1

AeroSpace and DefenceIndustries Association of Europe

Issues in theAIA/ASD Suite of ILS Standards

Inputs to the KoM of the ILS Handbook

R. SomozaAirbus Military

Slide 2 27th June 2011

Overview of ILS standards

S3000L

S1000D

S2000M

LogisticSupportAnalysisactivities

TechnicalPubli-

cations

IP DataSubsets

Provisioningdata

Logs matand data

Operationaldata

LSAdata

Designdata

Equipment identificationdesign data

S4000M

Operational and maintenance data feedback – S5000F

In s

ervi

ce u

se

Des

ign

of s

yste

ms

and

supp

ort e

quip

men

t

IETM, other media

Pro-visioning

Orderadmini-stration

Slide 3 27th June 2011

Main issues on ILS Suite of Specifications(1/2)

• Global process unclear. “Ideal” ILS process is in practice impossible, but no room for parallel development (e.g., S3000L, S2000M and S1000D work) due to lack of synchronization mechanisms.

• Feedback relationship and orchestration (S1000D, S2000M, S5000F) unclear.

• Different business rules / criteria / formats (e.g., for applicability)

• No common data model. No common glossary or data dictionary.

• No real data integration – specifications are separate “silos”. No global / transversal view. Different product structures.

• Parallel evolution of different specifications, without coordination / configuration (“mixability” of specification versions?)

• Computational problems not considered (e.g, required parsing of applicability)

• Implementation costs of the specifications, cost of evolution

• Interfaces between specifications are bilateral – “explosion” of interfaces, circular relationships and coherence problem (e.g., S1003X+S1002X=S2003X?).

Slide 4 27th June 2011

Main issues on ILS Suite of Specifications(2/2)

• No common data exchange mechanisms.

• Exchange not part of the suite of specifications.

• Exchange of data of a SAME specification (e.g., between supplier & prime contractor) unclear, except for S2000M.

• Formal relationship with OASIS – Are the A&D DEXes formally endorsed by AIA/ASD? How is the evolution of these DEXes controlled? By whom?

• DEX implementation guidelines (e.g., for SOA) not established globally.

• No specification/cross-specification Implementor forums

• Civil/military convergence? (currently only used massively for S1000D)

• Use of ILS in civilian programs

• Need for specific annexes (e.g., domain-specific)?

• Standard integrated data delivery format (e.g., for maintenance systems)?

• Relationship with ATA beyond S1000D? (e.g., S4000M, Spec2000)

Slide 5 27th June 2011

Gaps in the ILS Suite

- Configuration of ILS products

- Operations

- Use of 3D (Technical publications, training, maintenance…)

- Orchestration of services

Slide 6 27th June 2011

OPERATOR

S E

R V

I C

E S

BASICPROCESSES

Support to Product Design

Customer Support

PRIMARY PROCESSES

Design the Product Support

Equipment

Product Design

INDUSTRY

Support Maintenance

Support Operation

SECONDARYPROCESSES

• Analyze Results

• Influence Design

• Design AGE

• Design Maintenance

Support

• DesignTraining Devices

• Develop Operational

Documentation

• Design Maintenance

Courses

• Design Crew Courses

• Develop MaterialDocumentation

• Prepare Material Support

• Develop Maintenance

Documentation

PRODUCT & SERVICES

• Maint. Program

• LCC

• Maintenability

• Reliability• Testability

• AGE• ATE• GSE

• Courses• Manuals

• IPC

• FSR• SB (Upgrades)

• MRO

• Operations Manual

Checklist• MMEL

• CBT• FFS• MST

• Courses• Manuals

• AMM• CMM• WDM

• IPL• Repair

Services

Mission &Operation of

Services

• Develop Services

Level Agreements

• Develop Processes

• Develop Documentation

• Deliver the Contracted

Service

Gro

up 1

Lo

gist

ic

Sup

port

A

naly

sis

Gro

up 2

S

uppo

rt

Equ

ipm

ents

&

Sim

ulat

ors

Gro

up 3

S

uppo

rt, M

aint

enan

ce

& O

pera

tions

Gro

up 4

C

usto

mer

S

olut

ions

Inte

gra

ted

Lo

gis

tic

Su

pp

ort

Pro

gram

O

ffice

Slide 7 27th June 2011

S E R V I C E S S C O P E O F A C T I V I T I E S

Mission & Operation of Services

Customer Services

Product Support

After Sales

• “Partnering”- Total services

delivery- Operation of assets

- PBL• “Outsourcing

”

• “…abilities”

• “Classic Disciplines”

- Customer Solutions- Services Centers- Repair Centers

- Logistic Services- PBH

- RMT- LSA

- LORA- LCC

- Technical Assistance- Material Support

- Training- Tech. Documentation

Cu

sto

me

r R

ela

ted

Pro

du

ct

Re

late

d

Slide 8 27th June 2011

Data Model and Exchange Working Group

ASD/AIA ILS Spec’s Organisation

ASD - CPSCCustomer & Product Support Committee

AIAProduct Support

Committee

ILS Spec Council

S2000MSteering Committee S3000L

Steering Committee S4000MSteering Committee S5000F

Steering Committee

CPSC Specifications

Group

NB S1000D has separate organisation

Slide 9 27th June 2011

ILS Suite Production plan

S2000M PLCSIss 6.0

ASD – STE100

S1000DIss 4.0 Iss 4.1

S2000M

S3000L Draft 0.1

S4000M

S5000F

Iss 4.0

2005 2006 2007 2008 20102009 2011

Draft 0.1

Iss 1.0

Iss 1.0Draft 0.1

Iss 4.0

S1

00

3X

Is

s 0

.1

S1

00

2X

S3

00

2X

Iss 5.0

2012S

10

03

X

Iss

1.0

S1

00

3X

Is

s 1

.1

Iss 1.1

Iss 6.0

Iss1.0

Iss 5.0

SX000IIss1.0

2013