IT processes such as change, application and problem management- Core IT competencies: planning, support, operations, project management,

    knowledge management-

    Ethical behavior, data privacy and fraud prevention

    IT Governance Subjects

    IT Governance Activities & SubjectsIT Governance Activities & Subjects

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    28/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    & Drivers& Stakeholders& Governance Framework& IT Alignment & Value Delivery&

    Risk Management& Performance Measurement& Security& Conclusions

    & Drivers& Stakeholders& Governance Framework& IT Alignment & Value Delivery&

    Risk Management& Performance Measurement& Security& Conclusions

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    29/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    The Board should drive business alignment by:

    Ascertaining that the IT strategy is alignedwith the business strategy Ascertaining that ITdelivers against the strategy through clear expectations and measurement

    Directing IT strategy to balance investments between supporting and growing the enterprise

    Making considered decisions about where IT resources should be focused

    IT alignment is a journey, not a destination.

    Business

    Strategy

    Alignment

    Activities

    IT Operations

    IT StrategyBusiness

    Operations

    IT AlignmentIT Alignment

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    30/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    The board should drive alignment to ensure that IT delivers value:

    With the business strategy focusing on competitive advantage, elapsed time for order/service

    fulfillment, customer satisfaction, customer wait time, employee productivity and profitability Supported by an IT strategy that delivers on time, within budget and with the benefits that were

    promised

    IT value is in the eye ofthe beholder.

    Business Unit Financial

    Business Unit Operational

    Business Unit IT Applications

    Firm-wide ITInfrastructure

    Time for Business Impact

    Business Value DeliveredSample Measures

    Revenue growthReturn on assetsRevenue per employee

    Time to bring a newproduct to market

    Sales from new productProduct or service quality

    Implementation time:new application

    Implementation cost:

    new application

    Infrastructure availabilityCost per transactionCost per workstation

    BusinessBusinessManagementManagement

    ITITManagementManagement

    Degree of influence

    IT Value DeliveryIT Value Delivery

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    31/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    The board should manage enterprise risk by:

    Ascertaining that there is transparency about the significantrisks to the organisation

    Being aware that the final responsibility for riskmanagement rests with the board

    Being conscious that risk mitigation can generatecost-efficiencies

    Considering that a proactive risk management approachcreates competitive advantage

    Insisting that risk management is embedded in theoperation of the enterprise

    IT Risk ManagementIT Risk Management

    It is the IT alligators you do not see that will get you!

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    32/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Risk Management Expands.

    Risk Allocation - contracts, SLAs, etc.

    Risk Mitigation - security & control practices

    Risk Transfer - insurance & liability

    Risk Assurance - audit & certification

    Risk Acceptance - formal, transparent

    IT Risk ManagementIT Risk Management

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    33/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Information

    Financial

    Customer ProcessGoals Measures

    Goals Measures

    LearningGoals Measures

    Goals Measures

    IT Goals and MeasuresIT Goals and Measures

    IT Balanced ScorecardIT Balanced Scorecard

    Ifyou are playing the enterprise game and not

    keeping ITs score, you are only practising.

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    34/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    # of IT customers

    Cost per IT customer

    Cost-efficiency of IT

    processes up

    Delivery of IT value per

    employee

    Information

    Availability of systems

    & services

    Developments on

    schedule & budget

    Throughput &

    response times

    Amount of errors and

    rework

    Level of servicedelivery up

    Satisfaction of existing

    customers

    # of new customers

    reached

    # of new service

    delivery channels

    FFinancial

    CCustomer

    Staff productivity &morale

    # of staff trained in

    new techno/services

    Value delivery per

    employee up

    Increased availability

    knowledge systems

    LLearning

    PProcess

    Example IT MeasuresExample IT Measures

    IT Balanced ScorecardIT Balanced Scorecard

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    35/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Scorecard ObjectivesScorecard Objectives Demonstrate the value added by the IT organisation

    Establish a balanced set of measures for determining the effectiveness of

    the IT organisation

    Set guidelines for creating the IT strategic plan and linking it into

    operational plans

    Communicate and motivate IT performance in key areas as required by

    the business and its stakeholders

    Establish a framework for IT management reporting

    Approval of an IT scorecard by key stakeholders should be

    considered an IT governance best practice.

    Approval of an IT scorecard by key stakeholders should be

    considered an IT governance best practice.

