IPE Presentation CAPCSD 2018 FINAL PDF HANDOUT · 4/9/18 1 IPE/IPP Integration into the Curriculum...
-
Upload
truonglien -
Category
Documents
-
view
218 -
download
0
Transcript of IPE Presentation CAPCSD 2018 FINAL PDF HANDOUT · 4/9/18 1 IPE/IPP Integration into the Curriculum...
4/9/18
1
IPE/IPP Integration into the Curriculum
CAPCSD Conference, Austin, 2018
John W. McCarthyOhio University
Jeffrey J. DiGiovanniUniversity of Cincinnati
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 1
Disclosures
• The authors received partial salary support from the Ohio Department of Medicaid, Medicaid Technical Assistance and Policy Program (MedTAPP) Healthcare Access Initiative ODM Federal Funding: G-1415-07-0060; ODM201409.• John McCarthy, Jeffrey DiGiovanni have no
relevant nonfinancial disclosures.
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 2
Knowing your team…• Introductions
SpeakersAudience
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 3
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 4
PREVENTABLE MEDICAL ERRORS
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 5
“…particular difficulties receiving timely information, coordinating care, and dealing with administrative hassles.”
-Commonwealth Fund
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 6
4/9/18
2
The Continuum of
InterprofessionalEducation
Area an experience falls on IP continuum: Low Mid High
Typical characteristics of experience:
Classroom-basedEmphasis on text (books, articles, etc)
Interprofessionalcompetencies may be incidental and typically not assessed
May satisfy curricular course requirement for 2+ programs
Mix of class-based and clinical site learning
Mid- and high-fidelity simulations
Team-based learning
Content and assessments built around the IP competencies
Emphasis on team-based clinical practice in a health facility
Team-based meetings occur regularly
Experiences augmented with high-fidelity simulations, standardized patients, and other related, IP content
Grand rounds experiences common
Assessments a blend of clinical skills evaluations and team-based performance
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 7
What do you think of?
What do you think of when you hear… Interprofessional Education?
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 8
IPE Competencies in Accreditation Standards
9
• Graphic in presentation
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018
IPE
• Interprofessional education (IPE): Occasions when two or more professions learn from, with and about each other to improve collaboration and the quality of care (Freeth, Hammick, Reeves, Koppel, & Barr, 2005. p15)
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 10 McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 11
Competency Area DescriptionValues/Ethics Work with individuals of other professions to maintain a climate of
mutual respect and shared values
Roles/Responsibilities Use the knowledge of one’s own role and those of other professions to appropriately assess and address the healthcare needs of patients and to promote and advance the health of populations
Interprofessional Communication Communicate with patients, families, communities, and professionals in health and other fields in a responsive and responsible manner that supports a team approach to the promotion and maintenance of health and the prevention and treatment of disease.
Teams and Teamwork Apply relationship-building values and the principles of team dynamics to perform effectively in different team roles to plan, deliver, and evaluate patient/population-centered care and population health programs and policies that are safe, timely efficient, effective, and equitable.
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 12
4/9/18
3
Competency Based
• How to take core competencies into instruction and outcomes… • Classroom• Clinical Settings
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 13
Demonstration of Core Skills Example AdvantagesWritten Assignment Design a brochure, web-
page, tweet, post, blog describing your profession to different audiences
Draft, edit, rewrite cycle to improve skills
Archived for use in other contexts
Shared via social mediaFace-to-Face Conversation Practice introducing
yourself and what to do to students in the class, related professionals when you have a short, medium, or extended time
Repeated practice makes for a smooth, professional introduction in a variety of contexts
Recorded Video/Audio Do an “elevator speech”, or record a longer introduction of yourself for different audiences to embed on a webpage
A chance to edit for not only content, but also presentation
Video allows for students to critique themselves
Roles/Responsibilities
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 14
Variable Opportunities in Large Environments Opportunities in Small Environments
Types of Students Wide variety of health disciplines lead to a wide breadth of interactions where students are exposed to many roles
Smaller variety of health disciplines offer chances for depth in repeated interactions with a select few groups
Class Size Large classes allow maximum number of students to have an IPE experience
Small classes allow for more discussion between different professions
Group Size Large groups (6 or more health disciplines per group) allow for multiple viewpoints and dealing with complex cases
Small groups allow for discussion of co-treatment and complementary practices
Setting Large hospitals offer a variety of floors and ward experiences
Smaller hospitals allow for closer relationships with staff at sites
Technology Large universities might have simulation spaces, a pool or standardized patients, and Virtual and Augmented Reality opportunities
Technology can allow individuals in smaller satellites to connect and learn from each other or supplement expertise
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 15
What is the main challenge for IPE?
• Logistical – How do you make sure every student has an experience with another profession?• Scheduling conflicts
• Quality – How do you make sure the IPE experiences are meaningful for students?• What are the activities?
