Issuing securities

35
Issuing securities And considerable review

description

Issuing securities. And considerable review. Reading. 9, 10 (light on CAPM, heavy on SML), 12,13 (esp.13.1-13.4), 14.1, 15, 16, 18 (but not the appendix) 22.1, 22.3. Review Sessions. Review session: E. Chernobai, Weds., 12-11, NH 1110, 7:00-9:00. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Transcript of Issuing securities

Page 1: Issuing securities

Issuing securities

And considerable review

Page 2: Issuing securities

Reading 9, 10 (light on CAPM, heavy on SML),

12,13 (esp.13.1-13.4), 14.1, 15, 16, 18 (but not the appendix) 22.1, 22.3.

Page 3: Issuing securities

Review Sessions Review session: E. Chernobai, Weds.,

12-11, NH 1110, 7:00-9:00. Review session: Marshall, Thurs. 12-

12, NH 1006, 2:00-3:30.

Page 4: Issuing securities

Office hours Marshall: Weds. 3:30 - 5:00

Thurs. 3:30 - 4:30 Fri. 11:00 – 12:00

Ge: Sat. 10:30 – 12:00, 1:00 – 5:00 Sun. ditto

Chernobai: Fri. 10:00 – 12:00 Seo: Thurs. 10:00 – 12:00, 1:00 – 2:00,

3:30 – 5:00 Fri. 9:00 – 12:00

Page 5: Issuing securities

Review item What is a channel?

Page 6: Issuing securities

Answer Debt and equity are channels. They carry corporate earnings to investors. The debt channel is exposed to personal

taxes only. The equity channel is exposed to corporate

and personal taxes. Some tax-class clienteles value debt over

equity. Some value equity over debt.

Page 7: Issuing securities

Dividend review Dividend smoothing is a fact. We rarely

see firms changing dividend policy. The fact is hard to understand, because

dividends seem to be the basis of valuing firms.

Inescapable conclusion: Dividend policy is irrelevant to value of firms.

Page 8: Issuing securities

Elements of understanding Separation theorem (no taxes) Channels model (with taxes)

Page 9: Issuing securities

Separation theorem interpreted for dividends (Figure 18.4)

C1

C0

s lo p e = - (1 + r)

L o w -d iv id e n d fir m

H ig h -d iv id e n dfirm

w

F u tu rere tu rno r

d iv id e n d n o

Page 10: Issuing securities

Homemade dividends Investors who want higher dividends

sell some shares to get cash. Those who want lower dividends use

high dividends to buy more shares.

Page 11: Issuing securities

Dividend equilibrium

$ of operatingcash flows

HiDivvalueper $1

LoDivvalueper $1

mq ili riuo iv

EL

mEquilibriuHiD iv

u bD

V*=1/Rh V*=1/RL

...

Page 12: Issuing securities

Dividend smoothing explained Changing dividend policy does not raise

value. It hurts, if anything. Right now, December 2002, a tax decrease

is proposed for dividend income to individuals. The effects are unclear.

A firm that changes dividend policy correctly can potentially increase its value.

Page 13: Issuing securities

After the tax code changes firms raise their value by changing their

dividend policy in the right direction.

Page 14: Issuing securities

Cut in capital gains tax rates

$ of operatingcash flows inthe economy

HiDivvalue

LoDivvalue

Increased valueof old equity

More LoDivfirms

Page 15: Issuing securities

Dilemma for a firm Pay dividends: Shareholders pay extra

taxes. Invest in financial markets: Firm

becomes a mutual fund.

Page 16: Issuing securities

Solution: use the cash to buy stock

Investors who sell are those who want cash.

Stock price is unaffected … in theory. Stock price is little affected, in fact.

Page 17: Issuing securities

The IRS understands the buyback game.

Stock buyback for tax avoidance is illegal.

Therefore...

Page 18: Issuing securities

Excuses, excuses always another reason for a stock

buyback, usually ... our shares are a good

investment or...we disburse cash to prevent

takeover.

Page 19: Issuing securities

Summary Dividend policy is like capital structure. It probably doesn’t matter. If it does, it matters because of taxes,

and even that is temporary. In equilibrium, firms cannot increase

value by changing capital structure or dividend policy

Page 20: Issuing securities

The Costs of Public OfferingsProceeds Direct Costs Underpricing

(in millions)SEOs IPOsIPOs 2 - 9.9913.28%16.96% 16.36%

10 - 19.998.72%11.63% 9.65%20 - 39.996.93%9.70% 12.48%40 - 59.995.87%8.72% 13.65%60 - 79.995.18%8.20% 11.31%80 - 99.994.73%7.91% 8.91%

100 - 199.99 4.22%7.06%7.16%200 - 499.99 3.47%6.53%5.70%500 and up3.15%5.72% 7.53%

Page 21: Issuing securities

What is capital structure? The division of the value of the firms

assets between debt and equity.

Page 22: Issuing securities

Worrisome question When a firm sells debt and rebuys its

equity, the new equity is smaller than before. Doesn’t equity therefore lose?

Answer: Old equity got the gains. That is, shareholders at the time of the

restructuring got the gains.

Page 23: Issuing securities

The MM Propositions I & II (No Taxes)

P1: Value is unaffected by leverage P1: VL = VU

P2: Leverage increases the risk and return to stockholders(formula to follow)

Page 24: Issuing securities

Proposition II of M-M rB is the interest rate rs is the return on levered equity r0 is the return on unlevered equity B is value of debt SL is value of levered equity rs = r0 + (B / SL) (r0 - rB)

Page 25: Issuing securities

MM I with taxes VU = market value of the unlevered firm VL = market value of the levered firm B = market value of bonds TC = corporate tax rate result VL = VU + TC B

Page 26: Issuing securities

Short derivation Each year the tax shield is rBTCB Value of tax shield is rBTCB/rB = TCB

Page 27: Issuing securities

Effect of tax shield Increase of equity risk is partly offset by

the tax shield rS = r0 + (1-TC)(r0 - rB)(B/SL) Leverage raises the required return less

because of the tax shield.

Page 28: Issuing securities

MM II and WACC

Debt-to-equityratio (B/S)

Cost of capital: r(%)

.r0

rS

rB.0.200=

0.100

. rWACC

.0.2351

200370

Page 29: Issuing securities

ChannelsOperatingCashFlows=$1

Tc

Ts

(1-Tc)(1-Ts)1-Tb

Tb

Debtchannel

Equitychannel

Page 30: Issuing securities

Value asequity

Value asdebt

Operating C.F.’s ofthe whole economy

D of Institutions D of rich investors

V* = 1/Rb V* = 1/Rs

asdebt

as equity

Miller: Tax-class clienteles

Page 31: Issuing securities

Value asequity

Value asdebt

Operating C.F.’s ofthe whole economy

tax reform

increaseddebt

...

Page 32: Issuing securities

Exam review question A portfolio consists of the risk-free

asset and a risky asset A. The standard deviation of return on A is

.1. Portfolio weights are .5, .5. What is the standard deviation of the

portfolio?

Page 33: Issuing securities

Var RP( )

),(2

)()( 22

AfAf

AAff

RRCovxx

RVarxRVarx

Page 34: Issuing securities

Var RP( )

),()25(.2

)(25.)(25.

Af

Af

RRCov

RVarRVar

05.P

0025.)01(.25.

Page 35: Issuing securities