    An IT scorecard is one of the most effective means to

    achieve IT and business alignment

    From Ron Saull, CIO InvestorsGroup, Ca

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    36/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    & Drivers

    & Stakeholders& Governance Framework& IT Alignment & Value Delivery&

    Risk Management& Performance Measurement& Security& Conclusions

    & Drivers

    & Stakeholders& Governance Framework& IT Alignment & Value Delivery&

    Risk Management& Performance Measurement& Security& Conclusions

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    37/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Information SecuritySome Practices for the Board RoomSome Practices for the Board Room

    Know what questions to ask

    Know what is neededRaise the awareness at the top

    Have clarity of purpose

    Measure your performance

    Keep on doing it

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    38/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Information SecuritySome Questions for the Board RoomSome Questions for the Board Room

    Would people recognise a security incident when they saw one? Would they ignore

    it? Would they know what to do about it?

    Does anyone know how many computers the company owns? Would management

    know if some went missing?

    Does anyone know how many people are using the organisations systems? Doesanybody care whether they are allowed or not, or what they are doing?

    Did the company suffer from the latest virus attack? How many did it have last year?

    What are the most critical information assets of the enterprise? Does management

    know where the enterprise is most vulnerable?

    Is management concerned that company confidential information can be leaked ?

    Has the organisation ever had its network security checked by a third party?

    Is IT security a regular agenda item on IT management meetings?

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    39/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    IT Security

    Requirements

    Shorter business cycles

    Need to involve/connect/tie in with more partners

    Network centric business models

    Leverage VPN, remote access, collaborative tools

    Manage Risk

    Internet - UNIX - TCP/IP

    More hackers, more tools

    Increased dependency on IT

    Leverage Opportunities

    E-cash, e-commerce, e-tc.

    Open, modular, scalable

    Security a commodity

    Technology Drivers

    Business Drivers

    Managing networked

    c/s systems

    Provenance control

    Non-sharable info

    Profiling users

    Trust.

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    40/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    How to sell to top management Different styles depending on function

    FUD Cost reduction

    Responsibility

    Differentiator

    Cost of security

    Strategic approach - benchmark - gapanalysis - choices

    IT Security Awareness

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    41/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Cost of ITSecurity

    Cost of security and control vs. IT BudgetCost of security and control vs. IT Budget

    5 - 10% 20 - 25% 45 - 50% 55%

    Cost ofnoncompliance

    Benchmarking

    Leadership

    Cowboy

    operation

    Baselineoperation

    GoodPractice

    Industryreference

    site

    = driver for change

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    42/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Tools & Technology

    Process

    Policy &Procedures

    Security

    ManagementHuman

    Behaviour& Culture

    System

    Access Control

    Network

    SegregationApplication

    Security

    1122

    33

    6655

    44

    Policy

    IT SecurityPerformance

    01996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    9288

    76

    64

    48

    42

    96

    Policies & procedures

    Security mgt

    Human behav. & culture

    Application security

    System access controlNetwork segregation

    1.

    2.

    3.

    4.

    5.

    6.

    10

    10

    20

    20

    20

    20100

    0Verypoor

    1

    Poor

    2

    Fair

    3

    Good

    4Verygood

    5

    Excel

    Legend for ranking used

    5 - Excellent: Best possible, highly integrated

    4 - Very good: Advanced level of practice

    3 - Good: Moderately good level of practice

    2 - Fair: Some effort made to address issues

    1 - Poor: Recognise the issues

    0 - Very poor: Complete lack of good practice

    Legend for symbols used

    Average of best securityperformers in the financialindustry (begin 96)

    Company status Feb 97

    Company. objective for 2001

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    43/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Perform

    Intrusion

    Testing

    Perform

    Active

    Monitoring

    Issue

    Security

    Policy

    Security

    Management

    Design

    Security

    Defenses

    IT Security is a Continuous Effort

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    44/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    & Drivers

    & Stakeholders& Governance Framework& IT Alignment & Value Delivery&

    Performance Measurement& Risk Management& Security& Conclusions

    & Drivers

    & Stakeholders& Governance Framework& IT Alignment & Value Delivery&

    Performance Measurement& Risk Management& Security& Conclusions

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    45/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Objectivesy To understand the issues and the strategic importance ofIT

    y To ensure that the enterprise can sustain its operations and

    y To ascertain it can implement the strategies required to extend its

    activities into the future

    Goaly Ensuring that expectations forIT are met and IT risks are mitigated

    Positiony Within broad governance arrangements that cover relationships

    between the entity's management and its governing body, its owners

    and its other stakeholders and providing the structure through which:

    The entity's overall objectives are set

    The method of attaining those objectives is outlined

    The manner in which performance will be monitored is described

    IT Governance SummarizedIT Governance Summarized

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    46/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Become Informed About:

    Business and IT performance measures

    Business and IT outcome drivers

    IT strategic and alignment issues

    Best practices in IT governance

    Questions boards and management should ask

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    47/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    48/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Board Briefing on IT Governance

    TABLE OF CONTENTS

    Executive Summary........................................................................................................