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 16
Student Centered,
Student Driven
• In building our IPE Curriculum, we turned to the students• Build, Use, Edit, Re-Build, Use…
• Initial Group of Scholars to build materials• Critical mass of materials…
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 17
Common Discussions…
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 18
4/9/18
4
IPE Implementation: Activity Approach
• Get a number of activities• Activities are rated for number of hours• Advantages• Balance student involvement• Student control
• Disadvantages• Logistics• Still need to have someone
coordinate
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 19
Activities…
Represent
Tour and Demonstrate
Patient/Client EncountersMcCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 20 McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 21
What I think I do
What my mom thinks I do What my patients think I do
What my friends think I do
What society thinks I do
What I really do think I do
Your Profession
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 22
Audiology
WhatmyfriendsthinkIdo
WhatmymomthinksIdo
WhatsocietythinksIdo
WhatmypatientsthinkIdo
WhatIthinkIdo WhatIactuallydo
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 23 McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 24
4/9/18
5
https://blog.asha.org/2016/06/09/a-day-in-the-life-of-an-acute-care-slp/
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 25
Classroom Work
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 26
Patient Safety/QI Activities
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 27
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 28
Spaces…
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 29
Open Educational Resources…
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 30
4/9/18
6
Learning About Each Profession
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 31
Acute Care Setting
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 32 McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 33
Role Playhttps://www.dropbox.c
om/sh/p82cpktrh09vtcl
/AAA227HO90b6v9lKKc
vpbozva?dl=0
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 34
IPE Case Study Modules
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 35
IPE Case Study Modules…
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 36
4/9/18
7
MedEdPortal
https://www.mededportal.org/collection/interprofessional-education/
Other Open Resources: MedEdPortal
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 37
Exercise #1- What’s happening now? -
Part 1: Programs• Name “high connection”
programs in your college/university• Note:
• if they are within our outside your college
Part 2: Current Activities• List current efforts, such as:
• Annual IP conferences• Mixed-enrollment courses• IP specific courses• Grand rounds events
• Note: • Are they ongoing or one time events?• How many programs involved?• How are these driven? (by dept,
college, university?)
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 38 39
IP Training Model
Faculty Development
Team Interactions
Built around
Competencies
Variety of Settings
Assess, Assess
Resources and Tools
Commonalities
Our Enabling factors
Internal to College• Desire from College for IP
opportunities• Freedom to operate
• Numerous programs• Standards giving IP a nod
External• Willing regional facilities• Grassroots faculty interest with
follow through• Colleges desire collaboration• Available funding• Facilities value IP
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 40
Barriers we experienced
Internal to College• Programs “mixed” in their interest• College-level support not well
articulated• Providing supervision • Interest followed money
• Students and programs
• No coordination across programs to allow curricular space (time/credits/requirements)
External• Need to invest in local facilities• No formal coordination across
Colleges• Interest followed money
• Students and programs
• Another area where power struggles manifest• Facilities need non-$$ support
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 41
Exercise 2- Your own analysis -
Part 1: Strengths / Weaknesses• List the strengths and weakness
of your department and/or college as they relate to IP development and execution• Think about all types of resources
Part 2: Opportunities / Threats• List the opportunities and
threats outside your college (i.e., include the university and community organizations, etc)
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 42
4/9/18
8
Debriefing• Where the learning takes place!• Facilitate do not lead• Allow self-identification of both good and
not so good• Provide prompts if needed
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 43
Exercise 3- Your next steps -
Ideas for development• Consider• Available resources (people,
financial, space, facilities)• Partners: who’s on the same
page?• Activities: what’s already
happening?• Outcome: what’s the desired next
step?
Who, what, and when• Who do I need to involve?• What is the opportunity I’m
pitching• When will this be (first) offered?
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 44
OUTCO
MES
Teams & Teamwork Domain Pre Score M, SD
Post Score M, SD
P-value
Q1. Describe the process of team development
3.81, 1.13 4.35, 0.67 .017*
Q2. Describe the roles and practices of effective healthcare teams 3.92, 1.09 4.38, 0.57 .015*Q3. Engage other health professionals in shared problem-solving appropriate to the specific care situation
3.88, 1.14 4.69, 0.47 .001*
Q4. Inform care decisions by integrating the knowledge and experience of other professions appropriate to clinical situation
3.85, 1.90 4.58, 0.58 .003*
Q5. Apply leadership practices that support collaborative practice and team effectiveness
4.19, 0.85 4.50, 0.51 .070
Q6. Engage others to constructively manage disagreements that arise between healthcare professionals, patients, and families
3.92, 1.09 4.42, 0.47 .054
Q7. Share accountability with other professions, patients, and communities for outcomes relevant to prevention and health care
4.15,0.93 4.65, 0.58 .011*
Q8. Reflect on my individual performance for my improvement
4.62, 0.57 4.62, 0.51 1.0
Q9. Reflect on my healthcare team’s performance for my team’s improvement
4.38, 0.94 4.69, 0.70 .106
Q10. Use strategies that will improve the effectiveness of interprofessional teamwork and team-based care
4.19, 0.98 4.62, 0.49 .017*
Q11. Use available evidence to inform effective teamwork and team-based practices
4.19, 0.93 4.50, 0.65 0.88
Q12. Perform effectively on teams and in different team roles in a variety of settings 4.19, 0.85 4.70, 0.47 .009*
Roles/Responsibilities Domain Pre Score M, SD
Post Score M, SD
P-value
Q1. Communicate my roles and responsibilities clearly to patients, families, and other professionals
4.07, 1.0 4.41, 0.50 .058
Q2. Recognize my limitations in skills, knowledge, and abilities
4.44, 0.70 4.48, 0.51 .796
Q3. Engage diverse healthcare professionals with complementary professional expertise to develop strategies to meet specific patient care needs
3.74, 1.35 4.56, 0.64 .008*
Q4. Explain the roles and responsibilities of other care providers and how the team works together to provide care
3.56, 1.34 4.41, 0.64 .006*
Q5. Use the full scope of knowledge, skills, and abilities of available health professionals and healthcare workers to provide care that is safe, timely, efficient, effective, and equitable
3.70, 1.54 4.44, 0.70 .009*
Q6. Communicate with team members to clarify each member's responsibility in executing components of a treatment plan or public health intervention
3.93, 1.21 0.23, 0.45 .001*
Q7. Establish interprofessional relationships to improve care and advance learning 4.33, 0.78 4.74,0.45 .017*
Q8. Engage in continuous professional and interprofessional development to enhance team performance
4.30, 0.95 4.74, 0.45 .030*
Q9. Use unique and complementary abilities of all members of the team to optimize patient care
4.07, 1.27 4.56, 0.64 .035*McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 45
Interprofessional Communication Domain Pre Score M, SD
Post Score M, SD
P-value
Q1. Choose effective communication tools and techniques to facilitate discussions and interactions that enhance team function
4.19, 1.02 4.52, 0.50 .101
Q2. Communicate information with patients, families, and healthcare team members in a form that is understandable
4.23, 0.80 4.44, 0.57 .317
Q3. Avoid discipline-specific terminology when possible
3.74, 0.70 4.0, 0.73 .111
Q4. Express my knowledge and opinions to team members involved in patient care with clarity and respect
4.04, 0.89 4.54, 0.56 .008*
Q5. Listen actively, and encourage ideas and opinions of other team members 4.48, 0.57 4.85, 0.36 .002*
Q6. Give timely, sensitive feedback to others about their performance on the team
4.12, 0.92 4.44, 0.79 .041
Q7. Respond respectfully to feedback from others about their performance on the team
4.33, 0.82 4.59, 0.56 .083
Q8. Use appropriate, respectful language in a given difficult situation such as interprofessional conflict
4.33, 0.86 4.70, 0.45 .032
Q9. Recognize how my experience and expertise contributes to communication, conflict resolution, and interprofessional working relationships
4.26, 0.80 4.56, 0.57 .070
Q10. Recognize how my position in the hierarchy of the healthcare team, contributes to communication, conflict resolution, and interprofessional working relationships
4.04, 1.0 4.44, 0.63 .032
Q11. Consistently communicate the importance of teamwork in patient-centered and community-focused care
4.04, 1.17 4.48, 0.57 0.038
Values/Ethics Domain Pre Score M, SD
Post Score M, SD
P-value
Q1. Place the interests of patients at the center of interprofessional health care delivery 4.41, 0.64 4.81, 0.40 .005*
Q2. Respect the privacy of patients while maintaining confidentiality in the delivery of team-based care
4.56, 0.64 4.81, 0.40 .094
Q3. Embrace the diversity that characterizes patients and the health care team
4.41, 0.64 4.70, 0.47 .021
Q4. Respect the unique cultures, values, roles/responsibilities, and expertise of other health professionals
4.33, 0.83 4.74, 0.53 .005*
Q5. Work in cooperation with those who receive care and those who provide support or care
4.22, 0.89 4.56, 0.58 .094
Q6. Develop a trusting relationship with patients, families and other team members
4.33, 0.88 4.59, 0.57 .070
Q7. Demonstrate high standards of ethical conduct and quality of care in my contributions to team-based care
4.44, 0.85 4.74, 0.53 .088
Q8. Manage ethical dilemmas specific to interprofessional patient centered care situations
4.04, 1.16 4.52, 0.51 .021
Q9. Act with honesty and integrity in relationships with patients, families, and other team members
4.60, 0.75 4.89, 0.32 .039
Q10. Maintain competence in my own profession appropriate to my scope of practice or level of training
4.52, 0.70 4.60, 0.57 .617
OUTCO
MES
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 46
Simulation Resources
• Formal Simulation Course: http://sirc.nln.org/mod/page/view.php?id=789• Storyboard and Template: https://collaborate.uw.edu/ipe-teaching-
resources/simulation-scenario-building/• IPE Simulations: http://www.ipe.uwo.ca/Administration/case.html• Competencies: http://qsen.org/a-template-for-simulation-scenario-
development-that-incorporates-qsen-competencies/• National Patient Safety
Goals: https://www.jointcommission.org/assets/1/6/2018_HAP_NPSG_goals_final.pdf
McCarthy/DiGiovanni CAPCSD 2018 47
Acknowledgements
48
• ODM Federal Funding: G-1415-07-0060; ODM201409• Ohio University 1804 Fund• College of Health Sciences and Professions• Heritage College of Medicine• College of Education• Scripps College of Communication• College of Fine Arts