    1. What Is IT Governance? ............................................................................................

    2. Why Is IT Governance Important?............................................................................

    3. Who Does It Concern?................................................................................................

    4. What Can They Do About It? ....................................................................................

    4.1 How Should the Board Address these Challenges?................................................

    4.2 How Should Executive Management Address the Expectations?...........................

    5. What Does It Cover? ..................................................................................................

    5.1IT Strategic Alignment ........................................................................................

    5.2IT Value Delivery.................................................................................................

    5.3 Performance Measurement ...................................................................................

    5.4 Risk Management.................................................................................................

    6. What Questions Should Be Asked? ............................................................................7. How Is It Accomplished?............................................................................................

    8. How Does Your Organisation Compare? ..................................................................

    9. What Do Regulatory and Standards Bodies Say? .....................................................

    Appendix A. IT Governance Checklist ..........................................................................Appendix B. Board Action Plan .....................................................................................

    Appendix C. Management Action Plan..........................................................................Appendix D. IT Governance Maturity Model ...............................................................

    Appendix E.The Emerging Enterprise Model ..............................................................

    Appendix F. Regulatory Reports on Governance..........................................................

    References.......................................................................................................................

    GG

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    49/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Best Practices

    Subjects of attention

    IT & Business Objectives

    Core IT competencies

    Business & Technology Developments

    MeasurementPerformance

    Measurement

    Results

    Activities

    Critical Success Factors

    WHO HOW

    V A R P

    V = IT Value Delivery A = ITStrategic Alignment

    R = Risk Management P = Performance Measurement

    IT Governance Toolkit

    IT GIT G

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    50/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    IT GIT G

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    51/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    Information Security Governance:Guidance forBoards of Directors and Executive Management

    Table ofContents

    PURPOSE AND STRUCTURE OF DOCUMENT...................................................................................

    INFORMATION SECURITY GOVERNANCE: A PRIMER FOR BOARDS OF DIRECTORS

    AND EXECUTIVE MANAGEMENT ......................................................................................................

    1.THE BACKGROUND TO INFORMATION SECURITYGOVERNANCE .............................................................

    2.WHATIS INFORMATION SECURITY? ......................................................................................................

    3.WHYIS INFORMATION SECURITYIMPORTANT? .....................................................................................

    4.WHO SHOULD BE CONCERNED WITH INFORMATION SECURITYGOVERNANCE?.......................................

    5.WHATSHOULDTHE BOARD AND MANAGEMENTDO? ............................................................................

    Understand Why Information Security Needs to be Governed...............................................................Ensure It Fits in the IT Governance Framework...................................................................................

    Take Board Level Action .....................................................................................................................

    Take Management Level Action...........................................................................................................

    6.WHATARE SOMETHOUGHT-PROVOKINGQUESTIONS TOASK? ..............................................................

    To Uncover Information Security Issues...............................................................................................To Find Out How Management Addresses the Information Security Issues...........................................

    To Self-assess Information Security Governance Practices...................................................................7.WHATSHOULD INFORMATION SECURITYGOVERNANCE DELIVER? ........................................................

    Strategic Alignment.............................................................................................................................Value Delivery ....................................................................................................................................

    Risk Management................................................................................................................................Performance Measurement..................................................................................................................8.WHATCAN BE DONE TO SUCCESSFULLYIMPLEMENTINFORMATION SECURITYGOVERNANCE?..............

    Questions for Directors .......................................................................................................................

    Questions for Managers ......................................................................................................................Adopt Best Practices ...........................................................................................................................

    Consider Critical Success Factors.......................................................................................................Introduce Performance Measures........................................................................................................

    9. HOWDOES MYORGANISATION COMPARE?...........................................................................................

    10.WHATDO REGULATORYAND STANDARDS BODIES SAY?.....................................................................REFERENCES ...........................................................................................................................................

    IT GIT G

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    52/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    IT is an integral partIT is an integral part

    of the businessof the business

    IT governance is anIT governance is an

    integral part ofintegral part of

    corporate governancecorporate governance

    IT GIT G

  • 8/3/2019 It Gov Books

    53/53

    INFORMATION

    SYSTEMSAUDIT AND

    CONTROL

    FOUNDATION

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    IT Governance InstituteIT Governance Institute

    3701 Algonquin Road, Suite 10103701 Algonquin Road, Suite 1010Rolling Meadows, IL 60008 USARolling Meadows, IL 60008 USAPhone: +1.847.253.1545Phone: +1.847.253.1545Fax: +1.847.253.1443Fax: [email protected]@isaca.org

    www.isaca.orgwww.isaca.orgwww.ITgovernance.orgwww.ITgovernance.org

    IT GovernanceIT Governance

    This information is provided for the educational use ofISACA members and chapters

    only. It is copyrighted by Information Systems Audit and Control Association. Any

    commercial use by chapters members or non members is strictly forbidden